Відео

@@JalilZavala officially yes that is when skeleton crew is supposed to be set. However, the only relating factor is the appearance of the character Vane, the Nikto pirate who was in Mando season 3 as part of Gorian Shard’s gang and is also in Skeleton Crew. But Vane has barely had any screen time in skeleton crew and therefore there is nothing in the show that specifically indicates this takes place after Mando season 3, and as such it does not break the continuity if we say that it takes place before

@@ProfEngywook thanks for the feedback. I didn’t notice the buzzing when I was editing but watching on my phone I can definitely hear what you’re talking about. I’ll improve on that in my next video.

@@johnthemachine I get where you’re coming from and I agree with a lot of your points, and I also get frustrated that the Mandoverse doesn’t seem to be heading anywhere. Disney and Lucasfilm went into the sequel trilogy with zero plan as for where the story was going, and it seemed like the first season of the Mandalorian was going to change that. But here we are nearly 6 years later and there doesn’t seem to be any coherence with each of the different shows they keep throwing out. However, I do think it’s salvageable. In a way, the fact that they have just been messing around and haven’t developed the story a whole lot yet is sort of a blessing for the Mandoverse, because it means there is still time to steer it in the right direction. And that’s why I put these videos out, because by trying to piece together a story that the writers themselves seemingly haven’t tried to piece together themselves, then at the very least I can improve the experience for myself and other fans who still want to enjoy Star Wars, and at the very most my ideas could potentially reach someone on the story group at Lucasfilm and make them realise that they need to put more thought into their work. In this age of endless mindless content on streaming platforms ruining franchises we all know and love, the only hope seems to be check out entirely or create your own head canon

That's a good point, however don't forget that until season 3 Navarro was a hub for criminal activity - a bit like Mos Eisley it was a 'wretched hive of scum and villainy' including pirates, bounty hunters, smugglers, etc. Those enterprises likely brought in a lot of illegal funds, and with Greef Karga at the top of that pyramid then he was the one to benefit most and therefore he could direct the funds however he deemed appropriate.

@@ariesstorm9577 good catch! I think I overlooked that. Luckily he only says “several years ago” and not a specific number, and The Mandalorian seasons 1 & 2 (+ Ahsoka in this timeline) take place 5 years after Return of the Jedi and the defeat of the empire so that line fortunately doesn’t affect the continuity, but great catch!

Firstly, he’s listed in the credits as Ki Adi Mundi which means it was an intentional decision by the writers. Secondly, Qimir literally says he’s a Sith. And although they’re only watching a hologram of Mae - who isn’t a Sith - they suspect she was trained by someone much more powerful in the dark side than her, as they say in the episode. I question your motives for trying to defend this show…

Well, the entire 6 movies are the story of Anakin Skywalker so...

@@bmarshy true but it ends with his transformation into Vader no enlightenment into his violent sad life during the empire

@@stoney7041ah I see what you mean, you’d like a story that explores anakin’s descent into the dark side after he becomes Darth Vader and how he becomes such a cold and merciless killing machine that we see in Rogue One and The empire strikes back?

At none. But fanatics must find something to spark a fire of hatred towards Disney and modern Star Wars.

Why

@@zufalllx Why not? Ahsoka is only 14 years old at the beginning of the clone wars and 17 by the time of Episode III when Luke is born. By A New Hope Luke is 19 years old and about 22 or 23 in Return of the Jedi. And The Mandalorian takes place roughly 5 years after ROTJ, which means Luke is 27/28 and Ahsoka is only about 45, so they would certainly be around at the same time, unless you mean you don’t think Ahsoka should have survived until that point in the timeline?

This plot hole was explained in the show’s finale though

@@Blockxolotl oh. I haven’t really watched the show and I don’t feel like it. Not to be rude

@@abelarmstrong8054 i didn’t like the show either, only watched it because my little sister was really liking it

@@natem9080 that is like a person being attacked by an alligator in a river and screaming “AGH! CROCODILE!” and then someone saying “wELL aCtUaLLy tHaTs aN aLLigAtOr”. And there is plenty of confirmation that they are Sith. For one, Qimir literally says he’s a Sith. Secondly, Darth Plagueis is in the final episode which means that either Qimir is a Sith or he’s at least pretending to be one and caught the attention of the real Sith. Either way it is illogical writing.

@@bmarshy I said "At this point there was no confirmation" meaning at the point that Ki-Adi was involved. Yes, confirmation of a Sith is obvious later, but all Mundi knows is that someone with the force was killing Jedi. Which, funny enough, lines up with Mundi's reaction in the phantom menace too. Qui-Gon gets attacked by Maul, but he's still in denial about it being a Sith.

@@bmarshy Your points about Qimir and Plagueis are totally irrelevant to the conversation. Those scenes confirm to us the viewers that there's a sith (duh), and to the Jedi that were actually there. Need I remind you that Mundi was NOT THERE for either of those two things.

@@austindeivert1198 dude chill out it’s just a meme over a fictional TV show, it’s not like we’re debating 20th century politics

​​@@bmarshy Are you telling other people to chill out meanwhile you upload a stupid video thats supposed to make fun of an allegedly mistake, creating a toxic comment section in the process, just because you kids have nothing better to do than hating on a tv show for basically no reason? How thin-skinned are you?

@@alvinobege7307 i did a little movie magic for the video 😉

There is no mandoverse. There is only Star Wars.

@@badangpatang dude people keep saying this but episode 5 came out TWOOO WEEKS AGO and he literally says he’s a Sith

@@bmarshy Qimir doesn't even claim that he is a Sith. He says he is not anything, but the Jedi may call him a Sith.

And he using Trakata, a Lightsaber style which is forbidden by the sith too

First, this show is awful and shouldn’t be taken seriously

@@FowlManor thanks for your support it means a lot! When I watched the shows like this for the first time it honestly felt like a whole new show so I’m glad that you find it interesting. If you watch the episodes in this order be sure to come back to this video and let me know what you think!

@@bmarshy It's a similar situation with The Clone Wars; If you watch the episodes in order of release you'll have clones in Phase I and Phase II armor in episodes right after one another and story lines will be picked up and then dropped for almost an entire season before being picked up again. If you watch The Clone Wars in the correct order, the long story lines are much better, and the end hits harder than you can ever imagine. 😭

@@wizlb I’m not sure that’s entirely accurate. I know a lot of “original” fans who are still fans to this day, even after all the mess Disney has made. I think people were just happy to see a Star Wars project that felt like George Lucas’ creation again when the Mandalorian came out in 2019. It’s not perfect, and I know a lot of fans have dropped out, but a lot of people are still rooting for Star Wars to be good again and at the moment the only light guiding the way seems to be projects like The Mandoverse and Andor/Rogue One (and the animation as you mentioned).

Andor is still good tho

@@bmarshy .. I’m not too sure of any franchise that didn’t have issues, James Bond, Indiana Jones, fast and the furious, mission, impossible, and the list goes on

@@bmarshy Star Wars fans need to take a damn deep breath, it’s only entertainment, it’s not real life

@@bmarshy.. However, as I mentioned earlier, the majority of fans who enjoyed the first three Star Wars films tend not to watch any of the animated films or series

I completely agree. That’s why I started looking for a way to fix it when I was showing my partner The Mandoverse for the first time. A friend of mine came up with the idea to put the episodes in a different order when we were watching the first couple of episodes of Ahsoka together, so after a few weeks I came up with this episode order. If you feel like the Mandoverse is broken, try watching the shows again in this order and see how the entire story changes and feels much more thought-out. Try it out and let me know what you think!

@@bmarshyEven with your fixes, it’s still technically broken. And you can rearrange all the broken pieces you want, and I think you’ve done it well, but they’re still broken pieces at the end of the day, just in a different arrangement.

There is no mandoverse. There is only Star Wars.

Someone hasn’t seen episode 5 and 6…

@@bmarshyI watched them and he's not in those episodes though, it doesn't say anything about him in them, what are u talking about. The show isn't even done yet its already starting to explain it.

How has this comment got anything to do with the video???