The case of the missing fractals - Alex Rosenthal and George Zaidan

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 26 сер 2024
  • View full lesson: ed.ted.com/less...
    A bump on the head, a mysterious femme fatale and a strange encounter on a windswept peak all add up to a heck of a night for Manny Brot, Private Eye. Watch as he tries his hand at saving the dame and getting the cash! Shudder at the mind-bending geometric riddles! Thrill to the stunning solution of The Case of the Missing Fractals.
    Lesson by Alex Rosenthal and George Zaidan, animation by TED-Ed.

КОМЕНТАРІ • 677

  • @jeremyzhou7242
    @jeremyzhou7242 8 років тому +982

    1. Sierpinski's Triangle
    2. Koch Snowflake
    3. Mandelbrot Set
    There. :D

    • @peenut169
      @peenut169 8 років тому +8

      +Jeremy Zhou My friend did a project on Sierpinski's Triangle... He thought it would be interesting. It turned out that the pattern was all there was. I did another project that worked out just fine. Maybe Pascal's Triangle? :P

    • @orthodox1818
      @orthodox1818 8 років тому +1

      HOLY SMOKES I FOUND YOU

    • @peenut169
      @peenut169 8 років тому

      Unless your youtube account name isn't your real name, it's not you... sorry if I confused you!

    • @jeremyzhou7242
      @jeremyzhou7242 8 років тому

      Nicholas Hao hi

    • @jeremyzhou7242
      @jeremyzhou7242 8 років тому

      Eric Ness This account is my real name, but you might be referring to a person with the same name. My name isn't too rare.

  • @rext5438
    @rext5438 7 років тому +682

    The script for this has been well-written. The animation is well-drawn. The story is well-thought of. The ideas and messages are well-presented.
    Well done, TED-Ed!

  • @CharlesVeitch
    @CharlesVeitch 10 років тому +724

    No matter how deeply you look into this video, it's greatness does not diminish

    • @petermarsella6537
      @petermarsella6537 6 років тому +1

      Charles Veitch deep

    • @bingbonghafu
      @bingbonghafu 5 років тому +2

      Are you related to James Veitch

    • @tjdelattre2939
      @tjdelattre2939 4 роки тому

      actually, the deeper you go the more and more this video becomes much much more beautiful

  • @angelalim543
    @angelalim543 8 років тому +366

    I burst out laughing at "...Is it a dodo egg?"

    • @kookinsomejamsclc3428
      @kookinsomejamsclc3428 8 років тому +5

      Lol hi Suga 😂

    • @jellyfish359
      @jellyfish359 8 років тому

      LOL ME TO I FELL OFF MY CHAIR I BLED BUT STILL LAUGHED AND MY DAD WENT IN LIKE"WTF" AND LEFT !!!
      LMAO XDDDDD!!!!!OMG PLEASE HELP ME I NEED A DOCTOR I CAN'T STOP!!!!!XXDDDD

    • @MsSBVideos
      @MsSBVideos 8 років тому

      +Katelyn Think of the worst vegetables you have ever tasted.

    • @FirstLast-fr4hb
      @FirstLast-fr4hb 8 років тому

      That was actually a pretty clever answer.

    • @traffic501
      @traffic501 7 років тому +2

      I think he said that because dodos are extinct.

  • @chloecorning8504
    @chloecorning8504 7 років тому +328

    "Is it an egg?"
    "No! Why would it be an egg?"
    "It's usually an egg."
    Lol.

  • @cosmicatrophy4648
    @cosmicatrophy4648 7 років тому +315

    couldn't you have made this a feature film?! this was awesome

    • @tygonmaster
      @tygonmaster 7 років тому +16

      Quality above quantity. :)

  • @skyletta0626
    @skyletta0626 7 років тому +152

    This was so intense.

  • @kelseymo8823
    @kelseymo8823 8 років тому +381

    Humorous and insightful. Why aren't more people interested this math stuff Ted-ED posts? 2 thumbs up for this vid!

    • @hahahanah9954
      @hahahanah9954 6 років тому +5

      Kelsey Mo the real question is, why dont math teachers teach like this

    • @Ionic_Glace
      @Ionic_Glace 3 роки тому

      @@hahahanah9954 the more thrilling question is, why we never use these riddles in our real life?

  • @Hannah-xl3tl
    @Hannah-xl3tl 9 років тому +605

    the beginning made me jump. turn down the volume.

  • @poisonrune
    @poisonrune 7 років тому +52

    In case you guys didn't notice, but when he released the fractals, his
    world of simple shapes adopted a more fractal look, see the cave wall
    lightning bolt, and clouds looking more 'natural' as they resemble fractals in
    nature! I think that's a nice touch!

  • @higashiwhy
    @higashiwhy Рік тому +7

    I can't believe this video is now 8 years old... I think I watched it 6 years ago for the first time and I was fascinated. Coming back here now and then, this one really is one of the best !

  • @rishi2837
    @rishi2837 5 років тому +14

    I saw what you did there "eyes(i) like imaginary numbers". Good one

  • @charlieinator5887
    @charlieinator5887 8 років тому +11

    "You're a strange little man." "Thank you!" 3:33 Lol

  • @douglaswolfen7820
    @douglaswolfen7820 8 років тому +66

    This is utter genius.
    but you missed a trick. Surely you could have found a way to squeeze in "here's looking at Euclid"?

  • @beestarjay
    @beestarjay 10 років тому +12

    I love that idea it was a lot more creative than just explaining it

  • @ChrisNihilus
    @ChrisNihilus 10 років тому +52

    This was a freaking MASTERPIECE!
    I love Noir, and i love Math. This was awesome!

  • @kenbobca
    @kenbobca 8 років тому +81

    My brain is in a knot! but I like it. Great video.

  • @et496
    @et496 7 років тому +8

    4:00 The dame had played me like a triangle.

  • @aletheadsouza7740
    @aletheadsouza7740 4 роки тому +3

    Ted-Ed PLEASE make more videos like this !!!! I keep rewatching it , I love it so much !!

  • @kaley5413
    @kaley5413 8 років тому +53

    And now you've just crossed into... The Twilight Zone

  • @speedingampalaya
    @speedingampalaya 10 років тому +5

    This is probably my favorite of the TED-Ed animated videos.

  • @keshavk6953
    @keshavk6953 5 років тому +5

    This is the best video that I've seen from Ted Ed.
    The analysis is stupendous.
    Great work,kudos Ted Ed.

  • @khadijahtariq7437
    @khadijahtariq7437 7 років тому +17

    This is the bet Ted-ed Video ever and it must be made into a series.

  • @Bellonging
    @Bellonging 7 років тому +2

    That was intense. I was not expecting that on a video about fractals, but consider me impressed.

  • @ohnree4110
    @ohnree4110 8 років тому +35

    Jesus CHRIST, a little volume control please?

    • @003Jetfire
      @003Jetfire 7 років тому +17

      Sorry m8, finite video length, infinite volume.

  • @Inrade
    @Inrade 10 років тому +10

    Wow...that's a great way to teach about fractals. Cool and sassy

  • @richardyu8723
    @richardyu8723 8 років тому +45

    The first one could also have been a black hole. Also, what was the Rubik's cube fiasco of '58?

    • @saubuithi6034
      @saubuithi6034 7 років тому

      I think you meant the " Event Horizon "

    • @isaiahstrong329
      @isaiahstrong329 7 років тому

      Richard Yu well young champ

    • @richardyu8723
      @richardyu8723 7 років тому

      No, i mean the singularity.

    • @richardyu8723
      @richardyu8723 7 років тому

      It doesn't have any area.

    • @jenl732
      @jenl732 7 років тому

      Right. How do you calculate a whirlpool's area?

  • @lizageorge8923
    @lizageorge8923 3 роки тому +1

    The lightning bolt was a fun touch :)

  • @ShawnRavenfire
    @ShawnRavenfire 9 років тому +55

    Imagine watching this stoned.

    • @jds150k
      @jds150k 9 років тому

      I just watched this Shawn Ravenfire and I can tell you it is harrowingly cool.

    • @daephx
      @daephx 9 років тому

      i did boss

    • @jimmycruz5308
      @jimmycruz5308 9 років тому

      bettr on cid maaan

  • @juwuu
    @juwuu 7 років тому +13

    couldn't the last riddle also been Sierpinski's triangle?

  • @lucasgaming61
    @lucasgaming61 7 місяців тому

    "What can I hold in my hand, but has zero area?"
    "Air."

  • @ananashrabi3728
    @ananashrabi3728 6 років тому +1

    This undoubtedly the best TED-ed video!! Hats off!!

  • @TheLJShow-ys8wr
    @TheLJShow-ys8wr 3 роки тому +1

    This gotta be the best ted ed video.

  • @Lefti4life
    @Lefti4life 10 років тому +4

    That was probably one of the coolest TED-Eds I have ever watched!

  • @RaptorJesus
    @RaptorJesus 10 років тому +2

    Congratulations, you've made a surprisingly good Cosmic Horror Story/Lovecraftian fiction.

  • @dvklaveren
    @dvklaveren 10 років тому +13

    Imagine a world with absolute chaos. And now a world with absolute order. How would you imagine it...?
    I imagine it thus; in a world of absolute chaos, there is no cause, nor effect, but everything is possible. Time has no meaning; it has no dimensions. It is simply a point; a coordinate of only zeros, in which all possibility has been squeezed.
    In a world of absolute order, there is cause and effect, but for there to be a beginning, there must be no end, or beginning, for a beginning and an end must be one another's causes and ends and the only way this can be true is if they are one and the same; void.
    But imagine a world with infinitely long strings of numbers, ever going on, in whichever counting system you adore. In a string infinitely long where no cause nor effects the next, it must be true an infinite string of seeming cause and effect must exist. In a string infinitely long where every number has a cause before, it can be true one must go back infinitely far to find it.
    In an infinite string of events, permutations and causes, both views can be and must be correct. A world can both be seen as though it were infinitely, but not absolutely chaotic, as well as infinitely, but not absolutely orderly.
    One must therefore wonder, what does this mean, in a world which, in an perspective of infinite order, is shocking finite?

  • @sh_tinydynamite
    @sh_tinydynamite 10 років тому +10

    This is so cool! Love the #Mandelbrot ref. Such a dynamic and fun way to introduce infinite iterations in number sets, as well as the boundlessness of the structure of the universe through geometric forms.
    The root of it... #fractals ROCK!!!
    Thanks to TED-Ed for the Sam Spade of learning, Manny Brot! May his character live on.

  • @minitumen
    @minitumen 7 років тому +1

    Ok, this has to be one of the best TedEd episodes.

  • @Farfromhere001
    @Farfromhere001 10 років тому +14

    YOU DID A GREAT JOB WITH THIS! LOVE IT!

  • @willodaise2405
    @willodaise2405 8 років тому +2

    That Maltese Falcon reference at the end

  • @briar9395
    @briar9395 6 років тому

    This might be the coolest Ted-Ed video I've seen yet.

  • @manasichhabra6572
    @manasichhabra6572 7 років тому +2

    this was so unlike a normal Ted-Ed video but I loved it so much! the script, the animation, the sound effects everything is just too good!

  • @getgloss
    @getgloss 8 років тому +26

    i've watched this 6 times and i still don't get it.....urgh... :(

    • @monkeyorful
      @monkeyorful 8 років тому +23

      egg is the solution

    • @SpitnifficusChannel
      @SpitnifficusChannel 8 років тому +7

      +zebratalks here's a simple way of explaining the first riddle. The triangle is slowly having its parts removed in each turn. After a large amount of turns, the triangle will have almost zero area due to the fact that its having its parts removed. So let's say after an infinite amount of turns, the triangle will then have no area. This is also a fractal.

  • @MultiPaulinator
    @MultiPaulinator 10 років тому +2

    Well, to be fair, the last riddle didn't even need a fractal. "r = ln θ" has that quality to such a pure degree that when you continuously zoom in on its center, it just looks like it's spinning.

    • @kurtilein3
      @kurtilein3 10 років тому

      but there only is one point that you can infinitely zoom into and find self-similarity, not an infinite number of such points.

    • @MultiPaulinator
      @MultiPaulinator 10 років тому

      This is true. ;-)

  • @Antiwarsdreamer
    @Antiwarsdreamer 9 років тому +5

    so basically we're trapped in infinity ... like inception

  • @gabogalaiz
    @gabogalaiz 7 років тому +4

    That's some real deep level thing

    • @gabogalaiz
      @gabogalaiz 7 років тому

      Like i understood 1/3 of the video (I blame the fact that i'm not a person who speaks english by birth)

    • @KEL5isGodrules
      @KEL5isGodrules 7 років тому

      gabriel armando galaviz melendez What is you speak by birth? I'm Russian ^.^'

  • @Lou-C
    @Lou-C 7 років тому +1

    What an interesting way of learning how fractals work

  • @TheBluMeeny
    @TheBluMeeny 10 років тому +29

    2:22
    The rubiks cube was invented in 1974. So...impossible to have a fiasco with such toy if it was only 1958.

    • @saikoujikan
      @saikoujikan 10 років тому +82

      I guess that's why it was such a fiasco.

    • @jackityyax4023
      @jackityyax4023 8 років тому

      +TheBluMeeny zomg it's murr!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    • @DLPCADAdelaide
      @DLPCADAdelaide 5 років тому

      from the future ted ed is a fortune teller

    • @albertfullman4264
      @albertfullman4264 4 роки тому

      r/hmmm

  • @manavkala3216
    @manavkala3216 9 років тому +5

    Wow I love it. this is the best ted -ed video ever.

    • @jimmycruz5308
      @jimmycruz5308 9 років тому

      whne ur whole life becomes a fractl....

  • @anuragmalakar356
    @anuragmalakar356 7 років тому +2

    This is a work of art. What a way to explain a concept as intricate as this.
    This deserves an Oscar :P

  • @Littlefa3
    @Littlefa3 10 років тому

    This was the best animation lesson EVER

  • @diffjuns323
    @diffjuns323 7 років тому

    Why can I not stop watching this?

  • @7777TheShade
    @7777TheShade 10 років тому +15

    Ultra triforce

  • @dandan_yt8300
    @dandan_yt8300 11 місяців тому

    "An angle . . . an angle from heaven" WHY WAS THAT SO FUNNY--

  • @RAZIdrizzle
    @RAZIdrizzle 10 років тому +2

    That was beautiful

  • @godwatelsecani
    @godwatelsecani 7 років тому +2

    very, very, very impressive one!!!

  • @ahmedalsherbini276
    @ahmedalsherbini276 8 років тому +1

    This is most interesting and fasciniting video i've seen good job

  • @bigbangtheking
    @bigbangtheking 7 років тому

    One of the best videos I've ever seen !!!.. Thank you ...

  • @ethanlee8307
    @ethanlee8307 4 роки тому

    I've watched this five times over three years and I finally understand this.

    • @ayushchampatiray7768
      @ayushchampatiray7768 4 роки тому

      But if you would have watched this five times in three days, then you could have started to use the knowledge from this video 2 years and 362 days earlier and could have mastered more complex theories related to the knowledge in this video and maybe could have found the key to the 4th dimension and understand the secrets of universe including quantum science and time dilation by which you could have ended with unlimited time and could have gain unlimited knowledge in that unlimited time.
      So basically you just wasted 2 years and 362 days of your life in which you could have ended up with all the knowledge in the universe and ultimately become the almighty. I feel so bad for you.

  • @fraserwhitehead539
    @fraserwhitehead539 7 років тому

    im so happy i found ted ed

  • @IgnacioLesser
    @IgnacioLesser 4 роки тому

    This video is so good I revisit it every now an then

  • @guilhermer.zimermann3896
    @guilhermer.zimermann3896 10 років тому

    this video scared me at the end but first my brain was melting...

  • @Daniel-xt9lm
    @Daniel-xt9lm 6 років тому

    The animation was extraordinary!

  • @aadityaprakashh
    @aadityaprakashh 7 років тому

    best way of explaining ever!

  • @devanshisoni6649
    @devanshisoni6649 4 роки тому +1

    An angle from heaven

  • @ulricaluo2442
    @ulricaluo2442 5 років тому

    This is the best one! Make some more like this!

  • @barbariumTV
    @barbariumTV 10 років тому +1

    This was freaking awesome

  • @dontcallmelil8619
    @dontcallmelil8619 7 років тому +2

    Soo many quotes.
    "Like an overindulging birthday clown"
    "After infinity pinches"
    "Flim-flam, there it was"
    Actually, this entire video is just quote worthy dialog.

  • @sergiopena8121
    @sergiopena8121 5 років тому

    Film noir vibes!
    Absolutely love it!

  • @abrahamhoti8686
    @abrahamhoti8686 7 років тому +14

    An thats how the universe was made...

  • @friendly_hologram9597
    @friendly_hologram9597 4 роки тому

    I like the vertigo reference, nicely done

  • @yyg4632
    @yyg4632 2 місяці тому

    This is a crazy creative way to teach math. My artist's math averse brain loved it.

  • @gregtheoz7919
    @gregtheoz7919 8 років тому +2

    Ahh ... Fractals !! The art of the universe ...
    Can someone tell me what kinda software they used to get the mandelbrot zooming out towards the end .. or was it hand drawn ?? ... if it was .. Hats off !!

  • @raphaeldirrim4432
    @raphaeldirrim4432 Місяць тому

    I'm waiting for the sequel

  • @caesium1102
    @caesium1102 10 років тому

    Triangles= illuminati, Squares= SPONGEBOB LOL

  • @user-of4ym1go4j
    @user-of4ym1go4j 7 років тому

    best ever answers...
    and yes lil confusing ..

  • @wayraa
    @wayraa 7 років тому

    love it!! i'm going to show it to my students!

  • @Maddyy3
    @Maddyy3 7 років тому

    The end was also really scary

  • @novellant
    @novellant 10 років тому +1

    Fractals are terrifying..

  • @Ricvictors
    @Ricvictors 3 роки тому

    Gotta love that Maltese Falcon reference

  • @robstar1a
    @robstar1a 10 років тому

    Clever video. Reminds me of "Mathnet".

  • @ottopike737
    @ottopike737 7 років тому +1

    "you're a strange little man".
    "thank you".

  • @want-diversecontent3887
    @want-diversecontent3887 7 років тому

    "Is it an egg" SJDBUSAHHAHAHSHDHBDHBEIWBHHDYGUGEUHEUWHDUWHSJAHHAHAHAAJEJWUWUQHSHABHAHAHAHSHAHABXHSBCHSBCJWXBJWHBAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHWKNJSHDUEBFHEBFRHVBDHCBDHCBDYVCSUVXAHVSWAUDEYCBEYFBELMAOLOLRJDISJDIWBSIDHDJCBCMSBSKSHDIEHRKRJROFLEKWJEIEHWJSNDKDNDJFJFIDJDHWHAHAHAHAHAHAHAJAHAH

  • @lucasgaming61
    @lucasgaming61 7 місяців тому +1

    Riddle 1 shape: Sierpiński Triangle
    Riddle 2 shape: Koch snowflake
    Riddle 3 shape: Mandelbrot set

  • @battatia
    @battatia 7 років тому

    just gonna say, this was amazing!

  • @eddbaguio96
    @eddbaguio96 7 років тому

    Ahhh..the lightning got me...I almost had a heart attack...

  • @evie2476
    @evie2476 10 років тому

    This was an amazing video!! Thanks Ted Ed!!

  • @thepencilcunts
    @thepencilcunts 7 років тому

    "You're a weird little man"
    " *Thank you* "

  • @nandkishoreagrawal6957
    @nandkishoreagrawal6957 6 років тому

    Excellent introduction to Fractals!

  • @sagellivokin
    @sagellivokin 10 років тому

    This is so cool. Good job TED!

  • @margoedwards6729
    @margoedwards6729 4 роки тому

    thanks for helping out with my homework

  • @thatrandomgamer8258
    @thatrandomgamer8258 5 років тому

    that was... unsettling

  • @shirinshariyarii
    @shirinshariyarii 10 років тому

    Excellent animation!

  • @harsyakiarraathallah2222
    @harsyakiarraathallah2222 7 місяців тому +2

    the Riddler can Learn from this!

  • @JhintendoTwitch
    @JhintendoTwitch 4 роки тому

    Magnificent video

  • @RyanHokie
    @RyanHokie 10 років тому +1

    well done!

  • @ian-dm4te
    @ian-dm4te 7 років тому +41

    Is this illuminati?

    • @misspinkskullcandies
      @misspinkskullcandies 7 років тому

      Ivan Lu there is a ton of Symbolism here, I noticed that as well.. Could be coincidence

    • @blanmorrison1794
      @blanmorrison1794 7 років тому +26

      No, welcome to the land of geometry.

    • @maswiyat_i
      @maswiyat_i 7 років тому

      +Blan Morrison haha, nice.

    • @attacheli9591
      @attacheli9591 6 років тому

      It's the TRYFORCE

    • @lu3ky998
      @lu3ky998 6 років тому

      I knew it

  • @owenl._.l4602
    @owenl._.l4602 7 років тому +1

    thanks for the heart attack in the beginning

  • @hinatasen
    @hinatasen 7 років тому

    I'm pretty surprised I actually understood this video and had a lot of fun, good job here xD

  • @saakethram6040
    @saakethram6040 6 років тому

    Excellent narration