Aww, you changed the description! You removed the quote that really made me remember this song. Fortunately I saved it. It was: "Every man has his secret sorrows of which the world knows not; and often at times we call a man cold when he is only sad." It really set the mood for this song! It's a beautiful and contemplative song.
You're welcome! I thought it was a really great quote. I remember it at times when you wouldn't expect to. But it helps me try to be kinder and more understanding of others.
Watching this again in 2020 really hits different;; All the current events of this year are really stressing me out but listening to this just brings me back to the good days, when everything was okay. I had such good memories with this song, it was so relieving to be able to listen to it again in the midst of all the stress I'm in right now. Thank you
"Every man has his secret sorrows of which the world knows not; and often at times we call a man cold when he is only sad." the truth that speaks to me moved me to tears
One of my first songs i ever listen when i was starting in the fandom, listening at 2022 hits you very hard, the nostalgic, when the fandom was very active and those first months in it, makes me sad and makes me happy, sad because those good years will never come back, and happy for being in this amazing fandom filled with good artists and very awesome musitians.
6 years ago I found myself in a state of pure despair and no way out of my own head. Locked up and ashamed and the only tune I could play in my head and tap my fingers to was this. It is so a soothing song to me and puts me right at ease. Mr Warner I absolutely love your newer music but I am almost addicted to the nostalgia of your older works. I will always always be a fan for life. Thank you.
Another legendary piece of musical perfection by Evening Star... Your work shall forever be recognized by the Brony Community. Keep up the good work, and continue making amazing music.
@@Alex-lz9py been for nearing 5 years and unlikely i will get away from it. last 2-3 years it slowly creeped into my music lists as i found amazing artists.
I strongly believe I will cherish the impact it had on me for the entirety of my life. Whatever new experiences or circumstances I encounter in the future, these memories and artifacts will always be there. This place chose me, and when I came out of it I had a new perspective on life and what I could achieve.
I wanna cry when I listen to this music, it reminds me of the happy days when I was young, it just feels weird and good at the same time when I listen to this 😍😍😍😍😍😍
Aaand re-liked. Wanted it to show up on my channel again so I wouldn't have to go searching for it. More beautiful art and serene music. Always puts me at peace no matter what kind of day I've had.
one of my favorite songs (mostly because of the picture and how i can imagine being in the city surrounded with peace and watching the sunset....... I just really love that picture... It makes me feel something. idk what but... something...)
i can really imagine the feeling of seeing cloudsdale as this incredible sight. the overwhelming beauty and excitement. this music adds to it so much. extremely fitting, beautiful, powerful, perfect for the "city in the sky" we all love know as cloudsdale. (also nice change in feeling of cloudsdale from "rainbow factory" XD)
this is a song that cannot be disliked as it is pure music and makes you fell the wonder of our beloved "city in the sky" I like this a milion times over, and then do it again.
One person does not know the meaning of loving or tolerating at all. that man/woman has a deep cold heart that was swallowed many years ago by hate and anguish. that one person is consumed by these horrible feelings and is stuck in a harrowing shell intill that one is long gone in a neverending slumber.
I hope you don't mind, but that kind of inspired me and I built on that and made this: "I do not know the meaning of loving or happiness at all. I have a deep cold heart that was swallowed many years ago by hate and anguish. I feel consumed by these emotions and am stuck in a harrowing shell until I am long gone in a neverending slumber, plagued with nightmares and chaos. I have not ever experienced love, not true love; and due to this, while I have been nothing but bitter, I have also never been bitter. Because having never felt love before, you would think that the bitterness just is. That it never changes. But maybe you can show me... friend. Maybe you can show me what it is like to love and be loved." and yes im aware this is a year old shhh
i like this music so much. Thank you evening star, i like all your music. Your music make me feel i am just flying in the sky or looking the sunset. I like your music and this is my favourite, hope you can made more like this.
Its just so beautifully created and a masterpiece to bask in its peace of harmony! ooh it makes me feel calm and inspired to live another day no matter what!:')
Words cannot express how much i love this specific music. I listen to this kind of stuff everyday specifically yours! Thank you for makeing such beautiful music i can say it has changed my life!
This, this made me subscribe. It's one thing to like music, but one that can make you think about life and feel at complete peace and bring hope. And the title by saying it "City in the Sky" just uplifts you and brings you into a trance feeling like you are flying to the city in the sky.
Once in a long far home, lived a small dove alone, this small dove grew up with a herd of ponies, these ponies died.. leaving this poor dove on its own journey, this dove, grew up alone officially... Now it is up to you, to pick up the dove and move the dove once more!
Another well made touching song. I'm so glad I came across your beautiful music, it's absolutely wonderful. Congratulations my friend, you have earned another loyal subscriber! Please keep up with your amazing work, I'm sure everyone else enjoys it as much as me. Thank you for your music. Just thank you.
-clap- you have created a masterpiece. its so calming and all flowy... can't really describe this music well but it fits the them of Cloudsdale very well. it 'sounds' all 'soft and floaty' like a cloud
I'd give anything for the sheet music for the piano in this song... I wanna learn the piano SO badly.. but all the songs they try to make you learn suck total ass. This "sounds" like something I could start out on... not to mention how much I FUCKING LOVE IT.
Dammit, Evening Star, you awesome. This song is a bit louder on the beat side, a bit "drummier", but still beautiful and lovely and great. It does make me think of a Pegasus city. The ever-so-slightly dubsteppy whum-whum-whum hidden in the beat fits the "city" part, and the dreamy electronic flow is perfect for reflecting the endless expanses of the sky. Thank you! Keep being amazing!
No other fandom I know makes such amazing compositions such as this one...
dark souls put off 2 pieces but thats it. Lordvessel and hollow. Hollow is probably one of the most emotional story telling songs i have ever heard.
Minecraft
Aww, you changed the description! You removed the quote that really made me remember this song. Fortunately I saved it. It was: "Every man has his secret sorrows of which the world knows not; and often at times we call a man cold when he is only sad."
It really set the mood for this song! It's a beautiful and contemplative song.
Thanks for saving that quote
You're welcome! I thought it was a really great quote. I remember it at times when you wouldn't expect to. But it helps me try to be kinder and more understanding of others.
Glad that I'm not the only one who occasionally comes back to Evening Star. I swear, his songs are quite iconic.
Watching this again in 2020 really hits different;;
All the current events of this year are really stressing me out but listening to this just brings me back to the good days, when everything was okay. I had such good memories with this song, it was so relieving to be able to listen to it again in the midst of all the stress I'm in right now. Thank you
Listen to this song as you drift into sleep, you can almost feel yourself in that city in the sky...
I've been to it. #luciddreaming
You can fly sky high to Cloudsdale in your.. Imagination.
+Shadow runner it's right
or when in a plane
Or when going through all of Evening Star's songs at once and commenting on amazing members of the fandom.
"Every man has his secret sorrows of which the world knows not; and often at times we call a man cold when he is only sad."
the truth that speaks to me moved me to tears
One of my first songs i ever listen when i was starting in the fandom, listening at 2022 hits you very hard, the nostalgic, when the fandom was very active and those first months in it, makes me sad and makes me happy, sad because those good years will never come back, and happy for being in this amazing fandom filled with good artists and very awesome musitians.
6 years ago I found myself in a state of pure despair and no way out of my own head. Locked up and ashamed and the only tune I could play in my head and tap my fingers to was this. It is so a soothing song to me and puts me right at ease. Mr Warner I absolutely love your newer music but I am almost addicted to the nostalgia of your older works. I will always always be a fan for life. Thank you.
너무좋아...
God... 10 years...
It's still so beautiful
Another legendary piece of musical perfection by Evening Star... Your work shall forever be recognized by the Brony Community. Keep up the good work, and continue making amazing music.
Holy crap man this song is amazing >.<
No... i can say is PERFECT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
this picture makes me feel like there are forgoten memorys that i must remember >_
Probably one of the best songs I've heard from the brony community. Also one of the many reasons I'm blessed to be apart of it /)
2, years, later.......
I'm still proud to call myself a brony and honered to call you all family
Are you still 1 year later? I have been for 4 years now.:)
@@Alex-lz9py been for nearing 5 years and unlikely i will get away from it. last 2-3 years it slowly creeped into my music lists as i found amazing artists.
I strongly believe I will cherish the impact it had on me for the entirety of my life. Whatever new experiences or circumstances I encounter in the future, these memories and artifacts will always be there. This place chose me, and when I came out of it I had a new perspective on life and what I could achieve.
Evening star and his perfection to soothe wandering souls
jesus that picture is beautiful.
Man this music puts me to sleep. And not in a bad way either. It's just so damned relaxing and peaceful. I Love falling asleep to music like this.
This song helps me find my inner peace and able to relax and have a wonderful day.It brings back precious memories,and its just so relaxing.
This, along with all of your music is a masterpiece. It calms me when I'm in a rage, and lifts my spirits when they've fallen. Thank you
Classic Evening Star. Memories of Season 3 :')
I wanna cry when I listen to this music, it reminds me of the happy days when I was young, it just feels weird and good at the same time when I listen to this 😍😍😍😍😍😍
Same
a timeless masterpiece to me. i keep coming to this now and again. always a good tune
Aaand re-liked. Wanted it to show up on my channel again so I wouldn't have to go searching for it. More beautiful art and serene music. Always puts me at peace no matter what kind of day I've had.
I didn't think it was possible, but I love Cloudsdale even more now! Long live the eternal city!
This should be put in a real mlp episode. I mean it. It would be so good with RD flying or the Mane 6 powering into something new!
one of my favorite songs (mostly because of the picture and how i can imagine being in the city surrounded with peace and watching the sunset....... I just really love that picture... It makes me feel something. idk what but... something...)
my new year music
I love your songs. They are really beautiful. I always feel like flying in the sky when listening to them. I love that feel. Don't stop making them!
Had this song as my alarm for years, always managed to get me up. Great music.
downloaded and listened to it numerous of times feels like one of these thinking about life songs beautiful sound.
the music and the picture together makes me feel everyone left and im the only one, but at the same time like im free
I could easily fall asleep to this. Beautiful.
i can really imagine the feeling of seeing cloudsdale as this incredible sight. the overwhelming beauty and excitement. this music adds to it so much. extremely fitting, beautiful, powerful, perfect for the "city in the sky" we all love know as cloudsdale. (also nice change in feeling of cloudsdale from "rainbow factory" XD)
this is a song that cannot be disliked as it is pure music and makes you fell the wonder of our beloved "city in the sky" I like this a milion times over, and then do it again.
I can't stop listening to your music every time I do I keep hearing the beats in my head and I just need to listen to them again and again.
by far my favorite song from you. its just so soothing
Wish I could fly over the earth and gaze at how beautiful the it really is
PLEASE RELEASE THIS TRACK ON SPOTIFY, DEEZER, THANKS SO MUCH
Same. And I just want to make it louder and louder. Because my soul demands more volume. Very uplifting music.
One person does not know the meaning of loving or tolerating at all. that man/woman has a deep cold heart that was swallowed many years ago by hate and anguish. that one person is consumed by these horrible feelings and is stuck in a harrowing shell intill that one is long gone in a neverending slumber.
Or maybe the music wasn't to their taste…?
Evening Star Or they don't like the image. The world may never know the reasoning behind that one lonely soul's choice.
De Demon He just had to be That One Guy
I hope you don't mind, but that kind of inspired me and I built on that and made this:
"I do not know the meaning of loving or happiness at all. I have a deep cold heart that was swallowed many years ago by hate and anguish. I feel consumed by these emotions and am stuck in a harrowing shell until I am long gone in a neverending slumber, plagued with nightmares and chaos. I have not ever experienced love, not true love; and due to this, while I have been nothing but bitter, I have also never been bitter. Because having never felt love before, you would think that the bitterness just is. That it never changes. But maybe you can show me... friend. Maybe you can show me what it is like to love and be loved."
and yes im aware this is a year old shhh
Evening Star Nah, thats impossible. This answer would be to easy to be true.
Not only an amazing song, but a perfectly fitted quote to go with it. My oh my, Evening Star, it's just beautiful.
Oooh boi this takes me back
My soul left from me and wondering in city of sky
NO dislikes. That also means no trolls. I instantly like this page for not just the music.
Wow. Beautiful. Also, that quote gave me deep emotional contemplation.
This song is just perfect
i like this music so much. Thank you evening star, i like all your music. Your music make me feel i am just flying in the sky or looking the sunset. I like your music and this is my favourite, hope you can made more like this.
Its just so beautifully created and a masterpiece to bask in its peace of harmony! ooh it makes me feel calm and inspired to live another day no matter what!:')
I love the beat!
That quote in the description really hit me hard
...
All of your music makes me feel so fulfilled. It makes me want to go do something with life.
Words cannot express how much i love this specific music. I listen to this kind of stuff everyday specifically yours! Thank you for makeing such beautiful music i can say it has changed my life!
from the Everfree Radio and I'm glad I find this place
thanks for the awesome music!!
@Marcus Warner: There is absolutely no reason to be embarrassed by your earlier musical work!
Facts 👍
Whenever i have a sleepless week full of migrains and comas... this is what brings me through... Thank you evening star.
This, this made me subscribe. It's one thing to like music, but one that can make you think about life and feel at complete peace and bring hope. And the title by saying it "City in the Sky" just uplifts you and brings you into a trance feeling like you are flying to the city in the sky.
Looking through my car window, into the clouds above, I live in your shadow.
Man.. dunno how to explain this but.. it reminds me of how it was for me in 4th grade when I played RS.. gives me a magical feeling..
This is a stunning song....
This music is filled with a power from the light, the colors of freedom.
More music like this, please.
totaly agree with the quote 100%
I cannot see the quote that multiple people have referenced...
Loved this one for a long time. Good for sleep alongside rainfall sounds.
It is beautiful, it makes my shiver and cry(normally I am very stolid).
Gotta enjoy what I can while I still can.
Thanks for making such excellent music.
That art is just BEAUTIFUL!!!! And the song is SOOOOOOOOOOO AMAZING! You make so many awesome songs!!! I just listen to them everyday!!
The atmosphere in this track is absolutely stunning.
I used this song for a part of an mlp audio play about Luna, it fit really well. Thank you for your beautiful music!
I love you Rainbow Dash
Thank you :)
God, this is flawless.
it's music like this that made me fall in love with this show
I just found this channel today. I LOVE this music.
Once in a long far home, lived a small dove alone, this small dove grew up with a herd of ponies, these ponies died.. leaving this poor dove on its own journey, this dove, grew up alone officially... Now it is up to you, to pick up the dove and move the dove once more!
I subscribed yesterday, came back today, and guess whats on my feed? A new song from you! Keep them coming, your music is amazing! :)
simply wonderful
Again, an amazing song, its been this way from the very beginning, don't ever change, Evening-Star :)
New Evening Star upload? Today is a good day.
I can honestly say this is, and probably will always be, my favorite song. Ever. It's that go
This song is so chilllllllllll
This is sooooo beautifull!!!
You sir seriously deserve 50x the subs that you have right now, this is truly amazing, and I'm glad I found you today!
Very moving music, and I adore the artwork & the quote. You're a true musician of vision, something very few musicians have.
It's just getting better and better with each song. Keep up the great work.
I need the download right now.
This is simply fantabulous. You obviously are improving. Keep up the amazing work.
Another well made touching song. I'm so glad I came across your beautiful music, it's absolutely wonderful. Congratulations my friend, you have earned another loyal subscriber! Please keep up with your amazing work, I'm sure everyone else enjoys it as much as me. Thank you for your music. Just thank you.
Beautiful.
-clap- you have created a masterpiece. its so calming and all flowy... can't really describe this music well but it fits the them of Cloudsdale very well. it 'sounds' all 'soft and floaty' like a cloud
You just earned a subbie for making this good music.......... I LOVE YOU....
This is so great! Thank you! :)
This has gotten me through so many long days and car trips
Same here
I'd give anything for the sheet music for the piano in this song... I wanna learn the piano SO badly.. but all the songs they try to make you learn suck total ass. This "sounds" like something I could start out on... not to mention how much I FUCKING LOVE IT.
so amazing ^_^ I can't believe I didn't find your music sooner. Subscribed ^_^
Stunning and breath-taking as always. You deerve way more attention than what you're recieving.
Me encantan tus rolas.
the beginning always brings chills
Came here from EqD music of the day. It's awesome!!!! ^_^
I think hes music makes all high and that why we like it (no hates luv your music)
Dammit, Evening Star, you awesome.
This song is a bit louder on the beat side, a bit "drummier", but still beautiful and lovely and great. It does make me think of a Pegasus city. The ever-so-slightly dubsteppy whum-whum-whum hidden in the beat fits the "city" part, and the dreamy electronic flow is perfect for reflecting the endless expanses of the sky.
Thank you! Keep being amazing!
beautiful quote.
adoro esta cancion
Such a brilliant composer.