Practical Linguistics
Practical Linguistics
  • 62
  • 142 112
THE HURT THAT WE HAD
KATE AND GERRY answer another question in the first interview given after the disappearance of their daughter Madeleine
SFL Analysis of the language used
All conclusions are subjective
Video for educational purposes only
interview source:
ua-cam.com/video/2T6g8h92YJo/v-deo.htmlsi=-0ecNyWWLSPh0MXs
Переглядів: 537

Відео

WE'RE IN A VERY SAFE RESORT
Переглядів 566День тому
Gerry and Kate answer more questions about the disappearance of their daughter, Madeleine. Linguistic Analysis. All conclusions are subjective . For educational purposes only. interview: ua-cam.com/video/2T6g8h92YJo/v-deo.htmlsi=-0ecNyWWLSPh0MXs
GERRY McCANN HIDES IN A HUGE CROWD AND AVOIDS THE BAR
Переглядів 1,2 тис.14 днів тому
SYSTEMIC FUNCTIONAL LINGUISTIC ANALYSIS OF THE FIRST INTERVIEW GIVEN BY KATE AND GERRY MCCANN ( to Ian woods of SkyNews) PART 2: Gerry's first question All analysis is subjective For educational purposes only interview source: ua-cam.com/video/2T6g8h92YJo/v-deo.htmlsi=-0ecNyWWLSPh0MXs
DEAD ON ARRIVAL: KATE TALKS ABOUT MADELEINE'S DISAPPEARANCE
Переглядів 1,3 тис.14 днів тому
Systemic Functional Linguistic analysis of Kate and Gerry McCann answering questions three weeks after their daughter Madeleine's disappearance in Portugal. All analysis is my own subjective view for educational purposes only. ua-cam.com/video/2T6g8h92YJo/v-deo.htmlsi=6S_-EyMPVFeGXuVa
Speech Analysis Flag Words- Comment Adjuncts
Переглядів 33014 днів тому
Hallidayan Linguistic Taxonomy of Comment Adjuncts for Statement Analysis apologies: Qualicatives should read "qualificatives"
SCOTT PETERSON SPEAKS ABOUT HIS WIFE LACI'S DISAPPEARANCE
Переглядів 68321 день тому
Systemic Functional linguistic analysis of sample clip of Scott Peterson giving an interview shortly after his wife's disappearance. All analysis is subjective, and does not constitute an accusation of guilt. This video is for educational purposes only. Sample Sources: ua-cam.com/video/-VGi_HBF1to/v-deo.htmlsi=hZgM7lwLBH1PJvQK ua-cam.com/video/BP15jfjTv1E/v-deo.htmlsi=ONzEDlaIdpY8eo1X
10 August 2024
Переглядів 55828 днів тому
THE RAMSEY RANSOM NOTE- CORRECTION AND APOLOGY
THE RAMSEY RANSOM NOTE- A Linguistic analysis
Переглядів 1,5 тис.Місяць тому
SFL analysis of the Ramsey ransom note. conclusions are my opinion only. apologies for error : correct clause should read " you will be denied her remains', not "you will be delivered her remains." Big difference, sorry.
PATSY RAMSEY'S 911 CALL- A LINGUISTIC ANALYSIS 2
Переглядів 561Місяць тому
Looking at Patsy's use if the word 'the' in her 911 call. ua-cam.com/video/Hss-ncQYZTI/v-deo.htmlsi=qcXQojS2TDhrLZZE
Linguistic Analysis of one sentence from Patsy Ramsey's 911 Call
Переглядів 609Місяць тому
Having just watched a Statement Analysis video on Patsy Ramsey's 911 call, I made this short response. It is not meant to be an ad hominem attack so no names are mentioned, I merely wish to draw attention to the fact that if one is in the business of analysing statements, inferences about deception and truthfulness should be based upon sound linguistic principles.
PASTOR J.P. MILLER LOSES CONTROL WITHIN FOUR SENTENCES
Переглядів 8 тис.Місяць тому
SYSTEMIC FUNCTIONAL LINGUISTICS APPLIED TO LETTER WRITTEN BY PASTER J.P. MILLER TO HIS CHURCH CONGREGATION. EMBEDDED CONFESSION DECEPTION DETECTION ALL ANALYSIS IS SUBJECTIVE AND FOR EDUCATIONAL PURPOSES ONLY Avinoam Sapir Interview, many thanks: ua-cam.com/video/GBpss0rIFuU/v-deo.htmlsi=MpImevhH2OBhsZSX
CHRIS WATTS Writes a Letter to GOD- A Linguistic Analysis through the Lens of Scott Rouse.
Переглядів 643Місяць тому
SYSTEMIC FUNCTIONS ANALYSIS OF CHRIS WATTS' LETTER TO GOD. Scott Rouse source: ua-cam.com/video/1OYnOcWbsPM/v-deo.htmlsi=43_Ek66i7e7Set97
STATEMENT ANALYST JACK SHAFER'S METHOD MODELLED AND APPLIED TO PASTOR J.P. MILLER
Переглядів 4,5 тис.Місяць тому
SYSTEMIC FUNCTIONAL LINGUISTIC APPROACH TO TWO OF JACK SHAFER'S METHODS OF DECEPTION DETECTION - THE TENSE SWITCH AND THE TEXT BRIDGE. ALL ANALYSIS IS SUBJECTIVE AND FOR EDUCATIONAL PURPOSES ONLY. sample source: ua-cam.com/video/_SRhuC5-66w/v-deo.htmlsi=7cFTPNzZCQ5XRg9Z J. Shafer interview: ua-cam.com/video/BP15jfjTv1E/v-deo.htmlsi=wwEnU8yWYdselMxO
Lorenzo Sewell Tells It Like it Isn't
Переглядів 215Місяць тому
SYSTEMIC FUNCTIONAL LINGUISTIC ANALYSIS OF RNC SPEAKER PASTOR LORENZO SEWELL
BARACK OBAMA TELLS A PORK PIE
Переглядів 371Місяць тому
HALLIDAYAN SYSTEMIC FUNCTIONAL LINGUISTIC MODEL APPLIED TO SPEECH SAMPLE FROM BARACK OBAMA. PORK PIES DETECTED.
STRONG MAGIC SHOULD BE HANDLED WITH CARE
Переглядів 432Місяць тому
STRONG MAGIC SHOULD BE HANDLED WITH CARE
SKY NEWS; " JAY SLATER FRIEND LUCY LAW makes EMOTIONAL statement" : A Linguistic Analysis
Переглядів 14 тис.Місяць тому
SKY NEWS; " JAY SLATER FRIEND LUCY LAW makes EMOTIONAL statement" : A Linguistic Analysis
STEPHAN STERNS' EMAILS FROM JAIL 3
Переглядів 771Місяць тому
STEPHAN STERNS' EMAILS FROM JAIL 3
STEPHAN STERNS' EMAILS FROM JAIL 2
Переглядів 609Місяць тому
STEPHAN STERNS' EMAILS FROM JAIL 2
Stephan Sterns' Emails from Jail 1
Переглядів 662Місяць тому
Stephan Sterns' Emails from Jail 1
Statement Analysis meets Linguistics meets Joe Biden.
Переглядів 353Місяць тому
Statement Analysis meets Linguistics meets Joe Biden.
Mark McClish Applied to Donald Trump
Переглядів 452Місяць тому
Mark McClish Applied to Donald Trump
Jill Biden Reassures Voters that Joe's All In - An English Perspective
Переглядів 300Місяць тому
Jill Biden Reassures Voters that Joe's All In - An English Perspective
Lucy Mae GoFundMe - A Linguistic Perspective
Переглядів 7 тис.2 місяці тому
Lucy Mae GoFundMe - A Linguistic Perspective
An Answer to Pat Brown- Why is The Zodiac The Zodiac?
Переглядів 3682 місяці тому
An Answer to Pat Brown- Why is The Zodiac The Zodiac?
Rex Heuermann- Embedded Confession / Delight- Linguistic Analysis of the Furniture Talk
Переглядів 6213 місяці тому
Rex Heuermann- Embedded Confession / Delight- Linguistic Analysis of the Furniture Talk
P DIDDY Tells a Bedtime Story
Переглядів 5553 місяці тому
P DIDDY Tells a Bedtime Story
KOURI RICHINS exposes herself on TV- 2
Переглядів 4523 місяці тому
KOURI RICHINS exposes herself on TV- 2
KOURI RICHINS Exposes herself on Good Things Utah
Переглядів 5193 місяці тому
KOURI RICHINS Exposes herself on Good Things Utah
STEPHAN STERNS Police Interview 3
Переглядів 6393 місяці тому
STEPHAN STERNS Police Interview 3

КОМЕНТАРІ

  • @TheTruthDetector
    @TheTruthDetector 11 годин тому

    And he was driving with a body whose life had ended

  • @Itsnotthatserious2023
    @Itsnotthatserious2023 День тому

    kingdom of darkness he serves! He was a big movie watcher, he told about couple movies he an she watched . What about a movie the newer bond movies are possibility a agent the guy who get in trees to spy on the ex wife using light that he shines lazar like she wrote in her court filed documents. The man, he has been a person who is at home one way an in the public or the places they go now she has to watch a pastor who supposed to be a double agent kinna says, you are a hyppocrite a hypocrite jp,, that is what she more than likely was calling him but the way he thinks of his own reputation even saying that was bad look for him so, a double agent he choses to tell a hallf truth . I think he being a hypocrite sounded like a word he heard as a statment he has put out before jp was a pastor, he used to think churches they were for he saaid, people who are one way there in house an a diffrent way in the church . They are words he shared think on his bio or the before he became a christian even or had started solid rock, he has been exsposed to be part of the bar , piano bar in croc rocks he an his friend in church both secretly were double minded an she was finding out finacial crimes an being told her getting the school plans together , he was telling her they did not have the money the moneys very much coming in by the cars an the material spending he was doing in the efforts to really have the Afrixa misson trip her looking at the money was the begining of the end the man, he tried to discourage her off the subject but unable to have her drop the Africa topic of hher new intrest in searching through who knwws all she was uncovering the root of evil is money an he has no love for her, God, he sees none of the 5 kids he has w ex an she has them , He seems to be with suszie as the alibi while they are going to see kids play soccer that day when he is not a dad , he shows the effort of all days in kids sports on day her body was found well, how convienient for him an the other widow . I think the man killed her an it will be eventually changed to murder,

  • @zugzwang2007
    @zugzwang2007 4 дні тому

    I am not sure your final inference from the "or not" coda is actually the right one. His seething anger could so easily be generated by the true story being that there was an overnight accident when they were, indeed, otherwise engaged in bed next door and that this accident arose from sedation for which he held his wife responsible, and he resents having to represent himself as having irresponsibly been in the Tapas Bar (not having paid for child surveillance). So the guilt arises from a different direction, not actually connected with doing the things that the question implies. And, if they were in the other room, they wouldn't have engaged the child care, would they?

  • @zugzwang2007
    @zugzwang2007 4 дні тому

    Fascinating analysis. As a lay reader, I find the problem with the first yellow clause is functional; the trouble is that it is an excuse. She is trying to represent it as a piece of contextual knowledge that the audience has, and also to use it as an some sort of situational descriptor: " I was doing these checks every 7 minutes, being very conscientious, and I found she was missing the third time I went in". Once the vagueness of the adverb ("regularly") is replaced by something concrete, we can see how feeble this is, both as a description and as an excuse (it would only be a good excuse if the checking were not only regular but hyper-frequent). But it is not a complete failure as a perfunctory answer to the question; her story is that she was checking regularly and it was the doing of this checking that led to the discovery (although, of course, the purpose of the checking was to forestall there being anything to discover). She doesn't, as remarked, actually want to tell us what she saw or heard, or smelt, or about feeling the temperature of the bed clothes, although these too would be answers to the question, construed as seeking information about how the discovery was for her, rather than about how it unfolded. She alludes to how it might have felt, but without telling us what it was like.

  • @HollySAWBONESSumpter
    @HollySAWBONESSumpter 5 днів тому

    I hear "riding herd over 'em". 'Em=them

  • @riac5388
    @riac5388 6 днів тому

    Thank you for this video, it was very informative

  • @mariemiles7287
    @mariemiles7287 6 днів тому

    The behaviour panel said they're innocent, and deceptive detective said they're guilty. All of them are experts, so i have no idea what to believe x

  • @retroactivejealousy-worldl1805
    @retroactivejealousy-worldl1805 6 днів тому

    Yes, as Chase Hughes puts it, there is a,“Vanishing Perpetrator”.

    • @Plingu698
      @Plingu698 6 днів тому

      @retroactivejealousy-worldl1805 okay. I am not sure that he said that about the McCanns, though. I think the behaviour panel covered this very interview and gave Kate and Gerry the all clear!

    • @retroactivejealousy-worldl1805
      @retroactivejealousy-worldl1805 6 днів тому

      @@Plingu698 Yes, that really surprised me

  • @BeijingBuzzz-China-Travel
    @BeijingBuzzz-China-Travel 7 днів тому

    Incisive - amazing how quick one can get to the truth from language.

  • @csanderson-ey5ep
    @csanderson-ey5ep 7 днів тому

    hes NOT a pstr hes as fake as fake can be seems to me hes a CULT leader and is impersonating to be a man of God to cover up for all the EVIL he has bn saying and doing

  • @lisasimon5498
    @lisasimon5498 7 днів тому

    ...and the analysts would also say, 'when your child is missing, you don't care about criticism about yourself, only what the child may be experiencing.'

  • @lisasimon5498
    @lisasimon5498 7 днів тому

    Also, "the hurt we HAD," in the past tense. Behavior and statement analysts would say, 'they've already processed her death' by using the past tense.

    • @Plingu698
      @Plingu698 6 днів тому

      @@lisasimon5498 that's a good way to say it

    • @zugzwang2007
      @zugzwang2007 3 дні тому

      Not only that (but, because it is a past definite) they NO LONGER HAVE IT. They are fine now (ie at the time of speaking) and relentlessly looking forward.

  • @valleygirl2530
    @valleygirl2530 7 днів тому

    I’m sadly behind in my viewing of your amazing videos. These all about McCanns language are bombshells and are very illuminating. I’m wondering if you could explain the language of the recent interview of Kamala Harris and Walz? It all sent up red flags for me. Consistent failures to answer directly the basic questions put to them especially Walz who likes to tap dance around the question. They both did a lot of sidestepping. Wow. (For example - I’ve made this one up): “how will you handle the devastating storms that are coming?” Answer by Walz “ Everyone has seen the flooding and folks out there without a place to live - I once authored a bill to provide new rowboats to the victims.” That was an example I made up but it sounds like Walz. I don’t know what he said after he said it !! After each question by the interviewer I expected a real response - (all 3 were seated at a table in a very recent televised interview. Please let me know if it’s something you want to discuss and I’ll send you the link. Thanks for all you do! You are Amazing!

    • @Plingu698
      @Plingu698 7 днів тому

      @@valleygirl2530 hey Valleygirl, you are too kind! I did watch it but I will finish the McCann interview before doing anything else. The best word that came out of it for me was " schlub". Ben Shapiro saying something like, " you are a presidential candidate doing an interview- who's that schlub with you?"

  • @kaminoire4910
    @kaminoire4910 7 днів тому

    I was so shocked forgot to thank you about your great analysis! Your squeezing out every drop you get from this few words 😊

  • @kaminoire4910
    @kaminoire4910 7 днів тому

    ‘Trying to do everything in our power” reminds me of a doctor trying everything to reanimate someone but failed. OMG 😦

    • @Plingu698
      @Plingu698 7 днів тому

      @kaminoire4910 yes. I thought that too. ' trying to get her back' is very reminiscent of just such a scene

    • @kaminoire4910
      @kaminoire4910 7 днів тому

      @@Plingu698 Yes, exactly. Kate‘s words were, yelling towards the restaurant: "Madeleine's gone! Someone's taken her!". I‘m not an English native speaker but „ gone“ is often used, to describe somebody died.

    • @valleygirl2530
      @valleygirl2530 7 днів тому

      @@Plingu698. The use of the word “Try” by people from whom one expects more direct action and words is a dead giveaway for me. “There is no Try there is only Do.”

    • @valleygirl2530
      @valleygirl2530 7 днів тому

      “Reanimate” 😅😅 best of luck with that!

    • @valleygirl2530
      @valleygirl2530 7 днів тому

      EXACTLY! It’s how I feel when hearing the presidential candidates give answers to the real questions put to them.

  • @patriciaburns1033
    @patriciaburns1033 7 днів тому

    Great analysis Bob, that end phrase "trying to find your daughter " is like Schrodingers attempt, instead of Schrodingers cat, as in it exists but doesn't exist at the same time, see ya next time when we board Gerrys blunder bus again.

    • @Plingu698
      @Plingu698 7 днів тому

      @patriciaburns1033 that is a very good analogy . Excellent!

  • @YellowJello57
    @YellowJello57 7 днів тому

    Remarkable insight as always. Thank you again for this free education in linguisitics. I've been thinking about ways to help this channel grow. Linguistics is complicated, more so than statement analysis. One thing that SA has going for it in the context of a YT video is its concepts are easy to understand and, even if you've never heard them before, can be quickly explained in a sentence or two. I'm noticing, as you guide the audience deeper into Hallidayan Linguistics, it gets harder for a newcomer to easily grasp concepts that have been introduced and explained in earlier videos. It's like - if you haven't done the previously required viewing, some things in this video might not make sense. I'd bet you've been thinking about this too. I wonder if there's a way you can think of to quickly summarise each specific technique or facet of the analysis so that every video can stand alone, even for a new viewer? It might be impossible to do so without compromising your craft. If it were possible, it would make your videos even more accessible and hopefully help them get the numbers of views I think they deserve. Just a thought. I'm sure it's already occurred to you. Sorry to bang on. Keep up the stellar work, I always look forward to the new video.

    • @Plingu698
      @Plingu698 7 днів тому

      @YellowJello57 I appreciate your feedback, yellow. I'll try to make things more accessible without being repetitive.

    • @valleygirl2530
      @valleygirl2530 7 днів тому

      I think viewers are responsible for their own catching up as it takes a personal intention to learn. As in a classroom where the students who have fallen behind are not allowed to slow down the ones who have kept up. It’s a tough world and this generous man appears to know what he’s doing - I don’t think he’s greedy for any and all potential viewers. People learn at their own pace and commitment.

    • @valleygirl2530
      @valleygirl2530 7 днів тому

      @@Plingu698. You are doing everything Right so please don’t change anything for the rest of the world!! “Those who can - Do. Those who can’t - won’t.” Tough world.

  • @KristyLeandra
    @KristyLeandra 7 днів тому

    Great analysis..thank you!!

    • @Plingu698
      @Plingu698 7 днів тому

      @@KristyLeandra you're welcome!

  • @srsly5570
    @srsly5570 7 днів тому

    Your analyses of the McCanns interviews is so good. Please do more.

  • @johnmorgun9961
    @johnmorgun9961 7 днів тому

    Maybe Jerry got tired with all the interviews. He tries to say the right thing. Very interesting.

  • @RosieLooks
    @RosieLooks 7 днів тому

    Your content is my favorite of all. I'm always looking for a new video from you and click on it the moment I see it. Thanks for sharing your brain with us. You are brilliant.

    • @Plingu698
      @Plingu698 7 днів тому

      that's too kind! thanks, Rosie

    • @valleygirl2530
      @valleygirl2530 7 днів тому

      Sharing his brain? If only more people were so inclined. Americans appear to have misplaced their brains these days. I’m scared.

  • @penelopehughes-jones5265
    @penelopehughes-jones5265 7 днів тому

    Magnificent analysis as always, Bob. Huge thanks, it’s absolutely fascinating. I did study English but (I don’t know if it’s ADHD or Dyslexia or what) I’ve never been able to remember the parts of speech etc, much like I can’t keep numbers in order. I’m saying this because even with my basic understanding of statement analysis I’d come to similar conclusions but to take it apart to this level is just so helpful and interesting…maybe I’ll finally remember the tricky stuff! Also I don’t really bother with body language but that massive blink Gerry does when he says the word, ‘back’, as in, ‘get your daughter back’, is hard to ignore. It’s not even a blink, it’s more like he can’t bear to look at the thought of *you* getting her back. Sorry for long post but just to add I saw this update from the McCanns and thought you might be interested: “It’s 17 years since Madeleine was taken from us. It’s hard to even say that number without shaking our heads in disbelief. Whilst we are fortunate in many ways and able to live a relatively normal and enjoyable life now, the ‘living in limbo’ is still very unsettling. And the absence still aches. “Your support continues to encourage us and bolsters our strength to keep going. We know the love and hope for Madeleine and the will to find her, even after so many years, remains, and we are truly thankful for that. Thank you again for remembering Madeleine and all missing children.” They just can’t say it, can they? Thanks as always Bob, I mean massive, giant thanks.🙏❤️🙏

    • @Plingu698
      @Plingu698 7 днів тому

      @@penelopehughes-jones5265 hi Penelope, I don't mind long comments at all! I wonder if 'get [...] daughter back' is borrowed from experiential knowledge - a memory of a resuscitation attempt? I'll give back and look at the blink.

    • @penelopehughes-jones5265
      @penelopehughes-jones5265 7 днів тому

      @@Plingu698 Ah…good thought, that makes sense. Something terrifying. I can’t imagine that terror…I feel empathy for them, even if Gerry is, to be honest, repellent. I wouldn’t wish what happened on anyone, whatever mistakes or bad decisions they made, even with the cash they’ve made from it, I’m still sorry for them, grateful not to approach that situation and of course sorry most for Madeleine. Thanks again Bob.

    • @valleygirl2530
      @valleygirl2530 7 днів тому

      @@penelopehughes-jones5265. They get zero empathy or sympathy from me. They’ve lied for years and taken money and fame that were undeserved. It’s called GRIFTING.

  • @mmcmiddlechild
    @mmcmiddlechild 7 днів тому

    Can I ask you if you have a beginner’s guide/checklist? I’m very fond of word-smithing, and I love statement analysis, this level of linguistic-analysis has me a little at sea, because, as a native speaker, I haven’t studied the intricacies of that which I do naturally. Is there a beginner’s guide that you’d recommend? This is a fascinating arena.

    • @Plingu698
      @Plingu698 7 днів тому

      @@mmcmiddlechild the best book is " An introduction to functional grammar " by MAK Halliday, which sets out the 'system' , but if this is too technical, which it is for a beginner, there is another book called , 'The explorer's guide to Functional Grammar" ( I think that's the title). I don't know if it is still in print but it is good if you can get it because it explains some of the key ideas for someone without any prior knowledge of linguistics.

    • @mmcmiddlechild
      @mmcmiddlechild 7 днів тому

      @@Plingu698 thank you so much! There’s probably a decent audience online for a course, if you have a system to teach this. 🙏🏻

    • @Plingu698
      @Plingu698 7 днів тому

      @@mmcmiddlechild I'll bear that in mind, thanks.

    • @valleygirl2530
      @valleygirl2530 7 днів тому

      @@mmcmiddlechild. Actually you’ll learn by osmosis if you keep watching this channel. It’s like learning a language after being dropped in a foreign country.

    • @BeijingBuzzz-China-Travel
      @BeijingBuzzz-China-Travel 7 днів тому

      @@valleygirl2530 Osmosis is awesome. but actually, you, keep, like and dropped are not so good.

  • @gillianlaing1073
    @gillianlaing1073 7 днів тому

    Hi Bob, Hurt that we had !!!! What about now!!! Strange thing to say, sounds that they have gotten over their daughter very quickly 😮

    • @Plingu698
      @Plingu698 7 днів тому

      @gillianlaing1073 Yes. Three weeks might be enough time to come to terms with an accident, but the hurt of a missing child would grind on forever

  • @annette2326
    @annette2326 7 днів тому

    You are right on this! I'm glad that my American sense of outrage at this idiot CP, can be discerned by people from other countries and backgrounds. A cowardly bully (sadist) can be unmasked by his "no way out" planning in ANY language. He bullies women and children. Married 8 times? You'd raise your son with THAT organism. I think the language represents the military background of CP. But Sébastien is not a soldier. He's a little boy with no one to depend on.

  • @Arcticnick
    @Arcticnick 7 днів тому

    As non-career criminals, the McCann's certainly do not know how to lie.

    • @valleygirl2530
      @valleygirl2530 7 днів тому

      Like politicians who want to be elected.

    • @Arcticnick
      @Arcticnick 7 днів тому

      @@valleygirl2530 Great comparison.

  • @radish848
    @radish848 7 днів тому

    Please examine John Paul Miller.

  • @radish848
    @radish848 7 днів тому

    " what's done is done" To me this means, this demons did something Horrific to this sweet innocent child.

  • @LeilaJane
    @LeilaJane 7 днів тому

    Yessss 🎉

  • @stuungar3390
    @stuungar3390 7 днів тому

    Brilliant as usual. The depth of analysis to a simple statement is astounding.

  • @penelopehughes-jones5265
    @penelopehughes-jones5265 7 днів тому

    Yaaaaaaaaay!🙏🥳🙏

  • @user-ul8ow6xj3u
    @user-ul8ow6xj3u 7 днів тому

    Yeah! Another video!!! You spoil us, Bob! ❤ Thank you!! I would love you to analyse the priest next-please!

    • @Plingu698
      @Plingu698 7 днів тому

      hi sophie, yes, that sounds interesting. i'll look for it.

    • @user-ul8ow6xj3u
      @user-ul8ow6xj3u 6 днів тому

      @@Plingu698 please do so! He is called father Haynes hubbard.

  • @MT-dd2rb
    @MT-dd2rb 7 днів тому

    Insightful. “What’s done is done” feeling- only 3 weeks after the disappearance. One also wonders why Kate refused to answer 43 questions from the police. Many red flags. Thank you for your analysis!

  • @MeatyPeach
    @MeatyPeach 8 днів тому

    As other commenters have said, “The Enemy” is basically saying the devil made me do it. There is lots of religious chatter - at the moment especially now as so many aspects of life feel uncertain - that humans as a species are facing spiritual warfare and it’s a battle and you need to stay alert and righteous so the enemy can’t accidentally take you over and use you for their goals….which are not clear to me. I respect most religions and beliefs systems and am not trying to categorically criticize any of them. There are many Christian beliefs and traditions that people have found helpful for thousands of years but some of the current American rhetoric is basically a call to hysteria. It also preys on people who are struggling because a call to arms where it’s good vs evil makes people who don’t have much power feel like they can do something. So that kind of Christian rhetoric is also frequently weaponized by politicians. JP Miller and CW definitely have being born again Christians who love quoting scripture and twisting it to justify their situations in common. Idk enough about Stephan Sterns to say. It is also common for people who have mental health problems that include psychosis and violence to feel possessed and view that part of their mental illness as a demonic enemy that is separate from them. JP would likely fit into this category given his diagnoses and long history with mental health treatment. It would’ve been further bolstered by the mental health system as it’s common advice, at least in many, many American hospitals to suggest psychiatric patients find some sort of faith to bolster them (it’s even common in self-help groups like AA) since spirituality correlated with better long term recovery outcomes. So for JP, as a second generation con man and preacher who has episodes of psychosis and has spent time in mental hospitals and is also trying to retain power and play politics within his church - the enemy is the devil and reinforced from so many different angles. It’s common for people who are facing LWOP for ending the lives of others to use the idea that an outside force cause them to do it rather than the fact they did something terrible of their own volition as a coping mechanism. So it’s not surprising that CW has come up with this framework to maintain whatever sanity he has left.

    • @Plingu698
      @Plingu698 7 днів тому

      @MeatyPeach it is a deception that supports many others, perhaps

  • @austrianchicken
    @austrianchicken 8 днів тому

    Thank you so much for your insights, Bob. Could you please analyse the priest who helped them next? His name is father Hubbard, there are some clips of him on youtube. All his statements appear somewhat suspicious to me, but I cannot pinpoint it! Would love to hear your thoughts on his language, cheers!!!!

    • @Plingu698
      @Plingu698 7 днів тому

      @austrianchicken that sounds like a good one to listen to. I have been a bit true-crime fatigued lately so I'll wait until I am back in the groove

    • @austrianchicken
      @austrianchicken 7 днів тому

      @@Plingu698 Yeah, sure! Take your time.. true crime is exhausting. I love any videos you put out there!

    • @Plingu698
      @Plingu698 7 днів тому

      @@austrianchicken thanks. You keep me going

  • @nickjenkins6905
    @nickjenkins6905 8 днів тому

    Brilliant analysis and explanation Bob - I love the way you systematically unpick it all. I think the average person, lacking your knowledge and skill, can also tell that the language is off and deceptive in nature though - the brain is an extraordinary supercomputer and can process things at an unconscious level without the person understanding why they have come to a particular conclusion.

    • @Plingu698
      @Plingu698 7 днів тому

      That's true. Something 'smells fishy' before you work out why

  • @markcheeseman419
    @markcheeseman419 8 днів тому

    She said 'I drove around hysterical looking for him', had a three way phone call with Chris and the Police, Chris said law enforcement are on their way to the house so... 'I ran back... I mean, drove back to the house'. It's deceptive. She also said 'it was really dark that night... uh and every night'. That night! Another mistake she said 'when I woke him up for school he wasn't there'. Her grammar is all over the place throughout her whole story telling and narrative building from all the cognitive overload. The same with Chris. It's looking likely now that something transpired the night before. Was there an altercation. Was Chris there? Coincidentally at the same time this boy goes missing Chris appears with several abrasions and lacerations on both of his forearms that look remarkably like human bite marks or nail marks. Which he claimed came from the dogs. Which is weird that multiple dogs made same marks independently but in the same place at the same time. If he had said "the dog" and not "the dogs." Maybe it's possible.

  • @geoffeverson5411
    @geoffeverson5411 9 днів тому

    Excellent work! The PR officer from the Government was Clarence Mitchell not Max Clifford btw.

    • @Arcticnick
      @Arcticnick 8 днів тому

      And then Mark Williams Thomas, who the Fine Madeleine Fund told me via email is in charge of Operation Grange now, although I don't know that to be true, they should surely know.

  • @PatsSpaghetti
    @PatsSpaghetti 9 днів тому

    Love your analysis of "people are aware..." Very intriguing

  • @austrianchicken
    @austrianchicken 9 днів тому

    Brilliant, Bob! Thank you so much! Two questions: Regarding the guilt that will never leave them and that was very difficult. Could that be Madeleine? Allegedly she was a difficult child and therefore sedated. Second, could "rationalize in our head" point to a fatal head injury that Maddie suffered?

  • @austrianchicken
    @austrianchicken 9 днів тому

    They cannot point their fingers at anyone, because it would ultimately point back at them! Except an anonymus kidnapper, of course! The fact that they never blamed the hotel, or any of their friends is very telling..

  • @kylekaliya1
    @kylekaliya1 9 днів тому

    Can we just listen to it? 🤦🏽‍♀️

  • @RosieLooks
    @RosieLooks 10 днів тому

    This is a pretty sentence. I feel like taking a train somewhere now.

  • @KimberlyADarling
    @KimberlyADarling 10 днів тому

    That red flashing like has me out, though I’d wanted to hear info. Mindi juvenile.

  • @penelopehughes-jones5265
    @penelopehughes-jones5265 11 днів тому

    I know this is a very serious matter but when the part about the smiley faces came up much laughter ensued! You make the point very effectively, Sir Bob and this whole video bears repeated listens. I just tuned in hoping for a new video…but it’s ok…I know you’re busy…sniff!😉🙏👏

    • @Plingu698
      @Plingu698 10 днів тому

      @penelopehughes-jones5265 hi Penelope! 👋 If you call lounging around busy...

    • @penelopehughes-jones5265
      @penelopehughes-jones5265 10 днів тому

      @@Plingu698 Hi Bob!🙋🏻‍♀️Well it’s advisable to relax whilst doing this analysis, I mean, if you presented whilst jogging it probably wouldn’t have the same impact…and yes, I’m hanging around like a word vulture waiting for part 4!😂

    • @Plingu698
      @Plingu698 10 днів тому

      @@penelopehughes-jones5265 i've done the thumbnail but that's all!

    • @penelopehughes-jones5265
      @penelopehughes-jones5265 10 днів тому

      @Plingu698 Gaaah!😫 No seriously, great things are always worth waiting for.🥰

  • @RosieLooks
    @RosieLooks 11 днів тому

    I wonder how safe Madeline would find the resort to be, if she was taken.

  • @Yvonne_AZ65
    @Yvonne_AZ65 11 днів тому

    Wow. Great job. I agree that if it was such a safe place to stay and abduction is so rare, then obviously SOMETHING ELSE happened. And they basically are admitting that. Very clever of them. But you are MORE clever. Thanks for clearing that up for everyone.

    • @Plingu698
      @Plingu698 10 днів тому

      @@Yvonne_AZ65 he wants to eat his cake and have it too!

  • @user-oq8ur5od4p
    @user-oq8ur5od4p 11 днів тому

    Doesn't make it right though does it???? You should have had child care....

  • @YellowJello57
    @YellowJello57 11 днів тому

    This is a brilliant series so far. Anecdotally (as per Peter Hyatt/Statement Analysis fwiw) innocent parents of children who have met with misadventure carry immense guilt for the rest of their lives. They don't typically get over it in a number of days. It's only those with guilty knowledge that feel the need to deny their guilt. If you have a clear conscience, you will be open to admitting you feel guilt. What is done IS done - it's just so final. They know what happened and have processed the events thus trying to move forward. Looking forward to more of these. You're really getting to the heart of things. It's got to be nigh on impossible for anyone to refute your assertions.

    • @Plingu698
      @Plingu698 11 днів тому

      hey yellowjello, you are too kind. I totally agree either way you- the finality is three-fold; it is manifest in all three parts of the clause. Interesting what you say about clear conscience admission of guilt. I agree with that. i am looking at the next question and answer right now.

  • @markcheeseman419
    @markcheeseman419 11 днів тому

    Another great analysis. LIKE & SUBSCRIBE!

    • @Plingu698
      @Plingu698 11 днів тому

      @@markcheeseman419 thank you