As a Palestinian Catholic Christian who lost rights to the land through the Diaspora, it must hurt our Lord’s heart to witness what’s been happening in Israel…I’m praying for our Jewish brothers and sisters, and Muslim brothers & sisters because Jesus came for ALL of us! The truth must be told and I thank you for your courage!
@@historyloveriii2949 They have rejected through ignorance. Both sides are paying the price for that. Jesus is always for peace. Love thy neighbor is his theme
The truth is the land of gaza in part of Canaan land that God promised to Abraham and Israel around 1920 BC. You can read about it in Genesis starting at Chapter 12 verse 7. It's a lot more land than Israel is occupying now and God keeps His promises
I Will pray for You and all the innocent people and the children in particular here in México we are in a silent war the criminals have taken over please also pray for us
I am a Protestant who grew up with this ideology. My mother went to Dallas theological seminary in Dallas for her doctorate and my father was a minister for many years. I am just now (nearly 30 years old) learning more about Protestantism and the Catholic Church. The more I learn, the more I am pulled towards the Catholic Church and it’s teachings. Thank you for this video and for your resources; it’s helping me navigate my faith journey. I learned something new today by watching this video!
@@pgstudio4651They want to destroy the Church. They have planted so many subversives, even in the highest of places. On the other hand, the Church is still networked enough for the righteous to wage a resistance.
I was a Protestant 3 months ago. The Catholic Church is the true and original Church that Jesus left on earth. Read the 1st century Church writings and writings from the martyrs. They were Catholic in theology 🙏🏽
Greek Orthodoxy has monks and prophecy that support it and outline how the war will effect them. I suggest you Google Saint Paisios and other Greek sources.
If you are really christian you know that the end times according to Jesus Christ has no peace because this now the fulfillment of the prophecy of Jesus
Pray that people will believe and have faith to the Lord Jesus Christ because if they don't have faith, believe, and have conscience, this world never have enough peace.
I really really enjoyed listening to this podcast for its theological value and the edifying tone and vibe. I can imagine people disagreeing, but cannot imagine them being offended. Thank-you Dr Marshall!
As a Protestant, up to a week ago i "believed" in Dispensationalism....but something about it didn't sit right in my spirit. Then the Lord led me to this and others explaining the Theology. As a budding theologian this has helped me greatly.
It also helped me also. What an awakening that was, coming from a Pentecostal church. I started researching Darby and Scofield and all those who promoted Dispensation theology.
Go back to your previous views. You were correct. Don’t fall away. Don’t be led astray. That was the devil deceiving you and taking you away from the truth.
@@Revelationstold As Christians we should imitate Jesus( the Prince of Peace) and pray for peace amongst ALL people. Matthew 5:9 Blessed are the peacemakers for they shall be called the children of God.
@@Revelationstoldmaybe prove why her old views are truth instead of demanding it. Demanding it reveals intention and also truth. This is a tactic prots use. Go find the truth and articulate it
Good evening sir, I am a Muslim and while we are theological opponents I commend you for your honesty. The only genuine Catholic position is to be neither for Israel nor Palestine. Many 'conservatives' Novus Ordo Catholics are uncomfortable when we remind them that Pope Pius X opposed Zionism. Also the real American position is America First, not Israel first or Palestine First.
God describes Israelite as kille*s of prophets and righteous persons. Which verse? Matthew chapter 23.33-39 Jesus used the continuous tense to indicate this is their habit.
I am a catholic. I strongly believe in Jesus Christ. But I pray 🙏🏿 to Jesus to give peace and protect the helpless children and innocent civilians who are affected by this horrible tragedy in Palestine 🇵🇸 and Israel. We all are Gods creation. We are all children of God .
Beautiful, yes, we must pray for all the dear innocents. We are all His creation, but truly, by The Word 📖✝️, one is only a Child of God if Baptised in the name of The Father, The Son✝️, & The Holy Ghost 🕊❤️
GREAT video, very helpful. I used to be a Pentacostal/Charismatic/Protestant/Evangelical who believed in dispensationalism and a pre-trib rapture. Now I am a confirmed Catholic and studying the TRUE faith as much as I can, to deprogram myself from all the heterodox doctrine I learned in back then.
I am an evangelical Christian, and i will never stand with an earthly, secular, democratic state like modern Israel that is commiting a mass genocide of innocent human beings especially children in Gaza, my Allegiance is to Jesus Christ and to His Kingdom alone.
Hopefully Taylor Marshall will be appointed as the Trump Administration’s Ambassador to the Vatican. He’d be a vast improvement over Joe Donelly 27:47 , a puppet of Nancy Pelosi, both pro abortion. He pretended to never lifee ed.
Thank you, Dr. Marshall, very informative. In furtherance, to the biblical insight you provided it is noteworthy to mention that Orthodox Judaism did not support the formation of the state of Israel, in fact, they emphatically insisted that was expressly against the bible, citing the diaspora.
One of the best podcasts from you. You have explained dispensationalism so very well backed by scripture. Thank you Dr Raylor Marshall for the indepth explanation
As a member of Palestinian diaspora, coming to Christ has only made me yearn for justice even more. it's my hope that those children in Gaza will one day be in Jerusalem, Haifa, Jaffa and Nazareth just like where their grandparents were. and that the kids trapped in the west bank will one day be able to visit the shores of Palestine. My GREATEST hope for the situation is that all Palestinians, Arabs, Muslims and non believers will convert and hopefully we'll all see the illumination of conscience VERY soon!
Pray for peace 🙏 pray for the conversion of Islamic Palestine and Jewish Israel to accept our lord and savior Jesus Christ as their lord and savior✝️⛪️🇻🇦 We need to put America first 🇺🇸🦅
Thank you for this interesting theological perspective. I was raised a Catholic with a Palestinian Muslim Father and Australian Catholic Mother. I Have been searching for a good explanation of this issue for so long and you have outlined it here so well. No Priest ever discusses this in Australia. It is concerning that Priests seem too wary to address such an important topic. Thank you for this insightful information.
Brother Andre of the Benedict Center has produced two podcasts on Christian Zionism which was most helpful as well, Because of the errors taught by Dispensation alism, Christian Zionism preceded Jewish Zionism!
That’s Dr Marshall’s commentary not solid Catholic commentary. Please Read your Bible about God’s covenant with Israel and the importance of the restoration of Israel along with the restoration of his Holy church. No where in the Bible does it say that God has forsaken Israel.
@@jesusgonzalez-acton8045enjoyed that interview as well cognoscenti that Robert Spencer is a Jew. He is also extremely well schooled from hood own work.
@@DrTaylorMarshall Thank You so much for the explanation. I have been waiting for almost a month for a good explanation on the Israel-Hamas conflict from the Catholic prospective. Also this is my first time watching one of your videos, very well produced.
Thanks for a great program as usual. Thank you for shining the light on what our faith “has taught” in the past and still teaches. So many of us don’t know the complexities of our faith and why we even believe it. I pray for all humanity.
We have no obligation or duty to serve Israel's interests. We pray for their conversion and embrace of Jesus Christ Our Savior. We need to put America First and pray for peace in the world. Support neither side in this conflict
True but if I had to pick sides I'd go with Israel over Palestine and Hammas. Still do NOT support giving anyone one penny outside of American citizens.
I was once invited to an evangelical church, and at the end of the service, we prayed for Israel. It's a little bit odd since the Israelites never believed in Christ as the Messiah. But since I'm a Catholic, praying for that country is still relevant
So good to hear St Pope Pius X's words. I find myself wondering how much the naming of that State is intended to undermine the identifying of True Israel...because "Israel" is in most people's minds now welded to that patch of land.
@@taroman7100 no they don't. The founding Zionists were for the most part of Khazar and Ashkenazi descent. The original Shepardim for the most part lived peacefully in Palestine with their Muslim and Christian neighbors and were against Zionism. Read the Controversy of Zion by Douglas Reed.
Hopefully Taylor's podcast here will open eyes! Spread it around. Also part two of Sensus Fidelium's podcast on Christian Zionism is helpful. I can't believe how this heresy has even spread among much of my Catholic family and few even realize about the plight of our Christian Palestinian brothers.
@@lorimav my family is Methodist (Methodism is so watered down, it’s barely Christianity 😂) and I’ve been surprised to learn that they’re just as nutty as evangelical Christians in their blind support for Israel no matter what 🇮🇱 does. My mom won’t even separate Palestinians from Hamas. 😤
The Bible also teaches us about the Remnant of the House of Israel who will be saved when the Lord Jesus comes in glory and that they will weep and welcome Him like a son and will finally recognize Him for who He really is.
Big difference between the state of Israel and the nation of Israel. Thank you for explaining this. My uncle (non practicing Catholic, now a protestant)always prayed for Israel. I always wondered why he was obsessed with this.
Remember there are 12 tribe's of Israel scattered they for the most part don't have a clue who they are. If a gentile is grafted into the vine they become the family of Israel
Fantastic Video Dr. Marshall. It's very useful to understand WHY so many Protestants suffer this confusion, so that we can better argue against their misconceptions. Christ is King!
Because many modern Churches defy Christian teachings, including traditional Protestant ones. Others have split over heresies, like ELCA, and PCUSA, UMC...
I’m very happy to hear this, I’m a Christian, and I agree totally with you on this…. Pray for the Church to wake up and stop supporting evil, the killing of innocent civilians and little children… God have mercy. God is not happy about this His heart must hurt 😢.
Great video on the subject! I didn't watch this sooner, because I was fooled by the title into thinking that it was a political conversation etc not a theological one breaking down errors. I love videos where you teach. Smart of you to come out with such a video after this war goes down as there might be more clicks on it.
Great lecture Dr. Marshall! Let's not forget the Temples curtain is torn I half at the moment Our Lord dies on the Cross. There the old covinent ends and begins the new one
I had always kind of suspected that Dispensationalism was responsible for the peculiar approach to Israel among so many western Christians. It’s great to have it laid out like this.
I wouldn't even say western Christians, it's majorly just Americans, ask the average catholic, orthodox or even protestant in Europe most won't support Israel
@@Adam-fj9px I wasn’t sure. From a national interest perspective, support of Israel can be debated, but the poor biblical interpretation is not grounds for such support.
This Vid is fantastic. I have trying to get a handle on this awful squabble for ages. Doc Taylor cuts to the chase when he explains things and its refreshing and also makes it easier to understand. Pius X nailed it good.
@@DrTaylorMarshallAs a cradle Catholic is it okay to attend the Norvus Ordo Mass. Since there's almost NO Traditional Latin Mass in the Philippines 🇵🇭.
I am Catholic and I do not support Israel's exaggerated war retaliation. I weep with and for the Palestinians. I have asked the God of the brokenhearted for mercy and compassion, to cleanse the Palestinian land of all the pains and sufferings brought about by the war, and grant them self determination and freedom.
True, because so many so called pastors and 'christian' leaders do not stand with the Prince of Peace, and worse many blindly support war and bombs that are killing even Palestinian CHRISTIANS. It's refreshing to hear a man of God question the zionist mantra about blindly supporting the state of israel. However to speak up, is really simply Christianity 101 because each one of us who take on the Cross of Jesus Christ know what we signed up for. Jesus said there would be persecution. We must never deny Jesus Christ before men or He will deny us before the Father. [Matthew 10:33].
IN NOMINE PATRIS ET FILII ET SPIRITUS SANCTI. AMEN. thank and praise Lord Jesus Christ. Thank you Dr. Taylor Marshall for this great lecture. It reminds me of the teachings of our Lord Jesus about love. "to love even our enemies". thank you
Prayers for our World! God will make a way. Where there seems to be no way. These last three years I’ve been struggling. But even as I struggle to support my children and myself I trust in you Lord. As a single mom things can be tuff both of my children are special needs but they are thriving now that I’m home schooling them. My hours to work are limited. I also suffered a heart attack two years ago and I’m battling lupus. Thankfully God is my rock! So as I struggle to pay my rent or as I struggle to buy daily necessities. God will make a way. Where there seems to be no way. He works in ways we cannot see. He will make a way for me and my children I have faith! God has not forgotten me.
You are a very brave man for stating fundamental Christian truths. No one comes to the Father but through His Son, the Lord Jesus Christ. As a struggling Catholic, I do my best to make Jesus the center of my life, not any state, not even the one I live in, nor do I put any race above any other--because each human being, even one born with the most horrible, crippling disease, is created in the image of Jesus. It's as if the spirit of anti-Christ itself is deluding people to believe otherwise. The only people who would cheerlead this kind of evil are those who simply do not know the Holy Spirit. The air around the entire world must be thick with demons. Bare minimum, one rosary a day, allows you to breathe in a world drowning in bloodlust. God forbid when I meet Christ that he should say to me, "Why did you kill my children?" Each child is HIS.
@@franniehillman217 No one said Jesus's last name is "Christ". Christ means "Messiah", and when we say Jesus Christ, we are acknowledging Him as our Lord and Saviour, the Messiah!
@@c.Ichthys 🤣🤣🤣 you dont even know the Hebrew language you stole the word messiah from. You Christians have stolen Hebrew language and appropriated it blindly, AND think youve figured some grand mystery out 🤣🤣🤣🤣
Oh wow! listening to this during a dark struggle. I went to Medugorje in 1999 when I was living a life of drugs and impurity. I didn't witness anything unusual personally but it was a pivotal moment in my life. Within 6 weeks of returning, I lost my gilfriend of 2 years, my job, my house and my car. I ended up living on a sofa in my mother's living room at the age of 27. I thouhht I had been cursed. But! within 2 years I met my wife, moved to Australia, had 2 children and last month we celebrated our 20th wedding anniversary. Mother Mary is a mother of mercy. By the way, I had been praying the rosary.
@@brianburnett4956 I don't know what you mean by fake. The fruits are certainly not fake, look at the numerous conversions, miracles and ordinations. The actual messages can be summed up as: Mass, Rosary, Eucharist, Prayer and Fasting. Now, if that is the work of Satan, it is counterproductive and self-defeating. As for the authenticity of the apparitions, well, you would be correct to say they are authentic only when the Church approves them. God gave us a brain to reason and the Holy Spirit to discern. You don't have to believe it, all you need is Jesus in the Holy Eucharist. God bless.
I am so happy you did a video on this topic. It has torn at me for years and I just cannot in good faith advocate for the killing of innocents, Muslim or not. I want to love all people, of all faiths, no matter if they’re my enemies or friends. I want to love how Christ loved and I just wish there were more people who could approach the topic of Israel with the virtue of love.
Not as many innocents over there as the news tells you. They are taught to hate all infidels (non Muslims) and even in the US over 65% of them support establishing a Caliphate here and taxing your church out of existence. a in many places no Bible, rosary, cross or other Christain objects are allowed. If you speak to them about converting, that is a capital offense. Besides they voted HAMAS in by huge majority.
Dear God, this is exactly how my mother (an evangelical christian in Brazil) explains this thing. Now I know the name of it. Dispensationalism. This might make it a lot easier to debate her. But, anyway, God is in charge. He convinces and converts people. Not me. Please, pray for us, whoever is reading this comment.
I am a protestant Christian, who has always known that dispensationalism was untrue. Watched the whole video but didn’t learn anything new. Very basic and obvious. Salvation is by grace alone through faith alone in Christ alone to the glory of God alone!
This is so very well explained, thank you! Dispentionnalism is not new to me, but now I grasp things better, getting the whole picture, it alongside with he true and orthodox doctrine of Salvation
A real eye opener, thanks for sharing... Watching from Kenya. I am shocked at the number of Protestant Christians who think Israels war on Gaza is a holy war!!!
Wow so your staying with hamas terrorists the sane islamic brother hood that butchered innocent people in kenya at the shopping mall, at the garish university abd so many more terror attacks in kenya. Will your blinded islam is planning more attacks on jenya so don't sleep too long on the hamas narrative.
God bless you. This was always my intention. I want to be confirmed first and become used to the liturgy. I just searched for Latin mass and thank heavens there is a society for just that in churches within my reach 🙏
Meni je izvrsno kad netko otvoreno i hrabro komentira, analizira i stoji iza svoje vjere i mišljenja! Samo jedno mogu napisati, svaka čast, samo hrabro i obilje Božjeg blagoslova!!! ✝️🙏🏻👍🏻
I'm a convert from the Baptist/Bible Church. I converted in 2009 and can't believe I never realized we weren't Zionists! This video is so helpful and informative.
Philistines are not a nation...they are human rabble...they lost they ethnic National identity long ago...just as General Patton stated...of course with the Muslim conquests...one must wonder about the demography of the region even further.
Thank u Dr. Marshall for such a crystal clear and direct to the point teaching. May GOD continously used u as his messenger of truth. Watching u from the Philippines.❤
Jesus himself was a Jew and he made it very clear at John 18:36: “My Kingdom is no part of this world.” By his example, he trained his followers to keep out of the political fights of the day and to focus instead on preaching the good news of God’s Kingdom. (Matthew 24:14; 28:19,20) This shows that we are completely loyal to God’s government-His Kingdom!
I am a Protestant, but I am not a Dispensationalist. You have said what I am always telling my friends. Although the majority of my friends are Dispensationalists, a growing number would agree with you. Thanks for the affirmation. This was an excellent sermon. 0:03
As an Orthodox Christian, I pray for the peace of everyone everywhere. But in no way do I have an obligation to or unspoken alliance for Israel. Most Christians today still give them the label of "GOD's Chosen People". But they lost that title when they rejected His Son.
![Fall Asleep Listening to Genesis: Bedtime Scripture for Deep Sleep [Holy Bible Audio]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/46IfXNk8YI8/mqdefault.jpg)
As a Palestinian Catholic Christian who lost rights to the land through the Diaspora, it must hurt our Lord’s heart to witness what’s been happening in Israel…I’m praying for our Jewish brothers and sisters, and Muslim brothers & sisters because Jesus came for ALL of us! The truth must be told and I thank you for your courage!
I hear you loud and Clear. Yet God is in Control
Sadly Your Jewish and Muslim Brothers have rejected Jesus! I cannot be personally responsible for everyone.
@@historyloveriii2949 They have rejected through ignorance. Both sides are paying the price for that. Jesus is always for peace. Love thy neighbor is his theme
The truth is the land of gaza in part of Canaan land that God promised to Abraham and Israel around 1920 BC. You can read about it in Genesis starting at Chapter 12 verse 7. It's a lot more land than Israel is occupying now and God keeps His promises
I Will pray for You and all the innocent people and the children in particular here in México we are in a silent war the criminals have taken over please also pray for us
I am a Protestant who grew up with this ideology. My mother went to Dallas theological seminary in Dallas for her doctorate and my father was a minister for many years. I am just now (nearly 30 years old) learning more about Protestantism and the Catholic Church. The more I learn, the more I am pulled towards the Catholic Church and it’s teachings. Thank you for this video and for your resources; it’s helping me navigate my faith journey. I learned something new today by watching this video!
Good luck in your journey, I will Pray a Rosary for you to come home to the Catholic Church.
@@pgstudio4651They want to destroy the Church. They have planted so many subversives, even in the highest of places. On the other hand, the Church is still networked enough for the righteous to wage a resistance.
Learn about Islam too. It gives answers for all of your questions
I was a Protestant 3 months ago. The Catholic Church is the true and original Church that Jesus left on earth. Read the 1st century Church writings and writings from the martyrs. They were Catholic in theology 🙏🏽
Just read Foxe Book of Martyrs and you'll stay clear away from the Roman Church. Go reformed Baptist before you think about the Vatican anti Christ.
I'm Greek Orthodox Christian and I always pray for peace ☦️
God on the inside peace on the outside. Not provoking or making trouble.
Thank you from israel
Peace peace peace
@@arielhatav0232 you're welcome 🇮🇱
Greek Orthodoxy has monks and prophecy that support it and outline how the war will effect them. I suggest you Google Saint Paisios and other Greek sources.
If you are really christian you know that the end times according to Jesus Christ has no peace because this now the fulfillment of the prophecy of Jesus
You're the only one who talks against Christian zionism, you're real brave for this
Plus X and Hitler did as well
@@lindaray7418 hold on UA-cam will ban us lol
Fr mawsdey does as well
Pastor Chuck Baldwin and Pastor Rick Wiles do too.
Pastor Chuck Balwin has some good content on Zionism as well.
I'm Catholic, and i always pray for the peace of the whole world
Pray that people will believe and have faith to the Lord Jesus Christ because if they don't have faith, believe, and have conscience, this world never have enough peace.
World peace is a false ideal
Christian history is all over Isreal.
@shalomshalom8715Islam is satanic. Period.
Yea u might wanna switch religions fast
NO WE SHOULD NOT. The only thing owe the state of Israel is the Gospel of Jesus Christ.
AMEN TO THAT!!!
Pray for all innocent victims of this tragic war🙏🏼
There are no innocent in this war....only God can decide which mortal is innocent.
@@francischu1584 Wrong! And wrong again.
@@francischu1584 I agree. No one knows anyone s inner conscious
@@francischu1584children.
The children are innocent for sure
I really really enjoyed listening to this podcast for its theological value and the edifying tone and vibe. I can imagine people disagreeing, but cannot imagine them being offended. Thank-you Dr Marshall!
As a Protestant, up to a week ago i "believed" in Dispensationalism....but something about it didn't sit right in my spirit. Then the Lord led me to this and others explaining the Theology. As a budding theologian this has helped me greatly.
It also helped me also. What an awakening that was, coming from a Pentecostal church. I started researching Darby and Scofield and all those who promoted Dispensation theology.
Go back to your previous views. You were correct. Don’t fall away. Don’t be led astray. That was the devil deceiving you and taking you away from the truth.
@@Revelationstold As Christians we should imitate Jesus( the Prince of Peace) and pray for peace amongst ALL people. Matthew 5:9 Blessed are the peacemakers for they shall be called the children of God.
@@Revelationstoldmaybe prove why her old views are truth instead of demanding it. Demanding it reveals intention and also truth. This is a tactic prots use. Go find the truth and articulate it
@@MTCatholic maybe Jake you should go and find the truth. I already have it. It seems you don’t!
Good evening sir,
I am a Muslim and while we are theological opponents I commend you for your honesty.
The only genuine Catholic position is to be neither for Israel nor Palestine.
Many 'conservatives' Novus Ordo Catholics are uncomfortable when we remind them that Pope Pius X opposed Zionism.
Also the real American position is America First, not Israel first or Palestine First.
Bring anti HAMAS is not the same as being a Zionist. Shut your mouth.
Common Pius X W
The Kingdom Of Israel. A crusader Kingdom...we will remake.
@@RenneDanjoule Amen. Deus vult.
God describes Israelite as kille*s of prophets and righteous persons.
Which verse?
Matthew chapter 23.33-39
Jesus used the continuous tense to indicate this is their habit.
I am a catholic. I strongly believe in Jesus Christ. But I pray 🙏🏿 to Jesus to give peace and protect the helpless children and innocent civilians who are affected by this horrible tragedy in Palestine 🇵🇸 and Israel. We all are Gods creation. We are all children of God .
Excellent sentiment and the prayers are worthy, of course. But, believers are adopted Children of God. All others are God's creatures.
As a second to your comment: my child's catechism says God becomes our Father at baptism @@flrevert
❤❤❤
Beautiful, yes, we must pray for all the dear innocents. We are all His creation, but truly, by The Word 📖✝️, one is only a Child of God if Baptised in the name of The Father, The Son✝️, & The Holy Ghost 🕊❤️
@@ElizabethKautzmann yes 👍 I agree with you 💯Thanks for your reply. May God bless you and keep you safe
GREAT video, very helpful. I used to be a Pentacostal/Charismatic/Protestant/Evangelical who believed in dispensationalism and a pre-trib rapture. Now I am a confirmed Catholic and studying the TRUE faith as much as I can, to deprogram myself from all the heterodox doctrine I learned in back then.
I often watch your videos but the BEST is when you are in teaching mode. Everyone. has opinions but only a few can teach. God bless you!
Thank you for shedding light into this! My friends and I have been talking about this lately and noticed that it is a thing among evangelicals.
Not really. As a Catholic I have my own reservation too. There are some questionable quotes in the Quran too. No one can dispute that
Because they’re heretics.
I am an evangelical Christian, and i will never stand with an earthly, secular, democratic state like modern Israel that is commiting a mass genocide of innocent human beings especially children in Gaza, my Allegiance is to Jesus Christ and to His Kingdom alone.
Dr Marshall I find your videos very helpful even as a Greek Orthodox Christian and I share them with my brethren ☦️
Roman and Orthodox Catholics need greater cooperation and love. I’m a Roman Catholic and my wife is Eastern Orthodox.
Catholicism / Orthodox is not a hard bridge to gap, spiritually-speaking.
It's mostly political.
We are well connected through our history & it’s good to share our values and learn with each other. ✝️
Oh no! Don't tell me the Orthodox here are also infected with Christian Zionism. 😮
Hopefully Taylor Marshall will be appointed as the Trump Administration’s Ambassador to the Vatican. He’d be a vast improvement over Joe Donelly 27:47 , a puppet of Nancy Pelosi, both pro abortion. He pretended to never lifee ed.
Thank you, Dr. Marshall, very informative. In furtherance, to the biblical insight you provided it is noteworthy to mention that Orthodox Judaism did not support the formation of the state of Israel, in fact, they emphatically insisted that was expressly against the bible, citing the diaspora.
Thank you for all your knowledge you
Share. I’m a Catholic convert peace to the world through Jesus the Christ. Jesus I trust in you.
@@AneluBrown-ky1xf Welcome Home may the Lord Jesus bless and protect you.
One of the best podcasts from you. You have explained dispensationalism so very well backed by scripture. Thank you Dr Raylor Marshall for the indepth explanation
Do you think Hitler was on the right track?
As a member of Palestinian diaspora, coming to Christ has only made me yearn for justice even more. it's my hope that those children in Gaza will one day be in Jerusalem, Haifa, Jaffa and Nazareth just like where their grandparents were. and that the kids trapped in the west bank will one day be able to visit the shores of Palestine. My GREATEST hope for the situation is that all Palestinians, Arabs, Muslims and non believers will convert and hopefully we'll all see the illumination of conscience VERY soon!
Amen!
I’ve just watched “The stones will cry out- voices of the Palestinian Christians.” It’s heartbreaking to watch”.
This is a worthy prayer. I will dedicate tomorrow's Rosary to this intention.
Amen. God willing all Palestinians will be free, physically in their homeland and spiritually through Christ.
wishful thinking
Got even more out of this as I listened to it again. Thank you and God bless!
Pray for peace 🙏 pray for the conversion of Islamic Palestine and Jewish Israel to accept our lord and savior Jesus Christ as their lord and savior✝️⛪️🇻🇦 We need to put America first 🇺🇸🦅
Plus great Britain 🇬🇧
Absolutely.
Pray for all innocents who are by far the majority.
Deus vult
We need to pray for the conversion of America. Plus. We need friends too.
One of your best, Dr. M. We're with you. Stand firm and continue to speak the truth.
Thank you for this interesting theological perspective. I was raised a Catholic with a Palestinian Muslim Father and Australian Catholic Mother. I Have been searching for a good explanation of this issue for so long and you have outlined it here so well.
No Priest ever discusses this in Australia. It is concerning that Priests seem too wary to address such an important topic.
Thank you for this insightful information.
Brother Andre of the Benedict Center has produced two podcasts on Christian Zionism which was most helpful as well, Because of the errors taught by Dispensation alism, Christian Zionism preceded Jewish Zionism!
Thank you for putting this out, I was waiting and looking for some solid Catholic commentary on the situation.
Glad it was helpful!
That’s Dr Marshall’s commentary not solid Catholic commentary. Please Read your Bible about God’s covenant with Israel and the importance of the restoration of Israel along with the restoration of his Holy church. No where in the Bible does it say that God has forsaken Israel.
@@vitamay1is the present day Israel filled with faithfulness to God????
@@jesusgonzalez-acton8045enjoyed that interview as well cognoscenti that Robert Spencer is a Jew. He is also extremely well schooled from hood own work.
@@DrTaylorMarshall Thank You so much for the explanation. I have been waiting for almost a month for a good explanation on the Israel-Hamas conflict from the Catholic prospective. Also this is my first time watching one of your videos, very well produced.
Thanks for a great program as usual. Thank you for shining the light on what our faith “has taught” in the past and still teaches. So many of us don’t know the complexities of our faith and why we even believe it. I pray for all humanity.
I love watching Dr Marshall. Its because he is truthful .
Thanks Doc. I needed this information, especially in light of recent world events.
Pray for the conversion of everyone involved in the conflict
One of the best videos you've ever done! And that's a pretty high bar! Excellent work!
This is amazing. I’ve never heard the Church’s position on this before!
This is not what the Magisterium/catechism says! He is wrong!
We have no obligation or duty to serve Israel's interests. We pray for their conversion and embrace of Jesus Christ Our Savior. We need to put America First and pray for peace in the world. Support neither side in this conflict
Amen.
True but if I had to pick sides I'd go with Israel over Palestine and Hammas. Still do NOT support giving anyone one penny outside of American citizens.
I agree. Put america first. Sorry to ruin your day but Israel is God's people. They are in the bible, America is not
It's not in our interest to fight everyone's war. Geez. We're getting what in return?
@@johnlowell8202 how can Israel be the church when they don't believe that Jesus is God? That makes no sense.
I was once invited to an evangelical church, and at the end of the service, we prayed for Israel. It's a little bit odd since the Israelites never believed in Christ as the Messiah. But since I'm a Catholic, praying for that country is still relevant
Thank you so much Doctor Taylor for informing us good information may Almity God bless you and your family keep on doing the work
This is brilliant, Dr. Marshall. I’m going to listen to this repeatedly until it really sinks in. It goes deep!
It is brilliant, agree totally.
Until he brainwashed yiu with nazi ideology 😅
Thanks!
Listening to this video gave me an insight into the theological issue of supporting Israel. Thanks Prof.
So good to hear St Pope Pius X's words.
I find myself wondering how much the naming of that State is intended to undermine the identifying of True Israel...because "Israel" is in most people's minds now welded to that patch of land.
You are definitely onto something.
It has been one long bloody graveyard but they have an ancestral attachment to it for three thousand years.
@@taroman7100 So do the Palestinians, and they were not exiled from those lands and scattered throughout the nations by God.
@@taroman7100 no they don't. The founding Zionists were for the most part of Khazar and Ashkenazi descent. The original Shepardim for the most part lived peacefully in Palestine with their Muslim and Christian neighbors and were against Zionism. Read the Controversy of Zion by Douglas Reed.
Jesús will literally come and set foot on the mount of Olives. Israel is the fig tree that began to re bloom in 1948 after 2000 years.
👍🏽 I hope the Palestinians know that we are praying for them
I do now. Thank you. 🙏
This makes me happy to hear, God bless you
Hopefully Taylor's podcast here will open eyes! Spread it around. Also part two of Sensus Fidelium's podcast on Christian Zionism is helpful. I can't believe how this heresy has even spread among much of my Catholic family and few even realize about the plight of our Christian Palestinian brothers.
@@lorimav my family is Methodist (Methodism is so watered down, it’s barely Christianity 😂) and I’ve been surprised to learn that they’re just as nutty as evangelical Christians in their blind support for Israel no matter what 🇮🇱 does. My mom won’t even separate Palestinians from Hamas. 😤
@@realolivertwistedThanks for your support ☦️🙏
The Bible also teaches us about the Remnant of the House of Israel who will be saved when the Lord Jesus comes in glory and that they will weep and welcome Him like a son and will finally recognize Him for who He really is.
Yes, as in the Old Testament there will be a remnant saved but that that won't include all ethnic Israel.
Big difference between the state of Israel and the nation of Israel. Thank you for explaining this. My uncle (non practicing Catholic, now a protestant)always prayed for Israel. I always wondered why he was obsessed with this.
Exactly
Is he a member of the Masonic lodge?
Remember there are 12 tribe's of Israel scattered they for the
most part don't have a clue who they are. If a gentile is grafted into the vine they become the family of Israel
Boomers just can NOT let go of Israel, it’s ridiculous and not scriptural. Israel is us- Christians!
😅
May God bless you and your Family Dr Marshall. Amen
Thank you, Dr. Taylor again for an enlightening video! God bless you!
Fantastic Video Dr. Marshall. It's very useful to understand WHY so many Protestants suffer this confusion, so that we can better argue against their misconceptions. Christ is King!
Marshall should lean to refer to Pope Saint Pius X as a SAINT and no “Pius X. This guy is no traditionalist!
They are heretics so they’ll fall for anything.
Because many modern Churches defy Christian teachings, including traditional Protestant ones. Others have split over heresies, like ELCA, and PCUSA, UMC...
I’m very happy to hear this, I’m a Christian, and I agree totally with you on this…. Pray for the Church to wake up and stop supporting evil, the killing of innocent civilians and little children… God have mercy. God is not happy about this His heart must hurt 😢.
This was the perfect guidance we needed I’ve listened to many interviews and podcasters on the issue and this makes the most sense. ✌️
YOU NEVER SUPPORT A WAR YOU PRAY FOR IT TO STOP!! PRAY THE HOLY ROSARY DAILY.. PRAISE BE TO GOD LORD JESUS!!
The rosary is not in the Bible. Pray to Jesus and him only.
Great video on the subject! I didn't watch this sooner, because I was fooled by the title into thinking that it was a political conversation etc not a theological one breaking down errors. I love videos where you teach. Smart of you to come out with such a video after this war goes down as there might be more clicks on it.
Great lecture Dr. Marshall! Let's not forget the Temples curtain is torn I half at the moment Our Lord dies on the Cross. There the old covinent ends and begins the new one
Covenants dont end. They are granted in perpetuity. Read Romans 11. Gentiles have been grafted in to the true vine. They have not replaced the vine.
@@alexandercawley3094Mathew 21-33-43 say otherwise
@@alexandercawley3094the ture vine is Jesus Christ not natural Isreal
@@alexandercawley3094There are 2 Covenants the Old Covenant before Christ, and the New Covenant after the birth and death of Jesus Christ ✝️.
Thank you for posting this video Dr. Marshall. Can't tell you how much it means to see people like you being honest about this issue.
Love it, ❤ Dr. Marshall! We all learn so much from you. Thank you so much. 😊 God bless 🙌
Thanks for this, Dr. Marshall. I don't hear this very often but I have always believed this is true. Prayers.
I had always kind of suspected that Dispensationalism was responsible for the peculiar approach to Israel among so many western Christians. It’s great to have it laid out like this.
I wouldn't even say western Christians, it's majorly just Americans, ask the average catholic, orthodox or even protestant in Europe most won't support Israel
@@Adam-fj9px I wasn’t sure. From a national interest perspective, support of Israel can be debated, but the poor biblical interpretation is not grounds for such support.
@@steelmongoose4956there is no national interest to support israel. It’s a one way street where we pay for everything and they give nothing in return
It’s diabolical
Bingo!
Thank you for making all this very clear. I've listened to this teaching twice.
This Vid is fantastic. I have trying to get a handle on this awful squabble for ages. Doc Taylor cuts to the chase when he explains things and its refreshing and also makes it easier to understand. Pius X nailed it good.
I'm new to Dr Taylor, but one of my friends is crazy about him, and I had to check him out. So far so good!
Glad you are here
Read his books also
Marshall helped me a lot become Catholic!
Thanks Dr Taylor! JMJ bless you!
@@DrTaylorMarshallAs a cradle Catholic is it okay to attend the Norvus Ordo Mass. Since there's almost NO Traditional Latin Mass in the Philippines 🇵🇭.
I am Catholic and I do not support Israel's exaggerated war retaliation. I weep with and for the Palestinians. I have asked the God of the brokenhearted for mercy and compassion, to cleanse the Palestinian land of all the pains and sufferings brought about by the war, and grant them self determination and freedom.
Agree my brother/sister. I am an Evangelical Christian and I support Palestine too. Israel's evil works to Palestine is not understandable.
Diabolical Disorientation
Finally, someone had the courage to address this important issue. God bless you Dr. Marshall.
True, because so many so called pastors and 'christian' leaders do not stand with the Prince of Peace, and worse many blindly support war and bombs that are killing even Palestinian CHRISTIANS. It's refreshing to hear a man of God question the zionist mantra about blindly supporting the state of israel. However to speak up, is really simply Christianity 101 because each one of us who take on the Cross of Jesus Christ know what we signed up for. Jesus said there would be persecution. We must never deny Jesus Christ before men or He will deny us before the Father. [Matthew 10:33].
IN NOMINE PATRIS ET FILII ET SPIRITUS SANCTI. AMEN. thank and praise Lord Jesus Christ. Thank you Dr. Taylor Marshall for this great lecture. It reminds me of the teachings of our Lord Jesus about love. "to love even our enemies". thank you
This man is very honest!!! Impressive....keep going your excellent work.
Prayers for our World! God will make a way. Where there seems to be no way. These last three years I’ve been struggling. But even as I struggle to support my children and myself I trust in you Lord. As a single mom things can be tuff both of my children are special needs but they are thriving now that I’m home schooling them. My hours to work are limited. I also suffered a heart attack two years ago and I’m battling lupus. Thankfully God is my rock! So as I struggle to pay my rent or as I struggle to buy daily necessities. God will make a way. Where there seems to be no way. He works in ways we cannot see. He will make a way for me and my children I have faith! God has not forgotten me.
🙏🙏🙏🙏
🙏🏽 ❤
stay strong faith in the Lord🙏🙏🙏🙏
You spreading good new
You are a very brave man for stating fundamental Christian truths. No one comes to the Father but through His Son, the Lord Jesus Christ. As a struggling Catholic, I do my best to make Jesus the center of my life, not any state, not even the one I live in, nor do I put any race above any other--because each human being, even one born with the most horrible, crippling disease, is created in the image of Jesus. It's as if the spirit of anti-Christ itself is deluding people to believe otherwise. The only people who would cheerlead this kind of evil are those who simply do not know the Holy Spirit. The air around the entire world must be thick with demons. Bare minimum, one rosary a day, allows you to breathe in a world drowning in bloodlust. God forbid when I meet Christ that he should say to me, "Why did you kill my children?" Each child is HIS.
The head of the Catholic Church is the antichrist of revelation. He is the beast of revelation. You are standing on slippery ground.
You know that Christ is not Jesus' last name.
@@franniehillman217 No one said Jesus's last name is "Christ". Christ means "Messiah", and when we say Jesus Christ, we are acknowledging Him as our Lord and Saviour, the Messiah!
@@c.Ichthys 🤣🤣🤣 you dont even know the Hebrew language you stole the word messiah from. You Christians have stolen Hebrew language and appropriated it blindly, AND think youve figured some grand mystery out 🤣🤣🤣🤣
@TheHardcoreAmericanPatriotUSA how so? Clarify please.
You opened my eyes about Israel and the end times. I can't believe I didn't see this coming. Thank you, Dr. Marshall.
😅 19:01
Oh wow! listening to this during a dark struggle. I went to Medugorje in 1999 when I was living a life of drugs and impurity. I didn't witness anything unusual personally but it was a pivotal moment in my life. Within 6 weeks of returning, I lost my gilfriend of 2 years, my job, my house and my car. I ended up living on a sofa in my mother's living room at the age of 27. I thouhht I had been cursed. But! within 2 years I met my wife, moved to Australia, had 2 children and last month we celebrated our 20th wedding anniversary. Mother Mary is a mother of mercy. By the way, I had been praying the rosary.
Amen ❤
Jesus is a miracle worker: happy for you.
Medju is fake. Grace comes from piety and sacraments. Not that place. Do your research!
@@brianburnett4956 I don't know what you mean by fake. The fruits are certainly not fake, look at the numerous conversions, miracles and ordinations. The actual messages can be summed up as: Mass, Rosary, Eucharist, Prayer and Fasting. Now, if that is the work of Satan, it is counterproductive and self-defeating. As for the authenticity of the apparitions, well, you would be correct to say they are authentic only when the Church approves them. God gave us a brain to reason and the Holy Spirit to discern. You don't have to believe it, all you need is Jesus in the Holy Eucharist. God bless.
I am so happy you did a video on this topic. It has torn at me for years and I just cannot in good faith advocate for the killing of innocents, Muslim or not. I want to love all people, of all faiths, no matter if they’re my enemies or friends. I want to love how Christ loved and I just wish there were more people who could approach the topic of Israel with the virtue of love.
Not as many innocents over there as the news tells you. They are taught to hate all infidels (non Muslims) and even in the US over 65% of them support establishing a Caliphate here and taxing your church out of existence. a in many places no Bible, rosary, cross or other Christain objects are allowed. If you speak to them about converting, that is a capital offense. Besides they voted HAMAS in by huge majority.
God Have Mercy On Our Souls🙏
Dear God, this is exactly how my mother (an evangelical christian in Brazil) explains this thing. Now I know the name of it. Dispensationalism. This might make it a lot easier to debate her. But, anyway, God is in charge. He convinces and converts people. Not me. Please, pray for us, whoever is reading this comment.
I am been thinking the same thing concerning my Pentecostal friend…
I am
It's called being part of a cult with a nefarious agenda behind it.
I am a protestant Christian, who has always known that dispensationalism was untrue. Watched the whole video but didn’t learn anything new. Very basic and obvious. Salvation is by grace alone through faith alone in Christ alone to the glory of God alone!
Will do!
This is so very well explained, thank you! Dispentionnalism is not new to me, but now I grasp things better, getting the whole picture, it alongside with he true and orthodox doctrine of Salvation
A real eye opener, thanks for sharing... Watching from Kenya. I am shocked at the number of Protestant Christians who think Israels war on Gaza is a holy war!!!
It is shocking and disturbing, isn't it?
Wow so your staying with hamas terrorists the sane islamic brother hood that butchered innocent people in kenya at the shopping mall, at the garish university abd so many more terror attacks in kenya. Will your blinded islam is planning more attacks on jenya so don't sleep too long on the hamas narrative.
Who said its a holy war - its a defensive war! Who kidnapped, raped, murdered on the 7th October?
Loving your broadcasts, they have been so educational for me as I am initiating into The Roman Catholic Church. ✝️
You are on the right road. I'm desiring to join the church soon too.
May God bless you. Attend the traditional Latin High Mass if you an. It will change your life.
God bless you. This was always my intention. I want to be confirmed first and become used to the liturgy. I just searched for Latin mass and thank heavens there is a society for just that in churches within my reach 🙏
@@leejennifercorlewayres9193 Don’t hold back and do it at the next opportunity, the first step is always the hardest.
So glad to hear you are coming home. God bless you all.
Meni je izvrsno kad netko otvoreno i hrabro komentira, analizira i stoji iza svoje vjere i mišljenja! Samo jedno mogu napisati, svaka čast, samo hrabro i obilje Božjeg blagoslova!!! ✝️🙏🏻👍🏻
Thank you Taylor Marshall. There are so many videos out there. You are truly wise.
Odličan komentar
Dragi Hrvati katolici probudimo se❤
I've enjoyed listening to this podcast so very much. Thank you for explaining this so beautifully.
When people do not accept Jesus as their savior, they are in the claws of evil.
Absolutely. Amen 🙏
Wow, thank you, always nice to hear your perspective!
I'm a convert from the Baptist/Bible Church. I converted in 2009 and can't believe I never realized we weren't Zionists! This video is so helpful and informative.
Thank you Dr. Taylor! I soo wanted this session since the Israel/ Gaza war. ❤❤❤❤
I trust you Dr Taylor..You are soo inspiring & knowledgeable. Bless you 🙏
Thank you and bless you for your incredible work Dr Taylor.
Thank you for this! It's so hard to get through to dispensationalists some times!
I can't like this enough!
Cognitive dissonance.
Thank you from Lebanon. Your arguments against dispensationalism are healthy for a christian mind
“I want people to stop dying” - Donald Trump.
I personally want peace and unity in the Truth, Jesus Christ. Pray for the conversion of both nations🙏🏻
Philistines are not a nation...they are human rabble...they lost they ethnic National identity long ago...just as General Patton stated...of course with the Muslim conquests...one must wonder about the demography of the region even further.
you haven't read Revalation
@@johneazevedoyou seem to think God wants to carry out revelations
@@johneazevedo I have read the entire bible from Genesis to Revelation
@@johneazevedoAnd you have no clue about its meaning nor even how to spell it.
Thank you so much, Dr. M!!
Are you single?
Excellent teaching! My people parish for a lack of knowledge!😊👍
Great teachings! Thank you, dr. Taylor Marshall. God bless you and your family!
That was excellent Dr. Taylor Marshall. Thank you for always providing sound explanations. God bless you and your family!
Thank u Dr. Marshall for such a crystal clear and direct to the point teaching. May GOD continously used u as his messenger of truth. Watching u from the Philippines.❤
My Jesus have Mercy on us
Viva Cristo Rey.. Long Live Christ ❤️
Thank you for sharing the truth Dr. Marshall, praise the Lord.
I love when you stick to the theological education for us.
Thank You Dr. Taylor!!
Excellent lesson. Thank you.
Very intriguing, helpful and well researched.
Jesus himself was a Jew and he made it very clear at John 18:36: “My Kingdom is no part of this world.” By his example, he trained his followers to keep out of the political fights of the day and to focus instead on preaching the good news of God’s Kingdom. (Matthew 24:14; 28:19,20)
This shows that we are completely loyal to God’s government-His Kingdom!
I am a Protestant, but I am not a Dispensationalist. You have said what I am always telling my friends. Although the majority of my friends are Dispensationalists, a growing number would agree with you. Thanks for the affirmation. This was an excellent sermon.
0:03
The Rothschild issue with the state of Israel was a huge warning for me that rocked my Z**nist church view.
Thank you. I am a Muslim that respects you as a brother in humanity who seeks justice.
Almost cried at today's responsorial psalm (147)..."He has granted peace to your borders.."
I read this today at Mass. ❤️
Amazing how God speaks to us. His timing is always so impeccable!
Resp psalm? Lol. Go to the old mass.
@@limen5442 Not all of us live within a 2-hour's drive to a Latin Mass.
Thank you Dr Marshall for the open, honest and straight forward explanation. Blessings🕯🕯🕯
As an Orthodox Christian, I pray for the peace of everyone everywhere. But in no way do I have an obligation to or unspoken alliance for Israel. Most Christians today still give them the label of "GOD's Chosen People". But they lost that title when they rejected His Son.
Great content. Crazy based! A breath of fresh air to hear a westerner say something other than the same old "Israel defend yourself" line.