Not sure about people wanting a silent video. I prefer listening to you Corin. You always give clear explanations during your work and that’s how we learn. For those that don’t want to hear it……. there’s a mute button on your device….’use it!!!’…….
Have the people who requested that you don't speak not got a volume button on their devices? Keep on with your commentary, don't let the few spoil it for the many.
Great choice of music but who was the doughnut that requested that one of the countries leading bonsai experts cease teaching and providing instruction on their videos?
You have the best bonsai channel on UA-cam for a reason. You explain your thoughts and practices and we as an audience learn from that. Beautiful collection and that maple in the intro is amazing! Let the naysayers use their volume buttons if they aren’t interested in an experts instruction.
I miss the « this one is growing up too much » and « this is a bit long » parts . To me that’s what is relevant AND relaxing . Thank you Corin for making such good content. Cheers
Hi Corin, I prefer it with the commentary. Why would people not want to know your thoughts and reasons on what you do? Isn't that why we enjoy watching your videos? By the way that is an awesome tree.
Really beautiful tree; well done! Well, everybody has the right on his or hers own opinion. I'm taking care and propagate bonsaï for more than three decades now. When you are talking while pruning, you are sharing your own thoughts, judgements, evaluations of the tree and the process of styling and taking care. I think one can learn (a lot) from that, and I know I do. And so, when bonsaï are (only) displayed, I can imagine some people prefer a certain level of silence or background "easy listening" or something like that. But, when working on a tree (and not only displaying it) by an experienced bonsaï nursery owner, I find it rather strange to prefer silence about the "job" and so, with no explanation at all about how and why. I mean: really strange... I rather prefer listening and learning... Keep up the good work, mr Tomlinson, I salute you!
It is just like the painter, the late Bob Ross. Looking how his painting evolved was nice, but his voice made it complete and was very relaxing. Please continue speaking to us, Corin.
My second reaction on your silent video. With you explaining, teaching us what to do, makes it a lot more interesting. If people don't like what you do there are much more alternatives to suit them. You just keep on doing what you do best. Make films about bonsai and give your comment, so the true bonsailover learns and improves his bonsai. Keep on doing what you do
Why do people not want to hear all your expertise and knowledge? Turn the volume down if you want quiet. You're a wonderful teacher. And,I for one enjoy your speaking to us.
Keep talking over the pruning videos! I enjoy how you explain your decisions.. you're a natural teacher! Also I have a drink every time you say "This ones growing down too much" lol
As much as I enjoy seeing the process of you pruning this magnificent tree, I much prefer listening to your commentary so I can get some insight into your thought process. Without the benefit of hearing your explanations I quickly get bored and can’t stop myself from fast-forwarding to see the end result.
I have learned SO much from you! Please don’t let the few spoil it for the rest of us! Especially since I bought a cedar for my collection because I saw you work on one! I like watching you work, could hang out all day, but I’d like to learn too. I agree with the others, those people can mute their device or play music on their own.
Yeah Nah...no more silent videos plz. Your talking is absolutely needed...👍 People that don't want to hear you, can put off the sound an play their own music....😒
I like your willingness to experiment, but I agree with the others who have said they prefer videos with commentary. Hearing your thought process as you work really helps people like me, who have only been doing bonsai for a couple of years. The more I hear experts explain why they're doing things as they're doing them, the more I remember and the more likely I am to make better decisions as I'm working on my own trees.
I have to agree with most of the other respondents: Your narrated videos are so informative for those of us looking to hone our bonsai skills that I find it such shame to eliminate your usual, accompanying narration. Those who prefer silence can always mute or lower the sound on their devices but why should they deprive us of helpful information?
I can appreciate that you want to cater to your subscribers Corin. However, hearing your plan, the why/for etc is (like a previous person said) the whole point. Though i must say, doesn't matter what video format you try I will be watching them all, still your verbal thoughts make the video 100 times better. IMHO
Hi Corin, I’m 1 minute in whilst reading the comments. It’s fair that people have their opinion, so therefore mine is - your content is absolutely brilliant, keep up the good work 👍🏾🇬🇧🌲I prefer the informative speaking style.
I agree with so many of the other commenters. Silence and music while nice is not really why I'm a subscriber. We have so much we can learn from you Colin. IMHO, asking you not to talk was just plain rude.
No Corin, No! I’m in the states and I need to hear the accent, and all the fun sayings, like “We’re just gonna give this a bit of tidying oop” and “This wants cuttin back right here”. Your fans want to hear you! 👊
I agree with other people much better to hear you talk Corin... I think also as you explain your decisions it helps get an understanding of the what the final result will be... and how to apply logic to own trees... But love this tree :-)
Please don't do that again worst video ever sorry. For me i tune in to see Corin and hear his thoughts whilst explaining the process while working on trees that's the whole point . If people want silent video's i'm sure there are places they can google them!
Hopefully no more silent videos - we don't learning anything! For those who don't want to hear Corin's instruction, hit the mute button and play your own relaxing music. Great tree 😀
Another nice video Corin. Have you ever thought of wearing a go-pro video camera on a harness on your chest? I saw this done the other day and the viewer saw what the artist was doing as he saw it. It added another aspect to the video.
I have to agree with the masses, you teaching is the reason i like watching your videos. Also, the camera angle didn't really allow me to see much of what your doing. Maybe a videographer wouldn't enhanced the silence but if still prefer hearing you explain your work.
Well, this is different. :) But to be honest, I don't mind you explaining what you are doing and why. That's relaxing and educational at the same time. But hey, you can never do it right for everybody can you? I enjoyed this very much anyway. Great tree, great video.
Corin i think alot of viewers prefer your talking explaining why your trimming here here and here "this is growing up to much" "this is growing down too much" "and this will back bud if i trim it here" keep up the commentary i say
The narration is necessary to help me understand what's going on. I watch these videos for self education. So a demo without any talking is like a car with no wheels.
Well I enjoy watching you but I also appreciate your comments to explain why you are doing whatever it is at that moment. I hope you don’t take their requests to heart. Most people want to hear you.
Bonjours, merci pour vos video, j adore la music de cette video, pourriez vous me dire son titre? Merci pour ce cèdre extraordinaire, le cèdre est un de mes arbres préférer. J'espère qu'un jour vos video seront traduit en Français ;o).
Please continue your videos as usual. If someone wants silence or music they can mute and listen to whatever they like. The rest of us won't be deprived of your insight. (The music is quite nice, but I miss your real time narration.)
I would rather hear what you are doing to be honest. Music is fine but I have no idea regarding the reasoning behind the cut, especially with no close ups 👍
Please don't stop teaching us Corin. There's always something new to learn which music alone cannot teach.
Not sure about people wanting a silent video. I prefer listening to you Corin. You always give clear explanations during your work and that’s how we learn. For those that don’t want to hear it……. there’s a mute button on your device….’use it!!!’…….
...and put your favourite music on the radio! 🙂
I find your explaining what you are doing and why you are doing it, to be very educational.
Have the people who requested that you don't speak not got a volume button on their devices? Keep on with your commentary, don't let the few spoil it for the many.
Agree
Aggreeed@@harrietb2141
they can mute and play their own music, LOL!
Who would ask that? Don’t watch don’t say anything please leave
💯
I didnot see the video yet but in my opinion this gentleman is a born teacher. Please keep on talking.during the video's. I learn a lot from them
Hi Corin,
I much prefer to listen to your explanations of why you make the pruning decisions you do.
I learn a lot more that way.
Proof that not all opinions are good. Let’s get back to the original setup so the majority are happy. Thanks 🙏
We learn so much from you talking and you explaining your thought process, please don’t stop.
As someone with much to learn, I prefer your commentary, Corin.
Beautiful tree 💚
Great choice of music but who was the doughnut that requested that one of the countries leading bonsai experts cease teaching and providing instruction on their videos?
Love your videos, keep up the great work
You have the best bonsai channel on UA-cam for a reason. You explain your thoughts and practices and we as an audience learn from that. Beautiful collection and that maple in the intro is amazing! Let the naysayers use their volume buttons if they aren’t interested in an experts instruction.
I miss the « this one is growing up too much » and « this is a bit long » parts . To me that’s what is relevant AND relaxing . Thank you Corin for making such good content. Cheers
Hi Corin, I prefer it with the commentary. Why would people not want to know your thoughts and reasons on what you do? Isn't that why we enjoy watching your videos? By the way that is an awesome tree.
Really beautiful tree; well done! Well, everybody has the right on his or hers own opinion. I'm taking care and propagate bonsaï for more than three decades now. When you are talking while pruning, you are sharing your own thoughts, judgements, evaluations of the tree and the process of styling and taking care. I think one can learn (a lot) from that, and I know I do. And so, when bonsaï are (only) displayed, I can imagine some people prefer a certain level of silence or background "easy listening" or something like that. But, when working on a tree (and not only displaying it) by an experienced bonsaï nursery owner, I find it rather strange to prefer silence about the "job" and so, with no explanation at all about how and why. I mean: really strange... I rather prefer listening and learning... Keep up the good work, mr Tomlinson, I salute you!
I'm like a few other commenters. I much prefer to hear you speaking and teaching! Have a great trip away!👍
It is just like the painter, the late Bob Ross. Looking how his painting evolved was nice, but his voice made it complete and was very relaxing. Please continue speaking to us, Corin.
My second reaction on your silent video. With you explaining, teaching us what to do, makes it a lot more interesting. If people don't like what you do there are much more alternatives to suit them. You just keep on doing what you do best. Make films about bonsai and give your comment, so the true bonsailover learns and improves his bonsai. Keep on doing what you do
Why do people not want to hear all your expertise and knowledge? Turn the volume down if you want quiet. You're a wonderful teacher. And,I for one enjoy your speaking to us.
No way dude! I love having tell me what you are doing and why! Please don't stop your narration.
Lovely tree, and yes keep talking 👍
I will always enjoy your videos but I also prefer that you continue to talk and teach us all as you go.
Keep talking over the pruning videos! I enjoy how you explain your decisions.. you're a natural teacher! Also I have a drink every time you say "This ones growing down too much" lol
As much as I enjoy seeing the process of you pruning this magnificent tree, I much prefer listening to your commentary so I can get some insight into your thought process. Without the benefit of hearing your explanations I quickly get bored and can’t stop myself from fast-forwarding to see the end result.
Speechless with the tree and your work with it! I prefer when you're talking since every single word is a lesson!
I would also prefer to hear you talking with us, Corin, about what you're doing.
Sure missed you chatting us up!!
I have to agree with the others, Much better when you're educating orally Corin 👍😎
I like it better that you talk, beautiful tree. 👍
To be honest, I like it better when you talk as you share your knowledge and allows us to learn step by step what you are doing to the tree.
I miss your voice. But also, this is a really incredible experience. Thank you!
Keep talking Corin, your advice is 2nd to none! 👍🏼
I have learned SO much from you! Please don’t let the few spoil it for the rest of us! Especially since I bought a cedar for my collection because I saw you work on one! I like watching you work, could hang out all day, but I’d like to learn too. I agree with the others, those people can mute their device or play music on their own.
Yeah Nah...no more silent videos plz. Your talking is absolutely needed...👍
People that don't want to hear you, can put off the sound an play their own music....😒
Hi Corin. Great video but as with others I much prefer to hear your educational commentary!
I like you explain ing what you're doing and why. Also enjoyed this one too.
Fantastica pianta ! Lei bravissimo come al solito ! Complimenti 😮
I like your willingness to experiment, but I agree with the others who have said they prefer videos with commentary. Hearing your thought process as you work really helps people like me, who have only been doing bonsai for a couple of years. The more I hear experts explain why they're doing things as they're doing them, the more I remember and the more likely I am to make better decisions as I'm working on my own trees.
I prefer when you talk. I prefer the reggae/ska soundtrack. I feel like that's the Corin I've come to "know"!
ya man I too!!
I liked it , very chilled out .A happy medium between in depth tutorials and relaxing videos 👍🏻
Thank you for your sahring my friend. Always useful for your information bonsai training
Miss the “down to earth, educational commentary” but a worthwhile experiment. Can you resume normal service soon, please?
I have to agree with most of the other respondents: Your narrated videos are so informative for those of us looking to hone our bonsai skills that I find it such shame to eliminate your usual, accompanying narration. Those who prefer silence can always mute or lower the sound on their devices but why should they deprive us of helpful information?
Great job Corin,this cedar is really awesome!👏👏👏👏
I like your talking and instruction, the pruning with music is nice in the beginning but gets old quick after awhile.
Loving the cedar looks amazing not sure about the no talking though 😜
I can appreciate that you want to cater to your subscribers Corin. However, hearing your plan, the why/for etc is (like a previous person said) the whole point. Though i must say, doesn't matter what video format you try I will be watching them all, still your verbal thoughts make the video 100 times better. IMHO
Talk is good. No talk is good too. Thanks for the video Greenwood.🌿
Scrap the music Corin. Your commentary is all part of the learning process.
Hi Corin, I’m 1 minute in whilst reading the comments. It’s fair that people have their opinion, so therefore mine is - your content is absolutely brilliant, keep up the good work 👍🏾🇬🇧🌲I prefer the informative speaking style.
beautiful tree
I agree with so many of the other commenters. Silence and music while nice is not really why I'm a subscriber. We have so much we can learn from you Colin. IMHO, asking you not to talk was just plain rude.
normally like the walk through you give on videos but it was nice to you just be in your zone and not worrying about explaining what your doing
Much prefer you teaching us Corin. Good man.
Beautiful outcome but omg please bring back the commentary and close-ups so we understand what you’re doing 😂
No Corin, No! I’m in the states and I need to hear the accent, and all the fun sayings, like “We’re just gonna give this a bit of tidying oop” and “This wants cuttin back right here”. Your fans want to hear you! 👊
Please talk again and take us through your thought process and explanations. Especially with trees like this. ❤
Agree with all these comments, prefer Corin talking and teaching than music.
Nope. The video needs narration and close ups.
I agree with other people much better to hear you talk Corin... I think also as you explain your decisions it helps get an understanding of the what the final result will be... and how to apply logic to own trees... But love this tree :-)
Explaining to us what you are doing is knowledge. Don't change it.
Enjoyed this video, but prefer it when you give a comentry explaining what you are doing.
Love it Corin I came last Sunday and was wondering what tree that was. I was right 💪
So you didn’t think it was a larch then 😂😂😂🤔🤔😉
I much prefer the talk through way...
Hope to see more of those.
best thing about pruning bonsai is you add more than you take
Please don't do that again worst video ever sorry. For me i tune in to see Corin and hear his thoughts whilst explaining the process while working on trees that's the whole point . If people want silent video's i'm sure there are places they can google them!
Reggae and commentary please!
Thanks anyway!
I wholeheartedly agree!!!
Hopefully no more silent videos - we don't learning anything! For those who don't want to hear Corin's instruction, hit the mute button and play your own relaxing music. Great tree 😀
Another nice video Corin. Have you ever thought of wearing a go-pro video camera on a harness on your chest? I saw this done the other day and the viewer saw what the artist was doing as he saw it. It added another aspect to the video.
magnificent tree
1 vườn bonsai rất tuyệt ❤
Keep talking please!!! Love your videos!
Id much rather hear your voice with all your helpful tips along the way ! But thanks for trying another way !
I prefer the educational commentary.
I have to agree with the masses, you teaching is the reason i like watching your videos. Also, the camera angle didn't really allow me to see much of what your doing. Maybe a videographer wouldn't enhanced the silence but if still prefer hearing you explain your work.
Well, this is different. :) But to be honest, I don't mind you explaining what you are doing and why. That's relaxing and educational at the same time. But hey, you can never do it right for everybody can you? I enjoyed this very much anyway. Great tree, great video.
Bring back the commentary!!
By the way: as far as I know, you can easily switch off the sound on all contemporary devices, isn't it...?
Please real date this work
I say in video it’s the beginning of sept ?
@@greenwoodbonsaistudio super thanks master. very nice larch.regards from Poland.
Corin i think alot of viewers prefer your talking explaining why your trimming here here and here "this is growing up to much" "this is growing down too much" "and this will back bud if i trim it here"
keep up the commentary i say
An option is to do a voiceover commentary as and when you want to share insights on the tree so we can still learn!
well like most of the comments, please keep talking, I would of love to know how far you cut the shoots back to. Love the tree though
I like hearing about things that "grow op too moch" ) On a serious note, don't you think this tree is a bit too conical and dense?
The narration is necessary to help me understand what's going on. I watch these videos for self education. So a demo without any talking is like a car with no wheels.
Shame on the people who requested a no commentary video ! They should be silent for 1 month as penance.
When you do this type of pruning, do you stick to the practice of pruning to the first or second growth? Or do you use a different method.
I use my eye. Not to a certain amount, constantly evaluating
@@greenwoodbonsaistudio thank you for replying. The method in question seemed non-sensical to me.
Well I enjoy watching you but I also appreciate your comments to explain why you are doing whatever it is at that moment. I hope you don’t take their requests to heart. Most people want to hear you.
I prefer a few more close ups of detail. That would be nice and you explaining exactly what you are doing. After all you are teaching!
Bonjours, merci pour vos video, j adore la music de cette video, pourriez vous me dire son titre? Merci pour ce cèdre extraordinaire, le cèdre est un de mes arbres préférer. J'espère qu'un jour vos video seront traduit en Français ;o).
You can click on the settings to show subtitles in French on you tube
Corin you could've at least used TwoTone or Midlands Ska for the music instead of the Muzac in the video. Great result
Much prefer the narration. I pick up things i haven't thought about.
Actually missed your dulcet tones Corin, keep talking in your videos matey
Without your explanations it's like providing the fish but not teaching how to fish
Don't listen to "those people"!
Understanding target design, how and why to get there is what we learn from.
Please continue your videos as usual. If someone wants silence or music they can mute and listen to whatever they like. The rest of us won't be deprived of your insight. (The music is quite nice, but I miss your real time narration.)
Normal service resuming very soon
I would rather hear what you are doing to be honest. Music is fine but I have no idea regarding the reasoning behind the cut, especially with no close ups 👍
As a beginner hearing what You are doing is very necessary. I suggest the people who don’t want to listen learn to find the mute button.
Please talk to us next time.
พร้อมหลงทาง😢ในป่า😮หลงอะไรกลิ่นดินกลิ่นต้นไม้และดอกไม้😮เก็บกวาดสะอาดตาตัวอย่าง😮เสนอขายชีวิตคนๆนึงรักทุกอย่างที่เค้าทำ❤สุดยอดชีวิตเห็นผลจริงมนุษย์ไม่จะเป็นคนชาติใด😮ชีวิตรักธรรมชาติบำบัดดูแลเวลาเดินแล้ว🥰🥰เต็มตาเต็มปอดเต็มใจซื้อ❤?ความสำเร็จถ้าท่านมี✂️