This brings so many memories! I had the immeasurable honor to be the Armenian duduk player who played/recorded in this song with Sir Paul, in the original recording... God's amazing blessing!!... we recorded it at Ocean way Studios, on Sunset Blvd, L.A. & we did it in one take. I truly do not know how I feel about hearing my duduk lines --one of the most expressive instruments in all history-- played on a MIDI accordIon/controller, triggering a duduk sample... still, I Love this SUPER GRNIUS!!! God bless him!!
Its a personal opinion, and everyone will have their own favorites which I respect, but when I think of what I consider his greatest compositions, not just from his solo career but also from his Beatles days, this song gets a nice high ranking (and I am not an easy customer.) The twists of this vocal melody set against this guitar part is a HAUNTING bit of genius. It's one thing to learn to play it, its another to be the original creator of it out of thin air. Very nice live performance. The original version of this song from the Chaos & Creation CD is a sweet treasure.
Jay Spangler Very nice perspective. Paul had said the song derived from chords he played with George, that consisted of the beginning of a Bach piece. Which also had influenced Black Bird.
Unbelievably great! And complimented by his long-time Keyboard man, Wix Wicken's, performing a sublime "Duduk" solo on an accordion no less? Simply stunning musicianship!
I gave this song to my girl. Her name is Jenny. Yes, if you look at it, it can be translated random ways and moments in all one's life. With this song I have seen each moment all the way through remembering stories she'd tell me in ernest. What it comes down to, is that she has had a beautiful heart all along the way through hardships. And now, once again, as she realized who we are together, her weary walls have fallen away, the mending she never thought could mend and catching up on the life with the love she always knew existed. This song is beautiful as it describes her heart. Thank you, Paul.
Paul is a genius when it comes to melody..I'm trying to be a songwriter and just started writing a few songs but i always find myself clinging to the same style of melody...
Haven't followed Paul in years, but this one caught my ear and I've been hooked on it ever since. If you can play "Blackbird" you can nail this one. Love it!
This one is so beautiful it's even hard to express with words, and the accordion solo is heavenly. Unfortunately, I think this is the last of Paul's signature stirring songs as of today, coz his latest album didn't give us anything as beautiful as this one...
I am intrigued by the Duduk. One might have thought Cello could have played this part but I really like this choice. Saxophone is one of my instruments that I play. I am hoping some of my experience with sax could help me play this beautiful instrument.
Una pena que ya no la toque en vivo 😢
This brings so many memories! I had the immeasurable honor to be the Armenian duduk player who played/recorded in this song with Sir Paul, in the original recording... God's amazing blessing!!... we recorded it at Ocean way Studios, on Sunset Blvd, L.A. & we did it in one take. I truly do not know how I feel about hearing my duduk lines --one of the most expressive instruments in all history-- played on a MIDI accordIon/controller, triggering a duduk sample... still, I Love this SUPER GRNIUS!!! God bless him!!
Wonderful story!
This men is the best musician on the planet. Its amazing his ability to compose master pieces
You are perfectly right. Paul is the best. Next to his friends John, George (and Ringo because he has yellow Submarine)
And solo too
Proof that Paul is the greatest songwriter of the modern era.
Its a personal opinion, and everyone will have their own favorites which I respect, but when I think of what I consider his greatest compositions, not just from his solo career but also from his Beatles days, this song gets a nice high ranking (and I am not an easy customer.) The twists of this vocal melody set against this guitar part is a HAUNTING bit of genius. It's one thing to learn to play it, its another to be the original creator of it out of thin air. Very nice live performance. The original version of this song from the Chaos & Creation CD is a sweet treasure.
Jay Spangler Very nice perspective. Paul had said the song derived from chords he played with George, that consisted of the beginning of a Bach piece. Which also had influenced Black Bird.
@@Versul1 ua-cam.com/video/3rsJIxV9XVU/v-deo.html
@@Versul1 I didn't notice I said John.
YOUR’RE NOT AN EASY CUSTOMER ? Wtf dude. Who care what you are. Keep it simple. It’s a beautiful song
@@stevescontriano860 I think you have misunderstood what I was saying and why. No matter. Peace to you.
Unbelievably great! And complimented by his long-time Keyboard man, Wix Wicken's, performing a sublime "Duduk" solo on an accordion no less? Simply stunning musicianship!
I gave this song to my girl. Her name is Jenny. Yes, if you look at it, it can be translated random ways and moments in all one's life.
With this song I have seen each moment all the way through remembering stories she'd tell me in ernest. What it comes down to, is that she has had a beautiful heart all along the way through hardships. And now, once again, as she realized who we are together, her weary walls have fallen away, the mending she never thought could mend and catching up on the life with the love she always knew existed. This song is beautiful as it describes her heart.
Thank you, Paul.
AMAZING song and very difficult To play
Preciosa canción ❤
Paul is a genius when it comes to melody..I'm trying to be a songwriter and just started writing a few songs but i always find myself clinging to the same style of melody...
Idk why but when Abe came out of the shadow beating the drum it was just epic
Such a catchy and beautiful melody... pure McCartney!
El mejor album de Paul chaos and creation💜💜
Este hombre es UN mago de la musica grandes recuerdos
Perfect live performance of this lovely, bitter-sweet masterpiece!
love Paul, love this song.
Haven't followed Paul in years, but this one caught my ear and I've been hooked on it ever since. If you can play "Blackbird" you can nail this one. Love it!
McCartney smokin as always. Took me a while to learn this on guitar
This one is so beautiful it's even hard to express with words, and the accordion solo is heavenly. Unfortunately, I think this is the last of Paul's signature stirring songs as of today, coz his latest album didn't give us anything as beautiful as this one...
Yeah but Save Us is just kickass
you right but you forget " early days" the same style
And in McCartney III there are some spicy tracks too
@@meestuinier4486 What are your favorite tracks?
@@kermeetton the kiss of Venus and long and tailed winter bird 😅
best version live!!!
Amo esta canción 😍 me encanta 💖
I feel special
❤❤❤ AMAZING SIMPLE AND YET POWERFUL MOVING MELODY !!!!!
I am intrigued by the Duduk. One might have thought Cello could have played this part but I really like this choice. Saxophone is one of my instruments that I play. I am hoping some of my experience with sax could help me play this beautiful instrument.
beautiful. why doesn't he play this anymore?
johann vs he plays nothing from chaos nowadays
He can’t reach the notes anymore..Age ...........
Una pena que no esté en algún álbum en vivo. Y tengamos veinte versiones de jet, Let me roll It o my love
this man is "the one". jenny wren is a leyend in the voice y creation of other leyend.
Fucking great!!!
A true world. Musican
That was excellent!
❤️
Love Wix!
I love this song❤! (but not the ending)
Love this song, the best on the album "Chaos..." and among the best song of Paul's in this century (I still prefer "My Valentine")
Me equivoco si digo que es mejor que Blackbird??
No te equivocas en nada
The end of the sun seems like "Mother Nature's Son"
Máster
Paul McCrtchan
What exactly is the drummer doing here and why?
the beatles are still alive
Paul was inspired by armenian duduk.
Indeed! And it's aural equivalent, beautifully performed on the accordion, was outstanding. Djavan Gasparian would, no doubt, have appreciated it.
@@artdonovandesign The Father of Armenian duduk is Azeri Tutek. Stop disinform people all around the world. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dilli_kaval
This song is so overrated honestly this is a great song and Paul is one of the greatest singer of all time he’s a legend.
You can be a musical genius and not think Paul McCartney writes good music. It's a matter of opinion. Get over, people have conflicting opinions.
Is that just random women from the crowd that it was doing intimate closeups on throughout the song? Not weird at all 😆