lol she has terrible social game that I don't think will change since she is unapologetically herself. She's Pre-jury when she returns and the hype she would create would be on Tony Vlachos-Game changers level. Plus everyone knows she's super smart and strategic since she got an amazing edit on 44. Hard to hide from that.
I found her to be really annoying for an episode or two... and then I started realizing just how much I relate to her and she just rocketed all the way up to the top of my rankings for the season and stayed there.
A testament to how few villains we get nowadays because we have like 5 from 41-44 and most of those were decent people edited as such who just played hard
@@EvilOrso definitely even the slightest villain gets beaten half to death by the fanbase and more if you're any kind of minority. Like Shan got it way WAY worse than Ricard
@@ashen_roses it’s not people not wanting to be villains. It’s the show not casting anybody who will clearly play a villain role. Why aren’t they casting any Rodney’s or russels who you can just look at and go “villain”
Karla Cruz Godoy is a villain in my book for secretly trying to betray Cassidy, then later trying to blackmail Cassidy in order to stay in the game (since Cassidy no longer felt any allegiance to Karla at this point after finding out Karla's secret plan), and finally influencing the jury to not vote for Cassidy.
Replace Chrissy with Karla because Chrissy is never gonna play again because of cancer hopefully she recovers one day but she has herself to take care of first
Look, can we stop with the Karla hate? She never influence the jury, actually look at people who know the game who explain why Cassidy lost. The sad truth is? Karla is an amazing player, and the jury never would had gave Cassidy the win. Is she a villain? yes...but a villain that played the game like Jesse. So get off your high horse. I bet if anyone from 43 would return, it be 100% Karla and Jesse, and maybe Owen and Noelle I see. All I got to say is this...why are all the 43 people love and still hang around Karla...but no one hangs around or talks to Cassidy? Legit answer me that coco.
@jjmara01 The jury all wanted Jesse to win and they all became bitter that Cassidy took it upon herself to eliminate Jesse by forcing him to make fire against the king of fire Gabler. And they are all still bitter to this day that Jesse did not win the season. Cassidy did the logical thing to not let Jesse get to the end so that is why they don't speak or hang out with her. Instead of giving her credit for winning immunity challenges and doing something that would help her chances to win, they resent her. Karla basically blackmailed Cassidy in front of all the cameras for all the world to see. You are a fool to think Karla didn't influence the jury behind closed doors and tarnish Cassidy's name as much as she could.
@@TheJayCoconut On one side, I do agree with the first part, but then again as seen in 44...maybe making fire wouldn't give Cassidy the win. The Karla part? Yes she said that, but that's to save yourself and happens every season. No one is ever "Hey yeah vote me out. I won't be angry".
True, but it will be all newby :(. Definitely should have been a returnee cast; maybe a second chance type season or fans vs favorite. Save Heroes v Villains for season 50 maybe
Loveee thiss, i miss intros so much!! i dont think yam yam and Chrissy as villians but we are defintly lacking in that with the new era also Cody doesnt fit the "hero" type either
Ok this is 4 months after this video was posted but if survivor 45 ends then I think some possible people here would be Emily, Drew, Austin, Sabiyah (she needs a second chance) and Kaleb are possible returners in the future I feel
I like this list a lot, my favorite players for a season would be, Chrissie (season 35) Dom Christian Angeline Devens Kellie Shan Ricard Omar Mike Jesse Cody Carolyn Carson Charlie Tiff Q Liz (season 46
Survivor Heroes vs. Villains (Horror movie Edition) Heroes Brooke Maddox (Scream) Domonique (Devil's Diary) Helen Shivers (I Know What You Did Last Summer) OJ Haywood (Nope) Richie Tozier (IT) Sue Snell (Carrie 2013) Theodora Crain (Haunting At Hill House) Wendy Torrence (The Shining) Xavier Plymton (American Horror Story) Yoga Pants (The Hunt Villains Esther Coleman (Orphan) Freddy Kruger (Nightmare On Elm Street) Gene Pratt (6:45) Indrid Wardin (Natural Selection) Jack Torrence (The Shining) Krampas (Krampas) Megan (Megan) Norman Bates (Psycho) Pennywise (IT) Ursula Wilson (The Devil's Diary)
How was Tori a villain? Because she's white and Twitter was literally trying so hard to hate her and then she pulled a classy move when she was voted out and then BIPOC ate their words and tried to act like it never happened. Seriously... lol
This is one of the better cast videos Ive seen. Although i would swap Xander out for either Jonathan or Danny. And swap Domenick out for Joe Mena or Alan Ball
Not bad, can’t fairly judge since I haven’t seen 35-36 or 38-39. Yam Yam definitely isn’t a villain but it’s not like the real H vs V cast made perfect sense either
I love tori but Sydney would be a great choice too. Why not both. Carla…. No, she was too bitter and jealous to vote for Cassidy in the end so pls no Carla
@@bramderidder3436 She was a bitter juror towards Cassidy, yes, but Karla was a good player throughout the game. Plus she's the villain I was eagerly waiting for to appear in the new era
Maryanne is a racist person and belongs on the villain tribe. In fact, she should have been ejected from the show like Dan was. Racism is always wrong.
@Valkyraya Evannyia (BlissfullyGazefulness) She was going into tribal council ready to vote Drea out one time (that episode had 2 split tirbal councils). When Maryanne saw that the 2 jury members were black, Maryanne refused to vote Drea out because that would make it 3 black jury members and Maryanne preferred to have a white person like Tori voted out instead.
@@person9305 It absolutely is racism. She treated individuals differently based on the color of their skin. How is that not racism? Discrimination based on race is racism.
after seeing carolyn play, i really think it’s time for heroes vs villains 2 ❤
So true! Shan, Cody and Carolyn have been the best finds in the new era. They deserve a second shot
Sounds good to me!
lol she has terrible social game that I don't think will change since she is unapologetically herself. She's Pre-jury when she returns and the hype she would create would be on Tony Vlachos-Game changers level. Plus everyone knows she's super smart and strategic since she got an amazing edit on 44. Hard to hide from that.
I can’t be the only one who smiles uncontrollably when I see Carolyn
I found her to be really annoying for an episode or two... and then I started realizing just how much I relate to her and she just rocketed all the way up to the top of my rankings for the season and stayed there.
I despise her
@@MachetesAreFun exact same way as me
in true Carolyn fashion i start to get choked up and teary eyed LMAO
A testament to how few villains we get nowadays because we have like 5 from 41-44 and most of those were decent people edited as such who just played hard
No one wants to be a villain anymore and I don't blame them
@@EvilOrso definitely even the slightest villain gets beaten half to death by the fanbase and more if you're any kind of minority. Like Shan got it way WAY worse than Ricard
Who was also a racial/sexual minority but our collective hatred for black women has been extreme since the show started
@@ashen_roses it’s not people not wanting to be villains. It’s the show not casting anybody who will clearly play a villain role. Why aren’t they casting any Rodney’s or russels who you can just look at and go “villain”
@@barrymccockiner9816 why did they get away with it I wonder
Man can we please return to the 39 day seasons PLEASE!?!?
Karla Cruz Godoy is a villain in my book for secretly trying to betray Cassidy, then later trying to blackmail Cassidy in order to stay in the game (since Cassidy no longer felt any allegiance to Karla at this point after finding out Karla's secret plan), and finally influencing the jury to not vote for Cassidy.
Also how she got the beads from everybody was villain'esque.
Replace Chrissy with Karla because Chrissy is never gonna play again because of cancer hopefully she recovers one day but she has herself to take care of first
Look, can we stop with the Karla hate? She never influence the jury, actually look at people who know the game who explain why Cassidy lost. The sad truth is? Karla is an amazing player, and the jury never would had gave Cassidy the win. Is she a villain? yes...but a villain that played the game like Jesse.
So get off your high horse. I bet if anyone from 43 would return, it be 100% Karla and Jesse, and maybe Owen and Noelle I see. All I got to say is this...why are all the 43 people love and still hang around Karla...but no one hangs around or talks to Cassidy? Legit answer me that coco.
@jjmara01 The jury all wanted Jesse to win and they all became bitter that Cassidy took it upon herself to eliminate Jesse by forcing him to make fire against the king of fire Gabler. And they are all still bitter to this day that Jesse did not win the season. Cassidy did the logical thing to not let Jesse get to the end so that is why they don't speak or hang out with her. Instead of giving her credit for winning immunity challenges and doing something that would help her chances to win, they resent her.
Karla basically blackmailed Cassidy in front of all the cameras for all the world to see. You are a fool to think Karla didn't influence the jury behind closed doors and tarnish Cassidy's name as much as she could.
@@TheJayCoconut On one side, I do agree with the first part, but then again as seen in 44...maybe making fire wouldn't give Cassidy the win.
The Karla part? Yes she said that, but that's to save yourself and happens every season. No one is ever "Hey yeah vote me out. I won't be angry".
I’m kind of surprised that Rick devens wasn’t on the villains tribe
There is no chance that he would be cast as a villain.
if rick devens got on the cast he would be the ultimate hero
He would be a hero for sure !
Yam Yam is not a villain lmao
Yam yam was on heroes side
Yam Yam is pretty villainous tbh. Like a big time fun villain. Like he stayed loyal, but he was a fun charismatic villain.
Definitely not a villain but they don’t cast villainous people anymore. It’s not hip in this woke era (same counts for casting attractive players)
If Yam Yam’s a villain, that means Josh is a hero
This would be a great season! I'd be rooting for Victoria!!
I’d watch the hell out of this season. Just throw Jonathan on heroes, Karla on villains, and you are spot on.
villains tribe would be SOOOO entertaining
I Feel Like Survivor 46 is the Perfect time for a Returnee Season?
46 is a newbie cast sadly
True, but it will be all newby :(. Definitely should have been a returnee cast; maybe a second chance type season or fans vs favorite. Save Heroes v Villains for season 50 maybe
@@bruja2591 its confirmed 46 is newbies
Be patient for 50 lol
Definitely need this season
Oh man. I hate seeing this video, because i LOVE seeing this video 😂 and i know its not gonna happen 😢😢😢
The best part of this video is the 39 days part.
Updating this one after 45:
Ricard : Kaleb
Devon: Rick Devens
Victoria : Emily
And we have the best cast for HvV2
I would absolutely watch this season
LOVE LOVE LOVE the cast!
Immediately yes
I’d give Carson Yam Yams villain spot but otherwise perfect
I’d argue that Carson deserves a spot on the HvV 2 roster. Also, give Malcolm one more chance after what happened to him on Game Changers!!!
Loveee thiss, i miss intros so much!! i dont think yam yam and Chrissy as villians but we are defintly lacking in that with the new era also Cody doesnt fit the "hero" type either
Cody doesn’t fit the hero type? Of course he is. He is lovable and positive
i would potentially switch yam yam and cody imo but i could see a case for not
Great castimg
Yam Yam is the ultimate hero wdym 😭
oh that villains tribe ate and left no crumbs
YESSSSS BRING BACK DAVIEEE
Ok this is 4 months after this video was posted but if survivor 45 ends then I think some possible people here would be Emily, Drew, Austin, Sabiyah (she needs a second chance) and Kaleb are possible returners in the future I feel
I’m team villain!
Where’s carson
Yam Yam is not a villain everyone on that cast absolutely adored him
More of a villain than hero
They sure don't make villains like they used to in the good ole days.
I MISS THIS INTRO SMM
I'm waiting forrr it
Cass is a villain
Would love to see Elaine back and Kellee from 39. Most people want to forget about that season but both ladies could do great on a returnee season
Janet over Elaine anytime.
Tori plays a good villain ngl lol
u cant put 2/3 tika trio its just not right😭
Is this a real thing or did you just make it up
I like this list a lot, my favorite players for a season would be,
Chrissie (season 35)
Dom
Christian
Angeline
Devens
Kellie
Shan
Ricard
Omar
Mike
Jesse
Cody
Carolyn
Carson
Charlie
Tiff
Q
Liz (season 46
Survivor Heroes vs. Villains (Horror movie Edition)
Heroes
Brooke Maddox (Scream)
Domonique (Devil's Diary)
Helen Shivers (I Know What You Did Last Summer)
OJ Haywood (Nope)
Richie Tozier (IT)
Sue Snell (Carrie 2013)
Theodora Crain (Haunting At Hill House)
Wendy Torrence (The Shining)
Xavier Plymton (American Horror Story)
Yoga Pants (The Hunt
Villains
Esther Coleman (Orphan)
Freddy Kruger (Nightmare On Elm Street)
Gene Pratt (6:45)
Indrid Wardin (Natural Selection)
Jack Torrence (The Shining)
Krampas (Krampas)
Megan (Megan)
Norman Bates (Psycho)
Pennywise (IT)
Ursula Wilson (The Devil's Diary)
i haven't watched hhh yet so idk about devon but yam yam as a villain is a little strange, i dont blame you though, ver few true villains
When will actually get returnee player to play again? Maybe season 50?
Heroes need Johnathan
Yam Yam is a hero
I'm already headcannoning Jesse/Emily and Drew/Victoria alliances.
I'd switch Yam Yam for Karla tho tbh
Tbh I was expecting Naseer too come out in The heroes tribe
If there's ever a HvV 2 I'm gonna need to see Rick Devens on the Villains tribe
Yam Yam is a villain???
How was Tori a villain? Because she's white and Twitter was literally trying so hard to hate her and then she pulled a classy move when she was voted out and then BIPOC ate their words and tried to act like it never happened. Seriously... lol
This is one of the better cast videos Ive seen. Although i would swap Xander out for either Jonathan or Danny. And swap Domenick out for Joe Mena or Alan Ball
Not bad, can’t fairly judge since I haven’t seen 35-36 or 38-39. Yam Yam definitely isn’t a villain but it’s not like the real H vs V cast made perfect sense either
tori's winning 💋💋
Love the idea but in the new era I think we need more castaways to choose from have no desire to see 75 percent of those players play again
Jam jam isn’t a villain lol
How is yam yam a villan
Need some pre-30s representation
Janet, the only hero of that season.
Am I the only one who disliked Cassidy? Cool idea but I think it would be better if she was swapped
Couldn't stand her. She was obnoxious on the show and far worse after the show. She shouldn't come back.
Janet was more of a villain than a hero
cassidy and yam yam need to switch lamo
How is yam yam a villain he just floated and made social bonds lol
Chrissy villain????????
I don’t get why everyone thinks Angelina is a villains sure she was annoying asf but she wasn’t a villain bruh
Replace Ricard with Carson and add Rick Devens for the heroes.
i love this
Dawg how is gabler not in heroes when he donated a million dollars to charity
He was both
Most people just want to forget about Gabler and him winning
Even if this is only a fancast, nobody wants to see that guy play again.
Do not agree that Yam Yam is a villain. Far from really.
Would hate to see Shan return again, she ruined the new era.
Lol what did she do
Yam Yam played like a hero, but has a villain mentality. You saw it in glimpses through the season.
This would be a great cast to watch play minus Tori. I don't really need to see her again. I'd prefer Karla or Sydney taking her spot
I love tori but Sydney would be a great choice too. Why not both. Carla…. No, she was too bitter and jealous to vote for Cassidy in the end so pls no Carla
@@bramderidder3436 She was a bitter juror towards Cassidy, yes, but Karla was a good player throughout the game. Plus she's the villain I was eagerly waiting for to appear in the new era
Loved Tori! Victoria could be replaced by Elaine
Half the villains tribe makes 0 sense
Hopefully the villain era is over.
'Promo SM' 😋
ngl the villain cast is such a weak one compared to the heros
Tori seems so out of place among this cast.
Maryanne is a racist person and belongs on the villain tribe. In fact, she should have been ejected from the show like Dan was. Racism is always wrong.
Care to explain how she's racist?
@Valkyraya Evannyia (BlissfullyGazefulness) She was going into tribal council ready to vote Drea out one time (that episode had 2 split tirbal councils).
When Maryanne saw that the 2 jury members were black, Maryanne refused to vote Drea out because that would make it 3 black jury members and Maryanne preferred to have a white person like Tori voted out instead.
@@AndrewSmith-pn2qc Are you out of your mind or simply a (very) uneducated person?
@@AndrewSmith-pn2qc that’s not racism wtf are you talking about
@@person9305 It absolutely is racism. She treated individuals differently based on the color of their skin. How is that not racism? Discrimination based on race is racism.
This isnt modern survivor. The inteo still says 39 days 🤡🤡🤡
Wtf is Cassidy doing up there??? Replace her with Elaine or NOELLE at best, but not Cassidy
im pretty sure that they are done with seasons 40 and prior and will cast from 41+