Inquisitive Mind
Inquisitive Mind
  • 163
  • 112 341
Muslim Apologists can't agree on the words to the Adhan that was called out aloud five times a day
www.kalamullah.com/bidayat-al-mujtahid.html
p116
They disagreed about the pronouncement by the mu'adhin for the morning prayer "prayer is better than sleep" whether it is to be pronounced or not. The majority maintained that it is to be pronounced while the others held that it is not to be pronounced as it is not a part of the adhan practiced as a sunna. This was upheld by al-Shafi. The reason for their disagreement *is their dispute whether it was pronounced in the days of the Prophet or whether it was added during the reign of Umar*
sunnah.com/tirmidhi:192
Переглядів: 178

Відео

Muslim Scholar tells us that the Quran contains foreign words
Переглядів 696Місяць тому
Original video ua-cam.com/video/bVbkEWc0aDE/v-deo.htmlsi=yeZRubjr3FHFK987 www.zakariyyabooks.com/product/select-chapters-of-itqan-on-the-language-of-the-quran ua-cam.com/video/hwQD8EpRo-0/v-deo.htmlsi=OYV-U4E9ZNUs9jck ua-cam.com/video/zId43sjk-oc/v-deo.htmlsi=bPmC2NUB9B76PZdO
Suyuti tells us Aisha said that there are errors in the Quran - its isnaad is sound based on Bukhari
Переглядів 308Місяць тому
Original ua-cam.com/video/lzXRIbHndVU/v-deo.htmlsi=1g681m3C60PZTBfX www.zakariyyabooks.com/product/select-chapters-of-itqan-on-the-language-of-the-quran/ ua-cam.com/video/_5qDnSpkNDI/v-deo.htmlsi=2Fze53X6Bk_amh_d ua-cam.com/video/bD8DXbwlgRw/v-deo.htmlsi=_zcYoHLI36YhclNr ua-cam.com/video/YdvkCGVKIbg/v-deo.htmlsi=c1xhrxhc-0vgamBj ua-cam.com/video/D4hTt6Wkhck/v-deo.htmlsi=t9Es9Ks4Vx_LbNPE ua-cam....
Pre-Islamic Arabic poetry and the Quran contain variant readings and categories due to human error.
Переглядів 618Місяць тому
p227 Shady Nasser's Transmission of Variant Readings of the Quran "By creating a database of variants for selections from the Quran and a few poems from the en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mufaddaliyat, I was able to *create twenty-three categories of variants applicable to both Quran and poetry* The first important observation is that both literatures *share the same types of variants* regardless of the...
Canonical Reading Contradiction Q10:16 - Would Allah have informed you or not informed you about it?
Переглядів 2422 місяці тому
www.altafsir.com/Tafasir.asp?tMadhNo=1&tTafsirNo=74&tSoraNo=10&tAyahNo=16&tDisplay=yes&UserProfile=0&LanguageId=2 youtube.com/@evquran?si=LFeRE-bxiJSc1yxm erquran.org/ x.com/EvQuran?t=ywuNhKOsNjJmetNHLEBPew&s=09 en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Al-Bazzi
Allah speaks bad grammar - Q20:63 Al-Farra 833AD tells us that Aisha said it's an error in the Quran
Переглядів 3052 місяці тому
www.academia.edu/103835301/Are_these_Nothing_but_Sorcerers_A_linguistic_analysis_of_Q_Ṭā_Hā_20_63_using_intra_Qurʾānic_parallels 1:33:52 ua-cam.com/video/xkMqKB5SM1A/v-deo.htmlsi=93IGpNvBYH3FppAj The famous disagreement on (Q. 20:63) which does not agree with the fasih Arabic, forced al-Tabarı to reject the proper 'arabiyyah reading of Abu Amr b. al-'Ala" who read “inna hadhayni”. According to ...
Ibn Ishaq 767AD says it was a monk in Busra; Ibn Rashid 770AD says it was a Jew in Oasis of Tayma
Переглядів 1653 місяці тому
The Expeditions: An Early Biography of Muhammad: 20 (Library of Arabic Literature) www.amazon.co.uk/dp/1479816825/ref=cm_sw_r_apan_glt_fabc_C29097CT6SXJEE97R5BR www.britannica.com/biography/Ibn-Ishaq en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ma'mar_ibn_Rashid Busra en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bosra www.worldheritagesite.org/list/Bosra Tayma en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tayma Oasis of Tayma saudi-archaeology.com/sites/tay...
In Q5:6 Allah can't make his mind up whether to wash one's feet or to wipe them.
Переглядів 1664 місяці тому
ua-cam.com/video/n8sG5bqot88/v-deo.htmlsi=b5wLRmwCJe5jspFK ua-cam.com/video/tDTB2ps48uk/v-deo.htmlsi=NJglw4_uVsbjaH_0 Grammatical mistake in Quran www.academia.edu/103835301/Are_these_Nothing_but_Sorcerers_A_linguistic_analysis_of_Q_Ṭā_Hā_20_63_using_intra_Qurʾānic_parallels academic.oup.com/jss/article-abstract/XXXIII/2/181/1682490
Allah speaks bad grammar - Hamzah recites Q4:1 "wa-l-arhami" is rejected by 7 scholars & grammarians
Переглядів 1414 місяці тому
p167 Shady Nasser's 1st book youtube.com/@evquran?si=LFeRE-bxiJSc1yxm erquran.org/ x.com/EvQuran?t=ywuNhKOsNjJmetNHLEBPew&s=09 Hamzah’s reading of (Q. 4:1) “wa-ttaq¯u ll¯aha l-ladh¯ı tas¯a"al¯una bihi wa-l-arhama” in which he read “wa-l-arhami” in the genitive case was rejected by several scholars and grammarians. al-Farra" stated that the reading in the genitive case is repulsive (f¯ıhi qubh),...
Allah speaks bad grammar - Hamza's Q18:97 Ibn Mujahid, al-Zajjaj and Al-Farsi say is bad grammar
Переглядів 1194 місяці тому
youtube.com/@evquran?si=LFeRE-bxiJSc1yxm erquran.org/ x.com/EvQuran?t=ywuNhKOsNjJmetNHLEBPew&s=09 Ibn Mujāhid rejected this reading by Ḥamza and suggested that the latter wanted to read fa-mā ‿staṭāʿū but he assimilated the tāʾ with the ṭāʾ, which was not permissible because the sīn is unvocalized and so does the newly assimilated tāʾ/ṭāʾ; Ibn Mujāhid, Sabʿa. Al-Fārisī considered this reading t...
Allah speaks bad grammar - Zamakhshari 1144AD says Ibn Amir's Q6:137 is revolting even for poetry
Переглядів 1394 місяці тому
page 7 Shady Nasser's 1st book youtube.com/@evquran?si=LFeRE-bxiJSc1yxm erquran.org/ x.com/EvQuran?t=ywuNhKOsNjJmetNHLEBPew&s=09 al-Zamakhshar¯ı’s Kashsha¯ f is his disparaging of Ibn Amir’s reading of (Q. 6:137) “wa-kadha¯ lika zayyana likath ¯ırin mina l-mushrik¯ına qatla awl¯adihim shurak¯a"uhum” (Even so, in the eyes of most of the pagans, their “partners” made alluring the slaughter of the...
If the dialect is non-Hijazi then how did it get in if Muhammad is not from there?
Переглядів 9684 місяці тому
sunnah.com/bukhari/66/9 sunnah.com/bukhari:4984 ua-cam.com/video/WOxjMIy5t_w/v-deo.htmlsi=eWNUe3oBwxXEBE2R ua-cam.com/video/khJElQasu-E/v-deo.htmlsi=GdQcwVSwps4J-QSS Grammatical mistake in the Quran www.academia.edu/103835301/Are_these_Nothing_but_Sorcerers_A_linguistic_analysis_of_Q_Ṭā_Hā_20_63_using_intra_Qurʾānic_parallels phoenixblog.typepad.com/blog/2023/09/tawatur-al-qiraat.html ua-cam.co...
If the dialect is non-Hijazi then how did it get in if Muhammad is not from there?
Переглядів 1,2 тис.4 місяці тому
sunnah.com/bukhari/66/9 sunnah.com/bukhari:4984 ua-cam.com/video/WOxjMIy5t_w/v-deo.htmlsi=eWNUe3oBwxXEBE2R ua-cam.com/video/khJElQasu-E/v-deo.htmlsi=GdQcwVSwps4J-QSS Grammatical mistake in the Quran www.academia.edu/103835301/Are_these_Nothing_but_Sorcerers_A_linguistic_analysis_of_Q_Ṭā_Hā_20_63_using_intra_Qurʾānic_parallels phoenixblog.typepad.com/blog/2023/09/tawatur-al-qiraat.html ua-cam.co...
Q11:81 Canon reading mistakes - which one is it? Did Lot take his wife with him or leave her behind?
Переглядів 1834 місяці тому
Video has no sound Marijn van Putten PhDniX/status/1452668408269520904?t=BJ2sR9_BAxZ1DNzdlN1aMw&s=19 ShAmmarKhatib1/status/1459648106161655812?t=IbbQTkEKjJz3Hqv8V_sceg&s=19 Tafsir (Commentary) on this verse www.altafsir.com/Tafasir.asp?tMadhNo=1&tTafsirNo=74&tSoraNo=11&tAyahNo=81&tDisplay=yes&UserProfile=0&LanguageId=2 To learn more about variant readings quranvariants.w...
Why are there hereditary scribal errors in the 4 archetype Qurans if Q15:9 says it will preserve it?
Переглядів 3404 місяці тому
Why are there hereditary scribal errors in the 4 archetype Qurans if Q15:9 says it will preserve it?
If Uthman sent reciters with the regional Qurans then why are the recitations a mixture of regions?
Переглядів 1 тис.4 місяці тому
If Uthman sent reciters with the regional Qurans then why are the recitations a mixture of regions?
If all the canonical readings were from Muhammad then why are they indivually a mixture of dialects?
Переглядів 1,6 тис.4 місяці тому
If all the canonical readings were from Muhammad then why are they indivually a mixture of dialects?
Was Muhammad referring to the Promised Land in Genesis 15:18?
Переглядів 2265 місяців тому
Was Muhammad referring to the Promised Land in Genesis 15:18?
Was Muhammad's cave revelation and Bede's Caedmon story copied from Isaiah 29:10-12?
Переглядів 3636 місяців тому
Was Muhammad's cave revelation and Bede's Caedmon story copied from Isaiah 29:10-12?
Muhammad tells us that the best place to live is in the Holy Land Q5:21 where Abraham migrated to.
Переглядів 2316 місяців тому
Muhammad tells us that the best place to live is in the Holy Land Q5:21 where Abraham migrated to.
Companion of Muhammad: Abu Darda asks Salman the Persian to come to the Holy Land Q5:21
Переглядів 2466 місяців тому
Companion of Muhammad: Abu Darda asks Salman the Persian to come to the Holy Land Q5:21
Muhammad mentions the Holy Land Q5:21 will be conquered before the End of Times
Переглядів 2606 місяців тому
Muhammad mentions the Holy Land Q5:21 will be conquered before the End of Times
Jerusalem is the Land of the Resurrection, Day of Judgment & Mecca and Medina will be brought to it.
Переглядів 1306 місяців тому
Jerusalem is the Land of the Resurrection, Day of Judgment & Mecca and Medina will be brought to it.
Abu Bakr says the entire span of the Holy Land Q5:21 is more pleasing to him than the whole of Iraq
Переглядів 1576 місяців тому
Abu Bakr says the entire span of the Holy Land Q5:21 is more pleasing to him than the whole of Iraq
If Muhammad was from the hijaz & they never had the letter hamza then how did it get into the Quran?
Переглядів 1,7 тис.7 місяців тому
If Muhammad was from the hijaz & they never had the letter hamza then how did it get into the Quran?
Azraqi 865AD tells us that there used to be a picture of Jesus & Mary inside the Kaaba
Переглядів 5 тис.8 місяців тому
Azraqi 865AD tells us that there used to be a picture of Jesus & Mary inside the Kaaba
If the canonical readings were well known to be from Allah, why is Ibn Mujahid calling some wrong?
Переглядів 9498 місяців тому
If the canonical readings were well known to be from Allah, why is Ibn Mujahid calling some wrong?
Why don't Muslims know if the basmalah is verse no 1 or not of the opening chapter of the Quran?
Переглядів 3889 місяців тому
Why don't Muslims know if the basmalah is verse no 1 or not of the opening chapter of the Quran?
Uthmamic master codices were enforced on the people using lashing, intimidation and violence.
Переглядів 3249 місяців тому
Uthmamic master codices were enforced on the people using lashing, intimidation and violence.

КОМЕНТАРІ

  • @Kassalawy56789
    @Kassalawy56789 День тому

    The prophet Mohamed peace and blessing be upon him never been a king.....!!!! He was offered all title, money to stop him from his message but he never accepted.... Thanks God for Islam ❤❤❤

  • @DomainofKnowlegdia
    @DomainofKnowlegdia 6 днів тому

    The Quranic corpus predates Muhammads time.

  • @richardokeefe7410
    @richardokeefe7410 7 днів тому

    This is a bit misleading around 13:50ish. You can quite easily end up with a single "fixed" text where there were multiple archetypes. We see this in genetics whenever an allele is "fixed" by genetic drift or selection. And indeed the allele that is fixed need not have been in the original population, but may be a mutant that spread. So the claim "could ONLY have happened" is WAY TOO strong, logically and empirically. And we have evidence from the oldest surviving texts of copies that disagreed with the official text being post-production edited to conform. The rest of such post-production editing is a text which had two archetypes.-

  • @harkamelrandhawa7125
    @harkamelrandhawa7125 8 днів тому

    Mohammad and the 5 dildos of Islam.

  • @BenM61
    @BenM61 8 днів тому

    لقد حقّ القول على هاؤلاء الذين يشكّكون في القرآن و كتاب الله و يدّعون العلم: لو كلُّ كلبٍ عوى ألقمتُه حجرًا لأصبح الصخرُ مثقالاً بدينارِ شاعر مجهول. أشهد أنّ لا إله إلّى الله و أشهد أنّ محمّدا رسول الله. و الحمد لله على نعمة الإسلام

  • @SufiyanMullaji-uc3xv
    @SufiyanMullaji-uc3xv 11 днів тому

    First the people who compiled the holy Quran aren't Anonymous like💀🥴 Gospels 😂😂😂really Lying Christian Retard🥴 3 Now go and smite Amalek, and utterly destroy all that they have, and spare them not; but slay both man and woman, infant and suckling, ox and sheep, camel and ass. 4 And Saul gathered the people together, and numbered them in Telaim, two hundred thousand footmen, and ten thousand men of Judah.

  • @SalazarChigurh
    @SalazarChigurh 13 днів тому

    Cope harder!!! He is most influential man ever. Cope harder!!!

  • @bpcgos
    @bpcgos 14 днів тому

    A king that didnt bother to build a palace because he believe this world is just temporary before going to eternal afterlife and rather build a palace there, a king that died leaves only an armor pawned to a jew,a sword and 2 pair of clothes including the one he wore, a king that slept on top of the mat made from palm dates leaves that leaves mark to his back, a king that crying for his people safety in afterlife during his last breath, a king that seldom to have a food in the table in 3 days straight because there was none for him to eat and he choose fasting, a king that choose to donate all of his part of spoils of war to charity body because he just cannot keep it more than 3 days in his house due to afraid of God will asked where he spent that pile of gold, a king that choose masjid made of mud brick as his palace and place where strategic move consolidate. There will never be king like him, all we can do is try to follow him as hard as we could.

  • @Kassalawy56789
    @Kassalawy56789 14 днів тому

    Man you need to be fluent in Arabic grammar to understand the difference.... Instead of merely depending in your ability to read Arabic... Thanks God for Islam ❤❤

    • @inquisitivemind007
      @inquisitivemind007 14 днів тому

      And I suppose it's just a coincidence that the differences in the Uthmanic master copies form a copying pattern is it?

    • @BenM61
      @BenM61 8 днів тому

      A copying pattern?

    • @inquisitivemind007
      @inquisitivemind007 8 днів тому

      @@BenM61 the stemma he was referring to.

  • @nadermousa5569
    @nadermousa5569 14 днів тому

    1.9 billion muslims don't waste a minute to discredit Jesus or christianity they don't care the stuff you make up about your religion that is your business but you and church's and hundreds of programs on youtube and other platforms you keep attacking Islam , Muhammed and the Quran , you can attack all you want but it is not only attacking you guys make up stuff as you go hoping that keep enforcing it on youtube one day it will become facts .... you just wasting your time if you ask any muslim out of the 1.9 billion muslim to convert or leave Islam they'll tell you if you give me mountains of gold and diamonds I will never convert or leave Islam and all these lies about Muhammed and Islam or the Quran is wrong ...

  • @Kassalawy56789
    @Kassalawy56789 14 днів тому

    Christians have too many problems with their bible history & now a lot of them trying to critique the holy Quran.... Pls go figure out your problems with the bible.. Thanks God for Islam

  • @abd.-
    @abd.- 15 днів тому

    Instead of quoting lesser sources why are the most authentic islamic sources i.e. Hadith is not quoted. Lets start by Sahi Al-Muslim 160 and 161. There is no mention of a dream or vision

  • @YeshuaisEMET
    @YeshuaisEMET 19 днів тому

    Just shows its not from The True God.

  • @nasirarushdi8980
    @nasirarushdi8980 19 днів тому

    Very intresting system of All dah the Allmighty some of Anbias belonged to the refuted king as ibrahiem appointed nabi by Allah but they hated theose All things which peoples worshiped idiols sun moon stars fire any other things make the Allah partners .ibrahim had evry thing but you realized that how they find the hadyet of Allah And Moses as to Essa Essa as were poor but all arranged for them evry thing .While Haxzrat Mohammad saw belonged to a rich family but thier parents died in child hood and they brought up in a poor women carer who had not milk but his goats began to milk for food of Mohammad saw They were seven years old Allah mentions i give him under the supervission of the angel Mekaiel thhen on twvelve years old Jibraiel as care them always they take thier protection they were quiet uneducated But Allah revealed on them the Quran education .teach them writting and reading the all of Quran .How sports the Allah his Naib Na.bi or Rasool give him evry reward for his sacrificed the life .and his help Allah for his needs .

  • @shantimirpeace
    @shantimirpeace 21 день тому

    Quran 2:223: "Your wives are a tillage for you. Go on your tillage as often as you wish..." Sahih Bukhari 2658: The Prophet said: "Is not the testimony of a woman half the worth of that of a man?" The women said: "Yes." He said: "This is due to the deficiency in the woman's intellect." Sahih Bukhari 29: The Prophet said: "I was shown the Hellfire and the majority of its dwellers were women who were ungrateful." (Same in Sahih Bukhari 204) Quran 4:11: Women inherit half as much as men do. Sahih Bukhari 7099: "No nation will succeed that makes a woman its leader." Quran 4:34: Men are superior to women because of what Allah has given one over the other. Quran 65:4: Women can be married before puberty. Sahih Bukhari 5134: Mohammed married Aisha when she was 6 years old and had sexual intercourse with her when she was 9. Quran 4:24, Sahih Muslim 1456a : "Also [forbidden to you are] married women, except those your right hands possess [slaves]." Quran 4:34: "And if you perceive bad behavior from your wives, advise them first. If they persist, do not share their beds, and if they still persist, then strike them." Quran 38:44 - "And take in your hand a green branch and beat her with it." Mishkat al-Masabih 3260: "...and don't beat your wife as you beat your slave." Sahih Bukhari 3237, Sunan Ibn Majah 1853: A woman should not deny her husband's desire for intimacy, even if she is on a camel saddle. Quran 23:5-6, 70:22-30, 4:3: A man can make his sex slaves his wives. Quran 4:3: A woman should not criticize her husband's desire for polygamy. Bayhaqi 14490: A woman cannot leave the house without her husband's permission. Sahih Muslim 8:3425: A woman should breastfeed a non-relative man, so he becomes unmarriageable to her, if they are ever alone together. Quran 2:221: Muslim women cannot marry non-Muslim men, Muslim men can marry non-Muslim women. In Paradise, male Muslims will have 80,000 servants and 72 virgins (Jami` at-Tirmidhi 2562) with large, beautiful eyes (Koran 37:48, 44:54, 52:20), full-bosomed (Koran 78:33) untouched by any man (Koran 55:56), lying on green cushions and beautiful carpets (55:74), but somehow no mention of the multiple fields (from Koran 2:223). Women are a minority in Paradise (Sahih Muslim 2738a) (including the 72 virgins per man??) Sahih Bukhari 7142: "Allah's Messenger said: "You should listen to and obey your ruler even if he was an black slave, whose head looks like a raisin"" Sahih Muslim 10.3901: "A slave came and swore allegiance to the Messenger of Allah... not knowing that he was a slave. Then his master came and demanded him back, so the Messenger of Allah said: 'Sell him to me,' and he bought him for two black slaves, and he did not take anyone's oath of allegiance after that until he had asked him whether he was a slave (or a free man)." Quran 3:54, Qur'an 8:30: "Allah is the best of deceivers." Quran 9:29: "Fight those who do not believe in Allah or in the Last Day and who do not consider unlawful what Allah and His Messenger have made unlawful..." - Regarding the Last Day - Sahih Muslim 2953b: When will the last hour come? The Messenger of Allah remained silent for a while. Then he looked at a small boy in his presence... and he said: If this boy lives, he would not grow very old until the last hour would come to you. ( 1,350 years ago ) - About the credibility of Muhammad: Qur'an 69.44-46: "If he (Muhammad) had made up about Us (Allah) any sayings, We would certainly have seized him by the right hand, and then certainly We would have cut off his aorta." - compared to Sahih Bukhari 4428: "The Prophet used to say in his illness from which he died. 'O 'Aisha!... At this time, I feel as if my aorta is being cut from that poison.'" Quran 22:65: Allah is holding up the sky and prevents it from falling down on us. Quran 13:2: Allah put the sky on invisible pillars. Quran 16:79, and 67:19: Have you not seen the birds in the sky flying? No one except Allah holds them in the air. In this are truly signs for the believers. Quran 20:53: Allah spread out the earth like a carpet. Quran 18:86: ... he reached the setting of the sun and saw it setting in a murky spring... Sahih Bukhari 3199: "Do you know where the sun goes (at the time of sunset)?" I replied, "Allah and His Apostle know better." He said, "It goes (i.e., travels) till it prostrates itself underneath the Throne (of Allah), and takes the permission to rise again, and it is permitted and then (a time will come when) it will be about to prostrate itself, but its prostration will not be accepted, and it will ask permission to go on its course, but it will not be permitted, but it will be ordered to return whence it has come, and so it will rise in the west." Quran 21:33: And He it is Who created the night and the day and the sun and the moon; all travelling along in their celestial spheres. Sahih Muslim 758c: Allah descends to the nearest (first) heaven at night. Quran 67:5: "And We (Allah) have certainly beautified the nearest heaven with stars and have made [from] them what is thrown at the devils." Adab al Mufrad 1187, Ibn Majah 3723: Don't sleep on your belly, or Allah will be angry! Sahih Bikhari 3320: If a fly falls into your drink, dip it and take it out. One of its wings has a disease, the other a cure. Sahih Muslim 2220: Infections are not real. Sahih al-Bukhari 5686: The Prophet ordered them to follow his shepherd and his camels, and drink their milk and urine (as medicine). So they followed the camels and drank their milk and urine (as medicine)... The P in Islam stands for peace!

  • @BenM61
    @BenM61 21 день тому

    What about the oral tradition? So the language of Alhijaz does not pronounce the sukun of the alif or glottal stop but all the other tribes do. What’s the big deal about that? If you are hijazi you don’t have pronounce it and if you are not you can. This is just stupid.

  • @BenM61
    @BenM61 22 дні тому

    Actually FYI Putten there is another word in the Quran spelled and pronounced like kufuan كفوا and that is huzuan هزوا. That word is found in seven places in the Quran. I don’t know why you mentioned only kufuan. Also those two words are pronounced in four different ways: 1 - كفُؤَاً كفْؤَاً - 2 كفُوَاً - 3 كفْواً - 4

  • @BenM61
    @BenM61 22 дні тому

    The mushaf of Uthman was collected, copied and approved by a committee comprised by the companion of the prophet Muhammad. That is the one book we acknowledge as authority and everything else was just pollution and white noise with no authority.

  • @berkleystreetcapital3588
    @berkleystreetcapital3588 22 дні тому

    Regardless what it says does the document have anything to do with the message of Mohammad? So did the document suggest that Mohammad was part of Trinity or declared himself God? If not whether the document says king or not is irrelevant to the message of islam.

    • @jskok3280
      @jskok3280 17 днів тому

      I am a reborn Christian and my comment has nothing to do with Mahammed. It relates to Derek himself. Derek, go and find yourself a proper job and stop trying to impress yourself and other atheists with your babblelish nonsense.

  • @AhmirNawaz
    @AhmirNawaz 23 дні тому

    Who are the two guests and where can I get the complete video ?

    • @inquisitivemind007
      @inquisitivemind007 23 дні тому

      ua-cam.com/video/mn4Ch4jhK5s/v-deo.htmlsi=yhNcC0-AX92YUQKj

  • @joejr.cocker9997
    @joejr.cocker9997 25 днів тому

    ⚡ AI Debunkes Christianity in 5 Minutes @ Bobby 's Perspectives podcast ⚡

  • @almazchati4178
    @almazchati4178 26 днів тому

    This fellow is trying to milk spider.

  • @sajidkadri2623
    @sajidkadri2623 27 днів тому

    There are may but if, more research need, if the meaning did not change may be far shabha did not detailed information

  • @sajidkadri2623
    @sajidkadri2623 27 днів тому

    There where false prophet during the time abu bakar

  • @tommyjones2708
    @tommyjones2708 29 днів тому

    The West must oganize itself to fight to free every Muslim especially the women to be free to choose ..to return their human rights and dignity.. To expose the lies in Islam and its fake paedophile messenger. That Allah is NOT YAHWEH and has nothing to o do with this Fertility Moon God and expose this truth . Muhammad is not a continuity of the Jewush prophets. Every nion Muslim has his political correctness to say this direct to any muslim freely without threats to be be killed as this is a fact.

  • @shihabshihabi
    @shihabshihabi 29 днів тому

    So you agnore the eye witnesses who believe it is prohibited to lie and you belieive ignorant christians who lived dacades later and far away and willing to lie for their religion?

    • @inquisitivemind007
      @inquisitivemind007 29 днів тому

      You can't even get your opening story right never mind the rest ua-cam.com/video/JZprMoF6tq8/v-deo.htmlsi=FvI784NAPLbNbrvL

    • @bigboyshit1
      @bigboyshit1 29 днів тому

      Literally the same with Muslims! Muhammad lived 600 years after Jesus, yet knew best 😂

  • @rafaelsantiago9624
    @rafaelsantiago9624 Місяць тому

    Do these academics not know that all traces of paganism was commanded to be wiped out but Muhammad. So there not being signs of paganism around Mecca and Medina and out lying areas is a proof. Muslim (832) narrated from ‘Urwah ibn ‘Abasah that he said to the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him): “With what were you sent?” He said, “I was sent to uphold the ties of kinship, to break the idols, and so that Allaah would be worshipped alone with no partner or associate.” The Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) sent Khaalid ibn al-Waleed (may Allaah be pleased with him) on a campaign to destroy al-‘Uzza. and he sent Sa’d ibn Zayd al-Ashhali (may Allaah be pleased with him) on a campaign to destroy Manaat. And he sent ‘Amr ibn al-‘Aas (may Allaah be pleased with him) on a campaign to destroy Suwaa’. All of that happened after the Conquest of Makkah. Al-Bidaayah wa’l-Nihaayah, 4/712. 776. 5/83; al-Seerah al-Nabawiyyah by Dr. ‘Ali al-Salaabi, 2/1186. The more you do research the more important inline it comes to Islamic history

  • @penoge
    @penoge Місяць тому

    So what? The question is already how old the variants are. But the thing is, that the Quran was given to Mohammed who didn't write it himself but dictated it to writers who wrote it on different materials which just were at hand. That's why there were variants. That doesn't make much because the variants didn't change the major statements of the Quran. It's just the same as with the Bible. There are also countless variants but the major statements are unchanged.

  • @oluwaseunoluwatoyeen5493
    @oluwaseunoluwatoyeen5493 Місяць тому

    PLS DONT LINK JESUS TO THIS PAGAN SHRINE, JESUS HAS NOTHING TO DO WITH THE PAGAN SHRINE ,IT HAS ALWAYS BEEN PAGAN ,AND ABRAHAM NOR ISHMAEL HAS ANYTHING TO DO WITH IT THIS STORY IS FROM THE PIT OF HELL ,ITS A LIE

  • @MarioBeukes-vv1uz
    @MarioBeukes-vv1uz Місяць тому

    Remember, koran manuscripts was in Muslim hands long before it was available to public and non Muslim scholars. Explain the corrections to me, why corrections was made in manuscripts,all in the same place to fit Cairo text of 1924 or 1934? See Daniel Brubaker 😮

  • @Stardust475
    @Stardust475 Місяць тому

    Brilliant!

    • @inquisitivemind007
      @inquisitivemind007 Місяць тому

      p116 They disagreed about the pronouncement by the mu'adhin for the morning prayer "prayer is better than sleep" whether it is to be pronounced or not. The majority maintained that it is to be pronounced while the others held that it is not to be pronounced as it is not a part of the adhan practiced as a sunna. This was upheld by al-Shafi. The reason for their disagreement *is their dispute whether it was pronounced in the days of the Prophet or whether it was added during the reign of Umar*

    • @sasa_sasa_sasa230
      @sasa_sasa_sasa230 17 днів тому

      😂😂😂

    • @sasa_sasa_sasa230
      @sasa_sasa_sasa230 17 днів тому

      ​@@inquisitivemind007can you please put links of the books in comments that leed to a direct page of the book, so we can use this arguments?

    • @inquisitivemind007
      @inquisitivemind007 17 днів тому

      @@sasa_sasa_sasa230 www.kalamullah.com/bidayat-al-mujtahid.html you can download the book

    • @sasa_sasa_sasa230
      @sasa_sasa_sasa230 17 днів тому

      ​@@inquisitivemind007thanks i tried but something is wrong...

  • @acethegreat2946
    @acethegreat2946 Місяць тому

    This doesn’t refute Islam or the Qur’an in the slightest. There’s not a single foreign word in the Quran. Understand this. Is ‘cotton’ an English word? Obviously yes, right? However, its origin is Arabic. It comes from قطن which means cotton and is pronounced very similar. Now does this mean, cotton is not English but actually Arabic? Of course not.

    • @inquisitivemind007
      @inquisitivemind007 Місяць тому

      Some Muslims believe Arabic is a divine language meaning what's written on the preserved tablet is Arabic.

  • @user-xu1hn3ic6b
    @user-xu1hn3ic6b Місяць тому

    Why excuses. The words are supposed to be in clear Arabic which language preceded Islam and the Quran. There were no alphabets,dots diacritical marks which were introduced much later. Non Arabic words like injeel are from elsewhere not uncreated. Accept that the myth that Quran is perfectly transmitted and preserved and has no errors or contradiction is false. It's a fairly stable Text mayb from time of uthman codex. That doesn't mean the afire said are true

  • @user-xu1hn3ic6b
    @user-xu1hn3ic6b Місяць тому

    Itd true that islsmic standard narrative is full of holes gor dure

  • @DhikrDose
    @DhikrDose Місяць тому

    Arabic language isn't divine hence there is no creator and afterlife, got it 👍

  • @TheGuiltyGuys
    @TheGuiltyGuys Місяць тому

    anti-islam watchers be watching and slowly realizing this proves the Islamic traditional narrative and claims about the Quran 🤣🤣🤣

  • @irisvega5743
    @irisvega5743 Місяць тому

    Islam is a broken religion

  • @ailove313
    @ailove313 Місяць тому

    If its special from God, it should be easy to understand not complex and make it more difficult for people to understand.

  • @abuzakirnaik142
    @abuzakirnaik142 Місяць тому

    Why you don't wanna talk about the third footnote? It clearly said the hadith is muddarib, which I very much know you don't know what it mean.

    • @inquisitivemind007
      @inquisitivemind007 Місяць тому

      I recommend you buy Suyuti's book 📖 there is more www.zakariyyabooks.com/product/select-chapters-of-itqan-on-the-language-of-the-quran

    • @abuzakirnaik142
      @abuzakirnaik142 Місяць тому

      @@inquisitivemind007 I don't actually need to buy any book, because I know enough Arabic to understand the footnote. Why did you ignore the third Original Arabic footnote?

    • @inquisitivemind007
      @inquisitivemind007 Місяць тому

      @abuzakirnaik142 because the topic of grammaraticsl issues isn't just on one pages hence why I recommend the book. It's in both Arabic and English.

    • @TruthSeeker_1418
      @TruthSeeker_1418 Місяць тому

      This chain is authentic as per Bukhari and Muslim criteria, therefore, it’s is correctly attributed to Aisha.

    • @TruthSeeker_1418
      @TruthSeeker_1418 Місяць тому

      Similar chain is found in bukhari, here is an example: جاء في صحيح البخاري : حَدَّثَنَا مُحَمَّدٌ قَالَ : حَدَّثَنَا أَبُو مُعَاوِيَةَ ، حَدَّثَنَا هِشَامُ بْنُ عُرْوَةَ ، عَنْ أَبِيهِ ، عَنْ عَائِشَةَ قَالَتْ : جَاءَتْ فَاطِمَةُ بْنَةُ أَبِي حُبَيْشٍ إِلَى النَّبِيِّ صَلَّى اللَّهُ عَلَيْهِ وَسَلَّمَ، فَقَالَتْ : يَا رَسُولَ اللَّهِ، إِنِّي امْرَأَةٌ أُسْتَحَاضُ، فَلَا أَطْهُرُ، أَفَأَدَعُ الصَّلَاةَ ؟ فَقَالَ رَسُولُ اللَّهِ صَلَّى اللَّهُ عَلَيْهِ وَسَلَّمَ : " لَا، إِنَّمَا ذَلِكِ عِرْقٌ، وَلَيْسَ بِحَيْضٍ، فَإِذَا أَقْبَلَتْ حَيْضَتُكِ فَدَعِي الصَّلَاةَ، وَإِذَا أَدْبَرَتْ فَاغْسِلِي عَنْكِ الدَّمَ، ثُمَّ صَلِّي ". قَالَ : وَقَالَ أَبِي : " ثُمَّ تَوَضَّئِي لِكُلِّ صَلَاةٍ، حَتَّى يَجِيءَ ذَلِكِ الْوَقْتُ ".

  • @islandbwoy90
    @islandbwoy90 Місяць тому

    Language never fell outta the sky but I’d rather read an Arabic bible than a greek one. At least it’s in the same language family as the native tongues of all the prophets. Linguistically Quranic Arabic or Classical Arabic is highly unique because it gave rise to Modern Standard Arabic which is used throughout the world. What other text had an global effect on language as substantial as the Quran. There are about 20million greek and Hebrew speakers combined. There are 330million speakers of Modern Standard Arabic.

    • @inquisitivemind007
      @inquisitivemind007 Місяць тому

      ua-cam.com/video/2rGegCvKQ28/v-deo.htmlsi=QK3fmlvxrQ3KDONb

    • @islandbwoy90
      @islandbwoy90 Місяць тому

      @@inquisitivemind007 that doesn’t refute what I said. I would actually agree with Marjin Van Putten.

  • @JohnGeometresMaximos
    @JohnGeometresMaximos Місяць тому

    The Quran is most definitely a product of its time. Linguistically speaking, there is nothing special about the Quran. We know for a fact that the Quran uses transliterations of non-Arabic words like the word "Injeel" which is Greek.

    • @inquisitivemind007
      @inquisitivemind007 Місяць тому

      You absolutely right that there is nothing special about the Quran. Here is more proof: p227 Shady Nasser's Transmission of Variant Readings of the Quran "By creating a database of variants for selections from the Quran and a few poems from the en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mufaddaliyat, I was able to create twenty-three categories of variants applicable to both Quran and poetry. The first important observation is that both literatures *share the same types of variants* regardless of the proportions and percentages of each type in its respective genre. The limitations of the consonantal outline of the Quran and its liturgical and theological restrictions have definitely produced different proportions of the variants from those in poetry, which is restricted by meters and rhymes. The variants which are due to discrepancies in case endings and internal vowels are more frequent in the Quran, and I attribute this to the eponymous Readers’ modest knowledge of Arabic grammar and syntax, unlike the transmitters of early Arabic poetry who were mostly grammarians and philologists."

    • @krisc3371
      @krisc3371 Місяць тому

      @@inquisitivemind007 I wonder how the authors of; Encyclopedia of Arabic Literature knew that e.g. (Mutammim ibn Nuwayrah, Rabi'a ibn Maqrum, Abda ibn at-Tabib and Abu Dhu'ayb) had adopted ''Islam''. Islam wasn't yet the organised religion it would become later, rather they adopted Arab monotheism (Hanifiyyah) which was in that early period far closer to the Judeo-Christian traditions hence they also praised other practices forbidden in Islam-Wine, gambling (the game of maisir), etc. and not surprisingly ''neither the old idolatry nor the new spirituality are themes'' Either way, i never knew about this Pre-Islamic poetic works which again exposes the later Islamic tradition. Thanks brother.

    • @jaketwigg1065
      @jaketwigg1065 Місяць тому

      You literally cannot produce a chapter like the Quran

    • @inquisitivemind007
      @inquisitivemind007 Місяць тому

      @jaketwigg1065 yes artificial intelligence can chat.openai.com/share/afca5692-b06e-44e9-83c9-8f96791fc593

    • @JohnGeometresMaximos
      @JohnGeometresMaximos Місяць тому

      @@inquisitivemind007 lol #islam #quran #rekt

  • @KabirKhan7_BrazenImpudence
    @KabirKhan7_BrazenImpudence Місяць тому

    If you want a real shock, search up “Lloyd De Jongh Gnostic Islam” series, it’s super dark and interesting, and shows how deep the rabbit hole really goes

  • @KabirKhan7_BrazenImpudence
    @KabirKhan7_BrazenImpudence Місяць тому

    I got to give Yasir Qhadi credit, the man gave up dinars to tell the truth about salafism, and Islam (partly).

  • @hschoo77
    @hschoo77 Місяць тому

    Goodmorning everybody. FROM THE RIVER TO THE SEE , PALESTINE WILL BE FREE, is shouting a lot of people all over the world, because of the Israel - Gaza war. well if you read the translation of one of the scripts , you see that the Arabs conquered Palestine right up to the river Euphratis .... etc etc. That is very interesting, because here you have evidence that in 135 AD the Romans give that whole land the name Syria Palestine. So FROM THE RIVER TO THE SEE PALESTINE WILL BE FREE, means that ????????????. Israel , Jordan en 50 % of Iraq has to dissapear??????. IS THIS CORRECT?????

  • @kamarudinhj.dolmoin8578
    @kamarudinhj.dolmoin8578 Місяць тому

    "Finding" problems in the integrity of Quran preservation... That is what it really is. Quran preservation integrity is far, far more superior than the Bible. That is conclusive.

  • @omarhourani8424
    @omarhourani8424 Місяць тому

    For every hater out there don't insult your intelligence like those who commented below this to think that he is talking about the Quran... He is specifically talking about poetry..a. and if you think Quran is poetry ready chapter 69 of the Quran (the last verses)

    • @inquisitivemind007
      @inquisitivemind007 Місяць тому

      p227 Shady Nasser's Transmission of Variant Readings of the Quran "By creating a database of variants for selections from the Quran and a few poems from the en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mufaddaliyat, I was able to create twenty-three categories of variants applicable to both Quran and poetry. The first important observation is that both literatures *share the same types of variants* regardless of the proportions and percentages of each type in its respective genre. The limitations of the consonantal outline of the Quran and its liturgical and theological restrictions have definitely produced different proportions of the variants from those in poetry, which is restricted by meters and rhymes. The variants which are due to discrepancies in case endings and internal vowels are more frequent in the Quran, and I attribute this to the eponymous Readers’ modest knowledge of Arabic grammar and syntax, unlike the transmitters of early Arabic poetry who were mostly grammarians and philologists."

    • @acethegreat2946
      @acethegreat2946 Місяць тому

      The speaker is speaking only about poetry. The title and owner of this channel on the other hand is speaking about poetry and the Qur'an. Read the title. He's saying the Qur'an has variations and so does poetry, therefore, the Qur'an is poetry. Which is as dumb as saying, "Dogs have legs and humans have legs. Therefore, dogs and humans are the same."

    • @inquisitivemind007
      @inquisitivemind007 Місяць тому

      ​@acethegreat2946 your analogy is wrong: comparing the variants between poetry and the Quran is like comparing the difference between two human legs from two different people. They are both human legs but from different individuals.

    • @acethegreat2946
      @acethegreat2946 Місяць тому

      @@inquisitivemind007 So you agree it's from different sources. One from Allah and the other from humans. Good for you for finally coming around. Jokes aside. I think your problem is you don't appreciate the Arabic language for what it allows. The various readings were taught by the prophet and they are mercy from Allah. Try all you want to muddy it but you never succeed

    • @acethegreat2946
      @acethegreat2946 Місяць тому

      @@inquisitivemind007 The differences in poetry and that of the Qur'an are not identical. The clearest example of this are the rules of tajweed that follow each reading that poetry doesn't have. Which is one of the distinguishing features of the Qur'an. Not to mention the fact that Islam succeeded in the end against all odds. Truly a miracle for anyone with intellect.

  • @dondj314
    @dondj314 Місяць тому

    This stuff is hilarious! So much for perfect preservation, perfect grammar, perfect transmission etc. 🤣🤣🤣 Don't forget to leave a copy of the 📗 on your bathroom shelf just incase you run short of 🚽 🧻.

    • @acethegreat2946
      @acethegreat2946 Місяць тому

      You're brainwashed. Perhaps with toilet water and used shampoo.

    • @omarhourani8424
      @omarhourani8424 Місяць тому

      You know he is talking about poetry.

    • @inquisitivemind007
      @inquisitivemind007 Місяць тому

      @@omarhourani8424 p227 Shady Nasser's Transmission of Variant Readings of the Quran "By creating a database of variants for selections from the Quran and a few poems from the en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mufaddaliyat, I was able to create twenty-three categories of variants applicable to both Quran and poetry. The first important observation is that both literatures *share the same types of variants* regardless of the proportions and percentages of each type in its respective genre. The limitations of the consonantal outline of the Quran and its liturgical and theological restrictions have definitely produced different proportions of the variants from those in poetry, which is restricted by meters and rhymes. The variants which are due to discrepancies in case endings and internal vowels are more frequent in the Quran, and I attribute this to the eponymous Readers’ modest knowledge of Arabic grammar and syntax, unlike the transmitters of early Arabic poetry who were mostly grammarians and philologists."

    • @dondj314
      @dondj314 Місяць тому

      @@omarhourani8424 you know he's talked about the 📗 too, right? Right?... Oh no, you poor thing! You didn't know? I'm so sorry. Not! 🤣🤣🤣

    • @omarhourani8424
      @omarhourani8424 15 днів тому

      In this particular video he is not he specifically spoke about poetry.... You are very special Individual.

  • @MPM_News
    @MPM_News Місяць тому

    The sooner we Muslims realise that we are just like any other being trying to search for the truth rather than having a monopoly over truth, we can start engaging in real scholarship that is not sanitised by fear of free inquiry

    • @almazchati4178
      @almazchati4178 28 днів тому

      It is good that it is being questioned. I am all for it. Keep in mind that there is scant information coming out the sands. The scholarship is murky. If he/she can not identify the source though, a true scholar should say I don't know, not I have not found the source yet and by any means imply that Muslims are lying about it.

    • @shredx81
      @shredx81 22 дні тому

      St John of Damascus wrote about ‘the heresy of the ishmaelites’ in the 7th century. There was an anti-Trinitarian movement where Arab Christians considered Jesus to be only a prophet of god and not also god. There are references to ‘Mhmd’ pre-7th century. Mhmd understood to mean ‘the praises one’, referring to Jesus. The shahada, which can be found in the earliest inscriptions of the dome on the rock built by ibn Malik in the 7thC, is an anti-trinitarian statement about there being one god and Mhmd (Jesus) is his prophet. 200 years later when the Hadith were assembled, the name Mhmd was hijacked and attributed to Islam’s own concept of prophet. But it’s clear that it was entirely plagiarised. I’m glad there is resource available now that challenges the faith. Islam deal with criticism by issuing Fatwas and having its critics killed. No different to how Scientology responds when it receives public criticism. It vilifies people into silence.

    • @shredx81
      @shredx81 22 дні тому

      Just to add. I agree with you regarding truth. I think it is every aspiring Muslim’s duty to seek out truth. I think there are gatekeepers of truth in Islam, that keep information from the ummah. Dr Yasir Qadhi even stated that the subject of Quranic preservation is tenuous and shouldn’t be discussed in public. He goes on about high level students of knowledge only being sanctioned to have access to the information. That in itself is an elitist stance to have, to suggest that most Muslims out there aren’t sophisticated enough to look at the data and arrive at truth themselves. Essentially that the gatekeepers of Islamic knowledge aren’t prepared to let the cat out of the bag. I just think that is appalling. People devote their lives to the faith and are kept in the dark about its true history.

    • @almazchati4178
      @almazchati4178 22 дні тому

      @@shredx81 Where is the reference to the praised one in Gospels as Jesus? His birth is both celebrated by Zoroastrian Magi and who must have switched sides to Herod, when they were unable to identify a babyJesus. Conveniently the baby Jesus escapes the death by fleeing to Egypt. No escape the second time though. Herod gets him. Herod must be really inapt not to know Joseph and Mary with a mortal boy disappeared to Egypt, and forgets about them when they return. You are full of BS. Jesus of Gospels is a Zoroastrian prophet. Has no relation to OT. Even the Pope does not believe your crap.

    • @nutherdisciple
      @nutherdisciple 21 день тому

      @@almazchati4178 Herod died while Jesus was in Egypt, the next Herod was then ruling there were multiple Herods, it is either a dynasty name or a title also.

  • @acethegreat2946
    @acethegreat2946 Місяць тому

    Claiming the reason the Qur’an has different readings is be of human error is a lie, a flat out lie. The 10 famous readings of the Quran have thousands upon thousands of people passing it on. Arabic poetry on the other hand would generally have a broken chain and if it didn’t, it would be like one or two narrators. So acting as if the preservation of the Quran is like that of poetry is a lie.

    • @inquisitivemind007
      @inquisitivemind007 Місяць тому

      p227 Shady Nasser's Transmission of Variant Readings of the Quran "By creating a database of variants for selections from the Quran and a few poems from the en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mufaddaliyat, I was able to create twenty-three categories of variants applicable to both Quran and poetry. The first important observation is that both literatures *share the same types of variants* regardless of the proportions and percentages of each type in its respective genre. The limitations of the consonantal outline of the Quran and its liturgical and theological restrictions have definitely produced different proportions of the variants from those in poetry, which is restricted by meters and rhymes. The variants which are due to discrepancies in case endings and internal vowels are more frequent in the Quran, and I attribute this to the eponymous Readers’ modest knowledge of Arabic grammar and syntax, unlike the transmitters of early Arabic poetry who were mostly grammarians and philologists."

  • @hassanmirza2392
    @hassanmirza2392 Місяць тому

    He is talking about variant recitations of Quran here. You are illiterate enough to understand it.

    • @inquisitivemind007
      @inquisitivemind007 Місяць тому

      p227 Shady Nasser's Transmission of Variant Readings of the Quran "By creating a database of variants for selections from the Quran and a few poems from the en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mufaddaliyat, I was able to create twenty-three categories of variants applicable to both Quran and poetry. The first important observation is that both literatures *share the same types of variants* regardless of the proportions and percentages of each type in its respective genre. The limitations of the consonantal outline of the Quran and its liturgical and theological restrictions have definitely produced different proportions of the variants from those in poetry, which is restricted by meters and rhymes. The variants which are due to discrepancies in case endings and internal vowels are more frequent in the Quran, and I attribute this to the eponymous Readers’ modest knowledge of Arabic grammar and syntax, unlike the transmitters of early Arabic poetry who were mostly grammarians and philologists."