Man its really sad for marnie Parents were straight up just bad Neglecting her and stuff I mean i understand rich folks like to travel around and indulge in luxury But why not take marnie with them ?? And from what i think, (from the flashbacks and marnies description) Her father at least cared for her when she was little and nows he's indulged in work And her mother is probably cheating or not giving a damn about her family(like when she asked the nanny where is that child) The house maids and nanny were shitty And her child was a brat too Damn
@@crazylobster-minhaz Also, what about Kazuhiko's family? Emily could have gone with them. Is it maybe possible that they blamed Marnie for Kazuhiko's death even though it wasn't her fault and that's why they didn't bother to care for Emily? Or maybe in boarding school, it was his potential nieces or nephews bullied Emily and they didn't know they were cousins because maybe Marnie lied to Emily about them being related because of his death?
Pathetic? The woman came from a broken home, then lost her husband shortly after having their child, and then lost that child years later after she left home prematurely. There really wasn't much else for her to suffer at that point.
Marnie is Annas grandmother. Young Marnie is a ghost that wanted Anna to get to know her since she was too young to remember when Marine died and be a friend she needed
I didnt get the movie at first. In the beginning, I thought Anna might have had schizophrenia while Marnie had anxiety. The movie was beautifully done. The bigger question is why her late husband's family wasn't mentioned at all? We dk if Kazuhiko had siblings or not. They could have taken care of Anna. And Emily was barely mentioned after the revelation.
The 'young' Marnie in the film is basically Anna mentally recreating stories that her grandmother Marnie told her as a very young child before she died and Anna was sent to an orphanage. It's basically repressed memories that we can infer were agitated by seeing the marsh house mansion that was in the photograph she had as a little girl, as explained by her adoptive mother near the end of the film.
@@souilik2363 It's not a ghost. It's Anna's repressed memories of her grandmothers stories coming to life after she first sees the marsh house mansion. She had a photograph of the mansion when she came to live with her adoptive parents that she obsessively klept with her. She likely had also seen pictures of Marnie as a child in her house while she still lived with her.
If by happier you mean grimly soldiering on after the death of her husband and only child.... She loved her granddaughter - but she couldn't get over her daughters death, and it's not like she was in the best of health before her daughter left to begin with.
Yeah, i feel bad for them too. Cause if Marnie wouldn't be Anna's ahemm they would have been a perfect couple. I think that almost everyone shipped em. Even tought it's ghost like thing
Having read the book by Joan G Robinson, it makes me cringe that people shipped them. The whole point of the story, was for anna to finally feel like she had a family that loved her, so she belonged and could come out of her depression.
@@nothanks1239Yup tbf I don't ship Anna and Marnie, I just didn't like how people interpret their relationship in a romantic way. It's clear in the movie they just loved each other as friends/family and Marnie had a childhood crush too
I cried during this movie, it’s so sad 😢
:(
“I feel bad” might be the biggest understatement ever
Poor marnie
Man its really sad for marnie Parents were straight up just bad Neglecting her and stuff I mean i understand rich folks like to travel around and indulge in luxury But why not take marnie with them ?? And from what i think, (from the flashbacks and marnies description) Her father at least cared for her when she was little and nows he's indulged in work And her mother is probably cheating or not giving a damn about her family(like when she asked the nanny where is that child) The house maids and nanny were shitty And her child was a brat too Damn
Where's the proof she's cheating on her man?
@@rawansinger77 assumption and hints As i said "probably" We see her interacting very fondly With a diff man each time she jas screen time lol
@@crazylobster-minhaz Also, what about Kazuhiko's family? Emily could have gone with them. Is it maybe possible that they blamed Marnie for Kazuhiko's death even though it wasn't her fault and that's why they didn't bother to care for Emily? Or maybe in boarding school, it was his potential nieces or nephews bullied Emily and they didn't know they were cousins because maybe Marnie lied to Emily about them being related because of his death?
Speechless after watching this movie i just dont know my emotions like i was filled with love, sadness, happiness, and millions of thoughts
I watched that so sad i cry so sad
I CRIED WATCHING THE MOVIE 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
Me too 😭😭😭
i loved the movie so much defiantly my fav ghibli studios movie, just weirded out by how anna falls for her grandma.
Марни 😢❤
Music name?
A pearl- mitski
@@zznxx ty
те кто смотрели аниме:😭 те кто читали книгу: ....☠️
What’s the difference?
i couldn't stop crying when i first watched this 😭😭
Relatable But pathetic
How's it relatable dude ??
Pathetic? The woman came from a broken home, then lost her husband shortly after having their child, and then lost that child years later after she left home prematurely. There really wasn't much else for her to suffer at that point.
I hate the twin maids with a burning fucking passion.
Anime name pls
When Marnie whas there
Aw man, I remember watching this and crying like week because of that.
Me too 😢😭
I lov7e marnie but I don't understand the ending is marnie like her grandma ? Reincarnated too her young self for Anna if yes it's kinda weird
Marnie is Annas grandmother. Young Marnie is a ghost that wanted Anna to get to know her since she was too young to remember when Marine died and be a friend she needed
Its not weird
I didnt get the movie at first. In the beginning, I thought Anna might have had schizophrenia while Marnie had anxiety. The movie was beautifully done. The bigger question is why her late husband's family wasn't mentioned at all? We dk if Kazuhiko had siblings or not. They could have taken care of Anna. And Emily was barely mentioned after the revelation.
The 'young' Marnie in the film is basically Anna mentally recreating stories that her grandmother Marnie told her as a very young child before she died and Anna was sent to an orphanage. It's basically repressed memories that we can infer were agitated by seeing the marsh house mansion that was in the photograph she had as a little girl, as explained by her adoptive mother near the end of the film.
@@souilik2363 It's not a ghost. It's Anna's repressed memories of her grandmothers stories coming to life after she first sees the marsh house mansion. She had a photograph of the mansion when she came to live with her adoptive parents that she obsessively klept with her. She likely had also seen pictures of Marnie as a child in her house while she still lived with her.
Marnie wanted to break the cycle of child abandonment. Too bad she was not able to do that with Emily.
You could argue that she did in fact break the cycle. Not in the most preferable way but she never did really leave her
When I started watching it I could tell it was different from the other movies by the same people ( I fogot the name sry)
It's not a Miyazaki film though it is from the same animation studio.
Cried my eyes out for hours after watching this.
My first anime when I first born it took me like a 4 years to understand marnie old and young
Oh damn, not a movie to start with for sure.
Yé! But Marnie is happier at the end... ❤
If by happier you mean grimly soldiering on after the death of her husband and only child.... She loved her granddaughter - but she couldn't get over her daughters death, and it's not like she was in the best of health before her daughter left to begin with.
This movie makes me feel a kind of way I can't explain, it feels too familiar and yet so nostalgic, I love it it makes me so emotional.
Fr
Same… I love it too.
I cried when i watched this movie😢
I only love Marnie
Yeah, i feel bad for them too. Cause if Marnie wouldn't be Anna's ahemm they would have been a perfect couple. I think that almost everyone shipped em. Even tought it's ghost like thing
Having read the book by Joan G Robinson, it makes me cringe that people shipped them. The whole point of the story, was for anna to finally feel like she had a family that loved her, so she belonged and could come out of her depression.
@@nothanks1239Yup tbf I don't ship Anna and Marnie, I just didn't like how people interpret their relationship in a romantic way. It's clear in the movie they just loved each other as friends/family and Marnie had a childhood crush too
🫶🏻🫶🏻
Sad 😔 😢😢.
My name is called marnie
Haha good
OMG ARE U GHOST........just kidding just kidding nice u got nice name😀
Poop ending
💗🙂✨
I like Ghibli, I like Anna, Marnie
I love ghibli tooo
When can i whach the film @@zznxx
i saw that movie very beutiful story
سم الفلم بليزز
Hay un video de mi canal de ella me encanta este anime
Hate them twin maids.
Same
Same
Same
Are there more scenes with them?
@@aidank3237 Properly four.
Don't wanna be that guy but song??
Pearl by Mitski
@@kaleighc138 thanks
It's such a great sad movie,my fav
Name?
@@muslims585 when marine was there
:(
😀😀😀👍👍👍
Same