He's my 2nd cousin :) My grandmothers half sisters son. I just found out, our family is from The Six Nations reservation ( Ohsweken is a village on the Six Nations of the Grand River First Nation Indian reserve near ... Ohsweken, Ontario, Canada) :)
Im from Alberta, Canada stand up!!!!!!!!!!!!! Im not native though. Can you tell me what Tribe you and him are from ? In Alberta its mostly Plains Cree. You got artistic blood in you, Don't waste it
Mohawk. I also have Mississauga( My Grandmother) & Oneida... ~ (My Grandfathers mother, was Mohawk & Oneida). Just on my Mothers side however.(her parents) .... From my fathers side Im Polish, Russian and Mongolian. So I guess that makes me a Pohawk :/ LoL
im skimming through robbies memoir called testimony now, he met his wife dominique in france where she was a journalist covering the french music scene and robbie said french speaking girls from montreal didnt like english speaking people from toronto that much but robbie won her over.
Very profound. Reading Robbie's book Testimony I would say he had more than a full life. Having lived to 80 I suppose is a long life, however as I'm approching that age my self, not so sure. His life was not always easy, especially some of his childhood and teenage years. His stepfather got more and more abusive to Robbie and his mother, gave Robbie a black eye, hit him so hard once he fell against a wall and got a nasty bruise on his face. Also hit Robbie's dog, which Robbie never forgave him for. After his mother divorced Robbie's stepfather things got better, she encouraged Robbie in his dreams to become a musician. When he hooked up with Ronnie Hawkins, Ronnie, Levon and others would often stay at Robbie's house, his mother charged reasonable rate and apparently she was quite a cook.
@@hannejeppesen1809 I'm reading it now. I have to take frequent breaks to look up a song he names, or a movie, or a time in their history, or just to sit in front of my great sound system and listen to some of their music full blast. A band like no other.
His self titled album was the very first CD I ever bought, back when CD's were a thing. I played it endlesslly and I'm here right now watching this video to pay respects and because his music echoes in my heart. Rest In Power Robbie Robertson. Your music is poetry that will forever travel throughout the universe. Lay a flower in the snow...
@@mbrew3244 Yes it was. Robbie's an artist's artist...he had the Bodeans, Peter Gabriel, Bono all on it. And his voice is so unique and strange sounding, yet it works perfectly for his music. Some Where Down The Crazy River really does feel like you're in a dream. Very sad Robbie is no longer with us anymore.
So humbled, reading these comments. These songs.....this...Somewhere Down the Crazy River, they came around at a time when i was making my way towards them. That is to say, my journey through music. I was 22. Heavy into 1960s British invasion and such. Through that, i made it into Dylan, then The Band, etc etc... But during these younger days i remember Robbies name circulating. My older cousins talking about him and his indian heritage. Years later, By the time I was immersed into The Band, they became my timeless Up North, back roading listen while driving music. I was back in 1968, amongst pines that surely looked as they did then and simultaneously the Band was with Me in 2003, 4, 5,.... Their music was like that for me. Immediate. I was never sure if i was back then or they were playing next to me. Like the image of them in upper New York next to the old car. My northern Michigan was like that. Still is. But they all felt like musical friends of mine. So, as these icons of ours from a musical renaissance one by one, say goodbye, i feel a piece of me does as well. Reality of our mortality? As long as they remain we feel safe? Comforted. When they go, it feels like floodgates of emotion for the shamen of our youth. Our elders. Their wisdom. All the while, they were simply living and doing, playing and making music.....but it resonates to our cores. Thank you for the music Robbie. Reading everyones words here shows Me what one person, along with a group of like minded individuals can leave behind. Many deeply touched souls with wonderful memories. 1987 seems like yesterday. By the time i fully immersed in The Band, Robbie was 60. Time waits for no one. Our memories and the music will take us the rest of the way. R.I.P. Robbie.
One of the 80's most overlooked gems. The great Peter Gabriel singing harmony always gives me chills and cant say enough about Manu Katche's incredible drumming.
This whole album is just fantastic! I implore you all to sit down in front of a decent music system, open a bottle of beverage of choice, and just enjoy... RIP, Robbie... You gave me incredible moments... Thank you!
This song is an elegy to Richard Manuel, who along with Robbie Robertson, was one of the original members of The Band. Manuel, who was the Band's pianist and sometimes vocalist, was found hanging in the bathroom of a motel room in Winter Park, Florida on March 4, 1986. The group had re-formed (without Robertson) and played in Winter Park, Florida the preceding night. Manuel had serious problems with addiction for most of his life, but got sober when The Band started touring again in the '80s. He began abusing drugs and alcohol again in 1985, which likely contributed to his death. Eric Clapton's "Holy Mother" on his 1986 album August is also a tribute to Richard Manuel as is "Too Soon Gone," The Band's tribute to Richard from their 1993 album Jericho. "Fallen Angel" was the first single Robertson released as a solo artist. He wrote the song with Martin Page, who had co-written the hits "These Dreams" and "We Built This City." In our interview with Page, he explained: "Robbie was playing with lyrical ideas for a huge period of time and every time I would go back to the Village (the recording studio in Los Angeles) to work with him, it was quite frustrating, because I thought we were doing very well and he'd say, 'I've changed the words.' He would sing it and ask me, 'What do you think?' And I'd say, 'Well, I think it's all good, Rob. Really good.' Everything he did I thought was fine. But then one special day he called me and he said, 'I really have what this song's about.' At first it was going to be called 'War of Angels,' and it was going to be the idea of fallen angels actually falling out of heaven and touching hell. He was really getting into this kind of biblical place. But all of a sudden, very emotionally he said to me, 'It's about Richard.' And I could see in his face that he'd nailed it. It was his special song to Richard Manuel. I think it was a great testament to his undying friendship for his friend who left a little too early." This song features Peter Gabriel on keyboards. Gabriel also provides vocals on the chorus accompanying Robbie Robertson. The Robbie Robertson album won the Juno Award for Album of the Year in 1989.
thank you for your input. Robbie will always be an awesome song writer no question. I just feel that whatever was in his heart when he wrote this those feelings were expressed years to late. it would have been so much more meaningful if it had been when Richard was alive.
Steve Morse great story! What a treat it must have been to work with him. He is someone I have always wanted to meet. My mother passed away the year this album was released. This song in particular, stood out for me when thinking of my mother's long battle with cancer and untimely death at a pivotal time in my life. I included a few lines from the song in a tribute to her in my high school year book as she died the summer leading into my senior year. Robbie is not only a talented musician, lyricist, and artist, but also a great ambassador for Native Americans and Indigenous people in North America. Although he is in his 70's now and put on a few pounds since this video, he still sounds and looks great. He may not have the greatest vocal range, but knows how to deliver a melody in a distinct way and feel that he is able to connect with the listener and relay a story with emotional depth.
A moving tribute that Robbie wrote for bandmate Richard Manuel. Robbie has never been thought of as a lead singer. But on this song, Robbie captured the essence of Richard's singing and his soul. May you RIP with Richard, Rick and Levon.
He actually sang lead on a few songs. I wish he'd done more when he was with The Band, because he has a fine voice, close to Richard's as you can hear on "The Last Waltz Reprise." His vocal on "Out of the Blue," is very good, too, probably his best vocal with The Band.
Definitely Daniel is wonderful has produced several albums he's great! Robbie is one top fave musician! saw him in 60's backing up Bob Dylan in gig in Syracuse with The Band!... was fantastic ❤😊
Robbie Robertson is one of those rare musicians who brings you joy. To hear his work is to understand music. Robertson had a deeply personal relationship to his art, and he used it to connect to the world. I’m feeling his loss tonight. RIP Robbie Robertson
Robbie Robertson's 1987 self titled album is a spiritually uplifting and powerful celebration of music and life and these two legends Robbie and Peter Gabriel deliver one of the most haunting vocal performances
Are you out there? Can you hear me? Can you see me in the dark? I don't believe it's all for nothing It's not just written in the sand Sometimes I thought you felt too much And you crossed into the shadow land And the river was overflown And the sky was fiery red You gotta play the hand that's dealt ya That's what the old man always said Fallen angel Casts a shadow up against the sun If my eyes could see The spirit of the chosen one In my dream the pipes were playing In my dream I lost a friend Come down, Gabriel, and blow your horn 'Cause some day we will meet again Fallen angel Casts a shadow up against the sun If my eyes could see The spirit of the chosen one All the tears, all the rage All the blues in the night If my eyes could see You kneeling in the silver light Fallin', fallin', fallin' down Fallin', fallin' down Fallin', fallin', fallin' down Fallin', fallin' down Fallin', fallin', fallin' down Fallin', fallin' down Fallen angel Casts a shadow up against the sun If my eyes could see The spirit of the chosen one All the tears, all the rage All the blues in the night If my eyes could see You kneeling in the silver light If you're out there, can you touch me? Can you see me? I don't know If you're out there, can you reach me? And lay a flower in the snow Fallin' down, fallin' down Fallin' down, fallin' down Fallin' down, fallin' down Fallin' down, fallin' down Fallin' down, fallin' down
When my best friend, Tim, committed suicide, I went to this song to help me process that loss. We had enjoyed it together often and in his absence now, I come to this song to recall him in all his golden glory. RIP, my friend.
There is a magic synergy between Robertson and Gabriel's voices which is just the audible signal of their deep and sincere commitments to genuine causes..this song is a masterpiece in terms of true emotions!
Thank you Robbie and everyone who participated in this album...wonderful atmosphere, this energy goes straight to the soul, timeless music and production. Beautiful video. Rest in Peace Robbie!
As a Canadian Robbie was something special. His sensibility never left his music. The heart and love of his music was to me, educational. I came to this piece way back when it came out because it was essentially Peter Gabriels band and I have been a life long follower of PG. What I found though was not just great music from Robbie but the very first message to me, that as a Canadian, made me begin to question our long standing horrible treatment of Indiginous Canadians. His third album Music for the Native American was an emotional eye opener for me and for many others I think. Perhaps it is a bold thing to say, but for me personally, a European, Robbie Robertson was the beginning of understanding what reconciliation really means. You just have to truly listen
A song or piece of art can mean many things to many people. The thing that stands out to me listening to this songs and reading the comments. Don’t let things go unsaid or live with anger and resentment in your heart. If we forgive and live without fear we are truly living in the moment and creating heaven on earth
Thank you. 1987 for me, too. But, both my children have told me that this song is a touchstone for them, since they heard on the CD in the car(s) approximately 1000 times. Hoping this song, and all Robbie's amazing work, will endure through this and other means. God bless Robbie.
@lonewolf81252 I have been absolutely fascinated by Native Americans since I was a young child. My father did his "preceptorship" (training after medical school) on a Cherokee reservation when I was just a baby. And I KNOW in my heart that I have spent at least one previous lifetime as a Native American. I hate to see anyone denied their civil rights and experiencing abuse because of their race!! We came over here and stole their country. Sometimes I'm not terribly "proud to be an America".
When I got the call that my cousin unexpectedly passed away I played this for days on repeat. Cheers to you, Jed. And cheers to Mr. Manuel. May you both be happy wherever you may be.
Robbie does a lot of sad songs~~~~He sings of our ancestors and us now..Sometimes it's not what we want to hear, but listen to all his stuff..he so wants us "to live again!" We live through our ancestors as our ancestors live through us! Listen people!
+darling darlene snyder One day , we will be great again. Maybe not in this world. Maybe not here... I feel my ancestors run through my blood. This song makes me cry , really. And no one would have song it better with Robbie than Peter Gabriel
RIP Robbie. I was 17 back in 87 and my dad died of cancer . I had so many questions about his death and when I heard this song it brought me peace . I think I played it a hundred times that year . Your albums were brilliant Robbie - Rest in peace .
The addition of Peter Gabriel on this track compliments the depth of this song to no end. When he starts the harmony One can feel how much from the heart he and Robbie really do sing.
What an incredibly poignant song. Such a touching tribute from Robbie to embattled bandmate Richard Manuel. Great harmony vocals from Peter Gabriel, a year after his absolute classic record So. Peter, Robbie, Daniel Lanois and their players struck gold on Robbie’s eponymous solo debut
Bought this album when it was new and played it till I could see through the vinyl. Still puts me in a very emotional mood. All songs about a lost friend can have that affect. This was a great piece of work.
I played this song at my Mum's funeral , it was perfect. It was only days out back then. It said what I felt. When I hear it , I can feel her standing there beside me. I miss her badly. THANKYOU , Robbie. (Fallen Angel).
RIP brother. This song spoke volumes to me throughout the entirety of my life and it’s one of the first I can actually remember hearing. This whole album has forever been a favorite of mine. Broken arrow lives rent free in my mind until the day I get to meet you on the other side. Later in life I discovered you were a part of so much more music I had already come to love. You are one of the most inspiring musicians in my life and a big reason of why I began to love music in the first place. I’m sad to lose another person I looked up to, but I’m grateful for the impact you left on me.
Beautiful sing, and Robbie and Peter Gabriel s viices meshed so well together. Just as beautiful the video, very pognant and thought provoking as are all of Robbie's videos. Thanks fir your guft if music Robbie !
An artist becomes immortal when her music continues to open the doors of hearts to make sense of all those emotions that no words can ever fully describe.
All of Robbie's works are awesome, many very spiritual and uplifting. I too have Native blood. I am Abenaki on my mother's side and Mohican on my father's.
Let the Trail of Tears 😢 begin ....(Yes, I know the connotation), listen to this GREAT ALBUMN 1 MORE TIME.... with a brew, and sing 🎶 your heart out, PURGE!!! ✊️
RIP Robbie Robertson. It was this song on a Peter Gabriel rarities collection I had once where I heard Robbie for the first time. It's still good to this day!
"ONe day we will meet again" Time doesn't stand still. I hope Robbie and Richard are having lots of laughter about all their adventures together. While I am still here I want to go visit Richard Manuel's grave site in Stratford. Also John Till's gravesite that is in the same grave yard to pay my respects. He played with Ronnie Hawkins as well ..then went on to play with the Full Tilt Boogie Band and Janis JOplin on her last album. "Are you out there? Can you hear me? Can you lay a flower in the snow? I will visit this winter and see if there is a flower in the snow. Thank you gentleman for all the glorious music!!!!!
@SupernalOne I think there is nothing so beautiful and moving than seeing a man (or other male caregiver) in public, openly, unselfconsciously showing tender, sweet affection and care for his young ones, without a single care for who might see him and his possibly "un-macho" behavior! It's as though no one else in the world exists but his little pride & joy, and his utmost priority is loving, protecting, nurturing and BEING THERE for this child or children. I've seen this increase over time!!!
Peter Gabriel on backing vocals, this whole album filled with guest appearances, from people like Bono and The Edge from U2 to Rick Danko on the song Sonny Got Caught A great album that really never got the attention it deserved
I used to beat the hell out of this CD for years after it came out. Then it dropped off my radar. In the car today a local small town DJ played it and I had uninterrupted time on my drive in the country to take it all in again. I keep trying to think what I'd like played when I pass. I am glad I was reminded today of this song. Don't worry, I have no plans of checking out for a long time to come. Miigwetch.
Stay strong all you native people never give up on your friends and loved ones I don't understand either why you are and were made to suffer so I think some of us come here to show others how low humans can go and hopefully lift them back up away from evil sending you all love and may you be able to find peace and forgiveness
Uno dei brani più belli e sontuosi di Music pop rock che abbia sentito in cinquanta anni che seguo ed ascolto musica , impreziosito dalla più significativa e toccante voce della musica cioè il Sommo Peter Gabriel . Questo è il brano di apertura del primo disco di Robertson , un lavoro straordinario e fascino per sonorità ed arrangiamenti.
Robbies music is soundtrack to falling in love with my husband. What a magical blessing. Each time we listen to his music we are taken back to such intense depths of love and wonder. Thank you Robbie. We love you
i never saw this video until now! i bought this cd because of Peter Gabriel and I ended up enjoying the entire album, what a beautiful song, i used to listen to it alot.
A hauntingly beautiful masterpiece. Here are the LYRICS. Are you out there Can you hear me Can you see me in the dark I don't believe it's all for nothing It's not just written in the sand Sometimes I thought you felt too much And you crossed into the shadowland And the river was overflowing And the sky was fiery red You gotta play the hand that's dealt ya That's what the old man always said Fallen angel Casts a shadow up against the sun If my eyes could see The spirit of the chosen one In my dream the pipes were playing In my dream I lost a friend Come down Gabriel and blow your horn Cause some day we will meet again Fallen angel Casts a shadow up against the sun If my eyes could see The spirit of the chosen one All the tears All the rage All the blues in the night If my eyes could see You kneeling in the silver light Fallin', fallin', fallin' down Fallin', fallin' down Fallin', fallin', fallin' down Fallin', fallin' down Fallin', fallin', fallin' down Fallin', fallin' down Fallen angel Casts a shadow up against the sun If my eyes could see The spirit of the chosen one All the tears All the rage All the blues in the night If my eyes could see You kneeling in the silver light If you're out there can you touch me Can you see me I don't know If you're out there can you reach me Lay a flower in the snow Fallin' down, fallin' down Fallin' down, fallin' down Fallin' down, fallin' down
He's my 2nd cousin :) My grandmothers half sisters son. I just found out, our family is from The Six Nations reservation ( Ohsweken is a village on the Six Nations of the Grand River First Nation Indian reserve near ... Ohsweken, Ontario, Canada) :)
Im from Alberta, Canada stand up!!!!!!!!!!!!! Im not native though. Can you tell me what Tribe you and him are from ? In Alberta its mostly Plains Cree. You got artistic blood in you, Don't waste it
Mohawk. I also have Mississauga( My Grandmother) & Oneida... ~ (My Grandfathers mother, was Mohawk & Oneida). Just on my Mothers side however.(her parents) .... From my fathers side Im Polish, Russian and Mongolian. So I guess that makes me a Pohawk :/ LoL
im skimming through robbies memoir called testimony now, he met his wife dominique in france where she was a journalist covering the french music scene and robbie said french speaking girls from montreal didnt like english speaking people from toronto that much but robbie won her over.
Chey B that's awesome!
Well...yeah and a surprise lol I had no idea until my aunt told me.
“Death is not the greatest loss in life. The greatest loss is what dies inside us while we live.”
Very profound. Reading Robbie's book Testimony I would say he had more than a full life. Having lived to 80 I suppose is a long life, however as I'm approching that age my self, not so sure. His life was not always easy, especially some of his childhood and teenage years. His stepfather got more and more abusive to Robbie and his mother, gave Robbie a black eye, hit him so hard once he fell against a wall and got a nasty bruise on his face. Also hit Robbie's dog, which Robbie never forgave him for. After his mother divorced Robbie's stepfather things got better, she encouraged Robbie in his dreams to become a musician. When he hooked up with Ronnie Hawkins, Ronnie, Levon and others would often stay at Robbie's house, his mother charged reasonable rate and apparently she was quite a cook.
@@hannejeppesen1809 I'm reading it now. I have to take frequent breaks to look up a song he names, or a movie, or a time in their history, or just to sit in front of my great sound system and listen to some of their music full blast. A band like no other.
RIP Robbie...You will be missed by this world....Such brilliant creativity.
I just read he passed. May he rest in peace and join tge WARRIORS who are protecting us from EVIL
Yes he will be ❤️😭
lay a flower in the snow for robbie
I sure will
I didn’t know he died RIP Robbie.
His self titled album was the very first CD I ever bought, back when CD's were a thing. I played it endlesslly and I'm here right now watching this video to pay respects and because his music echoes in my heart. Rest In Power Robbie Robertson. Your music is poetry that will forever travel throughout the universe.
Lay a flower in the snow...
That album was something else, eh?
@@mbrew3244 Yes it was. Robbie's an artist's artist...he had the Bodeans, Peter Gabriel, Bono all on it. And his voice is so unique and strange sounding, yet it works perfectly for his music. Some Where Down The Crazy River really does feel like you're in a dream. Very sad Robbie is no longer with us anymore.
❤
I feel old. I bought it on vinyl.
@@karforeman1556 Don't fret...it's CDs that are considered old. Vinyl is the hot commodity nowadays! 👍
So humbled, reading these comments. These songs.....this...Somewhere Down the Crazy River, they came around at a time when i was making my way towards them.
That is to say, my journey through music. I was 22. Heavy into 1960s British invasion and such. Through that, i made it into Dylan, then The Band, etc etc...
But during these younger days i remember Robbies name circulating. My older cousins talking about him and his indian heritage.
Years later, By the time I was immersed into The Band, they became my timeless Up North, back roading listen while driving music. I was back in 1968, amongst pines that surely looked as they did then and simultaneously the Band was with Me in 2003, 4, 5,....
Their music was like that for me. Immediate. I was never sure if i was back then or they were playing next to me. Like the image of them in upper New York next to the old car. My northern Michigan was like that. Still is. But they all felt like musical friends of mine.
So, as these icons of ours from a musical renaissance one by one, say goodbye, i feel a piece of me does as well. Reality of our mortality? As long as they remain we feel safe? Comforted. When they go, it feels like floodgates of emotion for the shamen of our youth. Our elders. Their wisdom.
All the while, they were simply living and doing, playing and making music.....but it resonates to our cores.
Thank you for the music Robbie.
Reading everyones words here shows Me what one person, along with a group of like minded individuals can leave behind.
Many deeply touched souls with wonderful memories.
1987 seems like yesterday.
By the time i fully immersed in The Band, Robbie was 60. Time waits for no one.
Our memories and the music will take us the rest of the way.
R.I.P. Robbie.
One of the 80's most overlooked gems. The great Peter Gabriel singing harmony always gives me chills and cant say enough about Manu Katche's incredible drumming.
Agreed Shane Anthony!!!!
Second that!
third that
I concur
I have no idea why this was never played on the radio...
The wonderful Peter Gabriel singing harmony elevates this song from great to magical!
Peter does sound a bit like Richard Manuel; both of them were influenced by Ray Charles.
This whole album is just fantastic!
I implore you all to sit down in front of a decent music system, open a bottle of beverage of choice, and just enjoy...
RIP, Robbie... You gave me incredible moments... Thank you!
So true. On a good system, it just coats you with goodness.
those moments will persist until ..................
@@brucewayne3602 Hold on there, mate!
In 2005, my baby sister lost her battle with cancer at the age of 45. She was a big Robbie Robertson fan. I think of her every time I hear this song.
This song is an elegy to Richard Manuel, who along with Robbie Robertson, was one of the original members of The Band. Manuel, who was the Band's pianist and sometimes vocalist, was found hanging in the bathroom of a motel room in Winter Park, Florida on March 4, 1986. The group had re-formed (without Robertson) and played in Winter Park, Florida the preceding night. Manuel had serious problems with addiction for most of his life, but got sober when The Band started touring again in the '80s. He began abusing drugs and alcohol again in 1985, which likely contributed to his death.
Eric Clapton's "Holy Mother" on his 1986 album August is also a tribute to Richard Manuel as is "Too Soon Gone," The Band's tribute to Richard from their 1993 album Jericho.
"Fallen Angel" was the first single Robertson released as a solo artist. He wrote the song with Martin Page, who had co-written the hits "These Dreams" and "We Built This City." In our interview with Page, he explained: "Robbie was playing with lyrical ideas for a huge period of time and every time I would go back to the Village (the recording studio in Los Angeles) to work with him, it was quite frustrating, because I thought we were doing very well and he'd say, 'I've changed the words.' He would sing it and ask me, 'What do you think?' And I'd say, 'Well, I think it's all good, Rob. Really good.' Everything he did I thought was fine.
But then one special day he called me and he said, 'I really have what this song's about.' At first it was going to be called 'War of Angels,' and it was going to be the idea of fallen angels actually falling out of heaven and touching hell. He was really getting into this kind of biblical place. But all of a sudden, very emotionally he said to me, 'It's about Richard.' And I could see in his face that he'd nailed it. It was his special song to Richard Manuel. I think it was a great testament to his undying friendship for his friend who left a little too early."
This song features Peter Gabriel on keyboards. Gabriel also provides vocals on the chorus accompanying Robbie Robertson.
The Robbie Robertson album won the Juno Award for Album of the Year in 1989.
thank you for your input. Robbie will always be an awesome song writer no question. I just feel that whatever was in his heart when he wrote this those feelings were expressed years to late. it would have been so much more meaningful if it had been when Richard was alive.
:)
If Richard had been alive, there would have been no reason to write a song about his suicide.
The whole story, he could not go to his Funeral...to upset. This worsened the feud between Levon and Rob.
Steve Morse great story! What a treat it must have been to work with him. He is someone I have always wanted to meet.
My mother passed away the year this album was released. This song in particular, stood out for me when thinking of my mother's long battle with cancer and untimely death at a pivotal time in my life. I included a few lines from the song in a tribute to her in my high school year book as she died the summer leading into my senior year.
Robbie is not only a talented musician, lyricist, and artist, but also a great ambassador for Native Americans and Indigenous people in North America. Although he is in his 70's now and put on a few pounds since this video, he still sounds and looks great. He may not have the greatest vocal range, but knows how to deliver a melody in a distinct way and feel that he is able to connect with the listener and relay a story with emotional depth.
Manual is still much missed. Such an elegiac tribute And now Robertson, who loved him so. Ahhhhh
A moving tribute that Robbie wrote for bandmate Richard Manuel. Robbie has never been thought of as a lead singer. But on this song, Robbie captured the essence of Richard's singing and his soul. May you RIP with Richard, Rick and Levon.
And Garth!
@@Skinnyorangemusic ♬ We do have Garth with us..! 🎹
@@santamara 😂😂✌️😎
@@Skinnyorangemusic Thanks be to.. 'G' 🙏 ♬ 🎹
He actually sang lead on a few songs. I wish he'd done more when he was with The Band, because he has a fine voice, close to Richard's as you can hear on "The Last Waltz Reprise." His vocal on "Out of the Blue," is very good, too, probably his best vocal with The Band.
*A great move by Robbie to bring in the incredible Daniel Lanois into the studio, let's not forget Lanois touch too.*
Definitely Daniel is wonderful has produced several albums he's great! Robbie is one top fave musician! saw him in 60's backing up Bob Dylan in gig in Syracuse with The Band!... was fantastic ❤😊
I just saw an interview with Danny, didn't know he produced this plus "So" of Gabriel. Incredible. In fact there's Peter on this song 🎵 so cool 😎 🎉
His records with Emmy Lou Harris are gorgeous!
Robbie Robertson is one of those rare musicians who brings you joy. To hear his work is to understand music. Robertson had a deeply personal relationship to his art, and he used it to connect to the world.
I’m feeling his loss tonight.
RIP Robbie Robertson
Robbie Robertson's 1987 self titled album is a spiritually uplifting and powerful celebration of music and life and these two legends Robbie and Peter Gabriel deliver one of the most haunting vocal performances
That is a beautiful comment, George. Thank you.
@@johnthorne4093 you're very welcome
Still one of my favourite LPs....I have both vinyl and CD
don't even need the video to see this song.....amazing song!
RIP Robbie. Thanks for all the incredible music.
Are you out there?
Can you hear me?
Can you see me in the dark?
I don't believe it's all for nothing
It's not just written in the sand
Sometimes I thought you felt too much
And you crossed into the shadow land
And the river was overflown
And the sky was fiery red
You gotta play the hand that's dealt ya
That's what the old man always said
Fallen angel
Casts a shadow up against the sun
If my eyes could see
The spirit of the chosen one
In my dream the pipes were playing
In my dream I lost a friend
Come down, Gabriel, and blow your horn
'Cause some day we will meet again
Fallen angel
Casts a shadow up against the sun
If my eyes could see
The spirit of the chosen one
All the tears, all the rage
All the blues in the night
If my eyes could see
You kneeling in the silver light
Fallin', fallin', fallin' down
Fallin', fallin' down
Fallin', fallin', fallin' down
Fallin', fallin' down
Fallin', fallin', fallin' down
Fallin', fallin' down
Fallen angel
Casts a shadow up against the sun
If my eyes could see
The spirit of the chosen one
All the tears, all the rage
All the blues in the night
If my eyes could see
You kneeling in the silver light
If you're out there, can you touch me?
Can you see me? I don't know
If you're out there, can you reach me?
And lay a flower in the snow
Fallin' down, fallin' down
Fallin' down, fallin' down
Fallin' down, fallin' down
Fallin' down, fallin' down
Fallin' down, fallin' down
🌹
my favorite..lay a flower in the snow
Rest in peace dear Robbie!! One of the Greatest gifts we were ever given 💔
God has called you home. Thank you for a lifetime of beautiful work.
When my best friend, Tim, committed suicide, I went to this song to help me process that loss. We had enjoyed it together often and in his absence now, I come to this song to recall him in all his golden glory. RIP, my friend.
I've never had a friend do that so it's difficult to comprehend. The loss felt must be as deep as a tragic accident or a sudden death.
Wow so sorry about your loss! Yes this song is healing *
sorry for your loss
I had a friend named Tim who also committed suicide. Same person? IDK, but the sadness hit his old friends hard. I'm sorry about your friend, Tim.
@@kathymisuraca5047 Nutile? Tim Nutile.
There is a magic synergy between Robertson and Gabriel's voices which is just the audible signal of their deep and sincere commitments to genuine causes..this song is a masterpiece in terms of true emotions!
Peter Gabriel sounded sort of like Richard Manuel on this!
A legend in the Music world passed away yesterday. A big hole is left in many a heart.
Had this song in my head since I heard the news today.
RIP brother 😢
What a beautiful album, man, and talent. A Canadian legend.
Vale dear Robbie Robertson, such profound gifts he brought to us all. Frankly, it could hardly be closer to touching the source, thankyou Robbie.
RIP Robbie, thank you for sharing your story.
Thank you Robbie and everyone who participated in this album...wonderful atmosphere, this energy goes straight to the soul, timeless music and production. Beautiful video. Rest in Peace Robbie!
I wish Australia had heard more of his late 80s, early 90s songs on radio/media. We were unaware of these masterpieces... They are so good.
He was a genius ❤
As a Canadian Robbie was something special. His sensibility never left his music. The heart and love of his music was to me, educational. I came to this piece way back when it came out because it was essentially Peter Gabriels band and I have been a life long follower of PG. What I found though was not just great music from Robbie but the very first message to me, that as a Canadian, made me begin to question our long standing horrible treatment of Indiginous Canadians. His third album Music for the Native American was an emotional eye opener for me and for many others I think.
Perhaps it is a bold thing to say, but for me personally, a European, Robbie Robertson was the beginning of understanding what reconciliation really means. You just have to truly listen
Robbie Robertson, Fallen Angel. 1943-2023, Thank you Profesor. RIP
A song or piece of art can mean many things to many people. The thing that stands out to me listening to this songs and reading the comments. Don’t let things go unsaid or live with anger and resentment in your heart. If we forgive and live without fear we are truly living in the moment and creating heaven on earth
Beautiful song and music video
This song has haunted me since I first heard it in 1987. It's like a cathedral.
Thank you. 1987 for me, too. But, both my children have told me that this song is a touchstone for them, since they heard on the CD in the car(s) approximately 1000 times. Hoping this song, and all Robbie's amazing work, will endure through this and other means. God bless Robbie.
cathedral...good call
This song was written for Richard Manuel
Ethereal, gospel like........sings to my soul
Robbie Robertson R. I. P.
MUSIC POET. Great suff
🎸🎶🎷🌞😎
@lonewolf81252 I have been absolutely fascinated by Native Americans since I was a young child. My father did his "preceptorship" (training after medical school) on a Cherokee reservation when I was just a baby. And I KNOW in my heart that I have spent at least one previous lifetime as a Native American. I hate to see anyone denied their civil rights and experiencing abuse because of their race!! We came over here and stole their country. Sometimes I'm not terribly "proud to be an America".
If you,re out there...beware i think of you fallen angel Robbie😢
Everything about this song makes it one of the best songs ever made.
Rest easy Robbie!! My dad loves you
When I got the call that my cousin unexpectedly passed away I played this for days on repeat. Cheers to you, Jed. And cheers to Mr. Manuel. May you both be happy wherever you may be.
Robbie does a lot of sad songs~~~~He sings of our ancestors and us now..Sometimes it's not what we want to hear, but listen to all his stuff..he so wants us "to live again!" We live through our ancestors as our ancestors live through us! Listen people!
+darling darlene snyder Very True _ring them bells_
+darling darlene snyder One day , we will be great again. Maybe not in this world. Maybe not here... I feel my ancestors run through my blood. This song makes me cry , really. And no one would have song it better with Robbie than Peter Gabriel
Actually, this song is about Richard Manuel, a member of the band who hanged himself in 1986
Lay a flower in the snow!
you got to play the hand that's dealt ya!
RIP Robbie. I was 17 back in 87 and my dad died of cancer . I had so many questions about his death and when I heard this song it brought me peace . I think I played it a hundred times that year . Your albums were brilliant Robbie - Rest in peace .
The addition of Peter Gabriel on this track compliments the depth of this song to no end. When he starts the harmony One can feel how much from the heart he and Robbie really do sing.
Gabriel was writing So at the time if I'm not mistaken. The 80s had an explosion of great music. Some crap, but all in all pretty good.
I agree...I'm hearing it for the first time today..beautiful song and duet
What an incredibly poignant song. Such a touching tribute from Robbie to embattled bandmate Richard Manuel.
Great harmony vocals from Peter Gabriel, a year after his absolute classic record So. Peter, Robbie, Daniel Lanois and their players struck gold on Robbie’s eponymous solo debut
Today this song means even more: 'cause the man himself just died.
Heartfelt beautiful song for Richard. Kudos to Robbie and Peter and band
RIP Robbie Robertson! You will be missed.
Another of the great ones leaves us.
Bought this album when it was new and played it till I could see through the vinyl. Still puts me in a very emotional mood. All songs about a lost friend can have that affect. This was a great piece of work.
IS
i wanna be friends with you ❤️
@@magics.johnson well, ok
Love this song. It speaks to a primal human need for love and salvation. Listening to it helps me find balance and hope. Lay a flower in the snow.
RIP Robbie Robertson. One of my favorite guitarists of all time.
"If you're out there, can you touch me? Can you see me? I don't know. If you're out there, can you reach me? and lay a flower in the snow."
Gevowavemagnet
♥️
RIP Robbie. I loved his music growing up. Lots of sweet memories.
I also love the fact Peter Gabriel is playing keyboard and is heard accompanying Robbie in the chorus. Such a beautiful song !
I played this song at my Mum's funeral , it was perfect. It was only days out back then. It said what I felt. When I hear it , I can feel her standing there beside me. I miss her badly. THANKYOU , Robbie. (Fallen Angel).
perfect song
RIP brother. This song spoke volumes to me throughout the entirety of my life and it’s one of the first I can actually remember hearing. This whole album has forever been a favorite of mine. Broken arrow lives rent free in my mind until the day I get to meet you on the other side. Later in life I discovered you were a part of so much more music I had already come to love. You are one of the most inspiring musicians in my life and a big reason of why I began to love music in the first place. I’m sad to lose another person I looked up to, but I’m grateful for the impact you left on me.
A magnificent man and artist. We are blessed to have shared this time with him. Thank you💖🙏
One of the greatest... What more can be said? You will be missed Mr. Robertson. Your music lives on in my soul.
ROBBIE SPEAKS TO YOUR VERY SOUL!
Beautiful sing, and Robbie and Peter Gabriel s viices meshed so well together. Just as beautiful the video, very pognant and thought provoking as are all of Robbie's videos. Thanks fir your guft if music Robbie !
He certainly identify with his native American heritage. Beautiful wonderful song
You are now a fallen angel, Robbie. May your memory be eternal.
Aug 9 2023. Meeting with all your friends today. Thank you for all the great words and music. You will be greatly missed.
RIP my Brother, you are the best friend I never knew.
Your music will live on forever.
An artist becomes immortal when her music continues to open the doors of hearts to make sense of all those emotions that no words can ever fully describe.
R.I.P. Robbie.This song touched my heart,as did many more he wrote.
Rest in peace, Robbie. Thank you for the years of wonderful music.
Peter Gabriel harmonies take this song to a whole other level… listen to it with your eyes closed… ☺️
All of Robbie's works are awesome, many very spiritual and uplifting. I too have Native blood. I am Abenaki on my mother's side and Mohican on my father's.
"Casts a shadow up against the sun"... only Robbie could sing that, truly moving and haunting together. Gives me shivers up and down my back.
omg robbie
Let the Trail of Tears 😢 begin ....(Yes, I know the connotation), listen to this GREAT ALBUMN 1 MORE TIME.... with a brew, and sing 🎶 your heart out, PURGE!!! ✊️
Rest in peace. Thank you for your music. This song helped shape my spirit after I lost my father a long time ago. It's still one of my favorites.
This song always makes me cry. I love it!! ❤️
Hello Nora❤️
Thanks for been a great a fan listen to my music .
💗💗💗
I am so, so missing Richard. This song makes me sad.
RIP RICHARD MANUEL FALLEN DOWN AND ROBBIE
I get a lump in my throat every time I hear this song...And Gabriel's little purrs jus to add that bit of magic. !
RIP Robbie Robertson. It was this song on a Peter Gabriel rarities collection I had once where I heard Robbie for the first time. It's still good to this day!
R.I.P. Robbie...
You are and will remain one of my most important musicians...
So many good songs!!!
"ONe day we will meet again" Time doesn't stand still. I hope Robbie and Richard are having lots of laughter about all their adventures together. While I am still here I want to go visit Richard Manuel's grave site in Stratford. Also John Till's gravesite that is in the same grave yard to pay my respects. He played with Ronnie Hawkins as well ..then went on to play with the Full Tilt Boogie Band and Janis JOplin on her last album. "Are you out there? Can you hear me? Can you lay a flower in the snow? I will visit this winter and see if there is a flower in the snow. Thank you gentleman for all the glorious music!!!!!
A hauntingly beautiful and powerful masterpiece.
This period of writing has a non-ordinary reality feel- like a dream scape...
it hit my spirit so hard ..
@SupernalOne I think there is nothing so beautiful and moving than seeing a man (or other male caregiver) in public, openly, unselfconsciously showing tender, sweet affection and care for his young ones, without a single care for who might see him and his possibly "un-macho" behavior! It's as though no one else in the world exists but his little pride & joy, and his utmost priority is loving, protecting, nurturing and BEING THERE for this child or children. I've seen this increase over time!!!
I'll miss him and his gifts. 😢
HAPPY Birthday Robbie...STO LAT 05-07-2014 !
Just love this song. Love the album. RIP Robbie and condolences to your loved ones. Best wishes from Aotearoa New Zealand.
RIP Robbie. I had so many joyfull moments listening to you. Thank You.
It's a big loss. Dude was absolutely fantastic
How gorgeous is this song? The harmonies between Robbie and Gabriel make me shiver
Rest in Peace Robbie Robertson thank you for your wonderful music.
Truly genius. The whole album is fantastic.
Peter Gabriel on backing vocals, this whole album filled with guest appearances, from people like Bono and The Edge from U2 to Rick Danko on the song Sonny Got Caught
A great album that really never got the attention it deserved
R.I.P Robbie Robertson. A moving song from a marvelous album.
I used to beat the hell out of this CD for years after it came out. Then it dropped off my radar. In the car today a local small town DJ played it and I had uninterrupted time on my drive in the country to take it all in again.
I keep trying to think what I'd like played when I pass. I am glad I was reminded today of this song.
Don't worry, I have no plans of checking out for a long time to come. Miigwetch.
Stay strong all you native people never give up on your friends and loved ones I don't understand either why you are and were made to suffer so I think some of us come here to show others how low humans can go and hopefully lift them back up away from evil sending you all love and may you be able to find peace and forgiveness
Uno dei brani più belli e sontuosi di Music pop rock che abbia sentito in cinquanta anni che seguo ed ascolto musica , impreziosito dalla più significativa e toccante voce della musica cioè il Sommo Peter Gabriel . Questo è il brano di apertura del primo disco di Robertson , un lavoro straordinario e fascino per sonorità ed arrangiamenti.
Robbies music is soundtrack to falling in love with my husband. What a magical blessing. Each time we listen to his music we are taken back to such intense depths of love and wonder. Thank you Robbie. We love you
Gay
Another genius gone , Robbie and Llanois together, pure solid Gold, God take care of you my friend ❤
Haunting, touching, beautiful, a highly precious music gem. Rip, you will be missed so so much
I love this song and album, Peter Gabriel is singing in the background.
Robbie has a rare depth.
i never saw this video until now! i bought this cd because of Peter Gabriel and I ended up enjoying the entire album, what a beautiful song, i used to listen to it alot.
RIP Beautiful man Robbie 🙏✨💯👍💯✨💯❤️💋
What a beauty of a song
Big Robbie
A hauntingly beautiful masterpiece. Here are the LYRICS.
Are you out there
Can you hear me
Can you see me in the dark
I don't believe it's all for nothing
It's not just written in the sand
Sometimes I thought you felt too much
And you crossed into the shadowland
And the river was overflowing
And the sky was fiery red
You gotta play the hand that's dealt ya
That's what the old man always said
Fallen angel
Casts a shadow up against the sun
If my eyes could see
The spirit of the chosen one
In my dream the pipes were playing
In my dream I lost a friend
Come down Gabriel and blow your horn
Cause some day we will meet again
Fallen angel
Casts a shadow up against the sun
If my eyes could see
The spirit of the chosen one
All the tears
All the rage
All the blues in the night
If my eyes could see
You kneeling in the silver light
Fallin', fallin', fallin' down
Fallin', fallin' down
Fallin', fallin', fallin' down
Fallin', fallin' down
Fallin', fallin', fallin' down
Fallin', fallin' down
Fallen angel
Casts a shadow up against the sun
If my eyes could see
The spirit of the chosen one
All the tears
All the rage
All the blues in the night
If my eyes could see
You kneeling in the silver light
If you're out there can you touch me
Can you see me I don't know
If you're out there can you reach me
Lay a flower in the snow
Fallin' down, fallin' down
Fallin' down, fallin' down
Fallin' down, fallin' down
Thank you… 🥀
Proud to call him one of our own; Canadian.
Indeed, overlooked. Loved it since its release. May have just discovered video for 1st time. Thank you Robbie - r.i.p.