Відео

Why did you make that statue with the Notch head 8:47

do you understand, that all your criticism of new Minecraft apply to old Minecraft too?, gold tools, lapis and pigs are just some examples of old "bloat", having any structures at all takes away the canvas feeling, Minecraft updates today are way bigger then they used to be, if added fireflies would just be another useless mob to complain about, same thing for the mob vote losers, the only reason you play the "meta" is because you decide to , Minecraft is giving you free regular updates updates, and better yet lets you play the older versions of the game, which people like to take for granted, ask any community of any other game, and they will tell you that they wish they got the treatment that the minecraft community gets

I've only been playing Better Than Adventure. All the updates are literally mechanics from Terraria, which is an improvement in my book. Just turn it into Terraria.

Oh boy time to yap: overall its fair to not like a version, and honestly this is the best video ive seen discussing modern minecraft vs beta. There really isnt a clear winner and i like that this feels more of an argument for how good beta minecraft is to this day, it does make me want to try and play an old version as a challenge one day. But, that being said i do like yapping and breaking down the reasonings for people's opinions and i wanna point out the minor issues i have with your arguments: 1:16 this one is fair, the past few updates included some nice stuff out of context but with how the caves and cliffs update was handled... it definitely felt underwhelming to see the vision of the update being split into 3 parts. And with the silly reasoning with the firefly not being added still urks me to this day, I do think people should reflect on what was added rather than what was not, because honestly we got some pretty nice additions to the game despite it all. 3:59 again this one is also fair, not many people particularly enjoy seeing their favorite mobs get kicked off the face of the earth because one got the most votes. I was one who particularly loved the concept of the copper golem, he looked like a funny dude and i wouldve happily made a redstone build that was decided by the golem pressing one button or not. I will say i disagree with the idea that the armadillo has no involvement with the trial chambers, it introduced wolf armor which ended up being incredibly useful when its behavior got reworked to absorb both fire and creeper explosions, let alone just basic hits from zombies, spiders and skeletons. this makes bringing a wolf with you to a chamber actually worth while, since they scare off skeletons and boggs. One major issue im noticing from the first 2 arguments is while theyre fair, they have nothing to do with what modern minecraft offers in terms of gameplay, this is simply an argument that mojang hasnt been doing well at managing updates and their mob votes. which is fair, ive warmed up to the fact that what we got was pretty good but i will still be on the fence hoping that they learned their mistakes and will change things around for the better. the future of 1.22 and their new update cycles seem interesting and i hope this means they plan to release smaller but more consistent updates that people are happy with. 5:24 ok this i have a personal problem with. not because i dont see the point youre trying to make but because this is part of an argument that urks me. where do we draw the line between wanting more mobs with functionaility and adding "too many gimmicks". because not all the mobs have to contribute to your day to day gameplay, if they did, this would only fuel the point you make later about the "meta" being an issue, i just want mobs that have a fun interaction personally, not give me a new enchantment that only they can give me, or a mace equivalent for the crabs arms or some random bizarre addition. 6:11 im mixed on this. I completely agree that the modern community is abysmal, but thats a biproduct imo of people being exposed to games all about progression and "work". Players nowadays are obsessed with having the best playthrough in the most efficient way possible. But my main argument against this is what you mentioned later on. While we cant change their minds on how to play minecraft, that doesnt mean we have to play like them, this is a sandbox game through and through where the player gets to decide how they play. And its good that youre attempting to slow down and try and do what you want to do. And honestly imo the best examples of youtubers playing minecraft for fun are the people from hermitcraft, seeing them do their own thing and creating memories with each other and online is what makes minecraft (to me at least) fun. 8:00 now this is an interesting reason for liking beta. I think thats fair and its why i enjoy games like no mans sky when im exploring their planets, it feels empty and i like exploring a place that no one has ever been to. However, an easy rebuttle to this is by turning off "generate structures". Thats the best way to recreate that same feeling, and id argue it would be even cooler if it meant you could make your own village from scratch thanks to villager zombies being a spawnable entity. 9:00 this last one is a pretty good viewpoint on "less is more". However while i agree that creativity is at its best when you have limited blocks to use, that doesnt mean it cant be the same as modern minecraft, Building in survival has its benefits by being more rewarding when you obtain a new block that fits your build. Hell ive been so happy with the addition of bamboo planks because i now can create some wonderful houses out of the funny green sticks. Again this isnt a big issue i have because i understand the sentiment. honestly i have to say again i do like this video, its well structured and while i dont think your points are convincing that doesnt mean they arent valid, they make a good point that beta has alot to offer even if it doesnt have as much as modern minecraft, and i think its fair to not like how mojang has managed minecraft recently. I just wish the community would stop making scare tactics in order to sell that the game is hopeless and needs an overhaul.

BTA has tall birch forests AND fireflies!

Been 7+ years since I played minecraft. You had just expressed everything I had thought. Well done

There's something lethal about this company

I love this so much haha! This game does a good job of making everyone look gormless. 😂

Boeing Simulator

I hate to be this guy but the armadillo’s came out in their own update the armored paws aka 1.20.5

I dont play beta, I build like If I was still in beta. I have NEVER once changed my building style and I'm proud of what I can make with this style.

Player87 is writing. Nice video man, minecraft is really nice to look at.

despite not actually playing it when it came out, my first memories of minecraft was actually of beta (probably). i remember watching a lot of a youtube series of a group of friends playing minecraft when i was younger, and they had no hunger, so obviously before 1.8 beta. then i got minecraft and was super confused when i saw the hunger bar. dunno exactly when i got minecraft but it was probably some time between 2012-2014.

I agree about the market place and will like to add the suffocating all over your face aggressive marketing for realms when in reality both options are offered by the community with better qualities and offers

New Nvidia popup this is fake!!!

try playing this "modernbeta" server, its on the latest version of minecraft but theyre trying to make it indistinguishable from actual beta, boxblair's made a video on it so far and is making a series on it, the player base is pretty chill too.

where the timestamps at 😢😮

Well... at least you aren't like Sipover, who literally says that old minecraft was BETTER because it had less diversity of blocks... Also, I find it funny how y'all like beta more because of limitations, kinda reminds me of Jesse Keeler as he once said he propaply really enjoys limitations, as he is in a band with just 2 people.

Sorry for the long essay, but i see no one bringing up this point so here it goes: The Modern Minecraft Terrain Generation Problem- I'm going to postulate that the problem started with the Elytra. Now that you can fly (end game loot, btw) Mojang had to make the terrain more enormous. Not only that, but Mojang also assumes that people have beefy computers that can render VERY FAR for muh vistas. Minecraft feels more Oppressive because of the beefy mountains and the vacuous caves. It is no longer "cozy" where YOU are "god" of this world and are impelled to make it come to life. You see that mountain over there as big as Everest? Yeah, try and make THAT on your own! How can you compete with that? The mountain is the focal point and not YOUR creations. It's as if Minecraft turned the player into an ant, insignificant against the mighty world generation that does all the "impressive terraforming" for you and Without You. That your creations are just tacked on blemishes against the beauty of the world gen. It makes me sad and feel completely disconnected as I have to try and strain myself to make my builds flow more seamlessly into the landscapes (most humans want to preserve nature around their homes and thus this instinct is carried over when we play Minecraft) It feels bad when you want to make something but have to destroy a pretty hillside. Not only that but also an Over-Abundance of little points of interests scattered around in what feels like every 20 or so chunks. Shipwrecks, ruined portals, witch huts. villages (which used to be a rare sight) underwater ruins etc. They are too numerous and are places for easy loot. Why? Now Minecraft feels like a Linear game, going from point of interest A to point of interest B, etc. etc. Endless Distractions. The world is already populated.... It doesn't need you anymore....... I hate that this game gives off the same vibe as in real life. The world is already full and your intervention ultimately is meaningless... TL;DR: Minecraft is no longer your blank canvas. It is now a frustrating/constricting picture where by you add your creativity on an already crowded and finished canvas...

Minecraft is too big of a game with a lot of kids playing it... it will never have a good update again. Risks are too high to be really creative again. Minecraft just feels so soft and cartoony now days. When i was a kid it was this dark, rough and gritty game with very shitty simulation feel to it. Wich was the main apeal to it. Cus it didnt feel it wasnt made for kids but was literallu legos. Modern day minexraft just lost its charm. The cartoonyness is scaring off herobrine

About frogs and fireflies... ... you can WILLINGLY poison a parrot with cocoa seeds.

I love this content type, all of beta 1.7.3 is interesting

Adding a definitive end-state to minecraft felt like the moment the degradation began. In pre-End minceraft, the only "end" goal was diamond tools and conquering the nether. I remember Notch mentioning that one of the main inspirations for the game was Dwarf Fortress, which is much the same way; the only "end" goal is candy and conquering the circus. Otherwise, both old-school minceraft and DF both only have a "goal" of seeing what you could eventually build for yourself in your own world. Modern minecraft is different. There's a final boss. There's a million structures to find and conquer. There's villages to grow and protect. Why bother building a cool caste, a illustrious mansion, redstone contraptions, rollercoasters, pixel art? There's nether fortresses and strongholds to find! And you're gonna need a mob farm if you ever want to get the ender pearls for the end gate! Now, much like you reitierate in the video, I'm not going to be a nostalgic boomer who says it was objectively better in pre-release. But alpha, beta, and pre-release minecraft is a different game than release minecraft, and I prefer the relative simplicity of the pre-release versions.

I don't understand the hate for the marketplace. The marketplace is trash because it was executed poorly and has no content moderation... but wow creators getting paid for their hard work what a travesty..... /s :L Other than that I like your points and enjoyed your video. Thanks for sharing your thoughts.

I agree with the whole people are creative thing. + the beta community is less toxic and don't grief as much compared to modern communities.

I play alpha minecraft ._. (I used to play beta but alpha feels KINDA funnier but they all are better than "MoDeRn MiNeCrAfT"

Your doing good keep it up and I love the concept of u reliving beta

I find it so hypocritical of them to say fireflies weren't added because of the frogs would die if they ate them but cookies still kill parrots if you feed them the cookies like what the heck.

What a miss the most is how the beta terrain feels almost alien, as well as the music. I loved the idea of colonizing and surviving in a alien world, and now the terrain is now big, but realistic. The music has been made more catered to the realistic vibe and player, and it just feels different.

As much as I like the QoL of Modern, I am willing to sacrifice it all for Beta. Everything feels better with Beta. Excellent terrain generation. No bloat and simple. No end goal or any RPG elements, just a pure sandbox. I am currently building a wizard tower, and then I'm gonna try to build the Shire. Modern Mojang would have never added the Creeper.

The series are gonna be awesome. I SMELL IT.

i like how you did your mine the exact same way as on bb lol good vido

docspot try to have a consistent intro challenge (IMPOSSIBLE)

0:32 OMG GRAY REFERENCE

I look forward to this series

Hey it's the intro!

You got a lot done in 400 days, really impressive. Loved the details that you put on your builds :)

Oh wows