ollysworkshop
ollysworkshop
  • 158
  • 252 208
Preparing for a solid toolpost
Check out Hersch Tool:
www.youtube.com/@hersch_tool
Переглядів: 1 181

Відео

Installing a Lathe DRO
Переглядів 8623 місяці тому
How I installed a DRO to my Lathe. This DRO kit came from Aliexpress: www.aliexpress.com/item/1005002559006799.html I got the 3 axis 1um scale set for approx £230, plus £70 for the slim 1um scale (additional item). My only complaint would be that the small scale I got for the cross slide appears to have significant non-linear error. This is apparently common in that the ones that don't meet spe...
An alternative saddle DRO scale fitting?
Переглядів 6274 місяці тому
I attempt to make a draw wire linear encoder to get round some of the shortcomings of mounting the cross slide DRO scale in the usual places.
ER32 Lathe Collet Chuck Feedback
Переглядів 3964 місяці тому
I address some of the comments from the video I made on the prototype ER32 lever collet chuck Original video ua-cam.com/video/NUMWaofXYno/v-deo.html Files are available on printables here... www.printables.com/model/898709-er32-lever-collet-chuck Viewer feedback video ua-cam.com/video/DtSMJNj1zpA/v-deo.html
Tractor Transmission Problems!
Переглядів 3436 місяців тому
Any resembelance to persons living or dead is entirely intentional! - I'm a big fan of @CuttingEdgeEngineering - this repair just felt like it needed the CEE teatment!
Lever Action ER Collet Chuck - Prototype
Переглядів 1,7 тис.6 місяців тому
There's lots of lever action collet chucks out there, but no-one does one for ER collets, why?
Mounting a faceplate to my lathe (Part 1)
Переглядів 2 тис.7 місяців тому
This is the faceplate that I got off eBay some months ago, I have a go at cutting the thread with my toolpost spindle.
Just Machining - A simple casting
Переглядів 9199 місяців тому
I thought I'd try a video of just machining, and no rambling on...
Advent 23 - Day 24 - Wrap Up
Переглядів 34410 місяців тому
Thanks everybody, the advent caledar went really well this year. I go over a few of the comments, and have a look at what's likely to be happening next year Merry Christmas etc.
Advent 23 - Day 23 - Jon's Workshop
Переглядів 31510 місяців тому
Our final contribution for this calendar.... ua-cam.com/video/kQMjug9PQNY/v-deo.htmlsi=gzwHm_NA7tjKpeoQ
Advent 23 - Day 22 - Lights
Переглядів 31110 місяців тому
I revamp my garden lights
I make some 3D printed Lathe 'soft jaws' [A23-21]
Переглядів 39110 місяців тому
I printed these with PET-CF on my Bambu Labs X1 printer
My first part on my grbl CNC lathe [A23-20]
Переглядів 49810 місяців тому
I make a knob for my manual lathe on the new CNC lathe
Advent 23 - Day 19 - The Recreational Machinist
Переглядів 33510 місяців тому
A contribution from Matt at The Recreational Machinist... ua-cam.com/video/YnkY8-RdjvM/v-deo.html
Advent 23 - Day 18 - On yer bike...
Переглядів 31010 місяців тому
Advent 23 - Day 18 - On yer bike...
Advent 23 - Day 17 - DIY or Buy?
Переглядів 35710 місяців тому
Advent 23 - Day 17 - DIY or Buy?
Advent 23 - Day 16 - Screw it!
Переглядів 30610 місяців тому
Advent 23 - Day 16 - Screw it!
Advent 23 - Day 15 - Carbide Inserts
Переглядів 33610 місяців тому
Advent 23 - Day 15 - Carbide Inserts
Advent 23 - Day 14 - Metric
Переглядів 37510 місяців тому
Advent 23 - Day 14 - Metric
Advent 23 - Day 13 - The Knacklers Workshop
Переглядів 39610 місяців тому
Advent 23 - Day 13 - The Knacklers Workshop
Advent 23 - Day 12 - HSS
Переглядів 34910 місяців тому
Advent 23 - Day 12 - HSS
Spindle lock for my Milling machine AMA25 VM25 WM16 WM18 [A23_11]
Переглядів 43910 місяців тому
Spindle lock for my Milling machine AMA25 VM25 WM16 WM18 [A23_11]
Advent 23 - Day 10 - STOP
Переглядів 29510 місяців тому
Advent 23 - Day 10 - STOP
Advent 23 - Day 9 - Carbon Fibre Filament
Переглядів 29310 місяців тому
Advent 23 - Day 9 - Carbon Fibre Filament
3D Printed tailstock caddy [A23_8]
Переглядів 33910 місяців тому
3D Printed tailstock caddy [A23_8]
Advent 23 - Day 7 - Rustinox Xmas Message!
Переглядів 35010 місяців тому
Advent 23 - Day 7 - Rustinox Xmas Message!
Advent 23 - Day 6 - Sheet Metal
Переглядів 38210 місяців тому
Advent 23 - Day 6 - Sheet Metal
Using a GRBL controller for a CNC Lathe [A23_5]
Переглядів 89710 місяців тому
Using a GRBL controller for a CNC Lathe [A23_5]
3D Printed Carbide Insert Box Storage [A23_4]
Переглядів 41810 місяців тому
3D Printed Carbide Insert Box Storage [A23_4]
Advent 23 - Day 3 - Mr Factotum
Переглядів 44210 місяців тому
Advent 23 - Day 3 - Mr Factotum

КОМЕНТАРІ

  • @jonathanalmeida9788
    @jonathanalmeida9788 6 днів тому

    Doesn’t work for free fusion 360. So don’t waste your time if you are working a free version.

    • @ollysworkshop
      @ollysworkshop 6 днів тому

      I am using the free version, although it was a while ago so I will check if it still works.

  • @RustyInventions-wz6ir
    @RustyInventions-wz6ir 13 днів тому

    Very interesting. Nice video. Thanks

  • @thekomaenetja6852
    @thekomaenetja6852 15 днів тому

    where is the g-code you lier

    • @ollysworkshop
      @ollysworkshop 15 днів тому

      The gcode is generated by fusion, it's specific to the machine it's generated for, so there's little value in actually showing the raw gcode. This video was a response to comments on: ua-cam.com/video/Yraw1lli3EU/v-deo.htmlsi=_tevI1EkEjFzT1QS and was answering the question of how the tool paths are created that are used to generate the gcode. I did another video about creating machine profiles in fusion here: ua-cam.com/video/Yjken5DIyY4/v-deo.html

  • @robert574
    @robert574 19 днів тому

    If you want a little tighter fit, lubricate the reamer and run it into the hole and stop the spindle. Then draw it out. Treat the reaming operation the same as taking the final passes on a lathe. I always take two drilling operations, one to get it within 1/32 or 1mm, then a final drill to get the hole within a few thousandths and finish off with the light pass of the reamer (if you really care about the reamed hole). Of course it varies a little with the final hole size, but that's the idea.

  • @chrishouse6924
    @chrishouse6924 Місяць тому

    Thankyou for your time, nicely presented and informative. New to this hobby engineering, so of the dro fitted is it a magnetic or glass type?

    • @ollysworkshop
      @ollysworkshop Місяць тому

      Hi, it's a glass scale. The magnetic ones are smaller, but more expensive. Thanks for your comment! 👍

  • @nomadmika
    @nomadmika Місяць тому

    Thank you so much for sharing this videos on CNC lathe. May I please ask what software do you use to send the G-code? From your other videos It's clear how to create the toolpath in Fusion but how to send it to grbl controller board?

    • @ollysworkshop
      @ollysworkshop Місяць тому

      Hi, I use UGS as the gcode sender. I have also used candle, but UGS is less buggy. I think there's a few others, but I haven't used anything else. Hope this helps. Thanks for your comment! 👍

    • @nomadmika
      @nomadmika Місяць тому

      @@ollysworkshop Thank you so much it does help. I am using UGC for my CNC mill but wasn't sure about how to use it on a lathe.

    • @ollysworkshop
      @ollysworkshop Місяць тому

      @@nomadmika it is basically the same, just with 2 axes instead of 3. Working out the various offsets still gives me a headache. There's probably a good way to do it, but I haven't found it yet. The visualiser in UGS isn't designed for a lathe (unless there's a mode I haven't found). I have to trust what I see in the fusion simulation, then run the gcode. It doesn't always (read that as 'ever') work first time!

  • @MarcWh
    @MarcWh Місяць тому

    Hope you don’t mind me asking but why is your SX3 mill in bits? I watched your comparison video a while back when it was fully assembled. Asking because I have a Warco lathe that is basically the same as your Amadeal one and was thinking of getting an SX3 as well.

    • @ollysworkshop
      @ollysworkshop Місяць тому

      Hi. Good question. The SX3 you see in bits is not the same one that you saw in the comparison video. When I bought the CNC lathe, I also got a pile of bits for a CNC mill. The one in bits is the CNC mill. There was also enough bits for another complete manual SX3 (the one you saw previously). I'm actually looking to sell it (the manual one), just not got round to doing anything. I've run out of space!

  • @lord-rufusighodaro4165
    @lord-rufusighodaro4165 Місяць тому

    Hi Olly, this is great. The post processing which was a problem for me as a starter has now been resolved. Thanks a million!

  • @wmcrash
    @wmcrash Місяць тому

    Howdy! I have a literally identical concept of a CNC lathe (mine's built on a Jet 1220 wood lathe with hiwin type rails, but the electronics are the same and I also use Fusion) and I am having a bit of an issue. GRBL does not store tool length offsets. So as you go from one tool to another, you're expected to zero the tool as you go. If you have a part that needs several tools for example (right hand, left hand, parting, boring) you're sorta stuck. I am faking tool length offsets by assigning different WCS for each tool. I can use 6 WCS in GRBL, so I am limited to 6 tools. Do you have a plan that would allow the use of more tools with pre measured offsets? Thanks in advance!

    • @ollysworkshop
      @ollysworkshop Місяць тому

      Hi, the lack of GRBL tool offsets is a known limitation, and I've yet to do anything about it. I think the way you are doing it with WCS is the only way without doing anything clever. If you can write code, then it should be possible to run a script on your gcode to pick up the different tool numbers and directly apply the appropriate offsets to the x-z coordinates in the gcode. The other option, that I have been considering, is buying a mach3/4 compatible controller!

  • @davidberlanny3308
    @davidberlanny3308 Місяць тому

    Hi Olly, Interesting to see the "precisión" of the compound slide as delivered. You will have made a great improvement. Well explained and presented video, well done. Top marks for cleaning up afterwards!! All the best!!

    • @ollysworkshop
      @ollysworkshop Місяць тому

      Thanks David. It's when you look closely at these Chinese tools that you see all the little things that could have easily been done, but haven't. I hope my efforts make up for the lack of effort by the manufacturer!

  • @TheRecreationalMachinist
    @TheRecreationalMachinist Місяць тому

    Following with interest 👍 I usually succeed in spite of my compound, rather than because of it. Making it de-installable so it can be fitted only when required is on the to-do list...

    • @ollysworkshop
      @ollysworkshop Місяць тому

      Thanks Matt. Hopefully will be making some progress on the actual solid riser tonight 🤞

  • @GardenTractorBoy
    @GardenTractorBoy Місяць тому

    That looks like a great improvement and it was fun to watch how you did this

    • @ollysworkshop
      @ollysworkshop Місяць тому

      Thanks. I'm looking forward to seeing how much difference a solid tool post makes.

  • @GardenTractorBoy
    @GardenTractorBoy Місяць тому

    Great job, I really like your installation. You have encouraged us to think of installing a DRO on our lathe and gave us some good ideas, thanks

    • @ollysworkshop
      @ollysworkshop Місяць тому

      Thanks. Glad to have been of some help.

  • @GardenTractorBoy
    @GardenTractorBoy Місяць тому

    Just catching up with your videos after a busy year. This was a fantastic idea for the scale

  • @ypaulbrown
    @ypaulbrown Місяць тому

    enjoying how you make videos here n Central Florida, US...Cheers......Paul

  • @mike9500
    @mike9500 Місяць тому

    🤣 wayne's world. hahahahaaha

    • @ollysworkshop
      @ollysworkshop Місяць тому

      It's the first/only thing that I think of when Delaware is mentioned! I'm glad someone appreciated it. 👍👍

  • @matthewhibbs9602
    @matthewhibbs9602 Місяць тому

    Great fix. On my myford 7 I made a solid block which I fixed the tool post to. It massively improved rigidity and was able to fit a larger toolpost. It's amazing how little you actually need the compound. If you scroll through Steve Jordans videos you can see the mod, which I'm sure you could adapt to your lathe.👍

    • @ollysworkshop
      @ollysworkshop Місяць тому

      Thanks, I've seen a few of Steve's videos, I'll go and see if I can find it.

  • @HM-Projects
    @HM-Projects Місяць тому

    Good plan to switch to solid toolpost, its the way on these small lathes.

    • @ollysworkshop
      @ollysworkshop Місяць тому

      I'm looking forward to seeing the difference it makes.

  • @billmacfarlane4083
    @billmacfarlane4083 Місяць тому

    Going through the same process myself. Great to see your experience. Thanks

  • @MrFactotum
    @MrFactotum Місяць тому

    nice one Olly Far Eastern machines have to evolve, before there to a usable satifactory state see you next time👍👍👍👍 Kev

  • @Rustinox
    @Rustinox Місяць тому

    I would call that a win, for sure.

  • @MattysWorkshop
    @MattysWorkshop Місяць тому

    Brilliant job as always mate, Cheers

    • @ollysworkshop
      @ollysworkshop Місяць тому

      Thanks Matty. Hope you are doing well.

  • @BLECHHAUS
    @BLECHHAUS Місяць тому

    My minilathe will have a similar topslide. I think this will be a good improvement!

  • @Paul-FrancisB
    @Paul-FrancisB Місяць тому

    Great improvement for the lathe will be interesting to see your take on the solid toolpost. Good call for Hersch Tool, I've been watching him for a while has done a few good projects

  • @Festivejelly
    @Festivejelly Місяць тому

    I never use a compound anymore. I use my nano ELS if I need to cut tapers or compound angles. It puzzles me that these lathes dont come with these systems given how cheap they are to make.

    • @ollysworkshop
      @ollysworkshop Місяць тому

      The ELS is still on the list of things to do. Will check out the nano ELS. I have seen a video from Weiss for a lathe with ELS, but it looks a bit crap and no one seems to stock it. My lathe is over 15 years old, I don't think they had them back then!

  • @tankie287
    @tankie287 2 місяці тому

    What diameter is the hole please mate ?

    • @ollysworkshop
      @ollysworkshop 2 місяці тому

      From memory I think it was 160mm, hence the trepanning tool. Hole saws that big are silly expensive.

  • @homemadetools
    @homemadetools 3 місяці тому

    Excellent work. We shared this video on our homemade tool forum last week, and people really liked it 😎

  • @HaxbyShed
    @HaxbyShed 3 місяці тому

    Skilled work!

  • @marley589
    @marley589 3 місяці тому

    I thought it might be useful to repost my comment from the original video for viewres that missed it before it was posted. " Clamping the parallel shank of a tool by spring pressure is not used in industry for obvious reasons. Bellevile washers are used to clamp solid tapers into a socket via a drawbar where the inherent friction of the taper and drive keys stop the toolholder from spinning. The cutting tool is securely clamped in the toolholder. " Sealed collets would keep the chips out of the spindle bore. With about 2mm of free travel on a pair of Belleville washers do you need to have 1mm compression for clamping and the remaining 1 mm for unloading. If this is the approximate case as the load is non linear then the initial clamping zone of 1mm will be a small load and the unclamping extra 1mm of travel will be much higher. Would you use the clamping method of pulling the release bar back and tightening the nut by hand, then releasing the bar allowing the springs to clamp the part therefore a custom knurled nut may suffice.

  • @marley589
    @marley589 3 місяці тому

    Clamping the parallel shank of a tool by spring pressure is not used in industry for obvious reasons. Bellevile washers are used to clamp solid tapers into a socket via a drawbar where the inherent friction of the taper and drive keys stop the toolholder from spinning. The cutting tool is securely clamped in the toolholder.

  • @bobbybishop5662
    @bobbybishop5662 3 місяці тому

    I have had both of these mills , the Seig is a step below the Weiss . The PM version of the vm25 is a couple steps above the Weiss machine. The PM line of machines are the better deal.

    • @ollysworkshop
      @ollysworkshop 3 місяці тому

      Hi, thanks for your feedback. Unfortunately we don't have PM available in the UK, I think the closest we have is warco. On paper it's hard to tell the different vendors apart for what looks like essentially the same machine.

  • @OWSNubbles
    @OWSNubbles 3 місяці тому

    Always a joy to watch your uploads, thanks for sharing!

    • @ollysworkshop
      @ollysworkshop 3 місяці тому

      Thank you, that's very good to hear.

  • @TheRecreationalMachinist
    @TheRecreationalMachinist 3 місяці тому

    Nice work Olly 👍 Is that mysterious extra spindle poking out from the control box just for the chuck guard cover thing to sit on, or does it do something exciting?

    • @ollysworkshop
      @ollysworkshop 3 місяці тому

      Thanks Matt. I'm afraid you're right, tis just for the chuck guard, nothing exciting.

  • @Rustinox
    @Rustinox 3 місяці тому

    Good one, Olly. Just keep in mind that you're not alowed to make mistakes on dimentions anymore :)

    • @ollysworkshop
      @ollysworkshop 3 місяці тому

      I'm sure I'll find a way to screw things up, just more precisely!

  • @Machine_NZ
    @Machine_NZ 3 місяці тому

    Nice job Olly. DRO's are certainly a game changer on the lathe and the mill. Regards Kevin

    • @ollysworkshop
      @ollysworkshop 3 місяці тому

      Thanks Kev. Looking forward to using it.

  • @MrFactotum
    @MrFactotum 3 місяці тому

    great Demo Olly👍👍👍👍👍👍 i'm still old school, Imperial and Dials, just the way i was brought up, may be one day when i'm old and decrepid i'll fit a DRO 🤣🤣👍👍👍👍 nice one atb Kev

    • @ollysworkshop
      @ollysworkshop 3 місяці тому

      Hi Kev. There's definitely a place for dials, and sometimes even imperial. A dial graduated in 0.01mm increments is a whole lot more accurate than a digital version with 0.01mm precision. I don't use my mill DRO that much, but when I do it's really handy. I'm expecting the same with the lathe DRO.

  • @RustyInventions-wz6ir
    @RustyInventions-wz6ir 3 місяці тому

    Very nice work sir. Just done mine as well. It’s very helpful.

  • @ironhead65
    @ironhead65 3 місяці тому

    Thanks for sharing. I’m still mulling over how I’m planning to attach my scales. I’m glad you shared your adventure. It is helpful to visualize!

    • @JeremyMakesThings
      @JeremyMakesThings 3 місяці тому

      Same here, I need to get around to it. This was helpful.

    • @ollysworkshop
      @ollysworkshop 3 місяці тому

      @ironhead65 @JeremyMakesThings Hi both, glad it was useful, took ages to edit! For the cross slide, I think the best solution is the magnetic tape as it can be kept compact, it's just more expensive than the optical scales. I may well upgrade when I've saved a few more pennies.

  • @andrewdolinskiatcarpathian
    @andrewdolinskiatcarpathian 3 місяці тому

    Hi Olly. Fitting a DRO to my lathe was a game changer for me. Always a challenge to fit, but luckily mine was a kit designed especially for the Myford Super 7 and has an embedded solution for the cross slide. Very neat design. 👏👏👍😀

    • @ollysworkshop
      @ollysworkshop 3 місяці тому

      Thanks Andrew. I'm looking forward to the convenience of the DRO. I've managed without for ~17 years, but definitely shied away from jobs that needed a lot of precision. I'll look up the myford kit as it may be transferrable as a technique.

    • @andrewdolinskiatcarpathian
      @andrewdolinskiatcarpathian 3 місяці тому

      @@ollysworkshop The kit I installed is by MDRO and use magnetic scales. Because of their slim nature it means that the cross slide scale is fitted to a slim slot milled into the base of the cross slide. An incredibly neat solution. It’s proving to be very robust and accurate.

  • @davidberlanny3308
    @davidberlanny3308 3 місяці тому

    Hi Olly, well done!! You made some good improvements too. Look forward to seeing you do the mapping. Have a great weekend!!

  • @Bobs-Wrigles5555
    @Bobs-Wrigles5555 3 місяці тому

    Well Done Olly, Did not know that those slides could be non linear along their length, but obviously the designer/builder did and allowed a way of correcting it. Just wondering how many units were made before they realised and did correct it, Always pays to buy 2nd or later generation products.👍 There may be a story in there for EV car buyers...

    • @ollysworkshop
      @ollysworkshop 3 місяці тому

      Hi Bob. I think it's the rejects that get sold off by the no-name chinese brands. It said SINO on it, which is a well known chinese brand, so should have been good, but it didn't come from them. I think the way they become non-linear is if the photo-lithography goes wrong - e.g. the photopositive of negative or whatever they use is maybe not flat, or is at an angle to the glass. I'm sure there's lots of ways they can screw it up.

    • @Bobs-Wrigles5555
      @Bobs-Wrigles5555 3 місяці тому

      @@ollysworkshop I suspect you're right about 3rd party selling off rejects.(side thought, What Chinese businessman wouldn't do this.)😉

  • @DivineMisterAdVentures
    @DivineMisterAdVentures 3 місяці тому

    I discovered +/- 0.4mm adjustable ones for about the same price - smallest possible being 1/4 inch (6mm) Also hand reaming should eliminate the run-out wobble of a fixed setup.

    • @ollysworkshop
      @ollysworkshop 3 місяці тому

      Thanks for the tip, I'll see if I can find some!

  • @AaronEngineering
    @AaronEngineering 4 місяці тому

    G'day Olly. Kudos mate, that was a bloody good idea mate. I have a similar problem with my colchester as I need a very slim scale to fit it. Hence why it still doesn't have DRO just yet. Cheers, Aaron.

    • @ollysworkshop
      @ollysworkshop 3 місяці тому

      Hi Aaron, it's a really "nice in theory" idea, and I wanted to do it. It could be made much better with a stronger spring (or possibly a gas strut as they have constant spring rate), or even with a continuous loop of wire that both pushes and pulls. There's been loads of great ideas in the comments, so maybe one day I'll get round to trying them.

  • @stevewilliams2498
    @stevewilliams2498 4 місяці тому

    Your idea to convert to push/pull (pull/pull) does not have to run up inside the cross slide. As it is only a wire (2 wires), the interference with the tailstock would be insignificant compared to the scale.

    • @ollysworkshop
      @ollysworkshop 4 місяці тому

      Good point. I'll have a bit of a think on that one. Thanks 👍

  • @charlesstaton8104
    @charlesstaton8104 4 місяці тому

    I think you gave up too soon. I know, easy for me to say, you obviously put in many many hours already, but hey just doing my job as a spectator. If you pull the cable straight out of the pulley and eliminate the cosine error as you mentioned, i think that is half the problem. The other half i think is not enough tension. I would try a MUCH stiffer spring, something strong enough to actually preload the nut against the leadscrew. Might have to double up or triple up on your aramid yarn. If that doesnt work then yeah, you will need to close the loop like you metioned. But I like the spring because (if stiff enough) it turns your acme nut into a zero backlash nut. If you're going to close the loop and use timibg belt you might as well ditch the linear scale and just use a rotary encoder. It would take up a lot less room. And the belts could be routed through those places where you didn't want a linear scale because it might get damaged. It would just need a low profile shield to keep chips off it.

    • @ollysworkshop
      @ollysworkshop 4 місяці тому

      Hi, thanks for the comment. I reckon I'll revisit this, but for the moment I've "given up" because I want to get the DRO fitted, and the lathe back in service. I agree a much stronger spring would be good, I was just working with what I had, that'll be an easy one to try. I also like the hydraulic idea that's been talked about, more just because I like it rather than it being the right solution. I would also like to try a rotary encoder. I'm really good at starting projects, less good at finishing them, so we'll see what happens.

  • @matthewhibbs9602
    @matthewhibbs9602 4 місяці тому

    Perhaps you could do a conversion like they do for a myford ML7 or Super seven. Mill a slot in your cross slide and glue a magnetic strip there. I bought a kit fro M-DRO ,but I'm sure you could make one yourself.

    • @ollysworkshop
      @ollysworkshop 4 місяці тому

      Hi, that's certainly something worth looking at, thanks. 👍

  • @BM-jy6cb
    @BM-jy6cb 4 місяці тому

    Thanks so much for this - you've saved a lot of us a lot of time. I often think up "creative" solutions that generations of real engineers have long since abandoned for very good reason!

    • @ollysworkshop
      @ollysworkshop 4 місяці тому

      It's a flawed design, but it was drawn up in a few hours. I'm sure if man years were spent on it, a solution could be found, but in engineering the compromise usually wins.

  • @paradiselost9946
    @paradiselost9946 4 місяці тому

    needs to be push-pull... two cables tensioned against each other. as you will see in applications like exhaust servo valves, throttle cables, or ailerons etc. as it isnt under load, mere fishing line will do... braided filament? lot more flexible. the cable has to pull on the slide in parallel, in line as it comes off the pulley. the angle gives a trig error... and places excessive load on the slide. using a rotary encoder, and a timing belt, with the same "stationary belt moving pulley" setup you see on larger gantry style machines... resolution will be dictated by the pulley diameter. as well as encoder... a small geared stepper will possibly achieve better resolution, but will need signal conditioning to give decent logic levels. how many pulses can you get per turn and how does that equate to travel?

    • @ollysworkshop
      @ollysworkshop 4 місяці тому

      I covered the push-pull idea, used Kevlar thread, and pointed out the cosine error in the video. A rotary encoder is certainly one way to go with this. I'm not sure it's worth struggling with stepper motors though.

  • @HM-Projects
    @HM-Projects 4 місяці тому

    I think every moving part adds some backlash, the fundamental physics can't be changed. Even the optical scale readers have backlash specified in the data sheets +/- 5um for the decent ones.

    • @ollysworkshop
      @ollysworkshop 4 місяці тому

      Yes, too many moving parts.

    • @HM-Projects
      @HM-Projects 4 місяці тому

      @@ollysworkshop good to try things out nonetheless. If you're chasing microns lookup laser interferometer encoders 💸