Відео

Uncle Topher, May I ask one question? If the exercise is really just for show, why did The Commander of the Republic of China Navy (中華民國海軍司令),which is the highest-ranking military officer and commander of the Navy of Taiwan, said that it is a "python strategy"? By python strategy, he means that the PLA will keep adding up on the force of the exercise, and eventually is capable of transitioning quickly from one of the joint force exercise to a real war.

幹! 還有一堆統一派害怕 內部! 全是極其嚴重的危險

川普我不喜歡 但是他會勝利

Have been waiting for this video. Thanks for sharing, Topher.

抓重點大概翻譯如下： 4:19 叔叔在看到聯合利劍 2024A 的時候，原本以為會有三次演習，但目前看起來只會有二次。上次有針對聯合利劍 2024A 做過一隻影片，那時候我的看法是：原本以為會看到很多厲害的實彈射擊，結果根本沒有... 但他們確實派了很多船啦！至於這次 2024B... 我根本沒發現有演習，直到演習完媒體報導才發現有演習 😅 可想而知這次的演習更不壯觀了。 這次2024B也沒有實彈射擊，不過確實有很多船，大概 40 艘吧？然後有很多飛機。可是大家不要以為所有飛機都是戰鬥機喔！我發現裡面其實有很多是無人機。當然無人機也可以很危險... 6:32 這些演習看起來好像是要封鎖台灣，但實際上大部分的行動看來更像是在演習封鎖馬祖。 7:02 「聯合利劍」這聯合的意思，在軍事詞彙中指多軍種聯合作戰，例如陸海+空軍，或陸軍+海軍。中共宣稱聯合利劍有陸海空三軍+火箭軍+海巡，但實際上我是看到大部分都是海軍+海巡而已，還有一些些空軍。沒看到火箭軍有什麼行動，我不確定火箭軍到底參與多少。如果你知道哪裡可以看到火箭軍行動的證據，請在評論區給我連結。因為我的中文很差，說不定有漏掉 😅 8:50 還有一件事值得注意，就是這個演習時常有多短。才13個小時！這說明這個演習只是作秀而已，為了統戰宣稱的作秀。我以前在美軍演習的時候，即便我那時只是 cadet，任何的演習，類似聯合利劍這種 field training，從來沒有少於 48 小時的。我不曉得在這麼短的時間，他們能練習到什麼？ 翻譯到一半我發現叔叔有開字幕了 😅 請大家自己去開字幕，然後開自動翻譯，謝謝~~ 對了然後我想提醒叔叔，小心不要講太多美軍細節，中共也可能跑過來聽喔！

From China's latest drills, we can scientifically conclude: Chinese men just can't keep up with what women need-quick and over before you even blink !

Same here.

Great sharing! I was here after watching the “涼山训练”. I think the Topher's sharing is important and all about a selection of training a strong man to become strong soldier or to a strong + half wounded soldier(mentally+physically). Always support the more scientific way of training! Cant wait to watch topher in the 3rd series! Peace!

The PLA did release a propaganda video, but no footage of the Joint Sword 2024B. Most of the footage are from previous exercises. The video is made by the PLA Eastern Theater Command. UA-cam Link: ua-cam.com/video/WM6Jckppbg8/v-deo.htmlsi=MB2ueXhW5Lb276ig

Uncle Topher like to train our English listening and writing.

I doubt a referendum in Kinmen would happen, if they took control of the island then that's it. If a referendum take place then it legitimizes a referendum of independence of Taiwan itself.

選對中國強硬的

long-awaited commentaries ! thanks UNcle Topher

Hey Topher, a few minutes into the video, got me thinking, aren’t you worried about china government might come after you if visit china in the future? Love your videos, from Raleigh NC

哇！！聲音太小了！ 幾乎聽不見，麻煩您下次路的大聲一點點！ 謝謝您

❤

Thank you for your service 👍

Uncle Topher又成功地說服我一次，轉變支持的總統候選人~ 或許川普確實沒那麼糟糕。這也讓我了解其實自己對美國內部現狀了解非常不足!

The background music is so soothing 😂 totally on the contrary to the topic

我對賀沒有信心 她感覺很親中

the "exercises" by china is to make note of how Taiwan reacts and allies. This is for further intelligence and tactical operations to measure capacity, depth, power, support, etc.

The agenda of the Left is to maximize immigration and sensor all public discourse to silence all sane discussions.

The Chinese version of TikTok is filled with pro China propaganda and biased misinformation

As an US voter, would really like to know your take on both candidates.

@Uncle Topher Please, We need to see 中文字幕❤❤❤

if u need help with Chinese or translation, I am happy to help luv ur channel !!!

A story came out that the PLA propaganda exercise was only 6 hours. The US told PLA not get off after detecting Taiwan readied secretive "decapitation operation" of CCP leadership. Just saying.

Because Jinmen is a military strong hold.

CCP PLA is very good at performance arts! They have dancers and singers (actually mistresses of leaders) ranked as “generals”😂 Thanks so much for the military insights❤

Hii Topher ua-cam.com/video/wZ-wdz_GKoA/v-deo.html ua-cam.com/video/11MXIfEGMss/v-deo.html These are propaganda videos from China. Although I believe Taiwanese are unaffected and not scared of their military exercises, I think we still need to be mindful of the 'boy who cried wolf' effect. It’s important to understand their underlying intentions and the cumulative impact of these military actions in recent years. Perhaps we do need to raise our awareness of national defense

Well said Topher. Highly appreciate your kind and important clarifications!

賀錦麗接受記者訪問時回答台灣有權自衛，這是一句廢話。

There was zero military exercise.

57:22 What? the CCP bans TikTok, so why is it ok for us?

叔叔

😅 I think I know who you voted for 😎🤝

Yogo Topher 真是太可愛了😍

ya i can hardly hear you speak up

Kinmen has a CCP friendly representative

我聽不懂，但是還是按讚了😂

26:51- 27:38 WORD. 👍👍

I don’t like Mr. Trump, especially his speech including lots of Discriminatory words. This world will be destroyed possibly and we will face WWIII Because China, Russia, Iran and North Korea. Evil Union. Everyone will ask Who can stop them? I guess Mr. Trump will be the US president. Let the American Great Again.

Can you set auto-generated CC '*ON*'?

美國歷史對外戰爭大多是在民主黨執政時期發生的

戰爭造成成本上升，外交手段靈活，有助減少戰爭提升大部分的人生活品質

量子

about China exercises news link ua-cam.com/video/VAPXYqMIFCw/v-deo.htmlsi=71f0OJOHfs7-4ax5 ua-cam.com/video/aWrdJBMXlKo/v-deo.htmlsi=-N2Wo7_FpAekGyVi

Louder plz

這影片能翻譯中文嗎，感覺很重要

CC 字幕沒開..為難我老人家了.😮‍💨😮‍💨