Best Debut, Most Overhyped, Biggest Disappointment of 2024 + More!

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 22 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 70

  • @GarganoA
    @GarganoA 4 дні тому +2

    Agree with both of you on the new Crowded House. The stuff I'd heard from them in the past was all "eh, it's ok" and this new one really impressed me. I think I need to go back and listen to everything from them again.

  • @riffreverence
    @riffreverence 4 дні тому +4

    I absolutely agree with Joe, Invincible Shield kicks so much ass.
    Also, I have to say that the Blood Incatation album cover is also pretty dope.

  • @edward8597
    @edward8597 4 дні тому +2

    "Lives Outgrown" by Beth Gibbons would be my Senior Circuit winner. Absolutely incredible album. And "Dummy" was exactly 30 years ago, so it counts!

  • @179rich
    @179rich 4 дні тому +1

    Here we go!

  • @179rich
    @179rich 4 дні тому +2

    Time for y'all to deep dive Crowded House 🥳

    • @edward8597
      @edward8597 4 дні тому +2

      They did do Split Enz. But Neil Finn generally speaking seems like he'd be right up Jason's alley. He's just such an effortless melodicist. He's one of those artists who one day will pass away and everyone will talk about how much they always loved him. But here in life? He doesn't get 1/10th the acclaim he ought to. Crowded House, Split Enz, Finn Brothers, albums with his wife and with his son, true solo stuff... There's *so* much out there and so much of it is incredible.

    • @curly_wyn
      @curly_wyn 4 дні тому

      I never got the love for them. Good songwriting but itself does not a great band make. Musically, they’re just boring bland vanilla dated acoustic guitar-based soft rock.

  • @Sir_Eyeball
    @Sir_Eyeball 4 дні тому +3

    This year I didn't get to listen to that much music compared to last year, still got to 42 albums in the end.
    Album Cover: Chelsea Wolfe - She Reaches out to She Reaches out to She
    Overhyped: Charli XCX - BRAT
    Biggest Surprise: St Vincent - All Born Screaming
    Biggest Disappointment: Fontaines D.C. - Romance (Still a good album, but the singles are much better than the rest)
    Best Debut: Warm Exit - Ultraviolence
    Senior Circuit: The Cure - Songs of a Lost World
    Best Comeback: The Cure - Songs of a Lost World
    An album only I liked: Lime Garden - One More Thing (Got it at 4.5 stars, RYM score is 3.08)

  • @floydshambles
    @floydshambles 4 дні тому +1

    great video. i don't like when somebody implies that people just pretend to like a certain artist or album.

  • @independenceltd.
    @independenceltd. 4 дні тому +2

    album cover: Ironflame - Kingdom Torn Asunder
    overhyped: Opeth - The Last Will and Testament
    biggest surprise: Antioch - Antioch VII: Gates of Obliteration
    biggest disappointment: Pallbearer - Mind Burns Alive
    senior circuit: Saxon - Hell, Fire and Damnation
    best debut - Hands of Goro - Hands of Goro
    best comeback: The Black Crowes - Happiness Bastards
    against the grain; Richie Kotzen - Nomad
    ep: Demon Spell - Evil Nights

  • @LEMOnBRaINn
    @LEMOnBRaINn 4 дні тому +3

    Coldplays new album was SURPRISINGLY good tho the singles where terrible but there’s a lot of beautiful string arrangements on that album moon music, One World, Jupiter,rainbow, all my love, Aeterna all really great songs imo

  • @Vanessa.P
    @Vanessa.P 4 дні тому +2

    Album Cover: either To Shoot Another Day by Rosalie Cunningham or Plunge by Sam Evian
    Overhyped: agree with both of your picks
    Biggest Surprise: Cheekface, not because I had any bad experience with them but I remember seeing other people in the Discord really dislike their previous album in 2022 (I never heard it)
    Biggest Disappointment: Beth Gibbons, I didn't hear what other people heard with that one sadly (although Dua Lipa is a good one, I couldn't even finish it)
    Senior Circuit: Agree with both Judas Priest and Crowded House
    Best Debut: probably Friko, not sure if RIP Dunes really counts since he had previous projects
    Best Comeback: I was really disappointed by the Chloe and the Next 20th Century so Mahashmashana was a very welcome comeback for me
    Against the Grain: Not sure what to put here either, the one I was going to pick (J Robbins - Basilisk) used to have a really low average on RYM but it has actually gone up
    EP: Apollo Ghosts - Amethyst

  • @niallq8447
    @niallq8447 17 годин тому +1

    Like sprints album which is think is underrated.

  • @mattjohn4731
    @mattjohn4731 4 дні тому +1

    Debut 30 years ago is senior circuit? Then I must confess my fav artists are on the senior circuit. MDC, Alice Bag, Billy Bragg, Napalm Death, Redd Kross, the Cure, Steve Earle... Can you change the definition to 40 or 50 years since debut??

    • @mattjohn4731
      @mattjohn4731 4 дні тому

      Also Roger Waters is great. He speaks out while Young and Dylan play it safe

  • @AP530
    @AP530 4 дні тому +2

    Album cover of the year by Joe - Triple Fantasy where Joe photoshopped himself sticking his tongue into the john n yoko kiss on the Double Fantasy cover.. Quite brilliant actually

  • @bartholomeusjgunspy
    @bartholomeusjgunspy 4 дні тому +1

    Cover: BLUE LIPS - Schoolboy Q
    Overhyped: HMHAS - Billie Eilish
    Surprise: 2093 - Yeat
    Disappointment: WHY LAWD? - NxWorries
    Debut: Prelude to Ecstasy - TLDP
    Senior: Wild God - Nick Cave & TBS
    Comeback: Missionary - Snoop & Dre
    ATG: Like All Before You - The Voidz
    EPOTY: Connla's Well - Maruja

    • @niallq8447
      @niallq8447 4 дні тому +1

      Best debut. Last dinner party. You are bang on

  • @MaryScottHunter
    @MaryScottHunter 2 дні тому +1

    hmmm... Jason, you've turned me on to such great music (Nico Paulo, Kacey Johansing, Wednesday, etc.), but the Waxahatchee review surprised me. While I can respect not liking it as much as St. Cloud, rating it your biggest disappointment is surprising. To me Tiger's Blood is St. Cloud plus MJ Lenderman. While maybe not as fresh, still pretty darn good!

  • @davidellis5141
    @davidellis5141 4 дні тому +3

    Songs Of A Lost World 🌎 wins my 🏆 for Senior Circuit & Best Comeback.

    • @curly_wyn
      @curly_wyn 4 дні тому

      Facepalm. Jeez.

    • @davidellis5141
      @davidellis5141 4 дні тому +1

      Curly - As The Dude would say .. " Well , That's Uh Just Like Your Opinion Man " Please stop posting 📫 🙄 negatively in my replies. It's ponderous .. Man !

    • @curly_wyn
      @curly_wyn 4 дні тому

      @@davidellis5141 hey, what is life without a little balance? ;)

  • @nickmoss2046
    @nickmoss2046 4 дні тому +1

    Surprised we share so much:
    Cover: Geordie Greep
    Overhyped: brat. It's...fine... just EVERYWHERE
    Biggest surprise: Vince Staples makes great music again! Also me finally liking a Fontaines D.C. album was shocking
    Senior circuit: some good choices, but kudos to The Cure
    Best debut: I'm not going to cheat and pick veteran debuts or supergroups and say Friko
    Best comeback: who knew Los Campesinos! had such a masterpiece left in them after basically being on hiatus
    Against the grain: I liked the Japandroids final album more than most of the fanbase it seems
    Best EP: Nourished By Time by a million miles

  • @AllMediaReviewsPodcast
    @AllMediaReviewsPodcast 4 дні тому +1

    I can't avoid thinking of the cover and a song from Genesis Nursery Cryme (+The Musical Box lyrics) when seeing the cover of the Geordie Greep album.

    • @curly_wyn
      @curly_wyn 4 дні тому +1

      So gross and edgy for me, thumbs down.

  • @ShivasIrons22
    @ShivasIrons22 4 дні тому +1

    Have been wanting to ask, is that a golf bag over your left shoulder in the background Jason? Can't tell, and would not have pegged you as a golfer.

    • @curly_wyn
      @curly_wyn 4 дні тому

      It’s a guitar case

  • @nicjones7102
    @nicjones7102 4 дні тому +3

    Album of the year = Bill Ryder-Jones

    • @fmk1093
      @fmk1093 4 дні тому +1

      Love that album

  • @AP530
    @AP530 4 дні тому +7

    I thought my comments would have been nominated for most annoying?? Not even nominated!

    • @Manicprogressive1
      @Manicprogressive1 4 дні тому +2

      Ha, ha. Not even close. I do my rambles/rants at midnight when I’m going to sleep. Typical editor who can’t edit themselves.

  • @echosmyron1278
    @echosmyron1278 4 дні тому +2

    Most overhyped: Charli XCX - Brat (I don't even dislike this album; I gave it a light 8/10 and put it in my honorable mentions. However, it has dominated numerous year-end lists, and I don't think it's worthy of all these accolades; Charli (2019) was superior, but received less praise.)
    Biggest disappointment: St. Vincent - All Born Screaming (Another album that I liked. Unfortunately, the industrial rock aesthetic isn't explored to the degree I was anticipating, and I'm not crazy about track 2 or the album's closing leg. This is the first St. Vincent studio record not to make my top 50, breaking a 6-album (or 17-year) streak, and thus has to be considered my disappointment of 2024.)
    And now for my 5 least-favorite acclaimed (not necessarily universal acclaim) albums of 2024:
    5. Ariana Grande - Eternal Sunshine: I disagree with the sentiment that 2024 was a great year for mainstream pop. Billie/Dua Lipa/Camila Cabelo/Taylor Swift/Sabrina Carpenter/FLO put out middling material, but this Grande album was the most boring one of the bunch.
    4. Pearl Jam - Dark Matter: A dull and pointless album from a 90s legacy act. Bands like Collective Soul, Smashing Pumpkins, Dandy Warhols, Primal Scream, and Jesus & Mary Chain also put out lackluster records in 2024, but at least those ones were ignored.
    3. Phosphorescent - Revelator: Winner of the 2024 Andy Shauf Prize for blandest indie folk album.
    2. Sprints - Letter to Self: Some of the most uninspired post-punk I've ever heard. The band has no chemistry whatsoever.
    1. Body Meat - Starchris: A nightmarish, autotune-filled fusion of R&B/pop that encompasses every modern trend of music that I despise. Grotesque and hideous.
    (The rest of my honorable mentions from 2024 will be in the replies. I'm getting everything out of the way so that I only need to post my favorite songs and albums in the next year-end videos.)

    • @echosmyron1278
      @echosmyron1278 4 дні тому +3

      Another 30-or-so albums that I couldn't fit in my top 50. All of these are still in the 4-star range!
      Saidan - Visual Kill: The Blossoming of Psychotic Depravity
      NØ MAN - Glitter and Spit
      Cosmic Putrefaction - Emerald Fires Atop the Farewell Mountains
      Summoning the Lich - Under the Reviled Throne
      A Place to Bury Strangers - Synthesizer
      Fat Dog - WOOF.
      Michelle - Songs About You Specifically
      Ripped to Shreds - Sanshi
      Sierra Ferrell - Trail of Flowers
      Civerous - Maze Envy
      Osees - Sorcs 80
      Remi Wolf - Big Ideas
      The Lemon Twigs - A Dream Is All We Know
      Blood Incantation - Absolute Elsewhere
      Aetheria Conscientia - The Blossoming
      Escuela Grind - Dreams on Algorithm
      Wormwitch - Wormwitch
      Tribulation - Sub Rosa in Aeternum
      Ulcerate - Cutting the Throat of God
      F****d Up - Another Day
      Charli XCX - Brat
      Krallice - Inorganic Rites
      The Chisel - What a F*****g Nightmare
      The Decemberists - As It Ever Was, So It Will Be Again
      Glass Beach - Plastic Death
      Robber Robber - Wild Guess
      death's dynamic shroud - American Candy
      Nap Eyes - The Neon Gate
      The Bevis Frond - Focus on Nature
      Nicolette & the Nobodies - The Long Way

  • @BeerwithDonuts
    @BeerwithDonuts 4 дні тому +12

    My biggest disappointments of 2024 were Jason’s opinions on Sign o the times and seventeen seconds.
    Hey, Jason. Santa called. You’re on the naughty list!

    • @curly_wyn
      @curly_wyn 4 дні тому

      Release the cooooooal!

    • @afinn5555
      @afinn5555 4 дні тому +2

      Best Cure album ever

    • @curly_wyn
      @curly_wyn 4 дні тому

      @@afinn5555omg..r u serious? 😖

    • @TastesLikeMusic
      @TastesLikeMusic  4 дні тому +1

      He means 17 seconds not the new one. Relax

    • @afinn5555
      @afinn5555 4 дні тому

      @@TastesLikeMusic She! And yes!

  • @JJ-ez3tr
    @JJ-ez3tr 4 дні тому +1

    Best album: DIIV “Frog In Boiling Water”

  • @mjleger
    @mjleger 4 дні тому +1

    Bikini Body's Weird Party is the best EP of 2024 IMO, with Chelsea Wolfe's Unbound on the "need to listen to that properly" list.
    Embarrassed the biggest surprise for me is Geordie Greep since black midi was news to me, and I think both are great. The cover I didn't particularly like because it rips off Cultural Revolution imagery for the sake of love-murder navel gazing, but since that's what the New Sound is all about then it fits. In terms of covers, the Brat LP should be placed next to the Durutti Column sandpaper cover.
    I discovered this year that Canadian artist Baby Rose has a really good voice.
    In new to me I added to my itunes Bubu (Anabelas), some Wobbler albums, German Oak, Cardiacs and The Necessaries.
    Biggest disappointment was Cardi B speech for Kamala Harris. She should have shamed her rather than praising. Also disappointing is that Sweeping Promises are dragging their feet on making merch available online to fanatics. How hard can it be to print t-shirts.

  • @niallq8447
    @niallq8447 4 дні тому +1

    Best debut. The last dinner party
    Other good debuts are Sprints /English Teacher / NewDad
    Best comeback. The cure
    Most overhyped. Charil xcx brat.
    Biggest disappointment. Fontaines DC romance (although it was very good)

  • @matsetizar65
    @matsetizar65 2 дні тому +1

    My top disappointment is Valley of the Sun. Just lazy riffs, ones you’ve heard in a million metal songs. Previous album was so good, so I was really excited for it. I didn’t like the new Priest either, but semi expected it. Metal has not been good and this made me turn to country, sometimes.

  • @mitchellbenefiel4490
    @mitchellbenefiel4490 4 дні тому

    Are you guys going to react to any end of year best albums lists like Rolling Stone? That was fun last year

    • @TastesLikeMusic
      @TastesLikeMusic  4 дні тому +4

      We recorded a tier list video where we look at a bunch of em

  • @nightowl1851
    @nightowl1851 4 дні тому +1

    Ed Harcourt is in my top 10, but so is Waxahatchee.
    Overrated: Brat, Beth Gibbons, SPRINTS
    Biggest Disappointment: MGMT, Jesus and Mary Chain
    Favorite debut: Friko, The Last Dinner Party
    Senior Circuit award: X
    "LP only I liked": The Umbrellas
    Your Cindy Lee thoughts are music to my ears because I've been bracing myself for a 2-hour listen for months.

    • @curly_wyn
      @curly_wyn 4 дні тому +1

      Cindy Lee’s interminable album is just that. It’s too long. It’s way too damn long, especially for the quality of music that it is, it’s just too much. It’s not an Exile on Main Street or London Calling or 69 Love Songs situation where more is more, where every single song is amazing. Not the case at all.

    • @niallq8447
      @niallq8447 17 годин тому

      Sprints are underrated. Night owl

    • @niallq8447
      @niallq8447 17 годин тому

      Agree with you best debut which is spot on. Night owl.

    • @niallq8447
      @niallq8447 17 годин тому

      ​@@curly_wynwhite album

  • @timothyflanery5237
    @timothyflanery5237 4 дні тому +2

    Thanks, guys. Looking forward to a great year of music for 2025!
    1. Album Cover- Rockabilly Queen- Linda Gale Lewis 2. Overhyped- MJ Lenderman- Manning Fireworks 3. Biggest Surprise- Jess Cornelius- Care/Taking 4. Biggest Disappointment- Wild God- Nick Cave 5. Debut- Sprints - Letter To Self 6. Senior Circuit Award- X- Smoke & Fiction 7. Comeback Album- Beth Gibbons- Lives Outgrown 8. My Favorite Critically Ignored- Kevin Burt and Big Medecine- Thank You Brother Bill 9. Favorite EP- Kaeto-Intro

  • @paulok2153
    @paulok2153 16 годин тому +1

    man. crowded house were awesome back in the day, but I'm never going to feel brat, is it age? or could IT be she's just not that good?

  • @westong6215
    @westong6215 4 дні тому +5

    Thank you Jason for saying Brat is the most overhyped! Most overrated album this year no question.

    • @Hi85C
      @Hi85C 4 дні тому

      Jason not liking Brat and picking it as most over-hyped. Sure didn't see that coming.

  • @detectivecox
    @detectivecox 4 дні тому +1

    Charli XCX list go!

  • @anthonybernard3689
    @anthonybernard3689 4 дні тому +2

    Biggest suprise....Kram leaving!

  • @curly_wyn
    @curly_wyn 4 дні тому +1

    My favorite album cover:
    The Reflectors - Going Out of Fashion (great stylization and font!)
    My best debut of the year:
    Tie = Mk.gee - Two Star & the Dream Police, Liana Flores - Flower of the Soul
    Most overhyped album:
    Geordie Greep - The New Sound (I can’t believe you guys liked this one so much, it’s awful. It’s noodly and incel-y and gross and grating and annoying. And that album cover is awful too! I hate his accent, I hate his voice, and I hate the lyrics. Just edgy for the sake of being edgy.), but that Cindy Lee album isn’t far behind.
    Biggest disappointment:
    The Cure - Songs of a Lost World (it’s just diminishing returns for me, and not some amazing expectation-crushing all-time comeback. Not even close.)
    Biggest surprise:
    Jessica Pratt - Here in the Pitch (I never heard her before and now I love her, and Better Hate is one of my favorite songs ever now!)
    Senior circuit:
    Redd Kross - Redd Kross
    (Gotta be them for me, and I agree: great album cover too!)
    Best comeback:
    Blank. Can’t really see any album in my top list as a true comeback, although they’re all great.
    Against the grain? I’ll pick a negative that I feel alone in not liking, two of them:
    Again, the Geordie Greep album and the new Cure album. 👎🏻👎🏻
    EP of the year?
    Surprisingly, it’s: neverminds - nevermind, the winter.
    (Yeah, I didn’t even look at this one, and I really super enjoyed it!)
    Great awards video for 2024, boys! :3