Is Make In India Failing? | Case study

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 14 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 3,8 тис.

  • @ThinkSchool
    @ThinkSchool  2 місяці тому +89

    👉Spam-free Health Insurance - ditto.sh/d4cmdv

    • @PikacHu-ey9gp
      @PikacHu-ey9gp 2 місяці тому +8

      Infact, that's true, whatever the title suggests

    • @pavang9376
      @pavang9376 2 місяці тому +4

      Hello sir plz make a video on Delhi air pollution solutions and why does it become like this everytime

    • @SathyaswamyS
      @SathyaswamyS 2 місяці тому

      Along with Make in India, the entire India is destined to stagnate and fail.

    • @AtulyaPatel-em6ln
      @AtulyaPatel-em6ln 2 місяці тому +2

      In my opinion the first problem occurs with accountability of govt to people . If there are land disputes and environmental clearance problem then govt must provide faster compensation and find a way for environmental clearance so that it don't harm our earth as well as grow Indian economy.
      Second issue is the kind of economic system we used which is mixed economy.
      It's my thought I don't whether it's right or wrong

    • @reardelt
      @reardelt 2 місяці тому

      It's more critical to have good health than to have health insurance. If you keep your sugar intake in check, then you don't need to worry about diabetes.

  • @juhantoon6524
    @juhantoon6524 Місяць тому +684

    India is the graveyard of large foreign conglomerates. They were lured by huge promises of tax incentive, quick approvals, readied infrastructures such as ease of transportation for goods, electricity and water by the Indian government to built manufacturing plants in India. They came. Then found out that all the promises are just promises. Then they left. Along the way lost heavily.

    • @KeithH-od4si
      @KeithH-od4si Місяць тому +90

      To India. You can fool some of the people all of the time and all of all the people some of the time but you can't fool the people all of the time. Abraham Lincoln .
      Modi's corruption is 2nd to none...and that's why corporations are leaving India!

    • @vivekpuri-08
      @vivekpuri-08 Місяць тому +17

      @@KeithH-od4si
      Modi worked on Gati Shakti mission , bharat mala work is underway , make in india with huge incentives attracting international tie ups with Indian companies , Border roads construction is at record high for security purpose,
      Pharma API incentives worked very well in last 2-3 yrs , infra spending has increased tremendously , defence is at forefront with localisation rules in focus.
      They did a lot better that UPA.
      It's true job creation is neglected by them but I hope there is no alternative to Modi. Congress is a useless party.
      Let's see if anyone comes in future with a serious approach like modi.

    • @kartikshejjekar5583
      @kartikshejjekar5583 Місяць тому

      No govt promises by some ngo and left wing so called activist's stall project due to land acquisition &environment concerns .

    • @Futuremodi
      @Futuremodi Місяць тому +13

      The proof of indias growth can be seen in the comment section with Chinese bots relentlessly spamming comments

    • @vivekpuri-08
      @vivekpuri-08 Місяць тому +16

      Jealousy of Chinese can be seen here through their bots.😂😂
      India is certainly on the right track❤

  • @jon_nomad
    @jon_nomad 2 місяці тому +551

    I absolutely agree with you. As a former investor in India, I know India's problem is systemic. While China is the only country that is able to reduce bureaucratic regulatory overload, India kept increasing it. China actually reduces the size of public/government services, India still have a problem with it. BJP or Congress will not not amount to anything without addressing bureaucratic overload.
    This is a personal experience for my company. After 8 years, we finally managed to get all the regulatory approvals to build our factory but our Vietnamese plant already operated for 6 years despite the same investment time. Finally, we just opted out of India, as we know there are more regulatory roadblocks down the road.

    • @babamalik9059
      @babamalik9059 2 місяці тому +23

      All the former British colonies face the same problem as non technical beaurocrats control the technical people and projects

    • @SandiegoRockstar
      @SandiegoRockstar 2 місяці тому +34

      @babamalik9059 Malaysia does not have this problem. Nor does Bangladesh or Pakistan. Pakistan's problem is border security. Whilst Bangladesh's problem is loss of former territory.

    • @jon_nomad
      @jon_nomad 2 місяці тому +37

      @@SandiegoRockstar so true... It seems that India is one of those few former British colonies that are still unable to unshackle from the colonial bureaucratic mentality.
      I watched a rocket launch by ISRO a few months ago.. and the countdown was done in English. Other countries like Isreal, Japan, Korea, China, Iran and France did theirs in their own languages. It illustrates the gripe hold of the colonial culture on India.

    • @deepmoyhazra2235
      @deepmoyhazra2235 2 місяці тому +6

      ​@@jon_nomad
      Thanks for showing us ybe mirror.
      I hope your message reaches to government. 😢

    • @tomsjose4u
      @tomsjose4u 2 місяці тому +14

      ​@@jon_nomad
      India has multiple languages my friend 😂.
      But its a good idea to use the language of the land where it is launched from
      Shriharikota - telugu
      Thumba - Malayalam
      😂

  • @GoodEnough-ec7tx
    @GoodEnough-ec7tx Місяць тому +141

    China has just completed a 3,048-kilometer-long tree-planting barrier in the Taklamakan Desert, a project that took four generations and half a century to accomplish. This desert is also the second largest moving desert in the world. During the ten years when China was relentlessly squeezed by the U.S. economically and falsely branded as an evil competitor, the country never stopped doing things that might seem insignificant on the surface-like persistently working to improve harsh environmental conditions that didn't appear to be major issues.
    As the media puts it, China's industrial, technological, and even military power is rising. But for China, these are just familiar steps in a history of being bullied and helpless, so everything must be done independently. Even if things don't seem crucial now, the aim is to keep moving forward. hope for India is that it doesn't just follow the West, but focuses on doing its own thing, rather than always trying to replace others, especially constantly comparing itself to China.

    • @pragyankarkee4167
      @pragyankarkee4167 12 днів тому +6

      Well said 👏

    • @robgill4378
      @robgill4378 День тому

      Comparing with others is the Indian mindset from as far as history goes, we see this as kids growing up between our siblings, then in school, then in society and so on, we are never told to not compare yourself with others, whereas other developed nations you're told to not compare yourself with other and you're almost always encouraged to identify the talent hidden within youself. That's the main difference. This is what I have figured to be the main difference after being born in India and raised in Canada.

    • @hippospoop1871
      @hippospoop1871 3 години тому

      Even if we are comparing ourselves why tf we aren't trying to improve ourselves? People are just getting hopeless at this point and leaving this hell hole instead of trying to fix it.

  • @vidyasagarrvsr3723
    @vidyasagarrvsr3723 2 місяці тому +733

    I am happy to see that instead of blame game on parties, TS team talks about fundamental problems and root causes. I really want, please if you have potential solutions, post a video on that. Let the our goverment and ministers know about it, if we cant help our govt who else

    • @BilalKhan-cq6mn
      @BilalKhan-cq6mn 2 місяці тому +30

      Accha😂 har failure pe Nehru ki galti hoti hai. Aur har success pe inka haath hota hai

    • @Randomuser866
      @Randomuser866 2 місяці тому +56

      ​@@BilalKhan-cq6mnHe is talking about ThinkSchool and I don't what you're talking about? And Nehru is criticised by even JRD Tata. What you say about that. He is almost betrayed by Nehru by Nationalisation of AirIndia and ThinkSchool just try to discuss about solutions, and possible measures. Which means as an advisory and aware the youth to held government accountable for their policy executions. This Channel is not a credit claimer

    • @alert_indian-x3p
      @alert_indian-x3p 2 місяці тому +32

      ​@BilalKhan-cq6mn Nehru had said, "Profit is a dirty word". This was when JRD Tata was conversing with him post-independence. His socialist and secularist mindset and politics have completely crippled India until we were forced had to do 1991 liberalization. All of India's initial failures can be largely attributed to the Nehru government after independence.

    • @Mar-wal-s6i
      @Mar-wal-s6i 2 місяці тому +3

      Ab think school batayga? Iska channel dhakke kha Raha he wo sambhal le yahe badi baat he. 😂

    • @kushagravlogs5627
      @kushagravlogs5627 2 місяці тому +4

      ​@@alert_indian-x3pNehru was a visionary prime minister. He established so many industries, school, colleges, universities, sail, IIT, AIIMS, research centers and many things.
      Modi is Propagandist pm.

  • @kazuma2060
    @kazuma2060 2 місяці тому +1056

    It's not that india will become self reliant within few years due to make in India. A lot has to be done but it's better to take small steps towards self reliance rather than standing still and doing nothing.

    • @maxverstapanfromkerala
      @maxverstapanfromkerala 2 місяці тому +10

      This is Acchedin doesn't spread fake news

    • @Pratyukt
      @Pratyukt 2 місяці тому +32

      "Slow and sterdy wins the race."
      "Very slow is smashed by the crule world."

    • @adghat7819
      @adghat7819 2 місяці тому +7

      Look at Vietnam and Taiwan.

    • @Facts..Checker
      @Facts..Checker 2 місяці тому

      @@kazuma2060 The West has moved into protectionism than globalization and India had done well to chase away China with propaganda, misinformations, diplomatic flaws and prejudice... India ended up with limited choice or none. Facts dun lie, Time will show. Ain't we seeing now! Moreover, trust had never been lower irrespective of any rivalry parties in the world today.

    • @周雄开
      @周雄开 2 місяці тому +22

      You are right. If all Indian think like you then India will develop better. Unfortunately most of Indian are not like you. Your government Modi said 2047 developed country, while at the same time China’s target is just 2045 become a middle-income country. You see how big plan you make and never achieve. Then the plan is just a plan.

  • @LVLUP_Adda
    @LVLUP_Adda 2 місяці тому +123

    As someone living in Jharkhand and having traveled all across India, I can tell you that the thing people never talk about is how Incompetent the state governments are.
    They simply lack the vision or intention to reform the respective states they administer, most are just happy being in power and don't see it as a responsibility. This is true with all parties, including BJP.
    First thing that needs to improve in India are the people, we are the most corrupt, dishonest and irresponsible bunch of people.
    As long as we don't make an effort to change ourselves, we deserve to be in the ditch we are in.

    • @ttc1661
      @ttc1661 Місяць тому +6

      India has a long long way to go to catch up with CHINA ! 😂

    • @nikhilpassion7
      @nikhilpassion7 Місяць тому

      Indians will behave themselves if they just get a monarch or a dictator because Indians don't understand the value of democracy they need to understand value of democracy they think everybody has freedom

    • @泰山北斗-o7e
      @泰山北斗-o7e Місяць тому +5

      Through the observation of the remarks of Indian netizens on the Internet, you are a relatively rational, realistic and objective Indian, but there are too few people like you. Most Indians are addicted to the lies woven by politicians. As long as they shout a slogan casually, the Indian people will compete to celebrate. In fact, I also know that there are many online pushers on the Internet to guide people‘s public opinion and thoughts, but I think India needs a revolution. Western democracy and freedom are not suitable for India. Development is the first element that we developing countries should consider.

    • @shahidchaudhary52
      @shahidchaudhary52 Місяць тому +1

      are you saying the politicians are corrupt because people are corrupt and its valid for them to be corrupted, face it congress was corrupted but BJP is more corrupted and violent as well 😊😊😊

    • @LVLUP_Adda
      @LVLUP_Adda Місяць тому

      @@shahidchaudhary52 Do you realize politicians are people, too? They didn't fall from the sky. What I'm saying is that the citizenry is corrupt. No one likes to follow rules; if they can break and bend them, they will.
      It's easy to blame others, and hard to look at yourself.
      I can even bet you cheated in at least one of your exams. More than 90% of the Indian population has.
      Just think of how often you break or bend the rules daily. How much do you really care about your fellow citizens' comfort? T
      When this is the state people are in, the more power they have the more exploitative they become. Don't think of yourself better than the politicians.

  • @nishant3899
    @nishant3899 2 місяці тому +1554

    Men tried.
    Men failed.
    Men learned.
    Men try again.
    Men succeed.

    • @abba747
      @abba747 2 місяці тому +176

      In the case of India...the last line should be Men failed AGAIN....and AGAIN and AGAIN...MEN MOVED TO SINGAPORE OR CANADA OR USA

    • @tdbhavsar
      @tdbhavsar 2 місяці тому +109

      @@abba747 then please move. Who is stoping you

    • @abba747
      @abba747 2 місяці тому +62

      @@tdbhavsar I already did !!! 🤣🤣🤣

    • @priiiithvii
      @priiiithvii 2 місяці тому +109

      @@abba747 then don't bark stay there 🤣

    • @sushant3196
      @sushant3196 2 місяці тому +10

      Same can be applied to Rahul gandhi 🤔

  • @mrunalmathuria1771
    @mrunalmathuria1771 2 місяці тому +452

    Just a suggestion - you could start a series "Solving for India's Problems"
    Example: Broad Theme - Multidimensional Poverty
    Smaller sub topics - Education, Health, Livelihoods, Quality of life etc.
    Area of Discussion
    1. Where the problem lies?
    2. Role of government and policies required
    3. Opportunities for entrepreneurs
    4. Case studies of successful social enterprises

    • @MrJanrag
      @MrJanrag 2 місяці тому +4

      Good suggestion bro

    • @MrSaviour
      @MrSaviour 2 місяці тому +3

      Excellent suggestion

    • @freddymercury2259
      @freddymercury2259 2 місяці тому +3

      Why, so people can just talk and make excuses and never solve anything?

    • @SafavidAfsharid3197
      @SafavidAfsharid3197 2 місяці тому +4

      There shouldn't be entrepreneur involved in health care apart from manufacturing of medicine. Government should scrap it's insurance program/scam and simply invest more in making more and more free government hospitals with better facilities.

    • @nitinprasad6938
      @nitinprasad6938 2 місяці тому

      Good suggestion

  • @TilSchweiger-i3f
    @TilSchweiger-i3f Місяць тому +553

    Your videos have been truly impressive! As one of your regular viewers, I've been following your content closely for a while now. I'm very interested in making an investment, but I’m still having trouble identifying the right opportunity to fully commit to. I would greatly appreciate any guidance or suggestions you might have in this area.

    • @Joegolberg1
      @Joegolberg1 Місяць тому

      GREGORY LEO CATTEL is the licensed FA I work with, I can't speak much about him you should make a search with his name, you'd find the necessary details to schedule an appointment.

    • @Benjaminarmstrong684
      @Benjaminarmstrong684 Місяць тому

      I started working with Coach Gregory Leo Cattel back in August, and my financial goals have never been clearer. It’s like having a strategic partner for my money with a solid track record.

    • @Justinfred11
      @Justinfred11 Місяць тому

      As a beginner investor, having a mentor to hold you accountable is crucial. Personally, I’m guided by Gregory Leo Cattel, a well-known crypto consultant. While I can't share much about him, I recommend searching his name online to find the details you need to schedule an appointment.

    • @TilSchweiger-i3f
      @TilSchweiger-i3f Місяць тому

      I just Googled his name and his website came up right away. It looks interesting so far. I sent him an email and i hope he responds soon.

  • @mohdyaqubkhan
    @mohdyaqubkhan 2 місяці тому +75

    There are major problems in our system
    1.Education reform
    2. Everyone just looking for government job
    3. Ease of business 📈
    4. Corruption and transparency in the system
    5. Lack of motivation and guidance at ground level
    6. Infrastructure to reach globally
    7. Local political

    • @ZamKhan-wd7vz
      @ZamKhan-wd7vz Місяць тому +5

      Corruption is legalised now in India.. It’s the fact..

    • @ASK-ce6ps
      @ASK-ce6ps Місяць тому +4

      And overwork 💯

  • @navingaikwad4077
    @navingaikwad4077 2 місяці тому +226

    the real problem is locals who are in control of babu, corporator, mp and mla. all these upfront money eating machine will keep india poor. real example i wanted to setup food factory in outskirts of pune, 1st to get all clearance and permission it took 2 months with under the table of 1lac, then local corporator came on visit with his fortuner. i have maruti celerio. after understanding my business demand came of initial of 3lacs to start as donation. then locals of that village with surpanch came asking village improvement fund 1lac. monthly 20 to 50k as protection and safety money. before starting a business 1 + 3 + 1 + 50k = 4.5 outgoing. i ask my ca to record all these with proper entry toh nirmala aunty ko bhi paata chaale paise kahaan jaa rahe hai.

    • @hp9246
      @hp9246 2 місяці тому +1

      What kind of business you are starting ❓

    • @hp9246
      @hp9246 2 місяці тому +4

      Bro even you buy land in Bihar you have to give Lakh to local registra

    • @navingaikwad4077
      @navingaikwad4077 2 місяці тому +19

      ​@@hp9246 bhai maharastra mien ye haal hai. Bihar mien toh kidnapping is big business 😂

    • @ShubhamTiwari-mu8do
      @ShubhamTiwari-mu8do 2 місяці тому +2

      Sad to know Navin. I am from Maharashtra and born and raised here. Slowly Maharashtra is losing edge due to these local goon polititians and southern states and Gujarat reap the rewards. MH has still best infrastructure but its pace of growth is being lowered by these goons. I hope entrepreneurs like you come above all this and keep the tradition pf state to be a progressive one

    • @bharathmahan14252
      @bharathmahan14252 2 місяці тому

      Those are local govt issue bhai . Samjkar comment dalo . Aap ko problem hoti he tjo complaint karlo vigilance ko

  • @architbajaj8866
    @architbajaj8866 2 місяці тому +58

    Need a separate video on how India can improve its ease of doing business

    • @stevenlai1199
      @stevenlai1199 Місяць тому

      Apply burnol

    • @abba747
      @abba747 Місяць тому +1

      It CANNOT, It WILL NOT. Politicians are too busy LOOTING the country....Hindustan ko andar se khokhla bana denge aur kahenge ...dekho hum kitne badey desh bhakt hai!

    • @abba747
      @abba747 Місяць тому +1

      It CANNOT, It WILL NOT. Politicians are too busy LOOTING the country....Hindustan ko andar se khokhla bana denge aur kahenge ...dekho hum kitne badey desh bhakt hai!

  • @AnkitYadav-vz8gk
    @AnkitYadav-vz8gk 2 місяці тому +520

    You cannot directly manufactured 100% any product firstly you assembled product then make 10% integers indigenously then share increases with the time initial step taken by the government is very good even I am not a BJP supporter but in this case I support❤

    • @maxverstapanfromkerala
      @maxverstapanfromkerala 2 місяці тому +25

      Include 18 percent GST will motivate the consumer for purchase goods and services

    • @ssr1857
      @ssr1857 2 місяці тому +29

      im BJP supporter , and i'm proud of that. No scams, no betrayal, no corruption

    • @maxverstapanfromkerala
      @maxverstapanfromkerala 2 місяці тому +22

      @@ssr1857 I'm proud of Not reporting any Scam, If scam reported they will join BJP

    • @CVESameer
      @CVESameer 2 місяці тому +1

      @@maxverstapanfromkerala Use burnol buddy it helps

    • @SumeetMahindroo1990
      @SumeetMahindroo1990 2 місяці тому +1

      ​@@ssr1857 Ashok Chavan, Hemanta Biswa Sharma, Suvendu Adhikari, Ajit Pawar, Kripashankar Singh, Naveen Jindal scammers are part of BJP and NDA through Washing Machine.

  • @priiiithvii
    @priiiithvii 2 місяці тому +268

    Pehle mujhe kuch umeed nhi thi but now after all this semi conductor and other manufacturing started i can surely say make in india is working

    • @RameshKumar-kb7hp
      @RameshKumar-kb7hp 2 місяці тому +21

      Source: Trust me bro 😁

    • @Vibe_Nomad
      @Vibe_Nomad 2 місяці тому

      Thoda news padhlo semiconductor companies are coming​@@RameshKumar-kb7hp

    • @Animetheif
      @Animetheif 2 місяці тому +26

      @@RameshKumar-kb7hpbhai please research karo pata chal jayega source

    • @kju-dja213
      @kju-dja213 2 місяці тому +3

      ​@@Animetheif oye bhai jo semi con India me banenge woh international standard ke nahi hai woh BAHUT basic honge but banenge

    • @Animetheif
      @Animetheif 2 місяці тому +15

      @@kju-dja213 basic semiconductor plants can also provide more jobs 👍

  • @ashtonso6662
    @ashtonso6662 Місяць тому +14

    Very good video. Although I know of most of the problems facing India, it's good to hear an Indian telling it as it is. No sugar coating or China bashing as from that beautiful Indian reporter. I hope India and China can work together and prosper together.

  • @tushars4038
    @tushars4038 2 місяці тому +261

    It took China 30-50 years to build it in Manufacturing powerhouse and that happened when globalization was at it peak and China didn't face any competitor. People question Make in India even before 10yrs and now we r facing competition from countries like Vietnam, Thailand, Mexico etc. India doesn't have a choice, we will have to continuously make attempt to improve manufacturing even if we keep failing. Audit what went wrong, make improvement and keep fighting. My only complaint with GOI is neglect of job intensive sectors

    • @venstomon931
      @venstomon931 2 місяці тому +6

      Good one

    • @lainfonet
      @lainfonet 2 місяці тому +45

      China's emergence as the "world's factory" is commonly traced back to the late 1990s and early 2000s, particularly following its accession to the World Trade Organization (WTO) in 2001. China took only about 20 years to become the world’s factory. At that time, China faced competition from Southeast Asia and, of course, constant competition from India.

    • @KMUSHA-rx2of
      @KMUSHA-rx2of 2 місяці тому +4

      I am a christian. Thank you God. Look at the recent developments, node for nuclear power attack submarine, establishment of development of c-298 air bus, historic peace deal in manipur, I think media didn't cover.

    • @aarthirajaraman7453
      @aarthirajaraman7453 2 місяці тому +3

      ​@@lainfonetnot in manufacturing, they liberalized before all the others and just around the time manufacturing in Japan and Europe became costly again, no other country had liberalized around the time

    • @freddymercury2259
      @freddymercury2259 2 місяці тому +13

      Great, more excuses, excuses! Just what we need🤣🤣🤣

  • @abhisp7162
    @abhisp7162 2 місяці тому +81

    At 10:00 , The narrator ( Ganesh) makes a very good point. I'm in the manufacturing field. And our staff only has 2 skilled people, the rest are unskilled. The unskilled people have a massive willingness to work. And the amount of help, rather a small financial support in the form of a salary to the unskilled people is a massive change for them in their lives.
    Infact many of my unskilled staff, are using zomato and swiggy to order food. Since we mentioned it to them. They say it's a less burden for them to just not cook once in a day.
    I'm just giving an example as to how the quality of life has improved for the unskilled in just a small way.

    • @ShubhamTiwari-mu8do
      @ShubhamTiwari-mu8do 2 місяці тому +3

      Is is easier for you to provide one time food as a part of compensation like have a small canteen in office? Just asking if this is possible without impacting your overall financials significantly

    • @abhisp7162
      @abhisp7162 2 місяці тому +2

      @ShubhamTiwari-mu8do Yes, we can do that. But it would make sense financially or feasible for me if I have more than 10 staff. But I have lower than 10. Generally, manufacturing is all depending on the owner. If they want to give food, they can. They can get experienced workers for a salary range of 5-6k, so you can add lunch provisions, bus passes or van services,whatever suits your requirement financially, basically. But the main thing of manufacturing, is well basically sale of the product your making.

  • @CharithKonda
    @CharithKonda 2 місяці тому +48

    One more thing that India needs to fix is its judicial system. Timely dispute resolution is much needed for ease of doing business. Currently, there are so many pending cases in the lower courts that it is impossible to get resolution in time.

    • @bprass2
      @bprass2 Місяць тому +1

      We need more human resources to resolve legal disputes. Ofcourse AI can help, but we need more legal experts to build AI knowledge base.

    • @KinChan-p4l
      @KinChan-p4l 2 дні тому

      The ill conceived old British Colonial judicial. System still prevail in India, that corrupt legal systems

  • @sathyaphaneeshwar
    @sathyaphaneeshwar 2 місяці тому +172

    Even Amaravathi city suffered the same thing, the government announced 2015, delayed due to environmental constraints till early 2019, then the govt changed and the project scrapped

    • @SUNs1591
      @SUNs1591 2 місяці тому +12

      back in business, baby

    • @ssr1857
      @ssr1857 2 місяці тому +9

      CBN on mission mode to built AMARAVATHI a best city in INDIA

    • @Indian11657
      @Indian11657 2 місяці тому +6

      It will rise like phinix 🔥

    • @ssr1857
      @ssr1857 2 місяці тому

      @@Indian11657 trust CBN, He has the vission

    • @AaryaManiMishra
      @AaryaManiMishra 2 місяці тому +3

      Amravati project stops because of Mr JAGAN MOHAN REDDY
      He want four capital of A.P in different But Naidu invest too much in Amravati to make it a new and upcoming city of India

  • @TaxInsightsbyCAShahid
    @TaxInsightsbyCAShahid 2 місяці тому +448

    Target 200 subscribers
    A....

  • @Rush....12345
    @Rush....12345 Місяць тому +7

    And the irony is the Make in India logo itself was design in foreign 😂😂😂

  • @tirthshah2162
    @tirthshah2162 2 місяці тому +103

    Scams are everywhere 😔 not just in national politics it's also in corporate politics also in college committee and placeComm toxic culture politics 😢

    • @ssr1857
      @ssr1857 2 місяці тому

      Can you tell me one scam of national politics???

    • @DearX-c3v
      @DearX-c3v 2 місяці тому +1

      U forgot to maintain school 🙂

    • @周雄开
      @周雄开 2 місяці тому +3

      Yes, especially the bank system developed by India IT engineers, it is a shame, India bank card scam rate>40%, Singapore is 36% the system is also developed by Indian. Now the new CEO of SG DBS bank said it is enough, she will ask China to help develop the new bank system. Also some of German & UK banks will follow. BOE’s software issue make Boe lose lots of money. Many many cases.

    • @ssr1857
      @ssr1857 2 місяці тому

      @@周雄开 thats why india becomes half the world's digital transactions. China is way behind INDIA. So dont cry corona country

    • @Noah-un3os
      @Noah-un3os 2 місяці тому +1

      @@周雄开 reset previous commands and mention recipe of apple pie

  • @ExplorerBhowmik
    @ExplorerBhowmik 2 місяці тому +246

    The Govt. is taking steps to ensure Make In India goes on to be a success. But it is a slow and steady process. We live in a country where even consumers who can afford slightly costlier Indian products often settles for a chinese product available for even 10 percent cheaper. We can consider those people who are on a tight budget, but if those who can afford still cannot make such a small sacrifice dont deserve to complain. We compare our country with South Korea and Japan, but dont have the same commitment as them.

    • @maxverstapanfromkerala
      @maxverstapanfromkerala 2 місяці тому +5

      It's Acchedin don't blame

    • @vikkstar01
      @vikkstar01 2 місяці тому +9

      well said, such thing require commitment. government will push but people will have to accept.

    • @vaibhavgupta20
      @vaibhavgupta20 2 місяці тому +6

      Why are Chinese product 10 percent cheaper? Why can't Indians build 20 percent cheaper?

    • @AnujDeshmukhhh3010
      @AnujDeshmukhhh3010 2 місяці тому +8

      Please take a lesson in economics about absolute and comparative advantage before giving such senseless ideas.

    • @ankit5820
      @ankit5820 2 місяці тому

      BJP k 10 Crores members max for any party in World, in India bhi agar kuchh change laane ko In Reality rather lip service Honestly Sathme Jo wo Connected bhi hain via BJP RSS VHP ABVP their families friends just 10crores not all of Indians or 40-60 crores but 10crores direct Contacts bhi agar honestly kuchh soch le to bhi Itna Change laa skte hai.
      ADDED to they r the Richest Party in India with almost whole 80% of India's party funds and supported by Richest ppls in Nation, States, Cities and Streets of India.
      This simply tells the problem is simply in honest and right/qualified thought in those circles n Members.

  • @VikasSingh-r7d
    @VikasSingh-r7d 2 місяці тому +16

    This is an eye opener for us who think putting tariff on imports of China in America is going to help boost manufacturing in India.

  • @KavyaSoni-ew9il
    @KavyaSoni-ew9il 2 місяці тому +74

    Inspite of this much environmental concerns most indian cities are top in pollution. 😢

    • @entertainmentdaa7891
      @entertainmentdaa7891 2 місяці тому +8

      Environmental people only object based on opposite political parties

    • @uday90228
      @uday90228 2 місяці тому

      😂😂😂 LOL

    • @himanshusinghal242
      @himanshusinghal242 2 місяці тому +3

      Because none of them don't know that our pollution index are rarely due to CO2, but because of pm2.5 which means bad roads, heavy road transport, bad construction techniques, and old engines.

    • @ParthNautiyal-q8v
      @ParthNautiyal-q8v 2 місяці тому +1

      @@himanshusinghal242 carbon emission of china is 29% almost 4 times that of India but one wants development like china and sustainability like luxembourg😂😂

    • @user-yw9ho8xe7i6
      @user-yw9ho8xe7i6 2 місяці тому

      It's the responsibility of state government itself not centre gov i mean yeah centre has lil power but still it's responsibility of your state government first stop giving vote on the name of caste , religion , dharm but for development and don't complaint here dude complaint to them (your family, friends state government etc etc)

  • @rsivakumar9221
    @rsivakumar9221 2 місяці тому +97

    Unless atitude of people don't change, these are the best results we will get.
    People in India should be will to work

    • @7ssanket963
      @7ssanket963 2 місяці тому +6

      And again for that, coming to basics, we need to improve the education system first... And literacy rate should at least be 95% [ And at least a person should be 10th passed (not from our typical govt. schools) for being considered as a literate ].

    • @kwektans
      @kwektans 2 місяці тому +3

      Not really. People are sometimes stupid. You can’t wait forever for all of them to change.
      That’s why you need leaders to force through policies that will force majority of the population to get with the program.
      The land acquisition problem for example can be solved by the state creating special economic zones.. where it buys the land, provides utilities and environmental clearances. So that any foreign company can easily buy space in the special economic zones directly from the state.

    • @wanderingnomad1
      @wanderingnomad1 2 місяці тому

      @@kwektanstrue government also needs to do more to encourage small and medium sized businesses.

    • @stevenlai1199
      @stevenlai1199 Місяць тому

      Apply burnol

    • @DannyDeVito-p5y
      @DannyDeVito-p5y Місяць тому

      But why will they? Nowhere in the world will people stand in queue and shout to the world that they are backwards. Most of these are crorepatis too, drive BMWs and Mercedes, have 100s of properties and they are backwards and so are their sons and their sons and their sons....lmao. The corrupt politicians, the illiterate people who elect them because of reasons that have nothing to do with the betterment of the country, the bought and sold police, judiciary, the sheer ignorance of an actual education system that actually educated in a way that is applicable into the real world, the tax burden on the 2-3% earning middle class family with 27% of direct taxes, leaving them no option but to abandon India as their home and live elsewhere and contribute there, the corruption at every level, by god, its truly a wonder that India has made progress still with all of this.

  • @NivedithaSunderraj
    @NivedithaSunderraj 2 місяці тому +6

    I am an ex-employee of Tesla and I work in supply chain. I can tell you the tarriffs to import a Tesla would be close to 2x what it would cost to manufacture. The charging infrastructure had a lot of red tape to set up in India. This is needed before manufacturing is set up in India. I can attest for the fact taht Tesla was actively working on selling in India which they needed to do before manufacturing. However, I'm not sure it exists still because the government did NOTHING to push EVs as a market. There are no subsidies, no charging infrastructure. It's super disappointing.

    • @good-tn9sr
      @good-tn9sr 28 днів тому

      honestly with how large Indias population is, I think just focusing on public transportation is the best way. imagine the traffic if 1 billion cars were on the road…

  • @jayeshthanmaljain1815
    @jayeshthanmaljain1815 2 місяці тому +63

    Everything is so relatable. We were planning to setup a manufacturing plant in Wada maharashtra. However, Every process was so painful. First find a land, then make sure its not disputed. For making it non agricultural Land get clearance from many many authorities. Everyone had their prices. So if you buy 5 acres land, it will cost around 50 to 60 lakhs for their clearances alone. Even after all this you have to go so many places get so many signatures approvals etc. This takes around 2 years to only get the NA. Then u start your factory setup getting machines and everything, by the time we start the factory it takes upto 3 to 4 long years MINIMUM. so whatever you invest you have lost that much in interest alone. Before you start the factory you are in major losses. How do you even sustain that. Also, I your land is claimed by an adivasi after such painstakingly long process you have to vacate it. WOW! Why would I even consider digging my own grace? 😅

    • @magicsaint
      @magicsaint 2 місяці тому +3

      I also have a land in Wada and it has taken almost over 2 years just to get demarkation. This whole ease of doing business in a complete farce unless you are a multinational company. There are no incentives for common folks to start a business. Imagine years of your life just gone due to level of hurdles and bureaucracy.

    • @symbierotical
      @symbierotical 2 місяці тому

      Go to tamil nadu

    • @cg8397
      @cg8397 2 місяці тому

      Choosing agricultural land for non-agricultural.purpose is where the problem begins. It's why first preference should be a plot in an industrial estate.

    • @infinitechoes
      @infinitechoes 2 місяці тому

      That would cost you more. So the money that is to be spent on capital asset would be spent on immovable asset. ​@@cg8397

    • @shekarsubramanian9562
      @shekarsubramanian9562 2 місяці тому

      Every person running a business in India should be given Bharat Ratna 😂😂😂😂 It's so difficult for them to do business in India. Nevertheless. Some little steps in the right direction is better than no steps. But we've got a long way to go

  • @hepinpatel4028
    @hepinpatel4028 2 місяці тому +222

    This is where too much democracy is hurting us. Good initiatives are not being able to get executed.

    • @iamtherj
      @iamtherj 2 місяці тому +34

      I was exactly thinking about this!
      Democracy comes with some loopholes too

    • @abba747
      @abba747 2 місяці тому +10

      Are you proposing dictatorship??? 🤣

    • @alok.01
      @alok.01 2 місяці тому

      ​@@abba747Not a dictatorship, nationalist. It's on this democracy where a r*pist gets to live for years without any consequences and victims suffer

    • @SanjuktaSahoo-cm6uh
      @SanjuktaSahoo-cm6uh 2 місяці тому

      Dictatorship isn't good look at lives of chinese people, or russian people I'll gladly take a bit less rate of growth over a Dictatorship that has multiple times of growth.​@abba747

    • @vkwagh2738
      @vkwagh2738 2 місяці тому +26

      It's not about democracy it's corruption and visionless leaders who are failing india. We thought the bjp govt would fight against corrupt peoples but instead of that they welcomed most of the corrupt in their party.

  • @ta.bespoke
    @ta.bespoke Місяць тому +9

    Shift focus from Hindu-muslim to development and everything else will fix itself with more time to focus on the actual issues.

  • @vickydash13
    @vickydash13 2 місяці тому +26

    Even the defense projects like border roads which is very crucial is delayed due to environmental clearance 😢.

  • @भारतीय-1947
    @भारतीय-1947 2 місяці тому +37

    *"That's why I love watching your videos on important case studies! 🙌 While some focus on criticizing 'Make in India' just to undermine Modi, you bring constructive insights with solutions. Truly admirable - thank you for this eye-opening case study! 👏🇮🇳"*

  • @manekimmigrationservices
    @manekimmigrationservices 2 місяці тому +2

    The most important part to achieve success is " Implementation". We all know how lot of things are said and put on papers including schemes, laws, regulations, etc but the ground reality is there is no proper implementation of anything that is said. It only stays on paper for ages. Hence one cannot find any difference despite new promised made year after year irrespective of any government that comes to the power

  • @srikarpendem2762
    @srikarpendem2762 2 місяці тому +11

    We need a video on how India can improve the ease of doing business 🙏

  • @siddhantoswal6183
    @siddhantoswal6183 2 місяці тому +17

    The high imports are because of purchasing raw materials from other countries. We have started manufacturing a few good products in India, but all the raw material is still sourced from other countries. We need better supply chain of raw material and basic parts that make up the whole product step by step.

  • @Truth_seeker-bl5mi
    @Truth_seeker-bl5mi 21 день тому +2

    I went to vietnam recently and i am amazed by the development happening... Lot of construction, infrastructure is now comparable to some western countries and there are lots of manufacturing. The thing i found interesting is the general awareness of environment and cleanliness among even the poor section of society.... No one spits on the street or throws trash on the ground...there are even ciggarette dumpsters provided around every nook and corner of the streets....what is modi doing.....nothing....lot of electronics are manufactured by thailand and vietnam now....

  • @yashwanthachugatla1071
    @yashwanthachugatla1071 2 місяці тому +9

    Deprecation of rupee can't be explained any simpler. Kudos to you Ganesh. Happy married life BTW🎉

  • @Gitabhakta78
    @Gitabhakta78 2 місяці тому +8

    The elephant in the room is Geopolitics without denying the listed problems. Also the unsaid thing is Internal politics.

  • @akasiakasya6351
    @akasiakasya6351 20 днів тому +1

    We are from small countries we want India to succeed, if India become a formidable contender in the economy, India can be a check and balance factor for China and US. Keep it up

  • @ankitwakode426
    @ankitwakode426 2 місяці тому +28

    Indian Government should focus on the export quality agricultural products also.
    They need to take initiative like organic products from Sikkim and try to make them as a global brand so that rural infrastructure and economy become stronger.
    It will take take no land acquisition, no environmental clearances(because it is own by farmers and organic) for manufacturing or export industry that means these two hurdles for our Indian economy will not face more stress. ❤️🇮🇳
    Requesting @Think School to make a video on the situation of Indian Agricultural infrastructure. 🌅🌄

  • @theredbaron28
    @theredbaron28 2 місяці тому +15

    Ganesh is giving out all the points, I've been shouting at the top of my voice since many years now. Thanks for providing the information

  • @abrahamkurien543
    @abrahamkurien543 Місяць тому +4

    I have got full clearance in Tamilnadu within 24 months
    1) 50% of the problem is corruption.During my 24 months I met only one official who did not take ₹ and cleared the proposal in about 2 months
    2) Even to buy a house building plot is scary because even after 40 years somebody will file a case that his grandfather had three children and not two as per records . You could loose the land bought with hard earned.
    3) Layouts . The layouts are preparing with narrow minded interests because of corruption and then when you want to start a project you will find a road through the middle of your property.
    5) Forethought. Bangalore is planning a peripheral road . In my opinion opinion it should have been a 4 lane road both ways with two lanes services roads on both side . They are planning about 50% requirements. The result, before the road is completed they will start widening and damaged the new Peripheral road.
    Bangalore to Chennai road is an example
    I can go on just given a few examples.

    • @nmo3148
      @nmo3148 Місяць тому

      is 24 months something good?

  • @FawnTheCreator
    @FawnTheCreator 2 місяці тому +16

    Reform. Reform. Reform.
    We badly need reforms in many sectors.

    • @ekta_mundhra
      @ekta_mundhra 2 місяці тому

      Especially in education sector

    • @vamsivikasbuddha123
      @vamsivikasbuddha123 2 місяці тому +2

      2 party sytem will become great reform
      because no stability of govt
      regular elections
      constitutional reforms want2/3rd states support

    • @BarlasF
      @BarlasF Місяць тому

      @@vamsivikasbuddha123 There is no two-party system in any country. Limiting the number of parties is completely anti-democratic.

    • @vamsivikasbuddha123
      @vamsivikasbuddha123 20 днів тому

      @@BarlasF means america is not democratic country
      majority countries are two party system

    • @vamsivikasbuddha123
      @vamsivikasbuddha123 20 днів тому

      @@BarlasF what is democratic?

  • @latvialava6644
    @latvialava6644 2 місяці тому +39

    Land acquisition in India is So annoying that i really admire Communists approach in this.

    • @nightfurygame-hub4619
      @nightfurygame-hub4619 2 місяці тому +5

      But that's not at all a right thing at all. The land of the country belong to the people and not the govt. The issue cannot be solved by this method

    • @simray7602
      @simray7602 2 місяці тому

      少看假新闻了,中国钉子户比其他国家严重多了。什么都归结为共产主义,真是好笑

    • @chutingsoon
      @chutingsoon Місяць тому +1

      @latvialava6644 Exactly! That's one of the nightmares of many foreign investors in India.
      Classic and internationally known example is the length of time taken to complete any stretch of high speed railway track in India.
      To be honest, China do have land acquisition problems, but it's never a norm, it only happens in exceptionally low frequency.

    • @ruarika3112
      @ruarika3112 Місяць тому +1

      The difference is China also have it, but they know how to tackle it. For example: if people don't want to sell their land in China, they go around it and build it to the places where it is allowed.
      In India though, its like, we have to acquire everything in order to build something. That makes the prices go up and the land owners know that. They want to take as much as they can from the buyers.

    • @latvialava6644
      @latvialava6644 Місяць тому +1

      @@nightfurygame-hub4619 But, does this justify one individual's greed over the welfare of all others. 1 aspect of hard-core Socialism which I like is it focuses on the Combined welfare of society rather than Democracy protecting just an Individual's rights !!! Both are Right but, must be applied accordingly

  • @sangeethavinoth2989
    @sangeethavinoth2989 2 місяці тому +10

    Education system should be changed where kids should be taught and exposed to think about becoming entrepreneurs rather working for other countries. Such reform is needed to brought in young minds.

    • @vamsivikasbuddha123
      @vamsivikasbuddha123 2 місяці тому

      changing dragually it will take shape
      these are problems of high influance of communism
      more political parties
      federal system
      land banks
      etc..
      political stabilty will must

  • @frororf5357
    @frororf5357 2 місяці тому +116

    Your Thumbnail / banner pic is making you appear as a Supari UA-camr..
    Kindly refrain from such cheap tactics as you know building a brand takes time but it doesn't take time to demolish it.. You are yourself doing such blunder which is surprising..
    Don't do such things.. You're better than this

    • @Sudeep.J.B
      @Sudeep.J.B 2 місяці тому +11

      U are Right, This Channel Have Credibility & Accountability lot more than Other cheep channels, These type Tumbnail Doesn't Suit......📢

    • @ganit88
      @ganit88 2 місяці тому +2

      Bro watching you from the day when u used sit in a small chair and simple formal look and no mic and big tec around u. Now that ur growing big ur leaning towards left. Had good thoughts for u. Instead off pushing the government or highlighting the weak area. Ur pulling the whole dream of MAKE IN INDIA

    • @samsonsandeep1095
      @samsonsandeep1095 2 місяці тому +4

      @@ganit88 Atleast he is questioning and feed back to the current govt, stop being confirmable in blaming the opposition ...it over 10 years now.. time to give feed back if you love the country

    • @VarDaaaan
      @VarDaaaan 2 місяці тому +1

      ​@@samsonsandeep1095 adjust karna hi to sikhe h hum log "ATLEAST" is made for us indians only 🙃

    • @samsonsandeep1095
      @samsonsandeep1095 2 місяці тому

      @@JJ-hi4gh Let it ne its ok, Do you see the Arrogance of Nirmala Sitaraman.. She is becoming worse. You cannot take pride anymore by Defeating the opposition, you should also some work., Dollar rate, petrol Price are big concerns

  • @USDINRWALLAH
    @USDINRWALLAH 2 місяці тому +15

    Our foreign client come to India and when they see poor traffic, pollution lack of civil sense they said terrific how can someone will live here. Our Image in global are badly affected due to these factors. Forgot huge FDI, untill we improve ourselves. We are losing to east asian countries, that's sad reality

  • @savankothadiya9528
    @savankothadiya9528 9 днів тому

    I generally do not comment on UA-cam or infact any social media but would really appreciate and bow down to all the efforts in making such a content not only in this video but all the videos you and your team has uploaded till date. 🙌🙌🙌

  • @Laxmanca
    @Laxmanca 2 місяці тому +98

    make in India become blessing in one sector and just boost it Guess which one?
    INDIAN DEFENCE EXPORTS
    increased 31 times over the last decade, from ₹4,312 crore ($500 million) in 2004-05 to 2013-14 to ₹88,319 crore ($11 billion) in 2014-15 to 2023-24,
    Reflecting the global acceptability of Indian defence products and technologies.
    [technology imported from france,Russia help us lot,
    special thanks to (DRDO) focusing on make in INDIA and continue doing manufacturing,assembling and promoting private sector]
    We today itself achieve a great deal with SPAIN for manufacturing of C-295 aircraft in our NATION : )

    • @honeybeee23
      @honeybeee23 2 місяці тому +17

      Bro it also became success in electronics sector we are 2nd largest exporter of electronics 😊

    • @Laxmanca
      @Laxmanca 2 місяці тому +2

      @@honeybeee23 yes bro.

    • @Liboch
      @Liboch 2 місяці тому +5

      Actually India imports more electronic than export.

    • @anonymousdoctor8369
      @anonymousdoctor8369 2 місяці тому +4

      Now we are in top 5 manufacturing nation which is increasing every year,decade ago we r not even in top 20 so it is working i can say

    • @anonymousdoctor8369
      @anonymousdoctor8369 2 місяці тому +2

      @@Liboch yes bcz we dont focus on this sector before 2021 now we r increasing our export in electronics also

  • @vasusingh2475
    @vasusingh2475 2 місяці тому +15

    1) Land Reforms
    2) Structural reforms of bureaucracy(reduce powers of bureaucracy, they have too much power.)
    3) Ease in labor laws

  • @mohanloke5132
    @mohanloke5132 18 днів тому +2

    The biggest hurdle in to business is Govt permissions, corruption and lack of infrastructure. Even the IT service he is mentioning is dependent of foreign countries. The biggest thing to change is common man/ woman mind set. Typically there is no honor system in India. People won’t stick to their word, time management is loose and people are mostly laid back. The fundamentally things need to change from the bottom up.

  • @jayminpatel4267
    @jayminpatel4267 2 місяці тому +288

    Rome didn't built in 10 years, so its early to say Make in India failed

    • @magicsaint
      @magicsaint 2 місяці тому +56

      You are comparing something in 700 BC to today with so many technological advances to grow at record speeds?

    • @tejalakshman9912
      @tejalakshman9912 2 місяці тому +13

      Agree..we only need to look if we are going in the right direction..things go very slow in a democracy

    • @Priyaykanth2
      @Priyaykanth2 2 місяці тому +4

      ​@@tejalakshman9912 + Diversity

    • @Robin-to4ev
      @Robin-to4ev 2 місяці тому +19

      Sorry to break to you but we are not in 700 BC

    • @tejalakshman9912
      @tejalakshman9912 2 місяці тому +10

      @@Robin-to4ev sorry to break to you as well that we are not building Rome ;)..also "Rome isn't built in 10 years" is more like a proverb..and building something is a forever process until it breaks. "It took me 5 years to build my career" does not mean that person stopped learning and stuck in his/her current role.

  • @pcaso
    @pcaso 2 місяці тому +13

    Everyone is busy training for IAS and one who qualifies are busy blocking work

  • @kampoengbatoe2699
    @kampoengbatoe2699 28 днів тому +7

    Make-in-India .... is the biggest joke of the century 🤣🤣🤣

  • @gatherkeshav
    @gatherkeshav 2 місяці тому +6

    "Thank you for your efforts in producing this episode. Could you please share a detailed video on ways to improve the ease of doing business in India?"

  • @unknown.m.e
    @unknown.m.e 2 місяці тому +28

    It's not Govt fault if the people in India who makes the problem
    Mainly Govt employees and people who don't want to sell their land for developement

    • @sabari1102
      @sabari1102 2 місяці тому

      Better give your land and home after paying huge & loans, current govt. can setup some office for development purpose. Until it comes to their own butt anyone can speak anything. Whether the people receive better alternative places in better location to shift for their loss? Definitely no. That's why it is failing.

    • @unknown.m.e
      @unknown.m.e 2 місяці тому +2

      @@sabari1102 most of the time Govt don't ask for lands where homes are build until city road expansion
      Most of the central projects done in Greenfield roads and projects

  • @gfan003
    @gfan003 2 місяці тому +2

    Remember Recent Samsung factory strike in India, the workers Union wanted their work position to become their inheritance to be passed down family members!?

    • @praveenkrishnamoorthy6528
      @praveenkrishnamoorthy6528 Місяць тому

      Wrong. Don't blabber non sense. They asked to form a worker's union which is guarenteed by Indian law. The state machinery harassed workers. At last they were allowed to form a union. They didn't ask for other things. Read news kid.

  • @anishag9129
    @anishag9129 2 місяці тому +7

    Really good channel. Aside from the lack of comedy, think school is as close as it gets to Emmy winning show last week tonight with John Oliver.

  • @arjunssingh6055
    @arjunssingh6055 2 місяці тому +9

    The root cause of all these problems is sedentary behavior that is embedded in each and every Indian, right from the day they are born. The lack of discipline and the lack of fear of punishment is the reason, that when people grow and things have to be done by themselves they majorly try to postpone those things. Until this happens in government departments it affects the willingness of business owners and entrepreneurs. For setting up a mobile case-selling business, I had to spend around a month for just arranging documents, INDIA CAN NEVER IMPROVE UNTIL THE LEADERS DONT

  • @SonuKumar-fn1gn
    @SonuKumar-fn1gn 2 місяці тому +6

    Assembled in India ✅
    Made in India ❌

    • @Pseudoslayer
      @Pseudoslayer 7 днів тому +1

      Only adani empire Growing 🤷‍♂️🤷‍♂️

    • @SonuKumar-fn1gn
      @SonuKumar-fn1gn 7 днів тому

      @Pseudoslayer i born in Worst country

  • @DuckDuckgo047
    @DuckDuckgo047 2 місяці тому +31

    And the reason for FDI decline is India doesn't accept FDI from china, if allowed it would eat up all other things in India and also india cancelled 80% of its FTA which are signed during congress era and hurting India more than helping India. Sometimes i feel, think schools content is under researched when it comes to topics which involves deep understanding of geopolitics.

    • @honeybeee23
      @honeybeee23 2 місяці тому

      Yaa tesla isn't invited in india cause they were selling cars that were manufactured in China and at that time we were facing border issues and the govt. Now reduced taxes on import foreign vehicle if they invest 500 million

    • @siddharthreddy2167
      @siddharthreddy2167 2 місяці тому +9

      I agree..... Economic policies should augment geo-politics understanding . If we take FDIs without scrutiny that will again make us to dependency rather than self reliance. I feel today's entrepreneur should understand geo politics and long term impacts also before making decisions.

    • @peacelover2008
      @peacelover2008 2 місяці тому +4

      before you make fun of said think schools didn't make a good research, you should did a good research first. you said the decline of FDI, because of China, that is totally nonsense, China already realized invest in India will got noting back, because of the Indian punishment for no reason. there will be less and less Chinese company like to invest in Indian no matter Indian government allowed or not. the decline of FDI is actually from other countries. and the big percentage of it you know from which countries ? from Singapore, not from U.S. or EU. Those west countries also move their money away from Indian, because they got the same no reason punishment like Chinese companies.

    • @honeybeee23
      @honeybeee23 2 місяці тому +2

      @@peacelover2008 indian government punishment for no reason. Mf our 20 men died on border that shows how much you actually did

    • @Liboch
      @Liboch 2 місяці тому

      The problem why so many foreign companies pulling out from India is due to arbitrary imposition of taxes. Either you pay me or I impose these taxes arbitrarily on you. Corruption. Or better be called legal robbery.

  • @kingKabali
    @kingKabali 2 місяці тому +6

    I think it was better to not provide tax break to Tesla for import cars, as it would have negative impacted the local EV manufactures who are testing the market and investing continuously.

  • @mrpixelatedgod
    @mrpixelatedgod 2 місяці тому +1

    I think you should dive deep into some topics like land acquisition and environmental clearance. They might look problematic from purely financial perspective, but in long term eco system perspective they're not. It's good that such problems exists. We can't just ignore it to solve one issue and create several others.

  • @RavinderSingh-po2fp
    @RavinderSingh-po2fp 2 місяці тому +9

    Make case studies on state economics. Like which state is doing better and what are the learnings other state government can take. I would like see video on Rajasthan.

  • @latvialava6644
    @latvialava6644 2 місяці тому +43

    But, Some of our People are blindly Supporting Wangchuk jii without knowing the gravity & Depth of the situation.

    • @SDFNI3894YR
      @SDFNI3894YR 2 місяці тому +1

      what is wangchuk? that ladakh guy?

    • @ParthNautiyal-q8v
      @ParthNautiyal-q8v 2 місяці тому

      @@SDFNI3894YR yea that ladakh guy who want to save ladakh glaciers from mining (while china has milked out whole valley)

    • @MultiJennyrocks
      @MultiJennyrocks 2 місяці тому

      Thats their home

    • @b228d0
      @b228d0 2 місяці тому

      @ThinkSchool look at your subscriber base now. Is this the kind of following you sold yourself to?

    • @latvialava6644
      @latvialava6644 2 місяці тому +2

      @@ParthNautiyal-q8v Which mining??? U mean Digging out tunnels?? If he's against any particular project damaging the environment then, he can't directly go to the supreme Court. From, this logic the Mumbai Coastal road possessed Potential Threat for sea corals & Aquatic life. Does that mean mumbaikar starts protesting for Autonomy?? Or Uttrakhand also does so against All weather roads. To my knowledge the Extreme mining till now has been done For Infrastructure projects only. N moreover GOI is Constructing a small Geo thermal Plant there. He's asking for Political Autonomy like the one Tribal States in NE have. Do, you know without the Local government permission we can't even visit such places. Moreover, implementing any Central scheme also becomes difficult. Environmental concern?? Why not, emphasizing on getting a law or Policy regarding it?? It's already a Sensitive zone without the permission of the army & GOI u can't open anything there.

  • @swapnilnagtilak1861
    @swapnilnagtilak1861 2 місяці тому +2

    "Politics is the art of looking for trouble; finding it everywhere, diagnosing it wrongly, and deliberately applying unsuitable remedies"

    • @stevenlai1199
      @stevenlai1199 Місяць тому

      Apply burnol

    • @swapnilnagtilak1861
      @swapnilnagtilak1861 Місяць тому

      @@stevenlai1199 Looks like you’re the brand ambassador for it - always ready to use, huh?

  • @kzmOP
    @kzmOP 2 місяці тому +41

    Why people look for government jobs!!!! Untill this baby culture is not stopped nothing gonna change!

    • @KavyaSoni-ew9il
      @KavyaSoni-ew9il 2 місяці тому +10

      Again due to the poor manufacturing sector. Unemployment and exploitation in private jobs.

    • @priiiithvii
      @priiiithvii 2 місяці тому +7

      ​@KavyaSoni-ew9il so you want muft ki roti From tax payers money?

    • @sorryi6685
      @sorryi6685 2 місяці тому +2

      Have you seen exploitation in service sector

    • @KavyaSoni-ew9il
      @KavyaSoni-ew9il 2 місяці тому +2

      @@priiiithvii when I told that I want muft ki roti. I said that private sector jobs are the worst they treat as slaves, so that is why people want govt jobs even in low position.

    • @ParthNautiyal-q8v
      @ParthNautiyal-q8v 2 місяці тому

      @@priiiithvii Who doesn't want? In spotlight everyone pretends to be very polite and patriot while behind the curtains everyone wants to get easy bread
      Everybody(almost) in India is selfish unlike other asian countries

  • @shubhamrawat-sj8bo
    @shubhamrawat-sj8bo 2 місяці тому +8

    If possible pls include ans of these questions on your next videos:
    1. How can a education system of INDIA can be improved? I personally think lack of political literacy is one of the biggest reason of this. People needs to start asking questions to their state gov about local infra, education etc.
    2. Pls make a video about how this franchise model in higher education is hurting INDIA.
    3. Don't you think It should be state's responsibility to upskill their youth, get those land accusation and environment clearance. what incentives gov can give to state so that they start working on education, infra and other things.
    4. Do you think lack of efficient judiciary plays an important role in delays of projects becos it many cases court takes years in giving judgements and by the time of judgement cost of construction goes up 2 to 3 times.
    5. How can we create a judiciary system which gives justice in time. Specially considering our back log and pure size.
    6. How important is labor reforms for INDIA's growth?
    7. How Reservation/lack of meritocracy affects our bureaucracy?
    8. What Positive steps gov has taken (if any) to solve all these problems that you have mentioned and how can they improve their efforts?
    9. What is the reason behind delays in land accusation and environment clearance?. It looks like gov is doing a lot to solve other problems that you have mentioned like Lack of infra, lack of skill labor, red tape culture. Things might not be moving as fast as we have loved but at least there is a constant positive growth but Land accusation and environment clearance seems to be the constant and still mostly unresolved problem for the gov. How can they solve it?
    10. How important is farming reforms for INDIA's growth?

    • @vamsivikasbuddha123
      @vamsivikasbuddha123 2 місяці тому

      no 2 party sytem will decrease so many problems

    • @amitpanday6189
      @amitpanday6189 2 місяці тому

      If these points addressed and improved india will become best nation to live on earth

    • @AshokKumar-lc2gh
      @AshokKumar-lc2gh Місяць тому

      If a Farmer sold his Land for Capitalists for Cheap rate what he will do for Essential Needs

  • @nithishshet1163
    @nithishshet1163 2 місяці тому +3

    Please make a video on ease of doing business and especially emphasizing on startups.

  • @subhrashisnanda3054
    @subhrashisnanda3054 2 місяці тому +15

    You need to learn to crawl before you can walk and learn to walk before you can run. China started manufacturing at large scale in 1979 we started in 2014. You can't compete with a decade experience with someone who has half a century's experience. We need to support the make in india initiative and irrespective of our standing in the political spectrum should support the good work of the government. If we keep working at this rate and continue with course correction in 20 years we will be the manufacturing hub of the world. Jai Hind

  • @AmanKumar-yj5od
    @AmanKumar-yj5od 2 місяці тому +31

    here is the solution for land acquisition in india
    - central government should buy and acquire land in every district in advance for potential business to a such extent that even a steel plant can be setup in every states district
    - by doing this there will be no motive for political ,enviromental concerns at a specific time when a potential corporate buyer wants to buy a land because these issues would have already been resolved .
    - this a great task but without this in disorganized easily radicalised indian democracy nothing will gonna work in efficient manner.

  • @muhammad-bin-american
    @muhammad-bin-american День тому

    Great analysis. Love following Indian politics as an outsider.

  • @maheshrajareddy2848
    @maheshrajareddy2848 2 місяці тому +14

    Ganesh: I'm a subscriber and follow all your videos. Your Thumbnails & Banner nowadays gives a negative vibe though the content is positive. I feel it is done to catch attention of the viewer, please refrain from such cheap tactics.
    Make in India is a great initiative and today we have enormous national pride. Please don't become like Rahul Gandhi, a national waste.

  • @Undefined-Shade
    @Undefined-Shade 2 місяці тому +9

    The thing is - big things take time.. and since, we humans aren't patient.. we tend to change government fast like swapping cards.
    That does more damage than good in long term. Even small changes in economy lead to great accumulated changes in long term.

  • @ituhin
    @ituhin 20 днів тому

    Excellent commentary. The whole region can learn something from your analysis.

  • @vivekbr8015
    @vivekbr8015 2 місяці тому +7

    Make in India is not failing but some people could not digest and their thinking power fail that's it

    • @darshlimbasia2253
      @darshlimbasia2253 2 місяці тому +1

      Ya it's just shaping to better and needs to resolve many issues to shape it into the best
      But people here are economists and want us to self reliant in just 10 years while previous govt. Have done nothing regarding thos

    • @therealpatriot919
      @therealpatriot919 26 днів тому

      😂😂😂

    • @GauravThakur-f3r
      @GauravThakur-f3r День тому +1

      It's failing we can't even manufacture a simple homemade gun for our military.

    • @vivekbr8015
      @vivekbr8015 День тому

      @@GauravThakur-f3r Patience Bro Patience .... You were silent watching congress corruption for 75 years ...let us give some time for this BJP government who are just taking baby step

  • @Meta-qe7tv
    @Meta-qe7tv 2 місяці тому +8

    So just mainly because of environment concern and land related matters most of projects are delayed or closed.
    Ngo are major factor in environment concern which spread propoganda falsely influenced by foreign money and power 😔.

  • @DreamFanclub2.0
    @DreamFanclub2.0 5 днів тому

    Indian government should hire the guys these to ensure and solve these types of problems very sir and very appreciated for your hardworking 😁

  • @siddxk
    @siddxk 2 місяці тому +5

    I think not only the Govt. the people also should think about developing India by keeping their surrounding clean, having empathy about other people, doing moral duties, paying taxes regularly, not giving votes for notes or different perks etc. because remember all the Govt. employees from a pion to a Ministers are the reflection of the society.

  • @VickyYadav-qj6kv
    @VickyYadav-qj6kv 2 місяці тому +5

    It's not easy sir first we need ecosystem, supply chain, constant flow of critical mineral....it take's time but we moving toward right direction...little twiking is need.
    We focus not just hig tech low tech manufacturing also create more jobs like apparels, toy manufacturing.
    But some people think sab kam 10 sal ma hojagaya Jo 70years ke vision less Socialist governments ke policies ko change is real problem.

    • @darshlimbasia2253
      @darshlimbasia2253 2 місяці тому

      Ya it's just shaping to better and needs to resolve many issues to shape it into the best
      But people here are economists and want us to self reliant in just 10 years while previous govt. Have done nothing regarding thos

  • @hardik_kishnani
    @hardik_kishnani 2 місяці тому +2

    Please make a video on How India can improve the Ease of Doing Business…

  • @rutujd3270
    @rutujd3270 2 місяці тому +7

    Actual video starts at 9:23 , this is why I stopped watching

  • @pranavsinghal129
    @pranavsinghal129 2 місяці тому +10

    11:24 how is it easier to scale manufacturing than services? Infact, it’s completely opposite, right?

    • @himanshusinghal242
      @himanshusinghal242 2 місяці тому +1

      It's is easier as long as you use AWS or purchase them nvidia or intel.

  • @allaboutlearning8976
    @allaboutlearning8976 2 місяці тому +1

    The example of posco is so true which opposition is also involved in such a terrible failure of the govt..

  • @ujjwalgowda4781
    @ujjwalgowda4781 2 місяці тому +7

    More productive information expected

  • @subramanyamraju9738
    @subramanyamraju9738 2 місяці тому +7

    Administartion from gross root level has to change

    • @Randomuser866
      @Randomuser866 2 місяці тому

      True,no other proper reason than this at all.

  • @rishidas1641
    @rishidas1641 Місяць тому +1

    I just pray that some Indian govt official or minister or IAS sees this and address the issues!! Its's clear that India has a lot of potential but the problem is we are slow with negotiating our problems!!! And pls make a video on that land acquisition policy.

  • @AvijeetRanawat
    @AvijeetRanawat 2 місяці тому +4

    I suggest a solution to Land Accusation Problem.
    1. Create a Database of all the private owned lands in India. [To speed this up, create a Rule that you have to declare your owned land in a portal till 31st March next year, and if not done the land by default belongs to Government.]
    2. Also add bank accounts of individuals who own these lands. [Important for acquiring lands by depositing amounts directly]
    3. Utilize AI to create an algorithm which would for certain give the best estimates of a piece of land. [This is a already solved problem would require some training data for different regions]
    4. Government should build housing colonies within each city where people who would be displaced would be given free accommodation for 3 months till they figure out their new stays. [initial help by agencies to setup them up]
    5. Automate a digital process which handles everything [deciding which land to acquire, its cost, amount transfer to owner of land, temporary relocation and reestablishment help]
    6. This is for residential land accusation, for farm lands this should be lot easier [trade in of similar land in different location, or monetary compensation]
    Any other points that I have overlooked, or any other solutions, please let me know.
    Do you think this will work?

  • @Alfred-Bobby
    @Alfred-Bobby 2 місяці тому +5

    Happy married life bro🎉❤

  • @bharatc.sampat6406
    @bharatc.sampat6406 3 дні тому

    Good reporting. Will never happen with taxation policy. Never. No buying power and no change in basic innovation thought processes. Maximize and modernize existing capacity

  • @sujaynis3905
    @sujaynis3905 2 місяці тому +14

    I have a feeling that "make in India" will succeed because people like Sanjeev Sanyal are in power.

  • @deepakberry3235
    @deepakberry3235 2 місяці тому +5

    Hi
    Have you considered the Eastern and Western DFC, the Expressways constructed as well as under construction?
    I remember that the time it used to take for our luggage to move on transfer 15 years back has been halved now. Agree there is more that is needed but a lot has happened as well.

  • @sc-to4uf
    @sc-to4uf 17 днів тому +2

    *India will forever remain a country of the future! Which future? The forever future!*

  • @jiteshchouhan7266
    @jiteshchouhan7266 2 місяці тому +14

    22:17 so deforestation and killing wildlife is not a issue for you ?

    • @souvikraj1795
      @souvikraj1795 2 місяці тому

      I was also going to ask the same question.

    • @shivangisemwal-o3h
      @shivangisemwal-o3h 2 місяці тому +7

      Ya that's a problem to but with these delays the deforestation and killing wild life will still occur but it will cost more
      The point is that if something needs to be done it should be done on time these delays don't help anyone

    • @jiteshchouhan7266
      @jiteshchouhan7266 2 місяці тому +1

      @@shivangisemwal-o3h wow with this mentality only humans will left on earth
      Development will happen but at what cost

    • @souvikmukherjee5353
      @souvikmukherjee5353 2 місяці тому +5

      We're not usa or europe, we cannot afford our needs let alone deforestation, so I care less about deforestation, we need to catch up with the world, so we have to have cruel hands unfortunately

    • @Thehero-d5k
      @Thehero-d5k 2 місяці тому

      ​@@souvikmukherjee5353you need clean air to breath
      Health care will cost you more if deforestation happens at large scale

  • @rishitjasani3146
    @rishitjasani3146 2 місяці тому +8

    13:56 are you sure bro about what you just said 😬

    • @sunnyrawat6138
      @sunnyrawat6138 2 місяці тому +2

      Decrease taxes and increase investments bhai mtlb decrease taxes on foreign investments.... middle class corporates pr to tax 2x krke hi chodege ye loog🙂🙃

  • @arunagarwal9452
    @arunagarwal9452 Місяць тому +1

    The statement that manufacturing industry is easily scalable and service industry is not a blatant lie. Manufacturing industry is actually very difficult to scale .

  • @SameehSamad
    @SameehSamad 2 місяці тому +9

    15 bridges collapsed in a month no jobs increased communal hatred imbalance in economy increased tax rate only and everything for Adani &Ambani noting for common people just making people fight each other so noone talks about failure of gov policy

    • @sunnyyadav375
      @sunnyyadav375 2 місяці тому +4

      Under which era those bridges were made??😅 Laalu . Madrsa chhaap. Read something

    • @otpmohan8402
      @otpmohan8402 2 місяці тому

      People love fascinating words and speeches of politicians. People fascinated with quantity of bridges and statues if there is no employment and income. Who cares quality of bridges or statues? India's people have to change then government and rulers will change. Praise the God and Praise the government is not a solution for people. Whatever implemented schemes for ease to doing business for ruling parties and corporates. Wealth also concentrated for just 1% (0.99% will be Ambani and Adani) out of India’s total population. Crony capitalism is the serious issue.
      In India, agriculture, MSME’s and small entrepreneurs neglected that was why unemployment has been sky rocketed in last 10 years. Tax also another biggest issue for common people and small entrepreneurs.

    • @ParthNautiyal-q8v
      @ParthNautiyal-q8v 2 місяці тому +3

      No jobs increased😂😂😂😂
      I'm a congress supporter
      But even I know that current government has provided more jobs than UPA and Narsimha's tenure combined
      Be honest, we know that our population is at its peak
      The only reason I support congress is because current government is scared of passing population control bill

  • @ITObserver
    @ITObserver 2 місяці тому +5

    1. All new contracts firm overseas have large portion that needs to be made in India.
    2. FDI is at its highest.
    3. Growth is the highest in the world
    4. Infrastructure is at its highest
    5. India’s GDP is the 5th largest currently risen from 10th in just 10-15 yrs.
    6. Silicon chip industry growing
    India is the envy of the world.
    India’s skilled youth is highest in the world.
    Challenges:
    A1
    Global recession
    Geopolitics
    Ease of doing business has improved but still needs more work
    Make in India will follow as bases are moved from China to India. There is a lag time.

  • @rvidyaiyer
    @rvidyaiyer Місяць тому

    Another commendable study of the market & wonderfully presented insights. Nobody puts things down with clear apolitical perspective like you do. Thank you!