We can safely assume that the snow isn't over, as we see it snowing when Mrs. Flood is on the roof. This supposedly takes place in the June/July time period.
Yeah well thanks to Chibnall that great mysterious character called The Doctor has been utterly violated. And RTD has served up an awful series with a plot holed ridden mess of a finale. If people liked this, well fine I suppose. But how this mess can be just accepted without questioning major plot holes and feeling RTD has maybe literally lost the plot is beyond me. I mean the major backlash and out pouring of disappointment speaks for itself.
@@lanceuppercut3498 chibnall didn't violate anything, if anything it added to the mystery, and I don't even like chibnalls era but you are such a crybaby damn
The fact that we thought rubys mum was someone important makes it more believable that Sutekh would want to find out who she was, it baited us in the exact same way, a 15yr old girl Abandoned a child at a church, the point is weird they did say there was cctv so maybe only doing it for the camera, although she didn’t originally point when the doctor went there originally? Only in his memories and the time window and I’m left with a question, why does it snow? I’m thinking the time window being primitive it effected her even as a baby at the church the snow she can recreate is time window residue bleeding through time and what is the question Ruby repeatedly asks in the time room? “Who am I” let’s assume her mum could feel that through the time window like a little voice in her head that’s my thoughts
not really because Sutekh has the ability to observe things we don't. We are bound by the show, where the camera goes, Sutekh isn't. We are also bound by things like "not being able to see through dead cells. i.e. anywhere that has life can be observed by Sutekh)
Your love for Doctor Who shines through every single second of your videos and it is a joy to hear your thoughts and watch you express your feelings on every episode. Brilliant reaction channel 🙂
One note I have on the possibility of Kate and Ibrahim being in a relationship is that she is his boss. I'm for them being together, Kate really needs a new character development outside of being Brig's daughter. But can't ignore the power dynamic, so I hope that is addressed.
I think he learned to control the Tardis with sound by the Maestro who did the same thing with their Piano. I love how everyone is like "Oh him too? I mean he died a week ago!" In universe it was like 30 Minutes earlier xD (I reacted totally the same at first though xD) I hope they do NOT make Kate and Ibrahim a think. This would be extremely wrong.
I'm sorry for everything you have to go through, and I just wanna say you come across so well here, and your usual bright and lovely self (the cuteness of that hat cannot be ignored 😄)! There is no judgement from anyone, I'm sure, we're all friends here to watch your reactions, and you being you, no matter what. ☺ I remember you saying you weren't sure how many reactions you were gonna be able to do, in the long run, well look at you go! 😎 btw 'I kinda wish the deaths had hit me harder' that made me laugh 😄 there's therapy you can get for that, probably...😁
I love how kate is going to have a love life, I hope she doesn’t have anymore kids though because that would be a bit too weird. And colonel D’Josey, I think that’s his name has a relationship with Ruby, like the two Manchester’s have a love life. That would be so cute and Ruby could call the doctor ‘my doctor’ and the colonel ‘My soldier’ or ‘My guard’. Like there’s two relationships but different. It would be so interesting to see.
Great reaction 🙂I too had the initial feeling that it was a good conclusion but on thinking about it I realised it didn’t make much sense 😆 . The moral I’m taking away from this is that I’m not going to over think things. BTW Beenie hats are cool, great look 😊
I didn’t like how Kate and U.N.I.T. Was killed at the start because Kate never initially gives up but I kind of get what Russel T. Davies was trying to do to make us feel emotional. I didn’t like how Mel got killed off because Sutekh could have easily chose Ruby and killing Mel doesn’t make sense because Sutekh wanted Ruby. I didn’t really get how Sutekh was killed off so early in the episode because normally the monster goes at the end of the episode but I do also get it to allow Ruby to know about her mother and to reveal her and for Ruby to get to know her more. I really like the remembered T.A.R.D.I.S. which came from the Tales of the T.A.R.D.I.S. which was a nice touch. I also liked how Ruby met her mother and how she approached it. This might be controversial but I didn’t enjoy how Ruby’s mother was ordinary because everything with the snow and the song ‘Carol Of The Bells’ every time Ruby felt emotion. Like if you have that kind of imagery make the reveal of her mother massive like make her the master or something and not an ordinary human being. Overall, I just think the episode could have been thought out more and the atmosphere was just a bit odd for me, personally.
I know! That line makes so much more sense now! It’s always kinda stuck out to me for some reason and now it’s like the puzzle piece fit perfectly into place. So cool!
great reaction, 100% genuine! :) still, first episode was the best first part ever, second was the worst second part ever. it was too easy, i mean is like flux and reality bomb happend, and we solve it with a spon and a rope...and mom reveal was kinda dissapoiting too, but yeah, was very emotional.
Dont change your opinion because you watched other people's reviews. If you think it's a great finale, thars okay - and thar waa yoir genuine response. A lot of people disliked the finale because they wanted Ruby's mom to be 'special', but Doctor Who subverts tropes and that's okay. The point is that 'special' is a matter of perspective - remmeber the Ninth Doctor in "Father's Day" saying he's never had a life like that? It was a good finale. It was a strong season overall.
Worst season finale in my opinion it was good in some parts I didn't like the CGI sutekh they could had just easily used an actor in his original costume and mask and it still would had looked just as sinister and as effective. I thought Ncuti's screaming was too over the top and out of character of the Doctor. The resolution with Ruby's mother was a let down as it was building up and building up for weeks that she might be an alien or a relative or a former companion but no RTD took the soap opera route and just made it a plain girl who abandoned a baby I found that to be lazily written and that's nort Dr. Who to me.
How can sth be ooc for the doctor? every doctor is different or not? The resolution with Rubys mother makes total sense. Not everything has to be a big thing, because WE make it bigger than it is. Sutekh always was afraid that somebody will rival his "reign" and therefore he was "baited" like we with the importance of someone not important only because he and every one made her more important than she was. That is very intelligent to be honest.
also: the snow is not yet solved. RTD confirmed that :) I think that has something to do with Mrs Flood (even if she was not there all the time it snowed) Check the german fairy tale "Frau Holle"
I don't mind Ruby's parents being normal human beings, quite the contrary. But I think the 'pointing' could have been handled differently. The explanation in the episode doesn't work for at least two reasons: a) Louise Mille rcouldn't have been naming her daughter that way, because no-one saw her do it, she didn't communicate with anyone, as far as she knew she was all alone. Even if she knew about the CCTV, she wouldn't expect it to effectively communicate the naming to anyone. If she wanted to name her child, she would have left a note. b) The Doctor initially did *not* see her pointing. He says himself, in Space Babies: "The memory changed". This wasn't a throwaway line, it was quite heavily emphasized. RTD's failure to circle back to that was rather shoddy and frustrating. So I think a better answer would have been -- the memory did change. Louise Mille didn't point at anything; only her memory-image did, and that image was planted there by some entity which interfered with the memory. One commenter, on another review of the episode, suggested that this was the Tardis's doing: Once she became aware of Sutekh's presence and plans, she found a way to interfere with the memory behind Sutekh's back, throwing him a false trail to follow which would help the Doctor defeat him.
That's fine but then he should be writing soap operas not science fiction I'm just sick of companions and their family lives I want adventures in time and space with the Doctor being an eccentric alien fighting monsters and Daleks if RTD can't deliver us that then he should be working on another show.
companions having family and actually character and tension outside of just shining in the screen, is much better than companions who literally seem to have no lives but to just stick to the doctor for whatever reason
We can safely assume that the snow isn't over, as we see it snowing when Mrs. Flood is on the roof. This supposedly takes place in the June/July time period.
24:26 that whistle was used for K9! I think in New Who at some point as well but maybe not
Oh cool! Thanks for letting me know!
What happens to that mysterious traveler in time and space known as the Doctor? I'm sorry to say his story ends in absolute terror. Night-night!
Yeah well thanks to Chibnall that great mysterious character called The Doctor has been utterly violated. And RTD has served up an awful series with a plot holed ridden mess of a finale. If people liked this, well fine I suppose. But how this mess can be just accepted without questioning major plot holes and feeling RTD has maybe literally lost the plot is beyond me. I mean the major backlash and out pouring of disappointment speaks for itself.
@@lanceuppercut3498 chibnall didn't violate anything, if anything it added to the mystery, and I don't even like chibnalls era but you are such a crybaby damn
I assumed the Beast was an evil being that inspired a lot of mythical demons.
The fact that we thought rubys mum was someone important makes it more believable that Sutekh would want to find out who she was, it baited us in the exact same way, a 15yr old girl Abandoned a child at a church, the point is weird they did say there was cctv so maybe only doing it for the camera, although she didn’t originally point when the doctor went there originally? Only in his memories and the time window and I’m left with a question, why does it snow? I’m thinking the time window being primitive it effected her even as a baby at the church the snow she can recreate is time window residue bleeding through time and what is the question Ruby repeatedly asks in the time room? “Who am I” let’s assume her mum could feel that through the time window like a little voice in her head that’s my thoughts
jeah and it shows, how much fans are used to have fan service and cameos etc. i like that RTD chose it this way.
not really because Sutekh has the ability to observe things we don't. We are bound by the show, where the camera goes, Sutekh isn't. We are also bound by things like "not being able to see through dead cells. i.e. anywhere that has life can be observed by Sutekh)
Your love for Doctor Who shines through every single second of your videos and it is a joy to hear your thoughts and watch you express your feelings on every episode. Brilliant reaction channel 🙂
Thank you so much!
One note I have on the possibility of Kate and Ibrahim being in a relationship is that she is his boss. I'm for them being together, Kate really needs a new character development outside of being Brig's daughter. But can't ignore the power dynamic, so I hope that is addressed.
I can't be the only one who expected everything to be undone the second Kate died.
I think he learned to control the Tardis with sound by the Maestro who did the same thing with their Piano.
I love how everyone is like "Oh him too? I mean he died a week ago!" In universe it was like 30 Minutes earlier xD (I reacted totally the same at first though xD)
I hope they do NOT make Kate and Ibrahim a think. This would be extremely wrong.
I'm sorry for everything you have to go through, and I just wanna say you come across so well here, and your usual bright and lovely self (the cuteness of that hat cannot be ignored 😄)! There is no judgement from anyone, I'm sure, we're all friends here to watch your reactions, and you being you, no matter what. ☺ I remember you saying you weren't sure how many reactions you were gonna be able to do, in the long run, well look at you go! 😎 btw 'I kinda wish the deaths had hit me harder' that made me laugh 😄 there's therapy you can get for that, probably...😁
the christmas episode is called joy to the world
Death to death - a double negative, which makes a positive.
I love how kate is going to have a love life, I hope she doesn’t have anymore kids though because that would be a bit too weird.
And colonel D’Josey, I think that’s his name has a relationship with Ruby, like the two Manchester’s have a love life. That would be so cute and Ruby could call the doctor ‘my doctor’ and the colonel ‘My soldier’ or ‘My guard’. Like there’s two relationships but different. It would be so interesting to see.
Great reaction 🙂I too had the initial feeling that it was a good conclusion but on thinking about it I realised it didn’t make much sense 😆 . The moral I’m taking away from this is that I’m not going to over think things. BTW Beenie hats are cool, great look 😊
I didn’t like how Kate and U.N.I.T. Was killed at the start because Kate never initially gives up but I kind of get what Russel T. Davies was trying to do to make us feel emotional.
I didn’t like how Mel got killed off because Sutekh could have easily chose Ruby and killing Mel doesn’t make sense because Sutekh wanted Ruby.
I didn’t really get how Sutekh was killed off so early in the episode because normally the monster goes at the end of the episode but I do also get it to allow Ruby to know about her mother and to reveal her and for Ruby to get to know her more.
I really like the remembered T.A.R.D.I.S. which came from the Tales of the T.A.R.D.I.S. which was a nice touch.
I also liked how Ruby met her mother and how she approached it.
This might be controversial but I didn’t enjoy how Ruby’s mother was ordinary because everything with the snow and the song ‘Carol Of The Bells’ every time Ruby felt emotion. Like if you have that kind of imagery make the reveal of her mother massive like make her the master or something and not an ordinary human being.
Overall, I just think the episode could have been thought out more and the atmosphere was just a bit odd for me, personally.
The Doctor is looking at Mel like her arms are too long when he asked her to keep watch…
Jemma Redgrave To Get A Spin Of
Go back and watch Nine's first episode, it'll blow your mind lol. RTD's been planning this since the beginning
I know! That line makes so much more sense now! It’s always kinda stuck out to me for some reason and now it’s like the puzzle piece fit perfectly into place. So cool!
great reaction, 100% genuine! :) still, first episode was the best first part ever, second was the worst second part ever. it was too easy, i mean is like flux and reality bomb happend, and we solve it with a spon and a rope...and mom reveal was kinda dissapoiting too, but yeah, was very emotional.
Thank you! 😌
Dont change your opinion because you watched other people's reviews. If you think it's a great finale, thars okay - and thar waa yoir genuine response.
A lot of people disliked the finale because they wanted Ruby's mom to be 'special', but Doctor Who subverts tropes and that's okay. The point is that 'special' is a matter of perspective - remmeber the Ninth Doctor in "Father's Day" saying he's never had a life like that?
It was a good finale. It was a strong season overall.
Worst season finale in my opinion it was good in some parts I didn't like the CGI sutekh they could had just easily used an actor in his original costume and mask and it still would had looked just as sinister and as effective.
I thought Ncuti's screaming was too over the top and out of character of the Doctor.
The resolution with Ruby's mother was a let down as it was building up and building up for weeks that she might be an alien or a relative or a former companion but no RTD took the soap opera route and just made it a plain girl who abandoned a baby I found that to be lazily written and that's nort Dr. Who to me.
How can sth be ooc for the doctor? every doctor is different or not? The resolution with Rubys mother makes total sense. Not everything has to be a big thing, because WE make it bigger than it is. Sutekh always was afraid that somebody will rival his "reign" and therefore he was "baited" like we with the importance of someone not important only because he and every one made her more important than she was. That is very intelligent to be honest.
also: the snow is not yet solved. RTD confirmed that :) I think that has something to do with Mrs Flood (even if she was not there all the time it snowed) Check the german fairy tale "Frau Holle"
I don't mind Ruby's parents being normal human beings, quite the contrary. But I think the 'pointing' could have been handled differently. The explanation in the episode doesn't work for at least two reasons:
a) Louise Mille rcouldn't have been naming her daughter that way, because no-one saw her do it, she didn't communicate with anyone, as far as she knew she was all alone. Even if she knew about the CCTV, she wouldn't expect it to effectively communicate the naming to anyone. If she wanted to name her child, she would have left a note.
b) The Doctor initially did *not* see her pointing. He says himself, in Space Babies: "The memory changed". This wasn't a throwaway line, it was quite heavily emphasized. RTD's failure to circle back to that was rather shoddy and frustrating.
So I think a better answer would have been -- the memory did change. Louise Mille didn't point at anything; only her memory-image did, and that image was planted there by some entity which interfered with the memory. One commenter, on another review of the episode, suggested that this was the Tardis's doing: Once she became aware of Sutekh's presence and plans, she found a way to interfere with the memory behind Sutekh's back, throwing him a false trail to follow which would help the Doctor defeat him.
That's fine but then he should be writing soap operas not science fiction I'm just sick of companions and their family lives I want adventures in time and space with the Doctor being an eccentric alien fighting monsters and Daleks if RTD can't deliver us that then he should be working on another show.
companions having family and actually character and tension outside of just shining in the screen, is much better than companions who literally seem to have no lives but to just stick to the doctor for whatever reason