A Tragedy
A Tragedy
  • 25
  • 1 871 252
Messmer Caused The Shattering - Elden Ring Lore Theory
I had to get this out before Shadow of the Erdtree releases. I need to be wrong on time lol
Crunchy's Videos
ua-cam.com/video/DUWvaScZSnk/v-deo.html
ua-cam.com/video/mp9bEZAnRS0/v-deo.html
Zayf The Scholar Video
ua-cam.com/video/Wmjo72GiLRk/v-deo.html
Переглядів: 25 747

Відео

When You Meet Karlach in Baldur's Gate 3
Переглядів 3 тис.2 місяці тому
The decisions we're forced to make.
Shadow of the Erdtree: A Convoluted Lore Perspective
Переглядів 1,5 тис.4 місяці тому
First lore video and the gameplay is the first time I've played Elden Ring in like a year so don't you dare judge. Don't you dare. Also, I pulled an all nighter editing this and I don't remember what I said I would link so these are all guesses. Let's all hope I remember to check these at some point Philosopher's Stone Wikipedia en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Philosopher's_stone Quelaag video with the M...
Baldur's Gate 3 When You Meet Your Guardian
Переглядів 22 тис.7 місяців тому
It was the set up of the century.
Saving The Grove In Baldur's Gate 3
Переглядів 42 тис.10 місяців тому
Karlach will not be pleased. Like, comment, and subscribe if you like these and want more Support me on Patreon at www.patreon.com/aTragedi
Saving Mayrina In Baldur's Gate 3
Переглядів 74 тис.11 місяців тому
Or I guess you can "do the right thing and snap the wand". Whatever. Like, comment, and subscribe if you enjoyed and want more! Support me on Patreon at www.patreon.com/aTragedi
Baldur's Gate 3 But You're A Drow
Переглядів 1,2 млн11 місяців тому
It's an "absolute"ly fantastic experience. I'll see myself out. Like, comment, and subscribe if you enjoyed and want more! Support me on Patreon at www.patreon.com/aTragedi
Leveling Up In Elden Ring
Переглядів 4,4 тис.Рік тому
I went back and acquired vengeance with a quickness. Support me on Patreon at www.patreon.com/aTragedi
The Guys Who Guard the Stormveil Gates 2 | Elden Ring
Переглядів 7 тис.Рік тому
Support me on Patreon at www.patreon.com/aTragedi
Farming In Elden Ring Be Like
Переглядів 3,4 тис.Рік тому
Farming In Elden Ring Be Like
When The Elden Ring DLC Drops
Переглядів 16 тис.Рік тому
Me from the future: GOT THE ENTRANCE RIGHT!!!
When You Learn How To Block 6 Hours In
Переглядів 1,1 тис.Рік тому
When You Learn How To Block 6 Hours In
Sir Gideon Ofnir KNEW Better | Elden Ring
Переглядів 7 тис.Рік тому
Sir Gideon Ofnir KNEW Better | Elden Ring
Let Me Solo Her | Elden Ring
Переглядів 6 тис.Рік тому
Let Me Solo Her | Elden Ring
The Most Treacherous Conversation EVER | Elden Ring
Переглядів 9 тис.Рік тому
The Most Treacherous Conversation EVER | Elden Ring
The Guys Who Guard the Stormveil Gates | Elden Ring
Переглядів 113 тис.2 роки тому
The Guys Who Guard the Stormveil Gates | Elden Ring
Ranni Needs To Explain | Elden Ring
Переглядів 23 тис.2 роки тому
Ranni Needs To Explain | Elden Ring
How Alexander ACTUALLY Gets Stronger | Elden Ring
Переглядів 14 тис.2 роки тому
How Alexander ACTUALLY Gets Stronger | Elden Ring
How the Night of the Black Knives REALLY Happened | Elden Ring
Переглядів 206 тис.2 роки тому
How the Night of the Black Knives REALLY Happened | Elden Ring
When The Albinaurics Haven't Given Enough | Elden Ring
Переглядів 12 тис.2 роки тому
When The Albinaurics Haven't Given Enough | Elden Ring
When You Don't Want the Dung Eater Ending | Elden Ring
Переглядів 57 тис.2 роки тому
When You Don't Want the Dung Eater Ending | Elden Ring

КОМЕНТАРІ

  • @grendelbacani445
    @grendelbacani445 3 дні тому

    "you're on thin ice buddy" godwyn maybe

  • @nicolefrench8178
    @nicolefrench8178 4 дні тому

    I was a drow and a Druid so I was able to get the best of both worlds 😂

  • @cyrusol
    @cyrusol 4 дні тому

    The Gloam-Eyed Queen may also just be a title that may be inherited from one person to another. Or perhaps a spirit that may jump host bodies. I still believe Melina "is" the GEQ, or rather that she had been the GEQ back when she was actually alive. And the seal/sign across her eye, empowered by the Golden Order/Elden Ring, suppressed the GEQ "spirit"/side in her so that her actual human self can be in control. The player as the Lord of the Frenzied Flame destroys the power of the Elden Ring, thus the power of the seal, thus the GEQ side/spirit/personality whatever is unleashed again.

  • @panchodemiga8484
    @panchodemiga8484 8 днів тому

    this is like a fragment of a Smiling Friend episode

  • @typicalsmile2747
    @typicalsmile2747 9 днів тому

    Lmao Gale is too on point

  • @thebiggerboat3236
    @thebiggerboat3236 9 днів тому

    "The Emperor" feels like SUCH a re-write and is such a hard left turn. Its very obvious that the writers originally had something else in mind for your "ideal lover", but midway through said 'fuck it' and made them some lame mind flayer. Honestly, the Kafka/Lovecraft themes that were originally envisioned for a plot such as being slowly turned into an eldritch creature in both mind and body feels entirely lost here.

  • @thebiggerboat3236
    @thebiggerboat3236 9 днів тому

    Always felt like Drow got a worse treatment by people than even the Tieflings. Y'know, the literal devil-spawn with horns, sharp monster teeth and scary glowing eyes. I feel like if any one race should scare people, its the devil-people.

  • @alswisha8519
    @alswisha8519 11 днів тому

    treating me like the plague

  • @Vinno1234
    @Vinno1234 15 днів тому

    yo in retrospect with the DLC this hits different now lmao

  • @rimimaru121
    @rimimaru121 16 днів тому

    I got a Nat 1 when speaking to the Fists in Act 1, so I ended up having to slay them all

    • @aTragedi
      @aTragedi 15 днів тому

      Yeah I'm sure you HAD to do it. Classic drow behavior

  • @Tatominator
    @Tatominator 17 днів тому

    I think you were a little too literal with the narrative placements but otherwise good insights

  • @dwaynejones3900
    @dwaynejones3900 18 днів тому

    NOOOO! NOOOO! NOOOO! That’s what I said😂

  • @mariuszmoraw3571
    @mariuszmoraw3571 18 днів тому

    You think tieflings are spawn of Hell? Nah. Drows trump them.

  • @VoidTower_
    @VoidTower_ 19 днів тому

    I just wish Melina got to speak with Messmer in the DLC.

  • @Farfigschiter.
    @Farfigschiter. 20 днів тому

    Everyone in act 1 is like, "OH SHIT ITS A DROW, SAVE ME LAWD." Then past that point no one really gives a shit

  • @HellishSpoon
    @HellishSpoon 21 день тому

    If you play as a drow remember to wear a ID card that says "Not evil"

  • @cuttlefish1801
    @cuttlefish1801 22 дні тому

    my fave bg3 character is morally questionable mspaint drow

  • @lordcaedus8713
    @lordcaedus8713 22 дні тому

    Being a drow is badass, until you realize “oh shit, I’m a drow…”

  • @ToiletWolf12
    @ToiletWolf12 24 дні тому

    bg3 was my first experience with dnd. I picked a drow cause i always have one character i try to make when I play games, who just so happens to have a drow like skin tone. Was not prepared for the incredibly casual racism.

  • @douglashenrique188
    @douglashenrique188 24 дні тому

    the audio is really low

    • @aTragedi
      @aTragedi 24 дні тому

      Thanks, I’ll be increasing the volume for the next one

  • @kraanz
    @kraanz 24 дні тому

    I'm playing a Drow male, and I don't see any of this as a problem. They key is not giving a crap. "OMG, YOU'RE DROW! AAAa..." Yeah, whatever, shut up. I'm gonna need you to empty your pockets. Are your ears ingredients in some sort of a potion? No? You sure? Yeah, I'm still gonna take them, sorry, ssshshshssshshs, don't scream, there's no point, all your neighbors are dead already. Hm? Lolth? What's a... hehehehe, what the hell is a lolth? Same as lmao-th? Or rofl-th? You're so silly. Stop squirming, you're gonna ruin this ear.

  • @Overused_Toothbrush
    @Overused_Toothbrush 25 днів тому

    The robe with amethyst dye is fire. Looked great on my drow.

  • @antoninodarioconti6347
    @antoninodarioconti6347 25 днів тому

    Knowing a bit of GRRM, and his relations with religions, I doubt he wanted to build the story of norse mythology. Really, not the case. I think he showed how the concept of society and religions went togheter trough history: -The creation of life itself, the Crucible, venerated by the Hornsents. The focus is the spiral that imho represent the very first cornerstone of life. DNA. The veneration of life itself. Can be found in very ancient religions. -Age of stones, represented by the skin of ancient dragons, and the passage between nomadic life to civilization. A step that shaked the way of living itself (Having gained intelligence, the beasts must have felt how their wildness slipped away as civilization took hold.-Bestial vitality). They venerated the storms, lighting etc. exactly as ancient civilizations. Think about the Greeks, venerating Zeus lord of the thunder. -Age of the forge/fire: Another God, the Fell god, introduced another element of evolution, the smithing ability. His religion represent those ancient believes of sacrifing lives/parts of the body (The fire giant offering his leg to acquire power, and, something often misunderstood, Melina had to sacrifice herself because that is how the forge of the fell God works: SACRIFICE). Something close to religions like the one of the Aztecs. -Age of silver: Civilization blooms, and people start to do high-level scientific things, like alchemy. The Noxs wanted to create a god. This represent the rationalization of a God. They fail because they understood the methods, but didn't had the final ingredient: Faith. True faith. Something that alchemy or research cannot explain. -Age of Gold: Marika's one. A religion of assimilation. It takes elements of other religion and incorporates them in its own (Pots? Hornsents tradition. Fingers? Greater will. Erdtree? From the Greatree, tied with the crucible. Lighting golden dragons? They had their own religion before that. Leyndell? It was a noxian city, as we can get from the architecture). Reminds me of Islam. - Miquella: Literally Jesus in Christianity. Uses the power of love, wants to make the world in a gentler place, has his followers that believe in him blindly, literally stripped away his body to reach an higher state of spirituality, while we followed these parts to grow in power (Timeless truth I speak to you: Unless you eat the body of The Son of Man and drink his blood, you have no life in yourselves. John 6:53) and sacrificed himself, destiny included, for the world. Ah, he even "resurrected" someone. As if we did not have enough hints. -Ranni's ending: A lot like Buddhism, in a way. Those 4 arms aren't just for show. Also the theme that god shouldn't exist, is very tied to Buddhism, that doesn't truly believe in a God.

  • @silentknight9356
    @silentknight9356 25 днів тому

    Damn guess you were wrong; I’m still holding on to the theory that Godwyn is the first born and father of the other demigods, that’s why morgot is cursed that’s why Miquella is cursed instead of a self procreation it’s the product of incest that corrupted them, Godfrey only has one son Godwyn and Marika took him to make her other children and only when radagon left he was able to make other uncursed children, the theory that the curses are marinas fault is stupid because of this reason Radagon is marika and they have 3 kids that are not cursed when there is another partner and Godwyn is not cursed either and came from an Elden lord making him The Golden Son

  • @aTragedi
    @aTragedi 26 днів тому

    Ok, I keep getting the same comment and I’m a patriot and I’m not gonna take it!!!! I’m only kind of kidding lol. I speak in the American or “Amurrican” English dialect. I’ve also lived most of my life in the south, so I pronounce some words and names with a bit of a drawl in my accent. Marika is one such name. When it’s pronounced in game, it is not spoken in the American English dialect, but is instead spoken in various dialects from different parts of the UK. I shouldn’t have to spell it out more than that, but they pronounce vowels differently than they are pronounced in American English. But, that doesn’t make the use of the American English pronunciation of Marika “incorrect”. TLDR: I’m not gonna stop saying Marika that way and no one can make me. AMERICA!!!!!

    • @alanrockwell8160
      @alanrockwell8160 26 днів тому

      🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸

    • @bladej7688
      @bladej7688 22 дні тому

      Is McDonald's pronounced "Mc-Donald's" or "MacDonald's" 😂 Don't change! Everyone understands who you are talking about.

  • @InnerAtanih
    @InnerAtanih 26 днів тому

    Why does everyone insist on mispronouncing names that are clearly said lol

  • @antigrav6004
    @antigrav6004 27 днів тому

    I love your connection to revelation.

  • @Luis519RS
    @Luis519RS 27 днів тому

    Oh no they killed Baldur the golden, I mean Godwyn... Oh no... he didnt see it coming. Killed by a thing banished from the world, a thing that cant kill you so you forget about it. The only thing that could destined him to death. Killed by someone that only follow Marika. If only someone could be Marika... oh no Radagon... What did you do. I swear Radagon could fit he culprit to Godwyns murder. And who is the murder a benefit for. Oddly, his daughter.

  • @ivanayala2715
    @ivanayala2715 28 днів тому

    Saw this after the dlc, a bit far off but the spirit is there, maybe will happen on the innevitable elden ring 2 or Ds2 3

  • @blackfistxu7953
    @blackfistxu7953 28 днів тому

    “You gonna stay at the camp anyways.” 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

  • @blackfistxu7953
    @blackfistxu7953 28 днів тому

    These videos are excellent!

  • @colin8696908
    @colin8696908 28 днів тому

    Drow race sucks to, no good buffs in general.

    • @cuttlefish1801
      @cuttlefish1801 22 дні тому

      nah drow get darkness as a racial passive. crazy good for any obscured crit build, great for melee against anyone except other drow, strong cc otherwise. faerie fire at level 3 is overrated imo but the drow racial passives are some of the best in the game, except maybe the dragonborn ones and the duergar (prob consensus best)

  • @p4r4d0x2
    @p4r4d0x2 28 днів тому

    it's all fun and games until a drow starts whipping out the "hellspawn" and "half-breed"

  • @damienferguson8151
    @damienferguson8151 29 днів тому

    So I’ve beaten the dlc but I just wanna say the physics flask states she made them for messmer then stops after she’s abandons him and then ig seemly decides to scatter the pieces of this she made for her first born to every minor Erdtree which I don’t think she’d done

  • @pumpa244
    @pumpa244 29 днів тому

    i think when she say thou art yet to become me , to become a god , shes reffering to a defiance of radagon. He went and did something on his own , something she didnt want in an atempt to best her and he failed. (at least thats what she thought when she spoke those words) like "nice try radagon but you are not yet me a god so you cant best me. As even tho hes part of marika , he also has his own will

  • @nemesisundead83
    @nemesisundead83 Місяць тому

    I'm truly beginning to think Marika is fake or died a long time ago and was revived by Radagon to become the new god of the coming age

  • @VQM6
    @VQM6 Місяць тому

    is miquella blind like malenia?

    • @aTragedi
      @aTragedi Місяць тому

      Still inconclusive *SPOILERS* In his boss fight, both of his eyes are closed, however that could also be because he’s maneuvering his body with his spirit, as you can see his spirit hands as well

  • @kimjongwin
    @kimjongwin Місяць тому

    The story feels way too incomplete. We need more dlc.

  • @labeilleautiste6318
    @labeilleautiste6318 Місяць тому

    Interesting lore video i did not made these relation of Messmer with these rune of death, melina and Radagon stuff 😮

  • @certifiedcib7958
    @certifiedcib7958 Місяць тому

    Who’s “Maurka”?

  • @AndrewStonerock
    @AndrewStonerock Місяць тому

    I dont know man. I think you have a lot of good points, but i think you missed a few as well. Marika plucked the rune of death from the Elden Ring in order to stop the gloam eyed queen. Thats spelled out pretty clear. Maliketh defeats the gloam eyed queen, yes also true. The gloam eyed queen uses black flame, which is powered by destined death, which is the rune of death. Marika plucked the rune of death and gave it to Maliketh in order to rob the Gloam eyed queen of her power, thus allowing Maliketh to kill the Gloam eyed queen. That is spelled out pretty clearly in game. My theory is that Melina was the Gloam eyed queen. She is cannonically a daughter of Marika, she could have been an Empyrean when she had a body. When we meet her, she states "i am burned and bodyless". She is a spirit or soul when we meet her. We know spirits can come back to life in the Elden ring universe. The souls are "hewn into the erd tree" Maliketh kills Melina as she is the Gloam eyed queen. Her soul is sent to the erd tree, and Marika gives her new life at the foot of the erd tree. Where she finds new purpose as the kindling maiden. I do feel like maybe our tarnished is somehow related to a demigod. The start of the game has Melina discussing with torrent that we are special. We also seem to get kore help than any other tarnished. Hell, the only ither tarnished to even touch a great rune is Vike, and he was nailing Lanseax the dragon on a regular basis. So, when the Lord of Frenzy Flame burns the Erd tree to dust and jills the spiritual form of the Erd tree, Melina's memorys of being the gloam eyed queen are unlocked. Hell, maybe even when we release the rune of death. She does seem to be a fan of death after all.

    • @jubei7259
      @jubei7259 Місяць тому

      Data miners found evidence to support this theory - that we are in fact an illegitimate child of Marika, which is why we can hear the sound of a mausoleum when we awake at the beginning of the game. Only demigods are resurrected at the mausoleums, which would also help explain why we are capable of killing gods & demigods. This would make sense as to why we are doing Marika's bidding the whole time too.

  • @doms6561
    @doms6561 Місяць тому

    O

  • @foggyshades8338
    @foggyshades8338 Місяць тому

    Watching this video, I was also thinking. Along the DLC, through the Miquella's crosses, we see quotes from MIquella, like, "I abandon here my so and so part of my body/soul", and near those crosses you can also pick up little flowers (Empyrean-Blood Burgeon item), and when you find St.Trina she's also a plant.

  • @Orthanderis
    @Orthanderis Місяць тому

    Honestly, with the lore drop of Miquella abandoning aspects of himself like St. Trina, which are still independent living entities, I 100% believe Melina is an aspect of Marika, and is specifically the Gloam Eyed Queen that was fully unsealed by the defeat of Maliketh and freeing the rune of Death. It all makes too much sense

  • @GilbertVonArphostein
    @GilbertVonArphostein Місяць тому

    I mean, he was found half naked and surrounded by freaky tall women, so...

  • @alessandroguglielmo719
    @alessandroguglielmo719 Місяць тому

    Ma io vi chiedo in relazione alla demente di pro vita: Nel 2024 come si fa ancora a credere all uomo invisibile nel cielo?

  • @hectorlopez9453
    @hectorlopez9453 Місяць тому

    Damn bruh u butchering marika's name

  • @cjh.1920
    @cjh.1920 Місяць тому

    Tbh now that the DLC dropped, there’s a couple things here and there the DLC smacked down but I think you’re on the money with a big chunk of that.

  • @cjh.1920
    @cjh.1920 Місяць тому

    Messmer has probably dethroned Miquella as my favorite Elden Ring character.

    • @mustache0903
      @mustache0903 Місяць тому

      Miquellas turned into my least favorite lol

    • @glorytoukraine5524
      @glorytoukraine5524 12 днів тому

      Miquella didn't help his own reputation either

  • @diesel_tech_three4332
    @diesel_tech_three4332 Місяць тому

    Dude, this is solid gold! I think that you are correct with Radagon being the puppet master behind the scenes. I believe that the seduction was him, using marika's body, convincing the hornsent to use the flesh of the shamans to forge the Gate of Divinity and then the betrayal was him sending messmer to slaughter them all.

    • @aTragedi
      @aTragedi Місяць тому

      Ah, that gate of divinity theory is very interesting