IS THIS THE BEST MAST RAISING SYSTEM ON A TRAILER SAILER? | Ep.126

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 20 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 123

  • @joewilliams5396
    @joewilliams5396 Рік тому +12

    Hats off to the person who designed that solution.

  • @kurtkoenig6945
    @kurtkoenig6945 Рік тому +10

    Tony Smith is the designer. He also designed and built the Gemini Catamarans. I had a Telstar and needed to change out the anchor light one day so I dropped the mast at the pier. I had a handful of sailors run over to help with what they thought was a catastrophe only to stand in awe as I lowered, change the bulb, and raised it back by my self. Fun times.

    • @AlexGoesSailing
      @AlexGoesSailing  Рік тому +2

      Brilliant story! I get quite the audience at the slipway!

  • @PaulMernaugh
    @PaulMernaugh 11 місяців тому +2

    I own a Telstar Trimaran (Hull 352) and bought it new from Performance Cruising and had it shipped back from Anapolis to Minnesota - now in Florida. I was able to tour the factory and meet Tony Smith and spend time with Will Hershfeld, his son-in-law and sail it in the Chesapeake. Our boat is fast, safe and easy to handle and has quite the shallow draft. It is a really well designed boat.

    • @AlexGoesSailing
      @AlexGoesSailing  11 місяців тому +1

      That’s amazing! I’m really liking this boat so far. Super interesting design and perfect for what I need!

  • @Rammers282
    @Rammers282 Рік тому +5

    What have I just witnessed! Whoever designed that has a mighty brain, along with the croc wearing sidekick who fathomed it all out of course.

  • @quasimojo7399
    @quasimojo7399 Рік тому +3

    Absolutely brilliant solution. Certainly beats paying through the nose for every step and un-step.

  • @cousinjack2841
    @cousinjack2841 Рік тому +4

    I watched the 'up and down' over and over, and quite frankly, ended up a bit awestruck, with a bit of a headache though. Quite an ingenious system and so valuable insofar as it provides you with the independence that must be at the heart of every trailer sailer. Clever stuff; well done for getting it working.

  • @billywhizz6483
    @billywhizz6483 Рік тому +2

    That mast raising setup is a thing of beauty!

  • @simontaylor3492
    @simontaylor3492 Рік тому +3

    Alex, my good old Dad used to tell me off for bending straight, he told me it was simply called "straighenng", lol. Great video, you are always so "hands on".

  • @ooweesaler
    @ooweesaler Рік тому +3

    I wont pretend to understand how that works but its simply brilliant. A very elegant solution. On my hawk it was push up by hand, hope and hold on. This is far easier and safe. Now you have it all worked out it will be simple and safe. Good time to test it all having done the roof and mast base.

    • @AlexGoesSailing
      @AlexGoesSailing  Рік тому

      It will make a big difference compared to what I’m used to!

  • @derekshort1451
    @derekshort1451 Рік тому +2

    Wow that is very impressive clever was the person who came up with that

  • @hedleyjackson5131
    @hedleyjackson5131 Рік тому +2

    A beautiful bit of engineering could watch that all day. Well worked out.

  • @edwardhazelden6424
    @edwardhazelden6424 Рік тому +2

    I can feel a power Winch coming on!

  • @peterwatson6975
    @peterwatson6975 Рік тому +3

    Well done for keeping your faith in the raising system. Stopping a mast fall over the side is the most difficult element and it looks like this method is stable. Also youve tuned it such that you can stop and adjust the setup. Fab😊

    • @AlexGoesSailing
      @AlexGoesSailing  Рік тому

      It super safe and really easy. Will make life easy at the boat ramp!

  • @davideve6947
    @davideve6947 Рік тому +2

    Thus proving that with a fulcrum you will move the world. Brilliant set up.👍

    • @AlexGoesSailing
      @AlexGoesSailing  Рік тому +1

      It’s really good! Will make it so easy down at the ramp!

  • @danielgoldhill4589
    @danielgoldhill4589 Рік тому +2

    Wow, I bet the new raising system will save you so much time ! Another great video, thanks Alex !!!

  • @rjcote45
    @rjcote45 5 місяців тому +1

    Brilliant guy! Hats Off!!!!

  • @PatrickHoodDaniel
    @PatrickHoodDaniel Рік тому +2

    Nice crocs, no plugs. Somebody was having way too much fun with geometry when creating this method. I like the system of raising. complicated, but easy for a single hand. It also keeps the forestay straight. In my method, the forestay (furler) bends and can break at the joints. When raising, you should use the transformer sound effect, Wrrrrrr-CH-KCH-KCH-Wrrrrrr. You forgot to put the boon there. That boom support is pretty cool. The only change I would make is if there is too much tension on the line between the foot of the mast and the winch would be to add a boom sheet between the bottom of the fuller and the bow and you can get double the mechanical advantage.

    • @AlexGoesSailing
      @AlexGoesSailing  Рік тому

      That’s a good idea! Seems to be fine on the winch with the transition point between the frames being the only hard point. Really like this system especially solo!

  • @sailingona
    @sailingona Рік тому +1

    Wow that’s impressive how easy it’s looks like 👍

  • @AndyUK-Corrival
    @AndyUK-Corrival Рік тому +1

    Well Alex, it wasn’t until you started raising I got the geometry of this system. It’s brilliant, safe, quick and effortless once set up. I mean if you have any issues with the mast head, light, sheaves, lost halyard then it is super easy it seems to just drop the mask. Excellent. Andy UK

    • @AlexGoesSailing
      @AlexGoesSailing  Рік тому

      It has to be seen to be understood as I didn’t have a clue when I first looked at it! Thanks again Andy!

  • @chrisobrien5138
    @chrisobrien5138 Рік тому +1

    Such a well thought out design!

  • @marcusleather1329
    @marcusleather1329 Рік тому +1

    What an amazing way of doing it. Well done for working it out. Keep the videos coming. I can't wait to see you out in the solent sailing her.

  • @willwatchman4671
    @willwatchman4671 Рік тому +1

    Came here from the shoutout in the latest OYZ, great channel, fun + informative

  • @steve2758
    @steve2758 Рік тому +1

    Very clever and really interesting Alex , well done for getting it working correctly . Another great video cheers

  • @rodhinds4592
    @rodhinds4592 Рік тому +1

    Looks great, that's a big mast. I wonder if a slightly less complicated system could work for smaller masts.

  • @richardsue1
    @richardsue1 Рік тому +1

    brilliant just brilliant , well done.

  • @atcuzi20
    @atcuzi20 Рік тому +1

    Yes, great videos. It's going help me figure out my project Telstar 28. Thanks!

    • @AlexGoesSailing
      @AlexGoesSailing  Рік тому

      Keep in touch! If you need any info drop me a message!

  • @seanfitzpatrick8278
    @seanfitzpatrick8278 Рік тому +1

    It is an excellent idea❤

  • @gonesailing
    @gonesailing Рік тому +1

    Nice one Alex. Having struggled with mast raising on two earlier trailer sailor boats I’ve owned, I know that this can be frustrating and a little dangerous. The system you have looks scary but also ingenious now you have this sorted. Well done!

  • @richardadams3655
    @richardadams3655 Рік тому +1

    I have only had experience with counter-weighted systems with their associated weight and structure issues. This looks more complicated of course but once Alex has done all the clever parts it does seem better. Very interesting. Thanks Alex.

  • @robsinclair5586
    @robsinclair5586 Рік тому +2

    Super engineering, but looks like it takes a long time to set up; well done for getting it sorted out!The Farrier system uses the slightly (aft set) lowers to prevent side to side movement. Takes a bit more oomph to get the first bit up, but uses less hardware and is much quicker.

    • @AlexGoesSailing
      @AlexGoesSailing  Рік тому

      Yeah first setup takes a while but never has to be done again. Just dive down and pull one rope and it’s up!

  • @danialsentance3760
    @danialsentance3760 Рік тому +1

    Thats epic, big fan!

  • @scottlampe70
    @scottlampe70 Рік тому +1

    Looks incredibly complicated, but by crikey, it works beautifully. No lower back problems in your future.

  • @PaulGriffith
    @PaulGriffith Рік тому +1

    Genius engineering, better than the falling derrick method.

  • @SailingWithDave
    @SailingWithDave Рік тому +1

    Thing of joy watching that mast go up and down!!
    My only comment is about the lifting gear, ddoes that all stay in place permanentky and does it get int the way of sailing at all?

    • @AlexGoesSailing
      @AlexGoesSailing  Рік тому +1

      All stays in place and it doesn’t get in the way and is really nice for hand holds too!

  • @alecmartin2661
    @alecmartin2661 Рік тому +1

    Thats pretty damn cool, wonder how long that took to figure out when they designed that...

  • @neilquigley468
    @neilquigley468 Рік тому +1

    Never seen anything like that system before - impressive design! Wondering ... (with the KISS principle in mind) ... is there something about the design of this boat that prevented having a hinge at the mast step and using an A-frame (Jin-pole) on the foredeck to raise the mast, like most other small deck-stepped masts employ?

    • @AlexGoesSailing
      @AlexGoesSailing  Рік тому +1

      Mast is 34ft I think. So that a lot of weight to be dealing with on a lever arm. Also makes it easy as it drops into the transport location so no need to slide it around.

  • @marcusduffin7771
    @marcusduffin7771 Рік тому +1

    Looks like a great system. Will allow you to single handed raise and lower the mast. I assume the stainless system will be left with trailer while sailing? Too cumbersome to leave in situ.

    • @AlexGoesSailing
      @AlexGoesSailing  Рік тому

      Stays attached but doesn’t get in the way. Adds to the weight though 😬

  • @c.a.mcneil7599
    @c.a.mcneil7599 Рік тому +1

    Remember when I was young and my father said this is the perfect time to get a skyhook.

  • @andreimarius9695
    @andreimarius9695 9 місяців тому +1

    I see it as a genius leverage puzzle. It is working very nicely.
    I have no idea how heavy is that mast, but myself, I would rather have a simple more common raising mast system.

    • @AlexGoesSailing
      @AlexGoesSailing  9 місяців тому +1

      It’s a clever system! A more common system couldn’t handle the weight and would be impractical to use so this is the best solution to handle it.

  • @MartinLockhart
    @MartinLockhart Рік тому +1

    Wow brilliant

  • @markgallagher1376
    @markgallagher1376 Рік тому +2

    Looks like it works great, but it is quite a contraption.

  • @davemurphy2020
    @davemurphy2020 Рік тому +1

    Impressive and designed for single handed raising. In the middle of designing my own raising system fully aware of how nerve wracking it can be . Is it possible to stow all the hardware on the boat and do you think it could be used afloat?

    • @AlexGoesSailing
      @AlexGoesSailing  Рік тому

      Can be used afloat and all the frames stay in place so no need to set it all up. Definitely a great system and safe too!

  • @robertscholz4486
    @robertscholz4486 Рік тому +1

    Man that system looks almost effortless! You're going to pull up to the ramp and be in the water in under 10 minutes by the looks of it!! Nice!!! Now, without seeing everything together -- how much does the mast raising framework clutter up the deck space -- it looks like you lose some of the easy passage through to the bow around each side where the side supports attach to the cabin top. I guess that's a small price to pay for the ease of operation though.

    • @AlexGoesSailing
      @AlexGoesSailing  Рік тому

      Very good system. Luckily don’t lose and deck space really. There is a board that goes on the outside which makes getting to the bow so easy. Really well designed!

  • @carlamerritt490
    @carlamerritt490 Рік тому +1

    I had a 24ft sailboat and took me an hour to prep for launch. 45m to trailer. So I envy you.

    • @AlexGoesSailing
      @AlexGoesSailing  Рік тому

      I could probably get this rigged in 30mins but I can launch immediately as I can raise and lower on the water!

  • @jamesmansfield7146
    @jamesmansfield7146 Рік тому +1

    Fantastic do u take the frame down to sail😂 love you vids

    • @AlexGoesSailing
      @AlexGoesSailing  Рік тому +1

      All stays as it is! Doesn’t get in the way. Only thing is that it’s more weight though.

  • @JohnVH-diy
    @JohnVH-diy 3 місяці тому

    Hi Alex, love your channel. I just built a similar system on my sailboat. Works great. Posted a video of it on my channel.

    • @AlexGoesSailing
      @AlexGoesSailing  3 місяці тому

      @@JohnVH-diy that’s awesome! Will take a look!

  • @SuperDonald64
    @SuperDonald64 Рік тому +1

    O. Clever

  • @MarcusBehrens
    @MarcusBehrens Рік тому +1

    How much tension do you get on the line at different stages? With my old boat the biggest tension is when the mast is lying flat (see ua-cam.com/video/yFxLTyRWfCE/v-deo.htmlsi=EPgvvFHcnhWcDD_T&t=180). With your system it sees as if its more even throughout. Your system really looks very cool but do all of these heavy metal bars stay in place during sailing?

    • @AlexGoesSailing
      @AlexGoesSailing  Рік тому

      The transition between the frames is the only tight bit but it’s not too bad. All the frames stay in place too which is nice except for the weight!

  • @filmserve
    @filmserve Рік тому +2

    Rumour has it, the guy who designed this mast raising system also built the pyramids.

    • @randybruce3824
      @randybruce3824 Рік тому +2

      Tony Smith was originally a English Boat designer and Builder who moved to Annapolis, Md. where he built over 1,000 cruising Catamarans before he designed that Tri and rig and retired, Fair winds and smooth seas to you Tony and Sue when ever you are.

    • @AlexGoesSailing
      @AlexGoesSailing  Рік тому

      😂

    • @AlexGoesSailing
      @AlexGoesSailing  Рік тому

      @@randybruce3824 quite the story!

  • @ebutuoyotwen
    @ebutuoyotwen Рік тому +1

    For the algorithm, 🙂

  • @digitalfantazia3953
    @digitalfantazia3953 Рік тому +1

    Interesting idea from an engineering perspective but overcomplicated. Wouldn't like to do it in a breeze. A simple telescopic A frame in aluminium with 3mm sidewalls overlapping I ternally by 30% up to spreaders height would suffice. A frame Legs tied to shroud chainplate eyes to stop movement. Simple block and tackle to A frame intersect with a lassoo eye in line. 1 front sheet from a frame top to forestay chainplate and 2 rear lines from a frame top - one to each rear quarter (eg to port and starboard rear cleats) to steady a frame. Then lift and steady - simples.. especially if block and tackle has a camcleat in bottom block...

    • @AlexGoesSailing
      @AlexGoesSailing  Рік тому

      I have that kind of system on my last boat and it was stable enough but not really in high wind. I’d trust this system way more in the wind. The mast is probably a bit to big to be using an a frame and it would also be a challenge to slide the mast back before lifting too. The speed benefit is the main thing.

  • @monaghanpete
    @monaghanpete Рік тому +1

    Mast raising system is next level, cracking job

  • @seanmorris
    @seanmorris 11 місяців тому +1

    Every tool is a hammer (except screwdrivers, they're chisels)

  • @islandonlinenews
    @islandonlinenews Рік тому +1

    That’s called over engineering. Just connect the bottom on something with a hinge and push it up. It’s not even big.

    • @AlexGoesSailing
      @AlexGoesSailing  Рік тому

      Yeah no chance of pushing up this 34ft mast. I can’t even do that with a 22ft mast on my last boat that hinged!

  • @heritagebay
    @heritagebay Рік тому +1

    To complicated. Check out the Hunter system or Corsair

    • @AlexGoesSailing
      @AlexGoesSailing  Рік тому

      Only a little complicated but well worth it for the benefits. Also no need to set it up every time and it’s very safe and quick.

  • @ausweta44
    @ausweta44 Рік тому +1

    I’d consider removing it if you ever race. You can always leave the frames on the trailer.

  • @gavinferguson
    @gavinferguson Рік тому +1

    that was egineered not just designed i know folk will argue but there a difference.

  • @gatecrasher1970
    @gatecrasher1970 Рік тому +3

    looks over complicated

  • @quasimojo7399
    @quasimojo7399 Рік тому +3

    Absolutely brilliant solution. Certainly beats paying through the nose for every step and un-step.

    • @simontaylor3492
      @simontaylor3492 Рік тому +1

      unless you were part of a sailing club, where there is often a derick to lift and lower masts....for no cost as a member benifit.

    • @AlexGoesSailing
      @AlexGoesSailing  Рік тому

      @@simontaylor3492 do they have those in the uk?

    • @simontaylor3492
      @simontaylor3492 Рік тому +1

      @@AlexGoesSailing Yes Alex. I am at Portchester Sailing Club (opposite Port Solent) and we have a Derick for members use. No charge to use.

    • @AlexGoesSailing
      @AlexGoesSailing  Рік тому

      @@simontaylor3492 that’s very handy!