Rachel Shabi explains why journalists use figures from Gaza Health Ministry in reporting
Вставка
- Опубліковано 28 лют 2024
- “That's how basic journalism works. I am sorry you keep throwing shade on that. It's really insulting.”
Journalist and author Rachel Shabi and Natasha Hausdorff, the legal director of UK Lawyers for Israel, clashed over the use of figures reported by the Gaza Health Ministry on the number of Palestinians killed in Gaza, during their appearance on 'The World' show on Sky News.
Shabi said, “When we take figures from the Gaza Health Ministry, it is because those figures have checked out in the past. They checked out in 2008. They checked out in 2014. They checked out in 2012.”
Subscribe to our channel: ow.ly/AVlW30n1OWH
Subscribe to MEE Telegram channel to stay up to date: t.me/MiddleEastEye_TG
Middle East Eye Website: middleeasteye.net
Follow us on TikTok: / middleeasteye
Follow us on Instagram: / middleeasteye
Like us on Facebook: / middleeasteye
Follow us on Twitter: / middleeasteye
Anybody worth any "salt" will find Israel has always done the opposite of what this Nutasha said
Brilliant and very true!
People worth their salt AND without a selfish agenda, are already shredding Israeli lies into bits, at the ICJ.
This lady, Natasha is working overtime to be praised by Israel for spewing non-sense.
"Anybody worth their kosher salt" is what she meant to say
Oh, is that why there are so many Jews today? Because of their aggression?
When she said any “international lawyer worth their salt” what she really meant was any international lawyer on our payroll
She's a lawyer?????? She should be disbarred! Disgraceful propagandist!
You have to sell your soul to defend Israel.
No normal human can justify there fascist crimes.
Got it one Emily!
Keir Starmer is a human rights lawyer allegedly so being a lawyer doesn’t make you a moral person far from it…just makes you a well paid liar
@AodhanBeag couldn't agree more! He's proven he has no regard for human rights, international law, the prevention of genocide or UK law.
She's a part of UKLFI - UK Lawyers for Israel. Basically a hack of person
the lies this natasha tells is absolutely despicable. “bombing fleeing civilians” absolutely DERANGED
Rachel Shabi is lying more then breathing
I have seen them do this before: slander and throw out an accusation , when the point is addressed and fended off, they don’t even acknowledge their error. They move on to the next attack.
Exactly. Because, if the numbers don't check out, then why, could South Africa use these numbers at the icy jay AS EVIDENCE and fact ! They compiled thousands of pages of evidence.
Lol , I see facts have got you deranged. The Goldstone report clearly evidenced Palestinian civilians being targeted by the murderous IDF
A liar and a long nose. A warning sign from nature 🤥🤥
Natasha is a liar. I mean lawyer
same same
😂😂😂😂
A lie-yer
Hey! I saw what you did there 🤣🤣🤣
Should have written that Natasha is a lawyer, I mean a liar 😂
Natasha Hausdorff - UK lawyers for Israel. Please remember this vile name.
Remember your own vile name.
There is an Australian group of "Lawyers for Israel". They got a journalist sacked because she dared share a tweet from Human Rights Watch that was critical of Israel.
@@RogerRocks
That's true...emails have been revealed where they celebrate her termination and laugh about how easy it all was..
Several months before the current conflict UK Lawyers for Israel pressured a London Hospital into taking down artwork from children in Gaza that they had been displaying on their walls.
Oh I will remember her, but that's only cos I fancied her badly!!! Incredibly sexy babe. Long thin face, long nose and gorgeous straight hair. Typical Jewish features, but who cares? ❤❤❤❤❤
Rachel Shabi is a legend. Her book is incredible too.
Nah, it's israeli propaganda.
Shows the Ashkenazi Zionist are the issue, cannot even get along with Mizrahi
Thank you, Rachel. You did well dealing with this genocide-enabling gaslighter.
Rachel Shabi is lying more then breathing
They don’t like Rachel because she’s an anti-Zionist Iraqi Jew, who despite being born in Israel she revoked that citizenship and is a British national.
Natasha ... I can smell your bs from here !
You are all
Liars😊
@@anthonyblake9125 zeo's? Definitely.
Natasha works for a company called "UK lawyers for Israel" ffs. I don't think we can take anything she says seriously at all.
She is a Jew , not only uk lawyer
corruption and cover ups
There is nothing wrong with being Jewish but there is a problem about lying about Israeli war crimes. @@Sword_and_Crown
Why don’t you just quote the protocols and get it over with?
It is worth listening to these peoples’ arguments to see how they think. They are not interested in humanity or decency. It’s all “speak with a forked tongue” stuff.
She could not answer to the arguments and facts, started talking about Palestinians killing own people. What a shame.
A lie the Israelis love telling. She’s just a species of Hasbara.
Thats what weasels do
Cause its not even true
Biach mistook IDF for Hamas. It was diaper helicopter force that fired on own civilians on oct7.
... In colossal danger, only He can save you, none can compare
"Only the Creator Can Save You
Already in a grave calamity, yet you cannot see
Only by returning to tradition can you be saved and washed clean
You are harming yourself with modern notions and conduct
The red demon deceives you with atheism and evolution
Formation, stability, degeneration, and disintegration are laws-the cosmos is dissolving
Humans and Gods are all in danger, no one feels secure
Most people are Gods incarnate, coming here to take refuge
Awaiting the Creator to renew the cosmos and save all beings
In colossal danger, only He can save you, none can compare
December 10, 2017"
Master Li Hongzhi (Hong Yin VI, from Falun Dafa teachings)
Her spewing those broken record talking points to justify a genocide is why #AaronBushnell lit himself on fire.
People who can’t think of any words, resort to laughing hysterically, if only through emojis, Charmaine Carstens
the usa has troops in gaza, they are not only supplying weapons but also soldiers.
@@CatherinePearl100 emojis seem to be the only thing Y/T doesn't delete
Welcome to the batshit crazy world of Palestinian fandom, where objectively verifiable facts are airily dismissed as “broken record talking points”.
No, he did that because America won't stop the extermination campaign.
Natasha is claiming to be some sort of military expert yet has never even been to Gaza or probably seen a gun for that matter. She is clueless and has absolutely no evidence to support her baseless claim, yet she calls herself a lawyer. What a clown she is.
Have you been to Gaza?
@@user-cx3qi2te8khave you?
@@user-cx3qi2te8k He probably hasn't been to Gaza, but most, if not all, of the public figures who stand with Palestine have been to Gaza and therefore know the truth.
@@user-cx3qi2te8k Natasha is a paid mouth.
Plus some military experts have spoken out as well. None that went to Gaza themselves, I believe, but they're really stacking the evidence against Israel at this point
Shame on Natasha!
She like many others, have no shame. It’s cultural.
Yup! I’m the same! Being called “shame!” by people with completely different values, I can easily disregard it. I love my life and who cares about what others say about their problems are.
@@babykoda4752 shame is a society construct. Being shameless in a society that values honesty and integrity makes you a your people outcasts.
@@babykoda4752 dont lie. If you would be able to "completely disregard" why do you have to post your opinion on this. As it seems youre still attached to that phrase. To have a decency Shame is something wonderful, because without shame you will be able to slaughter 15000 children. The highest counts of children deaths ever in a war in such a short time period and this is way worse than any "terrorist" group was able to but Israhell keeps continuing. So babykoda shame on you for your insensitive comment.
@@jchan9761 very happy either way!
She's the director of 'UK Lawyers for Israel'. Asking her about Israel is like asking the devil to condemn himself
Director of liars
more like asking himler whats happens in the camps
@@rafsanstudent3792Wow, you’re seriously going to invoke the holocaust and compare Jews to Himler?
Regardless of what you think about this war, that’s an absurdly small-minded thing to do.
C’mon do better. This kind of argument does not help anyone.
@@ProVisionColor nah if the chosen doesn't be wanna called no no germs then simply don't act like one - Norman fricklestien. Words changed because youtube
@@rafsanstudent3792 Act like one? Do you have any idea what you are saying? You must not, because if you did, that would truly make you small minded, and I hope that’s not what you really are. Concentration camps, gas chambers, unbelievable illegal medical experiments on children. This war is awful, but comparing Jews to Himler is just ridiculous.
Rachel has dropped FACTS!
@@assafbin7532 😂😂😂😂 so everything Rachel is saying is a lie?
@@assafbin7532 at this point you zio-naz1 lovers are just projecting
@@Impartialguy786Yep. Anybody worth any salt would know she is lying... sorry, bullshitting.
Nobody in their right mind dropping bombs with total equivalent 3x nuclear bomb and then said they minimize civilian casualties.
Face it... More than half of buildings in gaza is flattened. If as she said Israel done selective targetting, then their target is actually civilian. Unless they claim all of the victim is hamas..wait some of Isra3l fan boy did say that...which means G3nocide.
YES 99% of it @@Impartialguy786
@@Impartialguy786Quite literally, YES!
The gaslighting is so irritating and infuriating. It's insane
Wait so do you deny Hamas killing it's own people via rocket misfire. Or shootung at fleeing civilians. Or Hamas kids with guns? Double counting bodies. Triple counting them. This is all part of Hamas strategy.
1. Haifa Massacre 1937
2. Jerusalem Massacre 1937
3. Haifa Massacre 1938
4. Balad al-Sheikh Massacre 1939
5. Haifa Massacre 1939
6. Haifa Massacre 1947
7. Abbasiya Massacre 1947
8. Al-Khisas Massacre 1947
9. Bab al-Amud Massacre 1947
10. Jerusalem Massacre 1947
11. Sheikh Bureik Massacre 1947
12. Jaffa Massacre 1948
13. Deir Yassin Massacre - 1948
14. Qibya massacre -1953
15.Tantura Massacre - 1948
16. qibya massacre -1953
17. Khan Yunis Massacre 1956
18. Jerusalem Massacre 1967
19. Bahro Al Baquar in 1972
20. Sabra and Shatila Massacre 1982
21. Al-Aqsa Massacre 1990
22. Ibrahimi Mosque Massacre 1994
23. Jenin Refugee Camp April 2002
24. Gaza Massacre 2008-09
25. Gaza Massacre 2012
26. Gaza Massacre 2014
27. Gaza Massacre 2018-19
28. Gaza Massacre 2021
29. Gaza Genocide 2023 is still ongoing.
SO DON'T LET ANYONE TELL YOU IT STARTED ON OCTOBER 7th
OVER 75 YEARS OF PALESTINIAN OPPRESSION
PLEASE REPOST
Well documented. Let the whole World know the truth
It goes back further to the first Zionist groups who between 1870 and 1890 ethnically cleansed 20 Palestinian towns and then bragged about how they had created 20 100% Jewish towns.
Zionism is terrorism. Always has been, for over 150 years.
And they never learned? By your account the Middle East must be only a huge cemetery with so many deaths.
Thank you ❤
Wow this is clearly what they like to coverup!
"gone way and above" to protect civilians like Hind Rajab, her family and the ambulance. She's a lawyer, she knows you can't lie in court but this is tv
I bet she has no problem lying in court too.
Wow that's like... Five people. The tragedy. That's genocide! 😱
@@TrollAxeThrower - That is not very funny at all.
@@mattbrown3549 it is funny a whole army is trying to save women and children from captivity, and you guys focus on collateral damage caused by hamas themselves.
@@TrollAxeThrowerare you serious right ??? There are Captives are in both sides
Watching this after viewing what Israel just did to 77 civilians waiting for aid trucks..
Numbers are now higher at 118.
The figures from the ministry are so accurate even the IDF uses them. But let the lady go on.
Wrong. They have no other option than to use them.
@@danielahuchaogu572Ah yes because people who exposed for lying about ߣh€ąďəď👶ies and the amount of casualties from the 7th (went from 3k, RETRACTED then to 1200), lied about a hospital calendar being h@m@$ shift schedule, lied about ammunition in Al Shifa, lied about a!ř$țŕ!çķ!ñģ an ambulance and claimed it was full of combatants but it was exposed they were ALL civilian.. so on so forth.. have no choice but NOT to trust themselves to report accuracy.
@@danielahuchaogu572Incorrect. Israel record their own civilian casualty figures whenever they hit a major target. They don’t care enough to count civilians killed alongside minor targets, though they are aware of how many civilians are likely to be killed or injured before every strike.
*** Edit ***
Since the revelation in the +972 magazine about Israel’s “Lavendar” and “Where’s Daddy” A.I. programmes which select targets and aims to kill them in their own homes (in civilian areas rather than at military facilities), it’s now known that up to 20 civilians per target is often permissible by the idf for minor targets, and about 100 civilian casualties has been approved for at least one major target.
It’s wild, this whole thing about disputing the numbers is a new thing that only started after Oct 7 and they actually STOPPED disputing them and quietly started accepting them, and yet you still have psychos like this lady who keep the propaganda the IDF has already moved on from alive.
@@danielahuchaogu572They actually use them. Then cut the numbers of women and children to claim every male deaths are Hamas!
That woman interviewer is vile.
She is not the interviewer. They are both guests. The interviewer didn’t appear in this clip.
Special place in hell for these kinds of liars
Natasha lies shame on you
It's a zionist thing. You won't understand.
The Western world is the main reason why the Palestinians are not considered worthy enough of basic human compassion, the constant distorting of Hamas run health ministry figures, children's deaths, men, women's deaths and injuries resulting from the bombarding of Gaza is downplayed & minimised even spoke of as righteous by some in the media. The Pro Palestinian protests were even reported as in support of Hamas at the beginning of the war.
This has really opened my eyes to the reality of life.
Now you have a glimps of how to spot the despots and liars, keep looking, reality is not what you thought it was.
Mine too. I’m 60, and am only seeing in the past five months that almost everything I thought I knew about the world, and my country the US, has been lies.
@@CatherinePearl100I was aware from my teenage years and I am the same age as you. I was a CND marcher in the early 80s and it opened my eyes to the lies of the media and politicians, as did the brutalisation of lawfully striking miners by the police, again with the support of the overwhelmingly right wing media.
Yep this is lifting the scales from a lot of people's eyes, including the American working class, who can't even afford housing in their own country while they pay for weapons to allow settler terrorists to steal houses from Palestinians.
I don't understand why, but "the establishment" loves Israel and will bend over backwards for it. Only the fact that we get news very quickly these days by sources outside the mainstream media saves us from not knowing what is really happening and blindly believing that Israel is a nice country fighting a just war.
Get we get toilet paper with her face on it ?
I still cannot believe that people still believe that Israel is innocent!!!
The cheek of this Natasha person.. the mind boggles.
Look at both their faces, and you'll know the liar even if you never heard of Palestine or Israel before.
Wow! Natasha must have recieved a heavy check. Would love to see those figures, since she doesn't believe in any other figures.
3 nuclear bombs??She has no idea what a nuclear bomb and it's devastation is.Very ignorant
When you hear it pronounced as "chhamas" , you should immediately know the person saying it is absolutely without a doubt compromised
The lies go on and on and on
May God mete out justice to these shameless liars , may God bless those who stand for the truth and humanity
My God the restraint that woman showed from keeping her hands off that creatures neck was incredible.
That lawyer is like: ‘Turbo lie: ENGAGE!’
Precision targeting?? They razed Gaza to the ground. More than 100,000 Palestinians have already been killed and wounded, and the worst thing is that in a few days even more will die of hunger and thirst, which was imposed on purpose by Israel. This is a complete disrespect to the viewers! People like this Natasha think that this kind of rhetoric can still pass. So let her think again!
Did she just say precession targeting by Isreal? RIDICULOUS LIE.
Humiliation does not mean anything to these Israili puppets.
هل لا حظتم ،،?ملامح من يدافعون عن غزة جميلة ومريحة للعين ووجوه من يدافعون عن الصهاينة سامة وقليحة
Actually she is pretty but after the speech , the brain filter the pretty into ugly.
Who is bombing Gaza?
Who has dropped 40,000 bombs in Gaza?
Who?Who?
@@waltermesser9737
Are you a joker?
The IDF has killed 30,000 people and you are playing games?
Who started the war and took baby hostages and elderly hostages?
@@joseffinn5836
That is not a reason to kill 30,000 people and wound 100,000 and destroy 159000 homes
@@joseffinn5836 These arabs never learn.
"NO YOU MAY NOT!!!..." strong woman!!.. that's how it is being done!!!! good job!!
And she still carried on talking over her the rude b*tch
God Natasha mindlessly repeating hasbara without proof
Incredible 🤔
This is how oppressors cling on to a narrative, aggressively gish-galloping. Then just straight up lying. If nothing works and you check mate them, bring out the A-word.
The US president disputed the matter -this may not count as important figure
you do realize he’s a proven liar, right?
Thank you Rachael. We’re with you.
You can’t fix stupid!
You know for yourself?
A text book Narcissist? How smoothly & swiftly she tried to lie there with no conscience.
What she thinks people are blind or what?
Seems like she's living in some alternative reality within her own mind & trying to convince her false belief.Just like the izra elis.
Props to the guest for answering with befitting reply & facts!!
Why invite someone if you don’t let them speak why try to put them down under your lie I can understand they pay you but not that’s mean you insult someone with your lie
Rachel Shabi 👏 👏 👏 👏. May God reward you in this life and the next for standing up for truth and justice.
Rachel, we all see it too. Thanks for standing up for the victims, and staying firm through that gust of lies from that 'lawyer'.
OMG this is no journalism😢
Did she really say that Hms has been taking out its own civilians? What about all the videos of ‘the world’s most cowardly army’ taking down a grandmother, a middle aged man, their own surrendering hostages, and even three sheep?
No, Hamas no. And you believe in Santa Claus, Easter Bunny. etc.
@@waltermesser9737 You can speak whatever nonsense you want, but the truth about this cowardly, undisciplined, sadistic military is witnessed by their own tiktoks.
@@ahmeda.3198 You are responding this post in front of a mirror?
@@ahmeda.3198 And by the way, what is happening is what your people choose - you started this and now buah! buah! buah! Be a man and take responsability for your mistakes.
@@waltermesser9737 You don’t know anything about me or who my people are.
Meanwhile the whole world is seeing how absolutely cowardly, sadistic and depraved the IDF is. They took out their own surrendering hostages. Without a doubt they captured it on an unreleased TikTok.
The whole world is also seeing how deranged and fanatical the settlers are. Never seen people so gleeful to be causing suffering to others. It’s one thing when the IDF does it, but when random civilians show up at the border to stop aid, and they make it a family event with DJ stands and bouncey castles, it reveals a whole new level of national pathology.
"The US president disputes them", oh that means he must be right
Classic malicious bad faith appeal to authority
Wtf??
When you have to talk while another already is, it can only be to impede them. She could’ve waited for her to finish.
How deranged one can be? Natasha be like - hold my horses.
Israhell nazionis
Her hallucinations level even far beyond her expectation...speechless!
2:14 no they didnt the UN called them out for breaking over 50 international laws. Do you realise how crazy that number is?
it's quite small actually, which is kinda sad
Is that Fräulein Genocide sincerely trying to persuade someone to not to believe his own eyes after 4+ months of such a monstrosities filmed?
Natasha backwards is “ah Satan.” Nuff said.
😂
😂😂😂❤😂😂😂
😂😂😂😂😂
Are these spokespersons open to lawsuits against them? I think we need to collectively start taking these goebbels to court
Natasha is despicably evil.
c e a s e f i r e n o w
“I have not finished yet”
“I have not finished”
Try to divert her from saying fact !
"I asked you a question! Don't interrupt me by trying to answer my question! This is journalism!"
Is it? Because if this is what journalism is now, maybe it needs a severe overhaul.
🇵🇸🇵🇸💔💔🇵🇸🇵🇸
Natasha, you dxmb as rocks if you think that Biden disputing anything makes it a concern. That guy disputes his own existence every morning. He probably thinks he's a little girl rn.
imagine saying 'the u.s president said it' as though those multiple illegal war crimes perpetrators have any honestly
Not even IDF claim what Natasha just vomited out of her mouth.
The Nazis lost so will the Zionists Nazis
Dream, dream, dream!
@@waltermesser9737 thats what the Nazi's were doing .. Dreaming... Delusional
@@waltermesser9737 wake up cos your (delusional) dream is coming to an end …
Who is this idf torture company spokeswoman and why does she have a tv show ?
Lying is like second nature to them
2:03 She has the audacity to bring up international law. The occupiers are Israel, under occupation international law is clear. In fact just days ago 63 countries were invited to speak on the occupation and 60 sided with Palestinians being under occupation. The occupied nation (Palestine) under international law has the right to armed resistance. While the occupier (Israel) has no right to cite self defense. The only reason why Israel isn't being held accountable is United States.
Absolutely... end of story.
We interview you but we won't let you talk about those we don't want our audiences know . Our job is spreading the false news and misleading the world.
Exactly what they did with Natasha!
do you really call yourself a Lawyer Natasha. A Lawyer of Lies
They always talk about the “poor Palestinian women and children”, but never about the bloodthirsty Jihadists fighting their little religious war against anyone they deem as an enemy.
They didnt even include those buried in the rubble listing them as missing. Lawyer what lawyer? parotting all the IDF claims and assertions as fact without the need to fact checking them.
I thought i read that the brilliant journalist Ms Rachel Shabi is of Jewish descent herself ? If that is so then what she is saying here is even more profound in bravery . Would this make her an anti Israel / jew with her comments ?
No I'm an Essene indeed she is blessed and we stand with her...we as Essenes stand with non zionist Jews whether they believe in Yeshua or not...zionist jews are not welcome and no better but much lower then pharisees...Essenes forever the true Jews and followers of Yeshua forever...we will support her no matter the cost and we have paid a high price everyday for being Essene until this very day...all non zionists welcome...
She's an Israeli jew. Born in Ramat Gan.
They would call her a ‘self-hating Jew’. Meaningless phrase.
Anti Zionist, this isn't about Judaism, this is about a terrorist ideology named Zionism.
Yep... theres lots of Jews critical of Israel.... and lots who have left because of the political situation. Cant blame tham can you?
Wow like the IOF ain't bombing Gaza and their own hostages. "But October 7" and "Hhhamas".... Getting old y'all!
Thanks
Natasha sounds so desperate to slander the facts given by a true journalist. Mind you are a lawyer, if you make claims where is you evidence and fact sheet?
Edit : A 3D animation that I myself can do is not credible evidence.
Luv the profile pic.
You an antisemite luv?
If this kind of people incharge the world operation, we will sure all living in the burning hell.
Natasha is complicit in those war crime by knowingly throwing shade on facts, it is only a matter of role in this crime scene
Hamas no?
@@waltermesser9737 you equate facts with fiction?
This Shabi woman equates fact with fiction if she trusts a terror groups figures...
I mean they don't even provide shelter to their own ppl, and steal their aid....
The Gazans blame Hamas for their wretched situation, why don't you?
What planet is she from??
No one believes that the occupier follows any laws. Not in 1948 and not since then, ever!!
Don't know why they waste their time with these type of robots
I didn't realise that there were slaves in the media, weird.
Thank you for sharing to the world
Why nobody prosecute her in the UK?
0:30 talking like the US President is a reliable authority to dispute any information. Dude could even dispute his own name. 🤣
Way above... like even bulldozering graves?
Whenever you on the right path. They will try cut you off and distract you
🥇🏆🌹She is always cool on this subject.😎👌👍
And they ask us to believe the source from likud, iof?
And Netanyahu and his people wonder why they have been hated around the world....for years....
Can you blame Europeans for not wanting them after WW2?
Both these women are Jewish.... so which stereotype are you highlighting?
I love how she says "any lawyer worth their salt" preemptively because she knows the vast majority of them will claim otherwise, so this is a way to filter those who don't fit her narrative.
Yeah, it's effectively "the only people you should listen to are those that support my claims"
How can these demons still go in public and spread lies, when every human being on earth knows they are lying?
For God's sake they they killed their own hostages and admitted that!!!
It’s so disgusting how she gets she gets aggressive and wants to beat you down if your not her opinion! Typical!!!
Lies originate from two things: low self-esteem and low self-respect
Are those gonna be held accountable? It's up to us people to make sure they are.