Відео

Thank you for uploading. I know that Mr. Czerny did more than etudes, but never heard any of them. This is my first time. Sounds charming

I've been an avid Czerny fan for about 3 years, but today I've discovered two masterpieces by him, both in f minor - this and the 4 hand Sonata Op. 10. Incidentally, my favourite Piano Sonata of his is the Sonata No. 3 in f minor. He was somehow very proficient at writing in f minor - possibly due to its association with Beethoven's Appassionata, a work by his teacher.

just brilliant

Bravo!

8:59 quote from Czerny’s Piano Sonata No. 10 Fourth movement

I like this!

how difficult is this piece?

Hey idiots, Chopin thought highly of Kalkbrenner. His Op 28 Preludes were influenced by Kalkbrenner and Bach. Chopin even dedicated his first piano concerto to KALKBRENNER.

So a 28 or 29 year old touring virtuoso wrote this and every town he went to heard something new and now in 2025 all this finesse and class and wonderful technique of Mr.Howard Shelley cannot make this a Beethoven night nor give this any luster it never had and it does shine but only as well as its music and the brain and creative talenets of Herr Herz could. Stephen Heller and Kalkbrenner and Moscheles are finer composers and has more imagination but I'll have to wait till I see whathewas writing after 1875 after lifeand maturity . did he sTAY FIT I wonder so late in that day and age or teach ?

Heller's harmonies are really interesting here as well as his texture and surprising rhthms . Heller wanted to be put in the highest ealms perhaps? Are there violin and piano concerti and Symphonies . His Beethoven variations show a thinker as do his Pagnini variations & the Schubert Erlkonig . Kalkbrenner and Thalberg too are more interesting than just being sidelines !

Magníficos estudios!!

I have a ballet dance to this song!! Super excited it’s really fun I don’t get to do these fast types of ballet dances very often and they happen to be my favorite kinds

I came across his name in a newspaper from the 1830s and decided to check him out.

Your description on your channel is so apt.👍 That's how I see it too.❤❤❤

He's not shy about those double and triple dots.

The pianist wasn't in the mood to play this

0:32

And we needed an opus 600? Czerny was a talentless composer.

Utter contrivance. Not one moment of real beauty and inspiration. Just copy cat vapidness. A model, nothing more.

This is not music. It is an exercise.

Playing this crap 'with expression' doesn't make it better than the primitive garbage that it is.

Good grief this is the worst writing for the piano - or any instrument - ever. Every note is contrived. Every gesture is cliché. And for 1843, the harmonic language is juvenile and boring. It sounds like an exercise. Otherwise, this is a masterpiece.

The real Liszt

I think this music is very beautiful and should not be compared with music of Fr. Liszt.

Such a cool piece

Thank you so much, also merry christmas 🎄

I love this pianist's phrasing and articulation, very deliberate

I've listened to the first movement only. It's a wonderful Christmas gift!

This is my first time listening to Kalkbrenner, and I must say, this guy really liked fast scale runs.

素晴らしいサロン音楽😊

Шикарный этюд,с очень детскими эмоциями

beautiful ❤❤❤❤

Həqiqətən möhtəşəmdir!♡♡♡

ショパンの影響を感じられます。😊 短い生涯だったのですね。 知られざる、貴重な作曲家の素晴らしい作品の共有を有難うございます！！😉👍️✨

I like the rhythm in this one.

He has a lighter touch than Chopin.

So boring, just hollow virtuosity without any depth. Perfectly to impress the audiences in the salon.

Дякую❤

Excellent....and Oh so Rare......BRAVO from Acapulco!

知らない素晴らしい作曲家の紹介をどうも有難う！🤗🎹✨✨😉👍️✨ 生まれはリストより数年早く、リスト🇭🇺と同じ時期まで長生きしたフランス🇫🇷の作曲家なんですね！😃😉👍️✨ (ロマン派のフランスの作曲家はアルカンとサン=サーンスしか知りませんでした。😅) そして格調高く、美しい旋律の数々😊✨🎵

The part in thirds around 6:28 is so charming. Also extremely unexpected picardy third at the end of the first movement 😅. Honestly think the 3rd movement is the strongest, feels the most idiomatic and original.

6:25 reminds me of some Chopin work, but I can't remember which one. (yes I know it are basically just chromatic thirds). I think the first movement is pretty good, especially the orchestral introduction. The second movement is rather pretty, but not so special. And the third movement, well, it feels like this typical Herzian "style brilliante": many fast runs but hardly any substance. Thanks for the upload anyhow!

God bless been waiting for someone to make this

👏

A boring Hummel

The two pianoconcertos of Chopin are almost 'holy' to me, but this pianoconcerto and the others of Kalkbrenner really appeals to me too.

BRAVISSIM9❤⁰

Чудоаої ❤🎼🎵👒 Дякую

Great Jehosophat! What a totally magnificent piece - revealed by simply astounding playing!

素晴らしい😮👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤