*Timestamps for Chapters:* 0:00 - Introduction 0:23 - Information about the Guest 2:05 - Reason behind writing the article "The Homosexual Challenge to Muslim Ethics" 6:42 - Influence of Thomas Aquinas 8:08 - Overlap of Christian and Muslim Ethics 9:28 - Challenges while writing the article 11:47 - Relevance of the article today 13:37 - Is Homosexuality genetic? (Does Gay gene exist?) 17:36 - Shariah on Homosexuality 24:03 - Proving the Homosexual act in Islamic Court 26:27 - Shariah implementation in Western societies 28:02 - Arguments of Liberal Muslims against the article 34:50 - Punishment of carrying out the act 38:05 - Restriction about speaking about key Islamic Values in the West 40:29 - Objective of the article and supporting the lgbt rights 45:17 - Muslims aligning with the political Left wing/Right wing. 54:53 - Dr. Ali's perspective on Homosexuality 58:07 - No Difference between sex and gender 1:00:32 - Promotion and normalisation of Lqbt 1:02:41 - Book Recommendations by brother Paul and Dr. Ali 1:08:30 - Causes and navigating Homosexuality 1:11:02 - Closing Statements
My husband is a very big fan of yours. You have inspired him in many ways. Thankyou so much for these very insightful and informative videos. We'll keep rooting for you. May Allah bless you and reward you greatly 🤲❤️
@ᗯᕼIᔕTᒪEᗷᒪOᗯEᖇ GᗩY ᖴEᗰIᑎIᑎE ᗰᗩᑎ ᔕᒪᑌT ᗰᗩᒪEᔕ ᖇIGᕼTᔕ 'A'ishah (may Allah be pleased with her) narrated that the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) said: "Everyone has been created with three hundred and sixty Joints. Whoever mentions Allah's greatness (says Allahu Akbar), praises Allah, extols Allah, and seeks forgiveness from Allah and removes stones from the path of the people, enjoins what is good and forbids the evil to the amount of those three hundred and sixty joints (sulama), he walks on that Day (of Judgment) having distanced himself from the Hell Up until 1995 it was believed there were only 340 joints in the human body. However, scientists then found 20 more! How could Prophet Muhammad know that there were 360 joints in the human body, as narrated in the hadiths
Ameen, btw right when I clicked on this video a gay ad showed up, these ads are Jeep on coming up especially Christian “ex Muslims” ads on Islamic videos it’s so annoying. They do everything but debunk Islam with proper sources
@ᗯᕼIᔕTᒪEᗷᒪOᗯEᖇ GᗩY ᖴEᗰIᑎIᑎE ᗰᗩᑎ ᔕᒪᑌT ᗰᗩᒪEᔕ ᖇIGᕼTᔕ if it’s a story and lie then how has there been many miracles of the Quran and proofs for it being more true than false? You’re probably just a troll account tho
Top job Paul. Just want to echo the same sentiment that has been expressed a (few) thousand times; you're doing an excellent job at producing original and thought provoking content that seek to defend conservative and traditional values. Wish and pray for your continued success and Tawfiq as you develop your channel. Much love and respect.
To summarize. 1- Islam separates between desires (e.g. unintentional homosexual thoughts) vs acting on these desires ( committing Liwat). 2- all scholars agreed that acting on homosexual desires is a sin, but they differ on what (worldly) punishment it warrants (in the context of a muslim society, not non-Muslim one) 2.1. public not private homosexual acts ( like Zina) is what warrants penalty. Public crimes are crimes so scandalous, that they manage to be witnessed by four upright male witnesses in a conservative Muslim society . 2.2. most lenient opinions on what the penalty is could be found in Hanifi school which assigns a ' tazeer' penalty ( leaving the type of punishment to society's judgment.) 2.3. i will add here , ibn Hazm opinion on the matter ( he considers it tazeer, if memory serves right) 3- Muslims in the West should re-consider their ties to the left and be cautions with the baggage that comes with these ties (eg. pressure to support LGBT causes) 4- people with homosexual desires, like those with heterosexual ones, are both trialed by their creator. The trial is to deal with these desires in accordance to divine will ( not their whims). 4.1. For example, a heterosexual man is never given the green light to commit zina no matter his circumstances ( i guess a Western example here is he is never allowed to commit rape). Patience is his test
Thank you for bringing the awareness about this issue. As a muslim that is struggling with Same Sex Attraction) SSA and will be till the end of my life, I really hope that Muslim community is more informed and emphatic towards this particular test. It is indeed a VERY HARD test as people growing up with SSA are much more vulnerable to suffer from mental related illness such as depression. I went through depression period mixed with suicidal ideation when I was younger. At one point, I remember constantly crying before sleeping and ask Allah SWT to take my life. Alhamdulillah I'm at a better place right now. But for Muslim community at large, they have to know how hard this test is because the percieved unfairness nature of this particular test. I can understand why many Muslims with SSA left the deen or turn to liberal Islamic interpretation of homosexuality promoted in the west. One thing that Muslim community should now is that attraction and action are 2 different things. What is accountable is our action. But then that doesn't really ease the struggle for Muslim like myself, because then what? I know that there are therapies that can help people to control the urge so that it won't be overwhleming. But SSA will always be part of us. It won't disappear, it is a lifetime struggle. So many of us afraid that we will be alone growing old and that kind of thought will gives severe anxiety and sadness. Off course SSA is a spectrum and some people are able to have a happy marriage with right intention (not for "curing" SSA whatsoever) but to be selfless in order to make a marriage works. It is to be noted that SSA is a spectrum, some people with SSA may also have some Opposite Sex Attarction (OSA). In the end, marriage is not a universal solution or even an option for some of us who may even repulsed by opposite gender. So as you can see, for some of us it is very hard and the support and undertanding from the Muslim community is very important. Also, what really help me right now is being part of a support group and community that have the same mindset as myself: we don't want to identify with LGBTQ+ lifestyle and want to try to follow the Islam deen as our way of life and not distorting it to accomodate our sexual desire. It helps us to cope with this struggle without judgement from both Muslim community in general and from pro-LGBTQ+ community. We are a minority wihthin a minority, so hopefully Muslim community can be more compassionate and supporting. If you are reading this and are a Muslim and struggling with SSA but still want to follow Islam as best as you could. Please consider joining Straight Struggle support group (It's a Discord group). Hopefully you can find benefits there. Salam.
Wow, this is a really enlightening insight into your struggle. This straight struggle support group sounds really important and useful for muslims going through such things. It really is a minority within a minority as you said. It’s crucial for the Muslim community to understand that marriage isn’t always a solution for some people. May Allah make it easy for all of you.
Salam there is no such thing as same sex attraction. there are only waswas and i think that people who think that they have this sexual attraction should learn more about how to protect themselves from waswas and the world of the jinns especially the hate of sheitan for mankind to begin. then try to cure their highly sexed thoughts by fasting regularly but not simply stop eating or drinking but by trying to take the control of their thoughts. roqya and jinn catchings can help them in that. suicidal thoughts are also the work of satanic jinns... the best way to FIGHT these thoughts is to be absolutely certain that this is the work of jinns and talk to them as if you were fighting an adversary ready to kill you in a battle field when these thoughts come into your mind you can say to the jinn risponsible for these thoughts that you can see what it is doing and now you will burn it till its death with the qu'ran then recite surat an nas and you will very really kill it this surat burns jinns litteraly till they die talking and meeting with people who think that they have this kind of attraction is a bad idea. you should leave this world of ego libido and abstain to regulate your hormone count in order to take control of it. also pornography is the major way of feeding these thoughts. That's the material jinns use to take you under control and make their waswas more easy for them to reach you... If you leave all this and replace it with an interest for founding a familly and having children the jinns will be tired of harassing you... but it's like dealing with a drug addiction, once you open a door by watching porn for example or feeding sexual fantasies is a call for the jinns and they will come back with much more ferocity against you because you chained them when you stooped doing so... this is a real war in their world and they really live it like that fighting our desires is the biggest jihad prophet Muhammad alayhi Salat wa Salam warned us about. but he gave us the massiv destruction arm to fight against the biggest lack in modern islamic sciences is the developpment of an islamic psychology that involves the understanding of the jinns' world... english is not my first language and i am trying my best to be understood but i would have more to say if i could write in french
It's always my pleasure time when I see that brother Paul has uploaded a new highly educational interview. *Thank you brother Paul* 🌹 May Allah rewards you with abundant good in this world and in the hearafter. *Ameeen*
Outstanding interview. Finally we can see and hear a balanced common sense approach. If you have faith it has to be faith. Otherwise it is pouring water into a bucket with holes and hoping it will actual hold.
Valiant approach to a tricky subject. And necessary, nothing should be brushed under the carpet. Only dealing with "hard to talk" topics can we estimate their real importance and dismiss "fairy tales". It's good to talk. Grateful to Dr Ali for his gracious,wise and courageous approach to the topic discussed. I've learned views and points of wich I wasn't aware and has helped me a great deal with my personal growth. Also thankful to you Paul for your choice of topics and erudite speakers. Delightful. 👍🏽😘
Dr Abdullah gave really good advice in dealing with people who want you to use a specific pronoun, especially in work places where you are pushed to do so. You can refer to them by their name and not use the pronouns.
As-salam aleikum wa rahmatullah wa barakatuh! Barak Allah fikum, it was very interesting and beneficial conversation. İnshaallah this video will reach and benefit wide range of people!
Very profound and insightful interview. Kudos to Dr Abdullah Ali for sharing such sensitive topic of close family members belonging to LGBT and how compassionately he deals with them.
I've just learned here that Sir Roger Scruton has passed away. I very much enjoyed his documentaries and talks. A really fine gentleman. May Allah bless his soul.
MashaAllah! Mr Williams is the manifestation of the Hadith in which The Final Messenger of Allah, Muhammad Pbuh said to his companions, " I yearn for my brothers, to which The companions said, ' aren't we your brothers?', He Pbuh replied, ' no, you're my companions.' and my brothers are those who will believe in me without seeing me.'
Very mature conversation about an important topic. If there is an intellectual basis for or discussion to be had about sensitive issues then intellectual censorship must take a back seat to that discourse even if it’s difficult, so long as the discourse is respectful.
Brother bin hamid Ali is an under the radar scholar. More people need to seek out his knowledge. I’ve benefited immensely from him, may Allah continue to keep him healthy so that he can continue his work and gain good deeds ameen
Thanks a lot for addressing this important topic. I just stumbled upon this channel and find it extremely informative. Love the format and everything about it.
I suggesr you enable ads on this channel because an inapropriate ad showed up whan i was watching this video.i suggest patreon as a way of supporting this channel.its better than ads.keep up the good work bro .salam
Assalamu Alaikum, JazakAllahu Khayran for having this discussion, just want to add that early trauma experienced by young children does seem to impact on gender 'choices' of young adolescents, and it does seem to be a sub conscious 'decision' that trauma victims make, in an attempt to 'protect' themselves from future abuse. Definitely not ALL homosexuality, but at least some of it.
What is great about the pandemics is that it normalize across the globe, video meetings. No need for venues, conferences and audience is now well used to it :)
Most relevant discussion of our times which we as parents are facing. It is our duty to convey the correct information to teenagers and young adults. It is a trial of our times which has the capability to shatter most of our moral values . It should be taken seriously.
I think this video from this scholar is helpful too. But i think parents need to watch this first before deciding to share this content with their pre-teen or teenager. Not that its explicit or anything but i find how the sheikh advise is quite realistic. I used some of these points if questioned by non-muslims who feel that muslims "hate" homosexuals and we dont have a a solution for people who are tested with these desires. I posted the link here. ua-cam.com/video/nvOKsfBo1Hs/v-deo.html
@@benharis1956 no, there is no sahih hadith which mentioned that the sons of adam and eve maried to each other. It's adptation from biblical naration and tradition. Which is wrong. The Qur'an and sahih hadith im-ply that human evolution exist.
Love from India Jazakallah khair for the interview Can we get more deeper and wide into this topic.. because the revisionist favouring homosexual relationships are increasing in numbers.. there's a facebook group I joined in the past by TED speaker El farook khaki..who runs the unity mosque in Toronto This group has homosexuals from all over the world and they are giving a different approach to this It would be great if you could arrange a meeting like this with him or such revisionist identities
Dr Abdullah Ali is the most courageous scholars rn in the Muslim ummah. He speaks out about our modern world and their agenda. He has recent talks about mandating vaccines also.
*In old testament Leviticus 20:13 Punishmed for Sodomy is death Penalty, and Quran depicts Sodomy as an heinous Crime but leaves its punishmed to Shura-Council. Shura can set any punishment which could be death penalty too. Quran has fixed Hadood punishment for some crimes like Zina and Slander but Quran gives option to Shura-Council to set punishment for those other actions/conduct which Quran has made illegal/Haraam*
That's not true as the prophet did say anybody who commits the actions of the nation of Lut kill him. That's the opinion of the vast majority of scholars, so we have a similar thing
@@alijawad432 Rationally your argument is totally flawed because Prophet left behind *not a single page of extra-Quranic manuscript.* So you and we cannot know what prophet really said on any subject, but we know, Quran 15:9, 17:88, 41:42 was revealed to Prophet, and Prophet *was BOUND* to follow only what is given in Quran 10:15, 6:19, 6:114. Therefore; there is ONLY AND ONLY one way, and that way is: to do Tadabbar in Quran to know what does Quran say: Besides, so called "Scholars" are not a Criteria of Islamic Law; but again, Criteria of Islamic law is only Quran which prophet and 4 Caliphs only left behind 6:114. Term "Scholar" is itself totally subjective and heavily disputed. Near you, one person could be a Scholar, but near us same person could be a Jaahil 9:31. So? *Also, you must learn that *majority is not a benchmark of being right. Fact: is Majority always followed wrong path (Quran 6:116). You can also see practical example which is in your front: Religion-wise Christians are in majority. Now, should you follow their doctrines of Son-ship and Trinity, ONLY because they are in majority! Should you leave Islam, and embrace Christianity ONLY because Christians are in majority!!* Matter is simple: As Iblis has mislead Paulines from 2000 years; in the same way SAME Iblis has misled vast majority of Muslims from 1200 years (Read 38:82-83, 14:22)
Thank you brother Paul for inviting experts and talking about Islamic position on current matters, airing the sharia position, and last but net least discussing political alliance issues of Muslims in the west. Certainly the left speaks alluring language for Muslims, but their background is in fact hostile to Islam and other religions. Muslims coming from countries where people are persecuted for their religious beliefs, their political views and ethnicities, find western countries and the left very attractive and they sway to the left. However left's core ideas are hostile to Islam.
The sad thing is that lot of our experiences can have detrimental effects on future behaviour. The problem is the claim and the belief that it is innate as is the believe that liking or disliking some food is innate. It is in our human nature to have preferences based on nurture. Exactly this makes us subjective and tribalistic ect. The left is just framing an emotional argument while we should understand that we do not anything about ourselves truly, but ourselves in mix/relation with the external world and influences. Why did we prefer this food over the other? If your first time fish was the worst experiences because of one bad fish you will maybe never eat fish. But if your first time was a really good fish, the second possible bad fish would make you understand that there exist a hierarchical structure of bad and good fish of the same type. You would understand that the first time can be sought and was the bad fish just accidental.
Islam have principle, we are muslims who follow the Islam religion, the follower must follow what has been written, “If you are tolerance for everything, then you are stand for nothing, if you ade stand for nothing, you will be fall in anything”, thats why islam is respected, people cant make fun of islam easily.
Hi Paul, I just have a video recommendation if u are willing to consider. Just found out yesterday that 137 is one of the biggest mystery numbers as per physics. I searched youtube and found a lot of videos on it. Then a thought came to my mind to check Alquran Alkareem about this mystery number so searched "alquran 13:7". Lo and behold, it talks about people asking for a sign from Lord. So this number is a sign from Lord almighty for these physics people. I would love if u can research on it and call a physics professor to discuss this topic or whatever u think best. I hope you like this idea
Hi paul,quite informative/constructive dialogue ,thanks.I must draw your attention to one of the most common misnomer and rather sinful ,namely luwat ,which connect the sexual intercourse between men to the name of prophet Loot.I am actually astonished that prof.Ali chose to overhear it when you mentioned the word.Also Unlike many other and very few human practices which are prohibited and considered sinfull, no mention of punishment is made in Quran .It's noteworthy that there is only one religion called Islam guided by the message of Quran
Fight those who do not believe in Allah or in the Last Day and who do not consider unlawful what Allah and His Messenger have made unlawful and who do not adopt the religion of truth from those who were given the Scripture - [fight] until they give the jizyah willingly while they are humbled. Quran 9:29
In Quran, if we see *degree of severity of punishment* for the people of "Sodom and Gomorrah"; then it becomes clear that their sin was even bigger than the sin of Zina. So, Shura-Council can make a law to punish such people, accordingly. This is the whole truth but if someone loves to twist the facts, no one can stop him.
36:34 I'm not convinced that Imam Abu Hanifa would have made those statements about throwing sodimites from a tower and then stoned afterwards. Imam Abu Hanifa was a strong rationalist and he would not have accepted those ahadith. The clear nass from the Qur'aan that links punishment to homosexual acts is Surah 4.16, where the general term fahisha [immoral acts] is linked to huma [two of them], which can be two men, two women or a man and woman. The punishment cannot be death, as the Qur'aan tells us to leave the two individuals alone after they have repented. Ibn Hazm of the Zaheeri school of thought did not seem to accept any ahadith which claimed that homosexuals should be put to death.
I see one way run with your family 🏃♀️ to Muslim country no one Muslim in the uk or imam can speak publicly about homosexuality education to our children.
with modern technology fiqh is expanded, you can even produce 100 witnesses of upright individual, or even 1000 at a snap of your finger now. That's with a camera/recorder. But the point is, we as humans cannot know better about ourselves and how to govern ourselves than our Creator. We are here for a function, the Quran and Sunnah are our manual. We just listen and obey.
You have an interesting discussion regarding the need for witnesses. However, it seems to be a massive leap to apply texts that clearly discuss adultery between a man and woman and then assume they also apply to men to practice their lusts upon other men. I haven’t seen any texts that validate the need for witness to the sexual act when it comes to men. It would be interesting to look into this
What about public advocacy of lewedness etc ? Issue is less of a public act, rather normalization in the public discourse and acceptance as normative behavior. What about a person who publicly claims he/she commits such acts and finds it normative behavior and defends such behavior?
Brother just because someone says something its normal, doesn't mean it IS normal. That's not how Allah (swt) created us. May Allah (swt) guide us all and grant us forgiveness. Ameen:)
9:00 he casually states that Aristotle had influence over mainstream Muslim scholars, the muhadithin, fuqaha, 4 imams were most certainly not influenced by Aristotle at all!
I can say according witnessing adultry Or sodonomy, that any body who enjoys watching pornography is actually guilty because he or she witnessed a crime and didn’t do anything about it and get himself to be a partner with them
@@brendantannam499 ofcourse not, what l am trying to say to Muslim people who don't feel guilty or shame when watching porn because they think it is not haram I want to tell them watching porn is like doing it and it is bad for our eman
In jurisprudence the fact that there is no agreement between the four madhabs is RahmatuLah a GOD's Mercy to prevent extremism and intolerance. Today I have learned that Paul al Hanifi is a follower of abu Hanifa's madhab al HamduliLah ! In aqeeda it's a litlle bit different from my point of view... There is only one way to understand Allah and the more you get close to that understanding the more you can see HIM... That's why we say that deen al Islam is divided in three segments according to the hadith of Jibril alayhi Salam... Aqeeda to know Allah, Fiqh jurisprudence to follow what HE Allowed and Forbidded and Tasawuf to get closer to HIM by purifiying your heart and seeck for the Adab that pleases HIM so that he Allows you to come closer to HIM. The beautiful secret of this initiation to this proximity with Allah is that that's HIM who purify your heart, choses you, allows you to get closer, prevent you from falling in sins, elevate you... By yourself you can do absolutely nothing... but seecking for pure humility and pure sincerity... Every time you break an idol of what you thought was sincerity you understand how hypocrite you were al HamduliLah wa Allahu Akbar wa SubhanAllah Allahu a'lam
The thing about the at least four witnesses is a condamnation of pornography from the time of prophet Muhammad alayhi Salat wa Salam. My guess is that prophet Muhammad alayhi Salat wa Salam was granted by Allah of visions of our time especially when he described the end of times
Why should they? Polygamy is not an oblgtion. 🤷 If the country doesn't care about the millions of women who can't be maried due to the law of monogamy. Then let them dstroy themself, coz that would prmoting prstitution and ceating mariage. Which is cndmned by God. 🙄
Genuine question: if a gay man or woman was married, and found Islam later in life, am I supposed to tell them to divorce their husband/wife and never be in a relationship again, forever? I don’t know if Allah would want that. It seems that we are against celibacy (compared to say, Catholicism, where their priests can not ever be married). Also, I think the Quran only seems to mention sodomy. Why do we equate sodomy with all gay people? What if a woman is gay? And if being gay is not genetic, then why doesn’t conversion therapy work? Why does it leave people traumatized and scarred?
You advise them with wisdom of the following: 1. Homosexuality is forbidden in Islam 2. Sodomy is strictly prohibited 3. Any marriage outside of a heterosexual marriage is not considered a marriage. 4. Seek Islamic therapy to help curb the homosexual urges.
You're too focused on the worldly aspect of our life. This life is a test, if they truly believe in islam, they would firstly have thought about divorcing and already has, because it's known I think that the major religions don't allow this act. This life is a test, the thing you ask them is would you follow your desires rather than God? Simple. We're not going to stay here forever, it's temporary. Well there are some people that are genetically attracted to alcohol for example, that will be their test, to go against their desires. We're not liberalists where you can follow a few desires you have, because it's not that big of a deal.
Of course, sodomy prior to the existence of condoms, was a health risk to some degree. And sexuality in general, given how strong an urge it is, is difficult to regulate, thus for unsophisticated folk, a general ban is a lot easier to understand and promote, than one full of nuance. But as sex is basically strictly physical, it has no direct impact on the soul. That impact occurs mentally based in motive. If the intent is to use it to express love and affection on a mutual basis, that is the ideal. If it is used to exploit someone, with no regard to their well-being, that is immoral. But confining sex to strictly reproductive purposes, while understandable in primitive cultures, is quite possibly also immoral, as it completely disregards the needs of the woman, who never has their God given ability to have orgasms satisfied.
Just to share with - in Islam we have some authentic hadith narrated by the wife of the Prophet , Aisyah and some of his other wives ( May Allah be pleased with them) on intimacy in marriage. There is emphasis on foreplay and satisfying the wife first before the husband satisfies himself. And that the concept of sexual satisfaction should be mutual between the spouses. Most of these hadith are usually taught to muslim couple before their marriage and also in today's context most likely include sexuality education etc. However when i was a young teenager my mum in fact got me a book about sex in a muslim marriage - i myself was surprised to see how much emphasis is being taught of taking of the wife's needs and that even leaving her unsatisfied is a sin in Islam - again based on the Prophet's ( pbuh) teachings and of course that the act of lovemaking is an act of charity and kindness - both husband and wife get rewarded by Allah when they make love to each other. Very beautiful. I am no expert on hadith but if you look at the chronology etc - to me at least this Prophet Muhammad ( pbuh) must be guided by God. 1500 years ago the pagan Arabs were killing their female babies, female toddlers and pagans would inherit women like they were things - so taking care of the female sexuality was unheard of. Only the Creator who created both the male and female could teach such concepts to those pagans. Also from the medical point of view - anal sex be it male or female - carries the risk of injury, infection etc as that organ is designed to excrete feces and not for sex. However lbgtq+ movement has put pressure on the medical community to be less outspoken on the dangers of anal sex/sodomy - but if you go by medical research and medical textbooks - anal sex has more negative issues compared to vaginal sex.
How about lesbian behavior caused by separated gender in school (islamic school)?? I am an indonesian. I have a girl friend who has inclination to "lesbian conducts" because she used to lived among muslim girls at an islamic boarding school special for female only." She stated to me that 'lesbianism' from that life style even being kept after they graduated, even they are married muslim men.. Please anyone gives me insight or preace me or anything.. this is a toughful question in my life
The idea that gender separation causes this is absurd. Ideas are contagious. She must have had certain influences that entertain certain ideas and feelings. Shaytan plays on these feelings to convince them that they are born like that and that their feelings are somehow legitimate. Sure knows what's acceptable behaviour and what isn't. She is in control therefore she is blameworthy for her actions.
Some people are just desperate to get laid, and because they did it at such a young age, that desperation gets carried into their adult life. Its the same as porn addiction imo.
I am going to be honest. I studied in all boys school and I had gay desires . I knew something was wrong with me not because it was an only boys school. I mean why the others boys did not had these feelings after doing some research and some self finding I found out it was all linked to my behaviour, my thinking and the things I was watching and the funny thing is I did not even watched gay porn not even once in my life but from where these feelings were coming from then I found out it was too much exposure to porn and other stuff so I started to change my habits. I do not want to go too much into it but it was mostly my problem or my test which Allah was putting me through and thank Allah that I was able to pass and did not do anything stupid that would leave a scar on my soul. So that friend of yours is responsible for her actions and she is just trying to find an easy way out by all this leabianism and lgbtq stuff. I hope it explains a little
Very slippery slope of morality. Paul tries to Justify Islam because of the private nature and the need for 4 witnesses. But the simple fact remains that the situation is comparable to Putin making propaganda for homosexuality illegal, without making homosexuality itself illegal. In Russia vigilante gangs immediately responded by persecuting gays much more vigorously. If you declare "homosexuals" immoral their legal protection evaporates. Teachers can suddenly loose their jobs over accusations of "propaganda for homosecuality", police and judges will look the other way. The same happens with Islam declaring homosexuals and Apostates worthy of capital punishment. It incites hatred and contempt. Vigilante attacks have even happened in the UK where Paul lives. The "narratives" will usually conflate pedophilia with homophilia, discuss all supposed health risks without acknowledging that many heterosexuals will have experimented with anal sex as well. The only way is for Islamic leaders to openly choose for persecution and legal action against gays to be wrong.
First off, regarding anal sex Islam prohibits that for both hetero and homosexual people. And Islam expressly forbids vigilante violence. And the whole desires defining who you are is problematic
*Timestamps for Chapters:*
0:00 - Introduction
0:23 - Information about the Guest
2:05 - Reason behind writing the article "The Homosexual Challenge to Muslim Ethics"
6:42 - Influence of Thomas Aquinas
8:08 - Overlap of Christian and Muslim Ethics
9:28 - Challenges while writing the article
11:47 - Relevance of the article today
13:37 - Is Homosexuality genetic? (Does Gay gene exist?)
17:36 - Shariah on Homosexuality
24:03 - Proving the Homosexual act in Islamic Court
26:27 - Shariah implementation in Western societies
28:02 - Arguments of Liberal Muslims against the article
34:50 - Punishment of carrying out the act
38:05 - Restriction about speaking about key Islamic Values in the West
40:29 - Objective of the article and supporting the lgbt rights
45:17 - Muslims aligning with the political Left wing/Right wing.
54:53 - Dr. Ali's perspective on Homosexuality
58:07 - No Difference between sex and gender
1:00:32 - Promotion and normalisation of Lqbt
1:02:41 - Book Recommendations by brother Paul and Dr. Ali
1:08:30 - Causes and navigating Homosexuality
1:11:02 - Closing Statements
Great help, many thanks 👍🏽😘
This shd hv been pned.
👏
Thank you for created this! Very helpful.
@@BloggingTheology Jazakallah khair brother Paul 😊☺️
My husband is a very big fan of yours. You have inspired him in many ways. Thankyou so much for these very insightful and informative videos. We'll keep rooting for you. May Allah bless you and reward you greatly 🤲❤️
Wow
Aameen 🤲
May Allah protect us and our children and our future generations of Muslims 🤲🏼
@ᗯᕼIᔕTᒪEᗷᒪOᗯEᖇ GᗩY ᖴEᗰIᑎIᑎE ᗰᗩᑎ ᔕᒪᑌT ᗰᗩᒪEᔕ ᖇIGᕼTᔕ
'A'ishah (may Allah be pleased with her) narrated that the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) said:
"Everyone has been created with three hundred and sixty Joints. Whoever mentions Allah's greatness (says Allahu Akbar), praises Allah, extols Allah, and seeks forgiveness from Allah and removes stones from the path of the people, enjoins what is good and forbids the evil to the amount of those three hundred and sixty joints (sulama), he walks on that Day (of Judgment) having distanced himself from the Hell
Up until 1995 it was believed there were only 340 joints in the human body. However, scientists then found 20 more! How could Prophet Muhammad know that there were 360 joints in the human body, as narrated in the hadiths
Ameen, btw right when I clicked on this video a gay ad showed up, these ads are Jeep on coming up especially Christian “ex Muslims” ads on Islamic videos it’s so annoying. They do everything but debunk Islam with proper sources
@ᗯᕼIᔕTᒪEᗷᒪOᗯEᖇ GᗩY ᖴEᗰIᑎIᑎE ᗰᗩᑎ ᔕᒪᑌT ᗰᗩᒪEᔕ ᖇIGᕼTᔕ if it’s a story and lie then how has there been many miracles of the Quran and proofs for it being more true than false? You’re probably just a troll account tho
@ᗯᕼIᔕTᒪEᗷᒪOᗯEᖇ GᗩY ᖴEᗰIᑎIᑎE ᗰᗩᑎ ᔕᒪᑌT ᗰᗩᒪEᔕ ᖇIGᕼTᔕ if God created adam and steve, not adam and eve, you'd probably won't even exist. Lol.
Ameen Ameen
Top job Paul. Just want to echo the same sentiment that has been expressed a (few) thousand times; you're doing an excellent job at producing original and thought provoking content that seek to defend conservative and traditional values. Wish and pray for your continued success and Tawfiq as you develop your channel. Much love and respect.
Many thanks Qaiser!
I'm impressed how as a convert you are so upto speed with Islamic views on contemporary issues and the nuanced opinions.
Paul has been around for a long time, way before this channel. But indeed, he continues to impress us
To summarize. 1- Islam separates between desires (e.g. unintentional homosexual thoughts) vs acting on these desires ( committing Liwat). 2- all scholars agreed that acting on homosexual desires is a sin, but they differ on what (worldly) punishment it warrants (in the context of a muslim society, not non-Muslim one) 2.1. public not private homosexual acts ( like Zina) is what warrants penalty. Public crimes are crimes so scandalous, that they manage to be witnessed by four upright male witnesses in a conservative Muslim society . 2.2. most lenient opinions on what the penalty is could be found in Hanifi school which assigns a ' tazeer' penalty ( leaving the type of punishment to society's judgment.) 2.3. i will add here , ibn Hazm opinion on the matter ( he considers it tazeer, if memory serves right) 3- Muslims in the West should re-consider their ties to the left and be cautions with the baggage that comes with these ties (eg. pressure to support LGBT causes) 4- people with homosexual desires, like those with heterosexual ones, are both trialed by their creator. The trial is to deal with these desires in accordance to divine will ( not their whims). 4.1. For example, a heterosexual man is never given the green light to commit zina no matter his circumstances ( i guess a Western example here is he is never allowed to commit rape). Patience is his test
I love this. Thankyou for these words. Peace be with you.✌
Muslims need to be woke about this .. soon otherwise they will suffer
Well-said.
Thank you for bringing the awareness about this issue. As a muslim that is struggling with Same Sex Attraction) SSA and will be till the end of my life, I really hope that Muslim community is more informed and emphatic towards this particular test. It is indeed a VERY HARD test as people growing up with SSA are much more vulnerable to suffer from mental related illness such as depression. I went through depression period mixed with suicidal ideation when I was younger. At one point, I remember constantly crying before sleeping and ask Allah SWT to take my life.
Alhamdulillah I'm at a better place right now. But for Muslim community at large, they have to know how hard this test is because the percieved unfairness nature of this particular test. I can understand why many Muslims with SSA left the deen or turn to liberal Islamic interpretation of homosexuality promoted in the west.
One thing that Muslim community should now is that attraction and action are 2 different things. What is accountable is our action. But then that doesn't really ease the struggle for Muslim like myself, because then what? I know that there are therapies that can help people to control the urge so that it won't be overwhleming. But SSA will always be part of us. It won't disappear, it is a lifetime struggle. So many of us afraid that we will be alone growing old and that kind of thought will gives severe anxiety and sadness. Off course SSA is a spectrum and some people are able to have a happy marriage with right intention (not for "curing" SSA whatsoever) but to be selfless in order to make a marriage works. It is to be noted that SSA is a spectrum, some people with SSA may also have some Opposite Sex Attarction (OSA). In the end, marriage is not a universal solution or even an option for some of us who may even repulsed by opposite gender. So as you can see, for some of us it is very hard and the support and undertanding from the Muslim community is very important.
Also, what really help me right now is being part of a support group and community that have the same mindset as myself: we don't want to identify with LGBTQ+ lifestyle and want to try to follow the Islam deen as our way of life and not distorting it to accomodate our sexual desire. It helps us to cope with this struggle without judgement from both Muslim community in general and from pro-LGBTQ+ community. We are a minority wihthin a minority, so hopefully Muslim community can be more compassionate and supporting.
If you are reading this and are a Muslim and struggling with SSA but still want to follow Islam as best as you could. Please consider joining Straight Struggle support group (It's a Discord group). Hopefully you can find benefits there.
Salam.
Wow, this is a really enlightening insight into your struggle. This straight struggle support group sounds really important and useful for muslims going through such things. It really is a minority within a minority as you said. It’s crucial for the Muslim community to understand that marriage isn’t always a solution for some people. May Allah make it easy for all of you.
Thank you for sharing, may Allah swt bless you with happiness and success in this life and the next
Salam
there is no such thing as same sex attraction. there are only waswas and i think that people who think that they have this sexual attraction should learn more about how to protect themselves from waswas and the world of the jinns especially the hate of sheitan for mankind to begin. then try to cure their highly sexed thoughts by fasting regularly but not simply stop eating or drinking but by trying to take the control of their thoughts. roqya and jinn catchings can help them in that. suicidal thoughts are also the work of satanic jinns... the best way to FIGHT these thoughts is to be absolutely certain that this is the work of jinns and talk to them as if you were fighting an adversary ready to kill you in a battle field
when these thoughts come into your mind you can say to the jinn risponsible for these thoughts that you can see what it is doing and now you will burn it till its death with the qu'ran then recite surat an nas and you will very really kill it
this surat burns jinns litteraly till they die
talking and meeting with people who think that they have this kind of attraction is a bad idea. you should leave this world of ego libido and abstain to regulate your hormone count in order to take control of it. also pornography is the major way of feeding these thoughts. That's the material jinns use to take you under control and make their waswas more easy for them to reach you... If you leave all this and replace it with an interest for founding a familly and having children the jinns will be tired of harassing you... but it's like dealing with a drug addiction, once you open a door by watching porn for example or feeding sexual fantasies is a call for the jinns and they will come back with much more ferocity against you because you chained them when you stooped doing so... this is a real war in their world and they really live it like that
fighting our desires is the biggest jihad prophet Muhammad alayhi Salat wa Salam warned us about. but he gave us the massiv destruction arm to fight against
the biggest lack in modern islamic sciences is the developpment of an islamic psychology that involves the understanding of the jinns' world...
english is not my first language and i am trying my best to be understood but i would have more to say if i could write in french
It's always my pleasure time when I see that brother Paul has uploaded a new highly educational interview.
*Thank you brother Paul* 🌹
May Allah rewards you with abundant good in this world and in the hearafter. *Ameeen*
Outstanding interview. Finally we can see and hear a balanced common sense approach. If you have faith it has to be faith. Otherwise it is pouring water into a bucket with holes and hoping it will actual hold.
Love from Pakistan. I was waiting for this one since the day you announced it .Great talk 🖤.
I agree its a Sensitive subject that needs to be addressed and kudos to Dr. Ali for being brave enough to speak the Truth..
How is it sensitive!!
@@klaw1425 I guess, it is because it is dangerous to talk about Homosexuality, Liberals would k'll you without actually k'll'ng you.
@@cactusmccoy3113 Very clever words.
Wooow.. blogging theology has been growing fast channel.. today 106k subscriber.. congrats Bro Paul..
Salam from Indonesia.. ❤
Wa alaykumu s-salam
Salaam all,
I agree with Paul when he says that there is no alliance benefit with the left.
Dr Abdullah Ali is a profound scholar. Cheers, ab
Right-wing economics are highly problematic and Abdullah Ali is not profound in that area at all.
Valiant approach to a tricky subject. And necessary, nothing should be brushed under the carpet. Only dealing with "hard to talk" topics can we estimate their real importance and dismiss "fairy tales". It's good to talk.
Grateful to Dr Ali for his gracious,wise and courageous approach to the topic discussed. I've learned views and points of wich I wasn't aware and has helped me a great deal with my personal growth. Also thankful to you Paul for your choice of topics and erudite speakers. Delightful.
👍🏽😘
@@yulia5009 Thanks for the link, I do think about death often, not in a sad way, on the contrary. 👍🏽😘
Nice to see the plaque on ur backgrounds seems fantastic!
Fantastic indeed 🥺
Dr Abdullah gave really good advice in dealing with people who want you to use a specific pronoun, especially in work places where you are pushed to do so. You can refer to them by their name and not use the pronouns.
Barakallahhu fik 💚
May Allah be please with all that are supporting this channel. AamiinX3
Im only 13 minutes in, and already seen like 3-4 commercial breaks. But ❤ the channel Paul.
Great work! Thank you both very much Gentlemen.
Jazakoum ALLAH khyr 🤲
Marvellous insightful
Love the shield at the background
Thnx for both of u , allah bless u amen , bless & preserve our ummah amen 🤲🏻
Congrats for the new chin , looks good on u 🌺
Brother Paul, there is more light in your face than before MashaAllah.. InshaAllah you get all good things in life and jennah ameen.
As-salam aleikum wa rahmatullah wa barakatuh!
Barak Allah fikum, it was very interesting and beneficial conversation. İnshaallah this video will reach and benefit wide range of people!
Wa alaykumu s-salam
Thank you Br Paul, your presentation and interview style is unique and easy to follow and understand for all
Very profound and insightful interview. Kudos to Dr Abdullah Ali for sharing such sensitive topic of close family members belonging to LGBT and how compassionately he deals with them.
I've just learned here that Sir Roger Scruton has passed away. I very much enjoyed his documentaries and talks. A really fine gentleman. May Allah bless his soul.
A great soul
Amazing video and an amazing speaker may Allah reward him and you and may Allah keep you both firm on the deen
MashaAllah!
Mr Williams is the manifestation of the Hadith in which The Final Messenger of Allah, Muhammad Pbuh said to his companions, " I yearn for my brothers, to which The companions said, ' aren't we your brothers?', He Pbuh replied, ' no, you're my companions.' and my brothers are those who will believe in me without seeing me.'
Very mature conversation about an important topic. If there is an intellectual basis for or discussion to be had about sensitive issues then intellectual censorship must take a back seat to that discourse even if it’s difficult, so long as the discourse is respectful.
Very insightful. Thanks.
Paul's maybe the Joe Rogan of Muslim Podcasts, except more classy and also more intelligent.
Subhana Allah. It appears that Allah wants people to repent and leave their sin, rather than punishment for the sinners.
Brother bin hamid Ali is an under the radar scholar. More people need to seek out his knowledge. I’ve benefited immensely from him, may Allah continue to keep him healthy so that he can continue his work and gain good deeds ameen
Thanks a lot for addressing this important topic. I just stumbled upon this channel and find it extremely informative. Love the format and everything about it.
Thanks, fantastic interview, very informative
I suggesr you enable ads on this channel because an inapropriate ad showed up whan i was watching this video.i suggest patreon as a way of supporting this channel.its better than ads.keep up the good work bro .salam
Salutations Mr. Paul!
Very informative and enlightening . Thank you both.
Assalamu Alaikum,
JazakAllahu Khayran for having this discussion, just want to add that early trauma experienced by young children does seem to impact on gender 'choices' of young adolescents, and it does seem to be a sub conscious 'decision' that trauma victims make, in an attempt to 'protect' themselves from future abuse. Definitely not ALL homosexuality, but at least some of it.
What is great about the pandemics is that it normalize across the globe, video meetings.
No need for venues, conferences and audience is now well used to it :)
Most relevant discussion of our times which we as parents are facing. It is our duty to convey the correct information to teenagers and young adults. It is a trial of our times which has the capability to shatter most of our moral values . It should be taken seriously.
I think this video from this scholar is helpful too. But i think parents need to watch this first before deciding to share this content with their pre-teen or teenager. Not that its explicit or anything but i find how the sheikh advise is quite realistic. I used some of these points if questioned by non-muslims who feel that muslims "hate" homosexuals and we dont have a a solution for people who are tested with these desires. I posted the link here.
ua-cam.com/video/nvOKsfBo1Hs/v-deo.html
@@lilyrosesoul0077 thanks for your advice. I will IA watch the recommended vlog
Masha Allah. Very good program. 👍
Really enjoy Dr. Abdullah Ali. Hope you will have more collaborations with him.
Hopefully!
"God created adam and eve, not adam and steve." (Uthman the excellent)
This is great. 😁 made my day. Thanks for sharing
And then he said to their kids to freak each other😂does that mean ur kids need to imitate it too ?🤣
@@papawastheretoo5yearsago.167 He only allowed it for that period in time, I.e beginning era, thereafter NO.
@@benharis1956 but still lol he did it, why didn't he just create more human instead😂🤣 if he saw it as bad?
@@benharis1956 no, there is no sahih hadith which mentioned that the sons of adam and eve maried to each other. It's adptation from biblical naration and tradition.
Which is wrong. The Qur'an and sahih hadith im-ply that human evolution exist.
Love from India
Jazakallah khair for the interview
Can we get more deeper and wide into this topic.. because the revisionist favouring homosexual relationships are increasing in numbers.. there's a facebook group I joined in the past by TED speaker El farook khaki..who runs the unity mosque in Toronto
This group has homosexuals from all over the world and they are giving a different approach to this
It would be great if you could arrange a meeting like this with him or such revisionist identities
Dr Abdullah Ali is the most courageous scholars rn in the Muslim ummah. He speaks out about our modern world and their agenda. He has recent talks about mandating vaccines also.
جزاك الله خيرا
*In old testament Leviticus 20:13 Punishmed for Sodomy is death Penalty, and Quran depicts Sodomy as an heinous Crime but leaves its punishmed to Shura-Council. Shura can set any punishment which could be death penalty too. Quran has fixed Hadood punishment for some crimes like Zina and Slander but Quran gives option to Shura-Council to set punishment for those other actions/conduct which Quran has made illegal/Haraam*
That's not true as the prophet did say anybody who commits the actions of the nation of Lut kill him. That's the opinion of the vast majority of scholars, so we have a similar thing
@@alijawad432
Rationally your argument is totally flawed because Prophet left behind *not a single page of extra-Quranic manuscript.* So you and we cannot know what prophet really said on any subject, but we know, Quran 15:9, 17:88, 41:42 was revealed to Prophet, and Prophet *was BOUND* to follow only what is given in Quran 10:15, 6:19, 6:114. Therefore; there is ONLY AND ONLY one way, and that way is: to do Tadabbar in Quran to know what does Quran say:
Besides, so called "Scholars" are not a Criteria of Islamic Law; but again, Criteria of Islamic law is only Quran which prophet and 4 Caliphs only left behind 6:114. Term "Scholar" is itself totally subjective and heavily disputed. Near you, one person could be a Scholar, but near us same person could be a Jaahil 9:31. So?
*Also, you must learn that *majority is not a benchmark of being right. Fact: is Majority always followed wrong path (Quran 6:116). You can also see practical example which is in your front: Religion-wise Christians are in majority. Now, should you follow their doctrines of Son-ship and Trinity, ONLY because they are in majority! Should you leave Islam, and embrace Christianity ONLY because Christians are in majority!!*
Matter is simple: As Iblis has mislead Paulines from 2000 years; in the same way SAME Iblis has misled vast majority of Muslims from 1200 years (Read 38:82-83, 14:22)
Thank you!
Thank you brother Paul for inviting experts and talking about Islamic position on current matters, airing the sharia position, and last but net least discussing political alliance issues of Muslims in the west. Certainly the left speaks alluring language for Muslims, but their background is in fact hostile to Islam and other religions. Muslims coming from countries where people are persecuted for their religious beliefs, their political views and ethnicities, find western countries and the left very attractive and they sway to the left. However left's core ideas are hostile to Islam.
Very good conversation. I enjoyed it
What do you guys think of "Muslim" institutions/imams in the West that somehow promote and participate in LGBTQ events?
The sad thing is that lot of our experiences can have detrimental effects on future behaviour.
The problem is the claim and the belief that it is innate as is the believe that liking or disliking some food is innate.
It is in our human nature to have preferences based on nurture. Exactly this makes us subjective and tribalistic ect.
The left is just framing an emotional argument while we should understand that we do not anything about ourselves truly, but ourselves in mix/relation with the external world and influences.
Why did we prefer this food over the other? If your first time fish was the worst experiences because of one bad fish you will maybe never eat fish.
But if your first time was a really good fish, the second possible bad fish would make you understand that there exist a hierarchical structure of bad and good fish of the same type. You would understand that the first time can be sought and was the bad fish just accidental.
Islam have principle, we are muslims who follow the Islam religion, the follower must follow what has been written,
“If you are tolerance for everything, then you are stand for nothing, if you ade stand for nothing, you will be fall in anything”, thats why islam is respected, people cant make fun of islam easily.
Great video. Far too many advertisements.
جزاك اللّٰه خيرًا
downloaded the video just in case
well done
Hi Paul, I just have a video recommendation if u are willing to consider. Just found out yesterday that 137 is one of the biggest mystery numbers as per physics. I searched youtube and found a lot of videos on it. Then a thought came to my mind to check Alquran Alkareem about this mystery number so searched "alquran 13:7". Lo and behold, it talks about people asking for a sign from Lord. So this number is a sign from Lord almighty for these physics people. I would love if u can research on it and call a physics professor to discuss this topic or whatever u think best. I hope you like this idea
Hi paul,quite informative/constructive dialogue ,thanks.I must draw your attention to one of the most common misnomer and rather sinful ,namely luwat ,which connect the sexual intercourse between men to the name of prophet Loot.I am actually astonished that prof.Ali chose to overhear it when you mentioned the word.Also Unlike many other and very few human practices which are prohibited and considered sinfull, no mention of punishment is made in Quran .It's noteworthy that there is only one religion called Islam guided by the message of Quran
Salaam only one God and it's Allah SWT love here from South Africa Johannesburg pray 5 time a day
Almost everything is a result of environment and genetics
Fight those who do not believe in Allah or in the Last Day and who do not consider unlawful what Allah and His Messenger have made unlawful and who do not adopt the religion of truth from those who were given the Scripture - [fight] until they give the jizyah willingly while they are humbled. Quran 9:29
Asalamualikum dear brother.
In Quran, if we see *degree of severity of punishment* for the people of "Sodom and Gomorrah"; then it becomes clear that their sin was even bigger than the sin of Zina. So, Shura-Council can make a law to punish such people, accordingly. This is the whole truth but if someone loves to twist the facts, no one can stop him.
Thanks!
Many thanks Qutaiba!
First like :)
36:34 I'm not convinced that Imam Abu Hanifa would have made those statements about throwing sodimites from a tower and then stoned afterwards. Imam Abu Hanifa was a strong rationalist and he would not have accepted those ahadith. The clear nass from the Qur'aan that links punishment to homosexual acts is Surah 4.16, where the general term fahisha [immoral acts] is linked to huma [two of them], which can be two men, two women or a man and woman. The punishment cannot be death, as the Qur'aan tells us to leave the two individuals alone after they have repented. Ibn Hazm of the Zaheeri school of thought did not seem to accept any ahadith which claimed that homosexuals should be put to death.
جزاک اللّہ خیرا کثیرا
I see one way run with your family 🏃♀️ to Muslim country no one Muslim in the uk or imam can speak publicly about homosexuality education to our children.
Good Video
So much work
Daniel Haqiqatjou and Sajid Libhan have gone to great lengths to debunk Homosexual
What do you mean by debunk?
Masha Allah!
with modern technology fiqh is expanded, you can even produce 100 witnesses of upright individual, or even 1000 at a snap of your finger now. That's with a camera/recorder. But the point is, we as humans cannot know better about ourselves and how to govern ourselves than our Creator. We are here for a function, the Quran and Sunnah are our manual. We just listen and obey.
Liars and devils come out to lie, curses of Allah, the angels and of men combined be upon them.
You have an interesting discussion regarding the need for witnesses. However, it seems to be a massive leap to apply texts that clearly discuss adultery between a man and woman and then assume they also apply to men to practice their lusts upon other men. I haven’t seen any texts that validate the need for witness to the sexual act when it comes to men. It would be interesting to look into this
What about public advocacy of lewedness etc ? Issue is less of a public act, rather normalization in the public discourse and acceptance as normative behavior.
What about a person who publicly claims he/she commits such acts and finds it normative behavior and defends such behavior?
Brother just because someone says something its normal, doesn't mean it IS normal. That's not how Allah (swt) created us. May Allah (swt) guide us all and grant us forgiveness. Ameen:)
I need Subtitle in Indonesia 😭😭😭
❤️
9:00 he casually states that Aristotle had influence over mainstream Muslim scholars, the muhadithin, fuqaha, 4 imams were most certainly not influenced by Aristotle at all!
I can say according witnessing adultry
Or sodonomy, that any body who enjoys watching pornography is actually guilty because he or she witnessed a crime and didn’t do anything about it and get himself to be a partner with them
Do you think the Muslim community should punish people who watch porn?
@@brendantannam499 ofcourse not, what l am trying to say to Muslim people who don't feel guilty or shame when watching porn because they think it is not haram
I want to tell them watching porn is like doing it and it is bad for our eman
@@sumasalim7201 That's fair enough!
You may consider the food (synthetic estrogens) and plastic (pbh) hormonal disruption and perhaps other chemical influences. Thanks to “science “…
In jurisprudence the fact that there is no agreement between the four madhabs is RahmatuLah a GOD's Mercy to prevent extremism and intolerance. Today I have learned that Paul al Hanifi is a follower of abu Hanifa's madhab al HamduliLah !
In aqeeda it's a litlle bit different from my point of view... There is only one way to understand Allah and the more you get close to that understanding the more you can see HIM... That's why we say that deen al Islam is divided in three segments according to the hadith of Jibril alayhi Salam... Aqeeda to know Allah, Fiqh jurisprudence to follow what HE Allowed and Forbidded and Tasawuf to get closer to HIM by purifiying your heart and seeck for the Adab that pleases HIM so that he Allows you to come closer to HIM. The beautiful secret of this initiation to this proximity with Allah is that that's HIM who purify your heart, choses you, allows you to get closer, prevent you from falling in sins, elevate you... By yourself you can do absolutely nothing... but seecking for pure humility and pure sincerity... Every time you break an idol of what you thought was sincerity you understand how hypocrite you were al HamduliLah wa Allahu Akbar wa SubhanAllah
Allahu a'lam
The thing about the at least four witnesses is a condamnation of pornography from the time of prophet Muhammad alayhi Salat wa Salam.
My guess is that prophet Muhammad alayhi Salat wa Salam was granted by Allah of visions of our time especially when he described the end of times
Lol I'm getting HIV medication ads 🤣
@24 min ; nowadays the public act is everywhere in the form of films and pornography.
Is br. paul married?
22:06 Tossing people from a tower, I am surprised by this opinion it is the same punishment in the talmud
Dr Z Naik says if found in nature it's God given and isn't a sin has it is found in the animal kingdom.? is it a sin
What is natural isn’t always moral. As humans we’re supposed to strive beyond animal instincts.
Interesting program. Please do a scholarly program like this on polygamy as well. Why don't muslims make an effort to get it legalized in US?
Why should they? Polygamy is not an oblgtion. 🤷
If the country doesn't care about the millions of women who can't be maried due to the law of monogamy. Then let them dstroy themself, coz that would prmoting prstitution and ceating mariage. Which is cndmned by God. 🙄
is Paul christian or muslim? i am getting mixed signals here.
He is Muslim. But he has not said it? Although he says all blessings on prophet Muhammad & all prophets? And inclined to think he is Muslim.
@@benharis1956 Yes he is a muslim.
Isn't zaytoonah where people like Hamza Yusuf come from?
@@mannimationz5706 Brother Paul probably doesn't know this, may Allah forgive him.
@@mannimationz5706 There's a video of Hamza Yusuf mocking the sharia.
Genuine question: if a gay man or woman was married, and found Islam later in life, am I supposed to tell them to divorce their husband/wife and never be in a relationship again, forever? I don’t know if Allah would want that. It seems that we are against celibacy (compared to say, Catholicism, where their priests can not ever be married). Also, I think the Quran only seems to mention sodomy. Why do we equate sodomy with all gay people? What if a woman is gay? And if being gay is not genetic, then why doesn’t conversion therapy work? Why does it leave people traumatized and scarred?
You advise them with wisdom of the following:
1. Homosexuality is forbidden in Islam
2. Sodomy is strictly prohibited
3. Any marriage outside of a heterosexual marriage is not considered a marriage.
4. Seek Islamic therapy to help curb the homosexual urges.
You're too focused on the worldly aspect of our life. This life is a test, if they truly believe in islam, they would firstly have thought about divorcing and already has, because it's known I think that the major religions don't allow this act. This life is a test, the thing you ask them is would you follow your desires rather than God? Simple. We're not going to stay here forever, it's temporary.
Well there are some people that are genetically attracted to alcohol for example, that will be their test, to go against their desires. We're not liberalists where you can follow a few desires you have, because it's not that big of a deal.
👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼
Too many ads!
Sorry!
Of course, sodomy prior to the existence of condoms, was a health risk to some degree. And sexuality in general, given how strong an urge it is, is difficult to regulate, thus for unsophisticated folk, a general ban is a lot easier to understand and promote, than one full of nuance.
But as sex is basically strictly physical, it has no direct impact on the soul. That impact occurs mentally based in motive. If the intent is to use it to express love and affection on a mutual basis, that is the ideal. If it is used to exploit someone, with no regard to their well-being, that is immoral. But confining sex to strictly reproductive purposes, while understandable in primitive cultures, is quite possibly also immoral, as it completely disregards the needs of the woman, who never has their God given ability to have orgasms satisfied.
Just to share with - in Islam we have some authentic hadith narrated by the wife of the Prophet , Aisyah and some of his other wives ( May Allah be pleased with them) on intimacy in marriage. There is emphasis on foreplay and satisfying the wife first before the husband satisfies himself. And that the concept of sexual satisfaction should be mutual between the spouses. Most of these hadith are usually taught to muslim couple before their marriage and also in today's context most likely include sexuality education etc. However when i was a young teenager my mum in fact got me a book about sex in a muslim marriage - i myself was surprised to see how much emphasis is being taught of taking of the wife's needs and that even leaving her unsatisfied is a sin in Islam - again based on the Prophet's ( pbuh) teachings and of course that the act of lovemaking is an act of charity and kindness - both husband and wife get rewarded by Allah when they make love to each other. Very beautiful. I am no expert on hadith but if you look at the chronology etc - to me at least this Prophet Muhammad ( pbuh) must be guided by God. 1500 years ago the pagan Arabs were killing their female babies, female toddlers and pagans would inherit women like they were things - so taking care of the female sexuality was unheard of. Only the Creator who created both the male and female could teach such concepts to those pagans. Also from the medical point of view - anal sex be it male or female - carries the risk of injury, infection etc as that organ is designed to excrete feces and not for sex. However lbgtq+ movement has put pressure on the medical community to be less outspoken on the dangers of anal sex/sodomy - but if you go by medical research and medical textbooks - anal sex has more negative issues compared to vaginal sex.
How about lesbian behavior caused by separated gender in school (islamic school)??
I am an indonesian. I have a girl friend who has inclination to "lesbian conducts" because she used to lived among muslim girls at an islamic boarding school special for female only."
She stated to me that 'lesbianism' from that life style even being kept after they graduated, even they are married muslim men..
Please anyone gives me insight or preace me or anything.. this is a toughful question in my life
The idea that gender separation causes this is absurd. Ideas are contagious. She must have had certain influences that entertain certain ideas and feelings. Shaytan plays on these feelings to convince them that they are born like that and that their feelings are somehow legitimate. Sure knows what's acceptable behaviour and what isn't. She is in control therefore she is blameworthy for her actions.
Some people are just desperate to get laid, and because they did it at such a young age, that desperation gets carried into their adult life. Its the same as porn addiction imo.
I am going to be honest. I studied in all boys school and I had gay desires . I knew something was wrong with me not because it was an only boys school. I mean why the others boys did not had these feelings after doing some research and some self finding I found out it was all linked to my behaviour, my thinking and the things I was watching and the funny thing is I did not even watched gay porn not even once in my life but from where these feelings were coming from then I found out it was too much exposure to porn and other stuff so I started to change my habits. I do not want to go too much into it but it was mostly my problem or my test which Allah was putting me through and thank Allah that I was able to pass and did not do anything stupid that would leave a scar on my soul. So that friend of yours is responsible for her actions and she is just trying to find an easy way out by all this leabianism and lgbtq stuff.
I hope it explains a little
@@user-rp5ix9vk8d friend her is worrisome. I was afraid n cut our friendship.
@Orient Express yeah after 6 months of marriage she inclines to ask divorce... as i dunno how to advice n yet married.. it scares me of my own future
Very slippery slope of morality. Paul tries to Justify Islam because of the private nature and the need for 4 witnesses. But the simple fact remains that the situation is comparable to Putin making propaganda for homosexuality illegal, without making homosexuality itself illegal. In Russia vigilante gangs immediately responded by persecuting gays much more vigorously.
If you declare "homosexuals" immoral their legal protection evaporates. Teachers can suddenly loose their jobs over accusations of "propaganda for homosecuality", police and judges will look the other way.
The same happens with Islam declaring homosexuals and Apostates worthy of capital punishment. It incites hatred and contempt. Vigilante attacks have even happened in the UK where Paul lives.
The "narratives" will usually conflate pedophilia with homophilia, discuss all supposed health risks without acknowledging that many heterosexuals will have experimented with anal sex as well.
The only way is for Islamic leaders to openly choose for persecution and legal action against gays to be wrong.
First off, regarding anal sex Islam prohibits that for both hetero and homosexual people. And Islam expressly forbids vigilante violence. And the whole desires defining who you are is problematic
Is Paul Muslim? Why does he never Salam his guests? Any particular reason?
That would indicate he isnt .. yet ..
@@TheWitnessss He is muslim
Maybe he did before he recorded it, who knows. God knows best. Don't judge him over a Salam.
He probably did off camera. People don't just call and immediately start recording lol
@@TheWitnessss He is a Muslim don't takfir him for Salam.
first