My vote is for Joe! The 1888 King Kelly tipped the scales. I have a different opinion than Mike, who won’t win an authentic altered. In the case of a card that is 136 years old and there are only 70 graded by PSA, the fact that this card exists, and that you own, it is incredible Joe. Plus, the fact that King Kelly was the Babe Ruth of his era. Another point as far as authentic cards, Orlando owns the most beautiful 1952 Topps Mickey Mantle in an authentic and I’m pretty sure everyone would love to own that one. I know I would!
I love these videos. Getting to see some amazing collections that you gentlemen have collated is definitely an experience. All 4 of you have amazing cards, so it is so difficult to pick, but the PeeWee card is gorgeous in my opinion so this week...Joe. Thanks for making great videos that showcase some of the most beautiful cards in the hobby, Mike.
I love the fantastic cards and banter! I was going to vote for Vince, but the last two cards you showed, Mike, put you into my #1 spot for this Smackdown Episode #2! Merry Christmas and Happy Holidays! ❄🎄❄🎄❄
Another great round with some awesome cards. Gotta go with Josh again to win this round. I like the diversity in these 10 again with Baseball, basketball and football cards of some of the all time greats. Next is tough, but I will go with Joe. I love the three 80's rookie cards in PSA 10. Next I'll go with Vince. Four nice Mickey Mantle cards, some other all time great rookie cards. Have to go with Mike to get fourth. Sorry, great cards just not a huge fan of all vintage. I know he will have some heat coming in the next rounds though.
My vote goes to Baseball collector on this one. It was too close to call until Mike brought in home with a psa 7 Mick & a 48 Dimaggio at the end. Another great one fellas!
I think it would be cool to tell the value you have put on each card you guys show, I think it would help the viewer be able to compare just where you guys are at. All Awesome cards, great show !
Authentic altered -- I like that SGC would tell you if it received that due to evidence of trimming. I can live with knowing my card was trimmed. I would not want a card that was altered with color additives. For that reason, I would likely shy away from a PSA authentic altered without a grader note explanation.
"Higher on the list but lower in grade 🤔" haha every good crew needs a good instigator. The Eskimo King Joe gets my vote for this round but could've voted for any of you guys, really great stuff all around! (as to be expected from this crew)
My vote is for Joe!
The 1888 King Kelly tipped the scales.
I have a different opinion than Mike, who won’t win an authentic altered. In the case of a card that is 136 years old and there are only 70 graded by PSA, the fact that this card exists, and that you own, it is incredible Joe. Plus, the fact that King Kelly was the Babe Ruth of his era.
Another point as far as authentic cards, Orlando owns the most beautiful 1952 Topps Mickey Mantle in an authentic and I’m pretty sure everyone would love to own that one. I know I would!
I love these videos. Getting to see some amazing collections that you gentlemen have collated is definitely an experience. All 4 of you have amazing cards, so it is so difficult to pick, but the PeeWee card is gorgeous in my opinion so this week...Joe.
Thanks for making great videos that showcase some of the most beautiful cards in the hobby, Mike.
I love the fantastic cards and banter! I was going to vote for Vince, but the last two cards you showed, Mike, put you into my #1 spot for this Smackdown Episode #2! Merry Christmas and Happy Holidays! ❄🎄❄🎄❄
@@vintagesanctuary Thank you Adam!! I’ll take the vote!!
Some really nice cards, and I enjoyed the banter back & forth.
It is fun to have them on the show! We like to give each other crap.
Awesome again! I'd give this one to Joe just for his 52 Topps Mays flex.
Fair enough but he didn't even show that card!! LOL
Another great round with some awesome cards.
Gotta go with Josh again to win this round. I like the diversity in these 10 again with Baseball, basketball and football cards of some of the all time greats.
Next is tough, but I will go with Joe. I love the three 80's rookie cards in PSA 10.
Next I'll go with Vince. Four nice Mickey Mantle cards, some other all time great rookie cards.
Have to go with Mike to get fourth. Sorry, great cards just not a huge fan of all vintage. I know he will have some heat coming in the next rounds though.
Voting for Vince here because of his sharp vintage, but honorable mention to Mike for that really cool Hack Wilson!
Beautiful cards gentlemen , really like Vinces cards best tonight. Thanks for sharing with us 😊
Good choice Doug. Vince has some incredible stuff.
Awesome countdown, thanks for sharing.
My vote goes to Baseball collector on this one. It was too close to call until Mike brought in home with a psa 7 Mick & a 48 Dimaggio at the end. Another great one fellas!
Thanks for the vote Jeff.
Amazing cards gentlemen!
Joe's PSA 8 Pee Wee Reese was my personal fav!!
We're just getting started. The best is yet to come.
Very nice cards fellas! I enjoyed the friendly banter as well. I like all of them. I’m giving the nod to Mike on this one.
Thanks for the vote buddy!!!
My vote is for Joe. The '53 Bowman Pee Wee Reese clinched it. Love the playful smack talk.
Thanks. Who said it was playful? LOL
I think it would be cool to tell the value you have put on each card you guys show, I think it would help the viewer be able to compare just where you guys are at. All Awesome cards, great show !
Good suggestion Scott. I will try to make sure we do a better job of telling the values.
Authentic altered -- I like that SGC would tell you if it received that due to evidence of trimming. I can live with knowing my card was trimmed. I would not want a card that was altered with color additives. For that reason, I would likely shy away from a PSA authentic altered without a grader note explanation.
"Higher on the list but lower in grade 🤔" haha every good crew needs a good instigator. The Eskimo King Joe gets my vote for this round but could've voted for any of you guys, really great stuff all around! (as to be expected from this crew)
Good choice on Joe. We have a lot more crazy cards to show.
Great cards from everyone. Hard to pick a winner because we all like different players and card types. bTW Hack Wilson had 191 rbi.
Thanks. Appreciate the correction.
fun episode fellas ,I like Josh cards just a bit more .
Great choice Adam.
I’m going with Josh. Vince would have been my pick, but he pulled the Topps Gretzky. I’m Canadian, so you do not have a Gretzky rookie Vince.
LOL. Love it!!
I’d legit vote for Mike!
Thanks Jake.
Awesome cards all around. I’m voting for Vince this time around but it was close.
Good choice!!
Mike won, but I pick Vince again. His shit is just astounding.
Come on Otto!! LOL. You are right though, Vince has an insane collection.
I refuse to vote for Josh simply because he can’t figure out how to show a card where you can actually read the flip.
Good feedback. I’ll see what I can do with the lights in the next video
For the Jeter alone,Joe wins
Lame! LOL Just kidding.
josh wins, wwf plus a world map
@ratedrookie keeps the belt between the Gretzky, Koufax, and 87 Jordan (super hard to find centered).
He has a really nice collection, that is for sure.
A $2700 Griffey card at #40 wow. My 89 Griffey PSA 9 is prob top 25 card of mine lol
There are some pretty epic cards still to come.
Thanks for sharing, fellas! Some REALLY good stuff you have. Please check out my tops sports cards video on my page! ⚾️🔥⭐️
I’ll check it out. Thanks!
Mike you skipped 36 originally and went to Josh for his 35.
Ahhh. Good catch. It is easy to get off track in these videos.