Will it be safe for Palestinians in Gaza to return and rebuild their homes? | Inside Story
Вставка
- Опубліковано 13 тра 2024
- Unprecedented levels of destruction.
That's how the UN describes the state of Gaza since Israel's war began in October.
No buildings have been spared from the Israeli strikes.
The UN's mine action agency says after more than six months of war, 37 million tons of debris litter the Strip.
Clearing it could take 14 years and likely be slowed down by the unexploded bombs and ammunition scattered throughout Gaza.
For Palestinians living among the rubble that makes for an even more dangerous environment.
And once the war is over, will it be safe for people to return and rebuild?
Presenter: Folly Bah Thibault
Guests:
Jonathan Guthrie - Director of Operations at Norwegian People's Aid.
Federico Dessi - Middle East Director at the NGO, Humanity and Inclusion.
Raja Khalidi - Director General of the Palestine Economic Policy Research Institute.
Subscribe to our channel: bit.ly/AJSubscribe
Follow us on Twitter: / ajenglish
Find us on Facebook: / aljazeera
Check our website: www.aljazeera.com/
Check out our Instagram page: / aljazeeraenglish
Download AJE Mobile App: aje.io/AJEMobile
#Palestine #Gaza #NorthernGaza #SouthernGaza #CentralGaza #GazaAirRaids #GazaAirStrikes #GazaUnderAttack #GazaHumanitarianCrisis #Israel #IsraelHamasWar #GazaWar #IsraelWar #IsraelPalestineWar #IsraelGazaWar #GazaBombardment #GazaRefugeeCamps
Palestine is occupied land, and under international law, the Palestinians have the legal right to resist this occupation by any and all means.
And Israel has rights to defend itself - by any means necessary.
@@JohnSmith-ux3tt nope cry harder
34000 tried ....
@@JohnSmith-ux3ttUnder International Law the occupied have a right to defend themselves. Occupiers and apartheid regimes do not have the right to defend their occupation and apartheid regimes
@@annmuldoon6064they have a right to defend themselves.
Why don’t those from Gaza that participated in 10/7 defend their women and children then.
Why are they letting them suffer like this ?
I saw a video of a 8th year old boy in a Gaza Hospital whose parents were killed in a israeli air strike and who lost both his legs as they were amputated without anesthesia
The hospital is existing on diesel generators as the occupiers shut down the electricity.
We are living in very dark times.
Maybe they should return the hostsges?
There are at least 13,000 and most likely at least twice that number of such stories. Their names and faces should be shown constantly in the MSM.
@@JohnSmith-ux3tt…the Palestinians should have Gaza returned to them in the same condition it was before Oct 10? Terrorists should have been brought before the courts…
@@JohnSmith-ux3tt how many you got in the basement?
@@JohnSmith-ux3tt There are currently 19,000 Palestinians children being held incommunido in israel jails. The vats majority of them being systematically tortured. Why can the ukrainians resist a occupation but not the Palestinians?
"I hate when I see politicians just trying to denounce Netenyahu as some sort of abberation from Israeli society. No, this is the norm. The whole Israeli society is as fascist as it gets. Look at the polling. LESS than 2% think that Israel was using too much firepower in Gaza after they obliterated and decimated the entire Gaza strip." ---- Abby Martin
This war is all about never ever again or else it would be worse
❤
Pysco lunatics nation
They're known to be super manipulators! & Liars
Don't forget to address the areas where IOF dropped white phosphorus.
"where IOF dropped white phosphorus."...ISR changed, now it is rainbow colored Phosphorous...don't you feel better...
Cry harder mayber they will hear you.
As an American, I’m so ashamed at the provision of all this munition. Thank god for the students here and around the world who are able to bring to the light the complicity of our government in this horror.
" the complicity of our government in this horror."...uuuhhh, US just provided more billions to ISR...students sure changed this (laughter)
Vote democrat 😆
I’m Ashamed that my country Australia has followed America in supporting this yes thank god for the young protesters the Zionist ideology has to go it’s causing so much death
Zionist ideology is the problem and APAC
@@user-dp1bt9ql2m What a defeatist attitude! The student protesters had a defining effect on the war in Vietnam!!
Israel should pay for all the clean up and rebuild for the Palestinians
Israel? not Hamas?
Yes ❤
Of course Israel
@@albxoxYou broke it..
YOU fix it...but it is still not yours.
@laurajohnson2479
Starting a war and losing it doesn't make you a victim....
the unexploded ordinance in the rubble is one thing, but people need to also remember how many thousands of people are still buried under all of that. so the removal of rubble will also continuously include the recovery and dignified burial of all of those remains. that's a point of particular distaste with regards to that temporary pier world central kitchen had created, too.
the depth of loss and destruction is utterly unfathomable
If I thought what remained of my flesh that is of no use to my spirit anymore, might be in the rubble that could be used to bring food and reconstruction, I'd have zero problem with that. I've made it clear to my adult children that if the Lord should tarry and my flesh should pass, that I'd like my ashes to be used as part of a planting of a nice shade tree that will grow, bringing shade, cooling, beauty and oxygen to generations in the future.
@@coleengoodell7523 sure, that may be your particular personal preference given a choice. but nobody gave the people of Gaza any say in the matter. they didn't ask to be ethnically cleansed, nor to be murdered in their tens of thousands. the connection these people have to their kinfolk as well as their homes is really extraordinary given the extreme circumstances. and those who lost everyone and everything may want to do whatever they can to collect the ashalāʾi or fragments of their loved ones. the emotional toll of this is incomprehensible
@@HaileISela Thank you for your reproof. Heard, understood and accept it.
"Reprove a wise man and he will love you. But if you reprove a fool, you'll only get insults for yourself." Proverbs
America how could you let this happen?
Cumplices, apoio incondicional!
@@kitanianunesdebarros2659 Thanks, support right back at you too
Let it happen?? This is a US Jen-o-side as much as it is Nazirael’s
Biden came in as a sheep and has been reveled as a wolf in sheeps clothing. I also strongly suspect that he is suffering from some stage of dementia and is a useful puppet, just as trump was, for the elites with special interests, including the Israeli government. Knowing what we know now about the Zionist regime and Biden's lifelong, almost worshipful devotion to it, is disturbing to say the least. Our so called representatives, including Biden and Blinken have sold their souls to support this wickedness for big dollar donations/bribes and sold out the American public in the process.
America didnt force Gaza to attack.
Start with a ceasefire, ceasefire, ceasefire, .....
Este va a ser el PRIMER PASO.
Novara media and owen jones have been covering these issues in detail.
more importantly how are the destructicons going to PAY the $100 billion for the rebuild
Too know about this atrocity…is like splitting your psyche into fragments! The devastation and suffering is beyond a normal brain comprehension! I weep for all the lives…suffering or lost! But, I am safe…and helpless to give aid or stop the nightmare…💔
It will not be safe for years to come. A total loss.
If Palestinians flatten the rubble and move area to area clear them and build straight on them,or stay in Rafa ign tents or build prefabricated houses till the real houses are built again for the 7th time. As long as Palestinians are in Palestine they can do everything needed to stay and rebuilt they are the top most educated people in the Middle East and Europe they have very many intellectuals who can do the rebuilds, hopefully they will get back their lands from 1967 border theft by IZRAELI Zionist squatters, move the Squatters back to the 1967 border. line. Not that the squatters own any land their but at least they would be out of Palestinians way.
Free Palestine and rebuild Palestine!
Why? It looks much better today than it did on Oct 7 don't you think?
Who will free & rebuild Palestine, your God? Keep praying for ever.
Take the Westbank and give it back to The Palistinians. Let Israel pay to all Palisinians millions in restitution. Germany has payed Billions to Israel for the past 79 years in Resetutions.!
Zionist trolls, which shows the subjects importance.
At this point, Gazans are better off going to Egypt.
Free palestine from hamas!!
Hamas is super evils too,
This destruction is beyond human comprehension. Let humanity always avoid whatever leads to this kind !
Very Meaningful Discussion.
Thanks.
*The Americans have a lot to answer for.*
America doesn't have to answer to anyone!🇺🇸
Amerikans: "It's all good, all is well ..."
@@Dianeallen-ml5fp Firstly, the Americans must respond to their own people come election time, secondly to the Palestinians victims who will still be survivors, and thirdly to the people of the world who witnessed the death of so many innocent civilians.
@@Jean-rg4spu mean 10/7 didn’t make life better for the Palestinians.
What happened ?
Support Palestine 🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸
Who is going to invest any money into this charade?
Are you still busy?
Jared kushner.
@@shaheedaessack6142 Hmmm. Never been stumped on this channel like you did. I stand corrected.
Western taxpayers after their governments give their money away.
@@Hlth-cn4fh Truth hurts.
No it won't - not if the world's owners can help it !
Free Palestine 🇪🇭
Amidst the rubble
The billions of dollars going to weapons seem not to be a problem for many world leaders. I don't see why the same amounts should be an issue for rebuilding and reparations for what is and has been happening to the Palestinian people for generations. In addition, the 1967 or even futher back boarders that were established, should and could, provide safe habitable areas for the population of Gaza until it can and should be rebuilt. It may inconvenience "illegal" settlers, too bad! The Palestinian people of this region have been more than inconvenienced for generations. Give them their land back!
I totally agree. First the Palestinians need a save place to live. Kick out the illegal Settlers . Is the Westbank large enough for 2 million people. ?
The billionaire leaders of hamas are quite safe in Qatar
BS
@@paulaheady8990 The billionaire leaders of hamas are NOT quite safe in Qatar!
Muslim countries didnt house syrians afgans etc. the double standard is extreme.
Over 10 years just to clear the rubble and unexploded shells…,WTH??? Oh my God.
The 21st century is the century of Palestine.
back to stone age.
Sadly, this will happen all over again within less than a year.
yup. Radical islam
Devastated bombings never seen in human history in Gaza.
When people is going to take about Netanyahu and is war crime cabinet go to prison
I agree wholeheartedly that we must not let the UN agencies be replaced by non-UN agencies or other entities. I’ve been thinking about that.
I've never seen such destruction! I disagree with the 14 year assessment for the clean-up. I've worked in open-pit mining and seen the same volume (overburden) pre-mining material, cleared away in 3 1/2 - 4 years. Millions of tones of hard compacted earth cleared away. They will need mining equipment for this clean up, maybe be a freight railway built to expedite. A fleet of Cat D11's , Cat 6040, Cat 797's , Cat 24's. Its incredible what this equipment can move in a short time.
From the river to the sea, Palestine shall be free.
You mean “will “
Slogans and chants won't work.
@@Hlth-cn4fh 😂🤣 Getting under your skin?
@@jovandjuric8340 Just getting under the skin of my friendly Bot. He is becoming quite a comedy feature.
Empty words to cover impotence.
The Hebrew Bible repeatedly highlights the wickedness of Israel
lol…..you funny. As long as they have Hummus in control? No way…..
Talking about rebuilding homes at this point only further illustrates the fairytale land you people live in. Keep watching. You have no idea what's happening.
Genocídio e limpeza etinica, Netanyahu e Biden tem planos para Gaza! E essas pessoas se iludem pensando que os israelenses permitirão que os palestinos continuem morando em Gaza!
Where will the Palistinians live now?
THANK YOU AL JAZZERA SUPPORTING THE IDF AND THEIR CARE
???
For I also was a son to my father,
cherished and unique in my mother's eyes;
God bless the people!
I want to see condemnation & who us sincere & not hypocrite
😢😢😢
Thinking outside the box: Everyone in the world that's for Palestinians could help rebuild what was destroyed structurally! As much Love the world has for Palestinian People Now, this would be well worth helping restoring their home land...Together!
It's actually quite ironic. So it could take ten years clearing mines etc before even plan to rebuild infrastructure, houses and everything that people need for living. So maybe 20 years. Where will the Palestinians live in the meantime? Also: as Gaza looks now and with the time table for demining and rebuild etc, Israel can't use it either for the next 20 years approx..Surrealistic.
7/10 Huge Mistake!!
1948, not october 7
What happened 1948
@@magnifiedentertainment7160you don’t know or you pretend?
Netanyahu knew what he was doing when he let 7/10 happen.
@@magnifiedentertainment7160so in 1948 did those Arabs commit acts like 10/7 then hide behind the women and children afterwards like those Serbs today in Gaza ?
Must.see.🙏🕊🌬⚡
Building of homes? Good one.
From the river to the sea, Palestine shall be free.
@@kam70111 Your slogans and chants won't work. They aren't working. Take a look. Israel has spoken.
"Israel has spoken" fk what zrael says. Sooner or later palestinians will be free from their oppressors once for all, now even the blind can see the real face of these colonialistic criminals
oye how's those NY tunnels. still digging?
@@rhetorical1488 Iran sent a tunnel boring machine. Secret 😂🤣
Hamas completely underestimated the retaliatory action of Israel. What did they benefit by taking Hostages?
so you admit casual genocide.
They don't care .
NOBODY thought that Netanyahu would leave the hostages there to get blown up by the IDF!!!
They simply don't give a f*ck
God ble
Netanyahu has reached his target of making gaza uninhabitable and unsafe by destroying everything possible including hospitals, schools, universities, mosques and houses. In the meantime where will Palestinians live during the years of reconstruction?
Yes where?
I know ,the Westbank
With what?
With money from natural gas bellow Gaza. 500 billions
Vida longa aos nossos irmãos palestinos! Allah Hu Akbar ❤!
Okay. The question is Where
Israel must pay for the rebuilding!
😂😂😂
😅😅😅
Not how war works
And the usa
Nope, not going to happen. Israel is going to build a wall between themselves and the Palestinians. They don't want to ever have to deal with them again.
“It will take 14 years” to rebuild? How did they come up with that number.? Why not 14 years and 6 months, or 12 years and 2 months. I think more like 2 or 3 generations, if ever.
It’s more important for Pharos to let the ppl of Palestinians live in their country as free ppl
And their country is where?
Where will they live now?
Egypt
Watch. The. Human.
They should tackle the rebuilding in stages, and erect mobile houses, schools and hospitals in places that is safe, in Palestine. If the Palestinians are removed, Israel will make sure they will never return.
If any group of people can rebuild it’s the Palestinians of Gaza. They’ve rebuilt time & time again before.
China built 2 hospitals in 10 days during the pandemic. The Somalilanders, who are 4 million, rebuilt in 5-10 years a city 90% destroyed Without the help of any international organization. Stop being so negative with GAZA
Nobody has the money to rebuild Mordor.......
Yes but palestinians should rebuild gaza the way they want and it would help them recover also financially for yrs
It was their choice. Hanea said that liberation requires sacrifice, so here is the result.., all by design
Where will Palestinians live in the next 15 years. Give them back the Westbank. Let Israel pay for the Devastation
It seems very strange to talk about clearing rubble when bombs are still dropping. Of course we need a plan, however this is currently putting the cart before the horse. If we keep ignoring the daily deaths, we soon won't have a population to rebuild.
Probably if they keep hamass away
They are going to be forced out in Jordan and Egypt.
How about letting Palestinians return to their actual homes in occupied Palestine 🇵🇸
My God is not blind. Just wait.
By whom?
Maybe Iran can pay for the reconstruction?
Both Vietnam and Afghanistan turned around from similar decimation efforts of USA, by God Gazans are ready to not only turn around but prove to the World the hidden miracles behind resilience
Send the bill to Israhell!!!
Hello 🙋🏻♀️ batibo madam
Yes very safe if they don't build tunnels again and change attitude and live in peace.
Tent city
I still can't believe we have 80+% of the structures / infrastructure in rubble but only like 1.5% of the population have died. I don't mean to sound insensitive or cold towards their struggle, but wouldn't we expect these two figures to be closer to one another? I mean if you flatten half my home town, I'd expect half the population to die as a result; replace the 1/2 with any fractional number you'd like and it still seems reasonable. I can't explain the discrepancy in the 80+% and 1.5% numbers, but the difference is large enough that there must be a causal reason.
Palestinians must not rewarded for oct 7
Shame on Arab for being silent
Of course Al Jazera 😂
It’s sad to what the Islamic state has done to the people of Gaza.
Yes provided they wont do 7th October again or keep firing rockets
Or 1948.
But they will do it all again - just ask them.
@@shaheedaessack6142 or 1600
How will Gaza rebuild? 1) reparations from israel; 2) many of us in the world community will be happy to help. If Gazans request our assistance, there needs to be a way to allow it to happen.
Good. All students demonstrating in the US France and wherever should come to Gaza and help clean up. It is a tremendous task. You can put your Free Palestine into practice and also help the local population. I wonder how many of the Stand for Humanity people would volunteer
看到那么多恐怖分子挨炸，真的是太治愈了哈哈哈
what a beautiful view
At present which one is the World Modern Fighter Jet?
American F-35
American F-16
American F-15
Their best performance
1) killed 12000 approx. Child killing (Gaza)
2) Killed 9000 approx.Women killing (Gaza)
3) killed 3000 civilians approx. people killing (Gaza)
4) killed 6000 approx. Freedom fighter killed (Gaza). Those people, who are fight, recovery their lost mother land.
May I asking a question, anyone have in the World who can give sanctions against this Fighter Jet.
Yes Donald duck ...
Palestinians Then:🕺😃
Palestinians Now:⚰️😢
Disgusting comment
Are people really this naïve to think Israel and America will ever allow the Palestinians back in Gaza?
Israel has entirely forfeited whatever claim it may have had to exist. US is already in collapse
Warum schreiben 'sie' so hochmuetig, von oben herab?
Sachlich bleiben bitte.
Von mir aus können 'sie' denken was auch immer.
FREE Porcupines
Insha Allah Palestine will be Free
And if allah hu fail to do so??
Allahu Akbar
🇵🇸❤️🇹🇷
You have Hamas to thank for the destruction in Gaza and they are also the ones to determine if Palestinians in Gaza will be able to rebuild their homes.
Take this comment down as usual.
netty was propping them, and he admitted it on video and you elected him
Israel must be held accountable and at least pay for or help funding the reconstruction of Gaza.
Israel is still being pay billions 79 years later ,by Germany
Netenyahu will understand god hand is more powerful then his air power U should understand from your history
No, they need to move where their inciters are. They need to move to Qatar, Iran, Syria, Yemen. These countries fund and irk them into hostilities. Qatar, Al Jazeera, funded and housed leaders of the crimes against humanity on October 7th as they were coordinating the invasion. The Emir of Qatar KNEW about the invasion way before it happened. All this that has happened because of it lays at the dissected head of the leader of Qatar.
Don't forget Palestinian rights in their mother land.
And don't blindly support Israel
Israel has entirely forfeited whatever claim it may have had to exist
As an american this is sad but i can't understand why people have kids living in these circumstances why bring life to suffer and also its weird to have sympathy for people who scream death to america
Why should it be Palestinians responsibility for rebuilding they didn’t destroy Gaza I thought Israel did no?Or do I live on Neptune?
Don't worry. Israel will make Gaza their new home so they will rebuild it
@@vorpalsword8165 ok now I feel better