Відео

I agree sparring should be playful and fun mma and traditional martial arts both have advantages all the martial arts are so great to do I get something out of them all

Simply put, BJJ is the refinement of Judo ground fighting, so you're only getting half of the teachings, though it can be argued that such focus helps you to become that much better at ground fighting, it's quite obvious when it comes to takedowns and upright grappling, BJJ is very lacking. Interesting that people are trying to compare the differences of something that encompasses so much. The correct term is "JU JUTSU" which then got changed into Jiu Jitsu, because of differences in pronunciations. Ju simply means flowing and Jutsu means techniques. Do simplified is "the way". Judo basically is Kano taking out the more difficult and brutal combat forms of Ju Jutsu and created Ju Do, a more sport-like form, which he did to fine tune the techniques but also to preserve them, so the practice wouldn't be banned after WW2. (Just like the dangerous arts of Ken (sword) Jutsu got adapted into Ken Do, Aiki Jutsu into Aiki Do, etc...). Traditional schools in Japan didn't just study Jujutsu, it was a subset of an entire curriculum better referred as Tai Jutsu or Budo, which also included many other "Jutsu", weapons, strategy, philosophy, etc... The 20th century brought about the separation of all the various subsets into single entities. So to argue if one is better than the other is silly. It's like comparing bicycling to running, swimming to surfing. Traditional combat Jujutsu with its vast techniques designed to cripple, break, and kill you should not be dismissed or taken lightly. For reference, just look up the Marine Corps methods and where it comes from.

This video to me didn't really deliver on what the title says and what you said the video was gonna be for the first few minutes. You said you're gonna talk about the differences between BJJ and Japanese Jiu Jitsu and then you spend the whole video talking about the importance of training a non-sportified version of both arts, and the importance of sparring. But you never talked about the differences between the two,.

i believe that the most famous form of jjj is called Aiki jujitsu. Supposedly, this is the Samurai style

100 percent agree

Awesome channel. Just wondering what your views are on this type of drilling for self defence? I also train GJJ but I see huge value in this side of JJJ/Aikido etc. I’m wondering how you find the balance between drilling and full on sparring?

Did old style Wado Ryu Karate for 3 solid years, we were tough, extremely fit and always sparring and competing. Then went to 1 year Aikido and 2 years (blue belt) JJJ and went completely backwards. Gracie JJ now to purple belt and also do an MMA class for the same amount of time and the difference is night and day. I spar more and more effectively in 2 weeks than I did in 3 years of combined Aikido/JJJ. I still love them arts and would love to add them to what I know now..I use plenty wrist locks and concepts from those arts, but there’s nothing like proper sparring and testing. Karate combined with BJJ , with MMA boxing and grappling is a great combo.

Well I have a black belt in both arts and. I have to say from my point of view Hapkido is more self defense orientated. Now I’m not saying Aikido can’t be I’m just saying from my point of view. Now I trained in old school hapkido and Aikido.

The difference between sport and self defense jujitsu is in one you are against an untrained attacker. The other their skill level, weight and age is the same as yours. The whole conversation is silly.

Good analysis. I trained 4 years in JJJ and kept waiting for some real randori and less compliant pressure testing, but the style had watered it down too much, so I went to Judo, however Judo was overly structured towards the sport, so ended up doing Combat Sambo before ending my journey in Martial Arts and heading to firearms training.

All bjj including “Gracie” jiu jitsu is sport oriented. If it wasn’t they wouldn’t need to roll at all in class. Judo its predecessor is competition based. Therefore it has its whole existence around a competition mindset. Yes you can use it for self defense but it is rooted in tournaments. The Japanese traditional ju jitsu styles are self defense and always have been. You drill as mentioned in the video to learn the technique and then pass it on through teaching. Even at the end of the video Helio’s quote talks about what your “opponent” might be and how to train for it. Let word is opponent.

👍

Thank you for a good analysis. I was lucky as a kid I studied JJJ for 23 years with a very good instructor who thought it wise drill train and practice using randori. It makes me sad to not see traditional JJJ around as much.

I agree, super important

Who and when was bjj started/ founded

Lol this is reasonable analysis. JJJ is a joke. BJJ helped me alot.

I did train japanese jujutsu in shrinkage Ryu jujutsu style of a master who went to japan at the main temple where this style born. After a couple of months I just dropped, very mediocre striking, akidio type submissions and very stiff and spazzy training partners, got injured multiple times on drilling takedowns. If you want good takedowns just train judo or wrestling, if u want to improve striking just traing muay thai, kickboxing or just boxing. You will be years light better than this japanese jujutsu dudes.

As always they leave out the racial aspect of this case.

I’m a 44 yr old, 5’5”, 175lb guy. I’m a got my purple belt in March 2023. I primarily train no-gi for the past 5 yrs. I trained many years ago in Silat, JKD, Kali, early gi BJJ, and Thai Kickboxing for 4 yrs. Additionally I trained Judo for 2 years during the pandemic. I am currently a BJJ instructor. I have been instructing for a little under 3 yrs now. My day job is human behavior modification. I have 23 years of experience there. This all being said, literal self defense training is just not possible at any real level. Those issues arise crazy fast and just can’t be predicted. I believe that the most important thing about training is the brain and body getting comfortable in very uncomfortable situations. You never want to discover an unexpected reaction or response that you didn’t expect. Like freezing up. Having a 6’3”, 225lb 25 yr old put his knee on you face as he is trying to rip your arm off kind of takes practice to think through. It’s not something that spontaneously comes to you in the moment. The first time is profoundly life changing and absolutely horrible. But the 1,000s time is old news. This is the value of BJJ. It pressure tests you like nothing else can. So someone runs up on you and grabs you in a rear naked choke, you kind of just respond with no thought. My 6’0” 17 yr old son always does that to me at random places. Not a training method, he is just being a kid. Anyways he is incredibly strong and talented BJJ practitioner. If I was in the middle of a conversation I can continue the conversation, defend the choke, escape the position, and start an attack. It’s just second nature. This is how these things help. Unfortunately most attacks are predators looking for easy prey. They pack up like wolves, attack in different directions, all utilizing different weapons. BJJ probably won’t be the best choice in that case. There was a recent armed robbery attempt in Houston, TX on Christmas Day at a local apartment complex. The Robbers were 12, 13, and 14 yr old kids with guns. Unfortunately for them the victim was armed and shot all 3 suspects. That ended the issue. The point here is who could have predicted that attack in that way with children. This kids would have definitely shot the guy if he went all martial arts on them. So self defense can only be trained with pressure testing in mind.

Bjj is only USA .. buth if u take world wide .. its .. not that popular sport

Great Video! 🔥

Would you mind posting another video like this if you have more footage? Aikido footage is just so rare

Very good content! Can't believe, this does not have more views. Actually real world examples

I cross train Japanese jiu jitsu, judo, and BJJ. JJJ is technically comprehensive but suffers from static drilling and not nearly enough randori. Judo has superior conditioning (it reminds me of wrestling) and randori is prioritised however it's sport oriented so the rules of the game affect what is trained eg. no leg grabs. BJJ is also sport oriented and while little details around escapes, top/side control are top notch, not enough attention is paid to areas not already on the ground ie. the clinch and takedowns. I'm in the process of determining what's the optimum ratio of time spent in each discipline. At the moment I have about 50% judo, 25% JJJ, 25% BJJ. If I ever got good enough to teach I would love to fuse them back together to teach a more martial judo more in line with Jigoro Kano's original vision.

Ronda Rousy was Judo. But good video otherwise.

I started BJJ back in 96. I hate seeing this guard pulling butt scooting crap. Work your take downs and throws. I am a black belt in BJJ. I’m have trained in Muay Thai, TKD and love jits.

That's why I like Gracie Jiu-Jitsu, I feel like it gives me the best of both worlds.

I wish people wouldn't speak 'bout BJJ as if it would be the one and only type of jujutsu there is - or even the only martial art there is... Y'know whenever I try to search videos 'bout jujutsu or self defense grappling, most of the videos I find, are somehow 'bout BJJ... BJJ here, BJJ there! Argh! I'm so sick of BJJ!

The shift of emphasis in (most) BJJ schools has been difficult for me to stomach over the years. It’s painful to see my art lose it's fight identity. Sport competition can be a good thing as long as the correct strategy is reinforced by the rules. This hasn't happened and as a result you get Jiu Jitsu specialists pulling guard in MMA. When I walk into most BJJ schools today what I see being taught is not what I know to be Jiu Jitsu. If you want Self-Defense these days you will have better luck finding a classical Jujutsu school that does randori than you will find a BJJ school that does Self-Defense. BJJ schools outnumber classical Jujutsu 30 to 1 now and most classical Jujutsu schools don't do enough randori. So if you are an aspiring Jujutsuka looking for a school and you find either a BJJ school that has kept the Self-Defense principles alive or a classical Jujutsu school that regularly trains randori you basically won the lottery. It shouldn't be this way but it is.

With my entire 30 subscribers and not having done a video in over a year.... I'd love to make a video with you about the differences in "real life" and "imaginary" self defence.

Nice skills level self defense techniques

Great insights! I would add though that in any martial art including wrestling/grappling you must always practice each technique with a nonresistant partner to learn and perfect each move and yes also must train with a resisting opponent to learn to adapt each technique.

Awesome video but i think you're being a little nice about BJJ. 😀

Like ju jitsu self defense demo techniques grappling wrestling technique mma skills

Thank you Coach .

I like your striking videos! I'm currently also researching how to best train and integrate striking with my (mostly GJJ) grappling, so your videos are very helpful for that.

Just start at the 5 min mark for the review.

Silat is amazing. I did it for years. I’m doing Catch Wrestling now. But I do miss it. Silat with Muay Thai is a hell of a mix. I’ve done it all. I’m good. But I learned hard. My Sifu used to crank us up.

You could cross aikidoo with wang chung to make sure you never stand a chance.

Great channel, is Tai Jutsu the same as Taiho? Just wondering because there is Tai Jutsu near me

The spiritual aspect of Silat is not unique. There is a reason why they say Silat was influenced by Indian as well as Chinese martial arts. What differentiates it is flavor when additional mixture of Islamic as well as pre Islamic pagan beliefs were added in the mix. But we see that even in some Chinese muslim arts. Arnis and Escima have Christianized versions. These spiritual elements were loat ir maginalized or watered down when exported to the west. But if you go deep into the traditions of all martial arts, there exists spiritual dimensions. These were emphasized depending on the historical period and socio political context of each art.

Interesting- another is penja punya ( something like that ). Close quarters combat techniques. Done in Malaysia I believe.

Can confirm the efficiency of silat. I have been a long time student of various Filipino Martial Arts, have been a student of Cikgu Maul Mornie for over 10 years, and student of self defence based Gracie Jiu-Jitsu, training with a private student of Rickson Gracie. I find that SSBD has a way of making everything better.

If you're looking to improve your BJJ for self defense, check out Gracie Combatives.

Silat is a fantastic martial art it blends very well with other arts

Never heard of Taiho Jutsu until today, much like (I'm guessing) many people haven't heard of the art of *Hapbaaldo* which is a "lost" Korean martial art that's only been passed on through word-of-mouth, with no books published, no instruction manuals/VHS' /DVD's etc ...

those martial art from asean was develope for military, they love to war with alot of dirty technique.even the sport one cant hold the dirtiness 😂😂😂😂.

Silat is one of my primary styles. I have no use for BJJ. Everything worthwhile I can do with BJJ I can do with Silat and Shuai jiao. Plus my background is heavy into self defense and the Brazilian military rejecting BJJ and the fact that before the UFC the BJJ guys were basically pervs picking up women teaching rape prevention at the Y. Luckily my instructors were combat vets who had a reputation in cqc in the military. I was taught Silat by one and Bando by the other. I then trained with the only available Shuai jiao instructor in Chicago. I would recommend silat

Oh yeah, Silat is awesome and I’m also a Hapkidoist… Awesome combination… I’m about to leave jujitsu also because, it’s too sport oriented …. Awesome !💪🏾

Coming from a JKD background, silat looks a lot like everything else in combat. Sometimes its very difficult to distinguish