no monetization on this video but idegaf like i can not explain to yall how many times i had to render this at like 3 am multiple nights 😭😭 i just want it out like god damn wtf. anyways, next video will likely be the quick review I made about artms’s DALL, it’s very brief ✌🏽👍🏽⭐️
From the reveal to the final concepts photos this album honestly never cought my interest, it just felt soulless, but not in an intentional or eerie way but rather in a dull and boring way. I‘m happy the music video was nice at least, if only they had more passion, time and maybe budget I feel like this could‘ve been a pretty memorable rollout, but this video honestly reminded me that wish you hell even exists lol.
i mean, you already said this but yea everything abt this comeback was just too pristine for the story they wanted to tell & concept they wanted to do. where’s the color? where’s the camp? where’s the textures?
its insane how they took every opportunity not to do something cool for the album. so many references missed, stylistic choices in the dumpster and charm lost it’s depressing
I remember when this was coming out i was confused but it made more sense once the MV was released. I REALLY wished they would’ve fully leaned into the 80s campy horror aesthetic of the MV to the whole concept/rollout as a whole! Like seeing Wendy looking at herself in the coffin was cool af and imo they could’ve translated that into the concept photos and album packaging as well! Like a coffin-shaped album would’ve been dope (i feel like this was mentioned before by someone but im not sure 😭). And the only positive i have for the concept photos/design is the scrapbooking! I think if they fully went into that route, as well as make it super personalized and super 80s, and have some pages in the album be different textures, have wendy write the lyrics herself and things that make her nostalgic, and stuff that pertains to the album concept would’ve been cool! I just remember feeling like everything else was all over the place and it upsets me because the concept in theory (especially the MV), would’ve been really great and beautiful! I just wish companies would stop being so polished with the photography and the production as a whole because it makes everything less fun like you said (and screams “money” too) Like seeing how polished her photos are given the concept is about her feeling heartbroken and leaving a toxic/messy relationship, gives me a headache (or maybe I’m just hungry lol) but it gives that same energy! And as always you do a great job explaining everything properly and I also loved the silica gel packet on the images too! It’s my favorite object you used! 🩵🤍🩶
18:45 No but it's crazy the fact that I can make a prettier and more interesting digital scrapbook in canva with pngs out of pinterest than a multi millionaire, well known company with enough resources. SM once again fails horribly at trying to create this style because when I think of a scrapbook I think about scribbles, lots of texture and unique patterns but SM sometimes will just place perfectly square pictures on top of each other resulting in a boring and lazy result that looks like something I would've done when I first started designing in canva.
Loved your analysis!! it makes me so upset how they screwed all of this idea but I kinda get why, wish you hell as a mini album is hard to conceptualize in my opinion but it doesnt justify the mess.. in terms of music is cohesive and follows a calm but fierce vibe to it which they failed to embody in my opinion. wendy had a clear vision since the mv direction was clear and less vague but the whole mini album had potential to do something rare and unique. i FEEL something similar happened with irene's recent debut which honestly just like wish you hell might have tried many different things and concepts at once that when i watched the music video i wasnt satisfied
irene had a slight advantage compared to wendy given that woocheol jo apparently helped out with her debut (most likely to make sure there is consistent branding amongst the girls debuts), but i do have to agree. given his involvement i was hoping we could get more dynamic shots but other than 2 really eye catching sets (for me) I was rather underwhelmed as well. not bad of course, i think given the state of center 3 all red velvet projects will be handicapped by their lack of agency and daring…but certainly not what it could’ve been under their original team. i think like a flower manages to salvage itself before its conclusion, which wish you hell just couldn’t. also thank you for listening 🐬🌺🩷✨
I wished with the mv or somewhere in the rollout they incorporated another color. Something like pink or red to signal at the start Wendy is head over heels in love for a man and signifying that not only is this *feeling* is foreign for Wendy but even to the viewer who knows blue is her signature color, the *color* she’s wearing is foreign to us as well. Then it could gradually progress to her signature blue signaling that Wendy is back loving herself and ending a relationship that proved not beneficial for her in the first place
love your review 🥰 honestly i was completely disinterested by the first teaser, it’s just not my thing and it felt polished but in a boring way. i do see the vision now and now i suffer
seems like most were if i recalled everyone’s reactions at the time and the people she lost in the rollout really never came back, let alone revisited it to try and understand the story they’re weaving. i don’t really blame them, first impressions are important
i need SM to get it together for RV! They don’t care anymore and it upsets me! That nail in the coffin was them AI images and I’m still upset to this day…
i was rlly excited for this project, since i was super curious to see how she’ll change her concept for her solo comeback but.. i can see why people don’t appreciate the art direction 🥲 it was super messy & the concept didnt really stand out.. (although i do really love the mv) 💖
I love this honest remarks as Wendy stan. I hope her next work would be conveyed artistically with much focus and assistance. I agree she needs a creative team with much effort. ~ Center 3 🤢
The design was hot garbage, but I love the album. My favorite solo artist album this year actually. Hope she gets better in the future though. She and the rest of the group need to fight for a better contract if they’re staying.
@@Lady_bugg9316 it’s unsure whether they’ll be able to fight for something better given that this is supposed to be the improved conditions after their previous negotiations
@ I don’t see why not. If their contract is about to end and SM wants to keep them then they’ll work with them for a better contract. That might include that the girls get more autonomy in their work and make more music or do more collabs and all that.
@@Lady_bugg9316 i just don’t see that working out for them, taeyeon is one of their heavyweights and even she has now spoken out about the mismanagement of her current album she just released. it doesn’t seem sm is interested in improving their work relationship. only way to see any hope for RV is their original team returning which is near impossible giving the new center system as many of them have been split up. woocheol offering to work on irene’s debut is as close as we’re getting to a return back in quality
@shprism the way they treat soloists has akways been garbage in comparison to geoups, but i get it. I'll continue hoping they'll fight for something better, though
I like this channel and love your style. Just constructive criticism: i think this video would be soo much easier to get through if the voice of the voiceover wasn‘t so piercing and like an annoying doll if i may say. It get‘s really difficult to concentrate after a while and annoying to listen to. I like your takes i hope you get my intention.. i think your content is qualitative. It‘s just this voice here😭. You can do whatever you like though.. i‘m just saying and i‘m sure i‘m not the only one that thinks it. It‘s a little like those barbie phone noises but it‘s not just some seconds but for 30 min content that you genuinely want to listen and get into. It‘s very penetrating on the ears. Thank you💜
@@shprism nooooo😭. I swear this video was awesome and spot on. I‘ve been looking for someone to speak on Wendys album and you summed up what i was thinking which was satisfying and even explained what i couldn’t put my hands on with why i thought the way i thought.. I find the way they manage Wendy horrible honestly.. i know for a fact that she loves working and works hard on her albums. So videos like these are important and you did well✨. It was only the voice😭. I listened to it without headphones and it‘s not even as bad anymore!🩵 I‘m probably just too sensitive HAHAH.
@Funa_Takaya WAIT NO NO FHDJDJD IM LAUGHING AT THAT IM NOT CRYINGJFIDD DO NOT WORRYFFJDKS also ive been working on trying to figure out something new in terms of voiceover situations, my gf doesn’t like the robot voice either! i just don’t have a good quality mic right now which is what a lot of people used to complain about before i switched over - so i’m trying to bts to figure out something in these next few months, thank you for the constructive criticism mwuah
@@shprismI guessed it near 16 min mark since Im quite sure the necklace comes from Marc jacobs (who may also have a weird spirit I tuned out from that man years ago). And yes I know about Alexander want it’s not even allegation theres like 3 different video of him touching men without consent. I can’t stand him.
oh we are so happy to see you back! tuned out of this release bc the teaser rollout was so uninteresting and the music didn't seem to be my taste, but i still thoroughly enjoyed your breakdown 🫶 it's really fascinating to see you explain how this could've been executed in a way that truly brought the concept to life! really looking forward to your take on dall 🥺 i was so so so disappointed when i heard the members touch on the actual point of the concepts (nighttime vampire gothic witches??? daytime blue ballerinas statues representing sadness??? artms' garden of eden???). it seems like modhaus failed to commit to any of their own ideas properly, like usual 🥲
happy to be back for you all 🥺🐬🌺💕✨ and i’m happy that despite many of you tuning out of this one, yall loved this review and felt like it cleared a lot of things up. honestly made it worth it to pursue this one! my take on dall is very harsh i won’t lie:):$:& i keep second guessing or whether or not to release it because i don’t want my critiques to be confused as an attack on the girls but more so the team who worked on it and did such a mediocre job. i feel like people can not separate the two, not to mention-people get extremely nasty in regards to anything modhaus related so i really do hate touching them with a 10 foot pole 😭 i was discussing with my girlfriend whether or not to still release
no monetization on this video but idegaf like i can not explain to yall how many times i had to render this at like 3 am multiple nights 😭😭 i just want it out like god damn wtf. anyways, next video will likely be the quick review I made about artms’s DALL, it’s very brief ✌🏽👍🏽⭐️
Girl, give us a patrion and we’ll fix that monetisation issue
🙂↕️🫂 soon i promise
From the reveal to the final concepts photos this album honestly never cought my interest, it just felt soulless, but not in an intentional or eerie way but rather in a dull and boring way.
I‘m happy the music video was nice at least, if only they had more passion, time and maybe budget I feel like this could‘ve been a pretty memorable rollout, but this video honestly reminded me that wish you hell even exists lol.
the last sentence 😭
it’s literally just a dream bc no one does movie soundtracks anymore, but red velvet should’ve been featured in the “lisa frankenstein” soundtrack.
100%
love how passionate u r about typography
after it being my least liked area of design until i turned 19 lmao
@ oh wow
i mean, you already said this but yea everything abt this comeback was just too pristine for the story they wanted to tell & concept they wanted to do. where’s the color? where’s the camp? where’s the textures?
its insane how they took every opportunity not to do something cool for the album. so many references missed, stylistic choices in the dumpster and charm lost it’s depressing
man i feel like who ever is managing rv is lately not giving a fuck and i want to CRYYY like i love my girls so much what is this
💔
still shuddering at that one set of cosmic teaser
@gyal7892 💔💔💔💔💔💔
I remember when this was coming out i was confused but it made more sense once the MV was released. I REALLY wished they would’ve fully leaned into the 80s campy horror aesthetic of the MV to the whole concept/rollout as a whole! Like seeing Wendy looking at herself in the coffin was cool af and imo they could’ve translated that into the concept photos and album packaging as well! Like a coffin-shaped album would’ve been dope (i feel like this was mentioned before by someone but im not sure 😭). And the only positive i have for the concept photos/design is the scrapbooking! I think if they fully went into that route, as well as make it super personalized and super 80s, and have some pages in the album be different textures, have wendy write the lyrics herself and things that make her nostalgic, and stuff that pertains to the album concept would’ve been cool! I just remember feeling like everything else was all over the place and it upsets me because the concept in theory (especially the MV), would’ve been really great and beautiful! I just wish companies would stop being so polished with the photography and the production as a whole because it makes everything less fun like you said (and screams “money” too) Like seeing how polished her photos are given the concept is about her feeling heartbroken and leaving a toxic/messy relationship, gives me a headache (or maybe I’m just hungry lol) but it gives that same energy!
And as always you do a great job explaining everything properly and I also loved the silica gel packet on the images too! It’s my favorite object you used! 🩵🤍🩶
thank you!! 🩷🌺✨
you put so much effort into this, monetized or not i’m happy people will get to see and enjoy it
THIS NEW INTRO IS GODLY MIAM
tankchuuuuu sniffle
18:45 No but it's crazy the fact that I can make a prettier and more interesting digital scrapbook in canva with pngs out of pinterest than a multi millionaire, well known company with enough resources. SM once again fails horribly at trying to create this style because when I think of a scrapbook I think about scribbles, lots of texture and unique patterns but SM sometimes will just place perfectly square pictures on top of each other resulting in a boring and lazy result that looks like something I would've done when I first started designing in canva.
@@fayette_ it’s one my biggest complaints when it comes to album packages from SM. just very lazy
Loved your analysis!!
it makes me so upset how they screwed all of this idea but I kinda get why, wish you hell as a mini album is hard to conceptualize in my opinion but it doesnt justify the mess.. in terms of music is cohesive and follows a calm but fierce vibe to it which they failed to embody in my opinion. wendy had a clear vision since the mv direction was clear and less vague but the whole mini album had potential to do something rare and unique.
i FEEL something similar happened with irene's recent debut which honestly just like wish you hell might have tried many different things and concepts at once that when i watched the music video i wasnt satisfied
irene had a slight advantage compared to wendy given that woocheol jo apparently helped out with her debut (most likely to make sure there is consistent branding amongst the girls debuts), but i do have to agree. given his involvement i was hoping we could get more dynamic shots but other than 2 really eye catching sets (for me) I was rather underwhelmed as well. not bad of course, i think given the state of center 3 all red velvet projects will be handicapped by their lack of agency and daring…but certainly not what it could’ve been under their original team. i think like a flower manages to salvage itself before its conclusion, which wish you hell just couldn’t. also thank you for listening 🐬🌺🩷✨
I wished with the mv or somewhere in the rollout they incorporated another color. Something like pink or red to signal at the start Wendy is head over heels in love for a man and signifying that not only is this *feeling* is foreign for Wendy but even to the viewer who knows blue is her signature color, the *color* she’s wearing is foreign to us as well. Then it could gradually progress to her signature blue signaling that Wendy is back loving herself and ending a relationship that proved not beneficial for her in the first place
oh certainly!
love your review 🥰
honestly i was completely disinterested by the first teaser, it’s just not my thing and it felt polished but in a boring way. i do see the vision now and now i suffer
seems like most were if i recalled everyone’s reactions at the time and the people she lost in the rollout really never came back, let alone revisited it to try and understand the story they’re weaving. i don’t really blame them, first impressions are important
Watching this instead of studying for my college finals 🩵
HEY?? GO STUDY.
i need SM to get it together for RV! They don’t care anymore and it upsets me! That nail in the coffin was them AI images and I’m still upset to this day…
it’s been so bad for my girls recently sigh
i was rlly excited for this project, since i was super curious to see how she’ll change her concept for her solo comeback but.. i can see why people don’t appreciate the art direction 🥲
it was super messy & the concept didnt really stand out.. (although i do really love the mv) 💖
also glad 2 see ur back! :~)💖💖
it’s very unfortunate 😭 i was excited as well, it’s sickening how much center 3 fumbled it
@@shprism exactly! i was expecting a little bit more.. especially from SM 🤦🏽♀️
ALSO also, i can’t wait to see your outro in the future 🥰
way i didnt even think about it Stappp i want itty
you’re back!! I like the new intro!!
i ammmm and thank youuuu 🐬🌺💞
the intro is so pretty 💜
thank you!! 🩷🩷
so glad ur posting legend
i love you all so much omg 🌺🩷 i could never stop posting
waking up to the notification ahhhhhh >>>>>
this rare ass shprism bingo card experience
cause i take eons to post i’m crying
I wish I understood typography better, but alas, I am a Comic Sans enjoyer through and through
😭😭😭😭
@@shprism "It's quirky, I swear!"
also i’m glad someone finally said what i been thinking about her logo lol shit from the butt
HELP
love the video a lot
@@kpopmood_ thank youuu 🩷
I love this honest remarks as Wendy stan. I hope her next work would be conveyed artistically with much focus and assistance. I agree she needs a creative team with much effort. ~ Center 3 🤢
@@rylle_rd the album was so good this time around too like ugh
you're back!!
i am i am 🌺🐬💕
ALSO also also, ily 💕💕💕💞💞💞
i love you moreeee baby
Gay (uplifting, positive, empowering, supportive)
we are so back....
LIKEEE
The design was hot garbage, but I love the album. My favorite solo artist album this year actually. Hope she gets better in the future though. She and the rest of the group need to fight for a better contract if they’re staying.
@@Lady_bugg9316 it’s unsure whether they’ll be able to fight for something better given that this is supposed to be the improved conditions after their previous negotiations
@ I don’t see why not. If their contract is about to end and SM wants to keep them then they’ll work with them for a better contract. That might include that the girls get more autonomy in their work and make more music or do more collabs and all that.
@@Lady_bugg9316 i just don’t see that working out for them, taeyeon is one of their heavyweights and even she has now spoken out about the mismanagement of her current album she just released. it doesn’t seem sm is interested in improving their work relationship. only way to see any hope for RV is their original team returning which is near impossible giving the new center system as many of them have been split up. woocheol offering to work on irene’s debut is as close as we’re getting to a return back in quality
@shprism the way they treat soloists has akways been garbage in comparison to geoups, but i get it. I'll continue hoping they'll fight for something better, though
SOOOO EXCITEDDDD
I like this channel and love your style. Just constructive criticism: i think this video would be soo much easier to get through if the voice of the voiceover wasn‘t so piercing and like an annoying doll if i may say. It get‘s really difficult to concentrate after a while and annoying to listen to. I like your takes i hope you get my intention.. i think your content is qualitative. It‘s just this voice here😭. You can do whatever you like though.. i‘m just saying and i‘m sure i‘m not the only one that thinks it. It‘s a little like those barbie phone noises but it‘s not just some seconds but for 30 min content that you genuinely want to listen and get into. It‘s very penetrating on the ears. Thank you💜
barbie phone noises is making me tear UP
@@shprism nooooo😭. I swear this video was awesome and spot on. I‘ve been looking for someone to speak on Wendys album and you summed up what i was thinking which was satisfying and even explained what i couldn’t put my hands on with why i thought the way i thought.. I find the way they manage Wendy horrible honestly.. i know for a fact that she loves working and works hard on her albums. So videos like these are important and you did well✨. It was only the voice😭. I listened to it without headphones and it‘s not even as bad anymore!🩵 I‘m probably just too sensitive HAHAH.
@Funa_Takaya WAIT NO NO FHDJDJD IM LAUGHING AT THAT IM NOT CRYINGJFIDD DO NOT WORRYFFJDKS also ive been working on trying to figure out something new in terms of voiceover situations, my gf doesn’t like the robot voice either! i just don’t have a good quality mic right now which is what a lot of people used to complain about before i switched over - so i’m trying to bts to figure out something in these next few months, thank you for the constructive criticism mwuah
@@shprism oooh i get that. So i guess we always complain seems like HAHA. It‘s literally fine so. Much love to you!💜✨
I HEAR MARIAH CAREY
Welcome back from the shadow realm 🫶🏾
thank you for the warm welcome 🧘🏽♀️🌺🐬💕
8:51 who?? And what piece the Jersey or the necklace?
the jersey-from the brand alexander wang (you can see it on the front*) he has multiple allegations of drugging and sexually abusing male models
@@shprismI guessed it near 16 min mark since Im quite sure the necklace comes from Marc jacobs (who may also have a weird spirit I tuned out from that man years ago).
And yes I know about Alexander want it’s not even allegation theres like 3 different video of him touching men without consent. I can’t stand him.
That’s on top of his weird parties….
yessssss
🥺🩵🩷
3.4k views after you been gone for months?!? Oh you’re taking it fren
😩😭
HI NINI 😁
hiiii toastie
Is this ajanugu ?
my name is all over my channel let’s use some context clues
Well i didn’t bother to watch the video so
@@mohhhhhhhhgjghvcythen fuck off?? go fill out a job application instead of being a prick in youtube comments 👍🏾 fucking loser
mind you i said my name is all over my CHANNEL not even the video, niggas can’t read and they stupid womp womp
smbdy free my family from this curse yall cannot be serious 🙂 /derogatory
oh we are so happy to see you back! tuned out of this release bc the teaser rollout was so uninteresting and the music didn't seem to be my taste, but i still thoroughly enjoyed your breakdown 🫶 it's really fascinating to see you explain how this could've been executed in a way that truly brought the concept to life!
really looking forward to your take on dall 🥺 i was so so so disappointed when i heard the members touch on the actual point of the concepts (nighttime vampire gothic witches??? daytime blue ballerinas statues representing sadness??? artms' garden of eden???). it seems like modhaus failed to commit to any of their own ideas properly, like usual 🥲
happy to be back for you all 🥺🐬🌺💕✨ and i’m happy that despite many of you tuning out of this one, yall loved this review and felt like it cleared a lot of things up. honestly made it worth it to pursue this one!
my take on dall is very harsh i won’t lie:):$:& i keep second guessing or whether or not to release it because i don’t want my critiques to be confused as an attack on the girls but more so the team who worked on it and did such a mediocre job. i feel like people can not separate the two, not to mention-people get extremely nasty in regards to anything modhaus related so i really do hate touching them with a 10 foot pole 😭 i was discussing with my girlfriend whether or not to still release
@@shprismall your opps are stupid and cannot formulate a sentence i say go for it sistah share your genius with us /encouraging