richard III & anne neville [TWQ] | but i will never be her

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 1 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 40

  • @vinitalaffrey1616
    @vinitalaffrey1616 6 років тому +65

    God! I feel soo...sad for Anne. She trusted Richard..had her full faith in him...yet Richard treated her this way. I feel so...bad for her tragic ending....

    • @marshmam
      @marshmam  6 років тому +4

      Vinita Laffrey well, we don't know exactly how it was according to hystory, do we? this story full of mystery plus there was no such a tragedy in original book TV show based on. so please don't be sad, I don't want anyone be upset because of my videos ❤

    • @vinitalaffrey1616
      @vinitalaffrey1616 6 років тому +17

      myrka nikolaevna I meant to say...I feel bad for The White Queen Anne Neville. In actual history, Elizabeth & Richard never had an affair with each other.

    • @vinitalaffrey1616
      @vinitalaffrey1616 6 років тому +3

      myrka nikolaevna Your video is Beautifully made & explains clearly Anne pain.

  • @zelfaxo8068
    @zelfaxo8068 6 років тому +115

    He never loved Elizabeth of York in real life though. I hate the show for making it look like he loved her.

    • @marshmam
      @marshmam  6 років тому +13

      Zelfa XX I read a lot about their relationship with Anne and I guess you’re right but it’s a TV show and I love it too for colorful and entertaining picture. Why not? It’s not a historically correct series and there was no urgent point for that I think.

    • @eliasveturius5343
      @eliasveturius5343 3 роки тому

      Why are you so sure Richard didn t love Elizabeth? There are so many proofs that said exactly the contrary.

    • @zelfaxo8068
      @zelfaxo8068 3 роки тому +6

      @@eliasveturius5343 elizabeth of york told me herself. she came into my dream saying that stop with the richard nonsense or she’s gonna have to get up from her grave to tell people that.

    • @maga946
      @maga946 3 роки тому +1

      @@zelfaxo8068 very funny kkk

    • @ele5583
      @ele5583 2 роки тому

      @@zelfaxo8068 love your response! There's no point in arguing with people who still wants to ignore the Portuguese double marriage, as well as Richard's public denial and the political suicide of making an incestous marriage with the niece whose illegitimacy meant your right to the throne.

  • @abbeyroberts2529
    @abbeyroberts2529 7 років тому +51

    Poor anne i feel her pain :(

  • @mickymcbryan4814
    @mickymcbryan4814 4 роки тому +53

    It's really weird that they invented a love triangle between Elizabeth / Richard / Anne because irl that never happened and also the reason he kept her in his court was because he was her legal guardian. HE WAS HER UNCLE!!!

    • @xxztarszebraxx4894
      @xxztarszebraxx4894 3 роки тому

      Yet a marriage between a uncle and a niece was common back then

    • @sameenshahid7457
      @sameenshahid7457 2 роки тому

      @@xxztarszebraxx4894 but historically speaking there is little evidence to support there was anything between them

    • @ele5583
      @ele5583 2 роки тому +1

      @@xxztarszebraxx4894 in reality it wasn't common at all... in fact it never happened before. Surely not in England. Besides Richard was about to marry Infanta Joana of Portugal and to marry off Elizabeth to the Duke of Beja.

    • @xxztarszebraxx4894
      @xxztarszebraxx4894 2 роки тому

      @@sameenshahid7457 Yeah I know that and I also know nothing happened between them

    • @xxztarszebraxx4894
      @xxztarszebraxx4894 2 роки тому

      @@ele5583 but it did happen before... Also either way it doesn't matter as their both dead and no one truly cares abt them...

  • @ameliaflynnhayes
    @ameliaflynnhayes Рік тому +3

    This song describes their relationship from being in love from not being in love he didn’t mean to fall in love with Elizabeth.

    • @JadlynJ
      @JadlynJ 5 місяців тому +1

      I believe he still loved Anne despite how distant they became. Even more than he loved Lizzie.

  • @JadlynJ
    @JadlynJ 5 місяців тому +1

    Richard was horrible for what he did at the end. His actions were a complete disregard for his wife and no matter what the truth of his intentions were, it's terrible on Richard's part.
    If he's just using Lizzie then he's displaying his neice as a whore to all of England and playing with her feelings. Also shaming his wife and hurting her feelings. OR. He could've been genuinely lusting over his neice, cheating on his wife and lying about it.
    Personally I think it was both as two things can be true at once. I call BS on him saying he didn't desire Lizzie, and his plan/strategy for political gain was also an excuse to cheat. (My opinion) And Anne seemed to realize this as well, since you could see she didn't believe him and it genuinely broke her heart.
    This breaks my heart... and this happens so much in real life too. Husbands starting to lust after younger women when their wives grow older💔

  • @misslet710
    @misslet710 4 роки тому +11

    Tive pena da Anne, admito. Eles eram um casal perfeito de início, depois de sofrer nas mãos de Edward (seu primeiro marido) ela finalmente reencontrou e ficou com o cara que amava desde o começo, Richard. E dava pra perceber que eles se apoiavam, tanto nas questões políticas quanto como casal, eram parceiros. Porém como Richard disse, a um preço a ser pago para chegar perto do trono, no final de tudo ainda acho que ele a amava, mesmo que pareça estranho, Elizabeth era mais pela luxúria, faz sentido?
    Bem, só sei que ele não foi a última batalha com a benção de sua esposa

    • @estreladomar720
      @estreladomar720 4 роки тому +2

      Tô tentando acreditar que ele amava

    • @eleanoralexavina7003
      @eleanoralexavina7003 4 роки тому +8

      Eu não pensei em momento algum assistindo a série, que ele deixou de amá-la. Ele tinha um jeito próprio de amar, diferente do dela, foi mostrado desde o início e mesmo ficando com a Elizabeth por interesse ou sentimento... Ele sempre se apoiava na Anne. Tanto que na cena onde ele vela o corpo dela, grita pra Elizabeth sair de perto dele. Eu gosto do jeito como retrataram ele. Uma pessoa boa que foi perdendo a essência com o tempo.

    • @misslet710
      @misslet710 4 роки тому +3

      @@eleanoralexavina7003 real, muito complexo.

    • @marianaschreiner6278
      @marianaschreiner6278 3 роки тому +8

      Eu tenho a mesma opinião que a sua... quando Rei ele se perdeu na luxúria do poder e Elizabeth representava isso, enquanto Anne era o real e verdadeiro. Depois de assistir a série fiquei inquieta e inconformada com esse desfecho... passei dias pesquisando artigos sobre Anne e Richard, e na história real ele não ficou com Elizabeth, amou Anne até o fim, inclusive ele chorou no funeral dela o que era muito incomum para Reis naquela época... então isso acalentou meu coração 💓

    • @luaventura123
      @luaventura123 2 роки тому +5

      Na vida real acharam uma carta da Elizabeth querendo que a rainha morresse logo para que o Richard arrumasse logo um casamento para ela, ele parou tudo inclusive os deveres reais quando Anne ficou doente, não era comum para os reis da época. Fora que na vida real o George escondeu ela em uma cozinha como criada em um lugar bem distante do reino só para ela não casar com o Richard, mas ainda sim ele procurou ela é não parou até achar, na vida real a história dos dois é mais bonita que na série, não existe registro de amantes dele, sendo que a maioria dos Reis tinham muitas. Mesmo na série eu acredito que ele ainda amava ela, de um jeito distorcido depois que virou rei mas ainda amava.

  • @raffaellatosello5475
    @raffaellatosello5475 3 роки тому +2

    Surely King Richard III with all respect was not as perfect as My Richard, even if My Love bears his name but Mine is the most perfect and Wonderful Man in the whole world, no one will ever be like My Richard!

  • @sundaybloodysunday2052
    @sundaybloodysunday2052 7 років тому +11

    Авввв
    Как же я люблю этих двоих
    Богечки,ну почему история так жестока?😢
    Прекрасное видео*о*

    • @marshmam
      @marshmam  7 років тому +2

      Sunday bloody sunday спасибо :з

    • @lenna255
      @lenna255 7 років тому +5

      Sunday bloody sunday и я их очень люблю,самая любимая OTP 🙈Ричард само очарование 😍

    • @saleka_art
      @saleka_art 5 років тому +2

      Вообще у него не было связей с Елизаветой Йорк . Он очень сильно скорбил по Анне . Он был верен ей. Этот сериал снят по роману . И для тех кто любит эту пару (включая меня) можно успакоится навсегда . Мне очень нравится из пара не только в сериале а так же в реальной жизни пример настоящей любви. Минус сериал в том что по роману снят . Сам писатель говорил что все сплетни это и есть Роман его

    • @liveelf5510
      @liveelf5510 5 років тому +1

      @@saleka_art , доброго времени. Подскажите, пожалуйста, что за сериал и книга? Очень хочется найти хоть что-то про Ричарда Йорка и Анну Невилл.

    • @saleka_art
      @saleka_art 5 років тому +1

      @@liveelf5510 Роман Филиппы Грегори Дочь делотелякоролей . Но я вам посоветую книгу Ричард 3 Светланы Кузнецовый Роман очень понравился он больше походит на историю идёт речь от одного лица ( Ричарда ).