U must be nationalist Singaporean. The price ( both rental n selling) of housing in Singapore is skyrocket high in 2024. Everything price in Singapore is climbing up n up. Yes, it's politics is stable bcoz the brainwashing of the gov't media (CNA) , school system n also iron fist suppression on the opposing voice by the gov't that is everyone in Southeast Asian countries know very well about it😢, only Hongkongers don't know about it.
Singapore is not comparing with any other country, just do its best. Hong Kong stock market is much larger than Singapore, but with new changes in internationally, may lose its shine..To add Singapore is not only strong in financial, there are many other strength as well.
As a Singaporean, I just want to highlight 2 important points why it’s unfair to compare HK with Singapore. First of all, HK is not a country who can make decisions all on her own like Singapore as a country can. HK has to listen to the motherland for many decisions (example: zero covid policy) Secondly, China will never let cities like HK outshine their own first tier cities like Shenzhen and Shanghai as it would look bad on CCP to have a city that had western influence (laws and legislation) outshine any Mainland cities. HK’s ultimate role is to support Shenzhen. Hence, with so many restrictions placed on HK, it wouldn’t be possible for HK to outshine Singapore in the long run.
@ditsygirl5409 But don't forget Hong Kong has support from China. Hong Kong need not worry about water, food and electricity supply. China Is Pro and Cons for Hong Kong.
No point to compare. Singapore is focusing on stability to survive. We have no natural resources and surrounded by neighbouring that want to be better. We too have to keep reminding ourselves that unless our stability remains and be united, only then success can be achieved
HK has China as backup and also managed by British from scratch...whereas SG from 3rd world,mud land n o resources country to the top tiers status now...At this juncture, SG already won won won many times..its can stand and survive on its own and not depending on others to bring the country up..
As a Singaporean it is a compliment to be compared to countries like Hong Kong. In case u didnt know, we modeled our MRT (MTR) system network the whole nine yards after Hong Kong. Just one of the many areas that we have modeled after other countries. We had nothing to begin with from our independence in 1965. Our country, our government has never wanted to be the top in any of our undertaking but solely to survive for an island state. As years passed by, we have better role models to 'copy' and we also attract more talent. Today we have surpassed many of our role models but this is not because we want to be the top but simply have to stay relevant and ahead otherwise we will suffer. Singapore is all about human capital with no natural resources. We are here today not because we want to the best but just want to be relevant in this world of business.
I am Singaporean. I think HK is still strong in financial hub and air hub. Just lost its shine alittle. I miss HK Movies. It just getting lesser and lesser. Not the usual HK movies like previous s. Both countries have to look forwards and strive.
我見識了香港人的優赿不比新加坡人的差！但只是有一样不同！就是香港政府比较沒有遠見對居者的坦心！I knew the hongky didn't worst than singaporen, but the different is the government don't have future focus to protect the situation of the civilian
i open the saxo account, but when i realized that they need to take 30USD when i withdraw 3000 usd from saxo to my bank account. I no longer login saxo any more...
If one monitors the trade between HK and Singapore, you realise they cooperate a lot in financial trading. Both are hubs of different regions and need each other for better economical activity. HK and Singapore have very different populations and therefore, it is not appropriate to say whatever works for Singapore can produce the same effects for HK. HK has its own strengths and all they need is to revitalise and continue to improve as they had done in the past.
You can say all the bad things about Singapore because you are an outsider and formed a very biased opinion about us, you are out to find fault with Singapore. Have you ever wonder if Singapore really has all these disadvantages as what you claimed, why is there no big exodus of citizens to other countries like Hong Kong in the recent years but instead more and more foreigners want to come in and investors willing to dump their money into our economy. What does that tell you?
Fund manager for years. Honnestly it does not matter 2nd or 3rd in financial world. Only the top mkt matters and thats the US financial mkt. No other mkt can beat or even come close to the US mkt in size, volume and volitility, Period.
Singapore won as China, like Russia, cannot be trusted. I left Hong Kong and come to Canada in the 90s as I don't trust China. My perdition was correct based on this video. Good Job!
Absolutely. Singapore has completely overhauled HK in every major field, be it in finance, living standards, university rankings etc etc. HK is on a downward spiral, there's nothing anyone can stop this trajectory in the near future.
@@yau7639 It's as difficult as naturalization in Switzerland. The only thing I don't like about Singapore is conscription. People should be given a choice, not by force to have the military training. If they don't have enough soldiers, they could do what the French do, and that's to set up a foreign legion, i.e. mercenary. Since Singapore is a wealthy country, I don't think it will mind spending a few bob.
SG never competes with HK, because we are different. 新加坡从来就没拿香港作为竞争对手，因为我们都来自不同的社会政治背景。HK cuisine mainly Cantonese whereas SG covers many different types of food. 香港粤菜一流；新加坡提供世界不同料理。所以，新加坡和香港无法同等比较的。 Therefore, no way to compare between SG and HK fairly.
People predicted the passage of Article 23 National Security Law would be the nail on the coffin for Hong Kong. Looking at Hong Kong today, I have to agree their prediction was correct.
I suspect most “Singapore supporters” in the comments probably doesn’t even qualify to be Singaporeans or PR. Just a bunch of China haters here. It’s a sad truth. 請不要酸，這只是客觀現實。 There’s no point comparing the two, there’s no trophy to be won. I have friends in Singapore and I am happy they gave a good life there, and it is because they are a productive part of their economy and on an individual level, that’s all that counts. But while they enjoy their living there, it’s not all roses, and they have their many concerns. One of my friends is eligible and considering renouncing his UK citizenship and to become a Singaporean, because he loves the city so much, however, his children will be required to join their military when they come of age. Another friend had been there for over 20 years, and to this day is not eligible to become citizen (I’m not 100% of their immigration policies but it’s very difficult for sure). For me, while I’d like to live in Singapore but my experiences don’t translate well in there, so I’m not even eligible to be a PR, unless I plan to pay and retire there, which is a really expensive choice. I do have to admit some acquaintances are in Singapore due to their “wealth worries”. But to be quite honest, their source of “wealth” is somewhat vague and dodgy, and Singapore is not a country that will let these kind of wealth taint their status quo, and we see adjustments in their policies already. But individual cases differ and there’s not one “comparison” that fits all. It’s not a football game where you cheer the one team over another. You can go ahead and move to Singapore if you want, but those who aren’t even eligible (including myself) should just make decisions based on their own situations.
![😑你其實沒有選擇...👉🏻安全的投資👉🏻 買入這個必賺的資產🧐 [中文字幕]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/LLPxMmBzLbo/mqdefault.jpg)
![😑你其實沒有選擇...👉🏻安全的投資👉🏻 買入這個必賺的資產🧐 [中文字幕]](/img/tr.png)
你認為誰是亞洲金融中心第一位? A or B?
更正: 05:51 資料引用出錯🙏 有關新加坡資助70% VCC 費用的詳情，請看這裡: www.citco.com/insights/can-investment-managers-still-utilize-singapore-vcc-grant-scheme-as-deadline-approaches
SaxoBank盛寶(國際證券買賣＋丹麥離岸戶 或 本地香港戶)，開立本地香港戶口送高達HK$1,200迎新獎賞* 或開立任何戶口送US$125 Super 8 課程優惠#**
請留意上面的Description Box內優惠條款
香港戶 (迎新獎賞):www.home.saxo/zh-hk/accounts/openaccount?cmpid=affi_rainishere
香港戶(課程優惠) :ad.doubleclick.net/ddm/clk/505677034;312961192;g
國際離岸戶(課程優惠)：ad.doubleclick.net/ddm/clk/505346021;312961192;v
推薦親友: www.home.saxo/zh-hk/accounts/referral?cmpid=affi_cm_26384795_312961192_0
🌧免費下載RainIsHere 目標訂立計劃表 & 一年收支計劃表：
www.investingwithrain.com
登陸Rain網頁，再點選👉🏻（下載 Download ）
如何下載：bit.ly/3TpOqOI
《豬豬成為專業投資者必學的7大課》估值模型/財務數據分析/年報分析：www.investingwithrain.com/courses/7majors
**如何報讀？教學 👉🏻 bit.ly/379mYS0
如果你想支持平台發展:
🌧到Patreon請我飲杯咖啡www.patreon.com/rainishere
‼最近有不法之徒冒用Rainishere的名義售賣課程，請注意Rainishere的所有課程只會在www.investingwithrain.com上發佈‼ 大家要小心喔！
資料來源：
tradingeconomics.com/hong-kong/gdp-per-capita-ppp
www.forbesindia.com/article/explainers/top-10-richest-countries-in-the-world/87305/1
unctad.org/publication/world-investment-report-2023
www.statista.com/statistics/720397/china-outward-fdi-flows-to-singapore/
www.ft.com/content/b66e2f92-1b92-47af-8f4b-f2a1abcedfbd
www.singstat.gov.sg/-/media/files/news/fdiinflows2022.ashx
tablebuilder.singstat.gov.sg/table/TS/M083801
www.reuters.com/article/singapore-economy-manufacturing-idUSL4N0AX1VG20130128
www.channelnewsasia.com/singapore/edb-singapore-fixed-asset-investments-3264856
www.bis.org/statistics/rpfx22_fx.pdf
www.mas.gov.sg/news/media-releases/2022/mas-launches-financial-services-industry-transformation-map-2025
www2.deloitte.com/ch/en/pages/financial-services/articles/wealth-management-centre-ranking.html
www.zawya.com/en/press-release/research-and-studies/2022-global-talent-competitiveness-index-global-talent-inequalities-hinder-progress-in-achieving-key-sdgs-dm6kqf4t
time.com/6321258/singapore-hong-kong-asia-finance-hub/
B
2023年的香港，是未来10里最高光的香港了。以后只会被中国一起给拖累死。
@@xander2890 "粤港澳大湾区, 昨日的梦 "? “一次不忠，百次不用”!
不少香港一般民众以为大陆还停留在改革开放以前的社会环境。因此很多没到过大陆不只香港一般民众，很多政治人物根本不知道大陆有多进步, 習慣了天馬行空言論，以己之見高談闊論，也以管窥天，夜郎自大，自以为是，但根本是井底之蛙。 如今的大陆已是世界第二大经济体，许多一、二线城市都已超越香港。
自從中國從英國手中奪回香港。 大多數（如果不是全部）香港人一直稱自己為香港人（暗示英國殖民者），而不是中國人。 此外，東方明珠的光彩幾十年來一直在夕陽中褪色。 香港人只剩下英國的殖民教育和美國的反中國宣傳。 更糟糕的是，爆发顏色革命和来自(美國控制)乌克兰生物实验室生物武器攻擊（截至2023年4月28日，近半数香港人口(39%)感染了Covid-19疾病）。 在香港颜色革命高峰期，中国政府开发广州南沙，以迅速取代香港。 2022年，广州南沙中欧铁路线已全面开通。 此外，自 2022 年初以来，越南、韩国等区域全面经济伙伴关系协定(RCEP)成员国一直在利用广州南沙中欧铁路线向欧盟出售商品。 那些香港人（英國殖民者）能從這裡去哪裡？
@@wildfire8126
你长篇大论，讲的顶多就是香港的GDP被大陆其他城市超越。香港失去的何止是GDP指数而已？香港所失去的国际优势，是大陆任何一个城市都无法取代的。因为没有任何一个大陆城市拥有香港曾经有过的历史背景，以及中西并肩的国际化资源。这些优势绝对不可能被大陆任何城市可以超越甚至取代，只有新加坡有这样的资源和可能性，可以超越或取代香港。😅
B
我在新加坡生活，看到政治經濟發展治安穩定，政府看到不适合政策会改善，新加坡人民語言強，包容和尊重各民族。新加坡是國際級城市，吃穿住行質素非常高，非常愛新加坡🇸🇬，新加坡齐心向前進 Onward as one
说到底是香港人自作贱，自甘当国外势力的工具破坏香港繁荣稳定，吓跑投资者，当然也包括洗钱的。
U must be nationalist Singaporean. The price ( both rental n selling) of housing in Singapore is skyrocket high in 2024. Everything price in Singapore is climbing up n up. Yes, it's politics is stable bcoz the brainwashing of the gov't media (CNA) , school system n also iron fist suppression on the opposing voice by the gov't that is everyone in Southeast Asian countries know very well about it😢, only Hongkongers don't know about it.
我是新加坡公民。我们一直没有争，是其它国家把新加坡和香港比较。我们只是一直在做好自己。我们政府做的都是以国民为着想。
講得好👍🏻 但係如果有大量唔見得光的資金落到嚟， 每個人都可以做到自己或者做好自己嗎？
你参与政策制定了吗？
normal society應該如此，香港有共產黨干擾，已經輸盡
@@kiyri333没有共产党香港有现在地位？还是依靠大陆市场和制造业产业资金资源支撑不然香港就回复以前穷乡僻壤村跟古代一样。😂
@@雅君墨客-i9z 97過後多謝你黨的恩賜
我感覺整條片最重要的資訊係最後講者嗰幾句: 「要有 穩定嘅政治環境、能夠資訊快速流通及可負擔的生活成本！」讚~!!
我是新加坡人。为什么需要比较？各有各的利弊。只要互相和平发展大家都会好。但是香港有比较好吃的点心和娱乐。欢迎更多好吃的来新加坡😂🎉认真点的话，新加坡有稳定的法律制度。国际化.香港比较有创业精神
我好buy你呢一句各有利弊與其講什麼不如話你哋心態真係好好多可能係教育同個人修養嘅問題
這個女人一聽他講話:就是台灣島民民進黨支持者或民進黨核心組員,所以:挑撥新加坡和香港特區市民互閗,心態邪惡
跟著美國賺錢，事實勝於雄辯。
整天拿兩地比較的都是當權者、以及靠此吹噓賺錢的群體。市民只有興趣比較哪裡好玩、哪裡消費便宜。btw作為香港人，真心認為香港只會越來越差，連「八個中文字」都不能說出口，說出口就會坐牢，香港這地方還敢稱自由港？笑死人。祝
新加坡人民天天愉快、國家越來越自由豐裕！
在香港你唔競爭，政府覺得你躺平，
香港政府唔同其他國家競爭，
會被阿爺指住嚟鬧
呢個超越類文化問題，係政治問題
小弟做創科start up
本地不友善的程度首屈一指
新加玻配套好,積極友善
感概!! 分別只一個，是新架坡有國家觀念，國民會為國家或眾人作某程度的犧牲，簡單如隨便丟棄垃圾，新架坡是最清潔城市! 香港人瘋狂地詛咒，憎恨自己的身份，自私自利，犧牲他人，揾錢至上，連丟棄垃圾(由七十年代的垃圾蟲)，到今天，還沒有共識，與政府對着幹，不能解決，公屋環境今天仍是重災區。醒醒吧！不要諉過他人了!
@@john-ss8hk 你真對,不用客氣
Singapore is not comparing with any other country, just do its best. Hong Kong stock market is much larger than Singapore, but with new changes in internationally, may lose its shine..To add Singapore is not only strong in financial, there are many other strength as well.
如果只比金融市场，新加坡不容易比香港大，但是新加坡也有几个业务是香港所没有的，比如世界第三大煉油中心，世界四大药厂都在新加坡有研究和生产，还有半导体产业等，所以不可以一一的比较，也不要常拿新加坡来比较吧，大家名求进步就好。
星加坡有geyland 与little India, both places are infested with legalised prostitutes.
新加坡金融业只是占了20%总体经济。与香港不一样。
As a Singaporean, I just want to highlight 2 important points why it’s unfair to compare HK with Singapore. First of all, HK is not a country who can make decisions all on her own like Singapore as a country can. HK has to listen to the motherland for many decisions (example: zero covid policy) Secondly, China will never let cities like HK outshine their own first tier cities like Shenzhen and Shanghai as it would look bad on CCP to have a city that had western influence (laws and legislation) outshine any Mainland cities. HK’s ultimate role is to support Shenzhen. Hence, with so many restrictions placed on HK, it wouldn’t be possible for HK to outshine Singapore in the long run.
Absolutely agree. laws and legislation determine the economy.
@ditsygirl5409 But don't forget Hong Kong has support from China.
Hong Kong need not worry about water, food and electricity supply.
China Is Pro and Cons for Hong Kong.
I think HK's ultimate role is becoming one of the districts of Shenzhen
China really made HK become worst and low tier place in the world.
Please don’t forget Hong Kong for China …😅
为什么一直要拿新加坡做比较？ 新加坡从不和别人做比较。
rain 你嘅影片愈來愈高質, 無論係剪接定動畫, 都做得好好!!! 希望你可以做多啲有關分析同銀行嘅野!!! keep going!
FYI,我在新加坡媒体上没有看过政府或团体机构拿新加坡和香港做比较；也没有听说新加坡做任何决策是为了超越香港。新加坡政府只是做了对自己国家好的决策；只是一些领域与香港重叠。
新加坡每年需要播出大量预算在国防开支；为了国防，大量人才和劳动力必须放在国家安全上。
国情不同，种族人口结构不同；又有大量预算拨给内政部，相关部门也聘用不小的劳动队伍，以应付种族宗教事端。
反观香港有祖国的市场和安全庇护，无需这些开销和人力上的“损失”，拿两地相比有欠公平！
但是祖國缺美金的時候會印人民幣換走港幣.
@@Skimpaul 港灿是不是食懵左？人民币和美元借到港元互换本来tm就是香港赚大钱的特权门路好吗！？
@@Skimpaul請問印人民幣來換走港元是如何做到？可否剖釋一下這個機制？
@@snooker9773 2022的新聞, 中國人民銀行（人民銀行）與香港金融管理局（金管局）今天（7月4日）公布優化貨幣互換協議，改為常備協議形式，毋須續期。 協議規模並由原來的5,000億元人民幣/5,900億元港幣擴大至8,000億元人民幣/9,400億元港幣
新加坡人解释下，金融最核心的投行业务只能在香港，距离市场，客户，监管更近。新加坡这个行业的市场规模非常小，金融最多只能做资管，family office，帮热钱避险。以及一些中后台业务，因为市场不在这边。仅从金融中心看的话，新加坡和香港差得远
你这一看就是在新加坡金融行业工作过的。这个sg完全比不过hk😂。即使吹sg科技行业，也比不过硅谷，而且打工人表示sg科技行业工资和中国上海差不多，打工人来说按sg的生活成本不到8k刀每个月基本月光。
土生土長香港人，得閒四圍旅遊，最愛飲飲食食，到目前為止都認為香港最好！我租客都是星架坡財金界人材，佢PREFER留港工作。真係人人睇法不同！
哈哈！今時今日嘅香港你仍然覺得最好，只可以話你活係自己的世界裡！😢
说得好，我是星国人，但香港能超越星加坡，因香港才是真中华民族的国土。
新加坡比较无聊点咯，但是比较适合有细佬仔的家庭。香港玩的野，单身的比较喜欢边度。
普通人純生活的話香港確實遠好過世界上絕大多數國家。但有些動不動就政治上腦，成天活在政治鬥爭裡的傻逼是不可能感覺香港好的。
新加坡又熱，又悶，乜都唔俾做！
新加坡🇸🇬❤❤❤❤❤❤
Singaporeans have to thank Mr Lee Kuan Yew, a great man with his firm government.
FIRM GOVERNMENT!
the man with his iron fist.
Thanks Rain. Now Singapore is so good while HK is so bad ...... BTW, wish you feel better soon.
多謝！
感謝你支持Channel發展 🙇🏻♀
No point to compare. Singapore is focusing on stability to survive. We have no natural resources and surrounded by neighbouring that want to be better. We too have to keep reminding ourselves that unless our stability remains and be united, only then success can be achieved
你講到好有理念， 講完好似冇講， 每個城市都會有競爭對手， 呢個係無可避免🙏🏻
@@danieltsang5223没错, 但你无法改变竞争对手, 因此最好是做好自己提高自己的能力, 让自己更有价值。
@@danieltsang5223 in a simple saying.. We are all trying to stays afloat
What Singapore needs the most is freedom instead of stability which Singapore has never lacked of.
@@chasejamie6118 any substantiation? especially the part that Singapore has never lacked stability. or perhaps you live in an alternate universe?
溫馨提示
非經事先批准，任何人不得在任何行業、職業或專業中，或在任何非官方機構的標識、印章或徽章中，使用國旗、國徽、區旗、區徽或其圖案。
龜兔賽跑的故事重複又重複 。。。建議可以考慮做個東南亞地區經濟特輯，GDP，主要工業分布，居住環境及成本，堅尼系數，應該好多觀眾關心
Thanks to Carrie Lam
香港對JPEX一件事的處理，外資點睇？
新加坡係加密貨幣天堂，Jpex在新加坡係攞獎同可以參展的，在香港變成scam
香港对加密货币更加严格，对普通投资者做到保护的作用。
很多古靈精怪的金融工具，本質都是詐騙，加密貨幣也是一樣。金融中心的本質之二，是賭場和洗黑錢。金融中心是不應該吃自己人，應限制本地人參與，反而應多吸納外資，吃外人。
香港自1960年至2003年一路领先星加坡和其他小龍直至2000年後開始漸漸被星加坡超越，因為受到很多限制如開賭
新加坡有很多赌场吗？你搞笑吧！香港主要是被几大家族玩废了，舆论和房地产都控制在他们手里，港府有利于人民的政策落实不下去！典型代表李嘉诚
新加坡❤❤❤
我地唔會葡萄新加坡，我地有夜繽紛繼續賣魚蛋燒賣，又有關愛隊！I❤HK😊
件衫十分好看很纖瘦, 祝早日康復😛
HK has China as backup and also managed by British from scratch...whereas SG from 3rd world,mud land n o resources country to the top tiers status now...At this juncture, SG already won won won many times..its can stand and survive on its own and not depending on others to bring the country up..
But we do depend on countries
Like Malaysia
We buy Johor water drinks.
As a Singaporean it is a compliment to be compared to countries like Hong Kong. In case u didnt know, we modeled our MRT (MTR) system network the whole nine yards after Hong Kong. Just one of the many areas that we have modeled after other countries. We had nothing to begin with from our independence in 1965. Our country, our government has never wanted to be the top in any of our undertaking but solely to survive for an island state. As years passed by, we have better role models to 'copy' and we also attract more talent. Today we have surpassed many of our role models but this is not because we want to be the top but simply have to stay relevant and ahead otherwise we will suffer. Singapore is all about human capital with no natural resources. We are here today not because we want to the best but just want to be relevant in this world of business.
Your vlog is excellent. Maybe I should consider changing my major in Chemical engineering to Finance and Economics
謝謝分享! thx!!😊😊😊✌👍
各有各好。只知道新加坡的税率低，税务奖励多元化，而且税法简单，很多大公司来新加坡设总部。题外话，新加坡在小贩中心和房屋政策方面的确好太多了。衣食住行成本都不会太高，除非你想住公寓，或是买车。压力的确比香港小很多
Saxo vs Interactive Brokers
邊個好啲？
5:51 篇報導係講香港SFC資助OFC點解會講成係新加坡資助?
Hello Justin, 我是RainIsHere admin，很抱歉我們剪輯時使用了錯誤的畫面。早前新加坡資助VCC 70%的費用的資料來源,請看這裡:www.citco.com/insights/can-investment-managers-still-utilize-singapore-vcc-grant-scheme-as-deadline-approaches
@@RainIsHere 感謝 加油!
香港是冒险家的乐园。新加坡是保守家的家园，各有所长，视各家所须而决定去留。不知対不対，请選择。哈哈哈。
I am Singaporean. I think HK is still strong in financial hub and air hub. Just lost its shine alittle. I miss HK Movies. It just getting lesser and lesser. Not the usual HK movies like previous s. Both countries have to look forwards and strive.
聖上很努力的讓香港 變的普通
與其講係聖上不如話港人治港可以有幾勁先
难道不是黄丝港废让香港变成这样，搞破坏还觉得是别人错😂，果然是黄丝港废
请问你所说圣上有管香港难道不是你们殖民教育文化媒体还有一些殖民精神白人四大家族资本和政治律法等利益集团还有黄丝港废破坏？😂
你简直没有一点逻辑思维可言
香港本来就不该特殊。让香港变特殊不过是百年国耻的结果。
英国租界香港99年后，新加坡依然是个独立国一切由自己 ‘’话事.‘’ 香港现在只是一个 ‘’区‘’ 一切听从中央。 ‘’美中‘’ 的贸易战或多或少对香港也有影响。新加坡继续往前冲，香港已经无法回到从前的辉煌年代了，也没有本钱跟做比较。
Singapore is moving to a tech hub like Silicon Valley, half of VC funds in Asean went to Singapore alone.
为什么我们这么爱互相比较？做好自己，好好爱自己的国家。
再过五年十年，状况有可能又有转变。谁胜过谁那么重要吗？是面子问题吗？
一個地方既經濟金融發展離唔開政治因素既影響
從長遠去睇 新加坡無疑會全面取代香港成爲亞洲既國際金融中心 紐倫坡將會成爲現實
而香港只會係一国既侵蝕之下逐步走向衰敗 直至最後被完全同化 淪為一個普通城市甚至系煉獄
除非可以徹底改變現實 出現前所未有既巨變 如果唔系香港既命運都唔會有任何改變
其實講到尾就係冇一啲好嘅人管治香港咋嘛不過港人治港就係咁囉望吓啲大部分香港小市民齷齪到咁我相信香港係中國毋庸置疑斷估都唔會害我哋無意思對佢哋嚟講無好處唔通內部搞分化演變成國際笑話成日有機會俾人入你好過癮咩
@@qirmic5215 唔系香港冇好既人只系好既人都被送曬去監獄或者被迫流亡海外
唔會害我哋? 睇嚟你都好天真下 香港既變化已經有目共睹 不容置疑
歸根到底只有香港成爲一個獨立國家并且將所有野蠻人趕盡殺絕之後 香港要回到過去既繁榮就唔會系難事
不用長遠，現在已經取代了，不過有一樣嘢新加坡難以超越香港，就係冶安，香港應該是全世界最安全嘅地方，人人安居樂業😊😊
@@wingli4965 安全嚟講我覺得從法律上香港唔夠新加坡強制執行到
@@qirmic5215好明顯上面係曲啦，你仲以為香港真係仲安居樂業呀嘛？！
热爱自由政治的新加坡不是第一首选，19年那些港人来了新加坡估计也不是因为政治自由来的。但你是为了稳定这一点新加坡不错。
坡佬把在當地爆粗鬧醫護既小仙女送去坐牢，這一點已經完勝，在新🐠港就要成排人向衣食父母道歉😅
早就话政府要强硬D，都唔知怕咩，我叼
你確定香港人服務態度出名差內地人都唔差到去邊不相伯仲，果然有樣學樣一家人最好香港去坡佬學下人哋態度咁好先
睇過小仙女拍條片都爭唔落，係醫院老屈護士歧視佢，係急症室又唔肯戴口罩又爆粗鬧護士，結果醫院要報警，女警嚟到問話又唔合作又耍大牌又搶女警証件，又將拍女警片掟上網想大家認為她被歧視，結果警方查吓查吓又發現犯了其它罪，又話她從事工作與工簽不同，話嚟做秘書其實唔係，結果角內好奇八掛友人肉她，發現她應該係外圍女，現在坐過多月算走運😅，按坡佬做法，應該終身不會比入境，跌咗幾個大客
这种闹事的就是在内地也要拘留的呀。，个人行为咋和国家扯一起，你这是偏见
那一句，唔該晒，簡直甜度溶入我心，秒定閱
我見識了香港人的優赿不比新加坡人的差！但只是有一样不同！就是香港政府比较沒有遠見對居者的坦心！I knew the hongky didn't worst than singaporen, but the different is the government don't have future focus to protect the situation of the civilian
香港政府不担心选票😂。
新加坡都不擔心選票，佢哋反對黨完全冇作為！有少少威脅，都被政府告誹謗，直至破產為止！破產者，不能參選😅
其實在香港這樣的政治體制下，執政者要做的樣樣周全也並非易事，再說一個不需要贏取選民支持的所謂政府，民眾會信任嗎？竟然不信任，有不少甚至是憎惡這樣的一個政府的，這樣的社會要如何能夠’上下一條心‘ 而同舟共濟呢？ 不用顧慮選民投票表決通過的政府又怎麼會有遐思和餘力做太長遠的規劃與籌謀呢？
@@simonlim943 理解！一个好的政府都是在最困难時候建立的！
@@simonlim943 你唔代表香港人，你只能代表你自己，事實上，約15萬黃C港毒離開香港！佢哋都唔代表香港！拜托！
i open the saxo account, but when i realized that they need to take 30USD when i withdraw 3000 usd from saxo to my bank account. I no longer login saxo any more...
主要係想你介紹富婆Rain來認識一下。😂
你看她自己的名字
今集好掂，財經角度比較新加坡同香港，廣東話內容黎講，應該係最強！ 富婆Rain果然勁！
If one monitors the trade between HK and Singapore, you realise they cooperate a lot in financial trading. Both are hubs of different regions and need each other for better economical activity. HK and Singapore have very different populations and therefore, it is not appropriate to say whatever works for Singapore can produce the same effects for HK. HK has its own strengths and all they need is to revitalise and continue to improve as they had done in the past.
新加坡第一名🇸🇬👍
香港要放下身段，不要一个套路走到尾，增强应变能力。
不明放下身段是指什麼，是否要跟俄羅斯，伊朗，北韓多些聯繫？如果改用這個套路，邪惡軸心經濟體將會成立！
@@woodyleung2284我諗佢應該係講緊政府嘅兼容性有待改進😂
@@woodyleung2284 香港已经在往这个方向走了，不过你们政府这么走的话不足为过，毕竟你们政府亲谁都看得出来。
@@woodyleung2284新加坡可不是民主国家，他们的领导人也是内定的，你在羡慕独裁国家？
@@woodyleung2284他说的是事实，港府很多有利于人民的政策落实不下来，经济被财团控制，新加坡强有力的政府，不会被资本控制！政府公租房推行不下去，财团控制媒体
講得好我都想支持香港香港呢個地方係唔錯㗎呢其實不過頭先阿波比冇得比兩個地方比較相差太大香港就好似街市星加坡就好似一個商場
政治和時間改變基本
選擇新加坡
新加坡只能做做富豪们的热钱白手套，真正赚大钱的股票基金，他差香港太远。
即使不說經濟、政治，我都覺得新加坡點解還是未能起飛，照理一早就應該是龍頭？懂國語、英語、粵語還有自身方語間直是個個都是語言天才。
新加坡没有一个大市场做靠山。其实力并不足以让东南亚各国俯首称臣。那些吹新加坡取代香港都是吃瓜群众，实际上李显龙政府对此很明白，是不可能取代的。
素來真是極似 姊妹城市, 差異就是主權國家及特別行政區! 防衛及外交開支差距甚大! 本人常幻.....未來能否用海底高鐵 來貫通兩座美麗城市呢??! 一小時共同生活圈 共享資源!
rain气色好很多❤❤
👍
Thank you for sharing you view.
Take care! 🌷
新加坡系一個主權獨立國家； 香港現在是被規劃城市(自身也失去97前特有城市自主地位)
暴動、縱火
97前香港有自主权吗？那英国人是摆设的？
新加坡主權獨立是表面，實際是寄生於美國霸權下的附庸國。97前的香港是服務英國和英國企業，根本沒有自主地位 。
Very informative. Thank u!❤
自己唔爭氣，超越都係好正常…
人均收入在2000年後一直輸新加坡，原因大家都清楚，香港電影業就是最好指標。
有國安法就得啦，其它野理九佢死
@@田飛A 香港电影业明明是被美国片打败的，香港自己的票房冠军都不是港片，这也要怨大陆？
@@samsamsamsam4914 防止外來干預法SG、反滲透法TW。。。唔系得你香港有国安法，读多D书啦巴打，唔好次次成绩差赖人地影响你，自己争气D好过啦🤣
@@elvisfung8000 You should be reading more about the details of the HKNSL before to say any stupid things here.
Rain 你講得好，但有一點 miss out 就是 security? 某國breach聯合國的承諾， 可同什麼force 來抖正？? 這是fundamental 的requirement. 怎可能放一大舊錢在一個無門夾萬？
新加坡實行政府主義，星展銀行，新加坡航空等公司都政府有份，基本上政府話事。新加坡投資公司及淡馬錫係世界各地投資，淨到益返新加坡人民。信和集團，Kerry Property去其他地方起樓淨人地錢，新加坡食飯都收6%稅，新加坡冇遊行冇示威，新加坡唔食得香口膠，帶留連上車，做錯少少咩都要罰，天氣熱，又多印度人，新加坡房屋政策9：1公屋：私樓，好多人話新加坡人人有屋住，其實政府做在地產發展商角色，你既稅收，退休金都去晒政府到去換取你既公屋，私樓一樣貴，可能重費過香港。
You can say all the bad things about Singapore because you are an outsider and formed a very biased opinion about us, you are out to find fault with Singapore. Have you ever wonder if Singapore really has all these disadvantages as what you claimed, why is there no big exodus of citizens to other countries like Hong Kong in the recent years but instead more and more foreigners want to come in and investors willing to dump their money into our economy. What does that tell you?
你可能是对的。你喜欢住在香港大狗笼，我喜欢住在新加坡大屋子.
香港這金融中心，是服務不願直接投資中國內地的外資，是以股票和相關衍生工具的交易為主，外匯交易次要。新加坡這個金融中心，是外匯交易為主，服務亞洲時段的交易者，而股票市場的規模很小。香港和新加坡的金融業，各有各的定位，近年再拿來互相比較，是因為有資產管理公司從香港遷往新加坡，但這趨勢是否能持續，仍是未知數
主要係香港依家既定位好尷尬。
香港一直以來都主打交通內外既樞紐，依家大陸對香港既依賴減少，歐美又對國害安法既香港既依賴減少，搞到兩頭唔到岸。
此消彼長新加坡第一只係時間既問題。
暴動、縱火
定位很清晰，就是中美交易的中介所。本来就是一个特殊时期特殊产生的富贵。实际上香港大富大贵都是中美建交之后，之前都只能做做胶花胶表之类的劳动密集型产业摆脱贫困，区位优势差新加坡很多。香港很多人唱衰大陆，实际上大陆繁荣，香港才能繁荣。
@@coffee_cat 被寵壞的孩子，需要飢餓歲月才能再次激勵進步； 很遺憾。😢😢
你的剪片非常❤
香港已经仆街佐几年啦! 人同钱都去佐新加坡啦! 新加坡已经成为了亚洲唯一的国际金融中心, 而香港的港币若还能有三年命就偷笑啦!😂
別這麼悲觀, 應該還能撐5-10年.
好開心可以見到Rain
我都好開心見到你地 ❤
富婆Rain，保重身體
Fund manager for years. Honnestly it does not matter 2nd or 3rd in financial world. Only the top mkt matters and thats the US financial mkt. No other mkt can beat or even come close to the US mkt in size, volume and volitility, Period.
辛苦你啦rain
新加坡比香港較好,因為新.馬有相同法制,但只有不同人種,所以大剛可以磨合,兩地人民有相互了解的前提下.只要執政者配合民意民生等問題就可以了.
人種正是馬來西亞的棘手問題，新加坡也出了很大的力氣才能解決種族矛盾。馬來西亞人口太少，就算融合，也不夠新加坡吃的。新加坡是必須吃盡整個東盟，才能保持他們的發展勢頭 ，否則就會遇到瓶頸。
香港是中国金融中心。新加坡是亚州金融中心。大部分欧美国家的公司都已经撤离香港了。
Singapore won as China, like Russia, cannot be trusted. I left Hong Kong and come to Canada in the 90s as I don't trust China. My perdition was correct based on this video. Good Job!
Nobody trust commie
支持一下😊
面向國際才有錢途
太依賴背靠XX
只會失去國際優勢
新加坡成功主要是靠自己找出路
不要依賴別人
否則一穫熟
😡😱😓🤔😩😭
Market Cap 幻觉来的。越来越多Family office, private equity funds, 这些都比起HK强。而且SG支持的初创都很有素质
正常，不進則退，但也不用棄餒，HK做返自己就得，Singapore 也不可能長期向上
2004年社會運動成功，香港咪可以做番自己囉!
可惜2019年失敗咗.......
@@ZenoHA-ri8fl係暴動，現在香港終於回復正常，慢慢從回正軌。
@@koneliem7704 社會係慢慢重回正軌，可惜而家香港人已經不斷喺度退步，長期浸淫在政治問題上，不思進取，為咗政治立場，政府做乜都要反都要嘲諷，拖慢香港發展。
重回正軌？
股市減半樓價大跌乏成交，小巴的士牌價冧，富人專業人士青年移出人口老化，名校中小學幼稚園收生不足停辦，消費疲弱夜經濟沉寂。
土地拍賣多次流標或只超低價成交，上年度財赤1400億，財政儲備創新低，繳稅人數連續3年減少，單上年度少33萬。
國際金融中心讓位星加坡，IPO排名世界第一跌到差過印尼印度
@@ZenoHA-ri8fl 謝謝，習近平主席，謝謝你幫助了新加坡美夢成真！！！
香港经济。。。特殊时期发展的产物。假若当初发展方向走向实体，也许会有不一样的进程。不过自从大陆加入wto后，香港的未来是注定的
没错 香港当年就是靠中介贸易发财 结果吃饭砸锅 自作孽不可活
投資最緊要係資金安全，賺咗都要拎得返
一講金融又要講到制度
一講制度又扯到去政治
所以唔講啦😂😂
你知我知連單眼佬都知，係嗰件小學生唔知。
生活有咩唔涉及政治？
在新加坡只要有份工，就可以成為新加坡永久居民，但要成為新加坡公民，非常困難，政策不透明，很多人，到退休時，仍然未取得公民權，只好返回原居居地，到老一埸空！
聰明而又有資格移民的香港人，佢哋會選擇移民到澳洲，加拿大，紐西蘭，很少選擇移民到新加坡！
@@yau7639 投資新加坡市場股票並不需要移民新加坡，現在在討論香港和新加坡的投資選擇
大陸都就快爆煲，香港咁耐都只係食老本，睇睇資金嘅流出同股市表現，只會演變成大陸其中一個金融中心。
Absolutely. Singapore has completely overhauled HK in every major field, be it in finance, living standards, university rankings etc etc. HK is on a downward spiral, there's nothing anyone can stop this trajectory in the near future.
But not on nationality law haha, hk uk and usa passport can beat just a single Singaporean passport lol
@@sunlijen3974Singapore Passport is one of the strongest in the world. HK dont even come close.
在新加坡只要有份工，就可以成為新加坡永久居民，但要成為新加坡公民，非常困難，政策不透明，很多人，到退休時，仍然未取得公民權，只好返回原居居地，到老一埸空！
聰明而又有資格移民的香港人，佢哋會選擇移民到澳洲，加拿大，紐西蘭，很少選擇移民到新加坡！
@@sgboon Agreed. It snatches the top spot in the latest Henley Passport Index rankings.
@@yau7639 It's as difficult as naturalization in Switzerland. The only thing I don't like about Singapore is conscription. People should be given a choice, not by force to have the military training. If they don't have enough soldiers, they could do what the French do, and that's to set up a foreign legion, i.e. mercenary. Since Singapore is a wealthy country, I don't think it will mind spending a few bob.
無爭過，一直都係香港，而家係香港吾願玩，拱手相讓比新加坡！ 如果香港仲係2019之前，新加坡都無可能啦
SG never competes with HK, because we are different. 新加坡从来就没拿香港作为竞争对手，因为我们都来自不同的社会政治背景。HK cuisine mainly Cantonese whereas SG covers many different types of food. 香港粤菜一流；新加坡提供世界不同料理。所以，新加坡和香港无法同等比较的。 Therefore, no way to compare between SG and HK fairly.
香港主要係官員廢才，財爺大事無料到，小事搞個夜市經濟都失敗，咁樣的官員李家超和中央可以忍L到，先好嘢.李顯龍同香港特首出來講嘢，起碼我呢個外人都聽得出來真誠，我地D官真係官字兩把口.
易拉下馬 才好操縱
你望吓香港有邊個人可以管得掂班香港人先仲話咩港人治港笑大人個口咩啲人又經常咁激進部分人又唔合作攜手共建就注定玩完啦！傻的嗎係都走高端路線仲玩乜嘢夜市賣魚蛋一啲都唔高效益不過呢啲確實係可以俾啲市民賺下錢仔玩吓嘅😂
不能把新加坡和香港的領導人直接比較，因為新加坡是國家，而且如彈丸般小，背後沒有靠山，自己國家搞不定，就會被鄰國吞併。所以，新加坡出產的領導人，是必須高瞻遠足，是政治強人，否則就會亡國。而香港是中國的一個行政區，只是地方領導，背後的靠山就是中國整個國家，配合國家政策行事就可以。而且港英年代的香港政府，由於利益衝突，當然不會培育政治人才，也不允許製造政治人才的土壤，只許本地官員當執行者的角色，然後扶植所謂的民主政黨，為英國日後撤離後，干預香港政治。沒有強勢領導人的香港，怎能與新加坡的領導人相比？根本就是不同檔次。
我是金融業的打工仔，新加坡的金融市場跟香港根本沒得比，大部分投行和基金經理的亞洲總部都是在香港而非新加坡。瘦死的駱駝比馬大。
投行?仲有大陸條水做先係再講野啦
@@professorlau6768 哈哈，你知唔知港交所的market cap係新交所的幾多倍？
很奇怪！为什么这么多人盯着新加坡，超过这个又超过那个。新加坡人都吃下了别人给于他的称谓，小红点，鼻屎大的。政府方面，从老李到小李，从没叫人民去超越这个国家、那个地方。不像一些精英，为了上位过者是一上了位就大言不惭的说在什么时候就要超越新加坡。新加坡人只要做好本份，只求国泰民安，很多时候是会退一步海阔天空。
問你呀，星加波有軍隊，雖然唔打得但都叫有呀，咁香港呢？？
已經超越了，
但小心步香港的後塵。
Rain, your vlog is very informative.Also, you looks very sweet and beautiful
新加坡冇國際政治因素影響、香港有，但香港在個人行為上比較自由好多，最小唔洗打滕😊新加坡人口約570萬公民約400多少少萬非公民佔150萬有多人，流動性不確定性非常大
欢迎光临 新加坡
People predicted the passage of Article 23 National Security Law would be the nail on the coffin for Hong Kong. Looking at Hong Kong today, I have to agree their prediction was correct.
Independence movement, riots, trigger national security law; HK will never be the same!
Yes, the 23 law will be the last nail , freedom of information will be even more restricted, no surprise if google service get kick out
你知道为什么中国要在香港制定国安法？
@@张先生-n7v1u 你知不知道國安法已經對香港原本的法治，造成多大的影響？
@@cytwlm 你认为面对当时香港的乱局，不立法北京应该作何应对？没有国安法会不会一直搞社会运动？
新加坡👍👍👍
香港重有IPO咩🤔一定唔會係香港。。香港藍籌股全部大陸已經唔係國際性同依加成交得幾百億。。。以前係幾千億。。。重玩香港股🤔要玩都玩美股啦😅
「當大部分人都想住喺一個政治穩定、開心嘅社會。享受自由又快速嘅資訊」，淨係呢兩句，香港已經被排除在外啦。
好簡單，如果有人喺呢條片留言「那首不能說出名字的歌」，都幾可能有啲手尾跟。
政治穩定❌
咁就開心❌
自由❌
快速仍然有嘅，因為已經係基建嚟
如果要改善不如嘗試撇開偏見先但係大部分人未開始已經pan左其實成日講嚟講去話要自由，不過你而家冇享受到嗎你生活上有啲咩限制？正常人生活應該冇乜影響到，都唔明你地心虛啲咩你有冇做過啲咩唔會無啦啦搞呢啲小市民😂
點解而家政策會收緊因為啲人玩嘢所以越係咁政策越嚟越緊儘管可能唔關你同我嘅事但我哋都係香港人所有嘢大家都係同舟共濟，點解會有規矩咪就係因為啲人做唔好，所以先要定啲規矩嚟規範啲人點解咁簡單嘅道理都唔明嘅😂
香港搞成今日，是19年之前，有人勾結外部勢力，在香港搞顏色革命，然後才被中央整頓收緊。由於香港如你這樣的愚民太多，配合了外部勢力，搞死自己的家園。顏色革命已過了幾年，還未看清現實，倒果為因？悲哀！
香港要國家安全就得~ 唔駛金融架
是的,香港最重要是國家安全,人民的肚子自然會飽的,何必做金融大哥呢😂
新加坡不需要安全？
暴動、縱火 😂 😂
星是國家，香港是城市，超越很正常！不超越就要檢討一下了.
I suspect most “Singapore supporters” in the comments probably doesn’t even qualify to be Singaporeans or PR. Just a bunch of China haters here. It’s a sad truth. 請不要酸，這只是客觀現實。
There’s no point comparing the two, there’s no trophy to be won. I have friends in Singapore and I am happy they gave a good life there, and it is because they are a productive part of their economy and on an individual level, that’s all that counts. But while they enjoy their living there, it’s not all roses, and they have their many concerns. One of my friends is eligible and considering renouncing his UK citizenship and to become a Singaporean, because he loves the city so much, however, his children will be required to join their military when they come of age. Another friend had been there for over 20 years, and to this day is not eligible to become citizen (I’m not 100% of their immigration policies but it’s very difficult for sure). For me, while I’d like to live in Singapore but my experiences don’t translate well in there, so I’m not even eligible to be a PR, unless I plan to pay and retire there, which is a really expensive choice.
I do have to admit some acquaintances are in Singapore due to their “wealth worries”. But to be quite honest, their source of “wealth” is somewhat vague and dodgy, and Singapore is not a country that will let these kind of wealth taint their status quo, and we see adjustments in their policies already.
But individual cases differ and there’s not one “comparison” that fits all. It’s not a football game where you cheer the one team over another. You can go ahead and move to Singapore if you want, but those who aren’t even eligible (including myself) should just make decisions based on their own situations.
在新加坡只要有份工，就可以成為新加坡永久居民，但要成為新加坡公民，非常困難，政策不透明，很多人，到退休時，仍然未取得公民權，只好返回原居居地，到老一埸空！
聰明而又有資格移民的香港人，佢哋會選擇移民到澳洲，加拿大，紐西蘭，很少選擇移民到新加坡！
香港已经仆街佐几年啦! 人同钱都去佐新加坡啦! 新加坡已经成为了亚洲唯一的国际金融中心, 而香港的港币若还能有三年命就偷笑啦!😂
@@xander2890人同錢都去左新加坡？你講你自己？
新 加坡 人高達8成人只能住在政府的 組屋，主要是新加 坡土地非常昂貴，貴到爆 炸，8成人根本買不起一般私樓，階級十分容易劃分出來，只要問你住 哪就知道你是不是窮人，另外新加坡 組屋只擁有使用權，將來要賣也只 能賣給政府，再讓政府去分配給其 他人，因此不可能賺到價差，當然也 不能讓子女繼承！除面積大啲之外，衰過香港居屋和公屋！
新加坡政府一言堂，完全不擔心選票，佢哋反對黨完全冇作為！有少少威脅，都被政府告誹謗，直至破產為止！破產者，不能參選😅
好好睇，好睇過 Lorey 個邊😊
新加坡人会讲和写马来珸，卬度语，华语和英语，不管什么样的人都能沟通交流。
As English is the first language
Thank you for your sharing 😊👍🥰
放心，香港仍是「天朝大國」(共產中國) 和「第三世界國際」 (俄羅斯、白俄羅斯、中亞細亞、伊朗、阿拉伯世界、東南亞、塔利班政府、真主黨、胡塞武裝組織、哈馬斯、非洲、委內瑞拉、塞爾維亞、巴基斯坦、斯里蘭卡) 之間的金融中心。😅
仲有東盟，金磚五國，一帶一路沿線國家，加埋已經超過全球經濟8成！
@@yau7639 係咪