What military equipment is China selling to Russia? | DW News
Вставка
- Опубліковано 14 лют 2023
- Companies aiding the Russian military despite Western sanctions is of growing concern for the Ukrainian allies. The G7 is reportedly now discussing further sanctions on Chinese companies for supplying non-lethal aid to Russia. Volodymyr Zelenskyy has been asking western countries to tighten sanctions against Russia. In June the US sanctioned five Chinese companies, but in September Biden said there was no evidence of China providing weapons to Russia.
Data analysts say there is clear evidence that China has dramatically increased military shipments to Russia since Putin's forces invaded Ukraine. A network of Chinese defense companies, operating directly under the Chinese state-owned assets commission, has been steadily supplying Russia wih the military hardware it needs. Almost 2000 companies operate within the Poly Group network, including a defense conglomerate called Poly Technologies. In October a company called China Taly Aviation shipped radar parts for the S-400 anti-aircraft system to a Russian defense contractor, Almaz Antey. That transaction was detailed in a Wall Street Journal Article, based on data from C-4 ADS; and between June and November there were multiple shipments of parts for M171 helicopters - this time Poly Technologies selling to Ulan Ude Aviation Plant. But because of complex supply chains, it's not just Chinese companies that are implicated.
Subscribe: ua-cam.com/users/deutsche...
For more news go to: www.dw.com/en/
Follow DW on social media:
►Facebook: / deutschewellenews
►Twitter: / dwnews
►Instagram: / dwnews
►Twitch: / dwnews_hangout
Für Videos in deutscher Sprache besuchen Sie: / dwdeutsch
#Russia #China #Sanctions
What a shocking, unbelievable and totally expected story.
What's news story next? North Korea will continue not to sanction Russia.😆
why? what did you expected? and what is the difference with the European war trade witj South Arabia?
It's not unexpected. All goods from from China needs to be sanctioned.
@@Crashed131963 ikr!
@@pierrevallet6188 What are you trying to say? What is "south arabia" as that's not a country, it's a region.
What did he mean by "despite international sanctions". I don't remember any of such a part from the western countries so the best term is western sanctions.
And how many people can afford made in America products? India also trading with Russia. Will you sanction them all? 😂then sanction everyone on the globe. These three countries are populous than the west by far. Think about that 😅
International sanction or western sanction😂
@@jungletunes3923 international sanction because even some not in western region are participating that sanction.
@@USMLEBOOSTER the question is who really control the prices? Is it the US or other countries or few individuals who has much wealth to control the world?
American sanctions, US has sanctions on over 50 countries fools !
The Chinese government has the morals of a business executive
They will go with whatever makes them the most profit
What about USA NATO ?
😂😂Isn't America like this?
@@hi4806 to an extent, yes
@@timslomkl USA isnt making any money from NATO. USA is THE biggest spender on NATO.
USA elites are making the most profit from the Ukrain war. US tax payer money is being sent to Ukrain in the form of military aid, boosting defence contractor stock prices, making them richer.
After the war, ukraine will own US government a lot of money, and nothing is free, making politicians richer.
Blackrock has signed a deal to help rebuild ukraine after the war with taxpayer money. This money will go into politician pockets and shareholders of Blackrock. While there, they will surely plunder the natural resources and buy up the dirt cheap war-torn prices of post-war Ukrainian. They might get a small fine for being naughty if the media find out.
Rinse and repeat. This is how the West makes money, baby. China is just copying, but the West does not like competitors, only want monolopy.
I live in UK with free health care, education, and social benefits do this system benefits me greatly.
The west is the best, its better than the rest, please don't test, we don't jest
"International sanctions" what international organization is that? The UN? Lol
Europe, US Japan and and and. The civilized world.
@@ernstschwaig4667 The civilized world.????lmao.
@@ernstschwaig4667 Mafia country lol
@@ernstschwaig4667 then it is not international. besides, really hard to say the USA is civilized, they blow off the NordStream 1/2.
@@ernstschwaig4667 What does China have to do with them? China has not imposed any sanctions and can trade with anyone.
Except for Australia and Latvia, which China has imposed sanctions on.
International sanctions?
I laughed hard when I heard that 😅.
Impossible to sanction china, entire world economy will collapse
west keeps confusing it self for a world.
@@maboketshabeclement4078 GDP of the west is still the majority worldwide even without china, russia and the other third wourld countries 🤣
So yes we could sanction china!
@@ElRabito Good luck!
Really? I wouldn't have guess! 😆😆😆
Not International sanctions but NATO sanctions
wrong.
several countries not in NATO have joined sanctions.
@@wamingo A group of white people doesn't even make half the world's population. Lmao
@@wamingo The vast majority of countries did not participate in the so-called sanctions, and China and India continued to buy Russian oil and gas.
@@hi4806 India bought ruzkie oil at a steep discount. Russia lost money big time. Then India resells it to the west for a big profit.
IOW, India is de-facto participating in the sanctions scheme.
160 countries continue to trade with China while staying away from war in Europe.
Their failing to defeat Russia in Ukraine now they are blaming everybody
The chinese company are with the blessing of PCC , TAIWAN USA SUPORT come what great cost..
Team Putin is not even winning
@@HK-ce2lj we are winning big time we are the reason NATO ministers meet every day
@@BBB-zc6sb it's been a year and you're still struggling to move beyond your boarder
@@HK-ce2lj Because we fighting against 50+countries that are sending weapons and mercenaries to Ukraine tel west to stop helping Ukraine than we will show you
Another mind boggling revelation.
hahahahahah
Nato give ukraine free arms. China selling arms to russia for money what is wrong with that??
@@iggy5347 the "mind boggling" is that China says one thing and does the opposite.
@@PjotrII yes. Meaning untrustworthy. As it has mote frequently shows. I ask you what haopens if you have a continuously untrustworthy familily member? Thats right. EVEN while related by blood family members distance themselves from that person. Now you can imagine why international community which is abidjng by international law, and by respect to souvereignity, looks with disdain how China is delivering parts to a nation that is systematically wiping out a people and its identty and its land and culture. In the most barbaric way
@@PjotrII sounds like the USA blow off the NS1 and 2.
Bunch of vassals of the US can't even decide their future, poor doggies
Russia is the one with the dumb puppets
@@stereomaster4231 they have 2 compared to the US
6 months ago, same DW "without the western parts the Russian military will run out of advanced equipment in a matter of weeks", DW now "oh no Chinese are delivering the necessary advanced electronics to the Russians, who could have predicted this "
those statements are both factual and neither are they mutually exclusive. its called good and objective reporting.
Russia are using old ammo and are begging for drones from places like Iran. So desperate that they had to enroll hundreds thousands more soldiers from their people. They still haven't reached their goals in a far less populated country with a less advanced army a year in.
@@eskobaros if you couldn’t predict that China would fill the void then I don’t know what to tell you…
Both are true, so what's your problem?
Let's see if the choppers from China will last as long as the tyres that they sold to russian military.
Why the headlines use question mark? It means news is unsure or false .
Because it's a direct question. Question marks go at the end of a question. Read it again.
No, it means they sell mil equipment, here is the list (helicopter parts, radar, S400 and so on)
BING CHILLING
can you even read English?
你甚至可以讀英文嗎？
What is international...?
NATO. White people think they are "the world".
Western company invested in China, western people bought made in China, and then China could support Russia with their money.
China does not support Russia with its money. It buys Russian oil with a huge discount to sell them weapons, as they do with every client. No money, no products.
Chinese support Western company , Chinese buy Western goods too. So what ?
You treat china as an enemy. You expect them to help you fight Russia?
@@jouvertalandwa5337 why will I do that , China is not my enemy, China's dealing with Russia is none of my problem
So what ?
Despite international sanctions 😅….people r so foolish,,,so many countries don’t care abt yo sanctions that’s for u not for the whole world
тсс, они до сих пор думают что всё крутится вокруг них)))
Dollar are dying while they concern themselves about sanctions bye2 USA...
@@haziq0007 and balloons are flying over their roofs 😂
Russia can't buy an unlimited number of new soldiers, no matter how the sanctions are going.
@@terahndlovu6571 👽 UFO too only in USA
international sanction?😥😥😥
They are mad, the west has sanctioned Russia not the rest of the world, so they must stop calling it international sanctions
We let our politicians depend on China so much that they can sanction us back even more
They are crying because there are loopholes in their scheming sanctions.
They think they are the God, they are the world, they are international, although only 40 countries go sanctions aginst Russia, while the world has about 200 countries. This is the West, they think they are the domination of this planet while the rest are nothing.
You stand by your Ally, China have every right to aid Russia by any means and Russia will do likewise when China move into Taiwan.
You need to take into account the States have one law as a super power but also china has also it's own law as it's an other super power and it's own country.
The states do not control the world.
Therefore different laws of what one can do or not do depends on the country.
You need to take into account that Chinas economy entirely relies on “made in China” sold to the west
Without that their entire economy disappears over night
China also relies on the west for food
Don’t worry, all made in China will soon be “made in India” and then india can take Tibet from China
The west owns most of the technology though and we can cut off the faucet
But there are international laws and regulations which are supposed to make the world a better place. And if I had to choose that this rules are governed by the US or China, I'm clear for an US dominated world order.
@@ernstschwaig4667 America makes the world a better place? Are you underage? America can't even make America better
@@ernstschwaig4667 thanks for that. I hope you will support us on our next occupation. ❤️❤️
This is the war between US-NATO and Russia, not the war between the world and Russia. It is impossible to cut all normal economic and trade relations with Russia by other unrelated countries. Definitely other countries will not boringly increase the tension with Russia to satisfy NATO and US's own selfishness.
Exactly. Africa supports China and Russia
@@suzygirl1843 Parts of Africa..
US and EU have full right to prevent THEIR products going into Russia. Just as Russia has the right to not allow their products be shipped to us. No one is saying that China or any other country can’t trade with Russia. It’s about western products.
I don’t know if you understand the meaning of the word “selfishness”, since the sanctions are against economic self-interests. The correct term you are looking for is therefore “selflessness”, because it’s not about neither NATO nor the US but about Ukraine.
@@zwcdamien You should remember that Ukraine also used Chinese drones to attack Russian-occupied Crimea. Could that mean the attack have been authorized by China?
One exporter have sold some mechanical parts, whether it is via smuggled or normal trade channels, should the exporter have unlimited responsibility to clearly control the whereabouts of the sold items?
Even after dozens of rounds of sanctions, the EU can therefore reach such a severe sanctions level. Before this round of sanction, the EU and Russia even carried out normal trade in chips and facilities. But no other country must abide by the rules made by the EU and US, because EU and US have no obligation to protect these countries too. Other countries have to face their own situation, for example if they have any problems incl. confrontation with Russia, they have to resolve the conflict by themselves.
Russia has invaded Ukraine and the Ukranians are fighting for their freedom from Russian oppression.
Africans should be sympathetic after having been through colonization and domestic and foreign oppression themselves.
This is going to be a very exciting decade.
It will be exciting till the moment of nuclear destruction!
Then it will be terrifying !
Which “International sanctions”? NATO is not “International”, West is not majority of the world. UN should be the place where international matters are discussed.
China nor Russia accept UN authority. They reject international law as "western decadence". Same for Iran and North Korea as well as the new Afghan ruling class.
It's like asking a criminal to accept the polices authority.
@@citronski You need to get more info about that, you are totally wrong. UN is being avoided by the West whenever they dont have majority (eg attack on Yugoslavia), and today they dont have majority for sanctions against Russia. Russia and China are probably the dame, hence lets not be hypocrites here.
😂😂😂😂 "international sanctions " wow
1% of the world's population threatens all the rest with sanctions.
Тhey just🤡🤡🤡
Soo funny 😂😂
Long live Russian-Chinese partnership!
It's time to sanction winnie the pooh too
Hells yeah 👍
Why?
Indeed, time to destroy China's economy.
Good luck with that, hold up a second while I strap myself in for a world recession.
Go for it lol
I don't understand, you guys keep saying western sanctions...
Is china a western state, if all of EU, Australia and US sanctions isn't working that's your problem..
The world isn't rotating around western state, everyone have an opinion
Meanwhile Russia can’t replace any equipment and has to buy air soft armor from china!
I don’t think profit is the primary motivation.
Yeah people are thinking on a personal level. China is doing this not for profit but because it benefits their interests.
You have a very narrow and naive definition of profit
We're shocked.. OMG should we be afraid??
China also sells weapon parts to the United States. Why surprise. And sometimes China don’t know what the parts used for, it could be used for both civilian purposes. For example, drones. How the heck China know what those will be used. Even Ukraine bought a lot of Chinese drones and customized them to military drones.
It’s far game. 31 countries against one.
China has the manufacturing capacity larger the the rest of the world combined. So far they have been suppporting Russia "under the table". What would happen if they were to do this openly? Provide Russia with a literally unlimited supply of munitions, including Russia designed missiles and drones? And in addition lauch dozens or maybe 100's of satellites to provide intellegence, such as when a weapons shipment crosses the border from Poland to Ukraine?
Yeah but every part needed for those industries in China are make in USA or UK so in the long run China and Russia are going to become the next Africa..
They wouldn't dare.
Oh it's shocking really. As if we don't know about this
*gasps* i would have never guessed!
It's funny how the EU NATO OTAN US refer themselves as the international community
😂😂😂😂
They think the world rotate around them
@@miraclenwankwo3288Civilization always spin around Europe
…… because…. they….. are….. an……. international…… community? I don’t understand your statement.
@@miraclenwankwo3288 It kind of does.
@@miraclenwankwo3288 "They think the world rotate around them"
It sure seems so, considering that you and me talk under a report of a European news network on a US video platform in the UK mother language. Not sure where you are from, but it certainly doesn't matter much if it's not EU NATO OTAN US.
'International Sanctions' 😅
just in January RuSSia has -47% in oil and gas revenues, and 🤣🤣🤣weiter
@@ramadankadriu5336 Russia running a negative tax deficit 🤣🤣
@@leegarrett5821 so is almost every country have you seen the u.s. budget crisis we have each year?
@@leegarrett5821 western countries worse than Russia now
@@mourka01 There’s a difference Russia can’t lend from the world bank Anymore America and Europe can.
what does the report mean by "despite international sanctions??
International sunction or western sunction' Russia and China have bilateral trade.
As an American it’s hypocritical for the USA to send weapons to Ukraine and tell china not to send weapons to Russia
USA needs to fix itself first. God be with you Russians. Keep fighting and win the war. I’m tired of usa and Russia Cold War.
I couldn't agree more. This year, America's military profit had significantly increased by selling artillery to NATO members, and of courses the reason behind it is Ukrainia. And yet they criticized China for doing the same thing.
We have what we need
I'd like to say I'm surprised and shocked but I'm not sure that anyone will be.
The real question is what will we do about it now.
Nothing. It is China's right.
To many people lacking morals these days allows for this kind of thing to manifest itself! Sad to say we are causing our own problems !!!!
Irony
@@jirachi-wishmaker9242 how?
Say the Eurotrash who colonized and pillaged the entire world.
@@carlosslimjunior
.
.
.
The fact US UK speaks about 'morality' in UN
@@jirachi-wishmaker9242 no one even mentioned either of them.
I'm just wondering how long it will take for western countries to understand that sanctions are useless. There are so many ways to get around them look on any country under sanctions the people might suffer but the regime will continue with their plan.
And it's true for all of them Russia, North Korea, Iran and probably many others.
People suffering and then blaming it on their own government is the whole point, the west just keep forgetting the key is to not take responsibility themselves and make the people hate the west instead.
Sanctions definitely work. Russia has no more money. They are selling all their gold
That's what the countries that are sanctioned want to make you believe.
Yeah its so inefficient iran’s economy is booming.
@@chbattchimeg8939 the people are suffering no doubt. but the sanctions are to prevent them from making weapons or supporting terrorists and they still doing it, so the sanctions are not working.
Well done China.
why DW re-played this video news from last week
This should be no surprise
No surprises in this report!
There were reports some months ago of American-manufactured electronic components found in Russian Drones supplied by a Hong Kong company!
Hong Kong is no longer sovereign. It's just part of China now after China has dissolved the HK govt into a puppet government. Should just say Chinese company in some province of China formerly HK.
we waited for it … sad it became reality 😔
Cry more 😂
Nato give it free
China sell to russia what is wrong with that?
@@TAM-90 hahahha she is a German 😂😂😂😂
@@remix-yy1hs what? what you talking about man?
:))
They are trade partners , what do you spect, us and Europe do the same.
Did anybody see this coming?
👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
We sell to Saudi-Arabia they sell to Russia.... weapons market is a free market
They sell to Saudi Arabia too. China sells to whoever buys. They were the first to get a major economic deal in Afghanistan already.
@@calvinhoward3808 doesn't change the fact that WE Nato members support the war in Yemen! No place for high ground in morality!!!
Let them keep supplying them. It's worth it.
Fair game
Is sanction from UN or G7 or G20. I am confused about the sanctions...
Western company invested in China, western people bought made in China, and then China could support Russia with their money.
Only NATO countries and a few of their allies are sanctioning Russia. For the rest of the world it's business as usual. It's not a UN sanction so nobody gives a damn what the westies say.
Cannot be from the UN, Russia and China have veto vote. So sanctions from G7 mostly
@@qili3899 by your goods somewhere else and see if u can afford it.
@@qili3899 the western countries made a huge profit from China past years for example apple 40% of its sale was in China last year so if these companies really want to exit China then do it the loss is themselves
China not listening to Western Media ?
NO they simple dont care...
@All Out Of Bubble Gum That's not correct, there it 's open.
@@pedrohpires6608 They do, but build their own opinion, which actually you should also.
1:20 how did the grand budapest hotel get wrapped up in all this?
So, was the balloon a reverse excuse to ignore sanctions? Are we going to enforce these sanctions or not?
Great news
The amount of censorship in DW
Are you talking about their channel in Russia that the Russian government shut down? Yeah that was a bummer, would have loved to have more reporters from any country in Moscow interviewing people
@@mtheory3 No I am talking about DW.
@@mtheory3
I don't understand Russian language. Not subbed to any Russian Channels.
Projection much?
Wow 3 hours passed and your comment is still there?
Chinese companies, including one major defense contractor, shipped military rifles (tagged as "hunting rifles"), body armor and drone parts to Russia through intermediaries like Turkey and the United Arab Emirates from June-December 2022, Politico reported on March 16
Sophisticated military ballons that enables you to look out for enemies below and to tap their phones.
I am wrong…?
International sanctions or US sanctions? The reporter is delusional 🤣🤣😂😅
West thinks it owns the world.aka white people.
@@monishboro8648 We do, don't we? We can cut you from money and global trade at will. We can opt not to buy your wares or blockade your trade routes.
Feels good to be free.😍
@@citronski well try it. White power time is over.
@@citronski actually rest of world will make sure you are not white anymore. Any actions you take in other parts of the world will only make sure more colored people will come to white lands and make them mixed.
@@citronski Is Mohammed the most popular name for new borns in your place?
No one should be surprised
Sounds about right.
No wonder Russia is never exhausted with weapons
Maybe you should stop watching this channel and think for yourself german
@@remix-yy1hs lmaoooooo agreed
They should continue shipment to curb expansion of imperialism
it encourages world power balance
Why must there be a balance between freedom of choice/religion/vote, rule of law and authoritarian dictatorships like China and Russia?
China's long-standing view has been that any country's sovereignty should be respected. China even does not have double standards on this. That was why China opposed the wars on Iraq, Libya, Yugoslavia, by US/NATO. China would be more willing to be on the US side if the US had respected China's sovereignty regarding Taiwan. But US clearly has double standards. This angered China.
This make sense china would like to see what it's military hardware can do against nato
No
Want the money
Want a hook into Russia
Want to be a pain to the west
Then it's time to sell bonds they're going to go down in price
Germany and US do it! Why should China do it not?
You cannot sanction everyone 😂
Why not?
Accusation😢
Sanction is the best way to go. Nothing can't be relinquished except RMB to go.
You clown the Chinese economy is bigger than the US in PPP GDP and bigger than the EU in Nominal GDP.
The entire Western auto industry is completely dependent on the Chinese domestic market for consumption.
Furthermore, all sanctions are illegal according to international law unless they are passed by the UN security council.
yep good luck with that :)
Exactly. That will be final nail in Europe's coffin
@@danwelterweight4137 slightly higher ppp but 4x the population…
Not to mention the EU isn’t even a country, hardly comparable.
LOL and watch the inflation skyrocket to 500%
In five months from now, EU will have to choose between defense, economy and filling the gas reserve...
That's when they will understand the true value of sanctions
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 The EU economy is 20 times bigger then Russias we will see 🤣🤣
@@leegarrett5821 I study geopolitics in college I can tell you are very ignorant about the economic situation
Be like Sweden we don't use Russian gas.
@@nathanmc6848 oh really let’s talk about Russias tax deficit, Russia is running a negative deficit through taxation like VAT if you think Russia is doing well you need a new class 🤣
Didn't the Kremlin have the same exact rethoric last winter?
We Chinese don’t except western sections
Increase the sanctions block accounts first before the conclusion to be on the safe side.
Come on Ukraine! Drop diplomatic relations with the PRC- return to the Republic of China. We have done NOTHING but help you all the way.
You gotta be crazy do u want china to sanction ukraine? Usa can withstand it but small country like ukr no way
They will not
@@polarbear7 We'll see ;)
@@andia968 China is supplying armaments parts to Ukraine. This is an act of aggression. It's like rewarding the Kremlin for dropping bombs. Drop the PRC.
America 😰 -> Russia 😀 🤝 China 😄
why is the u.s. warning countries / company in helping russia when in fact they the u.s. and european countries are sending weapons to ukraine.
So what you can't stop them
Business is business
Dw is my favourite Channi so far !
I like to see the news on Al Jazeera English channel, CNN channel, BBC channel, DW news channel, and WION channel. Because these news channels are so accurate and have many expert host in providing information ☺️🙏
What's wrong with China selling to Russia? No one complains about nearly every country supplying Ukraine
Because numbnuts, russia illegally invaded Ukraine. See the difference but maybe not. It takes a little intelligence.
@jaapongeveer6203 yeah, but hopefully russia keeps the war going for years
West is crying because all the weapons they donated to Ukraine is not able to push Russia out of Ukraine and now they are trying to find a scapegoat.
and there we go again " Return of the Mack"
In China it's all about the $$$$$$$$.
😂😂American arms dealers earn the most.😂😂
We live in a global village ad sanctions are very foolish
Couldn't imagine relying on Chinese military components with counterfeit chips and no quality control.
western Countries I thought they are developed but I now know they are developing
They developed first because of colonization, imperialism, militarlism by sacrificing asia, africa, latin america
God Bless 🇺🇸
God bless Russia
youa r gay
God bless America for?
America is a country with rainbow colors of LGBTQEFGH
Is this profit not blood money?
2:03 I swear that's DCS
possible
We should buy more from China to support them. Who’s with me?
Btw that’s sarcasm
Anyone want something from Amazon- they definitely not selling anything from China
Im confused what laws did china break. Is china not a sovereign nation who can make it's own policies?
Western laws disguised as international laws.
Capitalism disguised as democracy
China said they are neutral in the war. They are breaking their own word. Maybe you see Chinese as liars, but rest of the world trusted China.
Dawg everyting..Auf dein licht
Secondary sanctions please
Germany should focus on their LGBTQ people and should try to make some gender neutral leopard🐆 2 tank for their LGBTQ army. Then Germany can think about war on their LGBTQ soil.
The Gans are no longer the same as they were in the 40s. these are already frightened cu,ckol,ds who will lose consciousness from the whistle of bullets and from the sounds of an explosion
Well that was a useless reply
Thank Russia and China war agains warmongers
Not surprised by this?
Both have Common goal.. grab a Land?!