No one has ever had a fracking clue what Jon Anderson has been singing about. He is an alien sent to Earth to try to enlighten us all.. I’m not sure it worked, but he makes beautiful music.
Always struck me as being tonal poetry....not meant for straightforward consumption...remember just being gobsmacked when "Long Distance Runaround" and "Roundabout" hit the airwaves....Instant fan....👍
This song, "Close To The Edge" is the Masterpiece among Masterpieces in the world of music....no song or composition of music in the 20th or 21st century is going be better than this song. It is an incredible piece of Art!!! Period!
The more you listen to this masterpiece, the more everything just fits. You hear things you didn't notice before, and soon you're just going along for the ride. Each time I focus on just one instrument, I'm flummoxed by how amazing it is. Bruford constantly shifting when he accents with the snare, Squire's flying fingers on the bass, and how perfectly he and Bruford connect. Steve Howe masterfully playing different styles, Wakeman patiently supporting until his virtuoso section from the pipe organ on, and Anderson's clear tone, blending into the incredible harmonies you noted. This song just does something to me. Takes me to a different place somehow, and I'm always better for having taken the journey. I really enjoyed your reaction, Steve, and I'm glad you had your medicine handy for this one!
Me too. All the mysteries, challenges, and celebrations of life are in there for me. From primordial chaos to total spiritual realization, all of natural life and human experience is in this for me. I can never tire, nor find any fault with it. Perfection ❤
Close to the Edge is musical lighting in a bottle. The backstory of the different acts of musical composition and the inspiration for the lyrics, all impossibly comes together. 50 years later it still inspires me through difficult times. ✌️🍁
It was a long time ago but I think it took a few listens for me to get this song. After repeated listens each part, and the way the instruments interact, start to make sense and it all falls into place. I love the way the first part discombobulates me (great word that!) so that when the second soft part comes along the feeling of serenity that washes over you is so much deeper and desired. Then, just as you are lulled into a soperific state (another great word!) and a false sense of security you are hit by some of the most epic funky keyboard and bass work on the planet. I'm totally convinced this was all very deliberately and knowingly done by design by the band. But, yeah, two or three listens at least for it to start clicking. Then, do what I like to do which is zone into one instrument to hear how brilliantly it is being played. Anyway, if you like the middle part I highly recommend Awaken. Often cosidered a rival to Close to the Edge as Yes' best work - also long but is the antithesis of the craziness of CttE. Just pure melt-into-the-sofa deliciousness.
Now that you have heard this one, I invite you to consider what it was like for those of us who were attending concerts during this amazing period of time. We could pretty much count on a concert from Yes or Genesis every year, two at the most. All through the 70's to the mid 80's, myself and my friends would look forward to attending these performances, none of us knowing that we were living through the greatest epoch of rock music the world has known. I could tell you a few stories about this period of time. Of course it might require a fair bit of time and more than one bottle of single malt.
Totally agree first saw them in 1973 in Glasgow TFTO Tour as 19 year old. I've seen the greatest bands up to Porcupine Tree but Yes were the best of them all.
Up and down and all around, but listening to "Close to The Edge" always leaves me in a profound state of gratitude and contemplation - the musical backdrop to my long and lucky life. If you ever get round to listening to it again, uninterrupted, you will find it has an hypnotic and zen-like effect on your PTSD brain. Anyway, at least you had the guts to take it on, even if it will just become another jumbled memory.
@@lesblatnyak5947 appreciate the pat on the back there! I do try 🤣. I would call it Dusty Blonde my hair, although if I drink much more bourbon it might turn a shade red 🤣
If I had this on my headphones, going for a jolly walk . . . "Manchester man found after wandering aimlessly through city mumbling 'Yes, bloody Yes!' "
I heard this song when it first came out, so here's my take on the lyrical message of the song: Anderson said the lyrics were inspired by Hermann Hesse's 1922 novel "Siddhartha", which charts a journey of self-discovery and spiritual realisation, so... It opens with the peaceful sounds of nature, followed by the chaos of individual life in human society, the search for spiritual enlightenment, the notion that it cannot be found in human society ("Then according to the man who showed his outstretched arm to space, He turned around and pointed, revealing all the human race, I shook my head and smiled a whisper, knowing all about the place"), and ending with the sounds of nature one again (the Buddhist idea of enlightenment as being one with nature). The end of the journey was thus there at the beginning, all along. But while the author has attained that higher spiritual plane, they are still physically bound to the material reality of their lower, Earthly existence; so as seasons pass by: I get up, I get down.
Some great Yes tracks for you still to find out Steve And you and I Heart of the sunrise Starship trooper and my favourite I hope you will play soon “Awaken “ from going from the one album 👍
Got a chance to see Genesis & Yes within 2 days of each other at the palace theatre in Manchester in 75 as a 14 year old was in prog heaven, great memories
16 years old when released and inducted into the YES experience with the album Fragile the previous year 15 years old wore both albums out pretty quickly drop the album on a turntable turn the lights out and just absorb the musical genius from start to finish
NOW can't wait for you to REACT to the REST of this MASTERPIECE Album. BEWARE that AFTER this one, YES continues to progress into more GROUNDBREAKING Territory beyond "anything you've EVER seen or known" !!!
@@MusicForTheSoulReactions He is an excellent communicator and had a series on BBC several years ago about music. I've only watched a couple episodes but the one on Vivaldi (the Italian Baroque composer and violinist) was pretty amazing. Rick Beato just released an hour+ interview with him that was crazy good with him playing live on the keys to illustrate his ideas! Very entertaining. Beato has a great channel.
Masters at their craft! Now you might be ready for "Siberian Khatru." Oh, and get a larger whiskey for it, so you don't have to stop to refill! I just set a bottle of wine next to me! LOL!
Congratulations Steve. You’ve finally felt able to do it! I knew you wouldn’t be disappointed. It really does take you to some serious places. Each musician steps up and delivers. Chris’ bass is just sublime, as well as Rick and his organ (ahem! No pun intended!). Onwards and upwards for you. Thanks again. Neil (OGR)
Hey Neil. Yeah you all gave me enough encouragement to check it out. I'm glad I did, although it was another one of those challenging tracks you all seem to suggest from time to time. Such talent on display to enjoy, I just need another 100 listens now to perhaps understand 5% of it 🤣🤦♂️
CLOSE TO THE EDGE [LYRICS] A seasoned witch could call you from the depths of your disgrace, And rearrange your liver to the solid mental grace, And achieve it all with music that came quickly from afar, Then taste the fruit of man recorded losing all against the hour And assessing points to nowhere, leading every single one A dewdrop can exalt us like the music of the sun, And take away the plain in which we move, And choose the course you're running Down at the edge, round by the corner, Not right away, not right away Close to the edge, down by a river, Not right away, not right away Crossed the line around the changes of the summer, Reaching out to call the colour of the sky Passed around a moment clothed in mornings faster than we see Getting over all the time I had to worry, Leaving all the changes far from far behind We relieve the tension only to find out the master's name Down at the end, round by the corner Close to the edge, just by the river Seasons will pass you by I get up, I get down Now that it's all over and done, Now that you find... Now that you're whole My eyes convinced, eclipsed with the younger moon attained with love It changed as almost strained amidst clear manna from above I crucified my hate and held the word within my hand There's you, the time, the logic, or the reasons we don't understand... Sad courage claimed the victims standing still for all to see, As armoured movers took approach to overlook the sea There since the cord, the license, or the reasons we understood will be Down at the edge, close by a river Close to the edge, round by the corner Close to the end, down by the corner Down at the edge, round by the river Sudden call shouldn't take away the startled memory All in all, the journey takes you all the way As apart from any reality that you've ever seen and known Guessing problems only to deceive the mention, Passing paths that climb halfway into the void... As we cross from side to side, we hear the total mass retain: Down at the edge, round by the corner Close to the end, down by a river Seasons will pass you by I get up, I get down In her white lace, you could clearly see the lady sadly looking Saying that she'd take the blame For the crucifixion of her own domain I get up, I get down, I get up, I get down Two million people barely satisfy Two hundred women watch one woman cry, too late The eyes of honesty can achieve How many millions do we deceive each day? I get up, I get down I get up, I get down In charge of who is there in charge of me Do I look on blindly and say I see the way? The truth is written all along the page How old will I be before I come of age for you? I get up, I get down I get up, I get down I get up, I get down The time between the notes relates the color to the scenes A constant vogue of triumphs dislocate man, so it seems And space between the focus shape ascend knowledge of love As song and chance develop time, lost social temperance rules above Ah, ah Then according to the man who showed his outstretched arm to space, He turned around and pointed, revealing all the human race I shook my head and smiled a whisper, knowing all about the place On the hill we viewed the silence of the valley, Called to witness cycles only of the past And we reach all this with movements in between the said remark Close to the edge, down by the river Down at the end, round by the corner Seasons will pass you by, Now that it's all over and done, Called to the seed, right to the sun Now that you find, now that you're whole Seasons will pass you by, I get up, I get down I get up, I get down I get up, I get down
Some say it's the ultimate prog piece. I love it and never get bored of it, but there are so many other great pieces… Alone amongst Yes's catalogue, I have a few that I place over that one.
I've heard Jon Anderson explain that often he wrote lyrics not for their meaning but for how the words sounded. His voice was in instrument, so he chose words based on their syllables and sounds. Very fascinating way to write lyrics.
@@MusicForTheSoulReactions I hope you return to it many times. It is a really is a journey, based in part on the journeying of the first Buddha toward finding true peace and joy. It’s a cracking song as well. It’s got the lot. Next up: Yes’s Gates of Delirium. It comes close to this for me and many say it’s better.
The rapid notes early on in the song is courtesy of Rick Wakeman on keyboards. This song is one he really cuts loose on! (BTW - I have had the pleasure of attending 8 different Yes concerts with only one duplicate tour. The duplicate was on the 90125 tour where I saw the very first and very last performance of that tour. Yes, at the Berkley open air theater was something that is almost impossible to describe.
This is based on a Herman Hess book, "Siddhartha" and the search of self discovery and enlightenment. The initial sound of birds and nature, are meant to represent the natural state of being. The first bit when the band comes in, that sounds kind of chaotic, is meant to represent the chaos of modern life. When the the chaotic portion ends and it sounds more melodic and controlled is meant to represent the beginning of the search for enlightenment. Then intense section that follows the keyboard solo is meant to represent the inevitable setbacks and (temporary) failure, when the seeker believes they will not be able to attain what they are looking for. When that section resolves into the more tonal section, that represents some attaining some level of enlightenment. When the birds come in again, that is meant to represent that the seeker has not yet attained full enlightenment, and that is a continuing process. At least that is loosely how the book tells it.
Music from 70' was creative, a lot of musical groups with differents sounds. I grew up listening to Yes, Genesis with Peter Gabriel, Babe Ruth, Supertramp, ELP and the Beatles. The music today is like eating fast food. No taste, no creativity, no heart and no feeling. Another time, another need. Enjoy the 70' ❤
Who ever can listen to this and find it amazing, overwhelmingly beautiful and full of surprises even after a hundred listens, is ready for anything. Everyone who finds this annoying or disturbing, is not there yet (and may never be - probably that's true for most people, I met enough in my life who I was never able to convince). I think you're not quite there yet, but almost 😄 I'm sure you'll make it!
Haha absolutely agree. Oh for sure I'm no where near there yet. Its very complex, but I'm learning, evolving as I go in the hope of making it one day! Thanks for watching
@@MusicForTheSoulReactions so having got ‘close to the edge’ you now need to get through ‘The Gates Of Delerium’ before you finally ‘Awaken’ to the genius of YES.
OMG! You are fing adorable! I could watch you all day. Yes happens to be my favorite band of all time, and has been since I was 15. This whole album, all 3 songs, masterpieces!! ☮️❤️🎼😎 BTW- Yes does make you feel good. Positive. They are called YES for goodness sake lol.
Haha you are too kind! Thanks for watching and commenting! I can see why these guys would be a firm favourite of yours. Definite spring in your step type music, just don't step to the funny rhythm parts, people might think you weird 🤣🤦♂️🤦♂️
This epic truly takes many listens to fully appreciate it... but it's worth the effort. And the good news is, now you've heard this, everything else is plain sailing!
There you go! :) Glad you did this one. Jon's lyrics.... are often, if not always, as much about the sound and 'texture' (?) of the words, of vowels and consonants, taken together, as much as any intrinsic meanings of the words themselves - though there's always a thematic conceit and overarching message within the songs. And nobody does this nearly as well. Again, glad you enjoyed. Cheers.
I have listened to a plethora of prog rock and prog metal epics from almost all the popular and not so popular bands around the globe I have also listened to a huge variety of songs from all different genres as well and after giving a very thorough and deep insight to all of them,i reached to the conclusion that close to the edge is by far for me the best ever song ever composed and designed! Even though Octavarium by dream theater is my favourite song (i would love to highly recommend you to give a listen to that epic song altho its 24 mins long) but i really do consider that the musicianship in close to the edge,well its just ethereal, transcendental and purely on another dimension!
This song is beyond profound it is inspired by a Herman Hesse novel siddaharta about the nature of existence , now I did a PhD about suppers ready but that’s only because I hadn’t heard this at the time . When I retire I am going to do one on this album , Chris squire the best bassist ever, bill bruford the drummer who was in King Crimson originally ,Rick Wakeman plays the key board and Steve Howe the guitarist , the organ was played in Winchester cathredral ( where the omen was filmed) , I loved the reaction ,btw I once played sonic for 18 hours without a break ! The discord is deliberate but you need to read the book to know why , this is pure art . Now have to go to work to see a kid in prison who is probably psychotic but when I get home it’s wild turkey and Tales from the topographic ocean
@@gerryrafferty7500 I’m with you. Good to know - also Supper’s Ready. From the farmer to the geese. Been delving deep for decades. Also this one… but that’s your journey 🌞
A book has already been published about this album (by Will Romano). Chris Welch also published a book called 'Close to the Edge' which is a history of Yes.
@@gerryrafferty7500 Oh, me too - the divine/eternal secrets and keys to the universe are in this and other songs. I have been studying for 38 years. I wrote it all down once, but lost the note, so it remains inside my head
The composition of CttE was so detailed it drove Bruford from the band. I think 2 or 3 of the 5 musicians were OCD and struggled to get every note perfect. We are left with this masterpiece that needs many many listens to begin to appreciate. In 1972 I was with you - I only liked the last 2/3rds. Same for Gates of Delirium. Next time listening try to hold your head still and your eyes closed. Prevents or minimizes headaches, strokes and PTSD.
Glad to know I'm not the only one overwhelmed with first listen but encouraged at the fact I will understand it more the more I listen! Eyes closed is a good shout too
LOL! What a reaction. This is their 2nd most complex song. I'm not sure you were ready for it. I've listened to this hundreds of times, and seen it done live several times. To me, it all makes sense and flows. Think of Jon's lyrics like how impressionists paint, kinda abstract, but if you pull back enough and go with the flow, you get it. Also, the more you listen to it, the more you hear. If you go back, check out Chris Squire's bass, it's just mad. I think you will relax more with the second song from this album, "And You and I". It's more accessable. But if you want to top the insanity, go for "Gates of Delirium", aptly named. It's based on "War and Peace". There are many other journeys with Yes. We haven't even touched Tales From the Topigraphical Oceans. And when you're ready to achieve true Yes bliss, "Awaken" will take you there. Anyway, fun reaction! Now I have to watch my team get eliminated from the MSL playoff. NYC FC is playing away in Cincinati. US Roadie 1 signing out!
Thank you for the insightful ways in which to listen to this musical piece again. I'll see where the whims of Yes take me when next in their vicinity! Goooooo NYC FC 🙏⚽️🏆🎉
@MusicForTheSoulReactions We won! There was a crazy ass penalty shoot out at the end. Now to the next stage. NYC FC vs. NY Red Bulls. Kinda like Man City vs Man United. Unfortunately, people here aren't as big as fans are there in the UK. This won't even make the local news...but the fans are still passionate. Go NYC FC!
I was waiting for this to happen! Thoroughly enjoyed journeying through this with you. This, along with all 70s Yes, has been a constant world to escape into for me… and it’s lasted me forty years without ever disappointing. Like it or not Yes is a unique world of musical creativity. If you want to follow up, go for Gates of Delirium from the 1974 alb7m Relayer. But you’ll need double the Bourbon….
Well done! You have now listened to one of the major cornerstones of the Prog genre. Time to visit King Crimson's debut, if you haven't already, take a deep breath a put on '21st Century Schizoid Man' or 'In The Court Of The Crimson King'. It's a whole new world even though it was released in 1969.
Thank you, that was quite the challenge! 21st century schizoid man was actually one of the very first reactions I did on this channel but king Crimson blocked it almost immediately (apparently they do that a lot), so I've stayed clear ever since
@@MusicForTheSoulReactions Ah yes, there is that. For different reasons I hear Robert Fripp is almost as rabidly protective of King Crimson's intellectual copyright as Apple are of The Beatles. Pity - Would have been fun watching your brains get mangled by The Schizoid Man. Ah well, there's always Genesis. Or even better, Gentle Giant - The prog musician's prog band.
I've you ever seen Jon talk, he has a very high voice. That of an angel when singing. This stuff like Genesis always makes me feel good. I think I understand part of it, or not. "Seasons will pass you by" is trying to say don't take anything for granted and make the most of your time while you're here. Like the Beatles and others he leans toward Eastern philosophy. In any event I'll say every one of these guys is a genius. Bourbon and Vodka usually do the trick, LOL. Or more coffee... 9 times knocked down, 10 times get up. Or get drunk, either way.
I couldn't wait. Heh love these guys so much. And enjoy your reactions very much as well. Loved your Genesis adventures. Prog is a unique genre for sure. Don't worry, I will still drink later. Haha😅
@@ryanr5319 Hahaha love it! Appreciate your kind words and continued support for the channel, I love making content for you guys, prog rock certainly gives me a chance to be confused, bemused and in awe all in one go which leads to entertainment for you all so works both ways 🤣. Enjoy your night, Ryan
Thanks for mentioning you're from Manchester. Don't know if you're aware but Jon Anderson is from Accrington, just up the road. Pay attention to his singing and you'll probably hear some familiar noises coming out of his mouth (for example, listen to how he sings words like *hand*), even if you have no idea what he's going on about.
Its all about syncopation, off beats and odd time signatures. Thats what drives you nuts ;) And we love it! (syn·co·pa·tion noun: the practice of displacing the beats or accents in music or a rhythm so that strong beats become weak and vice versa)
23:10 That transition from the organ to the chaos is a reminder to not get too “attached” (in Buddhist terms) to anything in your life - even to emotion or religion (in my view). I’ve been pondering this song for nigh-on 40 years. Probably should have gotten out more 😂
Next up is Tarkus and Karn Evil 9 by Emerson, Lake & Palmer. You will be amazed how 3 musicians can create such complex music! Keith Emerson is widely regarded to be the best keyboardist of the 1970's along with Tony Banks of Genesis and Rick Wakeman of Yes.
'And we reach all this with movements in between the said remark.'.. So... I think that place Jon is talking about is somewhere deep within a millisecond of silence. The whole epic journey takes place almost instantaneously while we are sitting by the river. Btw, in the book Siddhartha, there is a period during his life when he encounters a strange river that becomes one of his most important esoteric teachers..I think it is a clue worth mentioning regarding the mystical themes that Jon was delving into here. I think Steve Howe and Jon collaborated on the austere themes of this album and also on Tales from Topographic Oceans the double album follow-up to Close to the Edge. So we can also blame Steve for these obscure, fay, oddball lyrics! Lol..
Now that you've heard Yes and Genesis epics, try ELP - Karn Evil 9 (1st, 2nd, and 3rd impressions); Pink Floyd - Shine on You Crazy Diamond (Parts 1-9); Rush - 2112; Elton John - Funeral for a Friend/Love Lies Bleeding; Alan Parsons Project - Fall of the House of Usher or The Turn of a Friendly Card Suite; Supertramp - Fool's Overture; Ten CC - Feel the Benefit... if you've not heard them before. All over 10 minutes... I have others as well.
I think you're onto something with your insight about Yes playing and singing lots of high pitched sounds and rising tones contrasting with the deep, growly bass. I think of them as making the music of yearning and longing, as well as positivity and hope.
Hilarious reaction! It was actually how I felt the first time I listened to CTTE 50 years ago. It definitely grows on you after a couple of listens. For the sake of your sanity, on no account listen to Gates of Delirium. But for the enjoyment of your viewers please do a reaction to this classic from Yes' Relayer album.
May I suggest The Gates Of Delirium from the Relayer album. Based on War And Peace by Leo Tolstoy, covering the buildup, battles and resolution. If you think CTTE is chaotic wait till you hear them perform a battle scene. Sounds like both war and very complicated music
This is the greatest prog album ever by the greatest band that has graced this planet. Steve who is Geoff ? You have now entered the masterpiece that is Close to the Edge. Jon Anderson the most emotive goosebumping voice in music.
Haha Geoff just seems to be the name I randomly use when I either don't know or can't remember a band members name, and want to make up some story to tell during the reaction 🤦♂️
I prefer a little of the green stuff rather than alcohol to prime me up for Yes, but to each their own. Always great to watch British lads discover their own countries revolutionary rock bands they gifted the planet in the 60's and 70's .
Hi Steve! Great song and band! I look at this type of prog in 2 ways. First. If you think of classical music or movie scores it’s very similar. The difference being guitars bass drums and keyboards vs. orchestral instruments. The second is prog is like reading a book like The Lord of the Rings or any sci-fi or fantasy book. There are highs lows battle scenes love scenes or journeying into the Mines of Moria. It’s a journey for the ears instead of the eyes.
My favorite version of this song is the live version from the live album "Yessongs." The recording quality isn't really outstanding, but especially the second half of the song got a lot of polish.
It's a little scattered for my tastes compared to other great songs from YES like Starship Trooper, And you and I, Long Distance Runaround, I've seen all good people...all more digestible on first listen not to mention later hits like Big Generator / Shoot high aim low
@@MusicForTheSoulReactions No idea pal, sorry! Wish I could help, I wondered if it was a setting you could select when you upload or something. Just watched your review, loved it! Destroyed by CTTE. It truly is a wtf is going on song, every time I hear it I get the emotions you displayed! I suppose over time and repeated listens it sinks in and you get used to it and then becomes normal, but yeah - what a song!
Ahhh. Close To The Edge! Listen to Jon's lyrics, but don't think them! (Well, later maybe.) I believe I saw an interview where he said he chooses the words for how they sound first and foremost.
No one has ever had a fracking clue what Jon Anderson has been singing about. He is an alien sent to Earth to try to enlighten us all.. I’m not sure it worked, but he makes beautiful music.
🤣🤣🤣💯👌
Squire said that Jon doesn't even know what he is singing about.
@@lesblatnyak5947 🤣🤣
He did say that much of this song is based on the novel “Siddhartha”
Always struck me as being tonal poetry....not meant for straightforward consumption...remember just being gobsmacked when "Long Distance Runaround" and "Roundabout" hit the airwaves....Instant fan....👍
this song is pure magic but you need to listen with full attention and no stopping it.
It's what I do after I've done the actual reaction/analysis of it, go back and take it in and enjoy it
Now that you've gone "Close to the edge", you have to pass through "The Gates of Delirium"!!! There's no way back!
Haha I bet, once my brain melts at the gates there will be nothing left to salvage!!
@@MusicForTheSoulReactions - My favourite Yes track. Yes, your brain will melt, but the ending section of this song will totally restore you.
Gates is actually about war and takes you there. But it also takes you ‘above the battleground’ to show you the light. Enjoy.
I too find Relayer to be on par with Close to the Edge.
My favorite Yes piece switches back and forth between CttE and Gates of Delirium, depending which one I am listening to.
This song, "Close To The Edge" is the Masterpiece among Masterpieces in the world of music....no song or composition of music in the 20th or 21st century is going be better than this song. It is an incredible piece of Art!!! Period!
Well that's a strong, confident statement, Sir. Its certainly a good song to throw in the mix for such a title!
The more you listen to this masterpiece, the more everything just fits. You hear things you didn't notice before, and soon you're just going along for the ride.
Each time I focus on just one instrument, I'm flummoxed by how amazing it is. Bruford constantly shifting when he accents with the snare, Squire's flying fingers on the bass, and how perfectly he and Bruford connect. Steve Howe masterfully playing different styles, Wakeman patiently supporting until his virtuoso section from the pipe organ on, and Anderson's clear tone, blending into the incredible harmonies you noted.
This song just does something to me. Takes me to a different place somehow, and I'm always better for having taken the journey.
I really enjoyed your reaction, Steve, and I'm glad you had your medicine handy for this one!
Couldn't agree more, each of them are in there bag for this one! This goes everywhere but with what I call chaotic purpose! Brilliant stuff
Me too. All the mysteries, challenges, and celebrations of life are in there for me. From primordial chaos to total spiritual realization, all of natural life and human experience is in this for me. I can never tire, nor find any fault with it. Perfection ❤
@mattleppard1964 great comment, well put Matt
At last , best prog song ever , even better than PF
No contest, with all due respect to PF.
PF is over rated IMHO.
“Be gentle with me”… Close to the Edge. 😂😂😂
Yeah....they weren't 🤣🤦♂️
Side 2 ,” And you and I “ a love song that never says the word love is special.
And Siberian Khatru. A magical trio of songs ❤
Close to the Edge is musical lighting in a bottle. The backstory of the different acts of musical composition and the inspiration for the lyrics, all impossibly comes together.
50 years later it still inspires me through difficult times.
✌️🍁
It's certainly a complex piece that requires numerous listens! Masterful compositions!
It was a long time ago but I think it took a few listens for me to get this song. After repeated listens each part, and the way the instruments interact, start to make sense and it all falls into place.
I love the way the first part discombobulates me (great word that!) so that when the second soft part comes along the feeling of serenity that washes over you is so much deeper and desired. Then, just as you are lulled into a soperific state (another great word!) and a false sense of security you are hit by some of the most epic funky keyboard and bass work on the planet. I'm totally convinced this was all very deliberately and knowingly done by design by the band. But, yeah, two or three listens at least for it to start clicking. Then, do what I like to do which is zone into one instrument to hear how brilliantly it is being played.
Anyway, if you like the middle part I highly recommend Awaken. Often cosidered a rival to Close to the Edge as Yes' best work - also long but is the antithesis of the craziness of CttE. Just pure melt-into-the-sofa deliciousness.
Well you've certainly sold the need for multiple listens and to check out awaken, a melt into the sofa deliciousness sounds awesome!
Now that you have heard this one, I invite you to consider what it was like for those of us who were attending concerts during this amazing period of time. We could pretty much count on a concert from Yes or Genesis every year, two at the most. All through the 70's to the mid 80's, myself and my friends would look forward to attending these performances, none of us knowing that we were living through the greatest epoch of rock music the world has known. I could tell you a few stories about this period of time. Of course it might require a fair bit of time and more than one bottle of single malt.
What a rich time to be alive! I love being from the 80s for lots of reasons, but musically I wish to be a 60-70s kid in many ways too!
Totally agree first saw them in 1973 in Glasgow TFTO Tour as 19 year old. I've seen the greatest bands up to Porcupine Tree but Yes were the best of them all.
And the acid was life changing 😊❤🎉
Up and down and all around, but listening to "Close to The Edge" always leaves me in a profound state of gratitude and contemplation - the musical backdrop to my long and lucky life. If you ever get round to listening to it again, uninterrupted, you will find it has an hypnotic and zen-like effect on your PTSD brain. Anyway, at least you had the guts to take it on, even if it will just become another jumbled memory.
Totally ❤
Thank you for the comment. This is definitely worth a revisit away from the channel, just me and the music 😎
@MusicForTheSoulReactions
You picked up on a few things that show you have a sharp mind, bud. Well done! You got red hair??? 🍸🍸
@@lesblatnyak5947 Very sharp and open to the flows and currents of the song
@@lesblatnyak5947 appreciate the pat on the back there! I do try 🤣. I would call it Dusty Blonde my hair, although if I drink much more bourbon it might turn a shade red 🤣
If I had this on my headphones, going for a jolly walk . . .
"Manchester man found after wandering aimlessly through city mumbling 'Yes, bloody Yes!' "
🤣🤣🤣🤣 brilliant. Made me spit my drink out!
@@Someonelser1
Or found you in a tree
I heard this song when it first came out, so here's my take on the lyrical message of the song:
Anderson said the lyrics were inspired by Hermann Hesse's 1922 novel "Siddhartha", which charts a journey of self-discovery and spiritual realisation, so... It opens with the peaceful sounds of nature, followed by the chaos of individual life in human society, the search for spiritual enlightenment, the notion that it cannot be found in human society ("Then according to the man who showed his outstretched arm to space, He turned around and pointed, revealing all the human race, I shook my head and smiled a whisper, knowing all about the place"), and ending with the sounds of nature one again (the Buddhist idea of enlightenment as being one with nature). The end of the journey was thus there at the beginning, all along. But while the author has attained that higher spiritual plane, they are still physically bound to the material reality of their lower, Earthly existence; so as seasons pass by: I get up, I get down.
Brilliant, informative comment. Thank you for the insights!!! Appreciate the background info for sure
Second album I ever brought as a young nipper
Got all my mates at school into the prog rock scene then
They still tell me to this day !
Happy days
Seems like I'll I'll thanking you for the same signs of generosity!!
@@MusicForTheSoulReactions lol 👍
Some great Yes tracks for you still to find out Steve
And you and I Heart of the sunrise Starship trooper and my favourite I hope you will play soon “Awaken “ from going from the one album 👍
Got a chance to see Genesis & Yes within 2 days of each other at the palace theatre in Manchester in 75 as a 14 year old was in prog heaven, great memories
What an amazing 2 days that is!!! Peaked at 14 🤣
"Yes-Sir" ...
You've arrived at the Edge !
Uh huh...
Quintessence of Prog .
16 years old when released and inducted into the YES experience with the album Fragile the previous year 15 years old wore both albums out pretty quickly drop the album on a turntable turn the lights out and just absorb the musical genius from start to finish
NOW can't wait for you to REACT to the REST of this MASTERPIECE Album. BEWARE that AFTER this one, YES continues to progress into more GROUNDBREAKING Territory beyond "anything you've EVER seen or known" !!!
Well that officially puts the fear of God in me 🤣
Rick Wakeman's organ on this is amazing.
I always forget who's playing keyboard, and then someone mentions it and I'm like 'oh of course, bloody Rick wakeman'. That guys got skills!
@@MusicForTheSoulReactions He is an excellent communicator and had a series on BBC several years ago about music. I've only watched a couple episodes but the one on Vivaldi (the Italian Baroque composer and violinist) was pretty amazing.
Rick Beato just released an hour+ interview with him that was crazy good with him playing live on the keys to illustrate his ideas! Very entertaining. Beato has a great channel.
Ladies and gentlemen, YES, the greatest show on earth. Now you hear why I saw YES 36 times over forty years. Did good kid, on to side two
✨️🎶👑🎶✨️
Wow, that's nearly a show a year you watched! Bet Yes recognised you on sight by the end!!!
Masters at their craft! Now you might be ready for "Siberian Khatru." Oh, and get a larger whiskey for it, so you don't have to stop to refill! I just set a bottle of wine next to me! LOL!
Hahaha you're right, I need to come to these bands more prepared! Enjoy your wine!
I like you Dana! 😊
Steve's already done "Siberian Khatru" and "And You and I".
They use time signatures that hadn’t been invented yet !
btw Phantom of The Opera came out on 1986...."The Close To The Edge" was created in 1972.
I wonder if the phantom took some tips from Yes 🤔
Congratulations Steve. You’ve finally felt able to do it! I knew you wouldn’t be disappointed. It really does take you to some serious places. Each musician steps up and delivers. Chris’ bass is just sublime, as well as Rick and his organ (ahem! No pun intended!). Onwards and upwards for you. Thanks again. Neil (OGR)
Hey Neil. Yeah you all gave me enough encouragement to check it out. I'm glad I did, although it was another one of those challenging tracks you all seem to suggest from time to time. Such talent on display to enjoy, I just need another 100 listens now to perhaps understand 5% of it 🤣🤦♂️
I said you'd need more than 1 tumbler of the hard stuff ... I tried to warn you. Honest!
CLOSE TO THE EDGE [LYRICS]
A seasoned witch could call you from the depths of your disgrace,
And rearrange your liver to the solid mental grace,
And achieve it all with music that came quickly from afar,
Then taste the fruit of man recorded losing all against the hour
And assessing points to nowhere, leading every single one
A dewdrop can exalt us like the music of the sun,
And take away the plain in which we move,
And choose the course you're running
Down at the edge, round by the corner,
Not right away, not right away
Close to the edge, down by a river,
Not right away, not right away
Crossed the line around the changes of the summer,
Reaching out to call the colour of the sky
Passed around a moment clothed in mornings faster than we see
Getting over all the time I had to worry,
Leaving all the changes far from far behind
We relieve the tension only to find out the master's name
Down at the end, round by the corner
Close to the edge, just by the river
Seasons will pass you by
I get up, I get down
Now that it's all over and done,
Now that you find... Now that you're whole
My eyes convinced, eclipsed with the younger moon attained with love
It changed as almost strained amidst clear manna from above
I crucified my hate and held the word within my hand
There's you, the time, the logic, or the reasons we don't understand...
Sad courage claimed the victims standing still for all to see,
As armoured movers took approach to overlook the sea
There since the cord, the license, or the reasons we understood will be
Down at the edge, close by a river
Close to the edge, round by the corner
Close to the end, down by the corner
Down at the edge, round by the river
Sudden call shouldn't take away the startled memory
All in all, the journey takes you all the way
As apart from any reality that you've ever seen and known
Guessing problems only to deceive the mention,
Passing paths that climb halfway into the void...
As we cross from side to side, we hear the total mass retain:
Down at the edge, round by the corner
Close to the end, down by a river
Seasons will pass you by
I get up, I get down
In her white lace, you could clearly see the lady sadly looking
Saying that she'd take the blame
For the crucifixion of her own domain
I get up,
I get down,
I get up,
I get down
Two million people barely satisfy
Two hundred women watch one woman cry, too late
The eyes of honesty can achieve
How many millions do we deceive each day?
I get up, I get down
I get up, I get down
In charge of who is there in charge of me
Do I look on blindly and say I see the way?
The truth is written all along the page
How old will I be before I come of age for you?
I get up, I get down
I get up, I get down
I get up, I get down
The time between the notes relates the color to the scenes
A constant vogue of triumphs dislocate man, so it seems
And space between the focus shape ascend knowledge of love
As song and chance develop time, lost social temperance rules above
Ah, ah
Then according to the man who showed his outstretched arm to space,
He turned around and pointed, revealing all the human race
I shook my head and smiled a whisper, knowing all about the place
On the hill we viewed the silence of the valley,
Called to witness cycles only of the past
And we reach all this with movements in between the said remark
Close to the edge, down by the river
Down at the end, round by the corner
Seasons will pass you by,
Now that it's all over and done,
Called to the seed, right to the sun
Now that you find, now that you're whole
Seasons will pass you by,
I get up, I get down
I get up, I get down
I get up, I get down
Thank you for sharing! Even reading it spangles my head, nevermind trying to take it in whilst hearing it!!!
Some say it's the ultimate prog piece. I love it and never get bored of it, but there are so many other great pieces… Alone amongst Yes's catalogue, I have a few that I place over that one.
I've heard Jon Anderson explain that often he wrote lyrics not for their meaning but for how the words sounded. His voice was in instrument, so he chose words based on their syllables and sounds. Very fascinating way to write lyrics.
I agree, never heard of that before, yet makes total sense, even if the words he's saying don't 🤣🤦♂️
Man alive! At last… This is a profound piece of art ❤
Hahaha I know you've been pushing for this for a while! To say it took me on a journey is an understatement!
@@MusicForTheSoulReactions I hope you return to it many times. It is a really is a journey, based in part on the journeying of the first Buddha toward finding true peace and joy. It’s a cracking song as well. It’s got the lot.
Next up: Yes’s Gates of Delirium. It comes close to this for me and many say it’s better.
@@MusicForTheSoulReactionsOh, the bass player also does the highest voice in the harmonies
@@mattleppard1970 oh, that's cool to know!
@@mattleppard1970 oh that's cool to know!
YES! 😊
The rapid notes early on in the song is courtesy of Rick Wakeman on keyboards. This song is one he really cuts loose on! (BTW - I have had the pleasure of attending 8 different Yes concerts with only one duplicate tour. The duplicate was on the 90125 tour where I saw the very first and very last performance of that tour. Yes, at the Berkley open air theater was something that is almost impossible to describe.
Wow, sounds like you've had some amazing Yes experiences! Lucky you!
This is based on a Herman Hess book, "Siddhartha" and the search of self discovery and enlightenment.
The initial sound of birds and nature, are meant to represent the natural state of being. The first bit when the band comes in, that sounds kind of chaotic, is meant to represent the chaos of modern life.
When the the chaotic portion ends and it sounds more melodic and controlled is meant to represent the beginning of the search for enlightenment.
Then intense section that follows the keyboard solo is meant to represent the inevitable setbacks and (temporary) failure, when the seeker believes they will not be able to attain what they are looking for. When that section resolves into the more tonal section, that represents some attaining some level of enlightenment.
When the birds come in again, that is meant to represent that the seeker has not yet attained full enlightenment, and that is a continuing process.
At least that is loosely how the book tells it.
Fantastic stuff, really interesting to learn the background of the song as I'm sire you could tell from my reaction, it overwhelmed me somewhat 🤣
"This is 18 minutes long, I mean, I'm just already nervous now" lol 😊
Great watch. A fabulous album that's every bit as good today as it was 5+ decades ago. Bourbon? We went for an alternative.
Alternatives are good 🥃. Music like this Will continue to challenge people in 50 years time!
Hi 👋
An absolute Classic.
Thanks for reviewing.
Now we're taking.
Keep Rocking 👍
Roadie Ronnie
SCOTLAND 🎸 🎸 🎸
Music from 70' was creative, a lot of musical groups with differents sounds. I grew up listening to Yes, Genesis with Peter Gabriel, Babe Ruth, Supertramp, ELP and the Beatles.
The music today is like eating fast food. No taste, no creativity, no heart and no feeling. Another time, another need. Enjoy the 70' ❤
Couldn't agree more. Well said!
45 years I have been listening to this song
Wow, you mist know it inside out then! Impressive!
Sounds like you have the "repeat one" function on. Just click the button again and you should hear "And You and I".
A big hand for the great Jeff Wakeman on keys
👏👏👏
Who ever can listen to this and find it amazing, overwhelmingly beautiful and full of surprises even after a hundred listens, is ready for anything. Everyone who finds this annoying or disturbing, is not there yet (and may never be - probably that's true for most people, I met enough in my life who I was never able to convince). I think you're not quite there yet, but almost 😄 I'm sure you'll make it!
Haha absolutely agree. Oh for sure I'm no where near there yet. Its very complex, but I'm learning, evolving as I go in the hope of making it one day! Thanks for watching
First for this…….could not miss it. Jumping off the high board………😂
Beat me! 🎉🎉
🤣🤣🤣👏👏👏
@@MusicForTheSoulReactions so having got ‘close to the edge’ you now need to get through ‘The Gates Of Delerium’ before you finally ‘Awaken’ to the genius of YES.
@@scifimonkey3 are you deliberately trying to see me off or what 🤣🤣🤣
@ what doesn’t kill you makes you stronger……..may be just a drop more bourbon to start with and you’ll be more than fine.😂
Best band, ever. Period.
I love how you've even managed to put Yes in your name tag!
@@MusicForTheSoulReactions Thanks. I've sen them 49 times live. I can die a happy man.
OMG! You are fing adorable! I could watch you all day. Yes happens to be my favorite band of all time, and has been since I was 15. This whole album, all 3 songs, masterpieces!! ☮️❤️🎼😎
BTW- Yes does make you feel good. Positive. They are called YES for goodness sake lol.
Haha you are too kind! Thanks for watching and commenting! I can see why these guys would be a firm favourite of yours. Definite spring in your step type music, just don't step to the funny rhythm parts, people might think you weird 🤣🤦♂️🤦♂️
@ I am weird
I love your reactions. Thanks
Thank you for watching!
This epic truly takes many listens to fully appreciate it... but it's worth the effort. And the good news is, now you've heard this, everything else is plain sailing!
Haha when you put it like that, you're right, I'm on easy Street from now on 😎
Greetings mate my mum was a war bride from Manchester thanks for the dare reacting to Close to the edge, quite witty 😅😅
Haha us lot from Manchester do get about places! Happy Happy hear your mum is one of us! Glad you enjoyed it
The first 2 minutes may be challenging for a Yes newbie, but just hang in there… trust me.
That was a FUN experience! Thanks, Steve! 😎
You're welcome, glad you enjoyed my continues journey towards insanity!! 🤣🤦♂️
I’ve seen quite a few reactions to this song, and I think this was the most amusing of them.
That's very kind of you to say, glad you enjoyed, thanks for watching
There you go! :) Glad you did this one. Jon's lyrics.... are often, if not always, as much about the sound and 'texture' (?) of the words, of vowels and consonants, taken together, as much as any intrinsic meanings of the words themselves - though there's always a thematic conceit and overarching message within the songs. And nobody does this nearly as well. Again, glad you enjoyed. Cheers.
It's a great idea choosing words based on sounds they make etc, definitely clever, albeit confusing to the listener 🤣
I have listened to a plethora of prog rock and prog metal epics from almost all the popular and not so popular bands around the globe
I have also listened to a huge variety of songs from all different genres as well and after giving a very thorough and deep insight to all of them,i reached to the conclusion that close to the edge is by far for me the best ever song ever composed and designed!
Even though Octavarium by dream theater is my favourite song (i would love to highly recommend you to give a listen to that epic song altho its 24 mins long) but i really do consider that the musicianship in close to the edge,well its just ethereal, transcendental and purely on another dimension!
Brilliant comment, eloquently put! 👏
This song is beyond profound it is inspired by a Herman Hesse novel siddaharta about the nature of existence , now I did a PhD about suppers ready but that’s only because I hadn’t heard this at the time . When I retire I am going to do one on this album , Chris squire the best bassist ever, bill bruford the drummer who was in King Crimson originally ,Rick Wakeman plays the key board and Steve Howe the guitarist , the organ was played in Winchester cathredral ( where the omen was filmed) , I loved the reaction ,btw I once played sonic for 18 hours without a break ! The discord is deliberate but you need to read the book to know why , this is pure art . Now have to go to work to see a kid in prison who is probably psychotic but when I get home it’s wild turkey and Tales from the topographic ocean
Wow, that's some marathon endurance for sonic!!! 🤯. Wow, hope you help that kid out!! Definitely sounds like a night for wild turkey for sure
@@gerryrafferty7500 I’m with you. Good to know - also Supper’s Ready. From the farmer to the geese. Been delving deep for decades. Also this one… but that’s your journey 🌞
A book has already been published about this album (by Will Romano). Chris Welch also published a book called 'Close to the Edge' which is a history of Yes.
@ thanks for that , I am ever so slightly obsessed by Jon Anderson’s lyrics
@@gerryrafferty7500 Oh, me too - the divine/eternal secrets and keys to the universe are in this and other songs. I have been studying for 38 years. I wrote it all down once, but lost the note, so it remains inside my head
Jeff is Rick Wakeman. He has about 18 different Keyboards of all sorts.
Talk about impressive!
"Be gentle with me, Yes" - next thing: CHAOS (beautiful chaos I might say)
🤣🤣🤣 ain't that the truth!
The composition of CttE was so detailed it drove Bruford from the band. I think 2 or 3 of the 5 musicians were OCD and struggled to get every note perfect. We are left with this masterpiece that needs many many listens to begin to appreciate. In 1972 I was with you - I only liked the last 2/3rds. Same for Gates of Delirium. Next time listening try to hold your head still and your eyes closed. Prevents or minimizes headaches, strokes and PTSD.
Glad to know I'm not the only one overwhelmed with first listen but encouraged at the fact I will understand it more the more I listen! Eyes closed is a good shout too
LOL! What a reaction. This is their 2nd most complex song. I'm not sure you were ready for it. I've listened to this hundreds of times, and seen it done live several times. To me, it all makes sense and flows. Think of Jon's lyrics like how impressionists paint, kinda abstract, but if you pull back enough and go with the flow, you get it. Also, the more you listen to it, the more you hear. If you go back, check out Chris Squire's bass, it's just mad. I think you will relax more with the second song from this album, "And You and I". It's more accessable. But if you want to top the insanity, go for "Gates of Delirium", aptly named. It's based on "War and Peace". There are many other journeys with Yes. We haven't even touched Tales From the Topigraphical Oceans. And when you're ready to achieve true Yes bliss, "Awaken" will take you there. Anyway, fun reaction! Now I have to watch my team get eliminated from the MSL playoff. NYC FC is playing away in Cincinati. US Roadie 1 signing out!
Thank you for the insightful ways in which to listen to this musical piece again. I'll see where the whims of Yes take me when next in their vicinity! Goooooo NYC FC 🙏⚽️🏆🎉
@MusicForTheSoulReactions We won! There was a crazy ass penalty shoot out at the end. Now to the next stage. NYC FC vs. NY Red Bulls. Kinda like Man City vs Man United. Unfortunately, people here aren't as big as fans are there in the UK. This won't even make the local news...but the fans are still passionate. Go NYC FC!
I was waiting for this to happen! Thoroughly enjoyed journeying through this with you. This, along with all 70s Yes, has been a constant world to escape into for me… and it’s lasted me forty years without ever disappointing. Like it or not Yes is a unique world of musical creativity. If you want to follow up, go for Gates of Delirium from the 1974 alb7m Relayer. But you’ll need double the Bourbon….
So glad you enjoyed it and more importantly joined me for it! Haha double the bourbon sounds like a great idea in the future!
Here we go!!!!!
Great Scot! Nice to see you here.
How could I forget Steven Wilson - Home Invasion, Regret #9?
Well done! You have now listened to one of the major cornerstones of the Prog genre. Time to visit King Crimson's debut, if you haven't already, take a deep breath a put on '21st Century Schizoid Man' or 'In The Court Of The Crimson King'. It's a whole new world even though it was released in 1969.
Thank you, that was quite the challenge! 21st century schizoid man was actually one of the very first reactions I did on this channel but king Crimson blocked it almost immediately (apparently they do that a lot), so I've stayed clear ever since
@@MusicForTheSoulReactions Ah yes, there is that. For different reasons I hear Robert Fripp is almost as rabidly protective of King Crimson's intellectual copyright as Apple are of The Beatles. Pity - Would have been fun watching your brains get mangled by The Schizoid Man. Ah well, there's always Genesis. Or even better, Gentle Giant - The prog musician's prog band.
Geoff is not on keys on this one it is Rick Wakeman (Commander of the Order of the British Empire)
🤣🤣 poor Geoof turns up in pretty much every band I review, what a good substitute he makes! Love wakemans skills, off the charts!
@ The current Yes’ keyboard player’s name is Geoff lol
My favorite Yes album. Good on ya.
I've you ever seen Jon talk, he has a very high voice. That of an angel when singing. This stuff like Genesis always makes me feel good. I think I understand part of it, or not. "Seasons will pass you by" is trying to say don't take anything for granted and make the most of your time while you're here. Like the Beatles and others he leans toward Eastern philosophy. In any event I'll say every one of these guys is a genius. Bourbon and Vodka usually do the trick, LOL. Or more coffee... 9 times knocked down, 10 times get up. Or get drunk, either way.
Perhaps a mixture of the 2, a bourbon coffee combo sounds like the perfect elixir to digest such talented bands!
@MusicForTheSoulReactions Irish Coffee. Have one in Boston if you're ever there. Great. At the Cheers light bar.
@scottzappa9314 actually visited Boston as part of a multi state trip for my 30th, for the exact reason of going to Cheers!! Loved it.
Love your reaction to this masterpiece....lol.....
So glad you enjoyed it. Thank you for taking the time to watch and comment on the channel
One of the best pieces of Music made in the 70s. Others are Starlighr by King Crimson and Supper’s Ready by Genesis
King Crimson blocks me each time unfortunately so don't cover them anymore, suppers ready is on my genesis playlist to watch if interested
@@MusicForTheSoulReactionsthere is. Very good live version of Starless from the 2000s. Check
That.
@ there is a very good live video version from the 2000s. With 3 drummers. Check this.
Whenever these reviewers say "im ready for this " i think " no youre not "
🤣🤣🤣. Yeah...I may have spoken a but prematurely there!!
Dude, don’t feel bad. I’m a big Genesis fan and I still never could get into. Yes.
Been a YES fan since 1973 Fragile album. They are the Prog-Rock Gold Standard IMO, such as it is.
I can certainly see how they could be given that title!
check out the dvd 'yessongs' . They do a live version of what you just saw.
Going to wait and watch this tonight with you and a drink. Could discuss all evening. My favorite band after Zep. The best.
I got through a bit of bourbon with this one so bring the bottle 🤣. Enjoy your evening 🥃
I couldn't wait. Heh love these guys so much. And enjoy your reactions very much as well. Loved your Genesis adventures. Prog is a unique genre for sure.
Don't worry, I will still drink later. Haha😅
@@ryanr5319 Hahaha love it! Appreciate your kind words and continued support for the channel, I love making content for you guys, prog rock certainly gives me a chance to be confused, bemused and in awe all in one go which leads to entertainment for you all so works both ways 🤣. Enjoy your night, Ryan
Re-listening and drinking with ya again on a Sunday eve. 😊
Thanks for mentioning you're from Manchester. Don't know if you're aware but Jon Anderson is from Accrington, just up the road. Pay attention to his singing and you'll probably hear some familiar noises coming out of his mouth (for example, listen to how he sings words like *hand*), even if you have no idea what he's going on about.
Oh I didn't know that! Cool to know he's from just up the road! I'll certainly focus more on his vocal sounds and word choices, such complex music!
Great reaction. Might I suggest a Yes palette cleanser, "South Side of the Sky." It will not drive you over the edge, I promise.
Always happy for extra suggestions. Thank you
No matter how many times I've crossed from side to side, I have NEVER heard the total mass retain. What am I doing wrong?
I think I've lost you on this comment?!
Its all about syncopation, off beats and odd time signatures. Thats what drives you nuts ;) And we love it! (syn·co·pa·tion noun: the practice of displacing the beats or accents in music or a rhythm so that strong beats become weak and vice versa)
It's very talented but yeah I know they do it on purpose to mess with our heads....the buggers!
You know they do this live!
I think that would be info overload! 🤣
Steve, never quite sat fully with me this one but 'Gates of Delirium' wowzers, i think you're ready 🔥🔥
Appreciate you watching regardless, it seems Gates of delirium is a popular choice!
@MusicForTheSoulReactions no probs, great channel mate
fun reaction
The Music is the experience. Let it be.
Anyone else think the chaotic beginning of 'Close to the Edge' reminds one of 'The Waiting Room' by Genesis (The Lamb Album)?
Very good comparison!!
23:10 That transition from the organ to the chaos is a reminder to not get too “attached” (in Buddhist terms) to anything in your life - even to emotion or religion (in my view).
I’ve been pondering this song for nigh-on 40 years. Probably should have gotten out more 😂
Ahhhh thank you! I like learning why certain parts occur. Certainly makes sense!
Next up is Tarkus and Karn Evil 9 by Emerson, Lake & Palmer. You will be amazed how 3 musicians can create such complex music! Keith Emerson is widely regarded to be the best keyboardist of the 1970's along with Tony Banks of Genesis and Rick Wakeman of Yes.
I shall endeavour to rise to the challenge you have set me!!!
Masterpiece!! 💙🎵🎶🎶🎶
💯
Very entertaining
'And we reach all this with movements in between the said remark.'..
So... I think that place Jon is talking about is somewhere deep within a millisecond of silence. The whole epic journey takes place almost instantaneously while we are sitting by the river. Btw, in the book Siddhartha, there is a period during his life when he encounters a strange river that becomes one of his most important esoteric teachers..I think it is a clue worth mentioning regarding the mystical themes that Jon was delving into here. I think Steve Howe and Jon collaborated on the austere themes of this album and also on Tales from Topographic Oceans the double album follow-up to Close to the Edge. So we can also blame Steve for these obscure, fay, oddball lyrics! Lol..
It just fascinates me that prog rock explores such crazy and random topics to sing about. Mind blowing stuff
Now that you've heard Yes and Genesis epics, try ELP - Karn Evil 9 (1st, 2nd, and 3rd impressions); Pink Floyd - Shine on You Crazy Diamond (Parts 1-9); Rush - 2112; Elton John - Funeral for a Friend/Love Lies Bleeding; Alan Parsons Project - Fall of the House of Usher or The Turn of a Friendly Card Suite; Supertramp - Fool's Overture; Ten CC - Feel the Benefit... if you've not heard them before. All over 10 minutes... I have others as well.
I think some of those are already on my list awaiting my attention, I'll see what I can do 🙂
I remember when this dropped ...2.99 at Newberry
Thats a cracking memory you've got there!
I think you're onto something with your insight about Yes playing and singing lots of high pitched sounds and rising tones contrasting with the deep, growly bass. I think of them as making the music of yearning and longing, as well as positivity and hope.
That's a great comment, well made
Hilarious reaction! It was actually how I felt the first time I listened to CTTE 50 years ago. It definitely grows on you after a couple of listens. For the sake of your sanity, on no account listen to Gates of Delirium. But for the enjoyment of your viewers please do a reaction to this classic from Yes' Relayer album.
Hahaha eeeee I have some sadistic viewers on my channel...ya'll want to see me in a straight jacket 🤣. Ah well, in for a penny, in for a pound
May I suggest The Gates Of Delirium from the Relayer album. Based on War And Peace by Leo Tolstoy, covering the buildup, battles and resolution. If you think CTTE is chaotic wait till you hear them perform a battle scene. Sounds like both war and very complicated music
I do have it on my list, I'll definitely cover it, perhaps a little come down first from my mental scars from CTTE 🤣
Rick reckons that Lloyd Webber nicked an organ riff from Judas Iscariot and used it in Phantom .
This is the greatest prog album ever by the greatest band that has graced this planet. Steve who is Geoff ? You have now entered the masterpiece that is Close to the Edge. Jon Anderson the most emotive goosebumping voice in music.
Haha Geoff just seems to be the name I randomly use when I either don't know or can't remember a band members name, and want to make up some story to tell during the reaction 🤦♂️
Too bad i never saw them in concert, just had the albums but Genesis, i saw many times, first time was in 1974 ! lol
I'd say Genesis is an excellent substitute!!!!
Steve Howe is really a "guitar master".
I prefer a little of the green stuff rather than alcohol to prime me up for Yes, but to each their own. Always great to watch British lads discover their own countries revolutionary rock bands they gifted the planet in the 60's and 70's .
Green stuff, Amber liquid, it's all good when it comes to the amazingness that is Yes!
Hee hee, @3:22 "that's very pleasant '
Hi Steve! Great song and band! I look at this type of prog in 2 ways. First. If you think of classical music or movie scores it’s very similar. The difference being guitars bass drums and keyboards vs. orchestral instruments. The second is prog is like reading a book like The Lord of the Rings or any sci-fi or fantasy book. There are highs lows battle scenes love scenes or journeying into the Mines of Moria. It’s a journey for the ears instead of the eyes.
Now you're speaking my language! Love it....especially the use of Lotr! Well played, Sir
My favorite version of this song is the live version from the live album "Yessongs." The recording quality isn't really outstanding, but especially the second half of the song got a lot of polish.
It's a little scattered for my tastes compared to other great songs from YES like Starship Trooper, And you and I, Long Distance Runaround, I've seen all good people...all more digestible on first listen not to mention later hits like Big Generator / Shoot high aim low
Love Shoot High……and yeah, my brain just isn’t wired to appreciate this as music.
Its certainly got its own unique charms, I'll give it that!
@ 😂. You’re more generous than I 😉
So under prepared!
Couldn't have agreed more!
Not watched yet mate, just started - but any idea why I can only get 360p on this?
Erm not sure. If you have any uploading tips I can try exploring that on future uploads?!
@@MusicForTheSoulReactions No idea pal, sorry! Wish I could help, I wondered if it was a setting you could select when you upload or something. Just watched your review, loved it! Destroyed by CTTE. It truly is a wtf is going on song, every time I hear it I get the emotions you displayed! I suppose over time and repeated listens it sinks in and you get used to it and then becomes normal, but yeah - what a song!
Ahhh. Close To The Edge! Listen to Jon's lyrics, but don't think them! (Well, later maybe.) I believe I saw an interview where he said he chooses the words for how they sound first and foremost.
That would make a whole host of sense!!!