Possibly not a good enough performance for a dvd or audio recording or possibly not the right vibe/theme to go with the other songs on the HAARP audio cd. Most likely reason is because it’s already on the Hullabaloo audio and dvd
I love what Matt does during my favorite part of this song, and he does it every time they play it. I cannot wait to see this on DVD in a couple weeks!!!
I can hardly remember this - it's a total blur of amazingness. I can remember, though, singing the "Hullabaloo riff" with some people next to me on the massive end! Amazing amazing amazing!
Just going by what Matt wears at different parts of the DVD, it looks like the first half of the DVD is from the 16th and the second half is from the 17th, so some of the songs played in the second half of the 16th didn't appear on the DVD and vise-versa.
For those who wonder why this wasnt on the DVD, this is the 16th's footage, the DVD is the 17th (apart from MOTP's Maggie's Farm Riff, which is the 16th due to technical faults)
He may have messed up at 1:41 but that is a part of playing live. Live is more human. Anyway its 1 second from 7 minutes of pure rock. Release the song! I guess the song not being available makes it all that more special that I saw them on the 16th. :) Best day! xxxxxxx
great post, love this song, such passion, wish i had been there, saw them at reading a v festival a few years back, amazing live band, they f**king rule
Thanks for the upload....Why they didnt include this on the DVD or CD I don't know...I was in the pit on my own and lost the plot when this kicked in....sorry to anyone who was next to me! I recall someone calling me a "mentalist Cunt" Good times.....
I agree. Citizen Erased is probably my favorite song of theirs. :( Even if they didn't put it on the DVD they could have at least put it on the audio CD.
Yeah, I agree, it is sad, but remember, Hullabaloo was in 2001, 6 years before this concert. It makes sense that as he is getting older, it will be harder for him to hit the high notes. But like as others have said, he's already done a lot of singing, and his voice would be really tired. F**king brilliant version though. I just love this song, one of my favourites of all time, next too the likes of Microcuts, New Born, Plug in Baby... hell all of Origins.. MUSE FTW! (Hullabaloo is FTW too :P)
Are you kidding me? I feel like crying now because of the fact that those songs weren't on haarp :( I would have loved to see the videos for all the songs they played...
why do i have to live in america and why can i not magically afford plane and concert tickets to see the resistance tour? life is cruel. thank god for youtube :D
i reckon they didnt put it on the cd or dvd because there are a few mistakes in the song, lyrics and bass wise. BUT STILL! WTF! I really wanted this song! This, i can understand not being on the DVD but at least the CD! And, Bliss, Sing for Absolution and Sunburn aren't on the DVD! WHY!
I'm outraged... yesterday i decided to look up the setlist for these two gigs and see which songs were excluded... (i was expecting maybe muscle museum and another older single) then I see Citizen Erased and promptly die a little.
that was no mistake... he did that on purpose. and it wasn't because of that that this wasn't on the dvd... its because this was on the other day that they played
Well then I'm sure you're not the only one to have some miracle copy it's not just your dvd. And basically every dvd is on the internet, so if you would kindly point out this video, or any evidence of this whatsoever, I'll believe you.
This is like the Muse-y-est of all Muse songs, this should have been on the DVD.
God...just realised that you can hear everyone singing on the chorus.....it made me shiver. God, I love this song so so effing much!
Why isn't this on the HAARP CD? This is probably their best song.
Possibly not a good enough performance for a dvd or audio recording or possibly not the right vibe/theme to go with the other songs on the HAARP audio cd.
Most likely reason is because it’s already on the Hullabaloo audio and dvd
yes, i agree. one of the best muse songs
3:37 I've never heard that bit like that before! Amazing! :D
This is the best performance of the best song of thier best album at the best gig of one of the bests bands ever.
And it's not on the dvd...
I love what Matt does during my favorite part of this song, and he does it every time they play it.
I cannot wait to see this on DVD in a couple weeks!!!
F
@@jonathanbustamante5195 😂😂 yikes
fucking amazing vid. good work. my heart exploded five-fold when I heard the "DUN DUN" drum beat... fav song of all time.
I can hardly remember this - it's a total blur of amazingness. I can remember, though, singing the "Hullabaloo riff" with some people next to me on the massive end! Amazing amazing amazing!
wtf, this is like their best song how could they leace it out
Just going by what Matt wears at different parts of the DVD, it looks like the first half of the DVD is from the 16th and the second half is from the 17th, so some of the songs played in the second half of the 16th didn't appear on the DVD and vise-versa.
How the hell did Citizen Erased get cut out of 2 of Muse's 3 live DVD's.
IT'S JUST NOT RIGHT!
This performance was on the first day. The dvd was of the 2nd day which I went to.
The audio only cd is from the first day though
For those who wonder why this wasnt on the DVD, this is the 16th's footage, the DVD is the 17th (apart from MOTP's Maggie's Farm Riff, which is the 16th due to technical faults)
great view.. this gig was the best thing ever!!
He may have messed up at 1:41 but that is a part of playing live. Live is more human. Anyway its 1 second from 7 minutes of pure rock. Release the song! I guess the song not being available makes it all that more special that I saw them on the 16th. :)
Best day!
xxxxxxx
great post, love this song, such passion, wish i had been there, saw them at reading a v festival a few years back, amazing live band, they f**king rule
excellent video. amazing day. love this song so much. shame you didn't catch the piano ending though.
anyway, very grateful for this!
Thanks for the upload....Why they didnt include this on the DVD or CD I don't know...I was in the pit on my own and lost the plot when this kicked in....sorry to anyone who was next to me! I recall someone calling me a "mentalist Cunt" Good times.....
your lucky you got this track, i was there on the sunday, and they didnt treat us with this track!
was an awesome gig!
yeah definitely. i just ordered hullabaloo off ebay :) sooo excited
i thought this wasn't palyed at wembley!, damn it shoudl have been on the dvd and also the cd.
im still hoping one day muse will surprise us randomly with a proshot video of this
The DVD is of the sunday night, this was played the Saturday night, it wasn't played on the sunday
I'd kill to hear the ending right now :p I decided to watch this cuz stupid Muse aren't putting this on the DVD/CD.
omg how the hell could this not be in the dvd or the album
Oh my god.. why wasn't this included?! HAARP is an awesome DVD but I was sooo expecting Citizen to be on it xD. T_T I love this song.
I agree. Citizen Erased is probably my favorite song of theirs. :( Even if they didn't put it on the DVD they could have at least put it on the audio CD.
So you're all asking why it wasn't on the DVD... Simply because the DVD shows footage from the 17th June, and this was on the 16th... :/
i know yeah its my favourite song by them and i was hoping that it would be on the new new cd/dvd, but it isnt :@
OMG, the part from 03:37 to 03:47 was AWESOME! - the whole song is awesome!
Oh baby!
apart from the 3 other videos in the sidebar you mean ;) CE was played, it just wasn't released in proshot.
It kind of makes me sad that he can't hit the high notes as easily as he used to, but they were brilliant all the same.
the dvd with the exception of the maggies farm riff and the odd crowd shot is entirely from the 17th.
Yeah, I agree, it is sad, but remember, Hullabaloo was in 2001, 6 years before this concert. It makes sense that as he is getting older, it will be harder for him to hit the high notes. But like as others have said, he's already done a lot of singing, and his voice would be really tired. F**king brilliant version though. I just love this song, one of my favourites of all time, next too the likes of Microcuts, New Born, Plug in Baby... hell all of Origins..
MUSE FTW!
(Hullabaloo is FTW too :P)
Amazing video, that audio is incredible - what did you use to record this!?!?! Thank you so much for uploading this song!
Faaar to awesome for being on a dvd...
That's the only logic explanation I can find xD
Are you kidding me? I feel like crying now because of the fact that those songs weren't on haarp :(
I would have loved to see the videos for all the songs they played...
totally agree with muserochile!why citizen is not included in the dvd!it's a Shame!!
they've played this both times i've seen them :)
This isn't bad, nice one! :D
Their best song ever!
I nearly creamed when i heard it that night haha!
@peskyseagull oh i thought we were talking about citizen erased . i have the haarp cd and dvd :D
Yes it is, this has like...been released in pro shot. Why would I lie?
why do i have to live in america and why can i not magically afford plane and concert tickets to see the resistance tour? life is cruel.
thank god for youtube :D
The little bit around 3:45 was epic win.
why is one of their best songs not on the dvd?
Hope they'll play it on 16th november in cologne
i reckon they didnt put it on the cd or dvd because there are a few mistakes in the song, lyrics and bass wise. BUT STILL! WTF! I really wanted this song! This, i can understand not being on the DVD but at least the CD! And, Bliss, Sing for Absolution and Sunburn aren't on the DVD! WHY!
yes it is, what DVD have you got!? it is on my copy, anyway..
I'm outraged... yesterday i decided to look up the setlist for these two gigs and see which songs were excluded... (i was expecting maybe muscle museum and another older single) then I see Citizen Erased and promptly die a little.
The only complaint I'll ever register against Muse is the lack of this song on DVDs.
Since the best part is the intro, the best part is NOT cut! :D
This is just plain sad...
They should of put ALL the concert on the DVD... T_T
anyway the dvd does not contain the whole concert..
well the DVD shows footage of both gigs, but not al the songs!!!
if u like this song, join on facebook: Muse need to play Citizen Erased on their stadium tour this year
this song its awesome!!!; but, WHY DONT AGREE IN THE DVD OR CD HAARP??
So on the Saturday night the audience got this and Micro Cuts, and on the Sunday we got.. what.. Bliss? Something else as well?
howcome this wasn't in the dvd?
have you guys considered asking for any of this videos as muse.mu's christmas gift?
Just curious, were you seated in block 126 when you recorded this?
If you can remember, thanks
fucking seriosuly!! jeebarse, was well lookning forward to it.
also, in reference to other posts, isn't citizen erased on the hullabaloo dvd?
@CLOVERFIELD667 I agree!!!
i downloaded it
why did they take this one of the DvD !!! its one of their best songs !
Dvd was on the 2nd day, which they didn’t play this song unfortunately. This performance was from the 1st day
shouldve been on the dvd
@peskyseagull it was not on the cd
WHY WAS THIS NOT ON THE FUCKING ON THE DVD. YES I AM FLIPPING MY FUCKING SHIT AT THE FAN!
Im actually quite pissed that they havent put it on....Its many hardcore Musers' fav song :/
:O this not in the haarp album :(
Y wasnt it on the DVD?!!! :'(
3:37 to 3:47 its awesome :D
it was on haarp
that was no mistake... he did that on purpose. and it wasn't because of that that this wasn't on the dvd... its because this was on the other day that they played
i will
emm, i can't hear anything wrong at 1.41.. what's the problem there?
esta rola no viene en el dvd del HAARP verdad??? =S
big day out? or do you mean wembley specifically?
and the same with Bliss and Micro Cuts.. So sad :,(
Well then I'm sure you're not the only one to have some miracle copy it's not just your dvd. And basically every dvd is on the internet, so if you would kindly point out this video, or any evidence of this whatsoever, I'll believe you.
where the hell is the piano part?
Oh wait nevermind. This isn't going to be on there. :/
Why the fuck did you cut off the rest of the song? You better have a damn good reason for cutting off the best part of Muse's best song.
me pregunto por que no se incluyó esta canción en el DVD de HAARP ni en el disco ¬¬.. en fin...
WHAT THE FUCK IT ISNT ON THE DVD! FUCK
1:07 girl has eargasm
i'm afraid its not on it mate
no one else filmed it cause they were fucking moshing it out
I don't thinks it's whiny so much as he tries to hit the note and can't hold it for too long. It's like he hits it, but it gets cut off too soon.
No it's not, this has like...never even been released in pro shot. Why lie?
@pimgooss yeah, cause he did it just to piss you off
is this the only song that isn't at HAARP's??
@peskyseagull woooow with the 21 on the dvd that makes 29 songs. NIIIICEEEE.
Portugal 7 - 0 North Korea :DDD
The 7 strings guitar is a manson...
1:05 : lol
@peskyseagull that's unfair
Why was this not on HAARP?!?!?!?!?
microcuts too
It wasnt so much out of key, more like a dive, an intended dip of the notes, it just didnt fit the song this time :P
no no biene u.u... pero si esta bien loka zeeee.. lastima