Ironically, this means that we can and *should* look up to Nintendo to actually take legal action since they are being impersonated and possibly defamed, which has legal ground for them.
If Nintendo knew about this yet still did nothing then it reminds me of another company that knew for over a half of year people were impersonating them that were sending emails that got people doxed and or swatted (which caused death or near death) saying they were hired.
So it wasn’t Nintendo we were mad about for going to far with the copyright claims but actually some impersonator that is going to actually get fucked by Nintendo because they’re infringing copyright laws?
i dont know but something has to give, else small creators are going to be completely erased from the platform because they can’t fight these claims like bigger channels can. its unfortunate, really
It's mainly because of safe harbor provision in dmca where if someone request a takedown then it needs to be taken down asap or else youtube won't qualify for the provision... The DMCA's “safe harbor” regime offers immunity to claims of copyright infringement if (among other requirements) online service providers promptly remove or block access to infringing materials after copyright holders give appropriate notice.
I, as a modder, have personally been getting over 100 takedowns since 2016. I have started fighting them one by one since 2018 and won every single dispute. I am fairly certain this is an imposter.
Nintendo imposters also go way back before 2016. Back then there were people taking down mediafire links and linking to misspelled nintendo websites that would have ads and viruses.
I've used Nintendo Music in my streams and they recently started getting copyright claimed. I disputed them, and they went away, so I believe it's all false copyright claims by someone other than nintendo, therefore they can't fight the dispute or they'll get caught.
But why is the question so many man hours on behalf of Nintendo for what because the only thing I can think of is they are a rival channel that’s trying to take out the competition
Won’t stop till they remove Susan, everyone connected with her, and actually put in people that care about the platform and respect the laws surrounding fair use in the country youtube is based in. All UA-cam cares about today is advertising money
I’m upset the Snowmobile Accident video got deleted. One of the best videos on GilvaSunner. No, SiIvaGunner didn't upload the original Snowmobile Accident video. It was originally posted on GilvaSunner's channel 9 to 10 years ago.
Apparently SolScribbles confused a copyright claim with a content ID claim. Nintendo is allowed to just slap “Nintendo” on it if it’s a content ID claim. And content ID claims are used for music too…
I have a few ideas about what may have happened: 1. Someone trying to make Nintendo look like an even worse company than already 2. Competition to Gilva, i.e. another uploader of Nintendo OSTs 3. As someone else said: A vigilante trying to “protect” Nintendo from copyright infringement by nuking channels like this
or they are just haters or want to get a revenge from Nintendo or Gilva himself or they have no life and wanted some fun in the quarantine as they have nothing to do or they programmed a bot that claims copyright alone and they want to test it on someone but that is the most unlikely theory. Evil Super villains
The fact that this imposter was able to get away with this and so easily trick Gilva into deleting his channel should stand as the ultimate proof of how utterly broken UA-cam is at this point.
@@thehunterjk2521 it’s either two things, someone who hates Gilva and wanted his channel gone, or someone who wanted to make Nintendo look bad for some reason, I guess?
If this genuinely isn’t Nintendo, then this guy is one of the most screwed people on the planet by deliberately pretending to be one of the most notoriously litigious companies on the planet if they decide to take revenge on the people that were falsely claiming to be them and hurting their PR.
@Safwaan Or a hardcore Nintendo fan that thinks he's doing the right thing in "defending" his oh-so-beloved company that will never acknowledge him, heck they might sue him for impersonating them.
In 2019, someone impersonated Scuderia Ferrari to give me a copyright strike...it was resolved and removed from my account thankfully. Heck, "TheFatRat" had to deal with someone IMPERSONATING HIM AND GIVING HIMSELF A COPYRIGHT STRIKE. No way a "Real human" would've let that happen... YT's system is a joke sometimes. It's almost like they don't even actually check the credentials of the person posing/representing said company striking the channel.
From what I know (and I may be wrong), UA-cam can't have common sense in copyright disputes. Pretty sure it's a part of the whole Safe harbour thing they have. So basically they either have to be impartial and not get involved, or they would lose their safe harbour status and the company would get sued for every copyright infringement. (As I said, I may be wrong)
You don't need credentials to file a strike. That's the fucked up part. You just need to make an account. Like "Totally Legit Dude Who Owns A Lot Of Stuff inc." and you're ready to go. It's totally fucked up. The people who would be sussing out who is legit and who is not really has no more data than you and me.. Guy A says guy B is in the wrong.. What does youtube know about guys A and B? Nothing but what dude A and B wrote in their profile. UA-cam support ain't got time to look into that any further, and that's how these things will continue... Such an absolute shitshow :( Our only hope is literally AI. Humans will not solve this, that is impossible. Fingers crossed for AIs getting less dumb.
@TyrecusK Dale Whoa, you're not really a bot but just a really sad individual that has nothing better to do than to shamelessly plug your video manually in every comment sections?
Honestly, I'm going through this right now with UA-cam. I uploaded a review of Evil Bong in 2012, and one of the many "AdRev" entities claimed it, saying I used the material they owned. Specifically, the 13 Nights of Elvira Evil Bong episode. However, said episode was not released until December 2014. I disputed, as you do, and they rejected. I appealed, and now they're aiming to give my channel a copyright strike for my trouble. As I do movie reviews almost exclusively and use a lot of copyrighted content in my videos, I'm more than used to the dispute process and the fact that fair use or not, UA-cam refuses to ever side with the creator. It's guilty until proven innocent, but this claim was so ridiculous - that I used copyrighted material that didn't even exist yet when I produced my video - I actually went to UA-cam themselves. Or team youtube on Twitter anyway... it's the best most of us can do. After explaining the situation, they came back and told me that AdRev is perfectly in the right because even though I used footage from Evil Bong, a movie owned by Full Moon Features, as AdRev are dealing with the digital rights of an episode of Elvira that licensed the movie, through some digital dark magic AdRev are now the rightful copyright owners of Evil Bong and are freely allowed to strike me as they see fit and I just have to deal with it. Since then I have been trying to get in contact with Full Moon themselves to see what they think about it, but unfortunately it has been eight years since I last worked with them and my contact has evidently moved on and his e-mail no longer works. Trying to bring this up to the company via their merch sales support staff has been less than fruitful. I'm certain I'll fight through this copyright strike just as I have the 10+ others I've received over the years, but the fact that the system is so broken that someone can claim copyright for material they don't own, based on a claim that isn't even possible to be true from the most basic understanding of how time works, and STILL I'm just gonna have to deal with it and hopefully not lose my channel? Really?
I said "13" on twitch chat and got my paid account instant banned from twitch for being "under age of 14" (ban was from twitch not charlie). I appealed it in, and 2 weeks later finally heard back and they said that I'm still banned for being under age of 14. I'm 23. Not going back to twitch.
if each takedown took two minutes to file (which they definitely don't, they take longer from my experience), 3500 takedowns would have taken 4.8 DAYS of just sitting there at a computer, doing this stupid shit
If you haven't seen, TeamUA-cam on Twitter replied to this original evidence thread saying how "These are all valid and in full compliance with copyright rules." Gilva has also retweeted this reply, which gives more reason to believe YT is telling the truth. They did give the whole generic 'if the creator thinks this is wrong, blah blah blah dispute it with a robot bla bla bla', which could mean it's a robot reply, but I kinda doubt it from the way the rest of the Tweet was written, and I bet with all of these copyright response Tweets they have to include that. And people do think YT is still lying, but people have asked a very important question which I also ask: What would UA-cam have to gain from lying about this? Gilva wasn't monetized, YT wasn't putting any ads on Gilva's channel from what I could tell, they weren't making any money, so UA-cam has no reason to lie, if they were making money off of Gilva they wouldn't just lie about this. I'd think that in a case where there's so many people upset about this, UA-cam would try their absolute best to confirm or deconfirm that it was Nintendo, and considering UA-cam/Google's size, I bet they have SOME way to contact Nintendo for this kind of info. Really, it comes down to this: If this was Nintendo, it just shows how stupid they can be and gives us another reason to be mad at them, if it was a person pretending to be Nintendo, that person is scummy and in huge legal trouble, because this would be a case where Nintendo would be right on the case with Nintendo Ninjas and all that stuff.
because UA-cam just doesn't care, they do what they do, example below I heard a verified channel got into copyright with some company, UA-cam did nothing. Then when the company dropped the claim realizing they were wrong, UA-cam demonetized that video and then a ton of them even without the usage of said company, and then his videos weren't getting recommended, then the guy said he thinks UA-cam is killing his channel
as a software engineer, i know this is possible and takes minimal effort to create a bot to file something like this, might take you like 2-3 hours to make but then it just automates and you wont ever have to think about it. so my guess is that it was someone who hated the channel and probably paid a dev to make him/her one
I find it hilarious that you have so little faith in the person who did this, that you automatically assume they couldn't program a bot that would take minimal effort.
I honestly was thinking that they probably used a bot for the takedowns. Side note I wish UA-cam would do something about all of the bot spam. Someone hypothesized that the spam looks like more engagement when they show advertisers stats so maybe that's why don't seem to do anything.
@C mac 55th street lmao why are you so mad and salty. i said 2-3 because of research. unlike you that has to watch a tutorial on how to do it and just follow along "kiddie"
@C mac 55th street Wow I have no doubt that you're clearly a software wizard. Your expertise puts everyone to shame. You must have a software engineering degree from MIT!
Here's the wild thing: If there's evidence that the Nintendo trying to strike down Gilva's channel is fake, what if there's similar evidence that the BrawlBRSTM channel takedown in 2018, which involved about 40-50k videos, >90% of which were 30-minute extensions, was also the same party?
In a way he really wasn't wrong though, he was in disbelief that Nintendo was even tech-savvy enough to use the Internet for something like this, and in this case he was right.
Nintendo being innocent (allegedly) for once was a plot twist I didn't see coming, hopefully the writer of the manga doesn't screw it up for the ending.
PewDiePie comes to mind. Whatever you may think of the guy, his own music was copyright claimed by some random person claiming they did it on behalf of PewDiePie, even though the whole idea behind his music is that it's free to use however you want to for remixes and whatnot. Wild.
Yup, I've seen that. I swear it's a bot checking the claims rather than an actual person, because who would think that someone wants to copyright claim there own song?
@@Gweivyth I think pacman is also a nintendo owned ip I'll have to look this up. Edit- okay so a quick Google tells me nintendo owns 3.8 million shares in Namco. So they are a partner and may well have grounds for copyright on Namco ips.
@@Gweivyth Nope Nintendo don't own Sega or Sonic Sega is still their own company and they just have a good partnership with each other since they have old history together.
So Nintendo is in fact not the raid boss. They were just set up to look like the raid boss. That's crazy. Never thought I'd see Nintendo playing second fiddle.
They probably won't knowing UA-cam. We will see, from what I've heard there has been numerous occasions where random people copy-righted different things you don't own.
"Some men aren't looking for anything logical, like money. They can't be bought, bullied, reasoned, or negotiated with. Some men just want to take down all Nintendo content."
@@kirby1346 I called it bias. UA-cam just doesn't want to mess around with big company like Nintendo so they admitted it to shut down the drama. It totally doesn't make sense with these evidences
@@yokai64 It's spelled "youkai" not "yokai" if you are trying to say ghost or demon. I'm guessing that's what you are going for because your avatar is a picture of a ghost.
Congrats my guy, 10 million is such a huge milestone. To imagine you started as a shy kid making a sniper montage, to what you are now, best of luck Charlie :)
If it is the case that it was someone/a group impersonating Nintendo, couldn't they be in some sort of legal trouble? That's also assuming they even can be found. EDIT: Gotta love the random bot spam comments :I
This goes EVEN FURTHER BACK then 2019, the earliest known instance I personally know of where people impersonated Nintendo to get content shut down was mid April 2018 when they targeted Roblox Pokémon content and got the MASSIVE game Pokemon Brick Bronze shut down, then early June 2019 they targeted Patreon, and I guess after Patreon they moved onto UA-cam and have been plaguing that since, it's likely the same individual
@@jorgefeliciano8183 I'd just assume that they wouldn't like someone impersonating the company. And if this whole thing is true, then Nintendo probably doesn't care about those videos anymore if they haven't taken any of them down.
@@jorgefeliciano8183 Copyright is not intended to be enforced by third parties. Only Nintendo or a law firm acting on behalf of Nintendo have the legal grounds to issue a DMCA takedown. If anyone could claim anything we couldn't upload anything not 100% original for fear of some random person hitting us with a takedown notice. I could issue a takedown notice on this video on behalf of Twitter user @SolScribbles or @GilvaSunner because their tweets are copyright protected (like any creative work is by default). That doesn't make sense, both because this use falls under fair use, but more importantly because I do not represent them and therfore don't know if they want this taken down (they probably don't).
Nintendo probably purposefully did this to throw everyone off there trail. They purposefully made it look like it could be a imposter to save there reputation. Nintendo could easily step in and say this isnt us if that were the case. And they didnt mind those videos/
@@lopesinho They Do not mention Nintendo of America Co. They could be defending the faker also it could be a UA-cam bought defending the person that's impersonating Nintendo.
Goddamn, this plot twist is so good, we now have a super villain behind all of this.. The fact that Nintendo could actually not be responsible for some of the takedowns that happened that occured over the years is really making this season's plot so interesting.
This also happened somewhat with Toei where someone was getting all these (ex One Piece focused) accounts suspended on Twitter under Toei's name. turns out it was some hell bent japanese person who wanted to "exterminate" all the people that talk about or show early scans of chapters before official release
Maybe I'm overthinking this but, this feels like some fallguy situation, where big company hire a person or group to do "fake" copyright takedown. Way too coincidental.
@Blade he did have some music remixes/colabs that were hosted in the channel and now i have no clue where to find most of them. Still what we lost wasnt the content but the story of GilvaSunner, its personality like the weird way he titled videos and the april fools jokes....
I have a crazy conspiracy theory: I don't believe this IS the case, but I believe it's still possible. Considering how ass-backwards crazy Nintendo fans are, it makes you wonder if this was all done by one rogue Nintendo fanboy bc they thought GilvaSunner was infringing on copyright, and thus brought it upon themselves to literally break UA-cam's copyright policy for some greater good to "help Nintendo".
@@quirinoguy8665 they certainly are such bootlickers that they would do something like that. all in order to protect the company that gives them their manchild nostalgia.
Personally, I'm pretty sure that this is someone with a grudge against Nintendo. Nintendo already does this kind of shit, and people would totally expect Nintendo to pull something like this. If someone wanted to make Nintendo look absolutely horrific, this would be a good way to do that.
I mean almost nobody even questioned whether or not Nintendo would do something like this to a UA-camr, because they (and just about every other major Japanese media company) have done so to several UA-camrs whether the content in question falls under fair use guidelines or not.
@Blade You're right Nintendo is not the best company,no one is,but least they have the rules for every person working there to follow and not be like the guys on Actvision-Blizzard I hope that Microsoft can do something with them now that they own the company.
False....Nintendo has been the made villain for a decade now, when they aren't the problem and never have been. And it's sad enough how gullible and brain dead society is and they will attack the good guys 10000% of the time while enabling and supporting the FACTUAL bad guys. Compared to Sony/Playstation, Nintendo is absolut Saints.
This isn't the first and only case of UA-cam's copyright system being abused. "Aiplex Software Private Limited" has also been falsely flagging any video *related* to Spider-Man on smaller channels. They claim these videos are using footage from No Way Home but that is not the case. Original works, such a parody I wrote, filmed, and produced have been taken down for "pirating" footage from the newest film. Seems that has been the only reason they use to take down content, irregardless of what the video is. "Bully Maguire" meme channels have been a high target from these assholes lately, and their videos, or even channels in worst cases, are terminated for "using NWH footage." These guys aren't even a legitimate company, and UA-cam has refused to get involved. It's one thing to have this kind of content taken down by copyright owners (such as Sony, Disney, or Insomniac because even GAMEPLAY footage has been taken down), but Aiplex owns NOTHING. They aren't a real company with any real legal standing to do this to anyone. I made a video detailing the entire situation in-depth, which Aiplex even tried to take down, even though it's just me talking into a camera with no background music. Charlie, we need bigger UA-camrs to speak out about this. UA-cam refuses to get involved, even when faced with a petition that bears 25,000 signatures to look into Aiplex. This "Nintendo" situation is only a small piece of a larger puzzle. So many small channels are needlessly at stake.
PewDiePie had his own song/music video claimed by a company who said it was “on behalf of PewDiePie,” and UA-cam didn’t revoke the claim when he disputed it. There’s always been an issue with UA-cam’s copyright policy, but you’d think they would do more to protect their users considering they are the majority of the company’s revenue.
First comment I've seen that actually sees the problem....this god awful community still blames Nintendo 10000% when Nintendo has literally never been the problem. Its youtube and the users themselves that have been the problem for the last 18 years. Even 10 years ago when the first problems against Nintendo appeared, it was never actually Nintendo striking everyone's videos. Or the simple fact people complained about how you can't upload Mario Kart, Mario party, Zelda, pokemon gameplay etc etc....but yet not one single channel I watch ever stopped nor had issues with uploading Nintendo content. Its actually funny how facts prove that Sony/Playstation is the #1 issue, and it's the Playstation fanbase that has been caught trying to sabotage nearly anything that is a threat to their brand
This actually just happened not too long ago in the One piece UA-cam community. Someone impersonating Toei claimed against a bunch of different UA-cam channels (predating the Totally not Mark thing). One guy went in and started to look into it and saw a lot evidence just like this. Seems a good way to get rid of competition
Hmm, that's interesting. I remember once reading a similar case where a copyright troll was taking down R34 art of Nintendo characters, claiming to be Nintendo. People immediately thought it was Nintendo's doing, and jumped on the conclusion. But later on, they discovered that they were fake, and I think they even discovered the guy behind these claims.
Good point. “Nintendo” isn’t a legal entity. Nintendo of America, Inc and those other longer names are indeed legal entities in those countries. If you’re a company taking a legal action like a copyright claim you would definitely do it in the name of the official corporate entity, not just the name of the brand.
Again is not Nintendo fault but someone who uses the law to make people suffer. Is like here in Brazil where people blame Nintendo for high price in the games but the one behind it is the goverment. It's sad knowing that a guy online would get this dirty to ruin a UA-camr and a company.
@Safan Kimon that’s just depressing. We’re all mourning, mad at UA-cam, mad at wherever took down Gilva, now you. UA-cam can’t even take you down. But music from our childhood? Yep.
They do this with music too. There's been music that wasn't claimed by the original artist but instead some other random person claims it. Mostly happens with leaks of songs that are posted on UA-cam and people get a hold of it before the label makes it copyright themselves
This is also a common trend on YT that they need to fix. Someone not directly related to a media property shouldn't be allowed to cause this in the first place.
@@kapa_nitori Well technically there's no such thing as Nintendo JP on that copyright strike. Even if they did say was confirmed by Nintendo they would specifically say. Nintendo of America Co
I think that the fact that it's just "Nintendo" is pretty damning evidence. It's no smoking gun, and can't be 100% confirmed unless Nintendo decides to speak about it, but damn, that's pretty solid.
This of course isn't the case, but imagine if nearly all the music takedown claims Nintendo has made on UA-cam over the years weren't actually from Nintendo but from someone posing as them, that would be both funny and sad.
thats exactly what I thought too. I mean, if the person/people posing as nintendo have been doing this since 2019... who knows how many "official" nintendo copyrights were the posers.
Still, the fact no one even questioned that this was a Nintendo move shows how much trust it lost from everyone due to their shitty treatment of passionate fans
Which improves the view that if those mail addresses are faked that YT didnt even bother to do rudimentary checks and isnt even checking it now :D Checking if an email address is valid is like an very easy task.
The only way I can think of doing something like this for any type of gain is if they were a rival game company that just wanted to worsen Nintendo's public image. (Worse than Nintendo already has, that is) And if that was the goal, yeah. Mission accomplished. Everybody's talking about it. Some game companies are releasing their music online, which is bringing attention back to this.
This isn’t the first time someone has impersonated Nintendo. If you remember, the Kirby reanimated project was taken down by “Nintendo” but it was proven that it was a company called “A-PAB” that has been taking down Kirby content and pretending to be Nintendo Edit: screw these bots
This is definitely a strong possibility. For example, on my main channel I’ve dealt with a guy pretending to be a anime music corporation. So when I posted a video with a video that should’ve had a copyright claim regardless, the UA-camr “anime kei” copyright claimed the video. So instead of the actual company taking the money, this random guy did.
Another weird thing about this is that the official Pokémon channel uploaded a video that contained the entire d/p soundtrack and said people were free to listen and download and use it as they pleased
On UA-cam? You have access to an account. You don't own UA-cam. Make your own website and you can have representation easily. But as an account user, get fucked.
You're tripping, any decent UA-camr admits their mistakes, you're watching the wrong people if you think charlie is doing something that's rarely done.
There’s no way. It’s a body hired by Nintendo. Literally no way that some randomer had access to this tool at this scale and got away with it. It’s impossible. Edit: to explain, to claim like this requires access to a backend tool and I don’t believe it’s possible to be granted access to this tool without being verified by UA-cam staff.
*Response to the edit* Oh yeah, because UA-cam has TOTALLY never been a stupid and/or Evil company before, they definitely know the difference between right and wrong.
I'm not actually surprised because the internet never fails to show a higher level of pathetic waste of air every single day almost x,D there will always be that person who is legit that deranged and no lifing to pull this crud off. Or a group of the gremlins snickering together as they shove more Doritos in their mouth like "yeah we showed them"
Most likely it's someone using scripts to automate the strike process, doing it so everyone thinks it's actually Nintendo doing it. Everyone then hates on Nintendo and the person doing it has accomplished their goal of spreading their hate for that company onto others. Honestly quite a genius move, I applaude that. Too bad for that person that this changes absolutely nothing
TF2 has been overrun with bots for the past 2 years, a lot of them are even pay to play accounts so they can mic spam, so it's a loss for both parties. It's so pathetic.
If this “Nintendo” really does turn out to be an imposter, I have 2 guesses as to their motivation: 1. They have their own UA-cam channel which puts out similar content, and they wanted to eliminate the competition. (Some people don’t care about the money. They just want to be internet famous and/or have a popular channel.) 2. Their intention is to blackmail the targeted channel or other similar channels. (They could be trying to extort the copyright striked channel, saying; “If you pay us $______ money, we’ll lift/remove the strikes”. Or use it as a threat to extort other channels, saying; “See how we destroyed ______’s channel? We’ll do the same to you unless you comply with what we want”.) Just my two theories. I’m sure there are other possibilities.
Theory: The person pretending to be Nintendo is a rival youtuber who also posts nintendo music, and wants viewers to watch their videos instead so they blocked all of the videos.
The fact that someone can just copy strike an entire channel by faking being Nintendo just shows how screwed UA-cam's copyright system is.
Copyright ruined youtube
@@_k__601 copyright was always around, just became more prominent and more fucking stupid as youtube grew
No, Toei Animations has done this aswell.
And the claimer will face no consequences…
UA-cam's copyright system isn't broken, the world's is.
Ironically, this means that we can and *should* look up to Nintendo to actually take legal action since they are being impersonated and possibly defamed, which has legal ground for them.
If Nintendo knew about this yet still did nothing then it reminds me of another company that knew for over a half of year people were impersonating them that were sending emails that got people doxed and or swatted (which caused death or near death) saying they were hired.
@@NealCamerlengo what company
@@Aidan_OSullivan McDonald's.
So it wasn’t Nintendo we were mad about for going to far with the copyright claims but actually some impersonator that is going to actually get fucked by Nintendo because they’re infringing copyright laws?
Nintendo most likely don't bother to do anything. This is basically letting other people to do their "dirty work".
Jesus Christ. How does UA-cam let random impersonators perform copyright takedowns so easily?
i dont know but something has to give, else small creators are going to be completely erased from the platform because they can’t fight these claims like bigger channels can. its unfortunate, really
Scuffed system. I honestly feel like bots review copyright claims, and not actual people.
simply cause they just dont care lmao
It's mainly because of safe harbor provision in dmca where if someone request a takedown then it needs to be taken down asap or else youtube won't qualify for the provision...
The DMCA's “safe harbor” regime offers immunity to claims of copyright infringement if (among other requirements) online service providers promptly remove or block access to infringing materials after copyright holders give appropriate notice.
@@raniel32 and you know that because?
Pretty scary to see something like this happen, honestly.
Fr
@UCQqVvy6-FuO8vs7W7-vax1A he hit 10m what are you gonna do bout it?
Gonna cri?
ua-cam.com/video/FUG_n2H6z4c/v-deo.html
yah, so scarry. shaking in my boots. good lord.
@@WoodenWizard Wow, you so tough I’m impressed.
I, as a modder, have personally been getting over 100 takedowns since 2016. I have started fighting them one by one since 2018 and won every single dispute. I am fairly certain this is an imposter.
Nintendo imposters also go way back before 2016. Back then there were people taking down mediafire links and linking to misspelled nintendo websites that would have ads and viruses.
I guess if anyone would know, it would be kaze
sus!
@@KazeN64 I had a feeling there was an imposter among us...
Thats wild. Love your work btw.
I've used Nintendo Music in my streams and they recently started getting copyright claimed. I disputed them, and they went away, so I believe it's all false copyright claims by someone other than nintendo, therefore they can't fight the dispute or they'll get caught.
Yo wassup
o
But why is the question so many man hours on behalf of Nintendo for what because the only thing I can think of is they are a rival channel that’s trying to take out the competition
@@abrahamnarvaez1730 my thoughts exactly.
Wait doesn't disputing them, give them your personal info
Sadly Gilva still deleted his channel :/ this sh*t is unfair dude I hate this
I agree
Won’t stop till they remove Susan, everyone connected with her, and actually put in people that care about the platform and respect the laws surrounding fair use in the country youtube is based in. All UA-cam cares about today is advertising money
Yeah he said that in the video
I’m upset the Snowmobile Accident video got deleted. One of the best videos on GilvaSunner.
No, SiIvaGunner didn't upload the original Snowmobile Accident video. It was originally posted on GilvaSunner's channel 9 to 10 years ago.
Based Weegeepie. My 2nd channel's banner is inspired by you. Love your vids, keep up the work man.
UA-cam's official twitter recently confirmed that it was the real Nintendo, so this is getting more confusing
They didn't say it was Nintendo of America Co though. It could be a UA-cam bot that's being miscalculated.
@@M64bros Why does this all have to be so vague.
@@cian.o Because it's Nintendo and UA-cam
Apparently SolScribbles confused a copyright claim with a content ID claim. Nintendo is allowed to just slap “Nintendo” on it if it’s a content ID claim. And content ID claims are used for music too…
@@almightysinnoh We don't even know that though. Yet... But we still need to wait and find out cuz right now a bunch of fans are confused as hell
I have a few ideas about what may have happened:
1. Someone trying to make Nintendo look like an even worse company than already
2. Competition to Gilva, i.e. another uploader of Nintendo OSTs
3. As someone else said: A vigilante trying to “protect” Nintendo from copyright infringement by nuking channels like this
I don't think it's 2. And if it is I don't think Gilva is being targeted specifically rather anyone who would be a rival is the target.
@@killerbug05 I’ll admit, 2 is a bit of a stretch but I still consider it as a possibiliy
After spending time interacting with Nintendo Twitter, my money is #3.
or they are just haters or want to get a revenge from Nintendo or Gilva himself or they have no life and wanted some fun in the quarantine as they have nothing to do or they programmed a bot that claims copyright alone and they want to test it on someone but that is the most unlikely theory. Evil Super villains
2 was exactly what I was thinking
This season of Nintendo: The Copyright Adventures is reaching a great climax!
Yeah
Nintendo annihilating the entirety of italy due to the vast amount of the population being named mario
@@Falutia Nintendo exterminates all Donkeys in the world because they stole their name from Donkey Kong.
69 likes
@@datingzonej8851 penguinz getting wacky in his room ua-cam.com/video/IZ4bm-ttVvE/v-deo.html
Whoever is doing this is probably thinking they're being a good antagonist/super villain and that's their life's goal.
Hi again
Here before this blows up
Yeah it’s probably some guy who hates everything created by Japanese people, which is not uncommon.
yeah I bet they're sitting in a basement somewhere, snickering as they're becoming more and more infamouns on the internet
WHY DID YOU CHANGE YOUR PROFILE PICTURE.
The fact that this imposter was able to get away with this and so easily trick Gilva into deleting his channel should stand as the ultimate proof of how utterly broken UA-cam is at this point.
The only question is who and why? Is it some sick, demented fuck that hates Gilva and wanted to hurt them?
@@thehunterjk2521 it’s either two things, someone who hates Gilva and wanted his channel gone, or someone who wanted to make Nintendo look bad for some reason, I guess?
@@mattbunky true. All we can do now is wait until we find out who it is
should stand that's an ultimate troll
@@mattbunky Nintendo already makes themselves look bad it's the most shit company ever
Charlie just makes mistakes and then takes them like a man and makes them scared of him. Respect.
nice comment
Yeah
@@datingzonej8851 penguinz getting wacky in his room ua-cam.com/video/IZ4bm-ttVvE/v-deo.html
Yea
Common sense, respect.
If this genuinely isn’t Nintendo, then this guy is one of the most screwed people on the planet by deliberately pretending to be one of the most notoriously litigious companies on the planet if they decide to take revenge on the people that were falsely claiming to be them and hurting their PR.
@The TacoCat I think you linked the wrong vid man, this is the real one: ua-cam.com/video/BT9h5ifR1tY/v-deo.html
They probably just hate Nintendo & is trying to make everyone else think so
@MersedesCute nobody gives a shit
That chum could've used that nasty power on something else. Nintendo music is definitely NOT one of them.
@Safwaan Or a hardcore Nintendo fan that thinks he's doing the right thing in "defending" his oh-so-beloved company that will never acknowledge him, heck they might sue him for impersonating them.
Love the idea of Nintendo swatting a child's birthday party, popping balloons and tackling fake Mario's and Luigi's, both adult and child
ua-cam.com/video/FUG_n2H6z4c/v-deo.html
Nintendo taking my child away from me shortly after childbirth (I named him Mario)
@@caesthoffe Happened to my cousin also baby Luigi.
@@adamking4246 get ahold of Yoshi he will save the baby Luigi from Doug Bowser
They stomp on the themed Mario cake 😔
I can't believe on this day, the most influential person in the hunger games series hit 10 million subscribers. Congratulations Charlie
#shoprogambit😔
Right! An amazing milestone to hit 10 mil
In 2019, someone impersonated Scuderia Ferrari to give me a copyright strike...it was resolved and removed from my account thankfully.
Heck, "TheFatRat" had to deal with someone IMPERSONATING HIM AND GIVING HIMSELF A COPYRIGHT STRIKE. No way a "Real human" would've let that happen...
YT's system is a joke sometimes. It's almost like they don't even actually check the credentials of the person posing/representing said company striking the channel.
From what I know (and I may be wrong), UA-cam can't have common sense in copyright disputes. Pretty sure it's a part of the whole Safe harbour thing they have. So basically they either have to be impartial and not get involved, or they would lose their safe harbour status and the company would get sued for every copyright infringement. (As I said, I may be wrong)
and PewDiePie's song, I forget which, got claimed by someone pretending to be claiming it in his name 😂
If you think that UA-cam copyright system is the only broken one oh boy are you in for a surprise
You don't need credentials to file a strike. That's the fucked up part. You just need to make an account. Like "Totally Legit Dude Who Owns A Lot Of Stuff inc." and you're ready to go. It's totally fucked up. The people who would be sussing out who is legit and who is not really has no more data than you and me.. Guy A says guy B is in the wrong.. What does youtube know about guys A and B? Nothing but what dude A and B wrote in their profile. UA-cam support ain't got time to look into that any further, and that's how these things will continue... Such an absolute shitshow :(
Our only hope is literally AI. Humans will not solve this, that is impossible. Fingers crossed for AIs getting less dumb.
The fat rat is a halo god
Whatever the case may be, RIP GilvaSunner. Mad respect to him, he was a true legend
ua-cam.com/video/xkHaGBdM_Mw/v-deo.html
MR BEASTS RESPONSE/
@TyrecusK Dale WTF IS THIS WHY ARE THEIR SO MANY BOTS
This damn bots.
@TyrecusK Dale Whoa, you're not really a bot but just a really sad individual that has nothing better to do than to shamelessly plug your video manually in every comment sections?
I miss him already.
Honestly, I'm going through this right now with UA-cam.
I uploaded a review of Evil Bong in 2012, and one of the many "AdRev" entities claimed it, saying I used the material they owned. Specifically, the 13 Nights of Elvira Evil Bong episode. However, said episode was not released until December 2014.
I disputed, as you do, and they rejected. I appealed, and now they're aiming to give my channel a copyright strike for my trouble.
As I do movie reviews almost exclusively and use a lot of copyrighted content in my videos, I'm more than used to the dispute process and the fact that fair use or not, UA-cam refuses to ever side with the creator. It's guilty until proven innocent, but this claim was so ridiculous - that I used copyrighted material that didn't even exist yet when I produced my video - I actually went to UA-cam themselves.
Or team youtube on Twitter anyway... it's the best most of us can do.
After explaining the situation, they came back and told me that AdRev is perfectly in the right because even though I used footage from Evil Bong, a movie owned by Full Moon Features, as AdRev are dealing with the digital rights of an episode of Elvira that licensed the movie, through some digital dark magic AdRev are now the rightful copyright owners of Evil Bong and are freely allowed to strike me as they see fit and I just have to deal with it.
Since then I have been trying to get in contact with Full Moon themselves to see what they think about it, but unfortunately it has been eight years since I last worked with them and my contact has evidently moved on and his e-mail no longer works. Trying to bring this up to the company via their merch sales support staff has been less than fruitful.
I'm certain I'll fight through this copyright strike just as I have the 10+ others I've received over the years, but the fact that the system is so broken that someone can claim copyright for material they don't own, based on a claim that isn't even possible to be true from the most basic understanding of how time works, and STILL I'm just gonna have to deal with it and hopefully not lose my channel? Really?
two dogs in the house two balls in my mouth
I don’t know they might got you through a legal loop hole? It definitely sucks and wish that you win this.
I said "13" on twitch chat and got my paid account instant banned from twitch for being "under age of 14" (ban was from twitch not charlie). I appealed it in, and 2 weeks later finally heard back and they said that I'm still banned for being under age of 14. I'm 23. Not going back to twitch.
The Internet personality wit da best hair
@@calixivitus2323 yes dude! I love this guy
Gilvasunner gets a shitload of takedowns.
Everyone: *Looks at Nintendo”
Nintendo: “look, we’re shitty, but we had nothing to do with this.”
“Nintendo!”
“What, I’m over here.”
“Oh, sorry, force of habit.”
And in the end, it really was nintendo.
No they did
Gilvasunner gets a shitload of takedowns.
Everyone: *Looks at Nintendo”
Nintendo: “BOI, DAFUQ, I AINT DO NOTHIN"”
Nintendo would never admit they're shitty lol
if each takedown took two minutes to file (which they definitely don't, they take longer from my experience), 3500 takedowns would have taken 4.8 DAYS of just sitting there at a computer, doing this stupid shit
You clearly don't know how physics work.
Maybe they had all hands on deck to ruin this one guy’s career
@@binladen2990 smh my head you don't understand how biology works
@@binladen2990 big fan
So basically one sweaty troll tweeker
While Nintendo didn't do it, that still doesn't excuse how bad UA-cam's copyright system is.
That, and also how bad they are at handling these bots.
It has been terrible for years now. A man who made his original music got copyright by someone
@@sabersroommate8293 TheFatRat I think
in my opinion it makes it worse that a random was able to do it
@tretret ertertert I'd like if he did that.
If it's someone pretending to be Nintendo, I hope Nintendo goes after THEM instead of Officially Striking more Channels.
My man is spitting facts.
@@datingzonej8851 penguinz getting wacky in his room ua-cam.com/video/IZ4bm-ttVvE/v-deo.html
There are many people falsely claiming content as theirs to fuck up people's channels.
Guy or gal is about to get the full copyright death experience by the end of this season.
Nintendo's copyright strikers are probably happy some random nutjob is doing their job for them tbh. 😛
If you haven't seen, TeamUA-cam on Twitter replied to this original evidence thread saying how "These are all valid and in full compliance with copyright rules." Gilva has also retweeted this reply, which gives more reason to believe YT is telling the truth. They did give the whole generic 'if the creator thinks this is wrong, blah blah blah dispute it with a robot bla bla bla', which could mean it's a robot reply, but I kinda doubt it from the way the rest of the Tweet was written, and I bet with all of these copyright response Tweets they have to include that. And people do think YT is still lying, but people have asked a very important question which I also ask: What would UA-cam have to gain from lying about this? Gilva wasn't monetized, YT wasn't putting any ads on Gilva's channel from what I could tell, they weren't making any money, so UA-cam has no reason to lie, if they were making money off of Gilva they wouldn't just lie about this. I'd think that in a case where there's so many people upset about this, UA-cam would try their absolute best to confirm or deconfirm that it was Nintendo, and considering UA-cam/Google's size, I bet they have SOME way to contact Nintendo for this kind of info.
Really, it comes down to this: If this was Nintendo, it just shows how stupid they can be and gives us another reason to be mad at them, if it was a person pretending to be Nintendo, that person is scummy and in huge legal trouble, because this would be a case where Nintendo would be right on the case with Nintendo Ninjas and all that stuff.
Yeah I know for a fact that They didn't mention Nintendo of America Co when they tweeted that tweet. I think it's a UA-cam bot
because UA-cam just doesn't care, they do what they do, example below
I heard a verified channel got into copyright with some company, UA-cam did nothing. Then when the company dropped the claim realizing they were wrong, UA-cam demonetized that video and then a ton of them even without the usage of said company, and then his videos weren't getting recommended, then the guy said he thinks UA-cam is killing his channel
"You all know how much I love to get wacky...but unfortunately today, I learned what happens, when Wacky...gets you."
-Charlie, 2022
the bots are at it again
Yes, I too watched the first ten seconds of the video.
Lmao the bots are everywhere
Reddit tier comment.
Why the hell is the comment section on this comment WACKY
as a software engineer, i know this is possible and takes minimal effort to create a bot to file something like this, might take you like 2-3 hours to make but then it just automates and you wont ever have to think about it. so my guess is that it was someone who hated the channel and probably paid a dev to make him/her one
I find it hilarious that you have so little faith in the person who did this, that you automatically assume they couldn't program a bot that would take minimal effort.
I honestly was thinking that they probably used a bot for the takedowns. Side note I wish UA-cam would do something about all of the bot spam. Someone hypothesized that the spam looks like more engagement when they show advertisers stats so maybe that's why don't seem to do anything.
@C mac 55th street lmao why are you so mad and salty. i said 2-3 because of research. unlike you that has to watch a tutorial on how to do it and just follow along "kiddie"
@@SirXtC lmao your the child, shut up.
@C mac 55th street Wow I have no doubt that you're clearly a software wizard. Your expertise puts everyone to shame. You must have a software engineering degree from MIT!
Here's the wild thing: If there's evidence that the Nintendo trying to strike down Gilva's channel is fake, what if there's similar evidence that the BrawlBRSTM channel takedown in 2018, which involved about 40-50k videos, >90% of which were 30-minute extensions, was also the same party?
huh, never thought of that
Hmm...
@@PhanTum926 hmmm...
damn i remember BrawlBRSTM.. if this is the same situation id be so pissed
Why can't youtube find a fking way to get rid of these fiking bots........
In a way he really wasn't wrong though, he was in disbelief that Nintendo was even tech-savvy enough to use the Internet for something like this, and in this case he was right.
yeah fr lol
Nintendo being innocent (allegedly) for once was a plot twist I didn't see coming, hopefully the writer of the manga doesn't screw it up for the ending.
@berlin penguinz getting wacky in his room ua-cam.com/video/IZ4bm-ttVvE/v-deo.html
I wonder if someone is taking down the vidos to sell nfts of the music
Most likely they'll leave that subplot unfinished as they move on with the main story.
@@candyace who is the character in your profile picture?
The greatest trick the devil ever pulled, was convincing the world he was Nintendo copyright claiming UA-cam videos
ua-cam.com/video/0aUGrE6doW8/v-deo.html
@@sensorsoonn6494 I don’t trust that link
@@sensorsoonn6494 you don't matter
sick reference
@@sensorsoonn6494 nice bot, where'd you get it?
“Like Monsters Inc, Nintendo is a scary company.” One of Charlie’s greatest quotes
I mean, he is not wrong.
Also, these fucking bots!?
im definitely keeping this one
The fact that UA-cam just accepted the "Nintendo" strike like "Yeah that seems right." Is pretty telling, to be honest.
PewDiePie comes to mind. Whatever you may think of the guy, his own music was copyright claimed by some random person claiming they did it on behalf of PewDiePie, even though the whole idea behind his music is that it's free to use however you want to for remixes and whatnot. Wild.
ua-cam.com/video/FUG_n2H6z4c/v-deo.html
Yup, I've seen that. I swear it's a bot checking the claims rather than an actual person, because who would think that someone wants to copyright claim there own song?
Did he manage to remove that copyright?
@@gamin546 it's pretty common knowledge that it's exclusively bots unless someone manages to get a manual review.
@@Tas_Ydrokolios yes he did
For some reason, Sonic, Tetris, Pac-Man, etc. were also being taken down as “Nintendo”. Yet, Nintendo doesn’t own any of those copyrights.
Isn't Sega owned by Nintendo? They'd probably have rights to Sonic, but the other ones are def weird.
@@Gweivyth lmao
@@Gweivyth I think pacman is also a nintendo owned ip I'll have to look this up.
Edit- okay so a quick Google tells me nintendo owns 3.8 million shares in Namco. So they are a partner and may well have grounds for copyright on Namco ips.
@@Gweivyth Nope
Nintendo don't own Sega or Sonic
Sega is still their own company and they just have a good partnership with each other since they have old history together.
@@ralcogaming7674 they would have grounds to pressure namco to do it but not do it themselves copyright action has to be taken by the holder
So Nintendo is in fact not the raid boss. They were just set up to look like the raid boss. That's crazy. Never thought I'd see Nintendo playing second fiddle.
Oh no, they still are just not in this case.
I wonder if somone is trying to sell NFTs of nintendos music
Or Nintendo got someone to impersonate Nintendo and are actually more villainous than we ever imagined.
Who’s the Dimentio to Nintendo’s Count Bleck
@@eFrog27
Nah
Is just a villain trying to frame Nintendo for something they didn't do
We got an Ace attorney case in our hands
Plot twist:
It was actually Nintendo, but they didn't want to lose reputation, so they used a fake Nintendo company acting to be themselves.
Ngl that is possible
Nah they dont care about their reputation. They already have a garbage rep anyways
@@ddm_gamer "That's why i don't play games anymore.. they steal their freedom"
@@lautarogomez9711 Nintendo?
@@Iamlewis93 the gaming industry in general
I really hope UA-cam takes a further look into this
They definitely will 👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻
They better. Hopefully it'll go some way to stop those proxy companies exclusively earning a living from strikes.
They probably won't knowing UA-cam. We will see, from what I've heard there has been numerous occasions where random people copy-righted different things you don't own.
Dedicated Bros STAND UP
That’s unlikely. The only way it’s gonna happen is if 50 famous UA-camrs all tweet about this
"Some men aren't looking for anything logical, like money. They can't be bought, bullied, reasoned, or negotiated with. Some men just want to take down all Nintendo content."
Instead of hiding his errors and pretending they never happened, Charlie makes a whole video explaining it. What a champ.
@sweet home 2 penguinz getting wacky in his room ua-cam.com/video/IZ4bm-ttVvE/v-deo.html
RIGHTT
Jesus christ 8 spam bots
There's a real life villain out there...
Yea and it turns out it is actually Nintendo. UA-cam confirmed it was actually Nintendo
@@kirby1346 I called it bias. UA-cam just doesn't want to mess around with big company like Nintendo so they admitted it to shut down the drama. It totally doesn't make sense with these evidences
@@kirby1346 But then again, Nintendo Does want this to happen. So it's no need for UA-cam to find the one behind all of this
"and that's humanity
it was really nintendo that did it
2:56 - This says 公式チャンネル (koushiki chaneru). It means Nintendo's Official Channel.
weeb
Cool
@@TheIzester yknow i think maybe there are people that know Japanese that are 𝗻𝗼𝘁 weebs
@@yokai64 It's spelled "youkai" not "yokai" if you are trying to say ghost or demon. I'm guessing that's what you are going for because your avatar is a picture of a ghost.
@@unemployed2 shut up
"It'd have to be someone with a grudge against Nintendo fans"
That sounds like Nintendo
ua-cam.com/video/xkHaGBdM_Mw/v-deo.html
MR BEASTS RESPONSE/
@@youtyiyyutuu104 mr beast?????
@Instagram User only 32k?
Amateurs.
@Instagram User not even 128K bruh
I’m convinced that the culprit is arumaru himself hoarding all of the paper Mario music for himself so nobody can like the wrong tracks ever again.
Oh my god! What a plot twist!
we must pray that dave awakens from his slumber
We gotta summon Dave Mathews.
Hopefully arumaru has played all the other paper Mario games then
Congrats my guy, 10 million is such a huge milestone. To imagine you started as a shy kid making a sniper montage, to what you are now, best of luck Charlie :)
ua-cam.com/video/0aUGrE6doW8/v-deo.html
Thought it was going to be about this, nice to see him admit to mistakes, still Rest In Peace GilvaSunner :(
@@datingzonej8851 penguinz getting wacky in his room ua-cam.com/video/IZ4bm-ttVvE/v-deo.html
can youtube do something about these bots
Bruh i thought there was conversation in the replies, sadly ITS ALL FUCKING BOTS!
The bots are out of fucking control in these comments
@@shinseka1 there is an application that blocks these bots, but I don’t think Charlie watched Linus tech tips
I love how Charlie accepts when he's wrong and isn't always defending what he previously thought
Because it's nothing serious here... what does he lose from admitting that he made a small mistake.
He's a child of science, apparently.
You think other youtubers would be defensive about a nintendo impersonator?
Yeah, Charlie's pretty cool
Being wrong just means another video
If it is the case that it was someone/a group impersonating Nintendo, couldn't they be in some sort of legal trouble? That's also assuming they even can be found.
EDIT: Gotta love the random bot spam comments :I
They could get sued for defamation at the very least because Nintendo can prove that the event caused negative PR
@@dovalist6637 o o f. Imagine getting sued by Nintendo
We need a bunch of 4Chan users to weaponize their autism into finding the person who did this (allegedly).
@@KatSpicert Bruh it'd be godtier.
This goes EVEN FURTHER BACK then 2019, the earliest known instance I personally know of where people impersonated Nintendo to get content shut down was mid April 2018 when they targeted Roblox Pokémon content and got the MASSIVE game Pokemon Brick Bronze shut down, then early June 2019 they targeted Patreon, and I guess after Patreon they moved onto UA-cam and have been plaguing that since, it's likely the same individual
ua-cam.com/video/0aUGrE6doW8/v-deo.html
@@sensorsoonn6494 why advertise a completely unrelated video on my comment, bruh
Pokemon Brick bronze wasnt taken down by impersonation.. Big youtubers advertised it and the pokemon company took it down
Well at least we know that if this guy gets caught, Nintendo's legal team is probably going to absolutely destroy them.
Why? He is just doing Nintendo job for them
@@jorgefeliciano8183 I'd just assume that they wouldn't like someone impersonating the company. And if this whole thing is true, then Nintendo probably doesn't care about those videos anymore if they haven't taken any of them down.
@@jorgefeliciano8183 Copyright is not intended to be enforced by third parties. Only Nintendo or a law firm acting on behalf of Nintendo have the legal grounds to issue a DMCA takedown.
If anyone could claim anything we couldn't upload anything not 100% original for fear of some random person hitting us with a takedown notice.
I could issue a takedown notice on this video on behalf of Twitter user @SolScribbles or @GilvaSunner because their tweets are copyright protected (like any creative work is by default). That doesn't make sense, both because this use falls under fair use, but more importantly because I do not represent them and therfore don't know if they want this taken down (they probably don't).
Nintendo probably purposefully did this to throw everyone off there trail. They purposefully made it look like it could be a imposter to save there reputation. Nintendo could easily step in and say this isnt us if that were the case. And they didnt mind those videos/
he didn't input 3500 manually, he 100% used a script/bot to file all those takedown requests
Either that or paid a service overseas to do it. Most likely in India.
@@PezIsGod Man I hate the people in my country sometimes
As far as auto clicker goes, it could be possible if theres no captcha in place
@@DRakeTRofKBam You dont fill requests with autoclickers lmao
@@gusthavo15yearsand98 well u can still run some script, you get the jist i hope lol
The fact that he went from talking about Nintendo to promoting his MoistShirt without sweat is just 💀
He went fron nintendo, to moistshirt, to death
update: youtube has confirmed it really was nintendo :(
They didn't mention Nintendo of America Co. It could be a UA-cam bot defending the faker
Of course
This whole problem could be bad to UA-cam so they want to end it quick and forget about it
@@lopesinho They Do not mention Nintendo of America Co. They could be defending the faker also it could be a UA-cam bought defending the person that's impersonating Nintendo.
@@M64bros
There's one thing they said anything and is the fake email
He said there's was fake email that was used
But nothing came to light
Goddamn, this plot twist is so good, we now have a super villain behind all of this.. The fact that Nintendo could actually not be responsible for some of the takedowns that happened that occured over the years is really making this season's plot so interesting.
The bots are here, oh no
@@quirinoguy8665 they're everywhere
There's no shame in being wrong when there's a literal conspiracy going on
@sweet home 2 penguinz getting wacky in his room ua-cam.com/video/IZ4bm-ttVvE/v-deo.html
Bruh the amount of bots here
Ayyyy eula pfp
The person who did this is obviously the “It’s within their legal rights to do this” type of Nintendo fan. the motives check out
sounds pretty accurate
its not impossible that its just a console wars thing and someone is doing this to make nintendo as a company look bad /shrug
Is not a Nintendo fan
This guy is trying to frame Nintendo
Can't you understand how big this is
@@hayleymarie5976 thank you for being the only commenter who got the damn joke
@@pugman9672 didn’t read the rest of the comments until now but yeah that’s the internet😭 they get defensive before they comprehend anything
"Great point made by the twitter user" Never thought I would hear those words.
This also happened somewhat with Toei where someone was getting all these (ex One Piece focused) accounts suspended on Twitter under Toei's name. turns out it was some hell bent japanese person who wanted to "exterminate" all the people that talk about or show early scans of chapters before official release
ua-cam.com/video/d0iBU20X284/v-deo.html
Yeppie.
that man has been watching too much attack on titan hahaha
@@2gamers100 yeah this guy literally made it his goal to get rid of this one early scans team but ultimately failed lol
these people are a different breed 😭
Maybe I'm overthinking this but, this feels like some fallguy situation, where big company hire a person or group to do "fake" copyright takedown. Way too coincidental.
Either way it's sad that the guy deleted his channel due to all this. I can just see all the hours of work just going down the drain.
Hopefully he has some sort of backup
@@seamussmyth1928 there is no such thing unless youtube reinstates it its gone for ever
he was dumb for that, you literally gain nothing, who cares if you have no vids you still have a channel with tons of subs
@Blade he did have some music remixes/colabs that were hosted in the channel and now i have no clue where to find most of them. Still what we lost wasnt the content but the story of GilvaSunner, its personality like the weird way he titled videos and the april fools jokes....
Hopefully one day he’ll get it back.
I have a crazy conspiracy theory:
I don't believe this IS the case, but I believe it's still possible.
Considering how ass-backwards crazy Nintendo fans are, it makes you wonder if this was all done by one rogue Nintendo fanboy bc they thought GilvaSunner was infringing on copyright, and thus brought it upon themselves to literally break UA-cam's copyright policy for some greater good to "help Nintendo".
Not impossible
Very possible.
ua-cam.com/video/xkHaGBdM_Mw/v-deo.html
MR BEASTS RESPONSE/
@@quirinoguy8665 they certainly are such bootlickers that they would do something like that. all in order to protect the company that gives them their manchild nostalgia.
Why does this sound plausible?
I think it could’ve been a doxxing scheme. From what I’ve heard, fighting strikes requires giving up your home address for some reason.
Personally, I'm pretty sure that this is someone with a grudge against Nintendo. Nintendo already does this kind of shit, and people would totally expect Nintendo to pull something like this. If someone wanted to make Nintendo look absolutely horrific, this would be a good way to do that.
I mean almost nobody even questioned whether or not Nintendo would do something like this to a UA-camr, because they (and just about every other major Japanese media company) have done so to several UA-camrs whether the content in question falls under fair use guidelines or not.
thats just insane, why anyone would just...like, impersonate this, is nuts.
Nintendo is already horrific surprised people still support it
@Blade
You're right
Nintendo is not the best company,no one is,but least they have the rules for every person working there to follow and not be like the guys on Actvision-Blizzard
I hope that Microsoft can do something with them now that they own the company.
False....Nintendo has been the made villain for a decade now, when they aren't the problem and never have been.
And it's sad enough how gullible and brain dead society is and they will attack the good guys 10000% of the time while enabling and supporting the FACTUAL bad guys. Compared to Sony/Playstation, Nintendo is absolut Saints.
This isn't the first and only case of UA-cam's copyright system being abused. "Aiplex Software Private Limited" has also been falsely flagging any video *related* to Spider-Man on smaller channels. They claim these videos are using footage from No Way Home but that is not the case. Original works, such a parody I wrote, filmed, and produced have been taken down for "pirating" footage from the newest film. Seems that has been the only reason they use to take down content, irregardless of what the video is. "Bully Maguire" meme channels have been a high target from these assholes lately, and their videos, or even channels in worst cases, are terminated for "using NWH footage." These guys aren't even a legitimate company, and UA-cam has refused to get involved. It's one thing to have this kind of content taken down by copyright owners (such as Sony, Disney, or Insomniac because even GAMEPLAY footage has been taken down), but Aiplex owns NOTHING. They aren't a real company with any real legal standing to do this to anyone. I made a video detailing the entire situation in-depth, which Aiplex even tried to take down, even though it's just me talking into a camera with no background music. Charlie, we need bigger UA-camrs to speak out about this. UA-cam refuses to get involved, even when faced with a petition that bears 25,000 signatures to look into Aiplex. This "Nintendo" situation is only a small piece of a larger puzzle. So many small channels are needlessly at stake.
PewDiePie had his own song/music video claimed by a company who said it was “on behalf of PewDiePie,” and UA-cam didn’t revoke the claim when he disputed it. There’s always been an issue with UA-cam’s copyright policy, but you’d think they would do more to protect their users considering they are the majority of the company’s revenue.
First comment I've seen that actually sees the problem....this god awful community still blames Nintendo 10000% when Nintendo has literally never been the problem. Its youtube and the users themselves that have been the problem for the last 18 years.
Even 10 years ago when the first problems against Nintendo appeared, it was never actually Nintendo striking everyone's videos. Or the simple fact people complained about how you can't upload Mario Kart, Mario party, Zelda, pokemon gameplay etc etc....but yet not one single channel I watch ever stopped nor had issues with uploading Nintendo content.
Its actually funny how facts prove that Sony/Playstation is the #1 issue, and it's the Playstation fanbase that has been caught trying to sabotage nearly anything that is a threat to their brand
@@brucebonner3491 ya had me in the first half ngl then you broke out the tin foil hat
Stop reporting my comments cause you can't stand facts and reality
@@brucebonner3491 that’s hilarious 😁
This actually just happened not too long ago in the One piece UA-cam community. Someone impersonating Toei claimed against a bunch of different UA-cam channels (predating the Totally not Mark thing). One guy went in and started to look into it and saw a lot evidence just like this. Seems a good way to get rid of competition
Hmm, that's interesting. I remember once reading a similar case where a copyright troll was taking down R34 art of Nintendo characters, claiming to be Nintendo.
People immediately thought it was Nintendo's doing, and jumped on the conclusion.
But later on, they discovered that they were fake, and I think they even discovered the guy behind these claims.
Wait so Nintendo isn't based?
Ah yes, r34 getting taken down, such a great loss for society.
Good old 4chan detectives. Never let us down before, even if they are 4chan detectives.
Honestly, wouldn't be surprised if it's literally the same person tbh...
Good point. “Nintendo” isn’t a legal entity.
Nintendo of America, Inc and those other longer names are indeed legal entities in those countries.
If you’re a company taking a legal action like a copyright claim you would definitely do it in the name of the official corporate entity, not just the name of the brand.
Right, it'd be like if you got sued by "frosted flakes" instead of kellogs.
Again is not Nintendo fault but someone who uses the law to make people suffer.
Is like here in Brazil where people blame Nintendo for high price in the games but the one behind it is the goverment.
It's sad knowing that a guy online would get this dirty to ruin a UA-camr and a company.
@Safan Kimon that’s just depressing. We’re all mourning, mad at UA-cam, mad at wherever took down Gilva, now you. UA-cam can’t even take you down. But music from our childhood? Yep.
@@johannaappleforest7482 don't even take the time to talk, it's a bot.
Too bad Nintendo did this themselves several times. They are not magically free of criticism because of this. They are scummy ad fuck.
@@thatitalianlameguy2235
Sadly
It's an imposter
UA-cam allows things like this to happen and they don't say sorry
Ainda sim a nintendo nem da bola pro brasil
They do this with music too. There's been music that wasn't claimed by the original artist but instead some other random person claims it. Mostly happens with leaks of songs that are posted on UA-cam and people get a hold of it before the label makes it copyright themselves
Like midunesti nane, and baka mitai.
Both are claimed by Turkish company before. Baka mitai has been resolved though (SEGA is real owner).
At least Charlie is honest about the mistakes he makes
ua-cam.com/video/3It1J_CD0so/v-deo.html
@@datingzonej8851 penguinz getting wacky in his room ua-cam.com/video/IZ4bm-ttVvE/v-deo.html
lmao its all bot comments
Holy shit, Is this a new Bot record?
@@minecraftweeeweeweeb8695 Jesus wtf I came back and it’s all bots
This is also a common trend on YT that they need to fix. Someone not directly related to a media property shouldn't be allowed to cause this in the first place.
Watch it actually be Nintendo trying to prank us into thinking it’s a troll, whilst still getting what they want
Nope. It was Nintendo. UA-cam confirmed it😑
they did not say Nintendo of America though
@@M64bros japan exist... wait... japan exist?
@@kapa_nitori Well technically there's no such thing as Nintendo JP on that copyright strike. Even if they did say was confirmed by Nintendo they would specifically say. Nintendo of America Co
I think that the fact that it's just "Nintendo" is pretty damning evidence. It's no smoking gun, and can't be 100% confirmed unless Nintendo decides to speak about it, but damn, that's pretty solid.
Honestly, this should be investigated further. What this “Nintendo” guy is doing is sounds illegal.
uh, it is. Pretty sure that impersonation of a corporation is a violation of United States Federal Law
Could be some autist going rampant trying to "protect" his fav company
@@jonathanzimmer725 what if that person is not living in the US ?
@@Yahula1edits doesn't matter where they live, only matters where UA-cam lives.
@@periberry7345 so your telling me youtube will pull someone in iran or russia or china to court for this? You jest
Congrats on your 10 million subscribers!
For a second I thought you were a imposter hyrule lol
Hello nft
It’s on 9.99M I think someone unsubbed
Read the room
@@liztarts5476 no, it was at 9.99 when I made the comment. I just figured he will hit it very soon.
Everyone: why would Nintendo take down that music?
Fake Nintendo: It's not about music. It's about the message...
Everything burns
This of course isn't the case, but imagine if nearly all the music takedown claims Nintendo has made on UA-cam over the years weren't actually from Nintendo but from someone posing as them, that would be both funny and sad.
thats exactly what I thought too. I mean, if the person/people posing as nintendo have been doing this since 2019... who knows how many "official" nintendo copyrights were the posers.
Still, the fact no one even questioned that this was a Nintendo move shows how much trust it lost from everyone due to their shitty treatment of passionate fans
Fucking bots
@卐-soundcity-卐 says the guy with nazi symbols in his username
@@michaelsnyman2800 nah its symbol of friendshipTM
Sup, lol
@@SilentDreamsMax Oh hey lmao, nice seeing you here
New plot twist; YT themselves confirmed that the real Nintendo took down those videos
Which improves the view that if those mail addresses are faked that YT didnt even bother to do rudimentary checks and isnt even checking it now :D
Checking if an email address is valid is like an very easy task.
@@Ark626 you have to realize that these are content ID claims, not takedowns
I love how honest Charlie is about being wrong about things. And I also love his basic titles
As a matter of fact... One person once said that if there is anything that may be griefed in any way... A griefer shall exist for it.
The only way I can think of doing something like this for any type of gain is if they were a rival game company that just wanted to worsen Nintendo's public image. (Worse than Nintendo already has, that is) And if that was the goal, yeah. Mission accomplished. Everybody's talking about it. Some game companies are releasing their music online, which is bringing attention back to this.
GilvaSunner was a legend that we all needed for his hard work over the years.
This isn’t the first time someone has impersonated Nintendo. If you remember, the Kirby reanimated project was taken down by “Nintendo” but it was proven that it was a company called “A-PAB” that has been taking down Kirby content and pretending to be Nintendo
Edit: screw these bots
The machines really are taking over the role of humans
@@marcusramirez8181 And doing a shit job at it, too
@@marcusramirez8181 “Nanomachines son”
"Just like Monsters Inc., Nintendo is a scary company"
Hilarious.
ua-cam.com/video/xkHaGBdM_Mw/v-deo.html
MR BEASTS RESPONSE/
I will always appreciate someone who broadcasts their mistakes as loud as the mistake was broadcasted. None of the MSM does this. Way to go, dude.
ua-cam.com/video/0aUGrE6doW8/v-deo.html
It's either a waste of time or a personal vendetta
It’s not just Nintendo they’re targeting. They even claimed Felix’s music videos.
This is definitely a strong possibility. For example, on my main channel I’ve dealt with a guy pretending to be a anime music corporation. So when I posted a video with a video that should’ve had a copyright claim regardless, the UA-camr “anime kei” copyright claimed the video. So instead of the actual company taking the money, this random guy did.
Another weird thing about this is that the official Pokémon channel uploaded a video that contained the entire d/p soundtrack and said people were free to listen and download and use it as they pleased
Really shows how separate the pokemon company and Nintendo are
We NEED to get attorney representation for Internet content creators as an official subset of law. This can’t be legal.
On UA-cam? You have access to an account. You don't own UA-cam. Make your own website and you can have representation easily. But as an account user, get fucked.
@@jonb3167 🤨
where’s matt murdock when we need him
LegalEagle usually gives free legal advice to content creators if you email him.
At least he’s being honest about his mistakes, that’s something most UA-camrs lack
Yea
Not a high bar
@today was a good day penguinz getting wacky in his room ua-cam.com/video/IZ4bm-ttVvE/v-deo.html
You're tripping, any decent UA-camr admits their mistakes, you're watching the wrong people if you think charlie is doing something that's rarely done.
There’s no way. It’s a body hired by Nintendo. Literally no way that some randomer had access to this tool at this scale and got away with it. It’s impossible.
Edit: to explain, to claim like this requires access to a backend tool and I don’t believe it’s possible to be granted access to this tool without being verified by UA-cam staff.
Yeah
If that's true, you'd think there would be way more channels being striked instead of JUST gilvasunner.
Yeah, kinda think the same. They just don't want the bad reputation on creators stick to them while at the same time someone's gotta do the job.
@today was a good day penguinz getting wacky in his room ua-cam.com/video/IZ4bm-ttVvE/v-deo.html
*Response to the edit* Oh yeah, because UA-cam has TOTALLY never been a stupid and/or Evil company before, they definitely know the difference between right and wrong.
I'm not actually surprised because the internet never fails to show a higher level of pathetic waste of air every single day almost x,D there will always be that person who is legit that deranged and no lifing to pull this crud off. Or a group of the gremlins snickering together as they shove more Doritos in their mouth like "yeah we showed them"
Most likely it's someone using scripts to automate the strike process, doing it so everyone thinks it's actually Nintendo doing it.
Everyone then hates on Nintendo and the person doing it has accomplished their goal of spreading their hate for that company onto others.
Honestly quite a genius move, I applaude that. Too bad for that person that this changes absolutely nothing
TF2 has been overrun with bots for the past 2 years, a lot of them are even pay to play accounts so they can mic spam, so it's a loss for both parties. It's so pathetic.
If this “Nintendo” really does turn out to be an imposter, I have 2 guesses as to their motivation:
1. They have their own UA-cam channel which puts out similar content, and they wanted to eliminate the competition. (Some people don’t care about the money. They just want to be internet famous and/or have a popular channel.)
2. Their intention is to blackmail the targeted channel or other similar channels. (They could be trying to extort the copyright striked channel, saying; “If you pay us $______ money, we’ll lift/remove the strikes”. Or use it as a threat to extort other channels, saying; “See how we destroyed ______’s channel? We’ll do the same to you unless you comply with what we want”.)
Just my two theories. I’m sure there are other possibilities.
Theory: The person pretending to be Nintendo is a rival youtuber who also posts nintendo music, and wants viewers to watch their videos instead so they blocked all of the videos.
i can see it now
So close to 10 mil subs congratulations Charlie you deserve it
@sweet home 2 penguinz getting wacky in his room ua-cam.com/video/IZ4bm-ttVvE/v-deo.html
Bots show up:
"Why are we still here... just to suffer..."
"You remember GiIvaSunner, the channel you killed in cold blood?!"
"What does it matter to you, anyway?"
*"EVERYTHING!!!"*
I can't wait to see his channel come back just for the real Nintendo to send him right back to the shadow realm
Yikes dude
The fact that youtube so easily allowed an impersonator to do this for all these years
Good work, susan