JS comics
JS comics
  • 31
  • 13 593
Should YOU separate art from artist?
In the world of art, you are, of course, going to come across more than a few bad eggs. But just because the egg is bad, does it mean the art is as well? In today's video, I thought it would be an interesting topic to discuss as we go over some of the more popular arguments for and against separating the art from the artist.
Now with the nature of this topic and, of course, this video, I am aware that some people may feel very...passionately about this topic. For this reason, I want to open the floor to you guys in the comments to feel free to express your opinions in a respectful manner, I do not believe wholeheartedly in censorship but if I see blatant attacks or bullying I will be moderating and deleting those comments. I want this to be a safe area to have an open discussion, keep it civil guys!
Persons used in the thumbnail:
Left: HP Lovecraft
Right: Neil Gaiman
Both are controversial figures accused of different acts - make sure to research them!
I have seen what you want, so don't worry! more OC guides and reviews are coming soon, I had this idea in the back of my mind so I just needed to get it out there :)
#art #artist #documentary
Переглядів: 12

Відео

Top 10 CREEPIEST creatures in film
Переглядів 3,1 тис.19 годин тому
Hey everyone, today's video is all about the creepiest monsters in media, I am thinking of making sequels based off of books, anime and cartoons in the future! But for now, here is my list for those in film! You may also notice a slight shift in editing style and I do have an announcement for that as well! I am in the process of learning Davinci Resolve and moving away from Adobe Express, whils...
5 BEST anime for beginners
Переглядів 64314 днів тому
Ever wanted to get into anime? Well here is a quick guide highlighting my recommendations for shows that you must try! Each of these has been chosen for how easy it is to get into them and I feel represent their respective genres in a way that will leave you wanting more! Remember that opinions are subjective and that, just because you didn't like a certain show, it doesn't mean you hate anime ...
The 5 WORST Isekai anime of all time!
Переглядів 1,3 тис.21 день тому
Last week I covered terrible tropes for your OCs, a lot of you seemed interested in my opinions when it came to the anime I showed as well. So, without further ado, here is my list for the top 5 worst isekai anime! As usual remember that this list is solely my opinion and, as mentioned, I have not watched every Isekai ever made, therefore the list is heavily biased towards the shows I have watc...
10 WORST OC tropes
Переглядів 7 тис.28 днів тому
Last week we discussed how to create an OC, this week we are talking about the worst tropes that we frequently see in OCs to this day, from edgy Mary sues to over-the-top gore OCs, this list has it all! Anime used in the video: To Your Eternity Seven Deadly Sins The greatest demon lord is reborn as a typical nobody Classroom of the Elite Princess Connect: RE:Drive Komi Can't communicate My hero...
How to create an OC
Переглядів 177Місяць тому
Today's short guide is all about self-expression and creativity! There are millions of OCs but few guides on how to make one yourself, so I thought it would be nice to give you all a few pointers to help you get started! I would also like to give a huge shoutout to Thiadel once again for the artwork used in the thumbnail! If you like her art, make sure to hunt her down and check out the rest of...
5 Must read books for beginners
Переглядів 125Місяць тому
I started off with many of these books when I was first garnering an interest in reading myself. Although nowadays I do not read as much as I should, these books hold a certain place in my heart that gives me the desire to just keep rereading them over and over again! This video is, of course, my opinion. If you disagree or have your own suggestions please let me know in the comments below, so ...
How to Publish a book: Traditional VS self Published
Переглядів 15Місяць тому
Last week I told you all how to write a book, this week the topic is how to publish your new story! I have seen many guides on this topic that attempt to convince you that one way is better than the other, but I disagree with this take on things. Each person should have the decision be left up to them rather than being told 'traditional bad', and in the interest of this I have tried to stay as ...
How to write a book: Beginner edition
Переглядів 2932 місяці тому
Ever wanted to write a book but you don't know how? This small guide is designed to give you the basic of basics to help you on your journey from a blank document to a complete story! Just as a side note, the last bit of advise is not designed to stop anyone from writing. If you have a story idea, always feel free to share it with the world! This piece of advice is simply to leave you all with ...
Censorship: The Dangers of Silence
Переглядів 112 місяці тому
Thought I forgot about this weeks episode? Think again! Today I wanted to discuss my thoughts on the dangers of censorship, especially in regards to historical censoring that I have seen occurring more often. Platforms such as UA-cam and Tiktok censor words such as 'dead' 'killed' 'Nazi' and other commonly used phrases that are prevalent when talking about human history and I disagree with it! ...
Is 'wokeness' the enemy?
Переглядів 192 місяці тому
Six separate attempts to add some of the gaming footage later and it is finally done! As mentioned previously I am currently branching out and trying my hand at different forms of media. The main point I wanted to make was that these subjects have a lot more nuance that creators seem to ignore in favor of a 'us vs them' mentality, which is something I disagree with. But let me know what you guy...
What is happening to JS?
Переглядів 92 місяці тому
It has been quite the week, from an electrical fire to a lack of motivation striking at me, there was a lot to cover today! Thank you to everyone who has continued to support me, more content is on the way as soon as I can actually see again! Until then I will still upload smaller videos to keep you all entertained. JS Comics discord: discord.gg/dWcu2SZb6V #update #youtube #drama
OC review episode 4 - 'Ivan'
Переглядів 233 місяці тому
Another week, another episode of OC review! This was one of my favourites so far with brilliant character depth and a well thought out backstory - really looking forward to seeing how Aster progresses with them in the future! In other news, I am shifting the channel focus to resources that I think will help writers come up with ideas, mainly based on lesser known cryptids and other creatures th...
Modernism: The Death of Art
Переглядів 133 місяці тому
Today we have something special, a nihilistic perspective on the current state of the world. I just wanted to put my stance on things out into the world, feel free to disagree and if you do let me know why in the comments! I hope this inspires at least someone out there to continue their passions and that others simply enjoy the video :) If anyone knows where to find that good copyright-free mu...
OC review episode 3 - 'Camille'
Переглядів 613 місяці тому
OC review episode 3 - 'Camille'
Tiktok's newest Manhater - Kyle Prue
Переглядів 274 місяці тому
Tiktok's newest Manhater - Kyle Prue
How to: Write Romantic Poetry for Beginners
Переглядів 134 місяці тому
How to: Write Romantic Poetry for Beginners
Dating advice: Long-Distance Dating
Переглядів 264 місяці тому
Dating advice: Long-Distance Dating
Who is JS Comics?
Переглядів 134 місяці тому
Who is JS Comics?
How to deal with Artist Burnout!
Переглядів 145 місяців тому
How to deal with Artist Burnout!
OC review episode 2 - 'Axilya'
Переглядів 265 місяців тому
OC review episode 2 - 'Axilya'
TikTok Hates smaller creators!
Переглядів 295 місяців тому
TikTok Hates smaller creators!
OC review episode 1 - 'Zenny'
Переглядів 535 місяців тому
OC review episode 1 - 'Zenny'
JS rants about Shrek lore for 5 minutes
Переглядів 213 роки тому
JS rants about Shrek lore for 5 minutes
Milk
Переглядів 1026 років тому
Milk
London Charity walk
Переглядів 466 років тому
London Charity walk
Carolina Reaper challange
Переглядів 926 років тому
Carolina Reaper challange
Meet the Hounds
Переглядів 597 років тому
Meet the Hounds

КОМЕНТАРІ

  • @jlawsl
    @jlawsl День тому

    I think there are so many generic, trash tier, CGI fight scene, png shifting combat, badly animated, crapy storyline isekais that they need to just have a dumpster category for all of them to count as one because they ALL follow the exact same plot, storyline, art style and low budget. Smart Phone was just one of the first trash tier animes that would soon open the flood gates to others

  • @boredAster
    @boredAster День тому

    I tend to pirate series of people I don’t want to support because I still like the media but I’ll be dammed if they Profite from me!

    • @JScomicsLTD
      @JScomicsLTD День тому

      A perfect example of why I am pro-pirate!

  • @JScomicsLTD
    @JScomicsLTD День тому

    I would also like to put up an apology for how I sounded in this video - I was a bit under the weather and fever-y but the show must go on! Hope the sniffing doesn't get too annoying :)

  • @owaine-changaming
    @owaine-changaming 2 дні тому

    Xenomorphs are both a threat but also cannon fodder because they will throw themselves at something until you run out of ammo or they overwhelm you and the threat being the intelligence they show when throwing everything at you won't work

  • @cadevasquez4849
    @cadevasquez4849 4 дні тому

    called UA-camErs

  • @cadevasquez4849
    @cadevasquez4849 4 дні тому

    I give this video like and hope you will run ads to promote your nice channel

  • @Nexus-r5i
    @Nexus-r5i 5 днів тому

    bro zero no tsukaima is a literal classic so i disagree with that and in another world with my smartphone wasnt that bad and i dont even have to talk about redo of healer cuz everyone already have said enough and you just got the wrong info ig

  • @Balliatiiviska
    @Balliatiiviska 6 днів тому

    My top 3 1. The facehugger from Alien (1979) 2. Terminator as in full robot form from the Terminator (1984) 3. The Ratmonkey from Braindead (1992) 😀

  • @chrisjohnstone9228
    @chrisjohnstone9228 6 днів тому

    Fabulous overview darling!! I love it, keep up the good work!

  • @charlene4419
    @charlene4419 6 днів тому

    Yeah, Tusk was damn messed up. The Bear mutant really did scare me. I couldn't look away from it, but it disturbed me, that's why I love it though. There's a creature or a manifestation from one of the Silent Hill games, Scarlet. That thing is creepy as hell.

  • @cinderworfu
    @cinderworfu 7 днів тому

    this would be useful for me building my ocs just in case I accidentally made one of the list so I could avoid it

  • @christianharris2158
    @christianharris2158 7 днів тому

    the human centipede ,

  • @walterfechter8080
    @walterfechter8080 7 днів тому

    When I was a kid, I was terrified by the demon monster in "Night (Curse) of the Demon" (1957). Yeah, I know that demon monster was a puppet, but it was truly hellish (literally)! At first glance, the face-hugger and adult xenomorph from "Alien" gave me the creeps. Then, there were assorted "blobs" in Horror/Sci-Fi films which made me feel uncomfortable.

  • @legendarygigolo823
    @legendarygigolo823 7 днів тому

    Zuni doll from Trilogy of Terror Larry from Come Play The plants from The Ruins The Zanti Misfits - Outer Limits S1E14

  • @jamielee9327
    @jamielee9327 7 днів тому

    Pale man, definitely very creepy

  • @zombiedude1488
    @zombiedude1488 7 днів тому

    “Pan’s labyrinth” is set during the Spanish civil war, not ww2.

  • @ThiadelNiniel
    @ThiadelNiniel 8 днів тому

    Im usually okay with most horror but tusk does something to me I can’t stand. Jump scaring me like that XP ❤️

  • @boredAster
    @boredAster 8 днів тому

    How can I love monstrous character designs so much but not tolerate horror at all? 🫠

  • @ghostthelizard
    @ghostthelizard 10 днів тому

    Characters who can do a lot (or even everything) arent necessarily bad. Its just, a lot of them seem like prodigies. I got an oc who can do a lot of things but there are two caveats: First - hes like over 1000 years old and spent years getting good at those things (although his magic ability literally is copying so it makes it easier to learn stuff) Second - after not doing some things for years he kinda got rusty. Like he used to be able to play cello but the last time he did it was maybe 50 years ago so if he picks up one now he might just not be able to do it Shonen anime tend to get it right too. Usually the characters dont start out as super strong. Take Ichigo, Goku, Naruto, Deku... all of them arent that strong at first and get stronger as the story progresses. Of course sometimes they have like very unique and special powers nobody else has that they unlock later on, but the point is that its not like immediately there. Meanwhile in isekais its like even if they arent immediately strong, they dont take long to become strong or its like rimuru from the slime anime where he may be a weak slime but he has one if the strongest powers away right from the start I also think the all powerful mary sues are very fitting for comedy stories. Thinking of Mashle, Mob Psycho and Saiki K. Actually like idk if they would really be mary sues because their personalities are more fleshed out and flawed than your average mary sue, but in regards to power level - yeah mashle can basically punch away any enemy, but considering the tone of the manga its very much what youd expect and quite funny to see him punch super powerful mages like theyre nothing

  • @silentbanana209
    @silentbanana209 10 днів тому

    Mary sues in my opinion can be perfect with skills and talent but they need to have some sort of flaw Also I’m thinking of an oc series and one dude is loosely based off me, granted I made him when I was like 6 or 7. He does fall in love with another character but it takes a while and is not the main focus of the characters or the story. He is also an alien who doesn’t look like me. So I don’t know if this falls into the self insert category or just a character category

  • @Theragegamerjfh
    @Theragegamerjfh 12 днів тому

    You forgot the ocs that are strong just because

  • @Blackaos367
    @Blackaos367 12 днів тому

    Good suggestions and great animes... how you managed to make it boring I don't understand though, sorry...

  • @thecouchpotatocom
    @thecouchpotatocom 13 днів тому

    I like to recommend Fruits Basket. Wonderful characters and story, little fantasy/magic but easy to get into and explains about Japanese culture and norms.

  • @blockeontheleafeon
    @blockeontheleafeon 14 днів тому

    Can't start your OC Journey without making at least one of these. I would know.

  • @isaquenoobkk
    @isaquenoobkk 14 днів тому

    The last part will be probably the most important one for be, because of the sheer amount of villains i actually want my story to have, and I have only though for now about the motivations of the three main ones, so I will have to fix all of it soon.

    • @JScomicsLTD
      @JScomicsLTD 14 днів тому

      @@isaquenoobkk It is hard work but you'll get there! Good luck!

  • @lorenzlazaga5197
    @lorenzlazaga5197 14 днів тому

    My oc is that, he's good at everthing he tries, but to balance it he's mostly good at the basics. Being able to be good at anything also tolls his time to improve, and won't be reaching his full potential any time, unlike my other characters who only utilize a few skills but in a mastered level.

    • @lorenzlazaga5197
      @lorenzlazaga5197 14 днів тому

      Basically the lesson in my story is 𝘵𝘰 𝘣𝘦 𝘦𝘧𝘧𝘪𝘤𝘪𝘦𝘯𝘵.

  • @Random_lnternet_User
    @Random_lnternet_User 15 днів тому

    Redo isn't a Isekai tho

  • @boredAster
    @boredAster 15 днів тому

    Looks like I’ve got some series to watch now!

  • @ThiadelNiniel
    @ThiadelNiniel 15 днів тому

    ah, ghibli my love. relly good recomendations and video ;)

  • @nekou8414
    @nekou8414 16 днів тому

    I will forever despise the COTE anime for how much it has bastardised how people first interpret ayanokoji as a character. Dude has a lot more facets to his personality in the novels than just being the 'evil mary sue oc', especially if you've read COTE volume 0. Like I don't blame y'all for using him as an example with how he's portrayed in the anime but the lack of research is kinda...cringe ngl lmao.

  • @isaiah-bp5fo
    @isaiah-bp5fo 17 днів тому

    The characters I plan on making are actually a play on some of this :3 Le Plot armor Da Edgy 1/realist Le optimist Monkey man king The one who knows all about it The strongest spider-man rip off This one exist

  • @Nombrenooriginal
    @Nombrenooriginal 17 днів тому

    1:05 oh shid I'm surprised with myself that i didn't made my OC like that

  • @JScomicsLTD
    @JScomicsLTD 17 днів тому

    I get it, Redo of the healer isn't an 'Isekai', I got the wrong information when writing this list. I still stand by my ranking of it at number 1 worst, just not of Isekai. I didn't think I would have to say this, but this is my opinion and you are allowed to have your own, yours doesn't discredit mine nor does mine discredit yours.

    • @jlawsl
      @jlawsl День тому

      To be honest, he was reborn in a new world with OP powers, so it fits the bill. It is the worst in my book as well. Its degenerate hentai that is written in the most disgusting way. The people that wrote that trash need to have psych evals. I felt bad for the character the first time around. But during the reset, this idiot went through all the same stuff just to be a lvl100 menace to booty holes and society. That and his powers were so weakly defined that they let him do anything from shape shifting to resetting an entire planet? What?

  • @vidservent
    @vidservent 18 днів тому

    With the many sub genres people tend to confuse everything with Isekai because other genres are often mixed with it. Reincarnation and Regression in particular can exist without isekai but is often confused with it having to be an isekai when it can be purely fantasy. Redo of a healer is a Regression set in fantasy not isekai since the MC didn't come from a different world.

    • @jlawsl
      @jlawsl День тому

      Technically different. That's like saying Suisei no Gargantia isn't an isekai because it happens on Earth when it is indeed an isekai in every sense.I think reincarnation and regression are simply subgenres of isekai because of the simple, similar format that they all share. Trying to argue that shows like Redo don't follow the exact overall structure of an isekai is pure sophistry. For all intents and purposes, its just a degenerate Shield Hero or Arifureta type of show.

  • @suntzu4607
    @suntzu4607 18 днів тому

    Redo of Healer isn't an isekai/transported to another world, it's a fantasy anime. It's like saying Berserk is an isekai. He was reincarnated in the same world after his death to exact vengeance. That's it.

  • @asenticon
    @asenticon 18 днів тому

    Redo of healer feel mostly fantasy than isekai ....i hate it but its not isekai since hes in his own world alternatively i would say re monster thats redo of healer lite like srsly the protag is lawful evil compared to the old goblin ways hes a good guy but consent sex n constantly aphrodisiac his slaves till he breaks them in is still rapey as shit the system is intresting like boufuri but rape is rape .....on side note 🎵 redo of healer manga is way way worse like hes way more rapey and sadistic than what they portrayed

  • @mauriman2210
    @mauriman2210 18 днів тому

    What about the *Micromanager Oc?* they're so annoying_ eg; *The Strongest Mage With The Weakest Crest* the best character in that show was the Dragon Girl!

  • @ndk2k4
    @ndk2k4 18 днів тому

    you start off the list with an anime that was made to make fun of the genre... discrediting the rest of the video... and redo of healer? lol....

  • @Wuffians
    @Wuffians 18 днів тому

    smarthphone isekai was imo the ancestor of weird isekai, it's not gonna win any contest for best isekai but for enjoyablity and watch something relaxing it's an 8/10 no one knows why something happen or how it works and prob neither did the writer but it's a relaxing anime with no major plot zero was a good one if you haven't watch any other isekai, or if you're below 14 years old. Bout the time when I watched it, overall decent anime with annoying tsundere but wholesome mc and similar to oreimo tsundere where the time female mc doesn't become tsundere it's the best part of the anime, also ending is pretty good, 6/10. wholesome but kinda dark at the end

  • @theparadoxicaltouristtrave9320
    @theparadoxicaltouristtrave9320 19 днів тому

    While i might disagree with the order., you defend your choices well.

  • @ZekeChanguris
    @ZekeChanguris 19 днів тому

    I would profoundly disagree with the Realist Hero assessment. The story is fascinating, the plot is complex, and using Machiavelli as a guide is genius. The idea that you don't need special powers to lead is also essential to the argument that having studied government and the humanities in college was important to his success. He gathers people around him and creates transformational change in government by making a good civil service. He even pursues a realistic effort to abolish slavery. If you look at the surface stuff, you are missing out on a unique story.

    • @JScomicsLTD
      @JScomicsLTD 19 днів тому

      @@ZekeChanguris Each to their own, I am happy you enjoyed it :)

    • @pl1guru
      @pl1guru 19 днів тому

      I enjoyed it too for the same reasons, using Machiavelli's "The Prince" is very unique. Was it great, no, but the overall story is good. Sure there is the harem trope, which is not needed, really all he needed was the princess, but manga writers like to put in the personal fetishes I guess. Then again all the "wives" allowed him to grow the kingdom via alliances with other nations (going the King Solomon route), so there is that. SPOILER: * * * * * * * * * * * * * * Later in the story per the light novel our boy also secretly marries the Empress of the big human empire I forget the name of and he marries the princess of the dragons to make his kingdom the dominant force against the invading demons.

  • @saphirestorm7952
    @saphirestorm7952 19 днів тому

    The funny thing about the first one is that I have an oc who's most interesting aspect is his tragic backstory because he has severe depression and rarely does anything and his friends have to force him to do basic health things like eating and sleeping, so I'd say that's a good example of the first one being done well

    • @ghostthelizard
      @ghostthelizard 10 днів тому

      Yeah, trauma definitely can and will affect people (even if its different between individuals).

  • @captainhyrule9741
    @captainhyrule9741 19 днів тому

    I'm almost afraid my OC falls into "gore for the sake of gore". He's an immortal knight that has to save his princess from an immortal monster, no matter what it takes. The knight can turn back time when he's killed and the monster can regenerate on the spot. Throughout the story you see the monster kill the knight so many times to the point the knight starts developing PTSD but continues to push through to save his princess.

    • @JScomicsLTD
      @JScomicsLTD 19 днів тому

      I wouldn't worry given the premise of your idea, the gore makes sense for the world-building you are making! Remember this list is not definitive and that some of these tropes can work if done correctly, but most of all enjoy the experience of writing :)

    • @АнтонСкориков-с2о
      @АнтонСкориков-с2о 13 днів тому

      Sounds like Homura Akemi type. Don't worry, it would still be a good story. I think.

    • @captainhyrule9741
      @captainhyrule9741 12 днів тому

      @@АнтонСкориков-с2о I'm not familiar with what that is

    • @windego64
      @windego64 11 днів тому

      as long as you don't go overboard like Re: zero I think you're alright

    • @silentbanana209
      @silentbanana209 10 днів тому

      Sounds interesting could go well with psychological things

  • @dr.deadpool5959
    @dr.deadpool5959 19 днів тому

    How a realist hero was the final straw for me in hating all generic Isekai anime. I specially hate how the main character is only interested in one girl but decides to marry all the girls after being gaslight into it. The last girl that shows up especially pisses me off because she acts like she’s better than all the girls there even though we don’t know who she is up until that point.

  • @ShrekisLuv
    @ShrekisLuv 19 днів тому

    Im waiting for redo season 2 "HEaL!"😅

    • @jlawsl
      @jlawsl День тому

      A lot of actual hentai aren't as bad as redo. It is straight trash for sadist and bad writers. Guy has the most dumb, undefined ability that does time travel, shape shifting, skill stealing, jizz power ups, memory manipulation, mind control, decaying, healing...blah blah blah. The MC is written so poorly because the writers had to give him OP skills while being a healer but they didn't know how because a healer is lame to begin with. They didn't know how to do it well, so they just gave him whatever skills he needed at the moment. Not to mention that the story and the MC are trash.

  • @batuhan6887
    @batuhan6887 19 днів тому

    I don't think you've even discovered the brunt of the isekai genre. I can't really talk about the smartphone one since I haven't watched it. The realist hero is not too bad, the production seems nice. The fruit of evolution s2 was dogshit I have to agree. The gag characters and the latter half of the season 1 was not bad imo. Now, Zero no tsukaima is a cult classic. Speaking of cult classics, you botched the entire list by putting redo of healer on no 1 because it is just time travel and not even reincarnation, let alone a different world. The literal explanation is that he "healed" the time. Also, a protagonist being irredeemable does not mean that the story or the production itself is bad. I am going to look up my watched list and put a top 5 in here in a few hours. Spoilers: no 1 is definitely conception.

    • @JScomicsLTD
      @JScomicsLTD 19 днів тому

      Redo meets the criteria since he is 'reborn' into this world, it also appears on every list I searched so I am counting it, Completely forgot about Conception! definitely a contender for the number 1 spot in part 2!

    • @zysce8017
      @zysce8017 18 днів тому

      @@JScomicsLTD you need to check the definition of an isekai

    • @jlawsl
      @jlawsl День тому

      Redo the healer was time travel and a form of reincarnation of sorts where he was able to keep his OP powers. The fact that the writers gave him about a dozen powers that have NOTHING to do with healing, like "hEaLIng tHe PlAnEt"...derp...really? When I saw that part, I cringed. When I saw the guy steal abilities, gain decay abilities, give jizz power ups because they needed a reason to SA the guy, I gagged. Then he shapshifts, steals abilities, memory manipulates and mind controls people? Why? It has nothing to do with healing. But, in the end, it fits every block as a form of isekai.

  • @Eternalwarpuppy
    @Eternalwarpuppy 20 днів тому

    I'm gonna call this list a complete fail. Not because of your opinions on the anime you listed as that is subjective, but rather because the anime you chose as the number 1 worst isekai of all time IS NOT EVEN AN ISEKAI. This is like making a soda tier list and saying that chocolate milk is the worst kind of soda. At the start of the video, you defined isekai as an anime where the main character is reincarnated into a fantasy world. This definition is not complete because it excludes anime where characters are summoned into another world while they are alive such as The Wrong Way to use Healing Magic, and anime where characters can freely travel between Earth and the fantasy world such as Gate. That aside, for an anime to be considered isekai, the protagonist must be from Earth and in the case of Redo of Healer, that just isn't true. The protagonist is born and raised on the fantasy world and Earth is never mentioned. It its also worth noting that he is never reincarnated, he just casts a spell to travel back in time, so Redo of Healer also fails to meet your own definition of isekai. Anime planet is the most comprehensive tag database for anime that I'm aware of and it can be a good guideline for Top X anime with X tag style videos.

    • @jlawsl
      @jlawsl День тому

      I mean, Redo the Healer is technically an isekai where the MC isekais himself into a redone world with all of his OP powers. And by the way, your definition of an isekai is so far off that it is YOUR personal opinion. The character doesn't need to be from Earth at all. The writers have just gone with the isekai trope and tweaked it so that now it should include reincarnation in the distant future, time travel, traditional isekai or alternate timelines. The same basic outline occurs- MC is born, brought, reincarnated, summoned, accidently stumbles into or intentionally triggers a plot where they are usually gifted with abnormal powers, have a party they travel with(usually a harem) and go around defeating a major enemy each arc, sometimes being former allies that they had conflict with. If this doesn't match Redo the Healer and 95% of every other modern isekai, I don't know what does. By your logic Suisei no Gargantia isn't an isekai just because it happens on Earth, in another timeline and the guy that came to Earth technically wasn't from Earth either. But, it is a pretty fantastic setting where a character is brought through a portal to a world where his technology is his secret power.

    • @Eternalwarpuppy
      @Eternalwarpuppy 12 годин тому

      ​@@jlawsl You can say that, but its not just me. Anime Planet, AniDB, and My Anime List all consider Redo of Healer to be Time Travel and not Isekai. I haven't seen Gargantia on the Verdurous Planet, but looking at its tags and description I agree. It is also not isekai. None of the sites I mentioned consider it to be isekai either.

  • @KurogawaGray
    @KurogawaGray 20 днів тому

    Realist Hero? Dumpster fire tier list.

    • @JScomicsLTD
      @JScomicsLTD 20 днів тому

      @@KurogawaGray I know right! As mentioned I can get the appeal but the execution was waaaay off!

  • @philskalation2881
    @philskalation2881 20 днів тому

    If you don't like Redo of Healer and want the story more like you described try the manga "Fukushuu o Koinegau Saikyou Yuusha wa, Yami no Chikara de Senmetsu Musou Suru". Never watched or read Redo of Healer but i'm pretty certain my recommendation is much much better. Don't get me wrong still sexual content involved. Straight up gore and basically everyone in the show is like the devils incarnate lol

    • @JScomicsLTD
      @JScomicsLTD 20 днів тому

      Thank you for the recommendation! I will look into it :)

    • @philskalation2881
      @philskalation2881 20 днів тому

      @@JScomicsLTD No problem It is some absolutely insane shit tho so be warned :D