Agree, Felix have many Fans, he so cutie, (只是, 可能, 無評判緣... )Why so low of Points....unknown. Anyway, Felix sing the (情非首爾), Then you know he is really singer .
I also agree that Felix has a beautiful voice and it's only a matter in time when the audience will start to appreciate his voice and singing, very much like William So!!!
I like yr comment, Specially Felix, although he was out, but last night in anotherTVB show, he shows his talent in 開心大綜藝，he looks very happy and positive, in Hong Kong we need this kind personality teenagers,think positively and look forward, 👍
I commented on Aeren's performance and I'll say it here again: I quite like her personality and determination, but her singing skills are definitely the weakest out of all the contestants. 愛是懷疑 is a very difficult song to sing and Aeren did not have the range for it; she was off-key and pitchy for most parts of the song. And while I'm a massive fan of Mag's, I don't think she sang that well either. In my opinion, Aeren's performance did not deserve to win over Felix. I can understand the subjectiveness in judging because everyone has their favourites, but I do think it was unfair to Felix that he was eliminated after what was a very "safe" and "passable" performance vs. a "non-listenable" performance by Aeren. Objectively, I could understand why judges gave a passing score to Aeren because she might have that versatility/performance factor that Felix lacked with his song choices (which was one of my major criticisms about him), but Aeren does not have the vocal chops to be a super star (she even admitted that she's the weakest one on the show). If rumours are true that Aeren made it into Top 6 then I see a revolt coming on. Arguably, those who sing and perform better should go further into the competition. So far Aeren has had more lackluster performances than good ones and I have yet to see the "star quality" in her, whereas other contestants have showed they're in competition mode. For Aeren to be in the "she's so hard working" phrase is not good enough anymore. Last night's results were definitely off putting. But once again, thanks for your thoughtful analysis, Clayton. Looking forward to next week's video.
Every week, I look forward and can't wait to listen to your comments. By listening to your comments, I know exactly the strengths and weaknesses for each contestants. Not only that, I can learn something each time from your comments when I listen to the artists' performances. Personally, I prefer Felix. The way he sings makes me think he is William So. He is such a talented boy. I totally have no clue why he is fouled. That is too bad. Hopefully, he will not give up and keeps learning and practicing. Being a second William So is not far away from him for sure. On the other hand, Aeren is good at rapping in the songs more than singing. I believe if she keeps learning and practicing, maybe she can be a female version of MC Jin, who knows? Again, it is only my opinion. Anyway, I look forward each and every contestants keep trying their best in the competition. Good luck to all of them.
Thanks for the professional comments on the contestants. When I watch this show, sometimes I found that the scoring systems and the comments of the judges are not tangible enough. For example, sometimes a judge said that a certain performance is not good enough and have rooms for improvement, but the judge still gave a green light. Let say, if you need to score their performance, from 0 to 10 for instance, how would you score their performance? Thanks a lot!
I couldn't actually heard what Archie was singing because his voice was so low and weak (in this performance). It was like he couldn't find the right pitch. I do think Jay had helped Archie a lot, not just the performance, by trying to bring Archie back to the right pitch whenever he started to go off by jumping in and singing "ohhhh". You could hear Archie changed his pitch and followed Jay's. But overall performance was enjoyable.
Right on the point about Felix ! The part you highlighted in the song is my fav and his adlibs are very good this time..Agreed with all your comments 👍except..... about Aeren's raps. Her raps was like' reading ' raps lyrics 😑but it was a nice try though.
评分制会更细致看出评判对选手的评价。现在的赛制是只能选yes or no，或者我们可以理解为评审不是在选择选手是否晋级，而是消费者在决定是否购买这首歌，yes or no。这种情况下，假设消费者的标准是过了50分就买，那么10个50分会比9个51分好。当然歌手也要努力上进做到100分，因为如果所有购买者的分数都是50分，那么这首歌就算销量很高，都红不起。
張老師嘅忠告真係好好，15位學員都係良性比賽，各位fans都應該互相尊重其他學員，唔好再惡性攻擊對手
同意
係啦！
@kai ming li 道出重點
係某幾位既fans，話輸左既比賽就係造馬=.=
Felix咁後生咬字清晰 無懶音，無刻意歪音，已經係難得.應對又大方得體
中肯! Felix個度講得好好, 好多人替佢不值, 希望Felix都知道好多人都支持佢, 排第幾唔重要, 將來都會有好多機會, 佢靚聲,上youtube節目又得, 自已搵一兩個朋友開下live都得,慢慢累積下人氣。至於Aeren, 實在無乜大突破, 睇返網上既評語,會覺得其實佢差唔多了, 再留係度繼續受批評(超大量), 對佢都唔好。特別係睇到好多學員都有好大進步時,Aeren真係差不多了。
Anyways, 支持理性討論, 唔好惡意中傷。
張老師評審得好中肯，判決公正及冇偏私， 不過替Felix 不值，佢把聲夠響亮及有力，辨識度也很好高，冇理由被foul, ，希望佢有機會做歌手，繼續聽到佢唱歌！
Felix 係有觀眾緣, 只係無評判緣. 分手總要在雨天點擊率到目前為此比其餘三個參賽者高, 希望他繼續努力💪🏼
Agree, Felix have many Fans, he so cutie, (只是, 可能, 無評判緣... )Why so low of Points....unknown. Anyway, Felix sing the (情非首爾), Then you know he is really singer .
認同
@@jojosun8559 聽咗啦, good song👍🏼剛睇完無線開心大綜藝, Felix同其他學員在節目中玩遊戲, 沒有比賽嘅壓力, 大家玩得好開心
超好聽
點擊似乎係睇人多過聽歌，好吾公平
今次條片的 chroma key 有少少問題，但其實也是我本人夠通透😂
另外很高興見到很多充滿正能量的觀眾樂迷！
都要多得張老師將呢份正能量傳揚俾更多樂迷
張老師父親節快！你有個乖女。我都覺得Felix把聲好好聽，正如張老師之前所講佢將來佢遇到一首啱佢嘅歌就會彈起。我都期待！張老師講得绝對冇錯比賽有良性競爭係啱嘅！ 希望唔好有太多惡意攻擊啦！因為十五位年靑人都好努力係值得讚賞嘅！
等左張老師好耐了🙏🏿好期待你既分析！
太好，張老師又出新片👍🏻
Felix把聲好靚，希望佢繼續努力
張老師既深入評論真係好到位，讚！
超正，依家變左每星期都等張老師的視頻。
me2 😍
+1
+1
＋1
+1
I also agree that Felix has a beautiful voice and it's only a matter in time when the audience will start to appreciate his voice and singing, very much like William So!!!
謝謝張老師的評語，很欣賞你細膩又有用的評價。
我也覺得felix 做得好好
很不捨得他離開....覺得他 deserve more..該有更多綠燈
好期待他跟Katlyin唱 從不喜歡孤單一個🥺
希望張老師可以提議有復活賽💕
張老師係一個好好的評審。由上一集 前一集，佢除左尊重聲夢學員，仲會開聲令觀眾留意到後面Johnny Yim 编曲，percussion, string, orchestra 的付出。張老師真係好全面同細緻👍🏻👍🏻LIKE!
張老師嘅講評好真誠好中肯👍🏻多謝你！好感恩見到有你呢位咁不偏不倚嘅評判🙏🏻
係呀。其實張老師係一個好好的評審。由上一集 前一集，佢除左尊重聲夢學員，仲會開聲令觀眾留意到後面Johnny Yim 编曲，percussion, string, orchestra 的付出。張老師真係好全面同細緻👍🏻👍🏻LIKE!
在亞視星光大道歌唱比賽中，張老師也是十分好評判，來指導各成員，所以他在翡翠台出現，我十分高興👍👍👍
諗返起以前JAC係佢個組🤣
張老師讲得很中肯,我很喜欢老師每一次的赛后评论.
agree
導師激發學員走出他們的舒適區
在導師的帶領下去嘗試及去體驗一些對於他們來講可能年代比較久遠，但對於有一定資歷的歌迷來講值得再回味的歌，原來當年有那麼多好聽的廣東歌作品，我覺得這個也是節目的一大特點，到後期很有意思的一件事情競技不是太重要, 呈現出非常美好互相之間音樂上的交流氣氛。
還有，節目組、編曲、導師們、主理人及學員都非常尊重音樂，喜歡學員的粉絲，在通過他們的演繹，去發現原來當年有那麼多好聽歌曲，很多的年輕學員及青年人不太了解粵語歌黃金時代的歷史，認為Kpop、外語歌係最好，但係通過呢個節目，他們會知道原來以前有那麼多好的，那些喜歡老一輩歌手的朋友也發現而家這些新歌也好聽，點激率比較高的歌曲可通過這個方式傳遞要出來，大家音樂尊重和包容使觀眾願意進入到這個裏面，關鍵嘅問題係有沒有讓大家聽到好的音樂，以往電台DJ也好、音樂節目主持人也好都會介紹音樂給大家聽，但現在的歌迷獲取歌曲的渠道搜尋一下咁一個制少咗一個引導歌曲的中介，帶來的狀況就是很窄、聽咗一兩句沒打動他就按下一首，所以樂壇要有一個包容度。
大家比賽的過程當中是彼此之間的欣賞及交流，讓新舊兩代歌手呈現出不同舞台的魅力，令觀眾覺得非常閃亮及期待，這也是星夢傳奇的魅力！
張老師評語好好，对於喜歡唱歌的明友當中也会學到野。相信声夢15位學員未來会大放光芒異彩。
多謝張佳添老師嘅評語🙏🙏我會繼續努力💪🏻💪🏻
💪💪😉
加油~！
雖然我很喜歡當晚Archie表現，但亦同意張老師比紅燈的原因，講得好岩，比得好岩，呢D真係你們專業評判才睇得出。
Totally agree with your review particularly on Archie.
Can’t agree more. 有專業人士講解👍🏻，好開心我聽得明。
十分認同張老師所說，👍Filex聲線好靚，好獨特，唱歌真係好好聽。💖好期待他在樂壇上發展，唱多啲好聽嘅歌！🎤💪💪💪👍✌🥰
好同意👍🏻 抽走導師們既performance
單獨睇學員既話 我認為Archie & Felix 既燈數應該不相伯仲 p無理由23 🆚 11 😅
蓮的 頭一，二段都是氣聲大，變化少，分數應該少過Felix。
其實Felix點都應該有15分,
@@vvonn9605 s
多謝張老師,我係Aeren支持者,其實我都覺得佢個表演吸引,有佢自己的亮點,可能佢真係將個重心放錯左,因為佢真係好唔夠力度...希望佢黎緊努力先練好唱功~令觀眾覺得佢留係度係有佢的價值
講得好啱!
專業的講解，讚👍🏻
先聲奪人！第一眼Felix 外表普通，但聲音有共鳴，驚為天人。始終年輕，唔夠自信，要很努力。周深都唔係外型取勝，但唱歌演出最重要唔係跳舞，唔係造型，聲音沒有得整容。
Totally agreed with you about Felix voice...please support Felix 🥰
張老師，父親節快樂👨🏻🎉 今日一直期待你出post🤩 因為好鐘意聽你嘅評語❣️
昨晚感到好可惜😟 如果一早知個賽制，「紅隊」唔使一次又一次夾硬留低個跳得唔唱得嘅Hugo， Aska 同Windy就唔使被foul得 咁唔底🥴 至於Aeren，原本頭兩集之後已經唔明白點解佢仲可以留低，「九強」之名，我個人覺得佢實在唔配❗️
學員不被大眾認同，夾硬留低留下反感印象🙃 唔應該被Foul嘅人，喺鋤強扶弱之下，加上大眾唔捨得佢哋💖 更加留有好印象🥰 前途無可限量🌟
張老師的解說及分享真的很有見地，例如Archie的solo中有些拍子位我聽的時候也感到有點勉強，一去到Jay就馬上比下去，真係”Jay幫咗個performance好多”。Archie在螢光幕的表情尚未令人感到真情流露及共鳴，如果係佢性格shy就會很吃虧🧐
很專業詳細的分析, thank you so much 張老師👍🏻
等咗老師好耐，真心希望支持者用心去支持學員，但唔好惡意攻擊其他人。始终，我相信喜歡聲夢嘅觀眾都係愛音樂嘅人。其實，至要成個節目起到朶，各學員何愁沒有自己的一片音樂天！。。不喜勿插！😉😉😉
同意，比賽要有體育精神，不可以輸打贏要，人身攻擊更是不文明的行為。
Aeren已經係youtube被班燥民鬧到傻，Felix輸又關Aeren事，俾分明明係班評審，Aeren真係慘
Felix唱得好好，聲缐獨特，真替他不值，希望有復活賽！
4:15同意felix把聲辦識度好高！ 比如許靖韻係唱得好好，技術好好，但辦識度唔夠，成日聽唔出係佢黎,認唔到佢。
9:28之前幾集felix 的確係冇咁有觀眾缘，冇其他參賽者咁受網民鐘意，但昨天被foul之後，多左好多人支持佢😢
其實Felix 一直好有觀眾緣，唱飛花當時已經好好聽👍，昨天支持者覺得他被foul感不直，所以發聲支持他
@@huisuki210 係呀。飛花，郵差，月夜小半曲 Felix 唱得好好，佢吾應該被foul...🥺好唔捨得佢
其實之前咁多集Felix 啲片嘅view數都係最低，今次淘汰吸粉可能係因禍得福，好似Mag 咁講，幾年後冇人記得你排第幾，只會記得你印象深刻嘅表演
@@huisuki210 但係冇gigi, chaltel佢哋咁多fans,咁受網民歡迎。不過大家知道佢被foul，就覺得好唔抵就幫佢出聲。
@@huisuki210 但係冇gigi, chaltel佢哋咁多fans,咁受網民歡迎。不過大家知道佢被foul，就覺得好唔抵就幫佢出聲。
Very well said !
多謝專業分析，又學到嘢
好同意張老師講 Aeren既rap幫左佢好多 可能評判們睇得出佢既獨特性 但我喜歡Felix多點😔真係有點可惜
我覺得Felix先天把聲靚d但太遲出力。
Aeren聲先冇Felix咁好但每一集都盡嗮力。
佢兩個走我都覺得好可惜的
但係呢個係唱歌比賽唔係rapper比賽咯，9強啦，評判仲未知自己係度做緊咩?老師都話Felix燈數偏低。而且Aeren咬字都唔清。如果唔係斗流行曲點解windy要走。
特登嚟幫張老師條片like
感激你嘅詳細分析！ Felix 把聲嘅辨識度真係最好, 佢都係一塊翡翠，希望喺未來嘅樂壇有機會比到佢。Archie 呢一頭黑馬唱每一首歌都有幾穩定嘅表現，都覺得佢啲 groove 不是由內到外，不過都係一個好嘅嘗試。Kaitlyn 比上一集好，氣聲有改善，但仲未去到爆出小宇宙嗰個階段。
作為一個不是專業的音樂人，始終唔明白點解Felix會輸比Aeren. 實在係R頭！ Aeren 個愛是懷疑的video 99%都係負評, 即係大部份觀眾都唔覺得合理，真心替Felix不值。
我覺得導師都好重要，Jay 可以幫Archie 提高正個表演，有一集講到Janice 要張最好可以表現的留給Gigi . 而呀Phil 係沒有做到，爆發力啲位去咗Phil 個到
係
我都覺得Felix出局好唔公平，但現在又咁多人替他發聲，這一点，己經賺咗，希望他能努力，在樂壇佔一席位，我期待。
每個星期必定睇張Sir嘎點評，受益匪淺🥰🥰🥰
OMG! Felix is so good,why he has only 11 lights.
Felix 剩係上次冇咗個earphone 照唱得咁好已經贏到開巷啦
坦白講，今場佢唔會係最差嗰個，佢把聲好靚，唱飛花唔錯，有時佢把聲靚過阿rock，但佢揀歌真係一般，例如印像
即使Felix只值得有11燈，Aeren取4-5燈就合理
張老師真的多謝你拍片分享專業知識給我哋
I like yr comment, Specially Felix, although he was out, but last night in anotherTVB show, he shows his talent in 開心大綜藝，he looks very happy and positive, in Hong Kong we need this kind personality teenagers,think positively and look forward, 👍
Agree!!
每次睇完《聲夢》再聽張老師的評價,好滿足,聽廿幾分鐘都唔怕悶。另今集最可惜係felix被foul,佢係值得留耐d
謝謝張老師分享點評！Felix出局雖可惜，但可當磨練。從來歌唱比賽都未必只有三甲才能出碟，才能紅。
I commented on Aeren's performance and I'll say it here again: I quite like her personality and determination, but her singing skills are definitely the weakest out of all the contestants. 愛是懷疑 is a very difficult song to sing and Aeren did not have the range for it; she was off-key and pitchy for most parts of the song. And while I'm a massive fan of Mag's, I don't think she sang that well either. In my opinion, Aeren's performance did not deserve to win over Felix.
I can understand the subjectiveness in judging because everyone has their favourites, but I do think it was unfair to Felix that he was eliminated after what was a very "safe" and "passable" performance vs. a "non-listenable" performance by Aeren. Objectively, I could understand why judges gave a passing score to Aeren because she might have that versatility/performance factor that Felix lacked with his song choices (which was one of my major criticisms about him), but Aeren does not have the vocal chops to be a super star (she even admitted that she's the weakest one on the show).
If rumours are true that Aeren made it into Top 6 then I see a revolt coming on. Arguably, those who sing and perform better should go further into the competition. So far Aeren has had more lackluster performances than good ones and I have yet to see the "star quality" in her, whereas other contestants have showed they're in competition mode. For Aeren to be in the "she's so hard working" phrase is not good enough anymore. Last night's results were definitely off putting.
But once again, thanks for your thoughtful analysis, Clayton. Looking forward to next week's video.
Well said. I agree completely
Agree.
有同感
Aeren冇贏到Felix，每個人都係獨立，Felix只係賽制下嘅炮灰，如果真係PK，Aeren輸到傻左啦
thank you for your thoughtful comment. very well said!
情非首爾(Felix + 李克勤), can loop 多幾次, 好好聽.
支持張老師！❤❤❤❤❤👍👍👍👍👍
中肯。
終於等到老師出片啦 👍🤩😍
上次張老師在自己的視頻評價Archie的「黑夜不再來」的時候, 我已經講張老師對Archie的要求已經完全超越一個參賽者的範疇.
張老師對Archie實在太偏心了, 對佢期望及要求不只嚴謹, 在一段28分鐘的視頻裏, 對Archie嘅評論佔了整整十分鐘.
如果我是Archie的話, 肯定會好好感激一個這麼欣賞自己的伯樂.
(最後我想補充一下, 為什麼我覺得張老師對「呃住先」🤣特別偏心, 因為上次張老師都已經承認黑夜不再來是一個good performance, 但張老師的要求是Archie要學陳奕迅那樣去駕馭這首歌, 這是對他有多大期望啊, 另外今次張老師故意給紅燈, 繼續去激發他的潛能, 不見得張老師會對其他參賽者這樣做, 真的用心良苦😃😃😃)
Agree. U like that boy, u will be more harsh to make him growth.
你明白我的用意便好
呢個節目真係好需要賽後評審評語👍🏻
如果唔係呢類影片出現，觀眾可能誤會評判意見 因為觀眾同評判嘅意見真係唔一樣，觀眾喺音樂知識方面冇專業評委咁多，可能只係睇表面覺得好好…而深入問題真係唔係張老師您講 我真係唔知😅
我又以一個聽歌者分享一下昨天四位的表現,這個只是個人意見,可能寫得長一點,可能分開寫慢慢寫。以Felix所唱學友的歌,其實,唱一些經典舊歌,跟我上次說一樣,除非你的版本好特別,好壓場,你就是歌者,否則,先入為主會使一個參賽的表演成為敗筆,回說Felix,是的,他有一把特別的聲,好輕,這個特別帶有一種震音,其實他唱每句歌詞時都帶有震音,這個是他個人唱歌出來的事實(outcome就是這樣),個人意見,雖然是特別,但相信這樣的唱腔市場真的有限,如果回顧他每一集的表現,其實變化真的不大,可能太年輕,未能練出一個腔可以帶出能量power,要成為一個吸引人入耳,其實得一把靚聲而未能擁有其實唱腔可出現聲音的變化,真係會悶,因為辨識度有限、層次感也會缺欠,這個就是我覺得Rock的問題,如以靚聲計Felix也在Rock之上,但就是欠了一些東西,由於年輕,這些東西應可練到,到時應有一番成就。而分手總要在雨天,就是看歌名,應該有一種淒慘的感覺,太平淡的唱腔,無論你有幾好編排、好拍子....等等,仍然未能唱出這個味道,更加很難要比分評審覺得隻唱你own咗而忘記了學友的版本,其實我也覺得林奕匡也唱不到這個味道,雖然他是一個很好歌手,所以個人覺得Felix是欠了一些東西也包括未夠放,如果經驗更多,更熟練應會好好多。多說一個有關辨識度及層次感歌手的比較,以李克勤和E神比較,當年開始時比較喜歡李克勤,但之後E神的受歡迎程度更一目了然,喜歡克勤就是他的靚聲、他好聽的歌曲,其實仍覺得他不錯,但我明白為何E神更利害,我發現李克勤每次演繹的方法及聲音處理比較單一,有嘗試改變,但萬變不其離中,唱腔是好有水準,但真係唔modern,E神呢,真係有幾把聲,又可玩鼻音、陰暗、澎湃...的聲音等等,真係帶出不同感覺,唱歌也能融入身體(這個之前說過Archie有),這個就是分別,Felix在舞台表演,結果分不高,可能就是欠缺一些東西、揀對歌也是非常重要,除非真係唱到人家覺得這是你的歌。不過,以四個比較,唱歌方面覺得他表現應在Aeren之上,但以整體表現,評審也可能睇成個表演,真係能"完全地"能分開partner去睇参賽者,相信很難,評審也可能會考慮視覺元素,有台風vs沒太多台風等,所以沒有一定的對,聽歌,都比較個人觀點及喜好,畢竟,是否早一點離開比賽,不一定成為未來成功與否,一個好勁的人在一次比賽失準可以離開,因為這是比賽,但不代表未來成功與否,只要有potential,什麼都有可能,年輕人努力吧!
第二位的Kaitlyn,論唱歌,其實真係做到靚聲表現,同意一些層次感欠缺一些,但我收貨,有些位其實deliver得幾好。同意她的聲音有她的limitation,所以揀歌是很重要,不過,早幾集前她有些歌所唱出的假音的高度是有點surprised。要贏出是有點困難,相信評審都會考慮一個歌手能否拿捏不同類型的歌曲,不過,蓮者有其獨特性、保持歌唱能deliver message,應有一定市場吧,分數跟我預期差不多。第三位Archie,其實,我也同意本次他有不小瑕疵,Jay是主力,分數比我預期多,不過,我提過他的身體能融入音樂,表演能全人帶動壓台感,這次也是這樣的,相信評審也是以整體表演及過往主觀感比分,所以很好,Archie是有potential。至於Aeren,我覺得唱這歌顯得不小問題,不說她的基本技巧問題,她一直被看差一點,個人覺得源於發聲問題,唱歌好多時由喉嚨發出,真音不實、假音比較朦、由於發音問題真音不實使到每句句子結尾部分好多懶音,用耳去聽聲,有時聽不清及很朦,本次不是最低分,真是rap 歌部分有點幫助以及有點台風看來沒太悶,看看能否改一下這種發音問題,如歌曲雖要真音轉假音或假轉真,很多問題會出現。揀歌也是很重要呢。這些都是個人見解而已,不見怪!
well said!
說的真係好好🥺
@@claytonmusic can you pin this comment? It’s so well said and very objective🙏🏻 more people should see this
張老師評語好中肯。謝謝你的分享。
我個人替Felix 有些可惜，因為他的表現不俗。
我同意Felix唱得好，聲靚沉穩，似乎應留下來。
Archie 係做出來的自信，呢句我實在非常同意，我覺得佢每次比賽好似睇完一大堆演唱會然後集合百家歌手的live大成咁來塑造自己的表演。當然佢本身唱得唔差，但好欠缺個人風格。相比之下，我都係比較鍾意演繹上真摰D的Felix
中肯
请老师申请felix复活赛
復活賽要求點唱情非首爾
不要，浪費時間，直接出道可以了
張老師我覺得J Fung 把聲全部cover 哂同埋我用Hi Fi 耳機聽完全聽唔到佢把聲全首歌淨係聽到J Fung 把聲，另外蓮姐情况一樣我聽到好攰，Fliex反而我覺得合格奈何被foul , 另一位真係乏善足陳好失望，如今唯有期望下一集 Gigi Chantel & Rock 嘅表現
林智樂唱腔很好 ，成隊學員都可以是明日之歌星！
Filex 声线好好听，比aeren好好多！可惜淘汰左！
都係最近先有睇張老師的評論，覺得今次的評論講得好中肯，尤其是FELIX，他真係有很有辨識度的聲線，好像在星夢的主題曲內一聽就認得出Felix 的那一句,所以,他被出局實屬不幸，另外對Archie 的評論也道出重點，唔聽張老師的評論，也不是他也犯下錯誤，以為他真的零瑕疵，聲夢實在很需要他這樣有質素的評判..
其實以前佢係亞洲星光大道佢都講得好好
张老师的评语中肯，专业。。👍🏻👍🏻 Your advice will lead them to success..
Felix出局很可惜，點解得11人比燈。真係唱得不錯，加油Felix不要浪費你把靚聲。
父親節快樂張老師，我覺得好突然Felix要出局，講真Felix改了好多，聲線好易認到！
Every week, I look forward and can't wait to listen to your comments. By listening to your comments, I know exactly the strengths and weaknesses for each contestants. Not only that, I can learn something each time from your comments when I listen to the artists' performances. Personally, I prefer Felix. The way he sings makes me think he is William So. He is such a talented boy. I totally have no clue why he is fouled. That is too bad. Hopefully, he will not give up and keeps learning and practicing. Being a second William So is not far away from him for sure. On the other hand, Aeren is good at rapping in the songs more than singing. I believe if she keeps learning and practicing, maybe she can be a female version of MC Jin, who knows? Again, it is only my opinion. Anyway, I look forward each and every contestants keep trying their best in the competition. Good luck to all of them.
Thanks for the professional comments on the contestants. When I watch this show, sometimes I found that the scoring systems and the comments of the judges are not tangible enough. For example, sometimes a judge said that a certain performance is not good enough and have rooms for improvement, but the judge still gave a green light. Let say, if you need to score their performance, from 0 to 10 for instance, how would you score their performance? Thanks a lot!
the light basically means wether judges think they pass or not
I couldn't actually heard what Archie was singing because his voice was so low and weak (in this performance). It was like he couldn't find the right pitch. I do think Jay had helped Archie a lot, not just the performance, by trying to bring Archie back to the right pitch whenever he started to go off by jumping in and singing "ohhhh". You could hear Archie changed his pitch and followed Jay's. But overall performance was enjoyable.
當年學友出道都是好小觀眾緣
Felix自己唱哂成首歌好過，同Phil合唱反而冇乜機會發揮。好喜歡他的聲音！而且17歲識唱咁多經典粵語流行金曲，實在難得。
Felix把聲係好靚的，出局替佢唔抵，希望佢遲D會做到歌手。好認同佢今集呢首，係甘多集當中最好的，感情好到位😉👍💕！
從琴晚等到今晚，因為琴晚睇聲夢見到張老師comment Felix 系正面嘅，但竟然被foul咗，都好想聽下問題系邊😭好希望張老師有機會引薦Felix俾肯栽培佢的唱片公司！來自內地的fans 🙋🏻♀️🙋🏻♀️
很認同張老師評語，只可以講，Felix 板斧暫時唔多，亦唔算是 “一鳴驚人” 嘅類型。需要時間去累積支持者。
Right on the point about Felix ! The part you highlighted in the song is my fav and his adlibs are very good this time..Agreed with all your comments 👍except.....
about Aeren's raps. Her raps was like' reading ' raps lyrics 😑but it was a nice try though.
Good comments! 希望學員受益, 再創樂壇新氣象!
我覺得，佢係將來嘅張學友和蘇永康 混之一体，希望公司唔好派一啲無聊嘅歌畀佢，Felix 把聲真係靚絕！
認同！Felix把聲靚绝！男声中超鐘意佢，係我－聽就着迷果種，有啲似黃品源，趟傳果类，等咗好耐先有呢类聲音，(对上一次係坤哥 ，真係红咗，我啲直觉竟然準过) 希望Felix睇到留言，唔好放棄，若有好歌派到比佢，佢－定可以唱到成為永恆經典。
坤哥我就好少聽到佢嘅成名作，但係felix嘅歌唱技巧，獨特的声美，就係佢所能夠抓住人的嘅心，俾首獨立宣言或者越問越傷心，分分鐘可能勁過原唱！
@@wanm3419 同意！突然諗起，新－代男声好少有翻唱歌手，女聲中譚嘉儀都算成功，Felix开個頻道先做翻唱，每首歌唱前再揾個老師练－练，啲吸引位，练得好先发佈最终最滿意嘅版本，已經係－個出路，衷心祝願Felix响網上可“殺出－条血路”，唔好放棄住。
能否再叫無 線播: 全部(比分的導師不被剪輯..都播出) 足本版. ??? 希望明天又知道你的結論. 謝.
Happy Father’s Day!
I totally understand what you said.
Great comments! Thanks 🙏
多謝你張老師
我覺得張老師很喜歡Felix呢類男子聲，比較清脆響亮，我也幾喜歡呢種男子的聲音。比賽進入淘汰賽，無論foul誰都會有人嘈，雖然被foul,但不需覺得可惜，從來歌唱比賽都不一定是冠軍嗰個爆紅。林欣彤有句說話說得好啱，你攞到第幾名基本上冇人記得，但你有好表現唱左乜歌反而有人記得。雖然我心目中Archie在表現上比Felix 高一班，我個人很喜歡Archie,但當天如果要foul一個人的話，我也不想foul Felix,我會揀Aeren,Aeren只是有dd運，佢只是險勝，只是比Felix多兩盞燈。我覺得Felix一點也不像蘇永康，蘇永康把聲好厚，Felix未必走到他的曲風。我見Felix和一位國內歌手有類似style，嗰位歌手叫「胡夏」，胡夏把聲不厚，但清趣響亮，我相信Felix走「胡夏」的曲風應該效果不錯。胡夏和Felix一樣，一樣不是靚仔🤣🤣🤣
我不是説 Felix 像蘇永康，我意思是他的市場定位可以類似蘇永康，也不是指曲風。而是一個不靠樣但靠聲和 mood 的戴眼鏡男生
张老师节日快乐！
🙏🙏
Archie 應該會好受惠於張老師嘅紅燈
我覺得archie唱得並不是那麼好，我不明白23，也不明白11
21:12 張老師嚴師出高徒
非常感謝張老師，他對今次各學員在台上的表現都分析得十分細緻。本人也很認同老師指出有一些評判對林智樂的評分真係有點harsh。因為他的表現其實真係不錯的，只是由於星夢的比賽遊戲規則是規定了每集都是有學員要foul。所以因為林智樂分數最低，所以率先出局了。其實很多人已經預測了下一集的比賽，會foul的學員將會是黃奕斌，大家大可以悉目以待。所以我們不應該將星夢視作一個比賽節目，亦不要太計較分數的得與失。因為這個只是其中一個TVB的娛樂節目吧！期望各位學員都可以為本港樂壇增添一些動力。～加油！💪🏻💪🏻💪🏻
Aeren开头几句吓死我！普通话又不准，音又不准！只有去rap先觉得吸引！巨无被淘汰真系好运！
佢係由第一集開始已經咁好运
aeren只是每一次都好運， 而Felix 有實力， 不是公平
導師每次都話aeren 有進步勤力（ 仲有咩可以讚佢？）（ 咁就可以有得留低？） ， 但係火雞aska同felix 都冇咁好運
@@mimiwong8519 絕對認同！一個本來零分嘅人進步到30分，就覺得好大進步！ 但係有冇諗過其實佢進步極呢30分都仲係好難聽？ 反而人哋本身都有80分嘅，就係輸在個運氣。真心替felix唔值
張老師想請問你Gigi 同Chantel 下集？表演如何啊好否透露一下
兩晚後你就知道了😁
其實 promo 也劇透了少少
男生，我最喜歡Felix的
事實上Archie係前段第一句甩拍子，但整體係算好聽！
張生
父親節快樂
有個咁掛住你的女
幸福
🙏🙏
呢4個今集講細膩講少失誤講穩定係佢做得最好，不過商業世界就係咁，歌唱比賽亦都係一樣，可以參考下ATV 亞洲星光大道決賽既第一名羅力威同埋第二名亢帥克當時表現，又可以參考下TVB 超級巨聲2 決賽既第一名林欣彤同第二名胡鴻鈞當時表現，其實都會明白。
支持！
I actually liked Felix’s performance in this episode!
😢😢係囉，，燈數偏低，好可惜，Felix,, 蓮姐同都泳衣唱歌都好聽，，
感謝張老師深入分析學員表現令觀眾明白為何學員會被foul走的原因👍🏻
想問下, 呢個俾分方法(每位評判只可俾1分或0分)是否有些問題?
假設如果每位評判每人可俾0-100分，50全格
當學員A有9個俾51分, 16個俾49分, 學員A共有1243分，現有俾分方式有9個藍燈
而學員B有10個俾50分, 15個俾49分, 學員B共有1235分，現有俾分方式有10個藍燈
計分的確會精準一點
评分制会更细致看出评判对选手的评价。现在的赛制是只能选yes or no，或者我们可以理解为评审不是在选择选手是否晋级，而是消费者在决定是否购买这首歌，yes or no。这种情况下，假设消费者的标准是过了50分就买，那么10个50分会比9个51分好。当然歌手也要努力上进做到100分，因为如果所有购买者的分数都是50分，那么这首歌就算销量很高，都红不起。