Would like to clarify a few things: - This build does NOT run in real time. It runs on MCHPRS, the server developed by StackDoubleFlow, which speeds up the game roughly 10-20,000x while running redstone. That brings the framerate to a much more reasonable 0.1fps, so the long timelapses in the video only took 9 hours to record in total. - The world download currently in the description is non-functional for two reasons: in order to prevent content thieves such as Steveee immediately stealing it and making a profit, and also because Uwerta and I are currently improving the GUI system to be more similar to normal Minecraft (there's some dissimilarity in how items are moved around in the inventory). I'll update this comment when we release a functional download. - If you want to learn more about how it works, a brief explanation video is in the description, and that one has links to all the documentation including flowcharts for the GPU and other hardware, and the entire (commented) program itself. And yes, we will run DOOM on this hardware at some point, but projects such as these take a long time to create! After all, we are only 3 people working on this in our free time. Have patience until then :)
for sure I thought there is some sort of a Steevee security in this world Just make a chunkban to avoid him logging in (aka /gamerule doSpectatorsGenerateChunks false, /gamerule doImmediateRespawn true, tp him in an unloaded chunks and kill it with a forceloaded command blocks)
For years I have seen “Now make Minecraft in Minecraft” comment, all the way back to the first “computers” made by Sethbling way back when. It honestly became quite a fond memory of mine, the sheer absurdity of it, a game running itself on a computer built inside of itself. I cannot believe it has finally been done. My finest congratulations to the creators of this, it is not an exaggeration to say this is the most complicated redstone build of all time.
The fact that a full 3D engine is even possible in Minecraft is truly astonishing, and it's absolutely incredible what you guys have managed to compile.
Honestly this isn’t really special, not to hate this is amazing to build but actually this type of red stone was already made 6-7 years ago along with incredible creations such as an actual phone that you can watch videos, call, face time on.
Oh God i can't wait to see what 2022 graphics look like in minecraft. (The year will be like 2494 by the time we develop that. And the server Redstone speedup will be like 5 million% + the 2000% video edited speed up)
@@bc20009 i don't even think that would be enough space to fit all the hardware inside a 4090. it's like billions of microscopic transistors... it's incomprehensibly scaled when each equivalent transistor has to be a few meters in size
holy shit, the extra details are so impressive: the glass being actually transparent, the sand FALLING due to gravity, the leaf decay, the chests somehow holding up to 10 STACKS??? this is insane, well done to all three of you geniuses.
@@MARC-yo7mo but damn was it a nice house! Just look at all the nuances and the intricate details. Using logs in the corners, and building the house out of something other than logs! A master of their craft. And don't get me started on the roof.
The fact that you were able to find a believable group of words to spell "AMOGUS" for your graphics processor is almost as impressive as the redstone build itself
This has to be one of the craziest creations I've ever seen anyone create in Minecraft, props to you and the team for an incredible contribution to the Minecraft community
I mean, I think he kinda did. Every logic gate being made available means that, in theory, this could be possible. There is obvious limitations, but the logic gates being made available is ALL that you need.
@@TimKGaming i even think theres no limit of redstone after i saw Sethbling's real time 3d video call in Minecraft few years ago, the limit is just people's effort and their will, they might have creativity and skill to do it, but they're too lazy to do it alone cuz it'll took a lot of time and effort
I was fascinates with the idea ever since i was 10 years old. Seeing someone having done it finally, now that im all grown up brings tears to my eyes. Thank you.
Minecraft is Turing complete so I always knew it was theoretically possible, but I never thought someone would actually do it. This video is incredible.
It wouldn't work otherwise. You can build logic gates from redstone, so I think they really build a computer inside minecraft, a computer that runs minecraft inside minecraft that is really impressive.
When people say that Minecraft is a bad, childish or a primitive game and that it's absurd that it's the most popular game in the world for many years now, I always show them this video. Minecraft is amazing. The fact that it's possible to make a game within a game, is not just impressive, it's absolutely transcendent to what video-game escapism is as a concept. We have a game that is brilliantly, intricately designed, that it allows us to emulate life to such an extend, that we not only live inside it, we can invent things, we can design and build complex tools of modern technology INSIDE the game. If Minecraft would not be the most popular game in the world with features like these, I would think much lesser of our race.
Final statement is a good example of false cause fallacy. You may outgrow that. If not, you'll make a great deontologist. Minecraft is a masterpiece and I got goosebumps from reading your comment even though I haven't played in years. Cheers, President Romnib.
The almost scary thing is that this could theoretically go on forever. As long as you build a large enough computer, load all of it, and have the patience to wait years for a single frame, you could keep building it
although with each iteration the actualy version would require exponentially more redstone, and even with an infinitely powerful computer minecraft itself wont load it all
lmao that intro was clever it made me pause and actually read it and i realized it was just soo comical. This worked because if you have left the warning message play out for a few seconds the viewers would've likely lost interest but since it flashed, i felt curious and wanted to read the message .
incredible! and I thought the Chungus 2 was the best. This isn't even believable. edit: just realized this could be its own separate version of Minecraft. Minecraft: Block edition!
Absolutely mental. Its amazing how well the 3d perspective still works with only two colors and such a tiny display. And holy shit all the features you guys implemented. And the fact that renders so well.
Ladies and gentlemen, we completed the circle. We knew this moment was bound to happen. Let's celebrate this milestone and look forward for the next one: Minecraft in Minecraft in Minecraft.
This is essentially, 1) a complete stimulation, 2) design from scratch of a real life computer, 3) programming a 3D engine. The vast amount of knowledge involved is unimaginable.
Before we started working on this project, I was writing a 3D renderer in Assembly. Once we started working on this, though, we quickly determined that doing the rendering in software would be way too slow to ever record a video, even with the acceleration from MCHPRS (at LEAST 100s, if not thousands or even more times slower than the end result). So we had to take that rendering code, and convert it into hardware instead.
The average game developer: “Ugh, why does transparency have to be this complex?” sammyuri, Uwerta, and StackDoubleFlow: “Yeah so our 3D Minecraft-in-Minecraft inception machine has transparent glass with 0 visual bugs”
This is one of the greatest video game achievements I've ever seen. Literally with this type of knowledge who knows what you can do outside of minecraft!
@@sasori5367 Yes, but with severe limitations. Just because the accuring principles are simple doesn’t mean it didn’t take a lot of work, time and brain power to make
@@Yonatan-jv8mvNASA computer when we went to the moon was weaker than this. Now we have phones stronger than NASA computer and they can't figure out how to land on the moon again.
I was working on some redstone stuffs for a video, and learnt how much of a pain it was to make a rom based display. This completely boggles my mind and simultanously excites me and gives me second place asian kid syndrome. I can't wait to see the explanation video!
This is possibly the greatest achievement in minecraft ever. There are some wildly impressive builds and world records, but this blows it all way way way out of the water. Congratulations to you and your team, I don't know the last time something made my jaw literally drop.
For anyone who is confused or wondering how this is possible: I’ll try to break it down in simple terms, at the lowest level your computer processes data in binary, 1’s and 0’s. A 1 meaning “on” and 0 meaning “off”. So let’s say you’re watching a UA-cam video, your computer takes the data it receives from UA-cam, converts it into billions of 1’s and 0’s, then reads and processes the binary and translates it back to you in the form of a video. It does this really really fast. Redstone is essentially just binary, Redstone that’s turned on is a 1 and off is a 0. So it’s basically possible to use Redstone to make a computer program that is coded only using binary, granted it is really really labor intensive since modern day computer programmers have the benefit of things like coding languages and 3D modeling software that can do a lot of the work for us and really powerful CPU’s and GPU’s that can process thousands of bits in less than a second. If you look up really early computers, like from the 50’s and 60’s they were extremely simple yet took up an entire room just to process a few KB. These guys were working with even less than that which demonstrates how momentous of an accomplishment this computer is
there's youtuber that milk content 10% as impressive as this for 20-40mins and you did a 3min video of this that's sped up but still shows hours of work. Hats off man!
This is one of the greatest projects I've ever seen. Can't imagine the amount of work needed to accomplish this. I'm also very happy that you understand the importance of running DOOM on every hardware in existence.
@@drachenreiter1296 Not a new challenge. Since Doom II, I believe, that people have been running Doom on Software too. Although, I would argue that there's no such thing as software "not meant to run Doom". Existence is meant to run Doom.
One of the greatest feats in all of game history. A game so complex, with players experienced enough to reach its fullest potential. The game, inside the game.
With you guys around minecraft we could even break the game in a different way which you did right now this is so stunning i cant even make a number display screen with buttons in minecraft while you built minecraft in minecraft very very unbelievable dude you team are the redstone gods i can bet that. Still soo unbelievable keep up your work and i am waiting for more projects like these from you geys.
When I first met sam on CK I didn't know he was such a tremendous redstoner. With time I learned that he was insane... but this goes beyond every scope!!!
Halfway through the video I completely forgot that this was in Minecraft and I thought it was an IRL computer running it. Absolutely insane. My brain has vaporized into nothingness.
Fun fact: anything declared "turing complete" can achieve this. It just depends on how many lifetimes you want to spend trying to work on it. Even the card game Magic: The Gathering is turing complete btw x)
@@louisrobitaille5810 The game of life has also been made to run itself!!! That is the first "game" that I know of to actually create itself within itself. And Mc now to be the first 3d game to be made within itself!!!
@@recon_leech4 yes but its far away from easy, you Need Computer Engineering Knowledge and you have to know how its done in minecraft AND you have to spend a lot of time
The amount of remarkable things in this is astounding. Forget designing an entire computer, lets start with how do 3 guys just write a version of Minecraft that fits in 8kb “in their spare time”? The amount of effort put into all of this is severely underrated
for real, it's already very challenging to make your own 3d graphics system with an actual programming language. these guys did it in minecraft, using only redstone, on their own virtual computer made entirely of redstone. like DAYUM
My man, my brother in Christ, you made a computer, in a computer, and then made it run the thing it was in. It is impossible to put into words how spectacular that is.
Inb4 they come in and SLAP these guys with a copyright infringement suit for attempting to reverse engineer and recreate Minecraft while calling it Minecraft
If the normal viewers are already impressed, imagine the actual Engineers and students!! This is ridiculously awesome and unreal, they used an entire knowledge of how computer works, and applied it, and finished the entire project… I’m really impressed, and it gives me hope to finish my grade
This is spectacular. This should be recognized in more than just the Minecraft community. There is a lvl of ingenuity, dedication and just straight up mad scientist vibes here that it needs to be shared
Beautiful. Some would say that redstone has peaked, and I was saying that too. However, truly, it's actually not an end, but the beginning of a new era. Redstone never has been so impressive! Thanks Sammy, Uwerta, Stack and everyone of the computational redstone community! Let's continue pushing onwards to great new heights!!
Im a software developer with a sidehustle in hardware engineering, even though I probably understand every used concept that went into this system, I still wouldn’t even fathom trying to build it. The days and months alone just preparing the blueprints and optimizing I/O syncs so memory address routing doesn’t break the entire thing would drive me mad… building this is not just about implementing known concepts, it’s about creating new ones with „logical hardware programming“. I did this in other games for years, and it’s a very useful skill to have as a person.
I know nothing about programming, so my question is, could they theoretically take this even further? And how far that would be? Could they improve on graphics and game mechanics in this game within the game?
@@lippi2171 there is basically nothing stopping them, if you put enough time into it, eventually you could recreate the game as it is right now, there are mechanics with falling concrete blocks that allow for colored screens for example. The only two limitations in terms of applicability are speed and Render distance, and they combat both of those things with mods i assume. It's just that at a certain point, this becomes insanely complex. Imagine rewriting the entirety of Minecrafts Codebase, but in a version of Java that you had to develop yourself, which then gets compiled to Vector-Language and on hardware you have to come up with in the first place. This here already is outside of my own imaginary boundaries, imagine how insane this would become if you start to recreate the actual game state. I doubt that even sammyuri and his team are THAT dedicated to go to these extremes just to prove a concept. We talk about years of development.
This video gives me even worse imposter syndrome haha. I also study programming and this shit is beyond crazy, i don't understand how someone is able to build this.
@@okdk2362 I know what you mean haha 😂 I assume they got an entire community dedicated to building compact circuits within the game. They probably spend days on end trying to optimize simple stuff like ROM storage blocks or address registers and got an entire database of litematica prints for all kinds of IC‘s.
@@uniforesVery impressive for sure. But I think the reason people think this is more impressive is because in real life computer manufacturing we have WAY more components and options for building a computer. They're essentially recreating a game with the bare minimum of logic possible, just stacked in ingenious ways. That's why it's so impressive!
As a software engineer, I just realized how clueless I am about hardware. I knew a thing or two, capacitors, how ram works, how cpu works to some extend but wow. I can't even imagine how this is working.
Same here lol. I was never very interested in the hardware side of things although I did very well in my Computer Hardware class in college where we learned assembly and how processors work (I remember pretty much nothing of course). But wow, this thing is insane. It's incredible what people have done in Minecraft.
@@25Yasindayim Its because you have the sowftware side but also the electric side wich is more about the physics parts. No one really learn both of them. They learn one or the other because it’s a lot of knowledge. Probably the main reason giving the need of a team. Its the same in real life.
This redstone creation will go down in not only redstone history, but it will be cemented in Minecraft history. A truly remarkable achievement by this team of 3.
What? I was already impressed by Mattbatwing's Multi line renderer, and now there is an entire 3D and physics engine. If it wasn't by you I would think it is fake.
@@VideosViraisVirais-dc7nxYour mom’s easy, let me hit almost every day last week. Only had to miss it one day because she was too busy complaining about you.
This is absolutely insane. My mind simply cannot fathom the amount of planning and labor that likely went into building this. I am simultaneously amazed, impressed, and absolutely horrified. ;-)
Minecraft is Turing Complete, you just need a powerful enough computer to handle it in the emulation / simulation of building it within itself and running it... It takes galaxies to emulate or simulate atoms, yet it takes uncountable atoms to make a single galaxy!!!
I'm pretty sure you can include a project like this in a resume to prove your worth to a company of high standard, because the time, knowledge and dedication to the craft is ludicrous, not a fan of reddit but I understand the pain of your post being taken down, this is probably one of the most impressive red stone projects I've ever seen, comming close to the one that allowed people to order irl pizza with a phone built all in minecraft, congratulations.
This isn't really a case of "plucky gamer has gaming skills so powerful companies need them". The skills required to make this are mostly just a whole lot of computer science and electronic engineering. It is basically impossible to make this without having side projects that are even more impressive, or more likely decades of experience working at the appropriate field.
As my fellow pre-commenter allready stated, this project and everything in it is on itself impressive in terms of dedication, but the components used in it are just scaled down, allready existing IC-modules. Everyone, including me, with a proper understanding of advanced computer engineering would be capable of replicating it.
@@hitbox7422 I mean it's an impressive architecture in it's own right. Humanity no longer really tries to optimize circuitry for hyperspecific tasks, not for games at least. A part of me wants to see how far you can optimize hardware for minecraft specifically, make it run on a 1$ chip. Like for example we don't really do graphic processors for computers of this size, and if you try to make this run on your washing machine, it will be incredibly inefficient due to lack of parallel computing.
@@hitbox7422 this particular program would still probably run just fine on a washing machine lol. Modern microcontrollers have a ridiculous amount of power. Would make for a great side project.
That "phone" project was not even remotely close to this one. I have no idea why people keep mentioning it here, let alone assuming it was more impressive?? Have you guys even watched any of the two past thumbnail?
I always believed that one day someone will make Minecraft in Minecraft. Now, I can't even fathom the joy I'm feeling to see this creation with my own eyes.
Basically this a proof that we are "living" in a computer simulation - and that the real world is much more complex, with more dimensions and stuff; right?
I remember watching sethbling videos from 10 years ago where he would show off these incredible creations. The things he did in minecraft were unfathomable, and he just kept pushing them further and further. Under all of his videos would be so many comments saying "one step closer to running minecraft in minecraft". It was unimaginable to me that that could happen, it's completely ridiculous, but here we are, 10 years later, and you've actually done it! I can't wait to see how you guys push the boundaries of redstone even further
I hope this man joins the medical industry with his brilliant mind because we need more cures available to the people for diseases like copd and emphysema
Like man the boundaries are way bigger than you imagine, red stone works like the way pc works, with 0s and 1s its impossible to replicate a pc but you can do a lot of stuff
Normally I don’t like videos but this deserves every like possible because how much more creative can yall get? This is UNBELIEVABLE. My mind is literally aching trying to figure out how this is possible lmao. How do you even make a SCREEN?!
when you realize that what he built only had kilobytes worth of processing power but his actual machine probably used orders of magnitude more than that in order to create this masterpiece...
I'm disappointed that I can't fully understand and appreciate how difficult this task must have been, and the amount of work required to accomplish it.
It doesn't take much to understand at least the basic concept of it. I only know some programming and electronics basics, but I fully appreciate and crown this the greatest feat in Minecraft and maybe even possibly the greatest feat in all of gaming history Still, I'm also a little frustrated that I don't know exactly how it works and cannot fully comprehend the actual effort it must have taken, only guess-estimate
@@hak0bu I think it took a lot of effort but the prerequisite knowledge isn't necessarily much. Take a free online course on computer architecture, like nand2tetris, and you could build a simpler version of this yourself. One course would really be all it takes. The hard part is designing an assembly language and then writing a program in said language. Yikes. And then the abysmal framerate... I don't know if it's worth the effort unless you're going to make a UA-cam video about it.
@@stone_pilot as someone who’s done nand2tetris, and built some simple computer components in Minecraft, it’s not comparable. This is far more than just that. They had to individually construct each part of the hardware, down to the individual logic gates for each part. They had to create 3d rendering from scratch that runs in Minecraft, they also had to then add the fundamentals of minecraft into the program. Doing that alone normally is already decently impressive, but to do all of that on a computer you built from scratch in a game is just ridiculous.
@@meta02 I can see how the way I wrote my comment may give the impression that I'm discrediting the difficulty of this project. I'm not. This would be a monstrous undertaking. The point I was trying to make was that the underlying concepts are surprisingly simple and easy to learn. The hard part has always been implementing them. Since we've mentioned it twice now, nand2tetris grows extremely effort-intensive as the project grows in complexity from basic logic gates to the ALU, CPU, RAM, Assembler, and OS. Each step grows increasingly more work intensive, and that's using a text editor and an architecture that has already been designed for you. When I made this comment I was thinking about all the people who see something like this and comment along the lines of 'Wow, I'm really struggling just to make a piston door this is crazy'. The reason you're struggling to make a piston door is because you don't understand even the simplest logic gates. You can do it too! It's really easy to learn. I know this because when I was 12 I thought redstone was magic and I didn't get it at all. I took one CS course in HS and suddenly I was capable of so much more.
you could explain this to me in a hundred different ways and my brain would not be able to wrap around how any of this even works. youve worked minecraft magic for sure.
What’s even crazier is that the devs probably never intended for that to be the case, either. This is players making the most out of what they’re given.
@@carcinogeneticist378 i don't think so. you know that you are watching this video and my comment on redstone (*cough*)? redstone can build logic gates. your computer, phone is made of logic gates. you only need this to do everything. thats why implementing redstone made minecraft way better. they literally multiplied infinite by infinite
@@carcinogeneticist378 It's a lot more impressive than the devs making something possible without intending to. Cause this isn't Mojang's Minecraft. This is DO's optimized Minecraft server - running redstone *a lot* faster than vanilla MC can.
Yep, bug fixing this was an absolute nightmare. I think doing the actual building hardware/programming was far below 25% of the time spent on this project.
I can only say wow. This is fantastic, as a computer science student I believe that things like these are what motivate us and the analysis of them brings us lessons and opens new directions. I qualify this as art. Just like you're running Minecraft there, we could play pacman, or snake, etc, right? I still can not believe it.
Would like to clarify a few things:
- This build does NOT run in real time. It runs on MCHPRS, the server developed by StackDoubleFlow, which speeds up the game roughly 10-20,000x while running redstone. That brings the framerate to a much more reasonable 0.1fps, so the long timelapses in the video only took 9 hours to record in total.
- The world download currently in the description is non-functional for two reasons: in order to prevent content thieves such as Steveee immediately stealing it and making a profit, and also because Uwerta and I are currently improving the GUI system to be more similar to normal Minecraft (there's some dissimilarity in how items are moved around in the inventory). I'll update this comment when we release a functional download.
- If you want to learn more about how it works, a brief explanation video is in the description, and that one has links to all the documentation including flowcharts for the GPU and other hardware, and the entire (commented) program itself.
And yes, we will run DOOM on this hardware at some point, but projects such as these take a long time to create! After all, we are only 3 people working on this in our free time. Have patience until then :)
This is stunning
Truly incredible work
For fun and fun only
But still great
Keep it up
U r best
for sure I thought there is some sort of a Steevee security in this world
Just make a chunkban to avoid him logging in (aka /gamerule doSpectatorsGenerateChunks false, /gamerule doImmediateRespawn true, tp him in an unloaded chunks and kill it with a forceloaded command blocks)
incredible work! Hope to see new works in future!
For years I have seen “Now make Minecraft in Minecraft” comment, all the way back to the first “computers” made by Sethbling way back when. It honestly became quite a fond memory of mine, the sheer absurdity of it, a game running itself on a computer built inside of itself. I cannot believe it has finally been done. My finest congratulations to the creators of this, it is not an exaggeration to say this is the most complicated redstone build of all time.
Taking virtual machines one step further
I guess minecraft is Turing Complete now.
@@Banilla468 it already was in the usual sense of the word (as in, it would be Turing complete if it had infinite RAM)
Now make Minecraft in Minecraft in Minecraft.
Quote me on this when it happens.
So far.
The fact that a full 3D engine is even possible in Minecraft is truly astonishing, and it's absolutely incredible what you guys have managed to compile.
Surprising to see you here
yes
Honestly this isn’t really special, not to hate this is amazing to build but actually this type of red stone was already made 6-7 years ago along with incredible creations such as an actual phone that you can watch videos, call, face time on.
@@jeremysg791 Datapacks, addons, mods, command blocks are different from vanill redstone
@@jeremysg791 the phone was using command blocks, and there were Addons to make it run better this is pure vanilla Minecraft red stone.
The next step is to add redstone, and begin building Minecraft within Minecraft within Minecraft.
Ah yes, MineMineMineCraftCraftCraft
Exactly
Lmfao
and then minecraft in minecraft in minecraft in minecraft
MINECEPTION
Imagine, enderman is bored and then takes one of the components 💀
lol
Noo
So basically real life hardware bugs, when a random component or wire dies, or just slightly degrades as to make its performance fall outside the spec
The fact you did this and only made a 3 minute straight to the point video is crazy.
Absolutely
Genuinely a youtube history gem already
I would of made this video at least 50 minutes long. Just to milk the hard work I put in.
It would take years to make something like this.. For a three minute video? Very doubtful it's real
@@Tonyklick ...who else has made minecraft in miencraft? Or do you think AI can do everything?
Certified best redstone creation ever created any category
100% agree
Agree
@@mattbatwings takes courage to roast yourelf like that
@@realoscar91 he worked on it lmao
Easily best ever
Now we know what Minecraft would've looked like if it released in 1983.
more like ~90-91
even extremely basic raycasters like wolfenstein 3d's engine were not possible on machines from 83
Oh God i can't wait to see what 2022 graphics look like in minecraft.
(The year will be like 2494 by the time we develop that.
And the server Redstone speedup will be like 5 million% + the 2000% video edited speed up)
@@ChristopherGray00 No. His 1983 date is pretty much on point.
@@drygordspellweaver8761 no, it isn't
@@HajileMalach nice rebuttal Einstein
I made a dirt hut survived night and then got blown up by a creeper.
Yeah, but these bozos don't play in survival :)
@@gdutfulkbhh7537and those bozos is you like ain’t no way you are calling them bozos even tho THEY MADE MINECRAFT IN MINECRAFT
no seriously what the fuck is wrong with these kids😭@@gdutfulkbhh7537
@@Mystery-v5r it's a joke, genius
@@meklpeckle1936 is anyone laughing? GENIUS?
First 1 kb in real life: size of a garage
First 1 kb in Minecraft: size of an Ikea
Yeah cause why not would wool only come in 1^3 meter lol
a 4090 in minecraft: size of the solar system
@@bc20009 i don't even think that would be enough space to fit all the hardware inside a 4090. it's like billions of microscopic transistors... it's incomprehensibly scaled when each equivalent transistor has to be a few meters in size
@@luviana_ yea ik, but who cares
@@bc20009 He was supporting your comment, not arguin 😂.
holy shit, the extra details are so impressive: the glass being actually transparent, the sand FALLING due to gravity, the leaf decay, the chests somehow holding up to 10 STACKS??? this is insane, well done to all three of you geniuses.
It is 2 mil speed tho but still incredibly mindblowing
most people dont realize how hard it is to make something transparent in a 3d environment
@@KingMetalMario especially in redstone xD
@@agentcripper yep
Transparency seems to slow it down, though, even when not on screen? No culling? Or maybe it was just the number of blocks.
Truly incredible. I can honestly say without a hint of doubt or irony, this is the most impressive thing ever created in Minecraft
you sure all he built was a house
@@MARC-yo7mo but damn was it a nice house! Just look at all the nuances and the intricate details. Using logs in the corners, and building the house out of something other than logs! A master of their craft.
And don't get me started on the roof.
@@MARC-yo7mo your all sure that every one play Minecraft made a house
@@UnableToucan he needs to make this machine inside of the machine. Then play Minecraft inside of that.
Why just minecraft? Probably all video games
This isn’t just impressive, this is the very foundation on how our whole world advanced so fast in just 100 years.
The fact that you were able to find a believable group of words to spell "AMOGUS" for your graphics processor is almost as impressive as the redstone build itself
Do you mean chungus?
@@zcrzy "AMOGUS graphics processor"
@@zcrzy amogus is the processor, chungus Is the computer
Chungus is the processor, amogus is the graphic processor
sus
This has to be one of the craziest creations I've ever seen anyone create in Minecraft, props to you and the team for an incredible contribution to the Minecraft community
I'll take my "OMG verified and only 23 likes" badge here.
But can it play Doom?
@@theflammiferofwesternesse6122 yes, soon™
nj
Hey jera!
I don't think Notch imagined people taking redstone this far, but holy sh*t you really did it
maybe this is exactly what he had in mind...
I mean, I think he kinda did. Every logic gate being made available means that, in theory, this could be possible. There is obvious limitations, but the logic gates being made available is ALL that you need.
@@TimKGaming «theoretically possible» and someone actually doing it are two very different things
@@TimKGaming i even think theres no limit of redstone after i saw Sethbling's real time 3d video call in Minecraft few years ago, the limit is just people's effort and their will, they might have creativity and skill to do it, but they're too lazy to do it alone cuz it'll took a lot of time and effort
I think he did, I think he left Redstone without limits on purpose so see how far people would expand it.
I was fascinates with the idea ever since i was 10 years old. Seeing someone having done it finally, now that im all grown up brings tears to my eyes. Thank you.
bruh, this was a joke from about 6 years ago that somehow turned into reality. This man made history
History indeed, never thought this could have been possible but he proved wrong
Minecraft is Turing complete so I always knew it was theoretically possible, but I never thought someone would actually do it. This video is incredible.
When someone is dedicated to prove you are not funny...
there was 3 people
Older than that, surely. I remember seeing this on some of the very first red stone build videos, back in 2011 or something.
I wish I had 1% of the ambition it takes to do something like this.
Lmao
Me to.
1% of the ambition and knowledge
ME TOO
well if it makes you feel any better they succeeded in 1% of what someone else accomplished.
What's mind-blowing is that at the scale they're building these components, they start to look like real-life computer parts.
Well yeah, that's exactly what they are.
It wouldn't work otherwise. You can build logic gates from redstone, so I think they really build a computer inside minecraft, a computer that runs minecraft inside minecraft that is really impressive.
@@sizu257 Yeah I mean I just think it's interesting that the architecture translates so well from real life to blocks
@@dunzek943 they ain't real life computer parts.
@@theoldleafybeard yeah but they do the same things as real pc parts do, using the same principles, the same mechanics.
When people say that Minecraft is a bad, childish or a primitive game and that it's absurd that it's the most popular game in the world for many years now, I always show them this video. Minecraft is amazing. The fact that it's possible to make a game within a game, is not just impressive, it's absolutely transcendent to what video-game escapism is as a concept. We have a game that is brilliantly, intricately designed, that it allows us to emulate life to such an extend, that we not only live inside it, we can invent things, we can design and build complex tools of modern technology INSIDE the game. If Minecraft would not be the most popular game in the world with features like these, I would think much lesser of our race.
Final statement is a good example of false cause fallacy. You may outgrow that. If not, you'll make a great deontologist. Minecraft is a masterpiece and I got goosebumps from reading your comment even though I haven't played in years. Cheers, President Romnib.
man already made the best redstone build in minecraft then DID IT AGAIN!!!! sammyuri you are so goddamn CRACKED you've got a bright future ahead
How did he made 3D? We need explanation video lol
@@-Cheatcheck the description for a video explaining it!
hello crafty!
Stop ripping off videos and make actual content
Is this why u told us to subscribe to this man yesterday?
This is literally the greatest thing ever created in Minecraft. I cannot believe my eyes.
Same brother
the greatest thing made in minecraft? minecraft
@@NotParallax just goes to show how great Minecraft -is- has the potential to be
The almost scary thing is that this could theoretically go on forever. As long as you build a large enough computer, load all of it, and have the patience to wait years for a single frame, you could keep building it
although with each iteration the actualy version would require exponentially more redstone, and even with an infinitely powerful computer minecraft itself wont load it all
This is the basis for simulation theory and also the reason as to why some people genuinely believe that we live in a simulation.
@@joaquimkeloglanian4801 or maybe we're in a simulation built in Minecraft in Minecraft and so on
minecraft within minecraft within minecraft
@@joaquimkeloglanian4801 simulation theory is unlikely
lmao that intro was clever it made me pause and actually read it and i realized it was just soo comical. This worked because if you have left the warning message play out for a few seconds the viewers would've likely lost interest but since it flashed, i felt curious and wanted to read the message .
The amount of work put into this is staggering, this video is a work of art.
incredible! and I thought the Chungus 2 was the best. This isn't even believable.
edit: just realized this could be its own separate version of Minecraft.
Minecraft: Block edition!
how has he managed this honestly
I want some crazy build this in hardcore
I agree random person I defo dk
@@maxmaxrips yea indeed
Bro got 48 missed calls from Mojang
thats crazy ngl
Idk man if this is real they haven't released a functional download in a year lol.
@@Mister_Racerit is real. If you zoom into the screen closley the redstone actually works
FR
@@Unexperiencedguy Could be faked easily.
Absolutely mental. Its amazing how well the 3d perspective still works with only two colors and such a tiny display. And holy shit all the features you guys implemented. And the fact that renders so well.
I take it you come from a time after the original Gameboy ran it's course lol.
@@houstoner 😂
@@houstoner I played the big chunky grey boy. Don't really recall seeing any 3D perspectives on there. Maybe I missed out on a really good one?
bro this is complete dedication and genius!
This is absolutely insane! I still struggle with piston doors at times and there's people doing stuff like this?!
25 minutes ago lol
*Y E S*
Yeah eret
R/Autism
Same i struggle with it too.
Ladies and gentlemen, we completed the circle. We knew this moment was bound to happen. Let's celebrate this milestone and look forward for the next one: Minecraft in Minecraft in Minecraft.
it's Turing complete
But first we will need redstone in minecraft in minecraft
@@brickone_ yeah he has
minecraft in minecraft in minecraft in terraria in minecraft in gta v in minecraft
It would take days to render a frame but I'm all here for it
If this guy would be working in the space flight industry, we would have colonies on mars allready 💀
This is essentially, 1) a complete stimulation, 2) design from scratch of a real life computer, 3) programming a 3D engine. The vast amount of knowledge involved is unimaginable.
Exactly! This is truly a case study of hardware design!
This essentially makes Minecraft turing complete.
Before we started working on this project, I was writing a 3D renderer in Assembly. Once we started working on this, though, we quickly determined that doing the rendering in software would be way too slow to ever record a video, even with the acceleration from MCHPRS (at LEAST 100s, if not thousands or even more times slower than the end result). So we had to take that rendering code, and convert it into hardware instead.
The average game developer: “Ugh, why does transparency have to be this complex?”
sammyuri, Uwerta, and StackDoubleFlow: “Yeah so our 3D Minecraft-in-Minecraft inception machine has transparent glass with 0 visual bugs”
Transparency is easy to make
It is very easy to make with two colors, but dang, think of all the redstone that made it!
Fit into under eight kilobytes.
'cause they are pro on this. ONLY this at that time.
this is so accurate coming from someone who tried to design glass in their own 3d minecraft replica.
This is one of the greatest video game achievements I've ever seen. Literally with this type of knowledge who knows what you can do outside of minecraft!
Hey I know you
this is basic engineering
@@sasori5367 Yes, but with severe limitations. Just because the accuring principles are simple doesn’t mean it didn’t take a lot of work, time and brain power to make
funni gd
@@sasori5367 so basic that it could be made since like 2015 and he was the first one to make it
Me struggling to make a basic piston door
This guy:
Mojang: we added all colors to Redstone lamp, red, orange, yellow, and more.
Sammyuri: more realism
yes
Then they can start working on mincraft within minecraft, within minecraft.
In theory he only needs, blue green and red and you could have normal minecraft
We could use Redstone Lamps to backlight red, green, and blue Stained Glass!
I would be the same, what are you talking about?
i can't believe the guys at NASA still have time to make videos like these. thanks guys!
He works at nasa?
@@riseofkings4405 in other words whoever made this is an absolute genius
@@zeenzodiac5952 oh it was a hyperbole that makes sense lol
@@riseofkings4405 also implying that it requires a NASA computer to run this
@@Yonatan-jv8mvNASA computer when we went to the moon was weaker than this. Now we have phones stronger than NASA computer and they can't figure out how to land on the moon again.
I was working on some redstone stuffs for a video, and learnt how much of a pain it was to make a rom based display. This completely boggles my mind and simultanously excites me and gives me second place asian kid syndrome. I can't wait to see the explanation video!
1st
@@vsdan4814 no one asked
Nah that guy's a friend, he's joking around lmao
Imposter syndrome moment
@@vsdan4814 It's the true first place asian
"Mom, can we stop at my buddies house to play mine craft?"
"No, we have minecraft at home"
This is possibly the greatest achievement in minecraft ever. There are some wildly impressive builds and world records, but this blows it all way way way out of the water. Congratulations to you and your team, I don't know the last time something made my jaw literally drop.
Achievement unlocked: minecraft in Minecraft
and now Minecraft in Minecraft in Minecraft
You guys just created a 3D engine with a game on an assembly inside minecraft! This is so impressive! And inspirational as heck.
2d
@@ReaperAHHH
3D rasterized into a 2D image.
@@ReaperAHHH 3d
🤓
Gd can do it faster
Only 2 years of redstone breakthroughs away from literally playing God
Next: DOOM Eternal made with redstone
hello Yahiamice. i finally found you in the wild
@@agnieszkabirbicz3620 it would be easier to make than minecraft i supose
@@memor22 you've got a point.
Jabibi minecraft 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
For anyone who is confused or wondering how this is possible:
I’ll try to break it down in simple terms, at the lowest level your computer processes data in binary, 1’s and 0’s. A 1 meaning “on” and 0 meaning “off”.
So let’s say you’re watching a UA-cam video, your computer takes the data it receives from UA-cam, converts it into billions of 1’s and 0’s, then reads and processes the binary and translates it back to you in the form of a video. It does this really really fast.
Redstone is essentially just binary, Redstone that’s turned on is a 1 and off is a 0. So it’s basically possible to use Redstone to make a computer program that is coded only using binary, granted it is really really labor intensive since modern day computer programmers have the benefit of things like coding languages and 3D modeling software that can do a lot of the work for us and really powerful CPU’s and GPU’s that can process thousands of bits in less than a second. If you look up really early computers, like from the 50’s and 60’s they were extremely simple yet took up an entire room just to process a few KB. These guys were working with even less than that which demonstrates how momentous of an accomplishment this computer is
there's youtuber that milk content 10% as impressive as this for 20-40mins and you did a 3min video of this that's sped up but still shows hours of work. Hats off man!
Hours? This likely took weeks, even with the help of copy/pasting builds.
@@antibull4869 game time is usually displayed as hours. That's why I said hours. Was def hundreds of hours
He works so hard
Good point. Gotta respect that.
it literally said at the start of the video that it took many months
This is one of the greatest projects I've ever seen. Can't imagine the amount of work needed to accomplish this. I'm also very happy that you understand the importance of running DOOM on every hardware in existence.
Actually they are trying to run Doom on software, that is not meant to run Doom... So, maybe a new challenge. Run Doom on every Software :)
@@drachenreiter1296 Not a new challenge.
Since Doom II, I believe, that people have been running Doom on Software too.
Although, I would argue that there's no such thing as software "not meant to run Doom". Existence is meant to run Doom.
One of the greatest feats in all of game history. A game so complex, with players experienced enough to reach its fullest potential. The game, inside the game.
Meh, Minecraft is just a really fucking slow VM lol
This is like Matrix stuff level lol
With you guys around minecraft we could even break the game in a different way which you did right now this is so stunning i cant even make a number display screen with buttons in minecraft while you built minecraft in minecraft very very unbelievable dude you team are the redstone gods i can bet that. Still soo unbelievable keep up your work and i am waiting for more projects like these from you geys.
Now I've truly seen it all
I didn't expect you to be here. Love your videos
its crazy that you only have one reply
When I first met sam on CK I didn't know he was such a tremendous redstoner. With time I learned that he was insane... but this goes beyond every scope!!!
oh hi marv
Oh hey there Marv
Halfway through the video I completely forgot that this was in Minecraft and I thought it was an IRL computer running it. Absolutely insane. My brain has vaporized into nothingness.
1st
I mean there is a real computer running it..
For for the people I haven’t realized this video sped up 2 million times and at the end 5.8 million
I won't lie, opening this video I expected to see the simplest 2D analogue of minecraft, more like Tetris. It's just unbelievable
@KINDLY HELP ME REACH TO 99K SUB fuck off bot
@KINDLY HELP ME REACH TO 99K SUB WOWW DON’T TALK
Everyone who worked on this should receive an award. This is one of the most insane accomplishments in video game history. Phenomenal work!
Fun fact: anything declared "turing complete" can achieve this. It just depends on how many lifetimes you want to spend trying to work on it. Even the card game Magic: The Gathering is turing complete btw x)
The reweard they recived was getting their post removed on reddit
@@louisrobitaille5810 The game of life has also been made to run itself!!! That is the first "game" that I know of to actually create itself within itself. And Mc now to be the first 3d game to be made within itself!!!
lol no
@@DAEDRICDUKE1 I 100% rdr2, this feat is more impressive.
I love how they make the most advanced redstone contraptions and call it by the dumbest acronyms. Real world computer manufacturers take note.
NASA has been doing it for as long as they've been around!!
I don't want an "RTX4.0 Model D" I want a GAG card (good asf graphics)
I worked for a semiconductor manufacturing company, and they already do this, but they're creatively hidden 😆
Tony Stark called one of his inventions, or one of his employee's invention BARF.
Ever heard of a flip-flop or a nyble?
That's literally impossible, my brain can't figure out how you made this!!
Its easy, i know how to do it)
@@pshego_pgits not easy and you don't know
@@eiskalt4259 let me play unlimited time and give me minecraft for free, i will show the MAGIC
@@eiskalt4259if you know computer engineering and all the concepts, its not very hard, just very repetitive and sometimes confusing
@@recon_leech4 yes but its far away from easy, you Need Computer Engineering Knowledge and you have to know how its done in minecraft AND you have to spend a lot of time
The amount of remarkable things in this is astounding. Forget designing an entire computer, lets start with how do 3 guys just write a version of Minecraft that fits in 8kb “in their spare time”? The amount of effort put into all of this is severely underrated
for real, it's already very challenging to make your own 3d graphics system with an actual programming language. these guys did it in minecraft, using only redstone, on their own virtual computer made entirely of redstone. like DAYUM
underrated ?
Not only that, but in pure binary too.
My man, my brother in Christ, you made a computer, in a computer, and then made it run the thing it was in. It is impossible to put into words how spectacular that is.
Look up "life in life" too.
Vm
Wait till you hear about “emulators”
Amen bro
@@MierdaAzul
Saying “harder than emulators” is a bit of a stretch but fair.
If Mojang doesn’t see this and at least comment on it, it would be the only thing I would be disappointed on, because this is just amazing!
Inb4 they come in and SLAP these guys with a copyright infringement suit for attempting to reverse engineer and recreate Minecraft while calling it Minecraft
this is part of the plan, they wanted Mojang OS
the fact that you have less than 100k subs is crazy, you deserve some more subs man.
If the normal viewers are already impressed, imagine the actual Engineers and students!!
This is ridiculously awesome and unreal, they used an entire knowledge of how computer works,
and applied it, and finished the entire project…
I’m really impressed, and it gives me hope to finish my grade
it has nothing to do with "how the computer works", only related to programming
@@klendow there’s a huge difference between programming a simple Java code, and make an entire structure of game with Red Stone and Command Block.
@@klendow apparent ignorance gives one away so fast that no one was even tempted to like your comment lol
@@klendow nah man this is using logic gates basically programming at the hardware level and designing of the hardware to compute the instructions.
This sucks cause it’s not in color lol
This is spectacular. This should be recognized in more than just the Minecraft community.
There is a lvl of ingenuity, dedication and just straight up mad scientist vibes here that it needs to be shared
Beautiful. Some would say that redstone has peaked, and I was saying that too.
However, truly, it's actually not an end, but the beginning of a new era. Redstone never has been so impressive! Thanks Sammy, Uwerta, Stack and everyone of the computational redstone community! Let's continue pushing onwards to great new heights!!
1st
Hi sloimay
Hi Slomay
Sammy, Uwerta, Stack... with that team, I can see how they named that graphics processor.
This is really mindblowing, love the amount of passion put into it, congrats❤
Im a software developer with a sidehustle in hardware engineering, even though I probably understand every used concept that went into this system, I still wouldn’t even fathom trying to build it. The days and months alone just preparing the blueprints and optimizing I/O syncs so memory address routing doesn’t break the entire thing would drive me mad… building this is not just about implementing known concepts, it’s about creating new ones with „logical hardware programming“. I did this in other games for years, and it’s a very useful skill to have as a person.
I know nothing about programming, so my question is, could they theoretically take this even further? And how far that would be? Could they improve on graphics and game mechanics in this game within the game?
@@lippi2171 there is basically nothing stopping them, if you put enough time into it, eventually you could recreate the game as it is right now, there are mechanics with falling concrete blocks that allow for colored screens for example.
The only two limitations in terms of applicability are speed and Render distance, and they combat both of those things with mods i assume. It's just that at a certain point, this becomes insanely complex. Imagine rewriting the entirety of Minecrafts Codebase, but in a version of Java that you had to develop yourself, which then gets compiled to Vector-Language and on hardware you have to come up with in the first place.
This here already is outside of my own imaginary boundaries, imagine how insane this would become if you start to recreate the actual game state. I doubt that even sammyuri and his team are THAT dedicated to go to these extremes just to prove a concept. We talk about years of development.
@@hitbox7422 that's pretty cool actually, thanks for your insight
This video gives me even worse imposter syndrome haha. I also study programming and this shit is beyond crazy, i don't understand how someone is able to build this.
@@okdk2362 I know what you mean haha 😂 I assume they got an entire community dedicated to building compact circuits within the game. They probably spend days on end trying to optimize simple stuff like ROM storage blocks or address registers and got an entire database of litematica prints for all kinds of IC‘s.
This might be one of the most impressive things i've seen not just in this video games but overall. This is genuinely such a mindbreaking invention.
What about a real computer?
Unifores they were essentially able to create a computer from scratch using red stone that is very impressive
@@jjagpal504 Indeed it is, but still it's more impresive all the possible things they did when they created real computers.
@@uniforesVery impressive for sure. But I think the reason people think this is more impressive is because in real life computer manufacturing we have WAY more components and options for building a computer. They're essentially recreating a game with the bare minimum of logic possible, just stacked in ingenious ways. That's why it's so impressive!
This already happend a year before the industrial revolution (if my memory still serves me), when a lathe was used to build/make another lathe.
These guys didn't mess around with 2D Minecraft as I would expect. They went straight to 3D and it's still somewhat playable!!
@KINDLY HELP ME REACH TO 99K SUB Yes we didn't.
@KINDLY HELP ME REACH TO 99K SUB my guy asking for 99k subs with 200 😂
@KINDLY HELP ME REACH TO 99K SUB yep
Not just that, they created a funtional graphic processor!
This could be a first step of free gpu hardware design.
It's sped up 2,000,000x tho
one day we will be having a working ps 5 inside minecraft
I think it's extraordinary that you practically need an engineering degree to even start to appreciate the magnitude of this project.
As a Software Engineer, I'm in _total_ awe.
nice ! :)
As a software engineer, I just realized how clueless I am about hardware. I knew a thing or two, capacitors, how ram works, how cpu works to some extend but wow. I can't even imagine how this is working.
Same here lol. I was never very interested in the hardware side of things although I did very well in my Computer Hardware class in college where we learned assembly and how processors work (I remember pretty much nothing of course). But wow, this thing is insane. It's incredible what people have done in Minecraft.
@@25Yasindayim Its because you have the sowftware side but also the electric side wich is more about the physics parts. No one really learn both of them. They learn one or the other because it’s a lot of knowledge. Probably the main reason giving the need of a team. Its the same in real life.
This redstone creation will go down in not only redstone history, but it will be cemented in Minecraft history. A truly remarkable achievement by this team of 3.
Actually not them only. There are a whole community behind the URCL.
Probably go down in engineering history as well
mumbo jumbo
@@artofrjm probably? It will 100% be in the minecraft history books, why wouldn't it be?
0:50
AMOGUS grapics processor is a best processor in a history
We have Minecraft in Minecraft before GTA 6
We might get GTA 6 in Minecraft before GTA 6 at this point
*DOOM the Dark Ages
@@RDJ1997frrr
how broo felt after commenting this🥵🥵🥵🥶🥶🥶🥶🥵😎😎😈😈😈😈😈👽👽👽👽💀💀💀💩☠☠💦💦💦💥
Mother of God. This has to be the most advanced Minecraft RC yet. This should be submitted to Guinness World Records. This is insane.
You guys are insane!!! The only thing left to do now is add redstone to minecraft and kickstart the cycle all over again...
why are you here? but fr ong no kappa your right
Still astounding that a render engine can be built within another already compiled game.
I just started playing minecraft and legit felt like I was hacking when I got my trashcan to work properly....
What? I was already impressed by Mattbatwing's Multi line renderer, and now there is an entire 3D and physics engine. If it wasn't by you I would think it is fake.
Same
I am not scared of computers taking over the world. I scared of people who can use computers LIKE THIS
actually. they're crazy
Its easy. U guys are lazy
@@VideosViraisVirais-dc7nxYour mom’s easy, let me hit almost every day last week. Only had to miss it one day because she was too busy complaining about you.
Minecraft won't hurt you
@@UnbannedAgain yes dude, yes it will
Gratz with becoming IGM!
This is absolutely insane. My mind simply cannot fathom the amount of planning and labor that likely went into building this. I am simultaneously amazed, impressed, and absolutely horrified. ;-)
Keep it at 555
The visuals are my favorite part, because it looks like if Minecraft was on the original Gameboy. It's beautiful.
Wow.. This is incredible!! JUST HOW? I can't believe that this is possible with redstone. This is truly a work of art!!
Logic gates
Minecraft is Turing Complete, you just need a powerful enough computer to handle it in the emulation / simulation of building it within itself and running it...
It takes galaxies to emulate or simulate atoms, yet it takes uncountable atoms to make a single galaxy!!!
wow i really don't know what to say but you took this famous blocky game to a whole new level, you can play minecraft in minecraft
I'm pretty sure you can include a project like this in a resume to prove your worth to a company of high standard, because the time, knowledge and dedication to the craft is ludicrous, not a fan of reddit but I understand the pain of your post being taken down, this is probably one of the most impressive red stone projects I've ever seen, comming close to the one that allowed people to order irl pizza with a phone built all in minecraft, congratulations.
This isn't really a case of "plucky gamer has gaming skills so powerful companies need them".
The skills required to make this are mostly just a whole lot of computer science and electronic engineering.
It is basically impossible to make this without having side projects that are even more impressive, or more likely decades of experience working at the appropriate field.
As my fellow pre-commenter allready stated, this project and everything in it is on itself impressive in terms of dedication, but the components used in it are just scaled down, allready existing IC-modules. Everyone, including me, with a proper understanding of advanced computer engineering would be capable of replicating it.
@@hitbox7422 I mean it's an impressive architecture in it's own right.
Humanity no longer really tries to optimize circuitry for hyperspecific tasks, not for games at least.
A part of me wants to see how far you can optimize hardware for minecraft specifically, make it run on a 1$ chip.
Like for example we don't really do graphic processors for computers of this size, and if you try to make this run on your washing machine, it will be incredibly inefficient due to lack of parallel computing.
@@hitbox7422 this particular program would still probably run just fine on a washing machine lol. Modern microcontrollers have a ridiculous amount of power.
Would make for a great side project.
That "phone" project was not even remotely close to this one.
I have no idea why people keep mentioning it here, let alone assuming it was more impressive?? Have you guys even watched any of the two past thumbnail?
I always believed that one day someone will make Minecraft in Minecraft. Now, I can't even fathom the joy I'm feeling to see this creation with my own eyes.
Who will make the first Minecraft inside of the Minecraft inside of Minecraft 🤯
@@maximanya7144 Joe
Basically this a proof that we are "living" in a computer simulation - and that the real world is much more complex, with more dimensions and stuff; right?
@@dnoodspodu1159 agree
@@dnoodspodu1159 DMT
I remember watching sethbling videos from 10 years ago where he would show off these incredible creations. The things he did in minecraft were unfathomable, and he just kept pushing them further and further. Under all of his videos would be so many comments saying "one step closer to running minecraft in minecraft". It was unimaginable to me that that could happen, it's completely ridiculous, but here we are, 10 years later, and you've actually done it! I can't wait to see how you guys push the boundaries of redstone even further
and Seth bling did stuff using command blocks, this uses no command blocks :o
Tbf, this minecraft in minecraft is unplayable. Something like .00001 fps. At least sethblings gameboy emulator ran on 1 fps if I remember.
I also remember that.
I hope this man joins the medical industry with his brilliant mind because we need more cures available to the people for diseases like copd and emphysema
Like man the boundaries are way bigger than you imagine, red stone works like the way pc works, with 0s and 1s its impossible to replicate a pc but you can do a lot of stuff
Normally I don’t like videos but this deserves every like possible because how much more creative can yall get? This is UNBELIEVABLE. My mind is literally aching trying to figure out how this is possible lmao. How do you even make a SCREEN?!
wow. I honestly don't know how you guys did this. My mind has been officially blown in spectacular fashion. :D
This video is making me think I might need to upgrade my dirt house to a wood one. But truly, this is incredible, wow.
Hi
Lol
Dirt can't burn. (Insert tapping head meme)
@@SubLordHawkFlying machine Redstone can't melt iron blocks
when you realize that what he built only had kilobytes worth of processing power but his actual machine probably used orders of magnitude more than that in order to create this masterpiece...
Notch was able to make minecraft with 4kB of ram and this dude has done it in just 1, inside of minecraft
You sir, are a God of Redstone.
It's fake
This is like creating a computer using logic-gates, protoboards and jumpers and then making Minecraft run on that. Absolutely amazing
Mollymauk what are you doing here! 😂
Not only that, but you're doing it inside minecraft with it's limited resources
And with really slow "electricity "propagation
I'm disappointed that I can't fully understand and appreciate how difficult this task must have been, and the amount of work required to accomplish it.
It doesn't take much to understand at least the basic concept of it.
I only know some programming and electronics basics, but I fully appreciate and crown this the greatest feat in Minecraft and maybe even possibly the greatest feat in all of gaming history
Still, I'm also a little frustrated that I don't know exactly how it works and cannot fully comprehend the actual effort it must have taken, only guess-estimate
@@hak0bu I think it took a lot of effort but the prerequisite knowledge isn't necessarily much. Take a free online course on computer architecture, like nand2tetris, and you could build a simpler version of this yourself. One course would really be all it takes. The hard part is designing an assembly language and then writing a program in said language. Yikes. And then the abysmal framerate... I don't know if it's worth the effort unless you're going to make a UA-cam video about it.
@@stone_pilot as someone who’s done nand2tetris, and built some simple computer components in Minecraft, it’s not comparable. This is far more than just that. They had to individually construct each part of the hardware, down to the individual logic gates for each part. They had to create 3d rendering from scratch that runs in Minecraft, they also had to then add the fundamentals of minecraft into the program. Doing that alone normally is already decently impressive, but to do all of that on a computer you built from scratch in a game is just ridiculous.
@@meta02 I can see how the way I wrote my comment may give the impression that I'm discrediting the difficulty of this project. I'm not. This would be a monstrous undertaking. The point I was trying to make was that the underlying concepts are surprisingly simple and easy to learn. The hard part has always been implementing them. Since we've mentioned it twice now, nand2tetris grows extremely effort-intensive as the project grows in complexity from basic logic gates to the ALU, CPU, RAM, Assembler, and OS. Each step grows increasingly more work intensive, and that's using a text editor and an architecture that has already been designed for you.
When I made this comment I was thinking about all the people who see something like this and comment along the lines of 'Wow, I'm really struggling just to make a piston door this is crazy'. The reason you're struggling to make a piston door is because you don't understand even the simplest logic gates. You can do it too! It's really easy to learn.
I know this because when I was 12 I thought redstone was magic and I didn't get it at all. I took one CS course in HS and suddenly I was capable of so much more.
@@meta02 Ridiculous is the right word.
So how powerful should we make this redstone computer?
Sammyuri: *yes*
you could explain this to me in a hundred different ways and my brain would not be able to wrap around how any of this even works. youve worked minecraft magic for sure.
Just the fact that redstone, freaking redstone in Minecraft can run a 3D space that you can walk around in honestly blows my mind, incredible work!
What’s even crazier is that the devs probably never intended for that to be the case, either. This is players making the most out of what they’re given.
@@carcinogeneticist378 i don't think so. you know that you are watching this video and my comment on redstone (*cough*)? redstone can build logic gates. your computer, phone is made of logic gates. you only need this to do everything. thats why implementing redstone made minecraft way better. they literally multiplied infinite by infinite
Minecraft is turing complete
You can break reality with redstone
@@carcinogeneticist378 It's a lot more impressive than the devs making something possible without intending to. Cause this isn't Mojang's Minecraft. This is DO's optimized Minecraft server - running redstone *a lot* faster than vanilla MC can.
My man. I am a Computer Science student. And holy shit the headache of bugfixes I see. I truly commend you sirs this is beautiful.
Yep, bug fixing this was an absolute nightmare. I think doing the actual building hardware/programming was far below 25% of the time spent on this project.
@@sammyuri like you have to wait hours to even see if one of your fix worked
I can only say wow. This is fantastic, as a computer science student I believe that things like these are what motivate us and the analysis of them brings us lessons and opens new directions. I qualify this as art. Just like you're running Minecraft there, we could play pacman, or snake, etc, right? I still can not believe it.
Congrats for adding such a marvel to my life. Honestly the most mind-blowing thing I've seen today.