medieval streetfighting demonstration

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 1 лют 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 173

  • @schizoidboy
    @schizoidboy 8 років тому +8

    Aside from chainmail they also wore gambesons or padded armor as well, in Italy I heard the the gambeson was popular to wear among some prominent businessmen, probably for protection. It might not have protected as well as chainmail but it would protect against glancing blows.

  • @djemps7983
    @djemps7983 17 років тому +3

    I love this! The beginning demos are very light hearted and fun, but then things become deadly serious by the end. Thanks for demonstrating how Medieval Longsword is not the only Western Martial Art being revived these days!

  • @Scropecaptayne
    @Scropecaptayne 16 років тому +2

    Fantastic video guys, love the kit and the techniques are beautifully done.

  • @WarlockOfAsshai
    @WarlockOfAsshai 7 років тому +2

    Great demonstration! All the guys are ready for tough medieval life :-)

  • @heatherwind
    @heatherwind 11 років тому +1

    This is a really interesting! In theater and the SCA I've taken part in stage combat and demos using bows and swords, but I have never seen one that so effectively demonstrated period knife fighting. Thank you very much - this was both entertaining and informative!

  • @Kunstdesfechtens
    @Kunstdesfechtens 16 років тому +1

    Exactly. These are techniques that were taught in fight schools all over Europe in the Middle Ages and Renaissance. A Martial Art is a codified system of combat, and this video details that quite nicely.

  • @skwuig
    @skwuig 17 років тому +1

    This looks really impressive. Both yourselves AND your guest! What are you called, do you have a website?
    Greetings from Langenort, The Netherlands

  • @piwright42
    @piwright42 15 років тому

    Thank you for the extra depth. I will look these points up when I have more time. This is a topic and period of time that I have only recently became aware of and I appreciate any opportunity to learn more about it. Your points will make my searches easier. Again thank you. :)

  • @forestcuriousity
    @forestcuriousity Рік тому

    What a great demonstration. Those watching must have found it so insightful.

  • @LordNelle
    @LordNelle 17 років тому

    Nice work! It´s so cool to see the medieval figthingstyles reeappear.

  • @JohnRaptor
    @JohnRaptor 16 років тому +1

    Very cool demonstration. It would have been great to see it in person.

  • @Thrand11
    @Thrand11 11 років тому +3

    This is Thrand!!! Awesome Knife work :D

  • @brothlick
    @brothlick 16 років тому

    that dagger toss was smooth. i didnt even notice it

  • @UnclePutte
    @UnclePutte 16 років тому

    I find myself to be under the impression that getting cut is rather a bit of a, say, once-in-a-lifetime experience.

  • @Kunstdesfechtens
    @Kunstdesfechtens 15 років тому

    In a "real' fight, you must close the distance more often than not. Being "at range" is dangerous, but sport fencers can play out at that range since a mistake doesn't mean death. In the historical manuals, a lot of emphasis is on closing the distance, since it's safer once you're inside. Those cross-steps are very much a part of messer fencing, and their purpose is to gain your opponent's back or side. The German group "Ochs" did a nice DVD on messer technique which shows it in detail.

  • @Spiritrunner6
    @Spiritrunner6 16 років тому

    Even so, the core design of Chain is to- in effect- turn the effects of a sharp edge very effectively into the effects of a blunt one, and nothing else. Chain is a soft armor, so it does not absorb impact as well as other modes of protection. And sharp points press between the links to spread them rather than having to cut through. A much easier time of it even if the mail is riveted.

  • @bigbro1989
    @bigbro1989 11 років тому +4

    @ DiabolusIgnis Got a little question for you: have you ever made a chain armour by yourself? It is a big amount of time you have to invest to produce one. The next thing is the material! You need a whole bunch of steel wire to make these thousands of rings in order to get your protection! Maybe you are right and you don't need much skill for it, but the rest (material and time) makes it really really expensive!

    • @Maciliachris
      @Maciliachris 10 років тому +2

      Especially if you want to make real mail armour who is riveted. I know a guy who made a butted mail shirt on his own. Because of the use of comparatively big, unriveted rings, the weight was quite high and the protection in real life wouldn't have been that great either...

  • @soreth6906
    @soreth6906 16 років тому

    Most but not all medieval-renaissance daggers were heavily thrust-oriented and they needed to be stiff to have a good chance at penetrating mail.Thus they were usually but not always narrow and thick with quite high edge degree which doesn't allow for slices at all. Normal chopping would in most cases result in broken bones only(if the proper bones are targeted like collarbone, hand, wrist, etc). If either of the fighters have a dagger that can cut nicely as well, the fight changes considerably.

  • @The_Ballo
    @The_Ballo 9 років тому +11

    weared chainmail? weared?

  • @jthewelshwarlord6331
    @jthewelshwarlord6331 7 років тому +3

    I see Fiore's daga and abrazare here.

  • @MagiRaz
    @MagiRaz 15 років тому

    I think the point is to keep shuffling around the perimeter of the group, so that even though you are shoving them past you, by the point they're recoved you've already moved to have them back in your field of vision.

  • @cipoSVK
    @cipoSVK 16 років тому

    Chainmail can be pierced with a dagger as well as with a sword. It depends on you if you cut or pierce. If piercing is done strong, it´s almost like with a sword. Chain mail mostly protects against cuts, not against stab wounds.

  • @Ketilbiorn
    @Ketilbiorn 14 років тому

    @elgostine
    There are also lots of techniques for the "Leibringen", the kind of wrestling they are doing and the fighting with daggers, sources would be Codex Wallerstein and the fighting manuals of Joachim Meyer and Hans Talhoffer. These can also be used for the fighting with a single handed sword only, because you can use the different "Huten", the different stances.

  • @elgostine
    @elgostine 14 років тому

    i likes the presentation of the sword techniques at the end. where can i find more examples of that, im hoping to do a comparison between european cut and thrust sword Vs the chinese jian.

  • @bakerthan
    @bakerthan 17 років тому

    Quality video indeed, thanks for posting! And just to be pedantic Djemps, the final weapon they were using is an Arming sword, not a long sword. The longsword is a two handed weapon, but fantasy gamers have confused the name and attached it to the single/arming sword. Now almost everyone gets the name wrong, heh.

  • @AuGeUNDoHr1
    @AuGeUNDoHr1 13 років тому

    im not sure, but in garching we also train medievial fighting by wolfgang gerleigner, and he told us, that there could be reflexes to defend your left body side, so you have your hand behind... (ok, bad english, i know :P)

  • @MadPyrotechnicus
    @MadPyrotechnicus 13 років тому

    @DiabolusIgnis What I heard by several blacksmiths in musea, "artisan villages" was that it was so expensive because it took ages to make and connect all the rings. Plate armour was expensive too because it required much more ores of metal and measuring to make it perfectly... That, I know.

  • @Kunstdesfechtens
    @Kunstdesfechtens 17 років тому

    Very cool. Most enjoyable. :) Keep up the good work.

  • @Azri686
    @Azri686 17 років тому

    Nice video you got there. You did a nice job mixing show with clear demonstration of technique and kept it realisic.
    BTW: Can you tell music is playing as backgroud? I really liked it.

  • @elgostine
    @elgostine 14 років тому

    @Ketilbiorn the jian is in the realm of the 1 handed double edged sword essentially. often close comparisons have been made using the rapier though i was told the balance and form better match the arming sword and the like.

  • @TraIveN
    @TraIveN 16 років тому

    I used to work with a guy from Toronto who tried to stop a fight outside of a bar one night, when one of the fighters turned and stabbed him four times: in the shoulder, neck, and arm a couple of times. He said didn't even realize he was stabbed until someone else noticed he was bleeding, he though the guy had just punched him.

  • @gemkapocs
    @gemkapocs 15 років тому

    You can get this close, because they are usng messer's, which are mainly short weapons (sometimes only 70-80 cm, the average lenght is about 100 cm, the longer version, the krieg messer is about 140-150 cm, like a longsword) With such a short wepon you NEED to get close to cause damage, but it's true that you're always risking that you get hurt.

  • @tiamat9989
    @tiamat9989 17 років тому

    hahaha that was really fun to watch!
    Good techniques too--I like the variety.

  • @KTo288
    @KTo288 13 років тому

    I like the section around 4.00 strikes to neck, armpit and thighs, the traditional places to strike against someone wearing body armour.

  • @Ketilbiorn
    @Ketilbiorn 14 років тому

    @elgostine I don't know what you mean with "side-sword". Do you mean the predecessor of the rapier? Because that is a different style of fighting, which I can't tell you nothing about. But there are a lot of techniques with the 1 handed sword, with no side-arm like a shield or a dagger, so just the 1 handed sword on its own. A lot of them are in the fighting manuals of Johannes Lecküchner, which are fighting manuals for the 1 handed sword.

  • @elgostine
    @elgostine 14 років тому

    @Ketilbiorn thats good because like i said, i want to get a comparison between asian and european styles of using weapons that are as close in form as possible to each other. in this case comparing to the chinese jian, theres LOTS of demonstrable techniques for that, but european equivalents are hard to find, what other swords in your opinion might matchh the jian in terms of form and function.

  • @NevTheDeranged
    @NevTheDeranged 16 років тому

    I love the "stab him with his own hat" technique. Priceless.

  • @gemkapocs
    @gemkapocs 16 років тому

    You're right that not EVERYBODY weared chainmails. But the nobles, even the ones who weren't so rich, often weared chainmails. Mercenaries, knights and the regular soldiers also.

  • @Judicial78
    @Judicial78 9 років тому +3

    Music is overkill at the end lol

  • @djemps7983
    @djemps7983 17 років тому

    Hi guys. Swordlaches is correct. I was commenting on how great it was to see a quality vid of other styles other than Longsword. He is also correct about the blades at the end being Messers and not Arming Swords. You can tell by the way they place the off hand on their hip, the curved pommel similar to a machette or big knife, and the heavy tips (those are hard to see). Arming Swords were used with shield, buckler or on horseback.

  • @Kantzarakos
    @Kantzarakos 16 років тому

    About sambo, it included judo and various forms of wrestling. Some were Middle Eastern, some were Russian and some were European. Yes, you are right that the unarmed portions of European martial arts, as well the ones about the usage of and defense against a knife have survived. But in the battlefields of Europe, you would see polearms, crushing weapons like axes and maces and swords(and bows of course). Even sports fencing isn't close to rapier fencing! It's those weapons that were forgotten.

  • @teddywinroth
    @teddywinroth 14 років тому

    The guy in blue clothes is really good

  • @Ranziel1
    @Ranziel1 15 років тому

    The left hand is held behind, because otherwise it could be sniped by a fast strike.

  • @0Felisenus0
    @0Felisenus0 15 років тому

    In the 14th/15th century, chainmail was more readily available then in the centuries before, thanks to the introduction of plate. So it might be possible... It would take quite a paranoid guy to actually do it though. :P
    Quite a brilliant video anyway! Especially the group combat looked impressive.

  • @TemenosL
    @TemenosL 16 років тому

    Sorry for thinking, I do really enjoy these videos, and I'm glad they were uploaded because I find them to be very interesting to watch and learn from. But in this case I was only wondering if chainmail could be pierced by a knife.

  • @Igotanewflashdrive
    @Igotanewflashdrive 15 років тому

    looks like much fun... reminds me I need more skill in not only defending from knife attacks, but also utilizing them efficiently and effectively.

  • @Kunstdesfechtens
    @Kunstdesfechtens 16 років тому

    True enough. But the takedowns shown are limb breaks as well, usually arm bars of some kind. Never take a knife fighter to the ground and "fight" him there. However, standup grappling is vital in knife fights. For the demonstration they have to do the takedowns/breaks safely, so the breaks are executed merely as locks. :)

  • @davedetrick
    @davedetrick 15 років тому

    Very nice. I like how they seemed to compare european techniques to a few asian ones.
    I'd love to lean both. Both seem just as effective. Between the excellent grapples, and the carefully placed stabs... it's all very professional.

  • @SavageInsight
    @SavageInsight 10 років тому +1

    Asian unarmed variations - key note.
    I'm curious about Asian dagger contrasts - European seems very quick and efficiency based.

    • @hawthorne009
      @hawthorne009 10 років тому +3

      Asian based dagger styles are also quick and effective. But for a different type of dagger. Euro daggers were longer and double edged. exact opposite for Asian daggers.

  • @swordlaches
    @swordlaches 17 років тому

    Hi Bakerthan,
    The single handed swords look like German 'Messer' to me.
    Also, Djemps didn't say they were longswords, he said it was good to see something other than longswords being demonstrated.

  • @hopper990
    @hopper990 16 років тому

    I see what you mean on the indorphins, but I've been really hurt in fights and in accidents and the rush of adrenalin can make all the pain disapear. You can't think clear enough though to be effective in a fight, but you can take a beaten!!

  • @thefez-cat
    @thefez-cat 14 років тому

    @mathewgivney If you look very close, you can see some text on the screen. It reads "Asian variations provided by a guest." You might also note that his techniques rather resemble some kind of Asian martial art, perhaps the Japanese art of aikido... I'm going to go way out on a limb here and say the two factors MAY be related somehow.

  • @basilolo
    @basilolo 15 років тому

    Hehe, my name is Christian too, and I am doing a "samurai" too :P Anyway, that's some really nice stuff presented here. Really nice!

  • @BADALEX1
    @BADALEX1 11 років тому

    Oh, I really do. However, I'm perfectly okay with you thinking that I don't.

  • @kokofan50
    @kokofan50 15 років тому

    the left hand was the side you used to wipe after and was generaly not use alot ever in some countries its still that way and why you use your right hand to shak with

  • @Kantzarakos
    @Kantzarakos 16 років тому

    Yes, modern military combatives include a large amount of European martial arts, even though most people think it's all jujitsu. That is especially obvious when you compare most of their techniques with those in historical combat manuals. There is also wrestling and boxing that was created by a rapier and quarterstaff fencer and originally included some wrestling. But when you talk about HEMA, what first comes to mind is swords, polearms, etc. that went extinct. Sorry for the misunderstanding :)

  • @rekakocsisnegregorics1024
    @rekakocsisnegregorics1024 12 років тому

    Chain mail was expensive, but I can't belive that a full armor worth a village... I think it's extreme exaggeration. By the way Alexander, who wore the chain mail, plays a noble (he has noble clothing).
    This performance is very well made. They use techniques, based on codexes, and they presumably made lots of investigation, in order to be authentic. I admire their work a lot.

  • @CichlidAsh
    @CichlidAsh 14 років тому

    Fantastic work really would not want too get on the wrong side of these guys

  • @MadPyrotechnicus
    @MadPyrotechnicus 13 років тому

    @DiabolusIgnis I might be wrong about this but the ones I saw were 1-in-8?

  • @Gunyo
    @Gunyo 16 років тому

    Awesome vid. During the Drunken brawl scene, where did those grappling techniques originate from? Any particular manual?

  • @faceleg
    @faceleg 14 років тому

    Thanks guys! Great show

  • @Dragonfist12185
    @Dragonfist12185 14 років тому

    you can see and use some of these tactics in Assassin's Creed 2.

  • @LaserRazorTaserTrap
    @LaserRazorTaserTrap 17 років тому

    Awesome job, guys! Really cool!

  • @HipposHateWater
    @HipposHateWater 12 років тому

    Almost feels like some Animus simulation with random NPCs

  • @elgostine
    @elgostine 14 років тому

    @Ketilbiorn so are there ANY techniques for the 1 handed armingsword on its own? or even the side sword?

  • @vaporz109
    @vaporz109 3 роки тому +1

    This is amazing. Why don’t we see choreography like this in movies? Instead it’s just same ol’ headhunting, back turning and swinging at each other’s swords.

  • @Ketilbiorn
    @Ketilbiorn 14 років тому

    @elgostine Sorry,but I don't know nothing about the function of the jian, so its hard to tell an equivalent...
    But i would say that a Spatha or a normal Onehanded Sword would match the jian.

  • @haffoc
    @haffoc 17 років тому

    Nicely done over all. One constructive criticism, if you will allow it: Too much slashing. The texts do not appear to support slashing as a response to most attacks, except against the hand. See Paulus Kal.

  • @TheAikidoBush
    @TheAikidoBush 14 років тому

    If you studied various Medieval Martial Arts could it actually benefit your Self Defence or Martial Art training?
    What is this Martial Art called?
    I was thinking of studying this and an Ancient Greek Martial Art (Used For Greek Olympic Games) called: Pankration.

  • @MotusSwordsmanship
    @MotusSwordsmanship 14 років тому

    Nicely done, guys!

  • @feXinat0r
    @feXinat0r 14 років тому

    Ist es nicht Sinnvoller, den Dolch wie ein normales Schwert zu halten (also nach oben), weil man sonst schnell entwaffent werden kann, und man den Dolch so besser von unten in den Brustkorb rammen kann?

  • @MriKentin
    @MriKentin 14 років тому

    @clinicalpsychologist could you tell us what are your arguments ? Have you already read medieval manuscripts ?

  • @Borisz80
    @Borisz80 13 років тому

    Intresting demonstration! :D

  • @TemenosL
    @TemenosL 16 років тому

    Ah, okay. Thanks, that's precisely what I was wondering!

  • @Kantzarakos
    @Kantzarakos 16 років тому

    Today we have the luxury of time and resources. Also, people train martial arts mainly as a hobby and stress relief, since there are other options for self defense.
    When martial arts were mainly used by the military, they got dropped because firearms were much more effective in large scale warfare. When people had to work all day to get by, they wouldn't really care about learning a martial arts, so they became extinct. The main reason they are revived is interest in heritage, not practicality.

  • @monkeyishi
    @monkeyishi 16 років тому

    its the start of the battle bots show song thingy i think

  • @Kunstdesfechtens
    @Kunstdesfechtens 16 років тому

    Grappling is an important part of knife combat. The similarities between German Kampfringen and Japanese Ju-Jutsu are very apparent. There are only so many available ways to do things. Look on youtube for the wrestling of the medieval German master by the name of Ott and you'll see what I mean. The demo is a bit staged, but that's the whole point... it's a demo meant to entertain and inform. :)

  • @incantatis
    @incantatis 14 років тому

    Great job! That was some cool Rockin!

  • @Ketilbiorn
    @Ketilbiorn 14 років тому

    @elgostine These are Langes Messer (sometimes called Großes Messer) techniques. One well known teacher of the Langes Messer was the german priest Johannes Lecküchner. Well, at least something I can be proud of as a German! xD

  • @djemps7983
    @djemps7983 16 років тому

    This group is from Germany. I think they are doing a great job presenting their work in a 'foreign' language. A few grammar mistakes can be overlooked.

  • @madtrizt
    @madtrizt 17 років тому +1

    of course you're right. training personal defense against weapons is different from sports. i understand it's a demonstration, don't get mad, but the one blow straight attack thing isn't realistic as far i know, got it? ;P

  • @thetriumphofthethrill2457
    @thetriumphofthethrill2457 8 років тому

    Thanks for sharing, very informative vid.

  • @Ieatbabyseals
    @Ieatbabyseals 15 років тому

    I'd like to see all of the most efficient parts of Eastern and Western martial arts combined...

  • @NorwegianFlag
    @NorwegianFlag 14 років тому

    I love how the Asian counterpart's moves are based the same as a wrestling move known as "The Russian."

  • @Kunstdesfechtens
    @Kunstdesfechtens 15 років тому

    Well, duelling is dangerous, period. However, messer fencing has those kinds of oblique steps. Modern sport fencing is on a piste so things are different there. This demonstration is a bit staged for the crowd. In a real fight the moves are a lot tighter. I believe this is the Dreynshlag group. Check out their other video and the messer video by Gladiatores for a better view of messer combat. :)

  • @elgostine
    @elgostine 14 років тому

    whats the name of the one handed sword techniques?

  • @BADALEX1
    @BADALEX1 11 років тому

    Sure I have. By all means, you are welcome to your opinion.
    Foolish though it may be.

  • @TemenosL
    @TemenosL 16 років тому

    In the first demonstration, I don't think a person would try to slash your back if they wanted to kill you. Wouldn't they stab you? (and would that pierce the chainmail?)

  • @h.u.g.oausmonchengladbach1131
    @h.u.g.oausmonchengladbach1131 6 років тому

    Schön gemacht :-)

  • @Byakuyasbrother
    @Byakuyasbrother 14 років тому

    hmm some of those moves are impressing and usefull in this century too

  • @VegaEtereo
    @VegaEtereo 14 років тому

    Excellent! I love the fact of including other cultures variations. *****!

  • @NetVoyagerOne
    @NetVoyagerOne 16 років тому

    Is that Aikido later on in the vid?

  • @TemenosL
    @TemenosL 16 років тому

    lol! I would definitely wear one too though. Better to be safe.

  • @MrAlepedroza
    @MrAlepedroza 12 років тому

    Something I dont get: At least from what I know about the matter, only relatively wealthy guys such as noblemen or men at arms could afford maille armors. Then why the vid says that people usually wore it on the streets?

  • @TemenosL
    @TemenosL 16 років тому

    Do you know? : / I would think it's horribly painful, though I've heard of people being stabbed in a fight and saying it felt like a punch due to the addrenaline rush.

  • @antonioarcano7989
    @antonioarcano7989 8 років тому

    One question where do you find these technicques? books?

    • @martinv.b.3415
      @martinv.b.3415 8 років тому

      Anthony Rivera you may google for Joachim Mayer, Codex Wallerstein or Lignitzer and many others- there are a lot of sources aviable as Faksimile or Transkription.

    • @Morrigi192
      @Morrigi192 8 років тому

      Yes, treatises written by weapon masters that survived from centuries ago.

  • @juckexD
    @juckexD 13 років тому

    Whats the first Music Called?

  • @TemenosL
    @TemenosL 16 років тому

    Interesting, I hadn't known that.

  • @Ketilbiorn
    @Ketilbiorn 14 років тому

    @elgostine Okay, but I can just tell you technique sources for the one-handed sword, not about the rapier, because it is totally different to fight with...

  • @Lissenen
    @Lissenen 11 років тому

    Seems fun!