JRR Tolkien - 1965 AUDIO interview by BBC Gueroult - SUBTITLES
Вставка
- Опубліковано 17 бер 2023
- This is just the same copy of the well-known interview, from 1965 BBC by Denys Gueroult.
I include it here finally since I am already putting all of Tolkien's interviews in one spot in this channel.
Subtitle is greatly improved than other online versions.
Gueroult interviewed Tolkien in 1964.11 (short session) and 1965.01 (longer);
BBC produced this longer remix from both sessions.
Short version was first broadcast in 1970.12 (BBC labels it 1964 mistakenly; 1965 is correct.)
- this is the longest of all published Tolkien interviews.
- a very good session; covers a wide variety of topics.
- timestamps are added for each segment.
Credit / Source:
- Tolkien Estate & BBC
---------
- for fan collection purposes; copyright belongs to their owners
- for lore discussion please use Reddit / tolkienfans
00:15 midgard
03:00 names (dwarves)
04:00 names (elven)
04:45 tree
05:00 not symbols
05:25 not symbols lol
05:45 hobbit fondness
06:00 childhood memory
06:45 childhood memory
07:40 Frodo
08:40 against odds
09:20 race
10:20 Elves
10:35 Dwarves
10:47 Men
10:55 Hobbits
11:30 longer life
11:59 love history
12:15 naming system / language
13:45 names
14:30 names start with a name
15:25 language influence
16:35 women in LOTR
17:25 reviewer lol
18:05 from hobbit to LOTR
19:10 dragons
19:30 writing LOTR & The Ring
20:01 Gollum
20:22 grey character & temptation
20:59 Sam and Gollum
22:20 reader feedback
22:45 take control
23:15 writing
24:33 maps
24:42 moons
25:05 started LOTR
25:30 lots typing, error
26:35 languages purpose
28:06 any guilt
28:47 allegory
28:53 world declining
30:03 god in LOTR
30:10 goodness
30:50 gods of men
33:22 high towers
34:11 Atlantis complex
36:08 if were the Vala
37:26 fan mails
37:40 success
38:06 theist
39:02 to be remembered
greatest timestamp comment in history
@@therealmvp1024
I agree !!!
Thank you so much for such precision
When the interviewer said that almost all the characters are portrayed as black or white, he seems to have forgotten Sam's musings in the chapter 'Of Herbs and Stewed Rabbit':
_He wondered what the man's name was and where he had come from; and if he was really evil at heart, or what lies and threats had led him on the long march from his home; and if he would not really rather have stayed there in peace--_
I love how Tolkien just dodges the Tom Bombadil question...
Today is September 2nd, 2023 and marks the 50th anniversary of the Professor's death. J.R.R. Tolkien's legacy endures today and for all time! Cheers to the Professor!
Cheers !
14:36 "you wouldn't much like a chap called 'Ugluk' would you". I love it lmao.
I laughed out loud 😂
I wish he published silmarilion in his lifetime and we had interviews on it aswell. It must be fascinating to hear JRRT talk on elder days
He tried to, but nobody would publish it.
It was that oath that caused all the troubles
@@lnsullivan422 No, he was endlessly tinkering until he died. That's why it was left to his son to hurriedly collate his notes into The Silmarillion... They were eager to publish it.
@@johnnyw525 Well, he did admit in the foreword to LOTR that his friends all felt no-one would ever publish his account on the Elder Days
This is the first time I heard him speak. The man is just brilliant. Talking about the different races and each of their exaggerated human traits. "Well, you've got them on your hands, don't you?" I'm a writer, nothing like this man was, but what an inspiration on world and character building.
I love this, this man, his thoughts and his world. And the interviewer does a better job then modern colleagues.
Far, far better...this is old good BBC school
When he starts dunking on Lewis 😂 I adore both writers and thinks their little squabbles with the others’ work is hilarious
Tolkien's work is just a different level of fiction. The word 'genius' is so abused it's nearly lost it's meaning.... But I've no other word for this man. He was a genius.
what an eloquent man
26:01 - that “I havent noticed any” is so wholesome
What a brilliant man. I haven’t read LOTR but I did read The Hobbit as a child. I’m going to revisit this series and get a good dose of Tolkien.
Thank you!
Thank you very much! Great work! ❤
Excited to see this. This channel is brilliant!
Thank you! I had such a great time hearing this interview. More hidden gems like this! :)
What a great ITW.... and what a great channel !
this interviewever is a major fan of the lore
thank you
Currently readin LOTR TheTwo Towers its so much detail it’s amazing
BRILLIANT !!!
The Ents marching on Isengard is the my favorite scene of fiction in the last 200 years.
9:07
I think Tolkien's theological thesis of good and evil as extrapolated through Christianity runs circles around C. S. Lewis'. It would have been fascinating for Tolkien to have written a book dedicated to his philosophy of Christianity, like Lewis did, I think his conception of ethics might have been quite different. Although he seemed shy and wanted to keep his conceptions to himself, preferring not to challenge or propose his own version of official Catholic dogma and to instead imply it through his art. When people reduce hobbits to being simple traditional Catholics, I think people miss the point of Tolkien's statement that as he says here, the good characters do more damage than the bad ones in the final outcome of the story - simple resistance and sacrifices of desires to temptation don't work out as they ought to. It might even be alluded to that in the end result, the one trait of Christ he says might be ascribed to Frodo, of enduring suffering, and bearing through persecution, may just as accurately, between the lines, be described as a trait of Gollum. Tolkien said Frodo does not embody all of the traits of Christ though, since for Christ it does not matter how much a person has sinner, the goodness of Christ is supposed to redeem the seemingly irredeemable who are in ''too sticky'' as he puts it a situation, a Christ figure in the stickiest situation redeems the sinner with no stickiness, and it would not have been able to alienated Gollum. And precisely that Frodo and Sam alienated Gollum while following what may seem as, the perfect Catholic dogmatic way of life at home, is where the paradox in Tolkien's religious impact his background had upon his books lies. C. S. Lewis, on the other hand, lazily just hands an allegorical Christ in the symbol of a silly talking Lion who has a perfect ethic of selflessness.
It is tragic that with such a good character, the videogame of Gollum could not be more interesting.
In Letters 329, Tolkien also writes "I neither preach nor teach". This sums up a major aspect between himself and CS Lewis.
The rings of power series is a abomination. The professor must be rolling in his grave. They completely lost the geist of his work. They took middle earth and mutated it into something abhorrent. It's a crime against humanity. I don't think I will ever forgive the injustice.
Finally, someone besides myself drew comparison to Dwarves and Jews!
You're not the only one lmao. Its pretty obvious with their semetic language
@@Hero_Of_Oldam I profoundly deaf or did Tolkien (oxford educated linguist) not say their language and naming is based on norse structure and customs,some names even coming from norse books?
He said both basically, some of the names were Norse, but he was really more saying that the traits (not physical traits) of the Dwarves were like the Jews. Likewise language has Semitic traits even though it was also inspired by the Norse.
@@garfieldodie3106 fair enough yeh but I dunno if it's so obvious by "their semetic language". But I dunno my hang up comes from not hearing the phonetic similarities so much
@@tmarritt this explains perfectly why they're portrayed as repulsive and downright unlikable in all of his writing. I never did like the dwarfs...like c'mon wreckin' bilbo's house with merry feasting and song? Enticing him to leave the comfort and safety of his home to seek GOLD??? Sound like anyone??? Classic Dwarf.
How my God , the interviewer is so bullheaded in persisting to extract an answer that he clearly did not hear but wanted. Tolkien is so patient.