Giraud Power Case Trimmer vs. L.E. Wilson Manual Trimmer

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 27 жов 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 39

  • @The4GunGuy
    @The4GunGuy  2 роки тому

    Hey everyone! Reviewing the comments below, I TOTALLY forgot to mention that there is a power drill adapter option for the L.E. Wilson that can help speed things up a bit and save your wrist! As I mentioned to a couple of folks below, just make sure that you set your power drill speed correctly for the caliber you're trimming so you don't bind the trimmer head (too slow) on the case mouth. Thanks again for watching everyone!

  • @jlppayette4992
    @jlppayette4992 2 роки тому +3

    The Giraud is the tool on my bench that I will never get rid of. Worth every penny.

    • @The4GunGuy
      @The4GunGuy  2 роки тому +1

      Totally agree JLP! Thanks for watching my friend!

  • @rudolphferdinand3634
    @rudolphferdinand3634 2 роки тому +1

    I have had the L.E. Wilson case trimmer for 3/5 years now, and it is perfect (slightly different style than the micrometers that you have, silver in color). I am doing right now 308 Winchester brass. Then I got to annealing 308/6.5 CM brass (EP Integration annealer).

    • @The4GunGuy
      @The4GunGuy  2 роки тому

      Hi Rudolph! Jason below uses the power drill adapter and that can speed things up a bit. As I mentioned to him, just make sure you set the speed of the drill properly. Thanks for watching my friend!

  • @JacobTerherst
    @JacobTerherst 2 роки тому +2

    I like the red trimmers.

  • @tomnguyen7412
    @tomnguyen7412 2 роки тому +1

    Since I have the Giraud case trimmer, I enjoy reloading a lot more

    • @The4GunGuy
      @The4GunGuy  2 роки тому

      Same here Tom! Thanks for watching my friend!

  • @joeyoutdoors
    @joeyoutdoors 8 місяців тому

    Giraud tri way - $119 shipped got it in less than a week. Trimmed around 3,000 223 cases this past Saturday. The most fun I have had ever trimming cases. Just ordered one for 308 yesterday. The worst part of reloading was trimming and bevel. Not any more. I f you only have a few calibers you shoot volume, the tri way by Giraud is the way to go.

    • @The4GunGuy
      @The4GunGuy  8 місяців тому

      Great option Joey! Thanks for watching my friend!

  • @Aldocello1
    @Aldocello1 Рік тому

    Just ordered mine yesterday , with holders and cutter heads for multiple calibers ... I live about 45 minutes from his facility so in about a week ill be picking it up ...

    • @The4GunGuy
      @The4GunGuy  Рік тому

      Hi Love! You'll be very happy with it and the ease of use once you get it set up. Thanks for watching my friend!

  • @jasonrad9332
    @jasonrad9332 2 роки тому

    Just recently started reloading. I have the LE Wilson but I bought the adapter to run it with a power drill. Haven’t used it yet. I fire formed my first batch, hoping to shoot my first ladder test this weekend. We’ll see how case trimming goes soon. Great video.

    • @The4GunGuy
      @The4GunGuy  2 роки тому +1

      HI Jason! Yep, I was using that adapter as well and it worked OK. Just be sure to find the right speed that works for the brass you're trimming and you should be good to go. Thanks for watching my friend!

    • @jasonrad9332
      @jasonrad9332 2 роки тому

      @@The4GunGuy thanks for the pointer.

  • @machinist7230
    @machinist7230 2 роки тому

    The issue with the Giraud is it locates off the shoulder, which can be variable, especially with mixed lots of brass.

    • @The4GunGuy
      @The4GunGuy  2 роки тому +1

      Hi Machinist! Very valid point. I really only work with one caliber so I don't have that issue. Thanks for watching my friend!

  • @raywang6528
    @raywang6528 2 роки тому

    Another great and informative video. Mind me asking why u have what looks like electrical tape on the cover?

    • @The4GunGuy
      @The4GunGuy  2 роки тому

      Hi Ray! The electrical tape is along that "window" so not so many brass filings get through. It amazed me how many filings came through that clear shield! Thanks for watching my friend!

  • @michaelbroning4184
    @michaelbroning4184 Рік тому

    So does putting the tap around top and bottom keep the brass particles from getting out..I'm having same issue as you and was thinking of doing what u did..I love the trimmer..how do u clean your trimmer..I'm looking for a small hose like thing to get back behind the inside of the trimmer..

    • @The4GunGuy
      @The4GunGuy  Рік тому +1

      Hi Michael! Yep, putting the tape around the top and bottom does help reduce shaving leakage. To clean it every time I use it, I simple take a vacuum hose and place it over the opening, which get's 90% of everything out of the trimming chamber. Once in a while I will take it apart though and give it a thorough cleaning. Thanks for watching my friend!

  • @tonsofgunsoffun8516
    @tonsofgunsoffun8516 2 роки тому

    How many thousand and thousands and thousands of pieces of brass have I trimmed, chamfered and deburd with my Frankfort arsenal in 3-steps?? I wish I would have bought this Geraurd years ago. My buddy tried to get me to buy one 8-years ago but they are just so expensive

    • @The4GunGuy
      @The4GunGuy  2 роки тому +1

      Hey Tonsoffunsoffun! First off, love the name. Yeah, they're a bit pricey, but I'm very happy with it. I sell a bunch of stuff to buy this stuff, so it's taken me a little time to get this thing, but loving it. Thanks for watching my friend!

    • @666-y8w
      @666-y8w Рік тому

      They are not worth what he is asking. Unless you are an ACE shooter competing in the highest of competitions around the world you will not be missing much with a manual trimmer vs a true precision tool (the GIRAUD is not a precision or consistent tool).

  • @ForceRecon112
    @ForceRecon112 Рік тому

    Have you used the Lyman xpress case trimmer? I don't like the manual ones and for a motorized one, it seemed like a fair priced option

    • @The4GunGuy
      @The4GunGuy  Рік тому +1

      Hi ForceRecon112! I have not used the Lyman, but it looks really promising. The only thing about it was the fact that it is an open trimmer, so filings would be all over the place...At least the one I looked at was open. If they sealed that cutter like the Giraud I think it might be a great option at a good price point. Thanks for watching as usual my friend!

    • @ForceRecon112
      @ForceRecon112 Рік тому +1

      @@The4GunGuy I am getting an updated reloading setup and you have been such a good source of quality info. And I love that you respond fast! Thanks big guy!

  • @1clnsdime1
    @1clnsdime1 2 роки тому

    I have used my Frankford arsenal trimmer for 5 years with the carbide cutter. What do u not like about it?

    • @The4GunGuy
      @The4GunGuy  2 роки тому

      Hi Andrew! I haven't used the Frankford trimmer, just the case prep tool (without the cutter). But, in my research I was concerned about the brass shavings being thrown around by the unshielded cutting head. The Griaud contains the trimmings so I just have to vacuum them out every cutting session. Also, I notice that the Frankford doesn't accept straight cases such as a .357 Magnum pistol case where the Giraud does accept them. I think the Frankford is a valid option for sure and maybe you just place it in a aluminum baking pan for example that can contain the filings. Thanks for watching my friend!

    • @1clnsdime1
      @1clnsdime1 2 роки тому

      @@The4GunGuy yea there are a few places that sell a pan for the shavings. It doesn't spin near as fast as the griaud and does have a cover on the top so the shaving fall out the bottom to the catch pan. It does work very well but not as fast as the griaud trimmer. Just another option that is cheaper. I would love to get the griaud or the Henderson one day if the Frankford dies. Just a heads up for anyone with the Frankford arsenal the RCBS carbide cutter is worth it and makes it cut quicker.

  • @darrylmchenryii809
    @darrylmchenryii809 Рік тому

    Your case to case variation on the LE Wilson comes from that junk Sinclair micrometer. Sinclair's quality is not what it used to be and MANY people have been complaining of its repeatability.
    With the LE Wilson micrometer, their upgraded TiN cutter, and their power adapter, I get exactly 0 case to case variation. Mixed once fired brass, all comes out exactly where I set it. 2.005" exact in the case of 308/7.62NATO. My Mitutoyo calipers are not accurate enough to detect even a .0005" variation.

    • @The4GunGuy
      @The4GunGuy  Рік тому +1

      Hi Darryl! You're right about that micrometer...For one, it drifted all the time and was a pain. I do like this Giraud for the "all in one" functionality (trim, chamfer and deburr) though. Hey thanks for your input and for watching my friend!

    • @darrylmchenryii809
      @darrylmchenryii809 Рік тому

      @@The4GunGuy any time, appreciate the great educational content!
      Glad to hear the Giraud is working for you, I never had great luck with shoulder indexing trimmers, clearly you've got it nailed down though!

  • @96gsxr
    @96gsxr 2 роки тому

    Go Big Red

    • @The4GunGuy
      @The4GunGuy  2 роки тому +1

      Hey Gardissono s!! I get more people commenting on my Big Red mug! OK, I'll tell you the story...When I was a kid, I watched college football and LOVED how that offensive line just plowed their way down the field against these puny defenses, and that's when I became a Big Red fan. I didn't go there, but I just love the simplicity of the team and the logo. Thanks for watching my friend, and yes...GO BIG RED!

  • @markperkins6052
    @markperkins6052 2 роки тому

    Giraud needs adapter for ever caliber.

    • @The4GunGuy
      @The4GunGuy  2 роки тому

      Hi Mark! If you call him up, he might either have one or make one for you. That's another thing I like about him. I called him with a question and talked to "the guy" himself. Super helpful, so call him and see what he says. Thanks for watching my friend!

    • @666-y8w
      @666-y8w Рік тому

      Hey, call him and ask him if he remembers being a dick to a guy that had an order but cancelled it due to his shitty customer service.