박희아님 진행 좋아요. 안정적인 목소리 톤에서 위안을 받고, 팬들이 느끼는 방탄 음악의 차별된 서사와 창의적인 면을 강조해 주셔서 너무 공감 됐습니다. 보컬 전문가이신 두 분의 설명이 더해져 음악적 분석을 이해하며 앨범을 더 재밌게 들을 수 있게 되었어요. 이런 전문적인 음악방송 참 좋네요.
this was so fun and interesting to watch i didnt mind how long it was didn't felt long either thank you so much for doing your research well it was well explained. thank you for eng subs too
Swag? Louder Than Bombs? Just no. They talk about their pain. They talk about the fans’ pain behind the bright smiles we show the boys that they became aware of through letters etc. The lyrics, the melody, the delivery of the vocals and rap, it all fit so well with the theme of pain. How on earth did you manage to see swag in this song...
Thanks for the eng subs so international ARMYs like me can enjoy your review. One thing though, I’m not sure how Louder than Bombs is a swag song..It shows their pain as artists, but it has a progression too. In the end no matter what hardship and pain they go through they will continue to sing for us. Will watch part 2!
Louder than bombs 물론 윤기 랩부분에서 스웩곡이라고 생각할수도 있어요. 정말 그 부분 가사 자체만 보면요. 하지만 이건 정말 가슴아프고 눈물나는 곡이에요 아미들은 다 알겁니다. 방탄이 아미를 볼때 팬들은 행복한 표정을 짓고있지만 우리 모두가 힘든일, 아픔은 누구나 있잖아요. 남준이가 팬들의 표정이 그 표정이 아니었구나 라는걸 깨달은 데서 시작된 곡이에요. 팬들의 쏟아지는 아픔들에 자신은 폭탄소리보다 더 크게 부서져간다고 해요. 아미와 방탄은 슬픔과 고통을 함께 느낀다고 말하면서요. 그래도 두려워하지 말하고 포기하지 말라고 어떤 파도가 덮쳐도 방탄은 아미를 향해 노래할거라고 방탄 스스로와 팬들에게 다짐하는 가사입니다. 너무 고맙고 눈물나는 그런 곡이죠.. 조금 가볍게 언급하고 지나가는 감이 없지 않아 있어서 곡의 의미 대략적으로 적고갑니다.
Thank you so much for making this video and review! It is very insightful, especially as an international fan, to learn about the Korean perspective of BTS' music. I feel that North American music reviews differ a lot (or perhaps I just have not seen the right ones). Here you touch on such subtle and delicate nuances of the album that most may not grasp. I loved to hear your thoughts on the reasoning and meanings behind each musical component- be it the vocals, lyrics, composition, mixing or arrangement. Truly enlightening!
Yeah. They latched onto Yoongi’s part and forced it into a swag meaning. Did they even listen to the rest of the song? They didn’t have much to say about it...
ikr. It's like the most painful song there is in the album. And the lyrics of yoongi about "if it's not us, then who else can go this way?" was not a flex for me. It was like them accepting their fate, and their responsibility as a celebrity and sacrificing themselves so that they can comfort others. It's a very sad line for me.
I enjoyed it alot. Thank you so much for this. Your analysis and positive comments makes me feel proud ARMY! 💜 now I need to watch the next part of this video. 😉
Kpop fan always making fan of jimin vocal not knowing that only jimin have that kind of voice in kpop, that what made him unique.. he can cover other song and make it sound soothing while other can't cover his song even if they able to cover it that just gonna be their version..
Thank you very much for the detailed review, and I truly appreciate the English subs. Like you, I am also looking forward to their next album and stories.
definitely, voice type is a preference thing, but I dont think jungkook's voice is in any way generic. i think he's got that style that not many people can do.
It is just a shame that they evaluate vocals by recorded stuffs. I'd rather see them review live vocals since vocals on recording are being held to a certain limitations.
I agree with u I think a lot of people say that jungkook's voice is generic but I think his voice is so special and no one actually sound like him He also know how to make his voice diff in their song to not make it sound boring
방탄 앨범 차분한 분석 감사드려요^^ 개인적으로 방탄은 보컬라인들의 개성있는 음색이 좋았는데 최근 앨범들에선 누구의 목소리인지 구분이 잘 안될 정도로 과한 오토튠 사용이 아쉬웠어요 각각의 개성이 잘 드러나게 프로듀싱했으면 하는 바람입니다 올해 공연들이 취소되서 넘 아쉬워요ㅜㅜ 정국의 탄탄하고 청량한 목소리가 담긴 시차 꼭 라이브로 듣고 싶네요^^
I think the whole vocal line is amazing and you don’t have to bring down other talented hard working artists to promote your favorite, yes Jungkook has an amazing voice but so does Jimin, Jin, and Tae, even Hobi.
I think the reason why he does not find JK's voice as unique bc JK can sound as the three other vocals. He does most of the backing vocals and adlibs bc he has the ability to ride the vocal range of the other three. And we are not yet talking about vocal stability during live here.
For me, I think Jimin and Taehyung's voices are different (unique) from other Kpop idols. Meanwhile JK is the most stable vocalist in the group. Jin's voice sounded like Jpop's vocalists. When they blend their voices together, I AM MELTED 😍😍😍😍
I don't think so As one of the experts said, jk has a unique voice which has a lot of air as well as a stable voice some of people tend to belittle his unique and versatile voice tone bcs he sings very well without making mistakes in live performances
@@jacquelinedupre6821 Everyone has their opinions and I respect yours. But for me, when I first listened to BTS, especially vocal lines, I found V and Jimin's voices different from other singers' voices I've heard before. But for you, you think it's JK. Never mind, JK also has a good voice too. All of them have good voices actually.
![[ENG SUB] BTS 방탄천국 시즌2 #1-2. Map of the soul : 7 리뷰 및 보컬 분석 (Review and Vocal Analysis)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/WhbvJQjv7eM/mqdefault.jpg)
![[ENG SUB] BTS 방탄천국 시즌2 #1-2. Map of the soul : 7 리뷰 및 보컬 분석 (Review and Vocal Analysis)](/img/tr.png)
![[Run Jin] EP.19 | Gymnastics Day](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/ySb4CteETSk/mqdefault.jpg)
![(eng sub)김영대 평론가의 'BTS 빌보드 1위의 진짜 이유' The real reason why BTS hits No.1 on Billboard [KBS 200903 방송]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/HGgdl--y_Kg/mqdefault.jpg)
![[Eng CC] 현대무용 전공자 쌤과 보는 블랙스완 안무 연습 | Showing BTS Black Swan Dance Practice to a dance instructor](/img/n.gif)
박희아님 진행 좋아요. 안정적인 목소리 톤에서 위안을 받고, 팬들이 느끼는 방탄 음악의 차별된 서사와 창의적인 면을 강조해 주셔서 너무 공감 됐습니다. 보컬 전문가이신 두 분의 설명이 더해져 음악적 분석을 이해하며 앨범을 더 재밌게 들을 수 있게 되었어요. 이런 전문적인 음악방송 참 좋네요.
this was so fun and interesting to watch i didnt mind how long it was didn't felt long either thank you so much for doing your research well it was well explained. thank you for eng subs too
Swag? Louder Than Bombs? Just no. They talk about their pain. They talk about the fans’ pain behind the bright smiles we show the boys that they became aware of through letters etc. The lyrics, the melody, the delivery of the vocals and rap, it all fit so well with the theme of pain. How on earth did you manage to see swag in this song...
it's different style of "swag" I think
Theu's probably just looking at the title lol hahah. The title is swag bc louder than bombs yow. Hahahs
Thanks for the eng subs so international ARMYs like me can enjoy your review. One thing though, I’m not sure how Louder than Bombs is a swag song..It shows their pain as artists, but it has a progression too. In the end no matter what hardship and pain they go through they will continue to sing for us. Will watch part 2!
기자님 목소리 정말 차분하시고 귀에 쏙쏙 들어오눈 매력적인 목소리이시네요! 가사와 곡분위기, 트랙순서위 의도까지 자세한 분석 정말 흥미로웠고 즐거웠어요
박희아님 진행 정말 좋네요 음악적지식과 방탄음악에 대한 지식도 많으시고 차분하고 따스한 목소리 너무 좋고 또 듣고싶어요
리뷰 감사하게 잘 들었습니다♡
Louder than bombs 물론 윤기 랩부분에서 스웩곡이라고 생각할수도 있어요. 정말 그 부분 가사 자체만 보면요. 하지만 이건 정말 가슴아프고 눈물나는 곡이에요 아미들은 다 알겁니다. 방탄이 아미를 볼때 팬들은 행복한 표정을 짓고있지만 우리 모두가 힘든일, 아픔은 누구나 있잖아요. 남준이가 팬들의 표정이 그 표정이 아니었구나 라는걸 깨달은 데서 시작된 곡이에요. 팬들의 쏟아지는 아픔들에 자신은 폭탄소리보다 더 크게 부서져간다고 해요. 아미와 방탄은 슬픔과 고통을 함께 느낀다고 말하면서요. 그래도 두려워하지 말하고 포기하지 말라고 어떤 파도가 덮쳐도 방탄은 아미를 향해 노래할거라고 방탄 스스로와 팬들에게 다짐하는 가사입니다. 너무 고맙고 눈물나는 그런 곡이죠.. 조금 가볍게 언급하고 지나가는 감이 없지 않아 있어서 곡의 의미 대략적으로 적고갑니다.
라덴밤의 사연을 풀어주셔서 감사합니다. 거의 매일 듣는 곡 중 하나예요. 대충은 알고 있었지만 님의 글을 읽어보니 더욱 큰 감동이 몰려오네요. 다시금 외쳐봅니다. 아.포.방.포! 💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜
아~~~~
엄청 재밌게 듣고 있었는데...
2부 언제 하나요?
빨리 곡 전부 듣고 싶어요ㅠㅜ
세분 모두 좋은 말씀 감사합니다
최고였어요👍👍👍👏👏👏💜💜💜
Thank you so much for making this video and review!
It is very insightful, especially as an international fan, to learn about the Korean perspective of BTS' music. I feel that North American music reviews differ a lot (or perhaps I just have not seen the right ones). Here you touch on such subtle and delicate nuances of the album that most may not grasp. I loved to hear your thoughts on the reasoning and meanings behind each musical component- be it the vocals, lyrics, composition, mixing or arrangement. Truly enlightening!
About louder than bombs being swag song i just can't see it.
Yeah. They latched onto Yoongi’s part and forced it into a swag meaning. Did they even listen to the rest of the song? They didn’t have much to say about it...
ikr. It's like the most painful song there is in the album. And the lyrics of yoongi about "if it's not us, then who else can go this way?" was not a flex for me. It was like them accepting their fate, and their responsibility as a celebrity and sacrificing themselves so that they can comfort others. It's a very sad line for me.
맵오솔 7 리뷰 넘 감사하네여. 자세한 설명 참 도움이 되구여 울탄이들 아티스트로서의 성취도를 높게 평가해주셔서 감사합니다.
Interesting. I’d say My Time is more R&B than pop. Also, Louder Than Bombs seems to be more sensual and mysterious than “swag”...
I love the host's voice and the way she speaks x
박희아님 자주해주세요 너무 좋아요 ㅜㅜㅜ>< 여러분덕분에 유익한 정보를 또 얻어가네요 감사해요 😊
이런.....2부가 따로 있었군요.. 올라오면 볼게요~오늘 영상 잘봤습니다. 감사합니다~~~^^
MOTS 7 전체 앨범을 리뷰해 주시다니 감동입니다. BTS는 앨범은 파면 팔수록 감동을 주는 곡이 너무 많아요. 그들의 진정성을 팬들이 느끼기 때문에 사랑 받는 그룹이 된 것이라 생각합니다.
박희아님 진행 정말 좋네요
감사드려요
기존 진행자때문에 안들었었는데ㅎ
보통 앨범 전체 리뷰 영상은 곡 분위기만 리뷰하고 빠르게 다음 곡으로 넘어가는데 가사와 곡에 담긴 의미까지 언급해주셔서 정말 좋네요! 잘 보고 가요
우리지민이 필터 국내외로 대박났죠. 솔로곡 중 가장 음원, 유튜브 둘다 가장 많은 사랑받는 곡으로 기록 세우고 있죠. 지민이는 방탄의 곡에 색을 입히는 역할이라고 하더라구요. 다른그룹과 다른 보컬의 유니크함이 중요하게 맡고 있죠^^
영싱 너무 재밌게 잘봤습니다 보컬 코치님들 유튜브 영상으로 보던분들이라 반갑네요 2부는 언제 하시나요? 빨리보고싶어요 곡설명도 잘들었습니다 mc분도 탄이들에대한 애정이느껴지고 곡에대한 해석도 깊이가 있으시네요 차분하게 말씀하셔서 귀에 쏙들어오네요
잘들었습니다..2부가 기대되네요..
좋은리뷰 감사합니다
방탄소년단의 음악적성장에 박수를보냅니다
특히 이번앨범을통해서 방탄 메인보컬의진가를
다시한번보여준 정국의 시차~!!! 보컬선생님의
특급칭찬 감사해요~세련되고 팝적인 음색과
리듬을갖고노는 보컬스킬에 저도 반했습니다
방탄소년단의 앞으로의 활동도 응원합니다
오랜만에 희아 기자님 뵈서 좋았어요 ♡♡♡
잘 보고 가요
와~~세 분의 진행이 넘 재밌어 구독 눌렀어요~방탄 앨범 해설에 격공합니다~
감사합니다~♡
'My Time' is less pop than JKs earlier songs lol. It's more R&B than anything else really
I enjoyed it alot. Thank you so much for this. Your analysis and positive comments makes me feel proud ARMY! 💜 now I need to watch the next part of this video. 😉
와 너무 좋다 제가 왜 지금 이 영상을 알았을까요 ㅜㅜ
구독까지 완료하고 갑니다
이런 영상은 퍼날라야한다고 봅니다 ㅜㅜ
Jungkook's voice is very special
정말 감사합니다~
전문가들이시라 제가 생각하지못한 부분들을 설명해주셔서 정말 잘 봤습니다~앞으로도 탄이들 리뷰 많이 해주셨으면 좋겠습니다~😊
박희아님 진행도 좋고 목소리도 너무 좋으세요.
조곤조곤 말씀하시니까 귀에 쏙쏙들어오네요. 이런채널이 있는줄 오늘알고 땅을쳤네요.구독하고 갑니다
Thank you for providing the english subtitles as this was very insightful analysis and review.
박희아님 목소리가 잔잔하고 안정적이어서 듣기 굉장히 좋았습니다. 보컬트레이너 전문가 2분도 제가 유툽에서 방탄 보컬 리뷰로 많이 봤었던 분들이라 반가웠습니다. MOTS:7 전 앨범 리뷰 해주셔서 너무 잘 들었어요~ 감사합니다 :)
Thank you for sharing the analysis with English subtitles. When will you post the next part? 💜🥰
리뷰 잘 봤습니다. 이런 영상 사랑합니다💜
애정이담긴 세분의리뷰 잘들었어요
시차 특히 애정하는데 좋은말씀
감사합니다~♡
현대적이면서도 트렌드한
정국이목소리 저도 좋아해요ㅎ
방탄소년단 모두 이번앨범을
통해 더 큰성장을보여준것같아요
항상 응원합니다💜
Kpop fan always making fan of jimin vocal not knowing that only jimin have that kind of voice in kpop, that what made him unique.. he can cover other song and make it sound soothing while other can't cover his song even if they able to cover it that just gonna be their version..
it's so rare to found this kind of content from koreans with english subtitle. Thank you so much!
정국의솔로곡 시차에대해서
알엠형도 정국이가아니면
할수없는 어려운곡이라했는데
정국이의 보컬역량이 정말놀랍네요
음악적성장을 더해가는 자랑스런
방탄소년단~!!! 이번앨범도 최고입니다
좋은리뷰 잘들었습니다🙏🏼💜
감사합니다 💜💜
Thank you very much for the detailed review, and I truly appreciate the English subs.
Like you, I am also looking forward to their next album and stories.
감사드려요~~ 방탄천국
Jungkook perfect vocal
감사합니다 😊 잘들었습니다. Thank you so much,very appreciate:)
태형이 솔로곡 너무 좋죠.. 쿨나님 안계셔서 서운하긴 한데 희아기자님이 태형이 이야기 해주셔서 좋았네요
영상잘보고가요~~
I love all of them and Jungkook's voice really got me, he planted his roots in my heart that no one else can do ..
They are my FOREVER SINGER 💜💜💜💜
I look forward to part 2.
I also love Jungkook voice😄💜
definitely, voice type is a preference thing, but I dont think jungkook's voice is in any way generic. i think he's got that style that not many people can do.
It is just a shame that they evaluate vocals by recorded stuffs. I'd rather see them review live vocals since vocals on recording are being held to a certain limitations.
they really said that? :/ i havent watched the whole thing yet, ive only watched my time's review and i thought it was ok:/
I agree with u I think a lot of people say that jungkook's voice is generic but I think his voice is so special and no one actually sound like him
He also know how to make his voice diff in their song to not make it sound boring
아니 이런방송은 많이봐야하는건데 조회수가 왜이리 낮아요 ㅠㅜ
지민에필터대박났죠~^^
thank you for putting on english subtitles!
Thank you so much for English subtitles and reviewing BTS album..I 💜💜💜💜💜💜💜U
박희아님 너무 좋아요~♡ 계속 진행해주시면 안될까요?
여자분 목소리 너무 좋으시다.....
울타니들 리뷰해주셔서 감사드려요.멤버모두 발전하고 있지만 울석지니 너무 많이 늘었죠?어떤장르를 갖다놔도 찰떡같이 어울려요
JK ♥️♥️♥️
라이브의 진리 정국이의 평가는 아쉽네...정국아 💜
정국이의 평가 넘좋은데요?
세련되고 팝적인음색과
한층더성장한보컬스킬에대해
높게평가해주셨어요
특히 보컬코치님한분은
정국이의 목소리와 세련된 비트감를
너무좋아하신다고 정말좋아하신다고
여러번말씀하시네요^^
Claro que jk es una voz unica e increible.
15:54 i think mistranslation was there.. he said jin and jungkook, but the subtitle was jin and jhope
It think you're able to hear jungkook's vocals better in his covers songs since he chooses them himself, you can hear how he prefers to sing
Yeah. They should review live vocals at least
Thank you for more give attention to jin's vocal. He really work hard to improve his vocal
방탄 앨범 차분한 분석 감사드려요^^ 개인적으로 방탄은 보컬라인들의 개성있는 음색이 좋았는데 최근 앨범들에선
누구의 목소리인지 구분이 잘 안될 정도로 과한 오토튠 사용이 아쉬웠어요 각각의 개성이 잘 드러나게 프로듀싱했으면 하는 바람입니다
올해 공연들이 취소되서 넘 아쉬워요ㅜㅜ 정국의 탄탄하고 청량한 목소리가 담긴 시차 꼭 라이브로 듣고 싶네요^^
Thanks for listening bts songs!!! 💜💜💜
thanks for the eng sub
I love Jungkook voice, he can pull any type of song.
Jungkook can sing any style, but it is impossible for someone to succeed in covering his songs
우리 방탄소년단!!^_^
Jimin❤
There's a track called "We are bulletproof: Eternal" it's about BTS but it's also about ARMY.
جونغكوك ملك غناء ماكني الذهبي💜💜💜😉😎
나의 취향 우리모두의 취향 JK~~~
🔥BTS👑😍💜AMAZING
광고 스킵하려는데 바디프랜드라서 ^^
바로 또 광고가 나와서 스킵하려는데 레모나 ^^
Jungkook voice i the best and also he does the back up vocal for other members so those vocals have no voice what so ever except Jungkook
I think the whole vocal line is amazing and you don’t have to bring down other talented hard working artists to promote your favorite, yes Jungkook has an amazing voice but so does Jimin, Jin, and Tae, even Hobi.
오른쪽분 유투버로 방탄 보컬분석인가 뮤비 분석인가 예전에 봤던거 같은데 채널이름이 생각 안나네요
💓💓💓💓💓💓💓💓
JIMIN's voice shines the most. I have never heard such a beautiful vocal tone like his💖💖💖
How come louder than bombs is swag. Maybe just the title sounds swag not the song itself.
i thought the guy on the right was pdogg until he raised his head
I think the reason why he does not find JK's voice as unique bc JK can sound as the three other vocals. He does most of the backing vocals and adlibs bc he has the ability to ride the vocal range of the other three. And we are not yet talking about vocal stability during live here.
Ikr..😌
I want them to watch and analyze live performance. Lol.
@@cristaljanemalit2489 then they will see how stable jk voice G how he can control his voice
@@nursyazwani6347 yeah. This is just nonsense because they evaluate the voice only not their technique and ability.
@@nursyazwani6347 hey. Kwep streaming My Time. 💜
i thought that was pddog for a second lol
31:20 filter
The MC giving to much information so the proportion to talk for vocal trainer just a little. Please next time giving more time to them to talk
For me, I think Jimin and Taehyung's voices are different (unique) from other Kpop idols. Meanwhile JK is the most stable vocalist in the group. Jin's voice sounded like Jpop's vocalists. When they blend their voices together, I AM MELTED 😍😍😍😍
I don't think so
As one of the experts said, jk has a unique voice which has a lot of air as well as a stable voice
some of people tend to belittle his unique and versatile voice tone bcs he sings very well without making mistakes in live performances
@@jacquelinedupre6821 Everyone has their opinions and I respect yours. But for me, when I first listened to BTS, especially vocal lines, I found V and Jimin's voices different from other singers' voices I've heard before. But for you, you think it's JK. Never mind, JK also has a good voice too. All of them have good voices actually.
박희아님 정국이 목소리는 악기가아니고 지민이 목소리가 악기라하던데 유포리아 작곡가 디제이스웨벨이 정국이 목소리자체가 악기라했어요 지민이만 악기아니에요 다들 목소리좋아요
그럼 정국이는 둘 다를 가지고 있는거네요
양 전문가에게 두가지면을 다 언급받았으니까요
기존진행자가 비호감이라 안들었는데, ebs 진행자 교체 고려해주세요.
내용이 전문적이고 재밌어요.
Louder than bombs is a swag song? Really? I disagree
@@cloverthv how different must be meaning of "swag" in this case as for me the meaning of the song is far opposite
Jamais Vu and louder than bombs are not about swag lmao idk how on earth you got that but.... no