Відео

Hi thank you for the comment. I wouldn’t agree on all Hornby’s locomotives. They have a huge catalog of models so it’s clear not all are going to be home runs 😊👍

Hi Stephen thanks for the comment! And it’s just the Hornby select controller from train sets, they always sound like this when attempting a crawl. They’re just not great, I have just upgraded to DCC but need a small fortune to upgrade all my locos in one go 😂 yes it’s something I need to check as it was derailing on third radius so clearly something isn’t right. I’ve also contacted TMC where I purchased from to see what they have to say on the matter hopefully they can help 😊👍

Hi thanks for the comment, I didn’t even realise but does look like thick glazing seems to only be through the side you can see it. For me personally it doesn’t detract from the rest of the detail. But I can get how it would bother some 😊👍

Hi Stephen, thank you for the comment! And yes it does seem like most have a very good model in comparison to mine. Like Hylton says it’s definitely faulty. I have contacted TMC and await to hear back from them to see where to go from here. But you’re quite right at that price it’s hard to say no 😊👍

@YorkshireRailways You should have any difficulty getting it replaced (or refunded, if you so wish). TMC is a reputable company. Buy if you do, Consumer law is very clear in such circumstances and is on your side. PS: I guess the reason these 9Fs can operate over exttemely tight curves is the flangless centre driving wheels, which, of course, are prototypical.

@ yes I’ve heard great things about them but I’m ashamed to say it’s my first time shopping with them 😂 but I’ll get it sorted. Preferably would like to have the model but depends if they have more in stock they can exchange it for. And yes I did notice that it’s a very clever design 😊👍

Hi thank you for the comment! And that painting sounds amazing! And yes not to everyone’s taste but the North Norfolk Railways has a special place in my heart so I had to get one 😊👍

@@YorkshireRailways That makes sense. I've lost track of who owns Black Prince now, but I know that it was once owned by David Shepherd.

@ I believe it is still owned by the North Norfolk railway but it’s ran out of its boiler card so won’t be allowed to run until it has some sort of overhaul which will be ££££££

Hi, thanks for the comment. Would disagree as there’s plenty of Hornby models that are a class act. But as with all manufactures there will be defective models. It’s just an unfortunate event when you get one 😊👍

Hi Dennis, thank you for the comment! Glad you enjoyed the video 😊👍

​@@YorkshireRailways You're welcome

Hi Al, thanks for the comment and that’s interesting to hear and I’m sorry you’ve suffered the same issues I have, hopefully it’s just we’re the unfortunate souls and we have both received duds. I’ve contacted TMC on where to go with mine in hope of either a replacement or repair 😊👍

Hi Rob thank you for the comment and kind words. Glad to know you have a good 9F. I have decided to contact TMC to seek advice on the performance of mine as many do seem to have good runners 😊👍

Hi Paul, glad to know you have managed to get a good Black Prince! I have contacted TMC to seek their advice on how to move forward because as you say multiple people seem to have bought them and all seem to run a lot better than mine. Will update when I find out more info 😊👍

I hoped you asked his permission to copy his channel !

The loco looks absolutely stunning!

Sams trains doesn’t own the idea of a model Railway review, go back and watch channels like Intercity82, a guy who started making model reviews in the late 2000s. Of course there’s going to be similar talking points in any review, like box, detail, performance, etc. Its not something you need permission for, unless you’re directly ripping an idea off.

Not really. Sam spends a great deal of time dissecting the mechanism whereas YR doesn't (at least in this review). That is not a criticism of either of them. All reviewers are entitled to adopt their own approach, provided they are fair and constructive. Both are, IMO.

@@robmckenzie2538 He even uses the same vocab eg Repeating the word stunning over and over.

Hi thank you for the comment! And yes the model was run in 30 mins in either directions before adding a load. Some manufacturers say you don’t but me personally I always do 😊👍

Yes, Hornby do seem to have a problem with quality consistency...

Hi Olivier thank you for the comment. Touch wood this is the first Hornby locomotive I’ve had issues like this with, I’ve contacted TMC where I bought it from to seek advice and where to move forward. Good to hear you have no issue running your 9F’s on R2 I’ll have to give it another try if I can get a replacement sent out 😊👍

Hi Ray, thank you for the comment! And yes I fear as much I have just contacted them to see where we can go from here. Hopefully a swap and a new one might prove to be better. If so I will do an updated review to show the true potential. I imagine on DCC with sound it’s amazing and I can’t wait to get mine chipped. Which decoder did you go with if you don’t mind me asking? 😊👍

I picked up an old Hornby TTS Decoder with speaker, I am well pleased with it, used a 21 to 8 pin adaptor which I had already. You can easily spend a lot of money!!

@@raymondjohnson6129 that sounds good and yes I have about 30+ locomotives currently so going to cost a fair bit to DCC chip and sound them all

Hi David thanks for the comment! Yes I would imagine that would be a good solution, however unlike Sam I don’t really possess the talent to do that and I wouldn’t feel comfortable trying whilst it’s still in the warranty period. I haven’t checked the gauging so will do that and see if adjustments are needed to allow smoother running. Thank you 😊👍

Hi Gordon, thank you for the comment! And it would seem from other comments that my example shouldn’t be the case and that it more than likely is a faulty model. I’ve contacted TMC for advice to see what they can do for me 😊👍

Hi Alan, thanks for the comment. It’s my controller that’s the Hornby select from train sets. It’s not very good but I am in the process of upgrading to DCC, I have the controller just need chip my locos 😊👍

Hi Bill, thanks for the comment and I’m sorry this is your experience. I have a feeling this one will be as well, the motor just doesn’t seem to be performing as others suggest it should. All the best 😊👍

Hi Patrick thank you for the comment. Yes fully aware my controller is terrible but I already have. The only problem is it’s DCC so I’m currently in the process of chipping my locos which isn’t going to be cheap 😂 so because I’m taking this step I won’t be changing my analog controller. All the best 😊👍

Hi thanks for the comment and wow that does sound like a bargain. Yes unfortunately it can be like that but I’ve being lucky this far. I’m tempted to get into contact with TMC and see what they think. All the best and take care 😊👍

@@YorkshireRailways sending them a polite enquiry can’t hurt!

@@Alpha-oo8 yeah did that this morning but I imagine been the weekend I won’t hear back till Monday

Hi Jersey Bill thanks for the comment! And yes it is making me scratch my head. I’m tempted to contact TMC to see their thoughts on the matter and see if I actually have a faulty model. May be the best thing going forward. Thanks for the kind words mate and all the best 😊👍

@@YorkshireRailways I think you, Me, and Hylton are of the same mind send it back and get a replacement. Good luck

Yes I’m going to get in touch with both Hornby Direct and TMC to see their thoughts and I think it will be going back for a replacement.

Hi thank you for the comment! And more than likely it’s the controller. I never bothered upgrading my analogue controller from the Hornby select that comes with the train sets as I knew I would be upgrading to a DCC controller at some point which I did get for Christmas. However it means I now need to chip all my locos, so for review purposes I will still be using the Hornby one for now. I’m interested to try taking the chip out of my Class 91 and put it in the 9F to test if it is the controller. Might be good for another video? And well I did get it from TMC in their after Christmas sale but I had a further 5% knocked off from a discount code I had in a magazine so I can’t complain about the price just the quality of the model. I’m tempted to see TMC’s thoughts on if this loco needs to go back for a swap or if it is knows to run like this. Anyway thank you for the comment and all the best 😊👍

Guagemaster analogue controllers use half wave rectification because DC motors run much better with it. PS Although they don't make the din that the one in the vid does!

Hi Hylton thank you so much mate! And I feel the same the tooling for the model is incredible it’s really well detailed with some nice features included. But I’m stumped with the performance. I’m waiting to see collectively what others say if this is a common thing or I’ve got a dud like you say. I’ve had it about three weeks and I’m tempted to contact TMC to see there thoughts on this because you’re quite right I don’t see myself being happy with this long term. Which is a shame as the Black Prince has a special place in my railwaying heart to have it be so bad 😂 either way time will tell I’ll fill you in when I have more to update. All the best mate!

Totally agree with you, Hylton. Mine (also bought from TMC @ £149) is an excellent performer. Harry's example does seem to be faulty.

@@stephendavies6949 that’s great to know Stephen! I have contacted TMC so will see if they can help sort things 😊

Hi mate, yes keeping well! And wow seems to be a huge difference between yours and mine. I am wondering whether to try swap it for a new one as it doesn’t seem good in comparison. I’m using the Hornby select which I know isn’t brilliant but I’ve upgraded recently for a DCC controller just need to chip all my locos 😂

@@YorkshireRailways i was going to say use a gaugemaster combi for dcc ready or analogue It does not buzz. Every one is models are different

I was going to get one of those but decided I wanted to take the leap to DCC which I’m glad I have as it’s a different ball game with sound so I’m looking forward to getting more locos chipped.

Hi Elliott thanks for the comment and I wouldn’t necessarily agree with all their models but I do find it interesting that a lot pop up in the sales at a really high discount 😊👍

Hi Thanks for the comment and yes that can be the case for a lot of people but I’d imagine for the price it could give more beginners looking for a high quality model the chance to get one 😊👍

Hi Tony, thanks for the comment! I’m a big fan of the GNER takes me back to my childhood going up and down the east coast 😊👍

Hi William, thanks for the comment and I’m in the same boat, there’s the odd bit I might pick up but waiting to see what comes from other manufacturers first. But I’m sure there’s still time to get some beetles wagons 😉 All the best 😊👍

Hi thank you so much for your comment and feedback! Yes the saints class I think is the highlight for most, hopefully it will be a good one. I will say for me personally there wasn’t much I will be picking up this year from the new range but I do think it’s a good all rounder and definitely for beginners perfect time to start with the amount of affordable railroad models on the market 😊👍

Yes I’m very excited to see what they are cooking up. That’s a great idea but good to know it is a nem pocket so you can interchange them. I thought that would be the case with the class 800 but I’m excited to see them. And yes the railroad range has had some series love this year Thanks for the comment 😊👍

@@markcale7034 Hi Mark, as I’ve established many times I do not have an issue with Hornby making the beetles wagons/trains if it works for them so they can fund new tooling great it’s a win win. It’s some innocent fun as many people do call it the beetles tat models. I’m fully aware it’s not aimed at me or my age group and that is okay. Only some light hearted banter it’s not that deep. If you are one of the people who really enjoy the beetles range that’s great and I’m glad you enjoy your models. Have a good day 👍

Hi Jersey Bill, thanks for the comment as always! And yeah bit of a jam packed year to talk about stuff 😂 I was loosing my voice a little towards the end. But thank you so much glad you enjoyed the video 😊

Hi Andrew thanks for the comment! I believe it’s using the same tooling as the GWR High speed train set that does have the long mk3 so if it does it will be a decent set to go for 😊👍

Hi James thanks for the comment, no it has a plastic body shell review is coming soon so stay tuned 😊👍

Hi Hylton thank you so much mate! And yeah I think they have a very solid range this year as well, nice to see they’ve gone heavy on railroad range at affordable pricing hopefully will bring in new blood to the hobby. Hope you’re keeping well my friend 😊👍

Hi ARP, thanks mate doing a lot better now! And I can see the saint selling out on preorder seems many are after it! And that’s good to know, seems a good price and nice to see a new tooled railroad 0-4-0. Yeah the Christmas wagons are a little pricy for effectively a new print every year they could be a lot cheaper. Keep well my friend 😊👍

Hi Matt, thanks for the comment! Couldn’t agree more it’s where most of us started and this years range definitely has something for everyone. Great to hear the models that are on your wishlist. I’d definitely like to grab another Class 91 but will have to see how my budget goes this year 😂

Hi and thank you for the comment, I never knew that but it doesn’t seem to sound as fancy 😂

Hi Ray thanks for the comment and feedback. And well for me personally the tin box modern image some takes my interest as I enjoy been able to see the real life locos running on the mainline as well as on my layout but I get they’re not for everyone. Steam does take my interest as well but I’m sure there will be something to float everyone’s boat 😊 think we are in an era of model railways where we are really being spoilt for choice. But not long to wait for the announcement! Take care and all the best 😊👍

@@dakshanbalaramesh Hi thank you for the comment and the way modelling trends are going I could see the GNR great northern making the cut. A lot of pre grouping models seem very popular at the moment! Not long to go until we find out! 😊👍

Haha we don’t mention the steampunk range 😂 it’s best to forget they even were a thing, but yes 20 years down the line they’ll be going for silly money on eBay 😂 although I did see some have finally sold out on Hornby.com

@@YorkshireRailways maybe Hornby should rebrand and enter the O Gauge market under Basset-Lowke

@ I’d be interested to see Hornby take that leap but I think for now they’re focused on been financially viable and sticking with OO and TT:120

@@mikeyratcliff3400 seems your more up on era 1 than I am but I chose invicta purely for its striking colour, components could be shared from previous models to help Hornby’s financial turmoil and the name is cool 😂 but not long until we find out

@@mikeyratcliff3400 Hi Mikey thanks for the comment and some amazing suggestions there! Not long to go until we find out

Hi Jersey Bill, thanks for the comment as always. Yeah it has been a tad cold here, getting better now though the temps have been rising today. And it’s one of them things there was a lot of colds and bugs going round through December just unfortunately I got every one of them 😂 and yes I do have one but it’s not the best I could do with getting a new one. And yes won’t be long until we find out so stay tuned for my breakdown of the new range see if I get any right 😊 take care mate and all the best 😊👍

@@williamvanalen9414 Hi William thanks for the comment, and yes I saw over Christmas a lot of the Hornby 08s were heavily discounted but I wouldn’t be buying one at full RRP, myself I am waiting for the Bachmann release. Haven’t got one on preorder yet but it’s on my watchlist 😊👍

@@williamvanalen9414 hi William thanks for the comment, and I found it pretty easy to be honest. The best way is having a small tray or pot for the screws and remember the way you take it apart. Because reassembly is just doing it in reverse. But yeah had no trouble with Smokey Joe. Sorry that’s not the most help, but all the best with your locos 😊👍

@@jonathanmillar1975 Hi Jonathan, thank you for the comment! And some great suggestions! I do think there is a high demand at the moment for network rail engineering vehicles so it will be interesting to see which manufacturers jump on the band wagon and flood the market with them. Not long to go till we find out. All the best 😊👍

@@christopherbellamy639 Hi Christopher those are some cracking suggestions. Only time will tell what will come. All the best 😊👍

Hi Adi thanks for the comment and thank you for subscribing. Yes maybe a bit safe but tried to think logically as to what we might see more than a wish list of locos I want sort of thing. A steam generator tank engine would be great just not sure if the technology is small enough to fit in a loco of that size yet. All the best 😊👍

​@@YorkshireRailways would be interesting to see a smoke generator in a tank engine or a diesel cuz they smoke as well

@@AdiPullen could see them doing a diesel more than the tank engine but I think for now they’ll be sticking to big tender engines

Some great additions there and haha I think there’s a market to do a whole load of fizzy drink inspired models, it’s got to be a better seller than the beetles 😂 I’d be interested to see if a few train sets of decent quality make the cut. Take care and all the best 😊👍