This is COMPLETELY different from what bobby did with buck and what bobby did with eddie. Bobby kept buck from the job because of his own personal issues and shouldn't have lied to him about why he couldn't go back to work when he got the go ahead from everyone that he was good to go back. I dont agree with the lawsuit but I under why he did it. Especially with all the hypocrisy with everyone else. Eddie had some obvious/serious mental health issues he needed to work out and bobby was right to not allow him back yet. So much is going through his head that he's not thinking clearly and bobby doesn't want eddie getting hurt on the job because he's not taking care of himself.
This Eddie's PTSD/Depression will be so interesting, I hope writers explore it properly and not in only one or two episodes. It's a very dangerous illness.
The "Go to hell Bobby" line hits harder once you think about how this is the exact place Bobby believes he is headed to after that fire. Anyway my general view over this is that in no way Bobby was wrong for suggesting Eddie to look help first before come back to work, specially after witnessing such unstable behavior, but I'm also not mad at Eddie for lashing out, because even tho he was quite low with that comment, like really low, this basically just prove Bobby's point about him not being well, and we know Eddie would never dare to say such a fucked up thing it if he was in a right state of mind. It was visible Eddie was not okay, he did put a happy face mask when going to ask for his job back, but Bobby saw through it, as well seeing it Eddie wasn't well and logically, he did hold the transference to his team temporarily so Eddie could prioritize his mental health instead, because admitting him back to work in that state could potentially be dangerous for the team and Eddie himself, who would most likely brush all the issues he has under the carpet again. Anyway really sad scene, but it's really well done, Peter and Ryan did great here.
Frankly if I was Bobby, even if I didn't know Eddie had a shitload of trauma, the fact that he made such a big decision to quit firefighting for his kid's sake and now wants to come back just 3 months later would give me pause. Feels like he's all over the place. I do think Bobby should've avoided saying that last thing, "hope they don't ask me for a recommendation", that bit of snark seemed to be the last straw that caused Eddie to lash out. Not that I'm excusing what Eddie said in any way, it was pretty nasty.
@@Slingblade87 Fr tho I think in some part it looked like a kid discussing with their dad (no jokes XD) The "I can always go to another house" comment when denied to get back on the job was such spoiled kid line I even thought it was kinda funny actually asdhfhgh Bobby fueling it with the recommendation comment didn't help, but the moment Eddie said what he said, it was way out of line.
@@ArlertAMVs they both hurting each other and it's childish 😒 so it's the writers way of completing writing Eddie off back in the day when the show goes to Direction we will see the character in s20 for emotional return but these times shows dropping like Flys and even the good ones so yeah we never see Eddie again.
Eddie just about added several truck loads of crap to his state of sanity and health. What he did will not easily go away. It will keep sawing into his emotional well being. The scene is very nicely done and played. Tough, yet carefully thought. KUDOS!!! to Peter Krause and Ryan Guzmán.
Bobby is the Captain and he knows what’s best for his team, every decision he makes comes from a good place because he cares about the people who work for him, he has to answer to those above him, but ultimately his team are bound by his rules.
"You shouldn't have to lose everything, before you allow yourself to feel something" -Season 3 Bobby to Eddie after he found out about the street fighting, feels appropriate here too
Feeling very similar vibes with this Bobbie and Eddie drama that i did with Bobby and Buck, except that Buck literally had doctor's approval to go back to work sooo.... come on Eds, go get approved AND THEN Bobby can tell you no
I was not expecting that to be honest, but Eddie did say he wanted to leave. Then again I haven’t watched the show since the hiatus and I can’t exactly remember.
Eddie is reacting like most folks do when told that they need help, he gets angry and defensive and doesn't stop for a second to think there may be something to it. And in Eddie's case in particular, it definitely seems to me like his father instilled some toxic masculinity BS in him that causes him to repress everything, because he feels like seeking help would make him weak and not a proper "macho man". It looks like he's headed for a true crash and burn in the coming episodes (we saw the clip of him sobbing). Going to be rough. And I do hope he takes back what he said to Bobby at the end here, that was a hell of a low blow.
Why’s everyone saying Bobby deserved that? Are you forgetting that Bobby was ready to commit suicide once he reached his goal. He wasn’t in the right state of mind and he ACTUALLY took the time he needed off. Bobby is literally looking out for Eddie, you can literally see that he wasn’t ready. I honestly think it’s a good call, because you can’t keep changing your mind about what role you would like when your job involves other people safety. You need to be in the right mental state which Eddie clearly isn’t in. That was a low blow, and it wasn’t like Bobby started the fire on purpose
No Bobby deserved it. He was being a coward by keeping buck awaying knowing he was cleared by the doctors and brass. He is doing the exact same thing with Eddie.
@@rukiakuchiki5154 YOU CAN PHYSICALLY SEE EDDIE IS NOT OKAY. Buck literally was coughing blood and had issue with the screws in his leg. BOBBY WAS RIGHT, but men are so damn stubborn
@@cyntanaa Bobby is trying to stop him from firefighting in general. Eddie said he would go some where else but Bobby said he won't let that happen. Bobby CAN'T stop him from firefighting all together. As for Buck sitting at a desk would not be good for a blood clot.
@@rukiakuchiki5154 this is how I know you don’t watch, buck was not sitting at a desk he was out in the field overseeing. He got fed up and sued the department, he won the case then at the party he was coughing out blood. So furthermore proving bobbys point. Of course bobby would not give Eddie a recommendation, what captain would want to put other in danger. Especially when he can see that Eddie is not coping at all. You can literally see he is tired and not in a good place. The only reason why Eddie wants to come back is because he thinks working will help. But it won’t, he needs therapy or a break out of LA
I like that they did this again, it shows that it can happen a lot more then people realize and it shows how quickly someone in pain can turn on you for trying to help. Bobby faced this twice now, Buck first, then Eddie, both had bad reactions and Bobby was at the brunt of it both times yet still holds them in his heart because he knows they don't truly mean it. I love this type of awareness, and I love seeing a positive and caring boss where you always hear about horrible bosses irl, Bobby sees them all as family and wont let them go into danger knowing that they could break under the pressure. Bobby is an amazing character.
Eddie owes Bobby a huge apology later on for that low blow. I know he’s upset right now and he’ll eventually see that Bobby was right not to let him come back but when he does he better apologize.
I feel 100% positive he will and will regret it for a very long time. Eddie tends to punish himself for things that aren’t even true, like that he let Christopher down
Well, he kinda did, but more as a "you had my back back then, now I'm gonna have yours" rather than a "I'm sorry I called you a murderer unfit to save people"
they said he apologized before that, it was just off screen, like half of the important conversations have been in current seasons. so glad kristen reidel has been demoted because she doesn't know what people need and want to see (like chimney apologizing for punching buck off screen as well)@@nguyenkhanhhailinh1721
Wow, that was a low blow for Eddie. Bobby has his back by not letting him come back until he's mentally healthy. Eddie just can't see it right now. Having someone's back means sometimes making a hard, yet life-saving decision. If you can't take care of yourself properly in that sense, you definitely can't take care of others in the best way.
Hate to say this but Eddie now you know what Buck felt like when Bobby kept him from working but you have people looking out for you unlike Buck did.. Although Eddie did go to far with Bobby's past.
eddie already acknowledged that buck's feelings were understandable when they made up way back then. and what do you mean, eddie has people looking out for him unlike buck? bobby has looked out for both of them. and it was eddie who went to buck to help pull him out of his depression. buck's choice to sue the department is what made him separate from the team, it was not the teams choice (though he still had maddie). eddie has bobby looking out for him from a distance, and who else? buck is just now noticing that eddie looks tired and it's been three months since he left and buck knew eddie was not okay even before that. as eddie's best friend, why hasn't he done more? he said himself he's spending all his time with taylor and didn't even follow up when eddie was a no show at the bar after he just noticed he might not be doing well. lets be fair.
@@LaNa-xv6rp I meant that Eddie now knows the feeling of being betrayed by his captain in a sense. But unlike with Buck Boddy told Eddie to his face why he does not want Eddie back.
Oh shit i did not see that coming at all i gasped so loud🥲 but everything bobby said is true eddie does need a therapist he is NOT okay at all , and i guess we’ve all seen the eddie sobbing scene so the next episodes eddie’s gonna have it rough and we have to endure this pain we are surely to have 💔💔💔💔💔this is a turning point for eddie and I’m so ready for it ❤️🔥
This was hard to watch. Bobby 👩🚒 is only looking out for Eddies best interests, by preventing him from coming back to the 118 too soon, as he is clearly suffering and is not in the correct frame of mind to do his job. I am 💯 behind Bobby, not only is he the Captain, but he is also responsible for all the other firefighters too, he has to make all the major decisions and has to be sure that Eddie is mentally stable and able to do his job. What Eddie said to Bobby was reprehensible and unforgivable, bringing up yet again the worst experience of his life. I am not sure what Eddie was thinking, but knowing the amazingly kind person that Bobby is, he will no doubt forgive those very hurtful comments in time.
But look at how he treated Buck. Totally diffrent. Buck was only recovering from a leg injury and was cleared by both the doctors and the brass who is above Bobby. Eddie can still see his therapist while have his job back. Buck does. That is no way in any shape or form fair. Bobby thinks he's helping but he isn't. He's making it worse. He needs to stay out of it.
So he leaves the 118, thinking he was making the right decision. But now he wants to come back after Josh had a talk with him. Obviously Eddie is not mentally and emotionally ready to come back. And characters doesn't need to go to the call center as a second job of sort.
He’s also gonna know that not letting Buck come back too soon was the right call as it is for not letting him come back yet either until he gets help. He could do more harm then good in his current state if he was allowed to return too soon.
@@cel101278 yeah i just want a scene where eddies venting and he has the realization that this is what buck felt and what drove him towards the lawsuit
There are three things I feel when I watch this scene: -I feel terirble for Bobby. He's aware that Eddie's only using these comments to lash out, not because he believes them, but it's gotta sting anyway. -I feel bad for Eddie because he clearly wouldn't dare if he weren't absolutely wrecked right now. And neither of them deserve this. -I also feels slightly vindicated on Buck's end. The one time he lashes out to defend what he believes is important to him, Eddie told him to just give it up and kinda said hurtful things to him when he didn't (and never apologised). Now he's in the same position and gets the karma treatment of knowing what Buck felt like. At least this time Bobby chose to be upfront instead of sneaking behind his back like with the bloodthinners fiasco. He's learning from his mistakes. Anyway, amazing job by Peter and Ryan. What great actors!
I don’t know why everybody comparing buck and Eddie situation with Bobby because they are clearly two different things. Eddie physically say he did not want to join the 118 that was his choice and he clearly not okay mentally because he dealing with a lot of trauma and Bobby is only looking out for him. Buck had a blood clot before he sued the department and he was clear by multiple doctors, Bobby should not have lied on buck and should have been honest that he was the one holding him back but on the other hand buck could have gone a different route than just suing the department. I believe that everybody needs therapy and these writers need to stop having these double standard situations.
All the ones saying that Bobby should let Eddie back or that Bobby shouldn't get to decide who comes back or not.....let's say he did let Eddie come back and they're out on call and Eddie has a panic attack and one of his fellow firefighters gets seriously hurt or killed....Bobby is looking out for Eddie and the rest of the 118, y'all can clearly see the Eddie isn't himself but wanna ignore the signs just to have the lives of his fellow firefighters in his hands, what sense does that make. Eddie needs to take a break from the firefighter and dispatch life altogether and get his mind and body right
@@rukiakuchiki5154 So you'll willing let someone come back to work under you, knowing that they're not fully functioning at their top level just cause they say they're fine while also putting your other firefighters at risk as well?
In my opinion, I think it's a bit of resentment still lingering after the lawsuit situation? Bobby went about it behind Buck's back, had the team follow suit in turning the cold shoulder when he lashed out and, in the end, never apologised. It all felt unfinished on one side. So I think they're using this as a kind of surrogate for that, since it looks familiar. I myself have had to cool my head and think "even if it looks similar, this situation with Bobby and Eddie is different and I should judge his actions based on what he has now, not from previous situations." At least, that's what I've gatheres by some people.
Oe eddie is in pain, i kinda get it, he is not sleeping, he is not happy. He thinks this wil make him happy to go back. But he needs therapy. Trust me it is for the best, speaking from my own experience.
I see everybody comment in this section on season 5 about Eddie and Bobby scene let's be honest Bobby was in the right because Eddie is suffering from PTSD and you'll find that out in the later episode if Bobby had let him back and and he had not deal with his trauma it would've been worse because in Eddie therapy session his therapist said to him what are you afraid of he couldn't answer that question then his therapist said to him reach out to the people that you serve with as part of your healing process you would discover that Eddie is suffering from survivor's guilt because he found out that the people that he thought he saved they killed themselves or they got killed and then you will find out that Eddie and Bobby actually had a heart to heart conversation at Eddie's place you would see Eddie and buck have a heart-to-heart conversation. Somebody mentioned Christopher said that he didn't want his dad to stop being a firefighter before that they were putting up decorations for Christmas and Christopher said that he wanted Christmas to be perfect and then he yelled out to his dad because his dad asked him what is this coming from why do you want Christmas to be perfect this year Chris said because you could be dead next year that's why Eddie quit being a firefighter because he thought he was putting his child life at risk of him being a firefighter not to mention that he didn't even tell Chris that he got held at gunpoint with buck as a hostage when they had the prison riot. And then you'll find out he had a heart to heart conversation with Carla. So all of this was contributed to Eddie leaving the 118. And somebody said that Eddie never apologized to Buck about what he said to him in the grocery store well if y'all remember that kitchen scene that Eddie and buck was having Buck basically apologize to Eddie for not being there for him and Christopher Eddie was spiraling out of control yet again. In the rage episode that was Eddie first times spiraling out of control. The second time you see Eddie spiraling out of control is going to be heart-wrenching
Im probably the only one who feels this way but Bobby actually pissed me off here, yeah what Eddie said was low and out of line and yeah maybe he's not ready to come back but im tired of Bobby getting to decide whose ready and who isn't, yeah he doesn't have to let him back to the 118 but he doesn't get to determine if he's ready or not. He can't stop him from going to another house. He did this to Buck also and Buck was cleared to go back, so if Eddie gets cleared, Bobby doesn't get to stop him from going back just like he didn't have that right with Buck.
@Claire-Louise Bell no he can’t, he doesn’t get to determine who is and isn’t ready to work, he can control who his firefighters are but he does not get to determine if their ready, he can get into some serious trouble with the union for that, if Buck would’ve went to the union instead of a lawsuit, there would’ve been a good chance of him losing his job, Buck was cleared, so he was wrong then too, Eddie was also cleared by medical, Bobby can’t just say your not ready, that’s not how it works, so if Eddie really wanted to he could transfer into a different fire station, but he would probably have to do something to make sure he is ready, it’s not off of a captains word.
@@kbl55429 what if he let him back on the 118 and something that could've been prevented happen to a patient. Bobby would be held responsible because Eddie's on his team
@@jazzyjonas6646 yes that’s why he doesn’t have to let him back at the 118 but he can’t stop him from going back to firefighting, Eddie then said we’ll I can go somewhere else and Bobby basically said he would make sure it wouldn’t happen that’s why Eddie got so mad. Eddie going back to that desk is slowly killing him, if he was back at the firehouse it would automatically lift his spirits, but Bobby doesn’t see things like, he did it with Buck, didn’t let him back and sent him off to a desk job that’s not good for blood clots, should Eddie be back firefighting, to a certain extent, he could’ve worked with his like Owen did with Judd but he didn’t, it always been his way or no way. It’s the one thing that’s always big me about him is his communication skills.
Bobby is just trying to do his job and be a responsible captain. He can't take Eddie back if, using his better judgment, he doesn't think Eddie is stable right now. It's similar to what happened with Buck in S3, except that back then Bobby initially didn't TELL Buck he was the one preventing him from going back to work, he hid behind the top brass. This time Bobby is owning his decision and not conveniently letting Eddie think someone else is responsible, so I can't really fault him for anything.
@@Slingblade87 you're right, but i wish that that, aside from eddie looking tired, they explained how bobby knows eddie is doing SO badly that he can't work and needs forced professional help. what information does he have to make such a strong statement and decision aside from under eye bags and eddie changing his mind after 3 months? 3 months isn't that short a time for a change of heart, it's not 3 days or weeks. anyway, *we* know bobby is right because we saw everything going on with eddie. bobby didn't see any of that.
I agree. He obviously didn't learn his mistake with Buck. This is not your concern Bobby. Stay out of it!!!!! You don't decided who can or can not come back. That's up to the doctors and the brass. Not you dude
As a first responder myself I wouldn't trust my captain if he'd allowed someone that is clearly not OK back on duty, the "brass" know jackshit about every single responder, z captain work shoulder to shoulder for 60 hours plus a week and yes, people that are not holding in together for any reason are LIABILITIES the kind that make responders and patients dead.
I watched the show and I'm disappointed with the results. We can see how miserable HOW EDDY is in his new job. You going to drag this situation as long as you can At least TK and a CARLOS MOVED IN TOGETHER.
I love Eddie but what he said was fucked up like he knows that hurts Bobby so bad he needs help like a lot everyone knows dam well that in a right state of mind he would never say that like dam what is this buck part two but worse
Called him out? What kind of heartless comment is that? You think Bobby was happy about that incident? He was so hard on himself that he was ready to commit suicide once he had atoned for all those lives. He doesn’t want Eddie to go down the same road he had. And Eddie wasn’t ‘calling him out’, he was just lashing out in anger. He didn’t mean it.
It’s is Bobby’s call it’s his house and he’s the captain, also Eddie LITERALLY brought his problems to him, it is Bobby’s job to look out for Eddie his past doesn’t matter he has to look out for him now and his team and Eddie is clearly not ready
@@myiataylor8364 no its not just like it wasn't with Buck. Buck was cleared by both doctors and Brass who is higher then bobby. Eddie can see his therapist while he has his job.Buck did so why not let Eddie. Bobby doesnt make this decision. Bobby deserved what he got.
![9-1-1 5x13 Eddie breakdown [buck is in the room] the Ending scene](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/nrQgaOEh3KU/mqdefault.jpg)
![9-1-1 5x13 Eddie breakdown [buck is in the room] the Ending scene](/img/tr.png)
Writers: "hey remember that thing we did a couple of seasons ago where buck and Bobby fight?... What if we do it again but with Eddie!"
"Yes and we could have him try to bite Bobby's head of. And get this Bobby doesnt say shet, he just speechless"
I just know he’s thinking “damn… so this is how Buck felt” 😅
Wow, Eddie is taking things from Buck’s play book
💀💀
Frrrr
To be fair, Buck was actually right. Bobby didn't let him back because he was scared of Buck getting hurt again. Eddie really is not ready.
"I want my job back."
Now where have I heard that before? 😏
I think I heard this song before
💀😭😂
Buck flashbacks
This is COMPLETELY different from what bobby did with buck and what bobby did with eddie. Bobby kept buck from the job because of his own personal issues and shouldn't have lied to him about why he couldn't go back to work when he got the go ahead from everyone that he was good to go back. I dont agree with the lawsuit but I under why he did it. Especially with all the hypocrisy with everyone else. Eddie had some obvious/serious mental health issues he needed to work out and bobby was right to not allow him back yet. So much is going through his head that he's not thinking clearly and bobby doesn't want eddie getting hurt on the job because he's not taking care of himself.
This Eddie's PTSD/Depression will be so interesting, I hope writers explore it properly and not in only one or two episodes. It's a very dangerous illness.
That’s what I was thinking!!!! His storyline could have potential.
and the writers finally did his illness justice on the latest episode
The "Go to hell Bobby" line hits harder once you think about how this is the exact place Bobby believes he is headed to after that fire.
Anyway my general view over this is that in no way Bobby was wrong for suggesting Eddie to look help first before come back to work, specially after witnessing such unstable behavior, but I'm also not mad at Eddie for lashing out, because even tho he was quite low with that comment, like really low, this basically just prove Bobby's point about him not being well, and we know Eddie would never dare to say such a fucked up thing it if he was in a right state of mind.
It was visible Eddie was not okay, he did put a happy face mask when going to ask for his job back, but Bobby saw through it, as well seeing it Eddie wasn't well and logically, he did hold the transference to his team temporarily so Eddie could prioritize his mental health instead, because admitting him back to work in that state could potentially be dangerous for the team and Eddie himself, who would most likely brush all the issues he has under the carpet again.
Anyway really sad scene, but it's really well done, Peter and Ryan did great here.
Frankly if I was Bobby, even if I didn't know Eddie had a shitload of trauma, the fact that he made such a big decision to quit firefighting for his kid's sake and now wants to come back just 3 months later would give me pause. Feels like he's all over the place.
I do think Bobby should've avoided saying that last thing, "hope they don't ask me for a recommendation", that bit of snark seemed to be the last straw that caused Eddie to lash out. Not that I'm excusing what Eddie said in any way, it was pretty nasty.
@@Slingblade87 Fr tho I think in some part it looked like a kid discussing with their dad (no jokes XD)
The "I can always go to another house" comment when denied to get back on the job was such spoiled kid line I even thought it was kinda funny actually asdhfhgh Bobby fueling it with the recommendation comment didn't help, but the moment Eddie said what he said, it was way out of line.
@@ArlertAMVs they both hurting each other and it's childish 😒 so it's the writers way of completing writing Eddie off back in the day when the show goes to Direction we will see the character in s20 for emotional return but these times shows dropping like Flys and even the good ones so yeah we never see Eddie again.
Eddie just about added several truck loads of crap to his state of sanity and health. What he did will not easily go away. It will keep sawing into his emotional well being. The scene is very nicely done and played. Tough, yet carefully thought. KUDOS!!! to Peter Krause and Ryan Guzmán.
This reminds me of Bobby and Buck. Bobby is just looking out for Eddie.
Two wayward sons, Buck & Eddy. Bobby's got his hands full
Bobby is the Captain and he knows what’s best for his team, every decision he makes comes from a good place because he cares about the people who work for him, he has to answer to those above him, but ultimately his team are bound by his rules.
The whole time I was “Eddie, honey…what are you doing?”
"You shouldn't have to lose everything, before you allow yourself to feel something"
-Season 3 Bobby to Eddie after he found out about the street fighting, feels appropriate here too
Feeling very similar vibes with this Bobbie and Eddie drama that i did with Bobby and Buck, except that Buck literally had doctor's approval to go back to work sooo.... come on Eds, go get approved AND THEN Bobby can tell you no
Eddie CLEARLY needs help. Whew chile 💀
I was not expecting that to be honest, but Eddie did say he wanted to leave. Then again I haven’t watched the show since the hiatus and I can’t exactly remember.
Eddie is reacting like most folks do when told that they need help, he gets angry and defensive and doesn't stop for a second to think there may be something to it. And in Eddie's case in particular, it definitely seems to me like his father instilled some toxic masculinity BS in him that causes him to repress everything, because he feels like seeking help would make him weak and not a proper "macho man".
It looks like he's headed for a true crash and burn in the coming episodes (we saw the clip of him sobbing). Going to be rough. And I do hope he takes back what he said to Bobby at the end here, that was a hell of a low blow.
I think once he realizes that Bobby was right, he will apologize cause he’s gonna feel like an ass for bringing that up.
This is literally dean winchester
Why’s everyone saying Bobby deserved that? Are you forgetting that Bobby was ready to commit suicide once he reached his goal. He wasn’t in the right state of mind and he ACTUALLY took the time he needed off.
Bobby is literally looking out for Eddie, you can literally see that he wasn’t ready. I honestly think it’s a good call, because you can’t keep changing your mind about what role you would like when your job involves other people safety. You need to be in the right mental state which Eddie clearly isn’t in. That was a low blow, and it wasn’t like Bobby started the fire on purpose
No Bobby deserved it. He was being a coward by keeping buck awaying knowing he was cleared by the doctors and brass. He is doing the exact same thing with Eddie.
@@rukiakuchiki5154 YOU CAN PHYSICALLY SEE EDDIE IS NOT OKAY.
Buck literally was coughing blood and had issue with the screws in his leg.
BOBBY WAS RIGHT, but men are so damn stubborn
@@cyntanaa Bobby is trying to stop him from firefighting in general. Eddie said he would go some where else but Bobby said he won't let that happen. Bobby CAN'T stop him from firefighting all together. As for Buck sitting at a desk would not be good for a blood clot.
@@rukiakuchiki5154 this is how I know you don’t watch, buck was not sitting at a desk he was out in the field overseeing. He got fed up and sued the department, he won the case then at the party he was coughing out blood. So furthermore proving bobbys point.
Of course bobby would not give Eddie a recommendation, what captain would want to put other in danger. Especially when he can see that Eddie is not coping at all. You can literally see he is tired and not in a good place. The only reason why Eddie wants to come back is because he thinks working will help. But it won’t, he needs therapy or a break out of LA
@@cyntanaa no it's because Christopher told him he never wanted him to quit. That's why he want's his job back. Watch it. Chris litterly told him that
I like that they did this again, it shows that it can happen a lot more then people realize and it shows how quickly someone in pain can turn on you for trying to help. Bobby faced this twice now, Buck first, then Eddie, both had bad reactions and Bobby was at the brunt of it both times yet still holds them in his heart because he knows they don't truly mean it.
I love this type of awareness, and I love seeing a positive and caring boss where you always hear about horrible bosses irl, Bobby sees them all as family and wont let them go into danger knowing that they could break under the pressure. Bobby is an amazing character.
Eddie owes Bobby a huge apology later on for that low blow. I know he’s upset right now and he’ll eventually see that Bobby was right not to let him come back but when he does he better apologize.
I feel 100% positive he will and will regret it for a very long time. Eddie tends to punish himself for things that aren’t even true, like that he let Christopher down
Well, he kinda did, but more as a "you had my back back then, now I'm gonna have yours" rather than a "I'm sorry I called you a murderer unfit to save people"
they said he apologized before that, it was just off screen, like half of the important conversations have been in current seasons. so glad kristen reidel has been demoted because she doesn't know what people need and want to see (like chimney apologizing for punching buck off screen as well)@@nguyenkhanhhailinh1721
First Buck does this to Bobby back in season 3 and now Eddie wow, who is it going to be next Hen or Chimney?
Buck: hold my beer
more like "hold my gear"
@@mew3677 lol
Wow, that was a low blow for Eddie. Bobby has his back by not letting him come back until he's mentally healthy. Eddie just can't see it right now. Having someone's back means sometimes making a hard, yet life-saving decision. If you can't take care of yourself properly in that sense, you definitely can't take care of others in the best way.
Hate to say this but Eddie now you know what Buck felt like when Bobby kept him from working but you have people looking out for you unlike Buck did.. Although Eddie did go to far with Bobby's past.
eddie already acknowledged that buck's feelings were understandable when they made up way back then. and what do you mean, eddie has people looking out for him unlike buck? bobby has looked out for both of them. and it was eddie who went to buck to help pull him out of his depression. buck's choice to sue the department is what made him separate from the team, it was not the teams choice (though he still had maddie). eddie has bobby looking out for him from a distance, and who else? buck is just now noticing that eddie looks tired and it's been three months since he left and buck knew eddie was not okay even before that. as eddie's best friend, why hasn't he done more? he said himself he's spending all his time with taylor and didn't even follow up when eddie was a no show at the bar after he just noticed he might not be doing well. lets be fair.
@@LaNa-xv6rp I meant that Eddie now knows the feeling of being betrayed by his captain in a sense. But unlike with Buck Boddy told Eddie to his face why he does not want Eddie back.
Well damn Eddie. Lawsuit all over again
I had Deja Vu with this scene. Eddie is acting like injured Buck.
Oh shit i did not see that coming at all i gasped so loud🥲 but everything bobby said is true eddie does need a therapist he is NOT okay at all , and i guess we’ve all seen the eddie sobbing scene so the next episodes eddie’s gonna have it rough and we have to endure this pain we are surely to have 💔💔💔💔💔this is a turning point for eddie and I’m so ready for it ❤️🔥
Oh !! So this is gonna be like Buck all over again :'(
This was hard to watch. Bobby 👩🚒 is only looking out for Eddies best interests, by preventing him from coming back to the 118 too soon, as he is clearly suffering and is not in the correct frame of mind to do his job. I am 💯 behind Bobby, not only is he the Captain, but he is also responsible for all the other firefighters too, he has to make all the major decisions and has to be sure that Eddie is mentally stable and able to do his job. What Eddie said to Bobby was reprehensible and unforgivable, bringing up yet again the worst experience of his life. I am not sure what Eddie was thinking, but knowing the amazingly kind person that Bobby is, he will no doubt forgive those very hurtful comments in time.
But look at how he treated Buck. Totally diffrent. Buck was only recovering from a leg injury and was cleared by both the doctors and the brass who is above Bobby. Eddie can still see his therapist while have his job back. Buck does. That is no way in any shape or form fair. Bobby thinks he's helping but he isn't. He's making it worse. He needs to stay out of it.
So he leaves the 118, thinking he was making the right decision. But now he wants to come back after Josh had a talk with him. Obviously Eddie is not mentally and emotionally ready to come back. And characters doesn't need to go to the call center as a second job of sort.
im happy eddie is alive
Now Eddie knows how Buck felt before he filed the lawsuit
He’s also gonna know that not letting Buck come back too soon was the right call as it is for not letting him come back yet either until he gets help. He could do more harm then good in his current state if he was allowed to return too soon.
@@cel101278 yeah i just want a scene where eddies venting and he has the realization that this is what buck felt and what drove him towards the lawsuit
@@cel101278 how was it the right call. It was a leg Injury. He was also medically cleared which means he had no right to keep Buck from working.
Ong🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
There are three things I feel when I watch this scene:
-I feel terirble for Bobby. He's aware that Eddie's only using these comments to lash out, not because he believes them, but it's gotta sting anyway.
-I feel bad for Eddie because he clearly wouldn't dare if he weren't absolutely wrecked right now. And neither of them deserve this.
-I also feels slightly vindicated on Buck's end. The one time he lashes out to defend what he believes is important to him, Eddie told him to just give it up and kinda said hurtful things to him when he didn't (and never apologised). Now he's in the same position and gets the karma treatment of knowing what Buck felt like. At least this time Bobby chose to be upfront instead of sneaking behind his back like with the bloodthinners fiasco. He's learning from his mistakes.
Anyway, amazing job by Peter and Ryan. What great actors!
Eddie and Buck are definitely soulmates 😬
He’s gonna pull off the exact same thing Buck did in season 3. He’s gonna bring up a lawsuit to the department and the 118 - gut feeling
So I haven't watched any of this season yet but it seems like Eddie is just retreading Buck's story with a slight twist.
Bobby is doing the right thing he cares for his kids he was being protective of buck the same way
I don’t know why everybody comparing buck and Eddie situation with Bobby because they are clearly two different things. Eddie physically say he did not want to join the 118 that was his choice and he clearly not okay mentally because he dealing with a lot of trauma and Bobby is only looking out for him. Buck had a blood clot before he sued the department and he was clear by multiple doctors, Bobby should not have lied on buck and should have been honest that he was the one holding him back but on the other hand buck could have gone a different route than just suing the department. I believe that everybody needs therapy and these writers need to stop having these double standard situations.
I love Eddie but that crossed the line tbh
Thank you thank you
Wow Eddie you just played a buck
All the ones saying that Bobby should let Eddie back or that Bobby shouldn't get to decide who comes back or not.....let's say he did let Eddie come back and they're out on call and Eddie has a panic attack and one of his fellow firefighters gets seriously hurt or killed....Bobby is looking out for Eddie and the rest of the 118, y'all can clearly see the Eddie isn't himself but wanna ignore the signs just to have the lives of his fellow firefighters in his hands, what sense does that make. Eddie needs to take a break from the firefighter and dispatch life altogether and get his mind and body right
His life not Bobby's. If he cares so much then he should require EVERYONE to see a therapist not just certain people. But he doesn't.
@@rukiakuchiki5154 So you'll willing let someone come back to work under you, knowing that they're not fully functioning at their top level just cause they say they're fine while also putting your other firefighters at risk as well?
They should be able to work and see a therapist. Not that hard to do.
@@rukiakuchiki5154 And what if they choose not to see a therapist, then what....you can't force them to see one
@@kngrzz007 can't force them not too either.
Anyone who ever left the 118: "I want my job back"
Bobby: "no"
Them🤬
Lmaoo
Bobby is used to this😭😭😭
Woooow, he's definitely loosing it.
buck and Eddie have something to come and they both get mad when they can't go back to work
Eddie omg bruh really i hate wen dey do this shit to Bobby
Am I the only one who get's a season 3 Buck Deja-Vu?
For the people who are mad at Bobby, PLEASE explain why. Cause I honestly need to have a hear at your train of thoughts
In my opinion, I think it's a bit of resentment still lingering after the lawsuit situation? Bobby went about it behind Buck's back, had the team follow suit in turning the cold shoulder when he lashed out and, in the end, never apologised. It all felt unfinished on one side. So I think they're using this as a kind of surrogate for that, since it looks familiar.
I myself have had to cool my head and think "even if it looks similar, this situation with Bobby and Eddie is different and I should judge his actions based on what he has now, not from previous situations."
At least, that's what I've gatheres by some people.
Oe eddie is in pain, i kinda get it, he is not sleeping, he is not happy. He thinks this wil make him happy to go back. But he needs therapy. Trust me it is for the best, speaking from my own experience.
Eddie....Eddie what are you doing....staaaaaaahp. Big Bro Bobby is doing you right. Let him.
I see everybody comment in this section on season 5 about Eddie and Bobby scene let's be honest Bobby was in the right because Eddie is suffering from PTSD and you'll find that out in the later episode if Bobby had let him back and and he had not deal with his trauma it would've been worse because in Eddie therapy session his therapist said to him what are you afraid of he couldn't answer that question then his therapist said to him reach out to the people that you serve with as part of your healing process you would discover that Eddie is suffering from survivor's guilt because he found out that the people that he thought he saved they killed themselves or they got killed and then you will find out that Eddie and Bobby actually had a heart to heart conversation at Eddie's place you would see Eddie and buck have a heart-to-heart conversation. Somebody mentioned Christopher said that he didn't want his dad to stop being a firefighter before that they were putting up decorations for Christmas and Christopher said that he wanted Christmas to be perfect and then he yelled out to his dad because his dad asked him what is this coming from why do you want Christmas to be perfect this year Chris said because you could be dead next year that's why Eddie quit being a firefighter because he thought he was putting his child life at risk of him being a firefighter not to mention that he didn't even tell Chris that he got held at gunpoint with buck as a hostage when they had the prison riot. And then you'll find out he had a heart to heart conversation with Carla. So all of this was contributed to Eddie leaving the 118. And somebody said that Eddie never apologized to Buck about what he said to him in the grocery store well if y'all remember that kitchen scene that Eddie and buck was having Buck basically apologize to Eddie for not being there for him and Christopher Eddie was spiraling out of control yet again. In the rage episode that was Eddie first times spiraling out of control. The second time you see Eddie spiraling out of control is going to be heart-wrenching
This was painful to watch, I feel sorry for the both of them
I might change my view later, but I’m on team Eddie. I think he’s right to be mad. I’ll edit this more further into this half of the season
I feel bad for Eddie and Bobby in this situation
Im probably the only one who feels this way but Bobby actually pissed me off here, yeah what Eddie said was low and out of line and yeah maybe he's not ready to come back but im tired of Bobby getting to decide whose ready and who isn't, yeah he doesn't have to let him back to the 118 but he doesn't get to determine if he's ready or not. He can't stop him from going to another house. He did this to Buck also and Buck was cleared to go back, so if Eddie gets cleared, Bobby doesn't get to stop him from going back just like he didn't have that right with Buck.
@Claire-Louise Bell he was wrong with Buck. Buck was cleared by the doctors meaning Bobby had no right to do what he did.
@Claire-Louise Bell no he can’t, he doesn’t get to determine who is and isn’t ready to work, he can control who his firefighters are but he does not get to determine if their ready, he can get into some serious trouble with the union for that, if Buck would’ve went to the union instead of a lawsuit, there would’ve been a good chance of him losing his job, Buck was cleared, so he was wrong then too, Eddie was also cleared by medical, Bobby can’t just say your not ready, that’s not how it works, so if Eddie really wanted to he could transfer into a different fire station, but he would probably have to do something to make sure he is ready, it’s not off of a captains word.
@@kbl55429 what if he let him back on the 118 and something that could've been prevented happen to a patient. Bobby would be held responsible because Eddie's on his team
@@jazzyjonas6646 Buck is seeing a therapist while working. Why can't Eddie?
@@jazzyjonas6646 yes that’s why he doesn’t have to let him back at the 118 but he can’t stop him from going back to firefighting, Eddie then said we’ll I can go somewhere else and Bobby basically said he would make sure it wouldn’t happen that’s why Eddie got so mad. Eddie going back to that desk is slowly killing him, if he was back at the firehouse it would automatically lift his spirits, but Bobby doesn’t see things like, he did it with Buck, didn’t let him back and sent him off to a desk job that’s not good for blood clots, should Eddie be back firefighting, to a certain extent, he could’ve worked with his like Owen did with Judd but he didn’t, it always been his way or no way. It’s the one thing that’s always big me about him is his communication skills.
"go the hell bobby!" I agreed totally
What why?
Bobby is just trying to do his job and be a responsible captain. He can't take Eddie back if, using his better judgment, he doesn't think Eddie is stable right now. It's similar to what happened with Buck in S3, except that back then Bobby initially didn't TELL Buck he was the one preventing him from going back to work, he hid behind the top brass. This time Bobby is owning his decision and not conveniently letting Eddie think someone else is responsible, so I can't really fault him for anything.
@@Slingblade87 you're right, but i wish that that, aside from eddie looking tired, they explained how bobby knows eddie is doing SO badly that he can't work and needs forced professional help. what information does he have to make such a strong statement and decision aside from under eye bags and eddie changing his mind after 3 months? 3 months isn't that short a time for a change of heart, it's not 3 days or weeks. anyway, *we* know bobby is right because we saw everything going on with eddie. bobby didn't see any of that.
I agree. He obviously didn't learn his mistake with Buck. This is not your concern Bobby. Stay out of it!!!!! You don't decided who can or can not come back. That's up to the doctors and the brass. Not you dude
As a first responder myself I wouldn't trust my captain if he'd allowed someone that is clearly not OK back on duty, the "brass" know jackshit about every single responder, z captain work shoulder to shoulder for 60 hours plus a week and yes, people that are not holding in together for any reason are LIABILITIES the kind that make responders and patients dead.
Can so.eone please remond me why eddie is not in the 126. I cant remember
126 is the station from 911: lone star :)
So this happens to buck than Eddie next thing Yk Eddie is gonna file a law suit
Bobby did the same thing with Buck.
I though that Eddie is back 🙁
1:25
OK I would expect that from Buck but not from Eddie
he’s such a diva!
I watched the show and I'm disappointed with the results. We can see how miserable HOW EDDY is in his new job. You going to drag this situation as long as you can
At least TK and a CARLOS MOVED IN TOGETHER.
I love Eddie but what he said was fucked up like he knows that hurts Bobby so bad he needs help like a lot everyone knows dam well that in a right state of mind he would never say that like dam what is this buck part two but worse
What !!!
does anyone know where I can watch this episode? I cant watch it on fox bc it says 'geographic restrictions'
finally someone called out Bobby for literally killing a hundred plus people 🤪
Called him out? What kind of heartless comment is that? You think Bobby was happy about that incident? He was so hard on himself that he was ready to commit suicide once he had atoned for all those lives. He doesn’t want Eddie to go down the same road he had. And Eddie wasn’t ‘calling him out’, he was just lashing out in anger. He didn’t mean it.
Exactly
Can they ya know write him off the show already
Bobby needs to stay out of other peoples problems. Eddie needs help but its not Bobby's call. Hate Bobby so much for this
It’s is Bobby’s call it’s his house and he’s the captain, also Eddie LITERALLY brought his problems to him, it is Bobby’s job to look out for Eddie his past doesn’t matter he has to look out for him now and his team and Eddie is clearly not ready
@@myiataylor8364 no its not just like it wasn't with Buck. Buck was cleared by both doctors and Brass who is higher then bobby. Eddie can see his therapist while he has his job.Buck did so why not let Eddie. Bobby doesnt make this decision. Bobby deserved what he got.
How do you hate Bobby for this😂😂😂😂 I REALLY want you to explain
The show's repeating storylines? Time to cancel it.