Відео

Thanks for the comment! I agree with that. I do like 10% of Disney Star Wars through

Thanks so much

For sure! Scott

Thanks for the comment! I love that storyline!

Thank you for your comment. This is a great idea especially since Looney Tunes is releasing another 2-D animated movie. It could be the perfect time for it plus the only name that you really need in would be Anthony Daniels.

Hey thanks for your comment! I like your stuff! Yeah it is over done but if they make it like marvel and dc it could work

@@fineadditions Exactly.

Thank you for your comment! Aside from visions and the Lego stuff

Thank you for your comment. I agree with that. I do think that the post return of the Jedi adaptations would be perfect for that

@@fineadditions Are you referring to the Thrawn trilogy? If so I totally agree! I bet they could even use Mark Hamill as C'Baoth. We've already seen how talented he is at playing insane characters with The Joker (Though to be fair C'Baoth's insanity is a lot different to Joker's chaotic insanity).

@@nilbogoblin6207Yes! Mark can play every one

Thank you for your comment. That is true. I mainly talked about Marvel because Marvel Studios is a sister company to Lucas film and that was the inspiration for this video. But yes a series of Star Wars legends films would be awesome.

Thanks for your comment! Did you put Swtor under Disney canon?

@@fineadditions Yes, I think so.

@@cyfreusz it is apart of the eu timeline

The Old Republic MMO was made prior to Disney and thus is Legends.

Thanks for your comment! Yeah I forgot that one and also that they forgot Asajj died in the books too lol and they didn’t care to explain.

Thanks for your comment! Yeah Aftermath was so rushed chuck bragged he wrote the first one in 40 days

@@fineadditions lol, it absolutely shows. it reads like a first draft where the author was just like, "this is fine"

Thanks for your comment! The good stuff from Disney is most likely stuff that fits in the eu

Thank you for your comment! But I’m gonna have to disagree with you. Could you give me a few examples of books and comics that you have read. I’ve read a good majority of legends. There were a few out-of-pocket things. Most of the times someone says that they’ve not read it and just heard someone else say it’s bad.

Have you even read any to begin with? Or are you just parroting Disney Shills and NPCs?

me and you both know you haven't read any of it.

@@fineadditions I wanted to like legends so bad I hear the opposite actually I hear everyone praise it but I just can’t get into it I hate how messy it is and the timeline for legends is all over the place and I know Disney has shitty stuff and have already retconned some of their material but I just like how much tidy and linear the Disney timeline is and in my opinion some stuff they did better like I prefer Disney thrawn compared to legends thrawn. But some stuff in legends are good like the old republic is way better than Disneys stupid high republic. I don’t wanna make a big comment but stuff like the Yuuzhan Vong i didn’t like and even the forced unleashed games which i love but starkiller being responsible for helping the birth of the rebellion was pretty dumb but im sure that just one of many legends version of the origin of the rebellion which is my point it was too messy but im also the one to hate the many different dimensions in both DC and marvel. Anyways thank you for being respectful I’m not too knowledgeable on legends so please correct me for anything I was wrong in I do apologize

@@claytonveno3710 i wouldn’t have commented if i didn’t or i would just plain out say Disney Star Wars is the best

Thank you for your comment. I think you make a good point except I will have to disagree with you on the inconsistencies and the expanded universe. To my knowledge, all of them have been recon and resolved to make it more cohesive.

​@@fineadditions i think the fan will gona start to build thier own canon. Just putt what story and characters you like.

@ I somewhat like that just as long as we get more legacy books

The Thing is the Expanded universe wasnt nearly AS inconsistent AS people Claim IT was ,they actually Put a good amount of effort into making IT consistent,rewrote earlier books to make it fit better. A Lot of the EU haters Bring Up random books that were clearly never Cannon to BE begin with and Cherrypick examples, the Star wars Universe was pretty consistent before filonis TCW Show compared to Other Franchises but TCW Bulldozered all over the Cannon and i think George Lucas didnt Care at that Point about Star wars anymore that much given how Just a few years later when TCW started IT was Sold to the devil aka Disney.

@@laisphinto6372 yeah that’s about right also TCW is just tall tales and propaganda know so yeah that makes was George’s idea

Failoni only cares about his OCs

Thank you for your comment. Dave has ego canon and doesn’t like to play with others kind of like how Timothy Zahn is lol

Thanks for the comment! I will have to disagree with you. It is pretty realistic to be able to have a cohesive story, especially if a lot of people are paid to have that job. That was the point of the 2014 story group. Also the writers and story group for the expanded universe continued to keep everything consistent. if there was a inconsistency which there were plenty, they would so it into the story and make it look good unlike the Disney canon.

@fineadditions You mean attempt to make the contradictions work. Like having the death star plans get stolen like ten different times, so they had to make some really stupid explanation about how they were all different pieces of the plans or something or other. Or how about Boba Fett having a doppelganger because they wrote him completely different before his backstory was revealed, so apparently it was actually a different bounty hunter cosplaying as Boba... for some reason. Or my favorite. The Clone Wars in the Thrawn books being not even close to what we eventually got in the prequels. I can't even remember if they tried to handwave that away. I'm kinda glad I don't. Oh yeah, didn't Shaak Ti also die like three separate times in Legends? Once at the Battle of Coruscant in the Clone Wars 2D cartoon, once at the Jedi temple during Order 66, and once by Starkiller on Felucia after she seemingly revived for a second time. Point is, I like Legends, but sitting here saying it was more cohesive than the Disney canon is just hilariously blinded by nostalgia for it.

@ I like your passion but all of the things you just said got fixed Boba Fett was undercover as Jaster for a mission who was named after his grandfather. The Nogri have a different calendar then the galactic calendar And she didn’t die in clone wars she died twice in revenge of the sith but those were deleted so not canon and TFU was her canon death. To my knowledge all the contradictions were fixed and the eu works together

@fineadditions Yeah but it's really dumb.

@@tristanskywalker1998 also there were several parts to the Death Star plans

Thank you for your comment! I do agree that there won’t be a good official canon anymore. I do think that they could continue the expanded universe and we could have a good alternative. I do also see a lot of people say that a lot of the EU is garbage. Would you care to elaborate? I’ve read a good chunk of the expanded universe. I would have to disagree the majority of people that make that comment have only heard the concepts out of context and haven’t even read the books and are just repeating what they hear people say. Because if it was that bad, we wouldn’t have had 37 years of it. I am working on a video about the things that people hate about the expanded universe, and I would love to hear your point of view.

37 years of work that kept the franchise alive. Garbage because you havent read shit.Sure.

​@fineadditions one thing I hate is the novel "dawn of the jedi: into the void". Honestly the worst star wars book i have read. I was so excited and left so disappointed. "Knight errant" was also disappointing until the last 3rd of the book

@@tedpogue6531 I can see want you mean, Dawn of the Jedi definitely works better if you read the comics first I don’t know if you’re into that but as a standalone, it is pretty shocking. Also KE I would have to say the same thing to read the comics first and I think they take place chronologically before it so it’s kind of strange that both of those books weren’t just comic books.

@@fineadditions thats fair. I hear the comics themselves are pretty cool. I've been meaning to get around to them but so many damn novels lol. The only comics I've read are the legacy comics and dark empire. (Also, them saying "bitch" in the dawn of the jedi novel threw me off so hard.)

Thanks for your comment! What ever lie that makes more money

I mean, apparently the Story Group did stop JJ from blowing up Coruscant, instead making the system destroyed in TFA the Hosnian system, which gives us our system of rotating capitals for the New Republic, so there's that. There's like, one other thing I can't remember, but was a thing they did.

Thank you for your comment! Kathleen Kennedy doesn’t know what she has. George Lucas told Disney that at the time Star Wars was worth more than marvel which I would agree with

Thanks for the comment! I’m glad you enjoy canon. From want I’ve seen the eu is not as messy as canon. But I do think the way you look at it is interesting!

Ew... Disney canon is the equivalent of a botched abortion😂

Star Wars is(Was) a singular cohesive saga,not a Multiverse. Unfortunetly Disney seems to disaggre.

@ it really was never cohesive

@@Lugiamasterbrony When the parts of the whole work or fit together well, it is cohesive.Thanks to efforts of the Holocron contunity database and work of many others,decades of fiction created independently fit together just the way they should

Thanks for the comment. I started diving deep into the eu in 2012 it was a time!

Thank you for your comment! I can see your pov, I look at Dave’s stuff like what he says it is tall tales some is true some is not

@@fineadditions People say that The Clone Wars is Lucas's project, but I disagree. I think George just gave Filoni his blessing and freedom to play around with Star Wars setting, threw a few ideas at him and then his involvement was quickly diminishing. Filoni in his turn abused that trust by essentially making The Clone Wars not about adding to George's story and expanding it, but by finding ways to retcon not only the EU (if he even acknowledged EU even a single time) , but even the movies to fit in his own characters and ideas. That it the problem to this day: he basically ignores anything that isn't TV series produced by him.

@ I see what you mean I think Lucas was involved but there were to many people that were scared to say there would be problems also Dave used Lucas as an excuse whenever people would criticize the concepts in his show

Treating TCW as in universe propaganda, or as secondary canon instead of T-canon for legends are honestly the best ways to keep it if you want material Filoni didn't have a hand in creating to also be canon.

@@1000g2g3g4g800999 Or you can do what comicbook authors did for years, take a multiverse approach. The original 6 movies exclusively is Universe 1, the original 6 + parts of EU is Universe 2, 3, 4 or 5 (depends on what exactly do you want to include), and TCW universe will include all Filoni TV shows and a hypothetical remakes of the original trilogy by FIloni.

Thank you for your comment! Yes it is

Agreed. I'll agree with anyone that Disney "ruined star wars" but I can't lie and say I hate all of Disney canon. There's a decent chunk of good stuff. They just slowly keep ruining stuff. But if I ignore the sequel era and half the shows it's not too bad 😂

Like Andor

​@@Сайтамен or the darth vadee marvel comics, they are pretty good

Thanks for your comments everyone! I wish they did both and it’s funny the stuff does does that is good could fit into legends with little effort

Disney Canon is the equivalent of a botched abortion 💯😂

Thank you for your comment. I do think that he doesn’t respect anything that is canon. But I do think this is the new rule moving forward because he is the chef creative officer

Karen Traviss deserved better.

More like it was made for George Lucas. He didn’t mind adding to the lore but didn’t want to be restricted when he wants to do something. Almost all of the the retcons of the EU in the show were confirmed to be decisions by George himself after all. I think Dave just carried on his philosophy into Disney's era because that's just how George did things.

Thanks for the comment. Thank you so much for the kind words. You can do it just find want gets you excited and write about it then talk about it

Thanks for the comment! I do that to for my head canon I like trying to fit R1 and Andor into the eu

By current canon Poe was born on Yavin 4 when the rebels were based there. He would still exist, but be different. My head canon has him train under Wedge.

@@joshuamueller3206 yeah I think the comic he is born in can fit into legends so that could work

Thank you for your comment! On the canon level list LEGO Star Wars 1-3 would be under non canon or S Canon and I think the Skywalker saga and force awakens are considered in continuity with the LEGO Star Wars TV shows at least the cut scene parts

@fineadditions thank you

Thanks for your comment! They can fit it but they need a Kevin Feige and I don’t think Dave is their guy