@@Mooneypilot101 just adopting the system of “ just “ ice will put Pakistan on right path….all thing you suggesting are sort of secondary problems…crux of all is accountability and requires a revolution atleast
جی جب روحانیت کو نہیں ماننا تو مذہب کا کیا فائدہ۔ فلسطین تباہی سے دو چار ہو چکا ہے اور ہم کرکٹ اور ٹک ٹاک اور عمران نیازی کے پیچھے لگے ہیں۔ شہباز شریف کتنا کچھ ٹھیک کر لے گا؟ نہ دین کے ہیں نہ ہم دنیا کے۔ مشکل لگتا ہے سنبھل پانا اگرچہ ناممکن نہیں لگتا۔
@@Pal3stin3ix_Lov3 We have wasted too many centuries on religion. When the world was advancing in the 15th with technology as simple as a printing press, our religious establishment opposed it. When the industrial revolution arrived in 19th and the 20th century, we were told that as Muslims we should reject western learning and technology. Pictures, movies, television and countless technological advances including in medicine were declared as un Islamic, by the Mullahs. Muslims completely missed the computer age(produced nothing) in the 20th century. Now our Mullahs are misleading and distracting us from the information technology by issuing misguided Fatwas. Muslims have been systematically destroyed by focusing on after life than this life. The consequences are in front of us. A technologically advanced country of Israel with just 6-Million Zionist settlers from Europe are controlling 375-Million Arabs and may well destroy Iran and Pakistan in the coming years. Our leaders(Feudal, Politicians, Military and Mullahs) are clueless or dont give a damn about our people in pursuit of their own foreign bank accounts.
A balanced video has both positives and negatives. Zero negatives were presented in this video which makes it a strong argument that this videos is sponsored by Chinese Communist Party
That's my point. I left Pakistan in 2001 to pursue engineering from the US. PKR exchange rate was 1$=75PKR. There used to be Citibank and American Express and direct flights from PK to every US and European major city. Fast forward today, the nation is confined in an open prison and I feel bad for my fellow countrymen. We will always be a nurturing state. We will give birth to children, we will give them education and send them abroad for a job or better education. It's OK to be a nurturing state and many countries in the world works on these model. Our time has come and gone and we missed it as a nation.
@@ahmedafb amreeka lost interest in Pakistan after 2021 now India is the new darling of amreeka and amreeka does not even sell military equipment to Pakistan that is in a hostile environment. Pakistan has to turn to China there is no other option. February 2019 proved that 7 times larger India will always be pakistancentric.
A balanced video has both positives and negatives. Zero negatives were presented in this video which makes it a strong argument that this videos is sponsored by Chinese Communist Party
ik its impossible situational image formed for pakistan right now, but showing diplomatic forms not to show we love china etc (altough we pakistanis even comon person❤ china with respect) thorugh this style china and pakistan can begin to work on CPEC, this is the only way like how india did took oil from Russia branded it as Indian oil nd selling it in Eu market which again russia was at loss in front of america while in india being amircan ally serve to its Diplomatic partnership of BRICS+ nation. Glad u liked this analysis as much as I get his views.
As usual. Pakistani mind looking for saazish. No doubt china use to park it's dollars in USA. As you said 1.3 trillion was max in 2013 which still would have been 5 percent of total USA gdp( pegged at 20 trillion ). Not very substantial. The reason is competition in global presence. By the way, China one road and belt policy is nothing but indebting the countries into debt trap. Example srilanka. Second in line is Pakistan. No pakistani will ever question why China is so much interested in gawadar when China has so many Port's across South China Sea aroud the coast of which 90 percent factories are operating. The distance from these industrial area to kasgar the starting point of cpec is around 4500 km on average. After that the length of cpec from kashgar to gawadar is around 3500 kmn. So total distance by road is 7500 kms. How this works economically when you take into consideration that cost of transportation by sea is at least 20 times cheaper than by road. And if you compare about time of transportation by sea to road, still it doesn't make sense because China is not transporting anything perishable.
This is other misconception. Silk route of 500 yrs back. That time the ships were not mechanised, no airplane, no railway and even in those days the major cargo that is spices from indian Chinese subcontinent was transported by sea. Silk probably was transported by road because the humid ship travel was detrimental to the quality of silk and hence this was called silk route.
News flash: There is no real silk routes.There are multiples major trade route that facilitated the exchange of goods between East Asia and the rest of the world, it was not necessarily a cheap means of exporting Chinese products and they never called it silk route.
CPEC should be reconsidered. It should not be built by any foreign entity but by us via different means. If we rushed to CPEC we will be in china debt trap. And now our establishment wants to okay CPEC diplomacy to stay in power. So it is not that simple. The best solution is always that Pakistan should build this infrastructure by themselves and yes we can do that without external help (we don't have money is pure BS just look out our generals, politicians, and establishment goons dubai investment)
Pakistanis have only one thing to offer to world powers and that is its geography and Pakistan needs China. February 2019 proved that India will always be pakistancentric duushman ka duushman dosta hotahai.
If nothing The TOLL TAX …the sleeping giant…. What more the bare minimum unfalltered free chungi; The: e.g …. bosphorus royalty. ? May Allah sawt Bless u w more Visions Out puts etc. Aameen s n more !!
Pakistanio ki illitrate thinking ki wajah se ye relocation Pakistan main nahi ho pa rahi jab ke ab terriffs lagna shuru ho chuki hain aor ye relocation wali policy ab china eastern europe se karne laga hai... Lagta nahi ke ab China Pakistan ko itni importance deta hai...
How much employment was generated during construction of CPEC is indicative of how useful it is for Pakistan. If locals feel that grand infrastructure is built on their land while their people stay unemployed, it is bound to have consequences. This would exacerbate the feeling of colonization in the local population and security matters will be hampered. Already people feel alienated due the disproportionate power and wealth distribution in its states.
CPEC is a shit dream to sell ye bohat purana ho chuka. Look at iran balochistan, chabahar city which is a free trade zone with no dutys on good and many five star hotel and look atpakistan balochistan gawadar city its policies to change the life of local balochi people and baloch make the foundation of trade free zone no punjabi and british system allow at balochistan state.
Bhai parachinar or baki Jo tensions create ho ri hai un k baray mai zara analytically baat karein. Or ap k hisab sy solutions suggest Karein. Always good to hear from you.
Can’t China easily get all petroleum and gas from Russia if there is a blockade? Why would they need this 6000 km corridor via Gwadar which is easily blockade able by US navy from their bases in ME incase of a war?
When there will be Chinese naval base in gawadar then how america will block china in fact china will be able to block American ships from entering into Persian gulf and From gawadar to China it’s 2300 km not 6000 km.and china moving factories in sink Yang province as well.
Thanku muzamil for highlighting key issues that beed to be addressed by our gov . I hope someone from gov would pay heed to these crucial steps that we need to take sooner than later.
You understand that Pakistan's challenge lies not with the CPEC itself, but rather with the absence of diverse international investment. While other developing regions are attracting varied foreign capital - with Western tech companies like Facebook investing in digital infrastructure across Africa, and Korean, Indian and Japanese firms developing transportation and logistics projects there, in Sri Lanka, Bangladesh, and throughout Southeast Asia - Pakistan struggles to attract similar investments due to its security concerns and financial constraints. Other than that it is always better for Chinese firms to relocate to a place where they can take the Advantage of RCEP, Indirect access to India's market and have low capital outflow constraints.
Inshallah, after completion of CPEC, Pakistan Inshallah zarur agay barhega, just we need to support our Govt and Pak Army, chahey jo bhi Govt main ho. 😇🙏 kyun k sab se pehlay Pakistan hai, phir or kuch...
A balanced video has both positives and negatives. Zero negatives were presented in this video which makes it a strong argument that this videos is sponsored by Chinese Communist Party
Your video about industrialisation in Pakistan is fantastic but chock point is that foreign or local funded industries grow only in this way as army goods industry should be banded or approved all taxes on them
Kindly mention this too how PTI GOVT and Imran khan’s Incompetence halted all projects of CPEC for 4 years which are still effected by his decision making
Then why did China forgot to transfer manufacturing industry under CPEC after making so expensive IPPs which are totally overkill for a weak country like Pakistan?
Do you know our Special economy zones aren't fully complement and operational. Industry kahan lagaye wo DHA bahria town me? Jab pichle 10 saal me ek dosre se larhne me lage hoye ho aur narray bazi kr rahe ho Mera babba theek tera galat Chahe wo nawaz ho ya khan. You have wasted a decade infighting and political war. Same what Benezir and nawaz did in 1990s. isme pmln pti or establishment sb responsible hai. SEZ apse complete ni ho sake theek se Function kr ni rahe Industry wo asman pe akar lagayen. Yehi Chinese bol rahe h ke apka focus growth ni political fight h Ek project time pe deliver ni hora government se chahe wo pmln ki thi ya pti. Khan sahab ka b pura hath h chalte paiyay me hath dene ka. 2014 ka dharna 2018 tak gov ko cripple krna Phr khud gov me ana or opposition ko deewar me chunanan or phr bahir ki dunya se pangay bazi krna bilawala or phr PDM wala azaab hum ne alag bughta. Everyone is responsible
@Mianaly20 I agree. Simple solution is stop meddling with elections and information. In this day and age, it doesn't matter how powerful you are, you can't control the natural flow of information. Let's disentangle the judiciary, executive and legislature. You forgot to mention the situation has even more nosedived after 2018 till now. DHA is getting bigger than ever, 2024 elections were the biggest laughing stock as election commission is still busy hiding and fudging their own documents at massive scale, but they couldn't do at such scale so crippled the judiciary for cover-up and abolished the people's right to speak and assemble through the barrel of the gun. I have never seen 2/3rd denocratically elected majority Govt so hated by the masses in its first year, so much nervous 2/3rd elected majority Govt that it has even become worse than the Musharraf's and Ayub Khan's dictatorship. When China/GCC would see that iron brother's 2/3rd majority elected PM is reluctant to never hold an open conversation, dialogue with its own public and don't wanna face their questions then who would invest in that country? Even Monarch Dictatorships of GCC for example MBS is much more democratic than the current beloved heavy majority elected Govt that also swept through 3 provinces in 2024 elections as well. With such on paper popularity, public would dump their savings into the Govt coffers and would agree to lower their own incomes at the single request of the PM for the bright future of Pakistan.
Muzamil, this is a superficial analysis of CPEC/OBOR that we have heard many times before. You did not discuss that there were surplus funds as the Chinese infra boom was ending in the 2010s. To prevent a situation like the present day real estate bust, China devised OBOR as a way to deploy both funds and companies to projects designed by China but paid for by foreign countries - you should have pointed out that no OBOR project is FDI, they are all loans backed by governments like Pakistan. So countries like Pakistan got expensive infra built for which they had no use. Ask yourself, if Pakistan built a North-South corridor itself, would it have taken 30 billion USD? The idea that CPEC is plan B for China if its sea based trade routes are blocked by US is also old and simplistic. First, Pakistan has to pay its loans regardless of the plan B ever being used. Second, if US blocks South China Sea, who will China be sending the goods to? FYI, US/EU are China's biggest trading partners. Also, if US can block South China Sea, can it not also block Arabian Sea? Another thing that is never discussed in such narratives is the fact that Chinese industry is concentrated on its eastern seaboard. You are expecting an alternative to Sea based shipping which will take weeks to travel by road across China, then cross Himalayas and take even more time in Pakistan. A single ship can take thousands of containers. Imagine a similar number of trucks across the mountain passes. The reality is long distance shipping by land is obsolete in the modern world. The bottom line is, OBOR is a grand Chinese vision with financial risk borne by the host countries. It is Pakistan's fault that it forgot to do that risk management.
It's good to hear about CPEC with a different lens. In my opinion, the security issue can't be resolved by danda anymore. Danda has destabilised Pakistan and ll do the same in future too coz it is used to keep one's hegemony.
I wish you can do a vlog on "more provinces of Pakistan for a better civil administration aligned with digital currency". The structural change will ensure justice, strengthen constitution and the digital economy will bring transparency. Har kaam danday k zor pe nhe hotha, Pathano aur Balocho ko baat samaj aa gayi hai.
Thanks for the analysis! I need some advice: I have a SafePal wallet with USDT, and I have the seed phrase. (alarm fetch churn bridge exercise tape speak race clerk couch crater letter). What's the best way to send them to Binance?
Pakistan ko literally CPEC se boht faida hona tha, Pakistan agar Gawadar ko tax free zone bana deta or security k problem solve karleta to yaqin karo aaj se 10-15 saal baad Pakistan wahan khara hota jahan aaj Dubai khara hai. Jis tarah China ne USA ki wajah se apni economy strong ki Pakistan b kar sakta hai lekin kia karain Pakistani log intihai bad qismat or kambakht hain
22:40 America allowed India to import oil from Russia but on the other hand America is trying to contain Pakistan so that India can grow economically and the military so India can focus on China to contain China. that is the policy of America in our region
@@vamppires laga mea toa bolta hu jaldi lagaya saction fir india self develop hogi . please apnie position ka istamal karo or usa ko bolo saction lagao india pea . 1970 mea lagaya tha fir bhi hum logo na nuclear or space program banaya 1998 mea lagaya tha tosala 6 month mea nikalna pada . aaj toa india kisi ka baap sa nahi derta bolta hai bring it on usa utna jaldicollapse hoga .
@ haha u r funny kar lo self development usa is giving u free hand just because they want to counter china warna wo use kar k Indians phainkega yad karo gay 😂
At present Chinese economy is going down and due to over capacity in manufacturing,and demand decreasing.Chinese factories are shifting are closing.For the time being china has lost interest in cpeck
There is a problem in his view that cpec is a back up for trade and energy which is dumb take the distance that would need to be traversed to get goods out and energy into china given the most of the industry and population is in the far east while the region near Pakistan is low in population is a desert.given that shipping is cheaper than any other transport by weight then only use of cpec is a navel port and to use it industrial capacity because china can not built roads and other infrastructure for ever in it's boarders so it diverted the capacity to save it industry from a slum and slow down.
China built CPEC, because China has exhausted its minerals and metals and converted them into products. China needs our minerals add metals from our mountains if you were smart you will learn how to process and build products out of those minerals and metals. Instead of just giving the raw materials to China and guess what United States is no longer interested in made in China products this gives opportunity to Pakistan to start making Chinese made products because Pakistan has the resources in the form of raw material cheaper Manpower and very relaxed Environmental protection. Pakistan just needs stability and we can easily become an economic Powerhouse
Pak is gateway and Afghanistan is heart of central Asia . cpec trade routes connect china with Africa middle east and Arabian sea. India USA Japan Australia control south china sea strait of Malacca which is dangerous routes. Pakistan is on Arabia sea Persian gulf near strait of hurmuz. 60% of oil goods passed through this hurmuz. This trade routes give too much profit from china import export.. cpec is only 3000 km long.
you have ventured into the right type of knowledgeable videos. best of luck and keep going strong
One of the most comprehensive explanations I ever had on this topic
Getting away from religious, ethnic and cultural divisions and conflicts will be the key in moving Pakistan forward.
@@Mooneypilot101 just adopting the system of “ just “ ice will put Pakistan on right path….all thing you suggesting are sort of secondary problems…crux of all is accountability and requires a revolution atleast
@Mooneypilot101
no chance jisa islam ka drug deaker grow kiya hai whoa ab kasa chod sakta hai ab pakistan tutaga uski adat nahi
جی جب روحانیت کو نہیں ماننا تو مذہب کا کیا فائدہ۔ فلسطین تباہی سے دو چار ہو چکا ہے اور ہم کرکٹ اور ٹک ٹاک اور عمران نیازی کے پیچھے لگے ہیں۔
شہباز شریف کتنا کچھ ٹھیک کر لے گا؟
نہ دین کے ہیں نہ ہم دنیا کے۔ مشکل لگتا ہے سنبھل پانا اگرچہ ناممکن نہیں لگتا۔
@@Pal3stin3ix_Lov3 We have wasted too many centuries on religion. When the world was advancing in the 15th with technology as simple as a printing press, our religious establishment opposed it. When the industrial revolution arrived in 19th and the 20th century, we were told that as Muslims we should reject western learning and technology. Pictures, movies, television and countless technological advances including in medicine were declared as un Islamic, by the Mullahs. Muslims completely missed the computer age(produced nothing) in the 20th century. Now our Mullahs are misleading and distracting us from the information technology by issuing misguided Fatwas. Muslims have been systematically destroyed by focusing on after life than this life. The consequences are in front of us. A technologically advanced country of Israel with just 6-Million Zionist settlers from Europe are controlling 375-Million Arabs and may well destroy Iran and Pakistan in the coming years. Our leaders(Feudal, Politicians, Military and Mullahs) are clueless or dont give a damn about our people in pursuit of their own foreign bank accounts.
Guys do subscribe! Content like this should be appreciated in Pakistan. Thanks Muzamil for your efforts.
Excellent Analysis About CPEC❤ 🇵🇰🇨🇳
A balanced video has both positives and negatives. Zero negatives were presented in this video which makes it a strong argument that this videos is sponsored by Chinese Communist Party
you should also use maps when explaning cooridors, routes, or countries location. it will be very helpfull in understanding matter discuss.
Name one country that ever received financial assistance from China and was able to flourish.
No country china only cares about its economy 😅😅😅😅
That's my point.
I left Pakistan in 2001 to pursue engineering from the US. PKR exchange rate was 1$=75PKR. There used to be Citibank and American Express and direct flights from PK to every US and European major city.
Fast forward today, the nation is confined in an open prison and I feel bad for my fellow countrymen.
We will always be a nurturing state. We will give birth to children, we will give them education and send them abroad for a job or better education.
It's OK to be a nurturing state and many countries in the world works on these model. Our time has come and gone and we missed it as a nation.
@@ahmedafb amreeka lost interest in Pakistan after 2021 now India is the new darling of amreeka and amreeka does not even sell military equipment to Pakistan that is in a hostile environment. Pakistan has to turn to China there is no other option. February 2019 proved that 7 times larger India will always be pakistancentric.
A balanced video has both positives and negatives. Zero negatives were presented in this video which makes it a strong argument that this videos is sponsored by Chinese Communist Party
@@ahmedafbبھئی تو یوتھیا ہے۔۔بہت مبارک بات نہیں؟😂
One of the best podcast so far I have ever seen by Muzammil. So in depth and to the point
تینوں اج سمجھ آئی ہیگی😂😂😂😂
Great series. Keep making these videos please.
I am living in China and i completely agree with Muzamul's Analysis.
ik its impossible situational image formed for pakistan right now, but showing diplomatic forms not to show we love china etc (altough we pakistanis even comon person❤ china with respect) thorugh this style china and pakistan can begin to work on CPEC, this is the only way like how india did took oil from Russia branded it as Indian oil nd selling it in Eu market which again russia was at loss in front of america while in india being amircan ally serve to its Diplomatic partnership of BRICS+ nation. Glad u liked this analysis as much as I get his views.
As usual. Pakistani mind looking for saazish. No doubt china use to park it's dollars in USA. As you said 1.3 trillion was max in 2013 which still would have been 5 percent of total USA gdp( pegged at 20 trillion ). Not very substantial. The reason is competition in global presence. By the way, China one road and belt policy is nothing but indebting the countries into debt trap. Example srilanka. Second in line is Pakistan. No pakistani will ever question why China is so much interested in gawadar when China has so many Port's across South China Sea aroud the coast of which 90 percent factories are operating. The distance from these industrial area to kasgar the starting point of cpec is around 4500 km on average. After that the length of cpec from kashgar to gawadar is around 3500 kmn. So total distance by road is 7500 kms. How this works economically when you take into consideration that cost of transportation by sea is at least 20 times cheaper than by road. And if you compare about time of transportation by sea to road, still it doesn't make sense because China is not transporting anything perishable.
This is other misconception. Silk route of 500 yrs back. That time the ships were not mechanised, no airplane, no railway and even in those days the major cargo that is spices from indian Chinese subcontinent was transported by sea. Silk probably was transported by road because the humid ship travel was detrimental to the quality of silk and hence this was called silk route.
News flash: There is no real silk routes.There are multiples major trade route that facilitated the exchange of goods between East Asia and the rest of the world, it was not necessarily a cheap means of exporting Chinese products and they never called it silk route.
Amazing!!
Very well discussed dear brother. Keep up the good work
Great Muzzamil bhai❤
CPEC should be reconsidered. It should not be built by any foreign entity but by us via different means. If we rushed to CPEC we will be in china debt trap. And now our establishment wants to okay CPEC diplomacy to stay in power. So it is not that simple. The best solution is always that Pakistan should build this infrastructure by themselves and yes we can do that without external help (we don't have money is pure BS just look out our generals, politicians, and establishment goons dubai investment)
😂😂 Such a goof and blind you are... i think you should stay silent on these issues seems like you are a certified youthar
Pakistanis can not even make their own cheese and Amreekanaiy do not build infrastructure in other countries they bring democracies in forms of wars
Pakistanis have only one thing to offer to world powers and that is its geography and Pakistan needs China. February 2019 proved that India will always be pakistancentric duushman ka duushman dosta hotahai.
Master class analysis ❤
Hats Off Muzamil - Most Comprehensive Explanations
behtreen ❤❤❤
MAA Shaa allah you are doing wonderful work ❤
I have subscribed bro!
very informative ❤
my question is chalo China ne Cpec bana liya wo apne liya oil and apne product inport export kar lega.par Pakistan ko kya fiyda hoga iss se??
It will be reminiscent of h1b for Pakistani unemployed youth
If nothing The TOLL TAX …the sleeping giant…. What more the bare minimum unfalltered free chungi; The: e.g …. bosphorus royalty. ?
May Allah sawt Bless u w more Visions Out puts etc.
Aameen s n more !!
Mozammil well done for the brilliant Vlog. Hope it unfolds the Blinds.
Pakistanio ki illitrate thinking ki wajah se ye relocation Pakistan main nahi ho pa rahi jab ke ab terriffs lagna shuru ho chuki hain aor ye relocation wali policy ab china eastern europe se karne laga hai...
Lagta nahi ke ab China Pakistan ko itni importance deta hai...
Real journalism
❤ ❤ ❤ ❤❤
Absolutely Brilliant !!!!!!!
Amazing no one ever explained the vision of CPEC from the Chinese perspective like this
Good analysis
Our strategic thinkers are bajwa, general pizza, ghafoora and many more
Very informative. Thank you!
Tysm ✨
Muzamil, you are super awesome! Thank you for explaining it all in such a simple yet informative way.
Well explained without any Western propaganda
Muzamil Hassan Bhai Keep it up
How much employment was generated during construction of CPEC is indicative of how useful it is for Pakistan.
If locals feel that grand infrastructure is built on their land while their people stay unemployed, it is bound to have consequences.
This would exacerbate the feeling of colonization in the local population and security matters will be hampered. Already people feel alienated due the disproportionate power and wealth distribution in its states.
CPEC is a shit dream to sell ye bohat purana ho chuka. Look at iran balochistan, chabahar city which is a free trade zone with no dutys on good and many five star hotel and look atpakistan balochistan gawadar city its policies to change the life of local balochi people and baloch make the foundation of trade free zone no punjabi and british system allow at balochistan state.
😢😢😢 bro why you hate punjabi 💔
Why bro hate Punjabi 😭
Why bro ,😭?
Well informed
#NoToCPEC
#BalochLiberationArmy ✋🏼♥️🔥
Need more discussion on Cpec, bring Ahsan Iqbal
Excellent sir
My God ! Very well explained ❤ buhut alla. I can say you did a thorough research. Hats off to you Shah sahab
Regards
Bhai parachinar or baki Jo tensions create ho ri hai un k baray mai zara analytically baat karein. Or ap k hisab sy solutions suggest Karein.
Always good to hear from you.
political analysis iska isnt that great mostly i watch him for business related stuff
Excellent analysis
Big fan of your videos ❤sir
Bhai ap ki videos bhot achi hai❤😊 love you 😊
I also love him he is so hawt
Ok I just subscribed you. I loved the way you asked
Can’t China easily get all petroleum and gas from Russia if there is a blockade? Why would they need this 6000 km corridor via Gwadar which is easily blockade able by US navy from their bases in ME incase of a war?
When there will be Chinese naval base in gawadar then how america will block china in fact china will be able to block American ships from entering into Persian gulf and From gawadar to China it’s 2300 km not 6000 km.and china moving factories in sink Yang province as well.
they are pakistanies and they follow islam facts have zero realivance to them .
please dont pop there bubble lol
Watching your videos make me realize the effort you put in making 1 video
Loads and respect and prayers for you
Very good boy you right ✅️ ❤❤❤❤
Pakistan should be a part of one china policy
Thanku muzamil for highlighting key issues that beed to be addressed by our gov . I hope someone from gov would pay heed to these crucial steps that we need to take sooner than later.
Subscribed 🖐️
good analyst. ❤
You understand that Pakistan's challenge lies not with the CPEC itself, but rather with the absence of diverse international investment. While other developing regions are attracting varied foreign capital - with Western tech companies like Facebook investing in digital infrastructure across Africa, and Korean, Indian and Japanese firms developing transportation and logistics projects there, in Sri Lanka, Bangladesh, and throughout Southeast Asia - Pakistan struggles to attract similar investments due to its security concerns and financial constraints. Other than that it is always better for Chinese firms to relocate to a place where they can take the Advantage of RCEP, Indirect access to India's market and have low capital outflow constraints.
Inshallah, after completion of CPEC, Pakistan Inshallah zarur agay barhega, just we need to support our Govt and Pak Army, chahey jo bhi Govt main ho. 😇🙏
kyun k sab se pehlay Pakistan hai, phir or kuch...
Try something else then "Inshallah"...Allah has not been kind to Muslims
A balanced video has both positives and negatives. Zero negatives were presented in this video which makes it a strong argument that this videos is sponsored by Chinese Communist Party
What an explanation. I wanna explore these things, too. And I also wanna speak like you on every topic. You explain things very well. MashaAllah
Debt is a trap - You can say it is not 'debt trap'.
Game changer
Business wali batain businessman he kr skta yahan podcast wala bata raha ha😂 but excellent work ❤
Political Stability is the first thing
Your video about industrialisation in Pakistan is fantastic but chock point is that foreign or local funded industries grow only in this way as army goods industry should be banded or approved all taxes on them
Kindly mention this too how
PTI GOVT and Imran khan’s
Incompetence halted all projects of CPEC for 4 years which are still effected by his decision making
He won’t he is cult supporter of pti
Average Potwari from Gawalmandi
Right broo
😅😅u r too innocent of thinking about Chinese well see you after decades.. what the game is played by Chinese
Bhai subscribed ker Lia hay your podcast is informative
Then why did China forgot to transfer manufacturing industry under CPEC after making so expensive IPPs which are totally overkill for a weak country like Pakistan?
These expensive ipps agreements made by commission khor chor noon league who don’t care about pakistan
Do you know our Special economy zones aren't fully complement and operational.
Industry kahan lagaye wo DHA bahria town me?
Jab pichle 10 saal me ek dosre se larhne me lage hoye ho aur narray bazi kr rahe ho
Mera babba theek tera galat
Chahe wo nawaz ho ya khan.
You have wasted a decade infighting and political war.
Same what Benezir and nawaz did in 1990s.
isme pmln pti or establishment sb responsible hai.
SEZ apse complete ni ho sake theek se
Function kr ni rahe
Industry wo asman pe akar lagayen.
Yehi Chinese bol rahe h ke apka focus growth ni political fight h
Ek project time pe deliver ni hora government se chahe wo pmln ki thi ya pti.
Khan sahab ka b pura hath h chalte paiyay me hath dene ka.
2014 ka dharna
2018 tak gov ko cripple krna
Phr khud gov me ana or opposition ko deewar me chunanan or phr bahir ki dunya se pangay bazi krna bilawala or phr PDM wala azaab hum ne alag bughta.
Everyone is responsible
@Mianaly20 I agree. Simple solution is stop meddling with elections and information. In this day and age, it doesn't matter how powerful you are, you can't control the natural flow of information. Let's disentangle the judiciary, executive and legislature. You forgot to mention the situation has even more nosedived after 2018 till now. DHA is getting bigger than ever, 2024 elections were the biggest laughing stock as election commission is still busy hiding and fudging their own documents at massive scale, but they couldn't do at such scale so crippled the judiciary for cover-up and abolished the people's right to speak and assemble through the barrel of the gun.
I have never seen 2/3rd denocratically elected majority Govt so hated by the masses in its first year, so much nervous 2/3rd elected majority Govt that it has even become worse than the Musharraf's and Ayub Khan's dictatorship. When China/GCC would see that iron brother's 2/3rd majority elected PM is reluctant to never hold an open conversation, dialogue with its own public and don't wanna face their questions then who would invest in that country? Even Monarch Dictatorships of GCC for example MBS is much more democratic than the current beloved heavy majority elected Govt that also swept through 3 provinces in 2024 elections as well. With such on paper popularity, public would dump their savings into the Govt coffers and would agree to lower their own incomes at the single request of the PM for the bright future of Pakistan.
If Est will not sit with Balochs and will not Agree what they are saying, in Long run Forget CPEC.
.
baluchistan toa alag hoga hi
Why arent the episodes being uploaded on spotify?
100 % right sir
CTA - Firstly, Instill a competent Government with mandate to accomplish this!
Muzamil, this is a superficial analysis of CPEC/OBOR that we have heard many times before.
You did not discuss that there were surplus funds as the Chinese infra boom was ending in the 2010s. To prevent a situation like the present day real estate bust, China devised OBOR as a way to deploy both funds and companies to projects designed by China but paid for by foreign countries - you should have pointed out that no OBOR project is FDI, they are all loans backed by governments like Pakistan.
So countries like Pakistan got expensive infra built for which they had no use. Ask yourself, if Pakistan built a North-South corridor itself, would it have taken 30 billion USD?
The idea that CPEC is plan B for China if its sea based trade routes are blocked by US is also old and simplistic. First, Pakistan has to pay its loans regardless of the plan B ever being used. Second, if US blocks South China Sea, who will China be sending the goods to? FYI, US/EU are China's biggest trading partners. Also, if US can block South China Sea, can it not also block Arabian Sea?
Another thing that is never discussed in such narratives is the fact that Chinese industry is concentrated on its eastern seaboard. You are expecting an alternative to Sea based shipping which will take weeks to travel by road across China, then cross Himalayas and take even more time in Pakistan. A single ship can take thousands of containers. Imagine a similar number of trucks across the mountain passes. The reality is long distance shipping by land is obsolete in the modern world.
The bottom line is, OBOR is a grand Chinese vision with financial risk borne by the host countries. It is Pakistan's fault that it forgot to do that risk management.
It's good to hear about CPEC with a different lens. In my opinion, the security issue can't be resolved by danda anymore. Danda has destabilised Pakistan and ll do the same in future too coz it is used to keep one's hegemony.
Ur right....everytìng ur saying
Kar deya subscribe . Bro !
I hope humari government tak yeh baaten pohnchen
I wish you can do a vlog on "more provinces of Pakistan for a better civil administration aligned with digital currency". The structural change will ensure justice, strengthen constitution and the digital economy will bring transparency. Har kaam danday k zor pe nhe hotha, Pathano aur Balocho ko baat samaj aa gayi hai.
Thanks for the analysis! I need some advice: I have a SafePal wallet with USDT, and I have the seed phrase. (alarm fetch churn bridge exercise tape speak race clerk couch crater letter). What's the best way to send them to Binance?
Pakistan ko literally CPEC se boht faida hona tha, Pakistan agar Gawadar ko tax free zone bana deta or security k problem solve karleta to yaqin karo aaj se 10-15 saal baad Pakistan wahan khara hota jahan aaj Dubai khara hai. Jis tarah China ne USA ki wajah se apni economy strong ki Pakistan b kar sakta hai lekin kia karain Pakistani log intihai bad qismat or kambakht hain
22:40 America allowed India to import oil from Russia but on the other hand America is trying to contain Pakistan so that India can grow economically and the military so India can focus on China to contain China. that is the policy of America in our region
its not USA allowed India to import oil from Russia. its indian diplomacy and political will because that India import russian oil.
@hamzasuri3209
unka pass koi option hai kya ?
tum log usa china ko baap banaya hoga .
hum na nahi .
sab hamra juti pea .
@@siddharthkalantri5076bol abi raha hai kal usa ne sanctions lagai to India 2 din mein paon pe hoga usa k 😂
@@vamppires
laga mea toa bolta hu jaldi lagaya saction fir india self develop hogi .
please apnie position ka istamal karo or usa ko bolo saction lagao india pea .
1970 mea lagaya tha fir bhi hum logo na nuclear or space program banaya 1998 mea lagaya tha tosala 6 month mea nikalna pada .
aaj toa india kisi ka baap sa nahi derta bolta hai bring it on usa utna jaldicollapse hoga .
@ haha u r funny kar lo self development usa is giving u free hand just because they want to counter china warna wo use kar k Indians phainkega yad karo gay 😂
Fee kia he apki class ki
At present Chinese economy is going down and due to over capacity in manufacturing,and demand decreasing.Chinese factories are shifting are closing.For the time being china has lost interest in cpeck
China has 13 more projects like cpec all over the world
Pls tell me what is the loan rate of interest.. y china did not disclose .. and what about other countries who obtained BRI
Collaboration k sath hama sikh a ko bahot mila ga
Mzamil thura slow bol lia kary plzzz...
There is a problem in his view that cpec is a back up for trade and energy which is dumb take the distance that would need to be traversed to get goods out and energy into china given the most of the industry and population is in the far east while the region near Pakistan is low in population is a desert.given that shipping is cheaper than any other transport by weight then only use of cpec is a navel port and to use it industrial capacity because china can not built roads and other infrastructure for ever in it's boarders so it diverted the capacity to save it industry from a slum and slow down.
What are you saying? Only 450 billion? I jave heard China gave 1.3+ trillion dollars debt in US Treasury bills.
He mentioned it
Keep your friends(China) close and your enemies(The West) Closer. Dont become a pawn in their games.
China built CPEC, because China has exhausted its minerals and metals and converted them into products. China needs our minerals add metals from our mountains if you were smart you will learn how to process and build products out of those minerals and metals. Instead of just giving the raw materials to China and guess what United States is no longer interested in made in China products this gives opportunity to Pakistan to start making Chinese made products because Pakistan has the resources in the form of raw material cheaper Manpower and very relaxed Environmental protection. Pakistan just needs stability and we can easily become an economic Powerhouse
Congratulations! You’ve finally graduated from the prestigious university of WhatsApp.
Then why imran khan against CPEC
He isn't against Cpec.
Who told u ?
Under his gov
Many Cpec projects got completed
Even the lahore's metro train
Because imran khan was working on foreign agenda to destroy economy of Pakistan we saved Pakistan
Jb tk halaat nai badlengy pakistan k hum subscribe nai krega ❤
Its hard to keep CPEC as it is ,because of USA..and for pak,imf and USA and UK is more important then china.
Muzammil Bhai please use J cuts. ❤
The course is too expensive for me.
Would have bought if it was near 100$.
Economics of education
Pakistan's education system and how to design an efficient one ?
Yield of different education systems ?
bhai kyn sari scheme bata raahy hu :P
Pak is gateway and Afghanistan is heart of central Asia . cpec trade routes connect china with Africa middle east and Arabian sea. India USA Japan Australia control south china sea strait of Malacca which is dangerous routes. Pakistan is on Arabia sea Persian gulf near strait of hurmuz. 60% of oil goods passed through this hurmuz. This trade routes give too much profit from china import export.. cpec is only 3000 km long.
Hum pakistani hain hum kisi ka bhala nahi karte 😂😂
Indian bhi aa gye knowledge lene 😂😂😂