Thank you do much for this wonderful video! This gorgeous piece is on my wish list Yo learn and your analysis gives great ideas for approaching practice, making it more accessible.🎹
I haven't been able to find the piece that is edited by Harold Bauer, even though I did go on the Imslp site. I ordered a copy of this but the edition is by Joseph Gahm and it's difficult to read. Can you give me another source? Thanks, Roseanna
Very helpful indeed. Now I don't feel so alone! Thank you Tommy. (I notice that Yuja Wang and several other professional pianists play the C# in bars 24 & 32 as trill, presumably moving all the accompaniment into the left hand..?)
Yes. In fact I think it might have started with Rachmaninov playing that trill. I’d bet Yuja could perhaps manage the trill and some other notes all in her right hand :-) - although it does look like she moves the other notes to the left. I doubt in my case I could manage such a long trill at the moment though so I’ve kept it simple for now.
Hi Tommy, wonderful tutorial! Is there a way to get the exact same transcription that you use in the video? The Link in your Description Box is not working and i really wanna have those sheets:) mabye you can send it by email? Thanks a lot!
First thanks a lot for this very sharp and usefull video. It is a so wonderfull music that I started to look at the score as you suggested. May I have one question : My english is not fluent and I did not understood the meaning of the two colors you are using for example measure 8 and 9. I would very appeciate if you could tell me why these two colors. Thank you.
The yellow highlight is because we have two notes (an upper note played in the right hand and, simultaneously, a lower note played in the left hand). The Pink is where we we have a single note rather than two. It’s a sort of ‘aide mémoire’ to help as we’re reading the score. What I found helpful was to colour code these little differences to help me as I was learning it. Does that make sense? If not, guessing by your name, vous préférez peut-être français? Je ne suis pas certain de pourvoir mieux l’expliquer, mais je peux au moins essayer :-)
@@TommysPianoCorner excuse me , because I am reading your answer juste now? So first great thanks. Your explanation is perfectly clear, and I understand. I am trying to learn the Juja wang version (encore version) but your video is helping a lot. Merci beaucoup ! because you took the time to answer me.
This video is very helpful. Tommy's explanations are very accessible. Thank you Tommy!
Thank you so much.
Thank you do much for this wonderful video! This gorgeous piece is on my wish list Yo learn and your analysis gives great ideas for approaching practice, making it more accessible.🎹
Glad to hear you found it interesting. It is a fantastic piece.
Great video about this beautiful piece, Tommy. Thanks!
Thanks. Happy you liked it.
I haven't been able to find the piece that is edited by Harold Bauer, even though I did go on the Imslp site. I ordered a copy of this but the edition is by Joseph Gahm and it's difficult to read. Can you give me another source? Thanks, Roseanna
Drop me an email tommy@tommyspianocorner.com and I’ll forward to you
Never heard of this one before, although it sounds familiar. Thanks for sharing!
I also thought it sounded familiar when I heard it - it is gorgeous!
Very helpful indeed. Now I don't feel so alone! Thank you Tommy. (I notice that Yuja Wang and several other professional pianists play the C# in bars 24 & 32 as trill, presumably moving all the accompaniment into the left hand..?)
Yes. In fact I think it might have started with Rachmaninov playing that trill. I’d bet Yuja could perhaps manage the trill and some other notes all in her right hand :-) - although it does look like she moves the other notes to the left. I doubt in my case I could manage such a long trill at the moment though so I’ve kept it simple for now.
I love a good Gluck .
Hi Tommy, wonderful tutorial! Is there a way to get the exact same transcription that you use in the video? The Link in your Description Box is not working and i really wanna have those sheets:) mabye you can send it by email? Thanks a lot!
If you’d like to email me tommy@tommyspianocorner.com I can send it to you. I’ll investigate that link in the description too to see what is wrong :-)
@@TommysPianoCorner thanks! I just sent you the request:)
@@sauerpower97 responded. Good luck with it :-)
@@TommysPianoCorner thank you very much!!! I ll keep you updated on the progress :)
@@sauerpower97 great! Look forward to hearing!
First thanks a lot for this very sharp and usefull video. It is a so wonderfull music that I started to look at the score as you suggested. May I have one question : My english is not fluent and I did not understood the meaning of the two colors you are using for example measure 8 and 9. I would very appeciate if you could tell me why these two colors. Thank you.
The yellow highlight is because we have two notes (an upper note played in the right hand and, simultaneously, a lower note played in the left hand). The Pink is where we we have a single note rather than two. It’s a sort of ‘aide mémoire’ to help as we’re reading the score. What I found helpful was to colour code these little differences to help me as I was learning it. Does that make sense? If not, guessing by your name, vous préférez peut-être français? Je ne suis pas certain de pourvoir mieux l’expliquer, mais je peux au moins essayer :-)
@@TommysPianoCorner
excuse me , because I am reading your answer juste now? So first great thanks. Your explanation is perfectly clear, and I understand. I am trying to learn the Juja wang version (encore version) but your video is helping a lot. Merci beaucoup ! because you took the time to answer me.
@@dominique0239 je vous en prie :-)