SaadtheMuzlim
SaadtheMuzlim
  • 6
  • 103 100
Is Fiction HARAM? (BEST and EASIEST explanation + EXACT rulings!)
IS FICTION HARAM IN ISLAM? What about fantasy and magic?
I've spent weeks of my life trying to answer the very alienating questions of: Is fiction halal ? And, is fantasy halal ? Inshallah, this is the best explanation you'll find on this topic.
Btw, this is a RE-UPLOAD. I made a mistake in the last video which I have now rectified.
Sources:
Quran.com
Sunnah.com
The Quran on storytelling:
www.researchgate.net/publication/277132608_The_literary_facets_of_the_qur%27an_as_a_guideline_for_islamic_literary_writing
Ma'arif-ul-Quran Baqarah:102:
quran.com/en/2:102/tafsirs/en-tafsir-maarif-ul-quran
Fiction is haram:
ua-cam.com/video/xytF9Rn3cUU/v-deo.html
ua-cam.com/video/d1FuwUxOW88/v-deo.html
ua-cam.com/video/g7Q2cDWayvE/v-deo.html
Fiction is halal:
ua-cam.com/video/d1FuwUxOW88/v-deo.html
ua-cam.com/video/fHf1b83BMBA/v-deo.html
islamqa.info/en/163469
My argument for fantasy:
ua-cam.com/video/d1FuwUxOW88/v-deo.html
Chapters:
0:00 THE BEGINNING :0
0:23 FICTION in Islam
0:27 Fiction is haram
044 No, it's not
1:21 More Proof
1:53 Is FANTASY haram?
3:17 The Grey Area
4:14 THE RULES
Переглядів: 3 716

Відео

The Real Meaning of Jihad (BEST and EASIEST explanation)
Переглядів 2,8 тис.3 місяці тому
What is the REAL Meaning of Jihad? Is Isis or 9/11 an ideal example of Islamic Jihad? How can you partake in Jihad and what's the importance of it in in your day to day life? These are all the questions that I'll be answering in this video! Background Music (which is vocals-only) by: @HalalBeatsWorld halalbeats.io www.youtube.com/@HalalBeatsWorld Source: A Lecture (in Urdu) by Dr. Israr Ahmed u...
10 'Unscientific' Quran Verses DEBUNKED
Переглядів 2,4 тис.3 місяці тому
These are the 10 most common 'Unscientific' verses in the Quran that you've probably heard from every anti-Islam preacher, all refuted by me :) Source video: ua-cam.com/video/7GfdOjyLwGw/v-deo.html Inspire by Jan ryczkowski's video: ua-cam.com/video/W2seyQe9YG4/v-deo.html Sources: Quran.com Sunnah.com ua-cam.com/video/W2seyQe9YG4/v-deo.html My imagination :) Chapters: 0:00 Lets start! 0:13 Milk...
Is Drawing Prohibited? (BEST and EASIEST explanation + EXACT rulings)
Переглядів 74 тис.6 місяців тому
IS DRAWING HARAM IN ISLAM? I've spent weeks of my life trying to answer this one question, and this is my answer to the extremely alienating question of: Is Drawing Prohibited? Inshallah, this is the best explanation you'll find on this topic. Smaller issues: Putting facial features on non-living things? Haram, according to ua-cam.com/video/TOQ56qll1Bo/v-deo.html Drawing a full face but without...
Is Music Permitted? (BEST and EASIEST explanation + HALAL alternatives!)
Переглядів 18 тис.7 місяців тому
Is music PERMITTED? This is possibly one of the most debated, alienating, and internet-argument-causing topic in the Muslim world. But, this video is here to put an end to the entire discussion and finally give a satisfying answer to the question of whether music is halal or haram. Sources: sunnah.com/ Quran.com/ About Abdullah ibn Masood: hadithoftheday.com/abdullah-ibn-masud/ The Music Made M...
Andrew Tate SCHOOLS Piers Morgan on Israel Palestine | Is hamas a terror organization?
Переглядів 2,2 тис.11 місяців тому
Free Palestine. This is a shortened version of the legendary debate between Piers Morgan and Andrew Tate on Israel and Palestine. Tate's every point was logical and agreeable, whereas Piers only demonstrated his love for Israel. PART 2: Andrew Tate Talks Palestine and Israel With Piers Morgan | Latest Interview: ua-cam.com/video/2pMsYSR7g78/v-deo.html Tags (Ignore): andrew tate podcast,palestin...

КОМЕНТАРІ

  • @sw33t_b3rri3s
    @sw33t_b3rri3s 2 години тому

    AHH TYSM!! some people would tell me that "oh drawing faces is haram" or "drawing eyes is hara" and i was super confused, but now whenever i draw on paper I'll make sure to make one feature missing!

  • @LearnWSheren
    @LearnWSheren День тому

    what about making a pixel art character without face for game assets?

  • @NathanielThomson-bh8po
    @NathanielThomson-bh8po 3 дні тому

    So can i keep the face in drawing with just removing the nose ??

  • @tanzimkakon8839
    @tanzimkakon8839 3 дні тому

    Trees have also life, they are not non living beings.Quran is complete book,we Don't need anything else...Hadis create confusion,it was made more than 238 years after Muhammad passed away and far away from Mecca. So how hadis can be so accurate when it is not approved by our prophet

  • @AllahHuAkbar-g9z
    @AllahHuAkbar-g9z 3 дні тому

    You used music in this video

  • @BlindfoldedPerson
    @BlindfoldedPerson 5 днів тому

    brother please make a video about gaming

  • @AhmedKhan-pw4fk
    @AhmedKhan-pw4fk 6 днів тому

    Saving the ummah from the dajjals trap. It’s important to give dawah on social media because the islamophobics are spreading fitna everywhere on tiktok , you tube and many social media paltforms. Mashallah keep making them videos brother

  • @AhmedKhan-pw4fk
    @AhmedKhan-pw4fk 6 днів тому

    Love you brother , you are doing Jihad Mashallah ❤

  • @AllahHuAkbar-g9z
    @AllahHuAkbar-g9z 7 днів тому

    Good work

  • @Aprotop
    @Aprotop 7 днів тому

    Please I need answer. Is halal making 3d human models or animal models without face or head.I don't make it show off, I just enjoy making it

  • @SpaceCowboy5634
    @SpaceCowboy5634 8 днів тому

    allah is gay lol

  • @crunchybirdy
    @crunchybirdy 9 днів тому

    Wait so do we have to remove the entire face or can we keep certain facial features and just remove one feature, like the nose or mouth?

    • @yoruaintknow131
      @yoruaintknow131 9 днів тому

      he says only remove the eyes but as my pov does it make any different then human? a person without eyes is just a blind person!

    • @crunchybirdy
      @crunchybirdy 8 днів тому

      @yoruaintknow131 I watched another video on this topic and it showed a credible article stating that you can choose to remove the eyes, nose, or mouth :)

  • @7fa51h
    @7fa51h 10 днів тому

    Bro at 1:37 avoid using such animations in terms putting Surah Liqman on one anime and Music on the other.

  • @ManhwaExplaineer
    @ManhwaExplaineer 11 днів тому

    Is it permissible to draw a body with a face missing one facial feature?

  • @Anaya9434
    @Anaya9434 11 днів тому

    Music is haram, but playing videogames isn't haram. Music is haram, but playing sports isn't haram. Music is haram, but taking pictures and videos isn't haram. Music is haram, but listening to podcasts isn't haram. Music is haram, but making jokes isn't haram. Music is haram, but reading a non-islamic book isn't haram. All of these things may not benefit us on the day of judgement but saying they are haram is completely not what Islam promotes. Subhanallah brother! that you found 1 interpretation of the Quran out of DOZENS that proves your point. This same scholar believed that a woman showing 2 eyes was haram! All those poor companions of the prophet that owned flutes and other musical instruments who didn't know about the correct interpretation? May Allah have mercy on them. Congratulations... I could write an essay about Bukhari but just because people were listening to music while doing haram things in their drinking party like drinking alcohol doesn't make it haram in itself. Association does not mean that they themselves were condemned. I can understand deriving the ruling that music with sex, alcohol, drugs is haram but music in itself? not so much. Also, the wearing of silk is permissible for women :) Islam is a religion that has rulings that are in the middle and not extreme. For example we can't gamble but we can still play games and have fun. In fact I'd argue that singing is 100 times worse than just instruments, but it is what it is.

  • @hyper-2308
    @hyper-2308 11 днів тому

    Is it "haram" or just sinful

  • @hyper-2308
    @hyper-2308 11 днів тому

    is it permissible to draw full-body of beings where face is covered for a reason, i.e full body of a knight or a biker with helmet?

  • @yahyayazgi
    @yahyayazgi 14 днів тому

    is sfx haram?

  • @randomviber7502
    @randomviber7502 15 днів тому

    Can i make AI photos without Facial features? Plsss reply

  • @ahmedcosovic2195
    @ahmedcosovic2195 15 днів тому

    These are not my words but I found in one comment on Zakir Naiks youtube video. If you read it pls give an opinion the comment is this: Drawing is NOT forbidden. With respect to depicting human and animal life, scholars of Islamic Law present a spectrum of opinion, running the gamut from those who view all image-making to be lawful to those who categorically prohibit all drawings of animal life. The First Opinion: Some scholars hold the view that image making is essentially lawful. It is permissible to make two-dimensional illustrations as well as three-dimensional statues. The scholars who hold this view argue that the texts that prohibit image making are to be understood in the context of the state the people were in at the advent of Islam. The people had just emerged from the times of ignorance and from idolatry. After people became distanced from the worship of images, the prohibition was no longer necessary. This is why we see in some history books that when the Muslims opened up the lands of the Persians and Romans, they did not interfere with the pictures and statues found there. The Second Opinion: Some scholars hold the view that all images are unlawful, make two-dimensional illustrations as well as three-dimensional statues. They base their argument on the apparent meaning of a number of texts. These include the following: `A’ishah relates that the Prophet (peace be upon him) said: “The people who will be most severely punished on the Day of Resurrection will be those who aspire to create like Allah.” [Sahîh al-Bukhârî (5954) and Sahîh Muslim (2107)] Ibn ``Abbâs relates that the Prophet (peace be upon him) said: “Every image maker is in the Fire. For each image he made, a being will be fashioned to torment him in Hell.” [Sahîh al-Bukhârî (2225) and Sahîh Muslim (2110) - The wording accords with al-Bukhârî] Abû Talhah relates that the Prophet (peace be upon him) said: “The angels do not enter a house wherein there is a dog or images representing (people or animals).” [Sahîh al-Bukhârî (3225) and Sahîh Muslim (2106)] The Third Opinion: Other scholars hold a view that is intermediate between the former two. They argue that only three-dimensional images are prohibited. Those are the images being referred to by hadîth like “Every image maker is in the Fire.” They argue that only the manufacture of three-dimensional images can possibly be described as “aspiring to create like Allah.” Moreover, statues and not illustrations are the objects that people are most likely to take as objects of worship. The drawings and illustrations to be found on cloth, on paper, and decorating walls are, therefore, not objectionable. After considering all of the evidence, the opinion that appears to be the strongest of the three is the last opinion. The reasons why it is the strongest opinion are as follows: 1. The question of a person aspiring to create like Allah is really a question of that person’s intent. It is an action of the heart and it is tantamount to unbelief. A person who acts with such intent is in a state of unbelief, regardless of whether he is making replicas of animals or of inanimate objects like trees, rocks, rivers, or mountains. This is the reason for the prohibition against the image making in the hadîth. This is the reason why the image makers are being cursed. This is clarified by another hadîth where the Prophet (peace be upon him) said: “Allah says: ‘Who does a greater wrong than one who aspires to creates as I create - a grain of corn, a seed, or a barleycorn?” [Sahîh al-Bukhârî (7559) and Sahîh Muslim (2111) - The wording accords with al-Bukhârî] Therefore, if the reason for the prohibition is that of aspiring to create like Allah creates, then the subject matter is irrelevant. It makes no difference if the image is that of an animal or an inanimate object. 2. The manufacture of statuary is unlawful because this activity is only carried out in order to aggrandize the subject. Such aggrandizement poses a danger of veneration and worship. The same can be said for photographs of prominent people when those photographs are erected high up in prominent places to be honored. In this case, such pictures become most certainly unlawful. The story of Noah’s people and how their making of statues in commemoration of their pious forebears led to their idolatry is clear proof of this danger. In our day and age, we see the pictures of many people displayed in public places for the purpose of false veneration. When we look at the generality of the statement - “Every image maker is in the Fire” -such a general statement cannot literally apply except to a great sin. This sin is that of willfully and intentionally aspiring to create like Allah. The word “every” that begins this sentence is the strongest word for indicating generality. Since it is then annexed to the indefinite noun “image maker” it linguistically indicates that generality is intended. The sentence is similar in structure to Allah’s words: “Every soul shall taste of death.” [Sûrah Al `Imrân: 185] When we look at the phrase - “those who aspire to create like Allah” - the term “aspire” here indicates a challenge. It means that these image makers are fashioning images in order to imitate Allah’s creative abilities and to present a challenge to Allah. We see in another hadîth related by Ibn `Abbâs that the Prophet (peace be upon him) said: “Those people who make these images in this world will be punished on Day of Resurrection. They will be commanded to breathe life into what they had created.” [Sahîh al-Bukhârî (5951) and Sahîh Mulsim (2108)] This specifies for us the meaning of “Every image maker is in the Fire” and the other hadîth mentioned above. All of the hadîth about image making refer to the intent of image maker to aspire to create like Allah. We find in the texts mention of many other major sins that are certainly worse that the making of images - like adultery, taking usury, and abusing parents - without it being declared that the perpetrators of those sins are consigned to the Fire, like we find in “Every image maker is in the Fire”. This should make it even clearer to us that those who make images without the intention of aspiring to create like Allah are not included in the generality of the hadîth’s meaning. Rather, the hadîth applies to all of those who have the intention of aspiring to create like Allah. 3. If we look at the statements of the Pious Predecessors, we can see that they understood the texts about image making to be merely a severe warning against what is sinful rather than a direct prohibition. For instance, when a man who was a professional image maker came to Ibn `Abbâs asking him for a ruling, Ibn `Abbâs merely said: “If you have to do so, then make images of trees and of that which has no soul. [Sahîh al-Bukhârî (2225) and Sahîh Muslim (2110)] Ibn `Abbâs was neither harsh with him nor did he make any categorical statement. He said nothing more than that. We find that the Pious Predecessors generally made statements about image making that indicated nothing more than pious reserve and avoiding that which can lead to deviance. 4. Many types of images produced today are meant for education and can hardly be dispensed with. One pictorial representation can often suffice for hundreds of words. We can see that `A’ishah used to play with dolls, and they were three-dimensional images. Such toys are permitted by the sacred texts. Scholars explain this permissibility by saying that the purpose behind such images is one of instruction and educational play. The ruling, then, applies to the general cause and not to the particular instance that illustrates this cause. If three-dimensional figures are permitted for children for education and constructive play, then it is even more appropriate that such images be permitted for adults, since adults are required to learn a far greater range of more difficult and critical skills. In today’s world, images - especially two-dimensional images - are indispensable for people to carry out the necessary activities of life. The ruling that such images are permissible is in harmony with the general ease and facility of Islamic Law. Allah says: “Allah wants to make things easy for you, and he does not want things to be difficult for you.” [Sûrah al-Baqarah: 185]

  • @Warriorgaming012
    @Warriorgaming012 17 днів тому

    Question: am I allowed to draw a girl? Even if I remove at least one facial expression and it’s not 3d, is it allowed?

  • @xxsqf
    @xxsqf 19 днів тому

    So i giess reading or watching dragon ball is makruh

  • @swege9315
    @swege9315 20 днів тому

    The article from islam qa got me confused it says without nose or eyes does it mean i cant have any of it or i can only pick one?

  • @G.Bfit.93
    @G.Bfit.93 29 днів тому

    Is anime haram?

  • @ryannatuor344
    @ryannatuor344 Місяць тому

    Never seen worse arguments for contradictions and mistakes in the Qur'an than the ones in this video

  • @turboturbo780
    @turboturbo780 Місяць тому

    Can you answer this someone here I dont get it is drawing living images like shirk but how when its 2 different Sins and second question is dont those who does shirk to Allah get most severely punished tormented and dont every muslim who passed away go jannah at the end even those WHO draw living images ?? Jazakallah

  • @muhammadadam220
    @muhammadadam220 Місяць тому

    Are national anthem haram?

  • @AhmedBinOmer-YT
    @AhmedBinOmer-YT Місяць тому

    The permissibility of music and musical instruments in Islam is a nuanced topic with a range of scholarly opinions and interpretations. Scholars throughout Islamic history have explored this subject extensively, and respected views exist on both sides of the discussion. 1. The Hadith in Video: The hadith often cited by those who view music as impermissible is found in Sahih Al-Bukhari #5590. However, this hadith is classified as "mu'allaq" (attached without a complete chain of narration), meaning it doesn't meet the rigorous standards that Imam al-Bukhari applied to the core hadiths in his collection. Scholars such as Imam al-Muhallab have indicated that Bukhari himself might have exercised caution regarding its authenticity. Moreover, narrators like Hisham bin Ammar have faced scrutiny from scholars like Imam al-Thahabi due to concerns about reliability, as Hisham was reportedly inconsistent in his narration. 2. Practices of the Companions: Historical records show that some Companions, such as Abdullah bin al-Zubair, allowed certain forms of music and instrumental accompaniment. Ibrahim bin Sa’d, for instance, is reported to have listened to music with instruments like the lute. While these examples are known, they remain subjects of debate regarding context and broader interpretation. 3. Scholarly Opinions: Numerous prominent scholars, including Imam al-Ghazali, Imam al-Shawkani, and Sultan al-Ulema al-Izz ibn Abdul-Salam, have argued that music, when morally upright, is permissible. Their writings emphasize that music itself is not inherently forbidden but can vary in judgment depending on the intentions behind it, the context, and the content. 4. Biblical Precedents: Some scholars highlight references to music in religious worship in the Bible, especially in connection with Prophet Dawud (David), as a sign of its potentially positive nature. This perspective suggests that morally uplifting music, which avoids forbidden messages, can be permissible. In the end, if someone chooses to follow a perspective that deems music haram or halal, it is their choice, based on their understanding and the guidance of trusted scholars. What unites Muslims beyond these differences is the understanding that the Quran remains the best guidance in all matters. It serves as the ultimate source, offering wisdom and clarity to navigate such topics with respect and balance.

  • @ad1bnwr07
    @ad1bnwr07 Місяць тому

    Can you make a video on jewelery wearing for men, like chains, rings, bracelets etc; the ruling, the permitted and haram, hadiths, quran and everything please?

  • @xxsqf
    @xxsqf Місяць тому

    Salam so for digital art drawing the facte and body is hala amoung soem scholers? Also in order to make a picture halal do u just cover 1 or both etes correct?

  • @neverexisted4452
    @neverexisted4452 Місяць тому

    Brother if you would make a video about the ruling of doing martial arts and are these prohibited in islam, then it would have been a big help for brothers like who are wanting to learn them but are not sure if they should do it or not ❤

  • @yepyen
    @yepyen Місяць тому

    Halal, next question. (Except songs with bad language)

  • @Saleem__786
    @Saleem__786 Місяць тому

    How about sculpting 3D models of characters on software like Blender?

  • @Outabi
    @Outabi Місяць тому

    Is drawing still haram even if its not shirk? I draw things for fun and from series i like i dont worship them. Iv been drawing since i was young and i kept a good amount of my old sketchbooks. I also have 1 anime poster and 2 figures. My parents got it for me but it feels bad to throw it away.

  • @aliabdelkader8554
    @aliabdelkader8554 Місяць тому

    who was the reciter in the middle of the video?

  • @otabek_jumaboyev
    @otabek_jumaboyev Місяць тому

    Working with 3d softwares and creating models and animating them is also haram then?

  • @ImaadtheAbdullah
    @ImaadtheAbdullah Місяць тому

    New Question, is making congregational dua after every fardh prayer an innovation?

  • @Baseduzxi
    @Baseduzxi Місяць тому

    Halal

  • @ibbyz7aep
    @ibbyz7aep Місяць тому

    if you make a human drawing but it isn’t realistic would it still be haram?

  • @Dawet-t1y
    @Dawet-t1y Місяць тому

    yay, now i have excuse to not studying music in my school and i never really intrested in music (Unfortunately, this is a mandatory subject at my school)

  • @dahoukmasarani
    @dahoukmasarani Місяць тому

    one question that has been on my mind is that what if I implement an image that I didn't make? I knew drawing was haram but since I didn't draw the image myself I still used it in a game of mine, after doing further research I couldn't find a geniune answer but I am still very worried, can anyone answer me regarding this?

  • @Iatesocksanditswasyummy
    @Iatesocksanditswasyummy Місяць тому

    so can i draw like already made cartoons like teen titian go and anime drawings with with just eyes and mouth and nose but no ears please answer me im curious bc i dont wanna sin by drawin and not knowing

  • @Gabriel_Arts
    @Gabriel_Arts Місяць тому

    THANK YOU SO MUCH! I've been looking for this kind of information forever and you just saved me for having to break my back searching for a simple answer! New sub!

  • @muhammadsuleman7846
    @muhammadsuleman7846 Місяць тому

    So what about anime

  • @yungyeshyyy3782
    @yungyeshyyy3782 Місяць тому

    What about animal drawings in a cartoonish style?

  • @RaanuAli47
    @RaanuAli47 Місяць тому

    IG toilet plumbing systems are haram cause theyre imating the human digestive system 😂

  • @zeero9901
    @zeero9901 Місяць тому

    Can you please make a video on AI art ? Like I am an AI artist and I make thumbnails for different youtubers but again for them I have to generate different Faces/cartoons/manniques I don't actually know if this is haram or halal ?

  • @mujahidhasan118
    @mujahidhasan118 Місяць тому

    ahh The Halal Haram Game 🤣

  • @luqmam
    @luqmam Місяць тому

    What if we just put sun glasses on characters is that halal