Daniel Franke
Daniel Franke
  • 42
  • 289 058
History 3932 Week 2 The Origins of War Debates
A short, highly reductive overview of the debates over the origins of war, to help students make sense of chapter 1 of Wayne Lee's "Waging War" and their assignment in Perusall, Azar Gat's 2015 overview of the literature.
Books and articles mentioned:
Wayne Lee 2016, Waging War: Conflict, Culture, and Innovation in World History
Azar Gat 2015, Proving communal warfare among hunter-gatherers: The quasi-rousseauan error
Ian Morris 2014, War! What is it good for?: Conflict and the Progress of Civilization from Primates to Robots
Reed Robert Bonadonna 2017, Soldiers and Civilization: How the Profession of Arms Thought and Fought the Modern World into Existence
Lawrence N. Keeley 1997, War before Civilization: The Myth of the Peaceful Savage
Raymond C. Kelly 2000, Warless Societies and the Origin of War
R. Brian Ferguson 2000, War in the Tribal Zone: Expanding States and Indigenous Warfare
Keith F. Otterbein 2004, How War Began
Douglas P. Fry, Beyond War: The Human Potential for Peace
Azar Gat 2008, War in Human Civilization
Stephen Morillo, Jeremy Black, and Paul Lococo 2009, War in World History, volume 1
David Graeber and David Wengrow 2021, The Dawn of Everything: A New History of Humanity
Gerda Lerner 1987, The Creation of Patriarchy
Douglas P. Fry, ed. 2013, War, Peace, and Human Nature: The Convergence of Evolutionary and Cultural Views
Agustín Fuentes 2012 , Race, Monogamy, and Other Lies They Told You: Busting Myths about Human Nature
Travis Rayne Pickering 2013, Rough and Tumble: Aggression, Hunting, and Human Evolution
Richard J. Chacon and Rubén G. Mendoza 2013 eds., North American Indigenous Warfare and Ritual Violence
Andrew K. Scherer and John W. Verano eds., 2014, Embattled Bodies, Embattled Places: War in Pre-Columbian Mesoamerica and the Andes
Nam C. Kim and Marc Kissel 2018, Emergent Warfare in Our Evolutionary Past
Переглядів: 139

Відео

History 3932 Week 1 Studying Military History
Переглядів 71Рік тому
Some thoughts about studying military history, for week 1 of my War in History course. 1-Why I chose Nolan for week 1 2-Michael Howard's "The Use and Abuse of Military History", and studying history in "width, depth, and context." 3-Our textbook author's, Wayne Lee's, introduction to "Waging War," and the role of innovation in war in terms of "capacity," "calculation," and "culture." Also, "The...
Thirteen Days--They Want a War
Переглядів 287 тис.2 роки тому
A great scene from a great movie. True, it overplays the aggressiveness of the chiefs and the conflict between them and JFK, but it's a useful teaching tool for the history and the policy angles. Note: Grateful to Warner Bros. for permitting me to post this video.
History 240 Lesson 4 Part 4 Versailles and the New World
Переглядів 593 роки тому
The world created by the Versailles treaty, the rise of far-right terrorism, and the political situation as of the May 1924 elections.
History 240 Lesson 4 Part 3 Revolution 1918
Переглядів 343 роки тому
In which we look at the various strands of the German revolution in 1918 and 1919.
History 240 Lesson 4 Part 2
Переглядів 213 роки тому
Part 2 of Lesson 4, History 240 Nazi Germany: "1918 From Imminent Victory to Sudden Catastrophe."
History 240: Lesson 4 Part 1 Treaty of Brest-Litovsk
Переглядів 1253 роки тому
Part of Lesson 4 of History 240 Nazi Germany.
Civil War Lecture 5 1864 and 1865
Переглядів 753 роки тому
Civil War Lecture 5 1864 and 1865
Civil War Lecture 4 1863 and Confederate Chances of Victory
Переглядів 283 роки тому
Civil War Lecture 4 1863 and Confederate Chances of Victory
Civil War Lecture 3 Strategy and Generals
Переглядів 423 роки тому
Civil War Lecture 3 Strategy and Generals
Civil War Lecture 2 Preparing for War
Переглядів 3493 роки тому
Civil War Lecture 2 Preparing for War
Civil War Lecture 1 Global Context
Переглядів 453 роки тому
Global conflicts from 1850 to 1872
History 101 Digital Project Overview
Переглядів 383 роки тому
We focus primarily on StoryMaps ArcGIS, which gives very nice results, has lots of flexibility, and does not have a steep learning curve.
We'll Fight For Uncle Sam
Переглядів 973 роки тому
A video I did in December 2014 during a...Skype call, I think (pre-Zoom), with some friends. One of my better efforts, overall.
There Goes Jackson...
Переглядів 314 роки тому
There Goes Jackson...
Charlottesville, August 12, 2017 #22
Переглядів 355 років тому
Charlottesville, August 12, 2017 #22
Charlottesville, August 12, 2017 #21
Переглядів 215 років тому
Charlottesville, August 12, 2017 #21
Charlottesville, August 12, 2017 #20
Переглядів 295 років тому
Charlottesville, August 12, 2017 #20
Charlottesville, August 12, 2017, #19
Переглядів 225 років тому
Charlottesville, August 12, 2017, #19
Charlottesville, August 12, 2017 #18
Переглядів 835 років тому
Charlottesville, August 12, 2017 #18
Charlottesville, August 12, 2017 #17
Переглядів 195 років тому
Charlottesville, August 12, 2017 #17
Charlottesville, August 12, 2017 #16
Переглядів 425 років тому
Charlottesville, August 12, 2017 #16
Charlottesville, August 12, 2017 #15
Переглядів 155 років тому
Charlottesville, August 12, 2017 #15
Charlottesville, August 12, 2017 #14
Переглядів 435 років тому
Charlottesville, August 12, 2017 #14
Charlottesville, August 12, 2017 #13
Переглядів 335 років тому
Charlottesville, August 12, 2017 #13
Charlottesville, August 12, 2017 #12
Переглядів 275 років тому
Charlottesville, August 12, 2017 #12
Charlottesville, August 12, 2017 #11
Переглядів 175 років тому
Charlottesville, August 12, 2017 #11
Charlottesville, August 12, 2017 #10
Переглядів 255 років тому
Charlottesville, August 12, 2017 #10
Charlottesville, August 12, 2017 #9
Переглядів 165 років тому
Charlottesville, August 12, 2017 #9
Charlottesville, August 12, 2017 #8
Переглядів 205 років тому
Charlottesville, August 12, 2017 #8

КОМЕНТАРІ

  • @thekameleon9785
    @thekameleon9785 Місяць тому

    Imagen carrying this stress.

  • @tommyhaynes9157
    @tommyhaynes9157 Місяць тому

    Curtis Le May was a dangerous man

  • @johnoh7705
    @johnoh7705 3 місяці тому

    JFK got good advice from Kenny. We need more people like that advising our Presidents.

  • @hermanhale9258
    @hermanhale9258 4 місяці тому

    Nobody I ever talked to remembers the Cuban Missile Crisis and I don't remember it. I remember a lot of articles about it, after it had happened and I think after JFK was dead.

  • @michaeljohnson1157
    @michaeljohnson1157 11 місяців тому

    A truly MAGNIFICENT MOVIE 🎥.> I LIVED THROUGH THE CUBAN⭐MISSILE CRISIS. Scared Americans to death...Our Dad and Mom, also. >>>12 Army Tanks from Ft Knox rumbled up our street. >>Dad talked with one of the Tank captains....scary October. Louisville KY. Michael W.Johnson retired.in modesto California

  • @James-nl6fu
    @James-nl6fu Рік тому

    Puts fear of climate change into perspective. Nuclear war was a far more immediate and tangible terror to deal with

  • @Wizard-xt5ld
    @Wizard-xt5ld Рік тому

    Military industrial Complex

  • @peterzaffaroni2871
    @peterzaffaroni2871 Рік тому

    so genius

  • @davidhutchinson5233
    @davidhutchinson5233 Рік тому

    I really feel that if it had been any other person besides Kennedy and his team, the world would definitely be a different place right now.

  • @stephendoherty8291
    @stephendoherty8291 Рік тому

    Amazing they trusted mcnamara.

  • @rynes.rai7er993
    @rynes.rai7er993 Рік тому

    Interesting subtext: It appears he's indicating a micro-managing scenario bc he doesn't trust his CoC. Johnson was widely criticized for micromanagement of Vietnam. He may not have trusted his Generals and Admirals either.

  • @chrismac2234
    @chrismac2234 Рік тому

    This is the one everyone knows about. The one you dont know about, is called ABLE ARCHER. We were all saved by a man called Oleg Gordievsky.

  • @ottohesslein3230
    @ottohesslein3230 Рік тому

    "The Navy won't let you down, Mr. President." Then, George HW Bush's CIA hit team, with the weight of the CIA and the Office of Naval Intelligence, killed him.

  • @PopulismIsForBottomFeeders

    LeMay was always a complete a..hole.

  • @granitesevan6243
    @granitesevan6243 Рік тому

    Ah yes, the famous "invisible hand of the market" that ensured the triumph of capitalism... Hasn't it all turned out beautifully for us as well 🤦🏼‍♂️

  • @voidisyinyangvoidisyinyang885

    R. Brian Ferguson has a brand-new book published! Please cover that. thanks

  • @steve4nj
    @steve4nj Рік тому

    This is why the JEWS killed JFK and RFK they wanted a war out Kennedy resisted,

  • @Demun1649
    @Demun1649 Рік тому

    There was only ONE reason for the "chiefs" HATING JFK. Pure and simple, it was because he was a Catholic, nothing else. The Proddies have no inkling of the least of the Teachings of the LORD JESUS CHRIST, SON OF THE LIVING GOD.

  • @nigelevans8259
    @nigelevans8259 Рік тому

    More American lies the missiles the USA put in to Turkey caused this crisis and the removal of them by the USA in a quid pro was what ended it, Kennedy was a corrupt war monger who only got into power because his criminal father payed the mob to fix the election.

  • @timfox1003
    @timfox1003 Рік тому

    KOSTNER IS A PUTZ

  • @KaiserSoza-lw9nx
    @KaiserSoza-lw9nx Рік тому

    This is a perfect example of Kennedys failure... could not make the tough decesions. Some will say not attacking was the tougher choice. But he appeased the Soviets, and quietly removed the missles from Turkey. Dumbocrat chickenshit move.

  • @Miguel41234
    @Miguel41234 Рік тому

    after this dutton returned to his ranch

  • @peterbohlman3178
    @peterbohlman3178 Рік тому

    looks like the war machine is hungry again

  • @KevinBalch-dt8ot
    @KevinBalch-dt8ot Рік тому

    The Jupiter missiles deployed in Turkey that lead to the Cuban Missile Crisis were placed there by JFK a few months into his administration.

  • @DMR4736
    @DMR4736 Рік тому

    General Lemay, to the other chiefs, "those god damn kennedy's are going to destroy this country, unless we do something about this"

  • @mikekenyon8483
    @mikekenyon8483 Рік тому

    I love how the US decides to impose a "quarantine" as if the US had any legal superiority.

  • @World_Analysis-
    @World_Analysis- Рік тому

    It’s crazy to think how powerful the Soviet Union was from 1945-1980. People don’t realize the Soviets whipped us in almost every aspect of the Space Race. One of the craziest pictures I’ve ever seen in Neil Armstrong and Buzz Aldrin taking pictures of the Soviets Space craft orbiting the moon at the same exact time the Americans reached the moons surface. They ultimately crashed and died. Ronald Reagan and his administration single handedly brought down our biggest enemy of all time. Now we have China, becoming even more powerful then the Soviet Union. In 5 years ever man from 18-32 could be in the pacific fighting the Chinese .

  • @Roogs
    @Roogs Рік тому

    This movie should have been bigger than it was. I have the DVD and play it all the time.

  • @magnuscroify
    @magnuscroify Рік тому

    That dialogue between Greenwood and Costner is fantastic - so well written and the music is perfect.

    • @KevinBalch-dt8ot
      @KevinBalch-dt8ot 8 місяців тому

      Except Costner’s character (Kenny O’Donnell) had almost no involvement with EXCOMM in real life.

    • @IronMan-tk8uc
      @IronMan-tk8uc 8 місяців тому

      Yep. Creative liberty here was in full charge!@@KevinBalch-dt8ot

  • @raymundotorres6905
    @raymundotorres6905 Рік тому

    This film is excellent, very well done!

  • @josephhuether1184
    @josephhuether1184 Рік тому

    Of course the coolest head/hero in this superpower shit show was Vasili Arkhipov. His action is probably the closest thing to a divine miracle / act of God that has taken place in my lifetime. No…God doesn’t help football teams win games.

  • @tommyhaynes9157
    @tommyhaynes9157 Рік тому

    Bruce IS JFK .....he really nailed it

  • @tradcath2976
    @tradcath2976 Рік тому

    This scene is total Hollywood b.s. And Kevin Costner is not a convincing actor. Horrible accent.

  • @kevinrushmere
    @kevinrushmere Рік тому

    I was two years old slept thru the whole thing did it turn out alright ? or is ukraine part 2

  • @World_Analysis-
    @World_Analysis- Рік тому

    Our country and history would be so different if President Kennedy and Bobby were murdered. We didn’t deserve them. These were good men, doing their best to manage impossible tasks. It was only a few years earlier that the threat of the world ending actually became real. Then America goes from perhaps the greatest General and Leader the world had ever seen with President Eisenhower, to a 42 year old young man who fought it WWII, was an orator, and smart as a whip. The eeriest thing about Kennedy’s death is the last thing Eisenhower said to the America people, “Beware the Military Industrial Complex.”

  • @JimmySailor
    @JimmySailor Рік тому

    LeMay was notorious for pushing both sides to the brink of war with recon flights. It’s little talked about today but the US lost over 200 airmen flying missions over Soviet territory during the Cold War. Frequently their mission was to get notticed, so that the Radar and radio transmissions from Soviet air defense could be analyzed. 129 of those men’s remains have not been accounted for as well. People think Gary Power’s U2 shoot down was a rare thing, but it happened constantly. In personal conversations LeMay even admitted he was trying to provoke the Russians.

    • @KayAteChef
      @KayAteChef Рік тому

      I wonder whether it was worth it. Maybe.

    • @IronMan-tk8uc
      @IronMan-tk8uc 8 місяців тому

      LeMay was interviewed in 1992 and by then, he STILL believed that the U.S. should've gone to a nuclear confrontation with the Soviets and that Americans would've WON!

    • @dug8377
      @dug8377 7 місяців тому

      @@IronMan-tk8uche was a disgusting person. You should watch Joe Rogan talk to Oliver Stone, supposedly he was smoking a cigar while JFKs autopsy was being messed around with by military officials. The photographer asked him to stop smoking and he blew smoke in his face….

  • @wtcashel
    @wtcashel Рік тому

    Did you Trump MAGA people see his CPAC speech yesterday (3/4/2023)? Can you imagine that rambling nut job managing the Bay of Pigs!! Unfit to Serve!

  • @markcooper2263
    @markcooper2263 Рік тому

    Break the law mark

  • @minniefantasia-xp7yd
    @minniefantasia-xp7yd Рік тому

    Daca vor trebuie sa și cunoască tacticile și consecințele razboiului

  • @SMGJohn
    @SMGJohn Рік тому

    The only war the US ever won, was the Iraqi war, and lets not count some student uprising in a South American country, I consider it not a war, but a complete genocide. You simply do not kill a thousand people because they want to have a different government and call yourself "liberators" If US had gone to war with Cuba, it would gone the same way the first time they tried it and the second time they tried it, in utter failure. Except this time, the Soviets were prepared to retaliate, the entire Soviet airforce was on launch command and the best Warsaw divisions were on standby to roll into Europe, they had spent months preparing for WW3, the Soviets knew, never trust americans but they sure as hell also knew, they would damn well push them real hard when the americans stepped on their toes like putting missiles in Turkey.

    • @LordTalax
      @LordTalax Рік тому

      WWI, WWII........

    • @SMGJohn
      @SMGJohn Рік тому

      @@LordTalax america won WW1 and WW2? In what sense are you talking about because last time I checked the German Empire literally surrendered after fighting the French, British, Belgians, Dutch and Russians for 4 years straight, the americans barely made any difference. WW2, the Australian army had more combat hours in the Pacific than the US did in the entire course of the war in both Pacific and Western front, fighting 20 000 Japanese soldiers on some islands and weak old men on the western front is not winning, its called "taking the glory like a fat bully"

  • @alcohol-freebeer3642
    @alcohol-freebeer3642 Рік тому

    President Kennedy may have been a corrupt drug addled sex maniac but he stopped the planet from getting blown up and put the two superpowers on the road to figuring out how to avoid every doing anything this stupid again (well, until Reagan came along but fortunately Stanislav Petrov and Gorbachev got us through that lunatic's Able Archer phase). That alone justifies his inclusion in the ranks of the great American presidents.

  • @andrewlancefield3730
    @andrewlancefield3730 Рік тому

    Scary how close to causing WW3 the Americans got and terrible how the covered it up after

  • @pspboy7
    @pspboy7 Рік тому

    Bruce Greenwood as JFK was awesome!

  • @pspboy7
    @pspboy7 Рік тому

    The Cold War was almost more scary just because you had to almost guess what the participants were thinking.

  • @thewkovacs316
    @thewkovacs316 Рік тому

    costner's boston accent is hilarious

  • @billmelvin6446
    @billmelvin6446 Рік тому

    Kennedy seems to have a convenient memory lapse during his recollection of the Bay of Pigs. He forbade the use of naval aircraft for the invasion and left the men sent in there to die. If the CIA invasion had succeeded no doubt, he'd have taken credit for the victory.

  • @andrewwerner2061
    @andrewwerner2061 Рік тому

    I don't like this movie or Kevin Costner in this movie cause it made it seem like Kenny o Donnell was in charge of everything stupid Kevin Costner

  • @adamesd3699
    @adamesd3699 Рік тому

    The thing is that things were actually a whole lot worse than anyone knew. First, a lot of the Soviet nuclear missiles were actually already armed and ready to fire. Had there been an invasion, the Soviet forces on Cuba were authorized and ready to resist it with nuclear weapons. The US marines coming on shore would have been vaporized in a mushroom cloud, and presto you have WW3. The Kennedy administration didn’t know those missiles were ready. Kennedy thought that the big danger was that if the US invades Cuba, the Soviets would invade West Berlin and what happens next? He didn’t know that an invasion of Cuba would itself be the trigger for WW3 aside from anything that happens in Berlin. And to make matters even crazier, I assume most people here already know about the Soviet submarine B-59 that was one turn of a key by one officer away from firing a nuclear torpedo at an American aircraft carrier, a pretty sure way to trigger WW3. The sub had been under water and out of communication for days, was getting depth charged by American destroyers (think Das Boot), and for all the crew knew, WW3 had already started and they weren’t going to die without fighting back. So they were going to put a nuclear torpedo into the nearest American aircraft carrier as a last act. But this required the top three officers on the sub to turn their keys. Two did, including the sub’s captain. The third refused. His name was Vasily Arkhipov. Had he gone along, none of us would be here now. Freakish to think that we are all around today because one Soviet officer kept his nerve under very crazy conditions. (By the way, who the F$!& depth charges a nuclear armed sub in international waters in the first place? Even if they were training-type depth charges with smaller warheads and couldn’t actually sink the sub, the sub’s crew don’t know that.)

  • @Supraman145
    @Supraman145 Рік тому

    Good thing we united against a common for. Magneto and his mutant group of thugs

  • @kyletoppingmotocross8428
    @kyletoppingmotocross8428 Рік тому

    One of the best movies of a president ever made!