Mr Japan, you have said the magic words " Cheap Labour." Typical big businesses & corporations they all supports foreign labours instead of training their own. It is all about the costs. Australia is one of the culprits. The amount of foreign workers entered Australia after covid 2019 was mind boggling. Keep up the good work Mr Japan.
Tech workers in the US don’t want the supply curve to be driven up by tech immigrants. They don’t want their wages to reduced or stagnate. Pretty obvious why a lot of tech workers don’t want those immigrants from Asia. It feels as though we are being betrayed as Americans by everyone in power in America. In fact it’s felt this way for quite some time. It’s one of the reasons I’m learning Japanese as my third language as a backup plan.
that’s exactly the same as DIE (diversity and inclusion politics) shitty american tech workers & “woke” tech workers are not the people i want being responsible for our data and electronic products. no shade on california but they have fallen to this point.
It is not that Americans have an issue with legal immigration. It is that American have an issue with the leaders of corporations skipping the domestic talent pool to hire non citizen immigrants like H1B1 visa holders. Americans are told to get degrees in university and then when they go into debt to get a degree in Software Engineering or other tech disciplines they are rewarded with either being pushed out of the tech labor market entirely or getting a job that does not pay enough to justify the effort.
But how do you pretend to be a corporation, and not want to generate and save as much money as possible? You might want to switch to anything other than capitalism my friend..
@@IronJhon788you might want to prepare for being dirt poor my friend because if the last decent paying jobs in the country are gone you’re never going to be able to make another dollar again.
Pragmatically though, is it easier to churn out more top 0.1% engineers from domestic universities, or just offer visas to top 0.1% engineers from all around the globe?
@@shugyosha7924 If it was just the top 0.1% then that would be fine. There is a different Visa for that though known as the O-1 not the H1-B1. The H1-B1 Visa is not for ultra high specialized skills but more general skill sets. If you are looking just for the top 0.1% in a field internationally you are going to offer a 0-1 Visa.
But he is also right.. you have to find 0.1% genius people for innovation, creation. Rare people capable of finding solutions for complex problems or bring up ideas to table. I believe Elon referring rare talented people not labor force.
@@interestedincphpsqlmysql4222 That's what they said when they said to embrace mass influx, ive still not seen that happen. Funny how we are now having to pay for those that were supposed to "save" the welfare system.
@@SvengelskaBlondie I am not sure what went wrong. But apparently American people don't want to work in industry involved with tech.. Perhaps I am wrong.. but I rarely meet a American software developer (majority of people I worked Indian rarely Chinese some of them from Russia) I am curious about the reason. Perhaps due low salary they are going for other jobs. What company supposed to do under this situation?
@@interestedincphpsqlmysql4222 I don't currently work in I.T. but I once did, and still have many contacts in the field. The domestic supply was always there. What I hear about from my associates is that the H1B1 Visa program *is indeed* abused by companies for cheap labor. The wage flattening effect of the supply inflation is a concern.. However, the larger issue lies in the fact that many (or most) of the immigrant workers aren't as skilled as Elon and Vivek proclaim. One of my industry associates referrerenced a previous job where he was managing a mostly Chinese and Indian software development Visa team. His exact words in describing their programming ability was "mediocre at best, dog-shit at worst." This was combined with constant culture clashes and communication errors. He wasn't the only one that shared these experiences. A couple of my friends ended up leaving corporate I.T. and stuck strictly to private consulting. One of them has joked around about half of his job consisting of "fixing the mistakes of foreign workers and DIY projects." Which he ends up charging double for. I never annectdotally experienced anything similar. Though I have noticed a disturbingly large amount of recent I.T. college graduates *(from all backgrounds)* with horrendous troubleshooting abilities.... I'll just have to keep my fingers crossed and hope for the best. Worst case scenario, I still have enough skills to fix my own shit.😅😅😅
What Talent gap? It is tiring excuses being said. America doesn’t protect their entry level jobs and outsource outside of America. You will see ridiculous requirements for entry level job, then act like they couldn’t find someone who could do the job… then interview a foreigner who lacks the skill and higher them. They will prefer hiring H1B1 to work in their company not because they are skilled at that job, but because they are cheaper and will likely work longer hours as they are accustomed to it in their country. It doesn’t take a rocket scientist to do a lot of these IT jobs, little training and they can get the job done. There is absolutely no reason why the jobs should go to an H1B1 worker. Yes, many companies have moved part of their companies to Europe and Asia. Not for the skilled workers, but cheaper workers. Didn’t Apple invest 3 billion in educating Malaysians to work for them.
To make a complicated issue simple. Basically trumps supporters don't want immigration in general though they will claim its just illegal immigration. The whole idea is that Trump is supposed to bring back more American jobs and to fix the economy for Americans and part of that is cracking down on immigration. So when they see that there making an exception and bringing immigrants in to work instead of choosing Americans it feels like a betrayal. I'm not a supporter but I would feel betrayed to.
3:22 you’re using japanese mouth movements to speak english words; you’ll get better soon; being an American….? the definition of that changes everyday
4:20 He’s saying that American culture values fun and degenerate behavior, not intelligence or morality. The athletes get praise, and smart people are ignored.
The problem with the H1B's in this controversy is that it's supposed to be a skilled worker visa for people who have skills they can't find or hire for in the local economy.
Wow Mr Japan, I didn't expect you to cover this topic! I'm an American white collar worker, so I have strong opinions on this topic in favor of Americans. I know that the service sector in Japan has been bringing in immigrants to help with the labor shortage. Is there a similar trend for white collar workers in Japan?
I think some foreign workers want to be in Japan ,but not as many as the US because the wages are so low..... I think the wages in Japan are too low to attract Immigrants workers from all over the world🤔
Mr Japan- the brunette is obviously not telling you the truth. She is paid to not tell the truth, if you catch my drift. How do we know that? You saw what Trump actually said, brother.
Im canadian and I want to get H1B visa to work in the USA. You get much more money making $USD than $CAD working the in exact same job field. Ironically this is because in Canada it’s very easy for immigrants to work in my sector. So obviously governments should try to protect their jobs for their citizens but every individual is ultimately looking out for themselves first.
4:24 "what is he saying" He is saying that America focuses too much on glorifying people that are essentially just dancing monkeys, they glorify entertainers, movie stars and music talents. These are fine but they are not needed. The people that built the country, that make the country function and that put forth all the inventions to make it work, they don't get nearly as much attention. The latter is more important, without it you couldn't have the former in any real capacity (just look at how much tech people are needed to do anything in the entertaining industry). 7:18 "So many options" You have well over 60 options, unlike Japanese where you have 0 options, despite how "beautiful" the language is. 17:13 "Idk" From what ive heard, they are mad at both illegal and H-1B1 abuse, allot of people get in that shouldn't get in cause they don't really fit the criteria. That's a thing that people don't like, when the so called high skilled aren't so high skilled.
"Japanese where you have 0 options" Yes sometimes I feel like Japanese Government has made English education so bad on purpose so Japanese people can never leave....🤣
Why are Japanese ALWAYS so worried about their accents? It is one of the reasons why it holds a lot of people back from learning English when it's not even the most important thing.
We need to look at what proportion of these visa holders are actually “highly skilled”. It looks like a part of them just work in restaurants for example. Even if they are highly skilled that doesn’t guarantee that they will assimilate into the culture. The US immigration system allows citizens to sponsor relatives to come over too, who are (from my experience in the Silicon Valley) LESS interested in assimilating.
@@MJapan0 you can still do it! the more you immerse yourself in the environment the more your accent shift! there's plenty of people who can speak only American after being for decades in the US, even if they moved in their thirties👍😎
nono we would welcome you in the US...the issue with h1b isnt immigration its about jobs!! a lot of employers are laying off american workers to hire h1bs for tech jobs because they are cheaper and will tolerate unfair abuse by employers. I work in tech and I had a really hard time finding a new job because all the work is being done by indians working remotely or h1bs visas so it is unfair. It's a totally different issue than immigration. Anyways americans love japanese you will be welcomed!
Elon Musk is starting to make his voice sounds like he runs our country because he is a billionair. Elon do not step out of bound and start to demand to dictate and force your will on us american just because you are a close friend of President Trump. Elon and Ramaswamy are starting to sound like they the two of them will control our destiny. Both of you should becareful and know your limitation. We american are not stupid people. Just because both of you are rich, you think you have right to force us to obey your will. You two are starting to annoy the american people with your arrogant.
In my opinion, companies should be free to employ foreign workers as their own expense. It’s a different conversation if they use tax payers money to poach foreigners into their country.
Let's be honest: some American corporations cheat the H1B visa system by falsely claiming that they can't find an American worker to fill the vacancy, so that they have to resort to an H1B holder. Unfortunately, immigration and the federal government doesn't care to investigate scummy corporate behavior
I got good news for you Shohei Ohtani and his wife Mamiko Tanaka is expecting their first child, so there you go. Maybe they'll have more babies in the future since he makes millions of dollars anyway.
There is simply a talent gap in the tech industry between those highly skilled foreigners and homegrown Americans. This talent gap extends over time. Allow young Americans to catch up and then maybe they can be in a competitive position.
the problem is that there's a gap in every software industry from web development to low level programming. In low level software you're already behind atleast 10 years, there's simply less hardware that exists in the American market that is intended for people to mess with.. I can't articulate it enough, but if there are Americans reading this, look into open-source firmware, like keyboards and routers, or android kernel development. That's where most people start, Chinese people are already advanced in those
lmao. they're giving work permits to fresh college grads. they have no skills, just cheap cost. guess our gov will actually have to run a campaign for white men for once.
I am guessing companies will not wait to catch up they will simply move their production line somewhere cheaper and reliable. AKA China or any other alternate like India. This is what trump trying to prevent with extra taxes.. but I doubt it will work out.
Ppl need to stop being racist as long as you work in this country and pay tax and good behavior you supposed to be more than welcome in fact I would prefer good non citizen rather than citizen who make problem and destroy tax payers stuff
Then being an American means nothing. We will just be in an economic zone the world can dump its problems in. Your belief is what got us in this mess you accept everything one cause your lazy and your afraid
Thank you so much for watching guys🥰 Elon Musk is the King?? 🤣🤣
you can become American! It is not over!🥹👍😎
Hahaha🤣
Mr Japan, you have said the magic words " Cheap Labour." Typical big businesses & corporations they all supports foreign labours instead of training their own. It is all about the costs. Australia is one of the culprits. The amount of foreign workers entered Australia after covid 2019 was mind boggling. Keep up the good work Mr Japan.
Thank you so much🙏
Tech workers in the US don’t want the supply curve to be driven up by tech immigrants. They don’t want their wages to reduced or stagnate. Pretty obvious why a lot of tech workers don’t want those immigrants from Asia. It feels as though we are being betrayed as Americans by everyone in power in America.
In fact it’s felt this way for quite some time. It’s one of the reasons I’m learning Japanese as my third language as a backup plan.
Thanks for sharing your thoughts
America First means American First it's a no brainer.
that’s exactly the same as DIE (diversity and inclusion politics)
shitty american tech workers & “woke” tech workers are not the people i want being responsible for our data and electronic products.
no shade on california but they have fallen to this point.
😎
It is not that Americans have an issue with legal immigration. It is that American have an issue with the leaders of corporations skipping the domestic talent pool to hire non citizen immigrants like H1B1 visa holders. Americans are told to get degrees in university and then when they go into debt to get a degree in Software Engineering or other tech disciplines they are rewarded with either being pushed out of the tech labor market entirely or getting a job that does not pay enough to justify the effort.
Thanks for sharing your thoughts🙏
But how do you pretend to be a corporation, and not want to generate and save as much money as possible? You might want to switch to anything other than capitalism my friend..
@@IronJhon788you might want to prepare for being dirt poor my friend because if the last decent paying jobs in the country are gone you’re never going to be able to make another dollar again.
Pragmatically though, is it easier to churn out more top 0.1% engineers from domestic universities, or just offer visas to top 0.1% engineers from all around the globe?
@@shugyosha7924 If it was just the top 0.1% then that would be fine. There is a different Visa for that though known as the O-1 not the H1-B1. The H1-B1 Visa is not for ultra high specialized skills but more general skill sets. If you are looking just for the top 0.1% in a field internationally you are going to offer a 0-1 Visa.
A country should prioritize its own citizens.
But he is also right.. you have to find 0.1% genius people for innovation, creation.
Rare people capable of finding solutions for complex problems or bring up ideas to table.
I believe Elon referring rare talented people not labor force.
@@interestedincphpsqlmysql4222 That's what they said when they said to embrace mass influx, ive still not seen that happen. Funny how we are now having to pay for those that were supposed to "save" the welfare system.
@@interestedincphpsqlmysql4222 there’s already a program for it genius. Their plan wants an unlimited amount of people coming in.
@@SvengelskaBlondie I am not sure what went wrong. But apparently American people don't want to work in industry involved with tech.. Perhaps I am wrong.. but I rarely meet a American software developer (majority of people I worked Indian rarely Chinese some of them from Russia) I am curious about the reason. Perhaps due low salary they are going for other jobs. What company supposed to do under this situation?
@@interestedincphpsqlmysql4222 I don't currently work in I.T. but I once did, and still have many contacts in the field. The domestic supply was always there. What I hear about from my associates is that the H1B1 Visa program *is indeed* abused by companies for cheap labor.
The wage flattening effect of the supply inflation is a concern.. However, the larger issue lies in the fact that many (or most) of the immigrant workers aren't as skilled as Elon and Vivek proclaim.
One of my industry associates referrerenced a previous job where he was managing a mostly Chinese and Indian software development Visa team. His exact words in describing their programming ability was "mediocre at best, dog-shit at worst." This was combined with constant culture clashes and communication errors. He wasn't the only one that shared these experiences.
A couple of my friends ended up leaving corporate I.T. and stuck strictly to private consulting. One of them has joked around about half of his job consisting of "fixing the mistakes of foreign workers and DIY projects." Which he ends up charging double for.
I never annectdotally experienced anything similar. Though I have noticed a disturbingly large amount of recent I.T. college graduates *(from all backgrounds)* with horrendous troubleshooting abilities.... I'll just have to keep my fingers crossed and hope for the best. Worst case scenario, I still have enough skills to fix my own shit.😅😅😅
What Talent gap? It is tiring excuses being said. America doesn’t protect their entry level jobs and outsource outside of America. You will see ridiculous requirements for entry level job, then act like they couldn’t find someone who could do the job… then interview a foreigner who lacks the skill and higher them. They will prefer hiring H1B1 to work in their company not because they are skilled at that job, but because they are cheaper and will likely work longer hours as they are accustomed to it in their country. It doesn’t take a rocket scientist to do a lot of these IT jobs, little training and they can get the job done. There is absolutely no reason why the jobs should go to an H1B1 worker.
Yes, many companies have moved part of their companies to Europe and Asia. Not for the skilled workers, but cheaper workers. Didn’t Apple invest 3 billion in educating Malaysians to work for them.
Searching for cheap labors never ends..
To make a complicated issue simple. Basically trumps supporters don't want immigration in general though they will claim its just illegal immigration. The whole idea is that Trump is supposed to bring back more American jobs and to fix the economy for Americans and part of that is cracking down on immigration. So when they see that there making an exception and bringing immigrants in to work instead of choosing Americans it feels like a betrayal. I'm not a supporter but I would feel betrayed to.
Americans aren't qualified for the jobs, to begin with.
So no immigration into your country then
Thanks for the info🙏
Elon will be brought to heel. Americans first, America first. America should train it's youth and not the youth of foreign countries.
The US has been sucking up all the brains of the world since its inception.
Are you willing to pay higher prices?
@@AughtelMost people are as long as there's no erosion of social trust, just ask countries as different as China and Israel.
@@lain9719 what do you mean by social trust?
@@lain9719 social trust 🤣
3:22 you’re using japanese mouth movements to speak english words; you’ll get better soon;
being an American….? the definition of that changes everyday
I am trying to sound better everyday my friend😎
4:20
He’s saying that American culture values fun and degenerate behavior, not intelligence or morality. The athletes get praise, and smart people are ignored.
The problem with the H1B's in this controversy is that it's supposed to be a skilled worker visa for people who have skills they can't find or hire for in the local economy.
Wow Mr Japan, I didn't expect you to cover this topic! I'm an American white collar worker, so I have strong opinions on this topic in favor of Americans.
I know that the service sector in Japan has been bringing in immigrants to help with the labor shortage. Is there a similar trend for white collar workers in Japan?
I think some foreign workers want to be in Japan ,but not as many as the US because the wages are so low..... I think the wages in Japan are too low to attract Immigrants workers from all over the world🤔
Mr Japan- the brunette is obviously not telling you the truth. She is paid to not tell the truth, if you catch my drift. How do we know that? You saw what Trump actually said, brother.
Im canadian and I want to get H1B visa to work in the USA. You get much more money making $USD than $CAD working the in exact same job field. Ironically this is because in Canada it’s very easy for immigrants to work in my sector. So obviously governments should try to protect their jobs for their citizens but every individual is ultimately looking out for themselves first.
4:18 legit
4:24 "what is he saying"
He is saying that America focuses too much on glorifying people that are essentially just dancing monkeys, they glorify entertainers, movie stars and music talents. These are fine but they are not needed. The people that built the country, that make the country function and that put forth all the inventions to make it work, they don't get nearly as much attention. The latter is more important, without it you couldn't have the former in any real capacity (just look at how much tech people are needed to do anything in the entertaining industry).
7:18 "So many options"
You have well over 60 options, unlike Japanese where you have 0 options, despite how "beautiful" the language is.
17:13 "Idk"
From what ive heard, they are mad at both illegal and H-1B1 abuse, allot of people get in that shouldn't get in cause they don't really fit the criteria. That's a thing that people don't like, when the so called high skilled aren't so high skilled.
"Japanese where you have 0 options"
Yes sometimes I feel like Japanese Government has made English education so bad on purpose so Japanese people can never leave....🤣
you can hire 5 hindu or 1 native
Why are Japanese ALWAYS so worried about their accents? It is one of the reasons why it holds a lot of people back from learning English when it's not even the most important thing.
SInce you are in the US now, how does it feel that American Healthcare is greedy
I am in Japan my friend😱
@@MJapan0 THE SHOCKING TRUTH
We need to look at what proportion of these visa holders are actually “highly skilled”. It looks like a part of them just work in restaurants for example. Even if they are highly skilled that doesn’t guarantee that they will assimilate into the culture. The US immigration system allows citizens to sponsor relatives to come over too, who are (from my experience in the Silicon Valley) LESS interested in assimilating.
8:10 I think Elon Musk has a very similar accent to the American one cause he moved from SouthAfrica pretty young
I wanted to sound like American too... I was too late🥹
@@MJapan0 you can still do it! the more you immerse yourself in the environment the more your accent shift! there's plenty of people who can speak only American after being for decades in the US, even if they moved in their thirties👍😎
nono we would welcome you in the US...the issue with h1b isnt immigration its about jobs!! a lot of employers are laying off american workers to hire h1bs for tech jobs because they are cheaper and will tolerate unfair abuse by employers. I work in tech and I had a really hard time finding a new job because all the work is being done by indians working remotely or h1bs visas so it is unfair. It's a totally different issue than immigration. Anyways americans love japanese you will be welcomed!
you can be american...your english is as good as the indians they have a very heavy accent
Oh you want to remain in Japan 🇯🇵
That’s Good 👍🏻 your Country needs You!
Japan needs Mr Japan👍😎
I want to say.. for the next 20 years.. Yes and after that... who knows🤔
haha maybe not😂
Elon Musk is starting to make his voice sounds like he runs our country because he is a billionair. Elon do not step out of bound and start to demand to dictate and force your will on us american just because you are a close friend of President Trump. Elon and Ramaswamy are starting to sound like they the two of them will control our destiny. Both of you should becareful and know your limitation. We american are not stupid people. Just because both of you are rich, you think you have right to force us to obey your will. You two are starting to annoy the american people with your arrogant.
Thanks for sharing your thoughts🙏
it was always fake. we went through all of this in 2016.
indian english is closer to a fully developed katakana english which is a nightmare for communication
katakana is easier to understand
Whose job are you taking anyways by coming to the US?
Just try to live somewhere in the United States 🇺🇸 for a long time. Eventually the American will set in!
Hahaha🤣
In my opinion, companies should be free to employ foreign workers as their own expense. It’s a different conversation if they use tax payers money to poach foreigners into their country.
so you're brown
Thanks for sharing your thoughts👍
Let's be honest: some American corporations cheat the H1B visa system by falsely claiming that they can't find an American worker to fill the vacancy, so that they have to resort to an H1B holder. Unfortunately, immigration and the federal government doesn't care to investigate scummy corporate behavior
I got good news for you Shohei Ohtani and his wife Mamiko Tanaka is expecting their first child, so there you go. Maybe they'll have more babies in the future since he makes millions of dollars anyway.
Not a fan of musk and vivek, but without the h1b visa, the US education system would probably collapse😂
You mean F1 international student visa?
🤣
There is simply a talent gap in the tech industry between those highly skilled foreigners and homegrown Americans. This talent gap extends over time. Allow young Americans to catch up and then maybe they can be in a competitive position.
the problem is that there's a gap in every software industry from web development to low level programming.
In low level software you're already behind atleast 10 years, there's simply less hardware that exists in the American market that is intended for people to mess with..
I can't articulate it enough, but if there are Americans reading this, look into open-source firmware, like keyboards and routers, or android kernel development. That's where most people start, Chinese people are already advanced in those
lmao. they're giving work permits to fresh college grads. they have no skills, just cheap cost.
guess our gov will actually have to run a campaign for white men for once.
I am guessing companies will not wait to catch up they will simply move their production line somewhere cheaper and reliable.
AKA China or any other alternate like India. This is what trump trying to prevent with extra taxes.. but I doubt it will work out.
Ppl need to stop being racist as long as you work in this country and pay tax and good behavior you supposed to be more than welcome in fact I would prefer good non citizen rather than citizen who make problem and destroy tax payers stuff
Then being an American means nothing. We will just be in an economic zone the world can dump its problems in. Your belief is what got us in this mess you accept everything one cause your lazy and your afraid
Mr JAPAN 2028!!!
Haha PM of Japan?? Maybe not me🤣