Marwan Bishara on Nakba's legacy: 'Israel might have won, but the Palestinians have never lost'
Вставка
- Опубліковано 14 тра 2024
- Al Jazeera's Senior Political Analyst, Marwan Bishara, emphasizes the ongoing significance of Nakba Day, stressing the need for a solution to the continuous Palestinian crisis over the past 75 years. He criticizes Arab leaders' inaction in preventing a genocide unfolding before their eyes and underscores Palestinian resilience against Israeli dominance. Bishara questions the U.S.'s mixed signals on arms shipments to Israel, likening it to historical betrayals, and highlights the West's complicity and the misuse of antisemitism as a shield for supporting Israel.
Subscribe to our channel: bit.ly/AJSubscribe
Follow us on Twitter: / ajenglish
Find us on Facebook: / aljazeera
Check our website: www.aljazeera.com/
Check out our Instagram page: / aljazeeraenglish
Download AJE Mobile App: aje.io/AJEMobile
#Palestine #Gaza #Israel #GazaHumanitarianCrisis #GazaWar #IsraelHamasWar #IsraelGazaWar #Nakba #Nakba76 #WestBank NorthernGaza #SouthernGaza #NuseiratAttack #GazaDestruction #GazaUnderAttack #IsraelWar #Rafah #GazaBombardment #GazaRefugeeCamps #Jabalia #GazaCity #DeirElBalah
I would sell all the political commentators here in Germany for one Marwan Bishara. In a heartbeat.
As always, right on the money and so refreshing to hear Marwan’s perspective, analysis and insights.
So well said Marvan bishara
👍💯Agree
I am white and born in Australia and feel great sorrow and shame for what is happening here.
What is happening here is same as Australia{Britain} taking by force something which did not belong to them.
Same thing America {Britain} did to indigenous peoples.
Shame on you Britain and the USA and Australia.
Australia "prides" itself on multiculturalism but will not stand up and be counted and speak up for the oppressed.😢
Shame on us... The civilized world.
Free Palestine
Free Julian Assange
Silly comment. Are you going to sit still while aborigines rape your mom and sister "Because you're the descendant of someone who moved ot Australia?" Also drop missiles on Australian school children? What provisions are you prepared to make for the aborigines? Will you leave Australia "from the river to the sea?" From Perth to Sydney, Australia wilL be free.HEY, IT EVEN RHYMES. FREE AUSTRALIA! FREE MAKARR-YINDI!
Thank you so much Mr. Marwan Bishara and Al Jazeera correspondent for the great analysis. ❤❤❤❤❤
Great journalism like always marawaan bashara i just love listening to him from South Africa
Israël maybe won a piece of land. But Palestine won the hearts of the world 🌎 ♥️
The world will follow the coming One World Ruler; the Son of Perdition. Woe to the world.
Same here!🇺🇸
Just Like the n@zis in 1945
35000 won nothing 6 feet of dirt above ...
@EdwardZeind Says the one without a heart.. 😒
Now go back to your stolen land and let them dance if they want to.
Today "Haaretz" has an excellent article about the Nakba, the Green Line, and how Israeli governments have systematically dehumanized Palestinians and erased Palestinian culture as part of the Jewish state's structural racism.
There are no such people as palestinians and no such thing as palestinian culture unless you count a blind hatred of Israel and jews .
❤ Thank you !
'Palestinians have paid the real price of Holocaust ' that hits hard. Yes, they weren't the party to it but have been paying for it since decades. It's NOT their fault for what happened in Germany.
I agree with Mr. Marwan 100%
Philippines 🇵🇭 and India 🇮🇳 are angry at china 🇨🇳 for occupying disputed territory but support Israel 🇮🇱 brutal occupation of Palestine 🇵🇸
Double standards from Philippines 🇵🇭 and India 🇮🇳
Free Palestine 🇵🇸
What about china occupy Tibet south magnolia yunan Unger muslim Shame on you 😢😢😢😢😢
@@siddharthsharma8962 free Palestinian let's condemned zioniss regime and imperialism colonialism apartheid regime against innocent people.
Much love and respect Marwan, AJ and Palestinians!❤💚🖤🤍❤The injustice is so cruel and heartless and it's difficult to understand why people in power can't put a stop to this brutality, but it brings me to the conclusion that they're simply unwilling, because they're all traitors, deceivers, liars, murderers etc etc. God will act until then I pray for strength, courage and wisdom to endure. (I'm so so sad today, I want this brutality to stop once and for all).
Netanyahu the war criminal must be behind bars Netanyahu is the most dangerous person on earth .from South Africa 🇿🇦
Both Netanyahu and Biden are war criminal murder.
Actually I think Joe Biden is the most dangerous person on Earth, on his watch the world has descended into chaos.
And his henchmen!
calm down and go back to your tunnel
Go back to Poland
He is talking about Israel "winning" in the first Nakba by ethnically cleansing the Palestinians with no repercussions , he is not talking about them winning this current war. Don't feed the trolls.
Exactly! People comment without listen.
Where the 2 Mio Arabs in Israel coming from ?
@@Sp3ll633 Terrorist attacks on Arab countries carried by Israel to drive antisemitism against Arab Jews and then bring them into the country. I would tell you to read more but people like you don't clearly dont know how to.
Israel didn't win anything, the resistance has never been so powerful
Please join your fellow terror group, there's time for you to kill all the Jews.
Ah a display of black humor ,they don't laugh in rafah though..
Cope harder
POWERFUL WITH DEATHS AND POVERTY AND A DEPENDENCY SYNDROME OF WESTERN AID WITH A GENERATION CURSE
GENERATION CURSE IS A BAD SPIRIT WHICH CANT BE BROKEN
With the overwhelming evidence that the modern Jewish population is of Khazar origin, author Arthur Koestler remarks that this would clearly indicate that "their ancestors came not from the Jordan but from the Volga, not from Canaan but from the Caucasus, once believed to be the cradle of the Aryan race; and that genetically they are more closely related to the Hun, Uigur and Magyar tribes than to the seed of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob." This conclusion would then logically render the epithet "anti-Semitism" void of meaning, Koestler says.
I see Marwan, I click. Simple.
The war was between other Arab nations and US/UK backed Israel . Nakba was part of the reason why other Arab involved. But most of the Palestinians were not armed or militarized. So when these Arab nations decided to leave. They left these unarmed civilians basically at the mercy of Israel. The German should let the Jews take over Germany if they are so upset since it was them that caused the Holocaust. And US and UK cared so much they should give them a state to these Jews instead of giving a land Arabs lived on for thousand of years.
Most of the modern day conflicts are result of seeds of division planted by the British Empire that became unavoidable outbreak of violent human nature under a diabolical situation. It was the same situation for partition of India. USA just inherited British ways to continue these efforts.
the first colonies to america were from England, until they decided to fight for their freedom also
Egypt and Jordan came to the war at later time ,to save the West Bank and Gaza. but all that war Palestinians were the only one fighting 1948 war.
@@Amen.ahmed1 It was more like a riot. This is the problem with Zionists. They only remember themselves. Consider all many people have murdered by invaders including Chinese under Japanese, Chinese under Europeans, SE Asians under Europeans, Africans under Europeans, Caribbean under Europeans. India under British. Just the India, it was estimate 165 million died. I don't know why the Jews get special treatment other than for political reasons.
"In December 1947, the Jewish death toll was estimated at over 200, and, according to Alec Kirkbride, by 18 January 1948, 333 Jews and 345 Arabs had been killed while 643 Jews and 877 Arabs had been injured. The overall death toll between December 1947 and January 1948 (including British personnel) was estimated at 1,000 people, with 2,000 injured"
Each one of so called IDF massacres have killed more than the total death between 1947 and 1948. So somehow other people have to live peacefully. Israeli can go ahead can massacre civilians because they are special?
Cmon, the land was partitioned and the Arabs rejected the partition hence attacked Israil a day after it declared independence.. they're many videos and articles written by the attackers themselves giving their reason for the aggression which was that they couldn't stand a Jewish state besides them... They went in to annihilate a race not to save their people
No because Israel belongs there where the original kingdom of Israel was
The Nakba, too, has been downplayed and misrepresented, time and again, in the mainstream media across the world. And beyond that, it is in fact the official policy of the state of Israel to systemically and consistently deny Palestinian suffering. In fact, the whole Israeli settler colony is built on the denial of the very existence of a Palestinian people, let alone their Nakba.
Now unlike in 1948 the whole world can see the horror unfold in real time we can put pressure on our governments in the West to push for justice for Palestinians
Gaza has become the fortress of Stalingrad. When the Hitlerites occupied 90% of Stalingrad, they thought they were on the verge of winning the war and destroying the Soviet people. However, the Axis was handed a significant defeat at Stalingrad in February 1943, and in the subsequent 2 years the stunning Soviet victories including the Battle of Kursk Bulge, Operation Bagration, Vistula-Oder offensive and the final conquest of Berlin, resulted in the capitulation of Germany. The xyo-nist Fourth Reich will share the same fate as its predecessor.
You forget one thing ,Arabs will never ever in a million years will be like russian or german troops if that was the case israel would not be able to be 76 years .
If Israel fought with no restraints like the Germans or Japanese gaza could be decimated in less that a week you just flatten it
They are screaming starvation when they miss lunch and you compare that to stalingrad it's laughable !
They lost this war on day one already that is the reason of their agression
It's not going to help 35000 people .
Yeah palestine stood No chance
British mandate 1921 and Hagana forces committed killing and migrating Palestinian people to neighbouring countries for 27 years. The British army left Palestine 1948 after the UN 1948 approved the occupation of Palestine.
Palestinian people have for hundred years endured unjust genocide by the occupation.
Ocupation stopped in 2005 guess what palestinians did
@@NicolasHaufe It never stopped, just another Z lie!
@@NicolasHaufe Occupation stopped? What in the bad Hasbara is this? 😂 Honestly, if Israel continues infiltrating the US government and committing war crimes, our “friendship” may be coming to an end. I don’t care what land your imaginary friend promised you in your silly children’s book. You will follow international law, or you will cease to exist as a nation. The choice is yours, choose wisely.
@@NicolasHaufe Well, I guess you have yourself CONvinced... Reich?
@@NicolasHaufe According to Israel, they left. According to the UN and many others they are still occupying.
Great journalism like always marawaan
Somebody kindly said here, under a video, yesterday:
"How you justify that Palestinians are under Israeli oppression?"
Palestinians in Gaza have been under the control of Israel, Usa, some joint other countries for decades have applied terror, force on Palestinians.
Economic, financial, moral, and ungodly exploitation are on Palestinians now, too.
Israel totally pulled out of gaza in 2005.
Praying for peace in our troubled world. Free Palestine
NO PEACE WITH FREE PALESTINE
Free palestine from hamas
alla has planning, planning and still planning. But never got a plan for the last 75 years 😅😅😅
Peace and palestinians are 2 parallel lines ...
Power + Prejudice = oppression. The strength and character of the Palestinian people is a bright shinning torch to humanity, that no matter what we suffer we will not only survive but come out stronger. God will right all wrongs, Palestine will be free.
Thank you Mr Marwan Bishara.
Dear friends,
Peace be upon you,
I would like to share with you some thoughts about Islam and why I believe it is the right religion. Islam teaches us mercy, justice, and tolerance, values that are not limited to a specific group but encompass all humanity.
In Islam, we find clear guidance on every aspect of life, whether religious or worldly, providing us with an inspiring framework for peaceful and happy living.
Moreover, Islam encourages the pursuit of knowledge, critical thinking, and continuous learning, which fosters progress and development in society.
In the end, Islam gives individuals a sense of inner peace and contentment, offering guidance for living a meaningful and fulfilling life.
I hope you have understood some of the positive aspects of Islam, and I invite you to explore more about this compassionate and tolerant religion.
Thank you for listening.
Peace be upon you.
Yes. That is how I was brought up to understand Islam. When I came to this region from my country, I was shocked to hear, see, experience Hamas and similar groups operating against civilians in the name of Allah
Novara media and owen jones have been covering these issues in detail.
"They beat me - it didn't hurt me!"
"They were whipping me - and I didn't feel it!"
I've never met a single palestani person, but I know the pain, and what people needs to understand is that there's a difference even with the outcome of violence in terms of anger, fear, feelings, etc.. I lost my son and my kids mom to a bullet. My son was 17 and my kids mom was 31. In the united states. I dont know how to share alikes with people of palestine but I know 1 thing for 100% certain. We understand the will it comes with being a victim to the lowest of humanity and thats death. We speak same language with childrens who are too young to speak but express fear and wanting comfort. The cries of the pain knowing your son, daughter, husband, wife, etc..is a blessing but at the same time a commitment. I get it. I couldnt do anything but shed some tears when on this video he said over and over and over and over again. I understand how depressing it must be forisrael to get support but arab neighbors only talk a good game. As I always have said, if justice doesnt come soon the history will takeover and it will seek justice. History dont care about money or color, it just gives you what you have done. Palestine people have done something no one in my lifetime have done. If I am on a site I dont know about and commenting here right now than trust me, spiritually we are with you and people are putting their education, life, family, all aside to make sure we all do what we can all over the world. Keep pushing!
I agree. Our creator sees us as equals only by our deeds and actions. Of course, all children are innocent and I too am concerned this will come firing back on us in a very bad way. The suffering of the Palestinians is extremely hard to see
One Nakba
1947 - 2024
This is a truth power talk fro Mr. Marwan Bishara - so true
Great Analysis by Marwan. The Palestinians have refused to loose and they won't loose for the Israelis to win. In shaa Allaah NEVER.
Fantastic analysis
Thank you for your powerful insight and sober minded political analysis Marwan Bishara and Al Jazeera. ✌🏾❤️🇵🇸🙏🏾
No more nakaba. Palestine must be take back their land Between around the hypocrites.
Long live palestine 🇵🇸❤️
I love you, Marwan Bishara ❤️❤️❤️
All the news channels in the West combined couldn't produce one Marwan Bashar..
❤
Where can I find God ?
God is in the heart of the downtrodden because God suffers with the suffers ❤
Unfortunately, you're right, but the Palestinian is getting stronger day by day, alhumdullha !!!!❤❤❤❤🎉🎉🎉
Long Live Palestine,
Long Live As Sham.
Long live cognac and Cuban cigars !
the Nakba never ended it has only continued
❤🙏❤️
💯✌️✌️✌️ Resilience, is in the Palestinians DNA.
👍
May Allah grant victory to Palestine 🇵🇸😊
Good Luck with that...when will you people learn...your people are a circus😂
The objective of lsreal is the safety of lsreal.
Hamas no longer governs Gaza and there will always be occupation troops in Gaza because of October 7th.
(That information is from a confidential source.)
They plan ALLAH plan is best for phalistine brothers and sisters...ALLAH HU AKBAR
Free palastinia
Palestine is nothing more than a Roman fabrication.
Exploiting the widening rift between the US and Israel by maximizing diplomatic avenues would be the strategic approach, as opposed to emphasizing grievances. This may be Palestine's greatest opportunity for progress with the West.
Some GCC are the problems for sake their chair
Allah protect my brother and sister Palestine
The current assault on the Palestinian people is bringing the horrors of 1948 to people who didn't really know about it before.
Palestine will win is a grantees from lord and also Palestine are not like coward
STOP! We are with Palestine 🇵🇸 but it has NOTHING to do with a god. Be THANKFUL that HUMANS from EVERYWHERE have empathy and support. Remember that the Zionists are saying that "the Lord" gave the land to them... AGAIN, be thankful that the world is not putting a god in the equation.
Palestine is nothing more than a Roman invention. It's called Judea and Samaria. Israel was, is and will be and there is nothing a flunky like you can do about it!
Very shame for Arab some countries
Especially uae
OTHER ARABS DONT WANT TO.DEPEND ON HANDOUT FOODAID LIKE THE ARABS IN WEST BANK AND GAZA
THEY WANT PROSPERITY NOT POVERTY
@@merhabatube219 UAE is RICH BY TURNING A DESERT INTO A MEGA CITY.COMPLEX
NOT.GAZA THEY TURN THE STRIP.INTO A WAR ZONE
TWO DIFFERENT MINDSETS
Before loosing a war America dropped two nuclear bombs on Japan. This time they are again preparing the world that after this genocide, loosing land is not an option. So are they really going for nuclear attack 🤔???
I completely agree with the comment. And I add: the glorious Palestinian people will never be defeated no matter how many unfair and unequal battles Israel wins and how many times Western countries will support the present and future catastrophes.
We should prevent "future catastrophies". Or do you think to continue the armed resistance?
In solidarity with the palestinian people who has been subjected to a suffocating occupation for decades.
Marwan has lost his intellect of analyst. He hasn't predicted anything valuable or new. He just repeats the news. There is no indepth analysis like when he was younger and more on the ball. It's like he is afraid to speak the reality.
It's beyond understanding how isre lis are heartless dehumanized society
This is the equivalent of the nazis saying they are the victim in 1945 even though they started the war
The xyo-nist Fourth Reich started the whole conflict in 1948 and started the current war in October.
@@v-corps okay Goebels
what if this was the other way around, giving aid to israel and giving arms to palestine. especially after the holocaust taking place and continuous suffering of those people. what kind of condition does a person’s heart and spirit have to be in to do such things. clearly not sensible and it’s like being the good bad guy
Free Palestine!
I pray one day the Palestinian people have peace and their own land free of Israeli persecution.
this all about trusting USA in all issues , that is mad.
Politician only personal interest
As Marwan says, antisemitism is banned in the West. Unfortunately Israel has exploited this to conflate Israel with Judaism, therefore any criticism of Israel = antisemitism.
Everyone was saying Israel 🇮🇱 was losing.
Israel hat unheimlich viel verloren.
Das kommt mit der Zeit zum Vorschein.
There is only ONE state. That is Palestine only. How can UK give a piece of land of Palestine to the jews ? Who are they to give ? Bcos of this , the war. Not only here they have done it in India Pakistan border re Kashmir. My opinion is that both UK and USA should be taken expelled from the UN and not allowed to Police the other countries affairs.
🔻🔻🔻🔻🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🍉🍉🍉
Arrest criminal netanyahu now !
Palestaine fight for justice and rights
Palestine have won the heart of the world❤❤
Long life Palestinian InshaAllaah 🇪🇭 😪 ya Allah please help Palestinian people and blessing safe and protect them from evil Zionism
Bush lives on fantasy island……this crushing defeat will set Hummus back 100 years
Shame on Israel! Free Palestine 🇵🇸
Free palestine from hamas shame on palestinians for electing n@zi hamas
Loosing a war savages doesn't make you a victim.
It's worse than the Holocaust
Arab nations started the war of 1948 and told the Palestinians to leave their own homes. Israel responded and won. The suffering of the Palestinians are the sole responsibility of the Arab nations who should take in the refugees. Stop blaming Israel.
"The Palestinian people does not exist. The creation of a Palestinian state is only a means for continuing our struggle against the state of Israel for our Arab unity. In reality today there is no difference between Jordanians, Palestinians, Syrians and Lebanese. Only for political and tactical reasons do we speak today about the existence of a Palestinian people, since Arab national interests demand that we posit the existence of a distinct 'Palestinian people' to oppose Zionism. "For tactical reasons, Jordan, which is a sovereign state with defined borders, cannot raise claims to Haifa and Jaffa. While as a Palestinian, I can undoubtedly demand Haifa, Jaffa, Beer-Sheva and Jerusalem. However, the moment we reclaim our right to all of Palestine, we will not wait even a minute to unite Palestine and Jordan." - (PLO executive committee member Zahir Muhsein, in a 1977 interview with the Dutch newspaper Trouw.
I pity the innocent in Israel if their are any
There Sure arent any in gaza
Hey Marwan, someone should tell u that before it was, as u call it, "the land of Palestine", it was actually THE LAND OF ISRAEL!!
Palestinian never lost? Lol all the cry me a river comments suggest otherwise.
Excellent analysis but it’s real shame on Arabs who are not saving Palestine.
Stop spamming the "subscribe to al Jazeera" at the end of every video. Every time i see it, i thumbs down the video. You are supposed to be concerned with the environment. Tacking that at the end of every video takes up gigabytes online, & uses more electricity per user. U r hurting the planet with that useless waste. Correct your green footprint & stop it. Everyone's intelligent enough to know how to subscribe. Stop talking to us like we are in kindergarten.
Inshaallah Pleastine will be free
In 10 years the world will forget these little palistinians.But israel will live on in victory in supremecy. Gaza will be ruled by us jews
Don’t start war nothing is nice is war
Boring
Shame on the ummah 😡
When they stop the free food they will take the L.. That aint far away now..
I am Jewish and support a Free Palestine. Share the Holy Land with the Jews.
You can always count on Marwan the clown for a good laughter, but usually you have to listen to the nonsense he talks, this time you just need to read the title
Why don't Al Jazeera dont talk about the Arab and moslems that are also complicit in the genocide like their own regime what did the Arab and Moslem leaders do NOTHING
😂palestine
1000 years of Raj over Lhindoostan 😂😂
Of course the Palestinians have lost. The Nakba, the catastrophe, is that the arabs LOST by majority vote in the UN, (every arab state voting against the state of Israel,) and the arabs refused to accept the decision of the majority vote. Is that democracy? That you get to start a war if you lose in the vote?
The Nakba is that a group of human beings (giving them the benefit here,) has refused to accept reality. As a group, the Palestinians have lived as refugees rather than moving on and creating new lives. Of course, some arabs HAVE moved on. Some palestinians are living in Dearborn. Some are doctors in the USA. The grandmother of Mossab Yousef moved to a city near Ramallah and made a successful life for herself. Try making a contribution to the civilized world. Plenty of other displaced persons have moved on, including the Jews.
Anti-semite
So who decided that there was to be a vote? Who decided to give British control of the region? So you say democracy? By who? You don't think middle eastern peoples vote should weigh more than anyone else local people should just give up and pack up and leave where they have lived for 500+ years so European jewish people who changed their names to Hebrew names can claim a homeland statehood that their ancestors never came from Palestine. Just because you call yourself jewish doesn't give you any special rights to anything.
Also so it's a democracy because a religious group of people who's life is screwed up because of other countries screwed them over so thees countries decided to dump this religious group of people into a area that was given control of by these same groups of countries and this religious group is given the go ahead to screw over the people who have lived in the given land from the beginning of time. Ya your brainwashed democracy.
@@joeearley3351 I guess it comes down to the rule of force. Except when the arabs are losing. Then they want "humanitarian aid"? I'd say that's a bad joke. One side gets to use the rule of force since you don't respect "majority rules" (and maybe you have good reason not to?) But then you don't get to CLAIM majority rules when you are IN the majority. Get it?
@@joeearley3351 I think your point is valid, as far as it goes. It was terribly unfair for the arabs living in what is now Israel to be asked to do, rather "forced to do", what no other country was willing to do after The Holocaust". On the other hand, there were over a million "displaced persons" in 1945 who had lived for hundreds of years in towns and villages all over Europe who couldn't go back to their legitimate homes. (Some did and were killed by the people now living in those homes. For those people it was accept "the homeland" you were offered or die. Who is going to choose "die"? Of course you are aware that Jews also lived in Israel before The Holocaust and those Jews had as legitimate a right to be there as any people living anywhere on Earth while the arabs living there also exercised "ethnic cleansing of Jews" to the extent they could, even before The Holocaust. Both sides have a legitimate claim to the land. Enter the rule of force (that always prevails. Remember what Stalin said? How many divisions does the Pope have?")
This man who was born in Israel enjoyed all the benefit and now against the state of Israel...Shame on him,if he is brave enough let him come back to Israel,he will be arrested at Ben Gurion Airport..!
The land is Palestinian. The Nazis (present-day xya-nists) occupied and annexed other people's lands, that doesn't mean that land was Germany.
Eretz Israel! Land of Israel 🇮🇱 ❤❤❤