Makes you wonder if one gould actually reverse the function of their digestive system 🤔 if I started to practice today shoving food up my ass and vomiting every meal how long before it would start to work like that naturally "on its own" 🤔
And none of them can cross over each other. No particles could be stacked either. We could hold ourselves together with spirals and mazes, although it would be difficult to generate force to push food through
@@Banana_Split_Cream_BunsWhen you’re talking about physical dimensions it’s different than how the fourth dimension is described in the theory of General Relativity (in which it is in fact time). If you are only going off of that theory, it is much much easier to describe the movement of matter and particles in space than it is to explain like, tesseracts and stuff, and the latter fits the context of this comment better.
It's like that one South Park episode, although IRL it works halfway in that an anus can eat food, only the difference it expels back out there like normal 👓🎓🦉 Bear Grylls even did so in MvW
It’s important to note that this is purely based on theoretical mathematics and physics, it’s entirely possible that if there were an alternate reality that existed in 2 dimensions that the laws of physics would actually allow things that we understand to be impossible
Actually, there’s a cool astronomy theory that the singularities at the end of black holes collapse reality into a 2-dimensional plane, so there’s a possibility of that alternate 2D reality existing! As for life on a 2D plane along with other things, that’s pretty much impossible for us to comprehend with our current knowledge.
It could support our universe if you just sliced the whole universe evenly, then laid each infinitely thin slice into the others, essentially super-imposed layers of reality, separated by Ordinality (rather than Cardinality which is what we have right now).
We ARE 4th dimensional creatures. Everything in the universe exists throughout time. Even the gravity itself keeping us grounded is a byproduct of the geometry of the 4th dimension that has a very real tangible impact on our lives. We just don’t see the 4th dimension the same way we'd see the other 3 in SPACE, but we still exist within it and by it.
@@HelloThere..... I was just thinking about this the other day. Thoughts and dreams only we can comprehend could only be the result of higher dimensions
There’s actually quite a few ways a being in 2d could function: 1: a latch system that operates like a cell wall 2: a “zipper” mechanism that will allow flexible material to interlock, allowing stuff to pass throw while the body moves like a inch worn 3. One hole for in and out
one potential actual problem is brains, wire like connections cant cross easily (this is potentially overcomable with some weirdness), but there might just not be enough space for a complicated brain to be compact.
@@terdragontra8900 well that depends on how atoms work in a 2D space, if a material is bonded is it a new material and solid or is it just tiny circles with high electrical and chemical forces?
imagine just existing and suddenly you rip in two pieces *no more one piece* edit: thx for the likes but, it's on thousands or millions???! also, dam guys you sayin' if we can get much higher, but I am already high enough
I'd imagine there is civilization of 4D creatures out there, and in the equivalent of youtube; there is a video exactly like this where they claim life in 3D cannot exist.
Fun fact: the GI tract is considered to be outside of the body. The epithelial boundary describes the tissue around the GI tract, which is exposed to the external environment. Picture a water weenie. The inside of the water weenie is the GI tract. It absorbs through mucous membranes to bring nutrients inside the body, but it is, itself, not inside the body
In a 2D world, it's impossible to have vision, at least as humans perceive it. To see anything, you need to have depth and width. You can visualize this by putting your head against a wall and trying to look across it through one eye. Things directly in front of you would block your vision and not allow you to see past them
In a 2D world, sight would be in a 1D line, just as how we see our world through 2D images. Any time we see a line, it is just a 2D highlight of a line. A perfect 1D line would be too small for us to see or visualize.
There was a book called Flat Land which actually explored this kinda' stuff, looking at how 2D beings would see, live, etc. as well as how they'd interact with 3D beings. I haven't read the book but I have seen the 2007 (I think) movie adaptation
By a guy called Edwin Abbott. It's to teach you about how a being from a universe with MORE THAN THREE DIMENSIONS OF SPACE AND ONE OF TIME would see us... and how we'd see it! It's BRILLIANT!
@@fendysusanto876 I'm describing amoeba for the sake of picturing it.. what about a slime mold then that digests outside it's body, or those hydra things that eat and poop from the same orifice
Don't worry, our insides could be wriggly s's and not just straight tubes that could interlock and hold us together by our intestines similar to puzzle pieces ;)
You know, Michael Stevens described this best: humans are just giant meaty donuts. Thanks Vsauce. Thanks for the horrible nightmares my inner child has had since hearing this...
"The tube that food goes in..." *Draws the tube that food comes out* "...and the tube that food comes out" *Draws the way food goes in* I'm fucking dead bro I can't 🤣
But the tract isn't what's bifurcated, that would mean the tract itself splits into two. Rather, the body is bifurcated by the tract. "Digestive bifurcation" would be a way more accurate title (unless the song is about someone with two buttholes, then it'd be perfect).
I remember recently hearing that someone was able to construct a theoretical form that could work as a digestive tract in a 2 dimensional body... I believe it was constructed only to separate when moving did through and then to rejoin afterwards
@@phillapple8260 a digestive tract in a 'C' shape could be made so that the geometry of the system could hold the system together. A force causing one end to expand would automatically cause the other end to contract making such a toxin much harder to use.
Some questions: would a tunnel work in 2d? How would you hold up the stuff on top without blocking the entrance/exit? Also how does gravity work in 2d? How does time and space distort in 2 dimensions? Can mass even exist in 2d?
@@aashishdevgun Sorry, I just now understand what you meant. There are no 2D molecules 😳 This is a misrepresentation of 2D world because it assumes that there is third dimensions the size of a molecule.
I feel like the twists and turns and the 'tube" would hold us together in two dimensions. I'm not a fan of the simplification of the digestive tract past the stomach, there's also like half a dozen sphincters in the human GI tract.
@@blizzard1198 you realize we can close our mouths. A 2d person could have hooks on both sides of his mouth and have a similar hooking butt to hold himself together. With detachable neurons so there is always a brain connection to the other half.
Let's be honest, they were about 25 other reasons we couldn't live in a two-dimensional world, he just wanted to use the term "bifurcates the body" and I'm ok with that
A Hungarian cartoon series, what continued Mezga Family with the story, that a boy built an inflatable space ship and used it in the night to go to other planets, has an episode, where he was on a 2D planet, where everything looked like xrayed. He turned someone of them into 3D, but he wasn't glad about it.
This reminds me of the old Sci-fi novel "The Planiverse" where a group of scientists or programmers accidentally connected to a being that lived in a 2d world. I loved that book as a kid, and seeing how everything (could have) worked was a really cool thought exercise.
Not really disappointed, coz we're the ones who percieve drawings as 2D to represent whatever. It's just like how you draw a portrait of a real life person on paper but doesn't mean that the real life person who were drawn are 2D. In the same way, anime characters are drawn as 2D coz that's a representation that we prefer of these characters and their world. The main point is, if we entered an anime world then the characters will become real, they will no longer need to follow our 2D representation and they'll be 3 dimensional. only difference is that they'll probably be prettier, hotter, cuter and more mesmirising than humans since their dimensions have different principles from ours when relating to our representation
There's a problem with this. Just because we interact in a 2D world doesn't mean our 3D existence ceases. You based your model upon an arbitrary 2D slice of a 3D body, which suggests our 3D body still exists. Thus, to a 2D world, we would appear to hold together magically because our 3D body has not ceased existing while interacting on the 2D plain.
I've actually thought about this, how a person would be able to live in 2D while still being able to eat. The solution I thought of is a series of valves that open and close to let food through a certain part of their digestive system, which serve a second purpose to maintain structural rigidity. Edit: I am aware, this is not a *good* way of doing it given a 2 dimensional organism evolved in a 2 dimensional world. There are far better ways. However, this was my interpretation of how the *existing* human digestive system could be transposed to work in 2d. Although, I'm not telling anyone to stop posting better ideas! They are fun to read and very interesting, just that you don't need to post it in a "actually," type way, ya know?
Not really. Bones and muscles can’t go around the digestive tract because there is no “around” in 2D space, so they would have to go across the tract, and then it wouldn’t be a tract anymore
Him: the tube that the food goes in Him again: **starts putting the tube in the butt** Him again: and the tube that the food goes out Him AGAIN: **makes the tube in the mouth** Me: PFFFFFF HAHAHAHAHAHAH
Two dimensional organisms could overcome the bifurcation issue by having cilia-like structures adaptively connect & separate as needed (like an organic zipper of sorts) to facilitate digestion while keeping the organism intact.
There's a Futurama episode where some characters get compressed to 2 dimensions. So they can't properly interact with the world, since the their 3D logic doesn't apply to the 2D world. There's also a puzzle game named Fez, about a 2D being who discovers the third dimension. The levels are build in 3 dimensions but you only see two at any time. You can rotate the camera to change perspective and can only interact with the world according to what you see from your current perspective.
@@ElHombreGato Oh yeah it's very cool I've been meaning to play it. It's a puzzle platformer if I remember correctly. It also has secrets that are still unsolved all these years later.
it would be simple to do it where parts slide into the body. When food swallowed, upper hatch opens while lower is closed. When food digested out, bottom hatch opens while upper is closed. When not eating, both hatches are connected.
If we were 2D though, surely our stomach and digestive tract wouldn’t exist, because the outer layer would be the one we consist of? So we’d be a nice big human shaped flap of skin 😃
2D doesn't exist in the real world, therefore it is not an experiment, it is nonsense, you could also ask "can a human body work in fortnite?". Just nonsense.
yeah something that would like protect the body.. have multiple layers… idk hmmm… maybe if we evolve with something I just thought of called skin? that would be pretty cool
Then the halves wouldn’t move away far from each other but in a organism there wouldn’t be any „meaningful“ connection of tissue and stuff so the halves couldn’t interchange blood or anything else
@@deytims of course they could. You could have valves that would interface between the two halves in such a way that they form a seal between the two sides which could let blood or whatever fluid you want really flow between the two sides. The way they would form the seals could be similar to a pressure sealed tube where the two halves are just pushed against each other hard enough to lock both of the two sides together. You just need a little imagination.
What if there was no way in or out until it created a way? Imagine a circle. Inside the circle is the digestive system. There is no break in the circle wall until food appears. The food goes through the break in the wall, and the break seals behind it. The food is digested, and another break appears on the other side of the circle. Once the digested food goes out, the break seals itself back up again.
A solution for the digestive system would be to shape it like a loose puzzle piece where you can’t pull it apart but there’s enough wiggle room to make space for food to pass through
It’s an interesting thought experiment. I think the whole issue is that a 2D body wouldn’t even be human, any more than a photo of a person is a human. There’s no logical reason a 2D representation of a human body would include the digestive tract. That aside, for a human to live in a 2D world, the part that would need to transition is what makes a human a human: the mind. If that could exist in 2D, then perhaps that would be enough for a 2 dimensional “human.”
The digestive system is as much a part of humanity as the mind is. While obviously some organ systems are more important that others, an entire species can't be reduced to a single organ.
I’ve always hated this demo because you could easily just have two (or more) sets of curls, one on each side, that wrap up inside each other to keep the halves of the body attached. Sort of like how a yin yang fits together. The curls would sort of grab onto each other like how train cars interlock. These curls could then slowly undulate with pulsing waves with a small gap between them that can carry stuff through while still keeping a seal.
If we didn't count arteries/veins and were only worried about digestive tract, humans could exist in that scenario if they were facing forward/backward because our face above the mouth would connect both halves.
In season 10 of futurama they did a bit similar to this. Fry, Leela, Bender, and the professor become trapped in the second dimension. It's only when they try to eat that they discover they can't and they all immediately decide they need to get back to the third dimension
Futurama can be split into a different amount of seasons depending on whether you go with production seasons, or broadcast seasons. This means that the episode you're referring to "2-D Blacktop", can be considered S10E1 or S7E15, depending on which source you choose.
Yea but what if there are bonds that hold the body together without blocking the space? Like how our bodies themselves are 90% empty space but dont fall apart because of the bonds between atoms/molecules
Actually, the human body got separated into two halves because of the perspective. The conduct bifurcates the body in half up to the mouth, however, the skull is still holding both sides even in a 2d perspective...
Well, if the mouth is in the front, then in 2D there would be no way to put food in it. The mouth needs to "touch" the borders to be able to put food in it, so the perspective of the video was the only possible one
@@_Sree_ the front view u only see a straight line ... The way he demonstrated it is more accurate.. we cant be in 2D cz in 2D there is only lines straight lines and surfaces we cant have mouth or anything as a hole Holes are 3D shapes In 2D lines surfaces (in 3D shapes like cubes up down forward backwards and sides) and cuts separate 2 lines/surfaces (in 3D a hole an empty space inside a shape) anything as a hole in 3d it would be a cut in 2D we the 3D creatures we would see it from the side as two shapes (surfaces) separated left and but the 2D creatures can only see it front view and they would see it as 2 straight lines on top of eatc others... if we exist in a 2D world we would be like some creatures that doesn't need to eat or breath because in 2D width dont exist so u cant put a shape inside another. eating/breathing is basically filling a shape with another shape . In 2D u can only stack lines on top of each or on front of each (from front view as a 2D creature ) or surfaces side by side of each (from side view -our view- as a 3D creatures) ... Sorry for my bad english but the idea is clear i guess.
Bro used a whiteboard, magic, and the design principles of a Super Mario game from 1993 to give the body horror version of why you can never be with your anime waifu.
But there’s also, by this logic, thick layers covering both holes. Remember, you can’t see the back of a 2D Characters head until they turn, meaning there are ways we could by his logic.
Him mixing up the “in” and “out” tubes was hilarious
He didn't mix anything up. That's how I eat.
@@pictonomii3295 HUH
@@pictonomii3295 bro????
@@pictonomii3295 ua-cam.com/video/zrbq-kndmGE/v-deo.html
@@pictonomii3295 alien alert
Human body: "gruesomely rips apart"
Him: *giggles*
Basically god.
@@TeaLurker 😒
@@springladyrose1918 your username certainly don't match your attitude.
@@TeaLurker dissing
@@springladyrose1918 the drag isn't dragging somehow
“Tube where the food goes in” *draws a colon
“Tube where the food goes out” *draws an esophagus.
Wait, so how does the person eat his food?
😳
i think they call that "intero-rectogestion"
Makes you wonder if one gould actually reverse the function of their digestive system 🤔 if I started to practice today shoving food up my ass and vomiting every meal how long before it would start to work like that naturally "on its own" 🤔
Oh, crap, have I been doing it wrong?
@@snobbingas189 I like to call that The Cartman Law
Maybe like how futurama showed us, they eat the food and just spit the remains back out the same way
that's how some animals actually do that, so chances are life would exist in a 2d world
That’s exactly what I was thinking
Could also make a segment where it interlocks like a zip and that while moving could also crush the food tho ghat be a sibiosis or something like that
Also a 2d universe might be so different they might not even need food in the first place
Like a starfish
“What can he do to get past it?”
*double jump*
Average brazilian samurai
There will be 2 (2) D (D)
@@НиколайЕфимчук-р8ш the man in the 2d nods his head
@@DzakiPedia The only dimension left
That's how you know an OG gamer... The "double jump"
4D being: "That's why you can't live in a 3D world"
True
Well this is actually true
The explanation is that they would just start to fall apart if they drink 4D water
@@Aaron-hv4hr which actually makes some sense
Well, those who lives in 2.5D world won't understand u
This man answering the real questions
Yep
Upgrade waifu to 3d model
Ikr
@@isaniruch lol
But has any one thought of skin to hold us together 🦧
stickman: *encounters wall*
stickman: *does a lil dance before climbing*
i dont think it was a dance T-T
@@sad_hammy_T-Tit is a dance
@@Th3rianScar oh srry-
@@sad_hammy_T-T lol
That looked like a bit more than a dance 💀
Using the same principle humans would be divided into literally thousands of pieces considering the amount of arteries and veins in the body.
Therr could be valves keeping them together
Arteries don't have their both ends open
@@blazingtatsumaki lymph vessels have one end open tho
vessels are closed and work more like a solid part of body.. air goes in through diffusion and goes out as liquid most of tye time
And none of them can cross over each other. No particles could be stacked either. We could hold ourselves together with spirals and mazes, although it would be difficult to generate force to push food through
"You might see a problem here"
Yeah, the food comes up my butt
Our mouth becomes our butt, and our butt becomes our mouth....I see no problem
@user-nv7cg6lq1rNah💀
one man one jar
IDK why but your comment has me cracking up so hard at work right now 🤣🤣🤣
@user-nv7cg6lq1rI want a eggplant
"where the food gets in"
**erase the butt**
"And where the food gets out"
**erase the mouth**
**insert the rock face meme**
🗿
Maybe he’s genderless child-not a giraffe- also vegan- loves kfc
@@Th3D0cT0r_11 he prob fell into a hole aswell
🗿
🤨
The where my food goes idk about you
Aliens: "Is it possible to live in 3D instead of 4D?"
No.
What do you mean? You can't even see through walls anymore!
Dude, we live in 4 dimensions, not 3.
@@Banana_Split_Cream_BunsTime is not a physical dimension soo no
@@Banana_Split_Cream_BunsWhen you’re talking about physical dimensions it’s different than how the fourth dimension is described in the theory of General Relativity (in which it is in fact time). If you are only going off of that theory, it is much much easier to describe the movement of matter and particles in space than it is to explain like, tesseracts and stuff, and the latter fits the context of this comment better.
He's just trying to say that you can't live in an anime world.
Breaking our hearts
3d anime games: *allow us to introduce ourselves.*
STOP STOP IT NO NO NO I WILL GO THERE ONE DAY!☹
𝓙𝓮 𝓼𝓾𝓲𝓼 𝓻𝓮𝓯𝓾𝓼𝓮́ 𝓽𝓸 𝓫𝓮𝓵𝓲𝓿𝓮 𝓽𝓱𝓪𝓽.
We'll see bat that 😏
Basically: you can't live in your anime world.
I still refuse to believe it 😭
@@A_D0G They aren’t real no matter how much you imagine or daydream about them they aren’t real COME ON COME ON
@@l4r1n3 idc what you say my Emma and my ray are real 😤
don't worry Elon Musk will grant that wish
@@pranitp.29 wow we never knew that, the guy you were replying to wasn’t joking at all
"JOKES ON YOU! I'VE SUPER-GLUED MY BUTTHOLE!! I AM BETTER!!!!"
dude...........
Noice
what did i just see
Then how will u poop
@@user-od6ur7nl5k WELL THEN 山卄ㄚ 丨丂 ㄒ卄丨丂 匚ㄖ爪爪乇几ㄒ 卄乇尺乇???
"Tube where the food comes in" Draws the ass
"Tube where the food goes out" draws the mouth.....
"Good goes in" (draws a butthole)
"Food goes out" (draws a mouth)
Bro, how are you used to eating?!
It's like that one South Park episode, although IRL it works halfway in that an anus can eat food, only the difference it expels back out there like normal 👓🎓🦉 Bear Grylls even did so in MvW
@@Sashil01 lol what 😳
This is why some people's breath smells so bad.
he didnt even draw a buthole or a mouth is what makes me chuckles abt this comment
@@mariisgarbagebuttHOLE
It’s important to note that this is purely based on theoretical mathematics and physics, it’s entirely possible that if there were an alternate reality that existed in 2 dimensions that the laws of physics would actually allow things that we understand to be impossible
I mean it's not like we can base it on anything else can we??
Actually, there’s a cool astronomy theory that the singularities at the end of black holes collapse reality into a 2-dimensional plane, so there’s a possibility of that alternate 2D reality existing!
As for life on a 2D plane along with other things, that’s pretty much impossible for us to comprehend with our current knowledge.
It could support our universe if you just sliced the whole universe evenly, then laid each infinitely thin slice into the others, essentially super-imposed layers of reality, separated by Ordinality (rather than Cardinality which is what we have right now).
Maybe evolution would push us into a 2d human that’s just as advanced as a normal human
Stop your attempts, just accept that you can't live in your anime world.
Instructions unclear, I split myself in half
gojo reference
Now it's my time to give backshots@@N8theinfinity
@@N8theinfinity tf
go/jo
@@GambitAnimates_he means the manga gojo
That stickman falling was so smooth
Burgerpants
@@AngelaLovesSpamton2 my gmail os hacked, i might disappear soon
Fourth dimensional creatures be talking about humans like this:
More like they would be talking about how their bodies would fall apart should they come to our low dimension.
"You can't go ¶§¬@¿€ this pole in 3 dimensions."
We ARE 4th dimensional creatures. Everything in the universe exists throughout time. Even the gravity itself keeping us grounded is a byproduct of the geometry of the 4th dimension that has a very real tangible impact on our lives. We just don’t see the 4th dimension the same way we'd see the other 3 in SPACE, but we still exist within it and by it.
@@HelloThere..... I understand what you are saying. but I'm also sure that you misunderstood the comment above
@@HelloThere..... I was just thinking about this the other day. Thoughts and dreams only we can comprehend could only be the result of higher dimensions
There’s actually quite a few ways a being in 2d could function:
1: a latch system that operates like a cell wall
2: a “zipper” mechanism that will allow flexible material to interlock, allowing stuff to pass throw while the body moves like a inch worn
3. One hole for in and out
Or a 2d being could operate on a atomic scale and can pass things like that
and 2d layers
Or act like a cell and absorb it
one potential actual problem is brains, wire like connections cant cross easily (this is potentially overcomable with some weirdness), but there might just not be enough space for a complicated brain to be compact.
@@terdragontra8900 well that depends on how atoms work in a 2D space, if a material is bonded is it a new material and solid or is it just tiny circles with high electrical and chemical forces?
imagine just existing and suddenly you rip in two pieces
*no more one piece*
edit: thx for the likes but, it's on thousands or millions???!
also, dam guys you sayin' if we can get much higher, but I am already high enough
No more one piece?! But I thought...
THE ONE PIECE IS REAALLL
😭😭😭
CAN WE GET MUCH HIGHER
@@loudfart_ SO HIGH
But but but
It’s real
“ because he’s in two dimensions doesn’t mean he can go around it”
goes around it
Well he meant just like walking past it.
No, that's going above it.
fr
3 dimensional thinking is hard, isnt it?
“Tube where food goes in”
Draws from anus to stomach
“And a tube where food goes out”
Draws from stomach to mouth.
I was looking for this comment; my exact thoughts😹😹
Omg saaameeee
I was like literally searching each comment for this pointer💀
#suppositories
"Let's just say... I put my lunch... UP MY BUTT!"
He did say he saw a problem there
@@Hexlattice “Yeah, so what, Joe? Ain’t that normal?”
I'd imagine there is civilization of 4D creatures out there, and in the equivalent of youtube; there is a video exactly like this where they claim life in 3D cannot exist.
What?
When I was a kid I thought of obesity as a 4D human being
@@thekodex1186 he is saying that 4D beings may look at us 3D beings, the we we look at 2D beings.
Exactly!
He's not saying life couldn't exist in 2D, just that humans can't.
2D waifus: “That’s why you can’t live in a 1D world”
Well they aren't technically 2D..
I sure am glad anime invented the concept of dimensions
1 D just isn't enough 🤤
@@molanogan7409 I’m with you, there 😅👍🏻.
@@luis-sophus-8227 what do you mean?
Fun fact: the GI tract is considered to be outside of the body. The epithelial boundary describes the tissue around the GI tract, which is exposed to the external environment. Picture a water weenie. The inside of the water weenie is the GI tract. It absorbs through mucous membranes to bring nutrients inside the body, but it is, itself, not inside the body
TIL I'm a water weenie
Damn, living in 2d is like parkour. Imagine doing so many obstacles every day, it much be so hard for the stickman I'm literally crying rn
F
Probably wouldn’t be manny
F
I’m literally shaking and crying rn
They would probably build streets under so you can have a straight road when you get out of your 2d house
In a 2D world, it's impossible to have vision, at least as humans perceive it. To see anything, you need to have depth and width. You can visualize this by putting your head against a wall and trying to look across it through one eye. Things directly in front of you would block your vision and not allow you to see past them
In a 2D world, sight would be in a 1D line, just as how we see our world through 2D images. Any time we see a line, it is just a 2D highlight of a line. A perfect 1D line would be too small for us to see or visualize.
They would have a one-dimensional vision, just as we see everything in 2d (light projected on a retina's surface, which is two dimensional)
then 2D life is basically one line
@@crazy_pyromaniac yeah but like a line with no thickness is practically no existent.
You wouldnt even be able to live in 2D dimensions
There was a book called Flat Land which actually explored this kinda' stuff, looking at how 2D beings would see, live, etc. as well as how they'd interact with 3D beings. I haven't read the book but I have seen the 2007 (I think) movie adaptation
By a guy called Edwin Abbott. It's to teach you about how a being from a universe with MORE THAN THREE DIMENSIONS OF SPACE AND ONE OF TIME would see us... and how we'd see it! It's BRILLIANT!
I don't recall that book discussing the digestive systems of the two dimensional beings.
@@doncherf2610 no, but it did explore what it'd generally be like to live in a 2D world
I’ve seen the Futurama version of it.
I wonder if there is a 3D version of the movie, just for irony.
The problem, is that we are 3dimensional
No. We are 4 dimensional. If we were 3 dimensional, we would be stuck.
@@Banana_Split_Cream_Bunsby your logic we're all 12 dimension, we just got screen lock on 3D
There was a whole Futurama episode based around this. Weird but probably one of my favourites.
I was looking for this comment.
@@FlyingDominion me too
Same!!
"3 dimensions?! I can't picture that! You're stupid"
Some 2-D creature
@@Mariorox1956 a very wise quote
There is actually a concept for a 2D being with a digestive track. It uses a sort of zip lock to stay together while still having a digestive track.
I was thinking the same. It would close around the food like an amoeba
@@danielescobar7618amoeba still 3d
@@danielescobar7618amoeba rely on 3D properties
@@fendysusanto876 I'm describing amoeba for the sake of picturing it.. what about a slime mold then that digests outside it's body, or those hydra things that eat and poop from the same orifice
@@danielescobar7618 spider
The thought of this actually happening is terrifying… 😨
i mean yes but what if in 2d can't fill Pain... Also it happend sooo fast soo u will notice it after... Few secs idk...
Yeah
@@dOwOp908 wut?
Chris chan spoke of the merge
Don't worry, our insides could be wriggly s's and not just straight tubes that could interlock and hold us together by our intestines similar to puzzle pieces ;)
Futurama did a perfect rendition of this concept. 👌🏻
You know, Michael Stevens described this best: humans are just giant meaty donuts. Thanks Vsauce. Thanks for the horrible nightmares my inner child has had since hearing this...
LMAO 🤣🤣🤣
almost any animal actually lol
Humans aren't meaty donuts
But humans are made of meat
Skin
And bones
What I mean by meat
I mean the insides
🤨
@@AbbeyKitty1013 delicious 100
"The tube that food goes in..."
*Draws the tube that food comes out*
"...and the tube that food comes out"
*Draws the way food goes in*
I'm fucking dead bro I can't 🤣
I noticed loll
Ah yes, intero-rectogestion
@@honor9458 it's only a matter of time before the maker of this video receives A Freaking Medal.
No no... he knows what he said...
So we eat with our thing and we do thing with our mouth I'm confused-
When I start my death metal band, my first single will be called "Bifurcated Digestive Tract."
I rock with that
But the tract isn't what's bifurcated, that would mean the tract itself splits into two. Rather, the body is bifurcated by the tract. "Digestive bifurcation" would be a way more accurate title (unless the song is about someone with two buttholes, then it'd be perfect).
Ask Bill Cipher that.
I remember recently hearing that someone was able to construct a theoretical form that could work as a digestive tract in a 2 dimensional body... I believe it was constructed only to separate when moving did through and then to rejoin afterwards
imagine a toxin in that world that activated the digestive tract and straight up killed people by splitting them in half
@@phillapple8260 a digestive tract in a 'C' shape could be made so that the geometry of the system could hold the system together. A force causing one end to expand would automatically cause the other end to contract making such a toxin much harder to use.
I'd like to see that if you can find the source. Sounds interesting.
Using a zipper-like mechanism iirc
Eat like snakes
casually living in 2d
“oh no the other half of my body”
Cringe
@@fatpanda9999Nuh uh
@@fatpanda9999for real like just let me live in a 2d world without my other half flying away from me. I hate when that happens.
@@fatpanda9999how is this cringe
@@tracypeh5752 cause it's stupid and not funny why does every comment have some moron trying to be a comedian
Some questions: would a tunnel work in 2d? How would you hold up the stuff on top without blocking the entrance/exit? Also how does gravity work in 2d? How does time and space distort in 2 dimensions? Can mass even exist in 2d?
The above demonstration is not at all an accurate definition of 2d. What defines 2d? 100 time more than the Planck length?
@@aashishdevgun 2D is a plane, it has length and width but no height. So height is equal to zero. It's not bigger than Planck length
@@professorx3060 I see, I have a hard time understanding this. Thanks.
@@aashishdevgun Sorry, I just now understand what you meant.
There are no 2D molecules 😳
This is a misrepresentation of 2D world because it assumes that there is third dimensions the size of a molecule.
Mass cannot exist, due to the fact that even with lenth and height, you would be infinitely thin
“Over or under”
Henry stick man:
“And you have a tube where the food comes in” *continues to draw a line from the bottom upwards*
I feel like the twists and turns and the 'tube" would hold us together in two dimensions. I'm not a fan of the simplification of the digestive tract past the stomach, there's also like half a dozen sphincters in the human GI tract.
@@9WEAVER9 you don't suck up your food through there? What kind of freak of nature are you /j
Well that is the direction it's formed (humans are made butt first)
@@9WEAVER9 no if there a mouth and a poop poop hole that connects it won't survive no matter what it's like disconnecting your body
@@blizzard1198 you realize we can close our mouths. A 2d person could have hooks on both sides of his mouth and have a similar hooking butt to hold himself together. With detachable neurons so there is always a brain connection to the other half.
Let's be honest, they were about 25 other reasons we couldn't live in a two-dimensional world, he just wanted to use the term "bifurcates the body" and I'm ok with that
"Goes in"
*starts putting water in the tube*
"Goes out"
*starts vomiting*
True tho 💀👍
A Hungarian cartoon series, what continued Mezga Family with the story, that a boy built an inflatable space ship and used it in the night to go to other planets, has an episode, where he was on a 2D planet, where everything looked like xrayed. He turned someone of them into 3D, but he wasn't glad about it.
Meanwhile in the fourth dimension:
"Is it possible to live in 3d?"
“No. I saw a 3D animation showing how horrific it would be.”
@@Pawnbandi saw the video, it looked terrifying 😨
hi clumsy slime
"If you live in 3D world, you might end up kissing your ass."
hi
This reminds me of the old Sci-fi novel "The Planiverse" where a group of scientists or programmers accidentally connected to a being that lived in a 2d world. I loved that book as a kid, and seeing how everything (could have) worked was a really cool thought exercise.
Another book to read alongside "the hive" by Barry lyga, I'll def read this too
There is also a 19th century novel called Flatland, that explored shapes living in a 2D world :)
You should read Otherland it explores the future of VR tech and sentience
@@bozieduble8541 Weren't both of these referenced in a Futurama episode?
I was going to recommend flatland but it seems somebody got to it first :)
Weebs: "Finally, a piece of hope!!!"
Weebs after watching the whole video: "My hope is destroyed and my day is ruined."
My disappointment is immeasurable and my day is ruined.
Lol true
@@PrincessChieswoll its a joke
Not really disappointed, coz we're the ones who percieve drawings as 2D to represent whatever. It's just like how you draw a portrait of a real life person on paper but doesn't mean that the real life person who were drawn are 2D. In the same way, anime characters are drawn as 2D coz that's a representation that we prefer of these characters and their world.
The main point is, if we entered an anime world then the characters will become real, they will no longer need to follow our 2D representation and they'll be 3 dimensional. only difference is that they'll probably be prettier, hotter, cuter and more mesmirising than humans since their dimensions have different principles from ours when relating to our representation
True
There's a problem with this. Just because we interact in a 2D world doesn't mean our 3D existence ceases. You based your model upon an arbitrary 2D slice of a 3D body, which suggests our 3D body still exists. Thus, to a 2D world, we would appear to hold together magically because our 3D body has not ceased existing while interacting on the 2D plain.
True
can I just say how much I love how he "animated" the stickman waking into the pole?
(awkwardly pushes)
Remembering watching this episode of Futurama as a kid
As a kid? I watched it again last week. I'm 30
@@jimizxztheorginal WHOA!!!
“The new Shrek movie won’t look as nearly as good”
Having parents who let you watch teletoon at night & adult swim was such a power trip as a kid
@Riggyvr-tn8ur 2d blacktop in season 10
I've actually thought about this, how a person would be able to live in 2D while still being able to eat. The solution I thought of is a series of valves that open and close to let food through a certain part of their digestive system, which serve a second purpose to maintain structural rigidity.
Edit: I am aware, this is not a *good* way of doing it given a 2 dimensional organism evolved in a 2 dimensional world. There are far better ways. However, this was my interpretation of how the *existing* human digestive system could be transposed to work in 2d. Although, I'm not telling anyone to stop posting better ideas! They are fun to read and very interesting, just that you don't need to post it in a "actually," type way, ya know?
Ya like magnets
Right, I was gonna say exactly this! Valves that latch and hold fast as they close.
Or we could eat by absorbing our food into our bodies like cinamon bun from adventur time
You mean valves like we already have? It was disregarded in this video but our digestive tract isn't just pass through tube.
@@HKJazz87 I mean specifically ones that can be load-bearing and support the body.
Human body gets ripped.
Him:giggles.
“Let’s just say this guy is walking and finds a pole sticking out the ground”
“Aggressively begins pelvic thrusting the pole”
😂
Blu was trying to get some money
Nah@@evancollums8207
He also lost his leg going over it lol
It’s the only logical next step
"this is where the food comes in" famous last words
Everyone sees the stick fig trying to defeat the pole…
I see the stick figure pole dancing
That's some imagination you got there
Your videos are always entertaining and educational. Thank you.
What a fascinatingly simple answer to a question I’ve never asked 🤣
And it's wrong. Jellyfish only have one hole and digest just fine.
@@piyh3962 So it's right then. Surprisingly, jellyfish don't have human bodies
@@piyh3962 humans aren't jellyfish
@@piyh3962 you're so dumb lol. It's okay to have one hole in 3D but impossible to live together in 2D with a "hole" that goes right through
@@piyh3962 do you only have one hole tho?
"We can't live in 2d because our digestive system separates us"
The skeletal, and every other system: 👀
Not really. Bones and muscles can’t go around the digestive tract because there is no “around” in 2D space, so they would have to go across the tract, and then it wouldn’t be a tract anymore
That would do nothing in 2d for the very reason he showed
Him: the tube that the food goes in
Him again: **starts putting the tube in the butt**
Him again: and the tube that the food goes out
Him AGAIN: **makes the tube in the mouth**
Me: PFFFFFF HAHAHAHAHAHAH
he just eat the wrong way
i dont wan think about that😂
I was wondering if anyone commented this😭
Did i ask
@@2miligrams ?
Jellybean
"What can he do to get past it?"
Me: "...double jump. 👁 👄 👁 "
Two dimensional organisms could overcome the bifurcation issue by having cilia-like structures adaptively connect & separate as needed (like an organic zipper of sorts) to facilitate digestion while keeping the organism intact.
bakteria, amebae and many other single of few celullar life forms do it that way in principle
Single handedly destroyed the hopes and dreams of every weebs
I'm proud of you sir
i thought so to
Not really.
If they believe even 2d people can exist unironically...well I think it would be hard to reason with them as well
@@hampter460 at that point, they are long gone
Is it? Okay.
There's a Futurama episode where some characters get compressed to 2 dimensions. So they can't properly interact with the world, since the their 3D logic doesn't apply to the 2D world.
There's also a puzzle game named Fez, about a 2D being who discovers the third dimension. The levels are build in 3 dimensions but you only see two at any time. You can rotate the camera to change perspective and can only interact with the world according to what you see from your current perspective.
"Sometimes the best way to deal with your problems is to drive away from 'em real fast."
I love that the beings that live in flat lands are like amoebas that eat through phagocytosis lol
Fez sounds awesome 😎👍 thanks for the info imma check it out
@@ElHombreGato Oh yeah it's very cool I've been meaning to play it. It's a puzzle platformer if I remember correctly. It also has secrets that are still unsolved all these years later.
@@DaimyoD0 Carl Sagan fan. nice.
it would be simple to do it where parts slide into the body.
When food swallowed, upper hatch opens while lower is closed.
When food digested out, bottom hatch opens while upper is closed.
When not eating, both hatches are connected.
If we were 2D though, surely our stomach and digestive tract wouldn’t exist, because the outer layer would be the one we consist of? So we’d be a nice big human shaped flap of skin 😃
In 2D a flap of skin would be a string. And to hold it in any shape, it would need a bone.
@@Mecharnie_Dobbs among us
@@siyacer sus
I was gonna reference All Tomorrow's with the Flatlanders, but the reply section has posted cringe.
@@thunderblood6603 I'm more of a the future is wild guy but you do you
Him: Human body's can not be in a 2D world
Cartoons: Are you sure about that
Well, considering cartoons are not actually made up of organic human material… yeah. 1000% sure about that. lol
@@Lexicoley1826 And cartoons exist in 2-D approximations of 3-D worlds.
In anime there are 11D 8D 5D
Your pfp kinda cursed
@@nasppoke3223 B@@@@
I like how futurama shows 2d world in that episode where they're racing and crash into eachother making a disc
Was just thinking about that episode.
@@josephbrown5292 same
I get confused by this because the marker ink is technically 3D, but just super tiny particles. Like under a microscope it occupies a 3D space right?
Moral of the story: When life puts a pole in your way, turn it into a stripper pole by climbing up and sliding down it! 💵 💵 💵
my great grandmother was a race horse
@@tuneboyz5634 👀
Big brain
@@tuneboyz5634 sus
The cringe is so strong it's making my face become 2d
we NEED an exhibition with all the cool experiments TAL has done!
His demonstration didnt made sense because our digestive track is surrounded by our muscles which is why our body is a 1 unit
@@-Sam69 but you can’t have that in 2D, which is the point
2D doesn't exist in the real world, therefore it is not an experiment, it is nonsense, you could also ask "can a human body work in fortnite?". Just nonsense.
Actually, the whole going over or under a wall thing made me think: how would gravity work in a 2d world?
-> O
It won't, lol
I’m pretty sure it wouldn’t change
@@Z0nnestraal u right
We always think gravity MUST go down, we never think if it could go any other way. It could be a spherical or hyperbolic
Bro violated that pole 😭😭
The way the stickman looks up and down at the pole gives him so much life.
Yessir
The splitting human problem could be solved through puzzle piece shaped locks that keep the body together but still allow stuff to flow through them.
yeah something that would like protect the body.. have multiple layers… idk hmmm… maybe if we evolve with something I just thought of called skin? that would be pretty cool
Then the halves wouldn’t move away far from each other but in a organism there wouldn’t be any „meaningful“ connection of tissue and stuff so the halves couldn’t interchange blood or anything else
@@s3rjfan did you have literally any thoughts take place before you started talking shit?
@@deytims of course they could. You could have valves that would interface between the two halves in such a way that they form a seal between the two sides which could let blood or whatever fluid you want really flow between the two sides. The way they would form the seals could be similar to a pressure sealed tube where the two halves are just pushed against each other hard enough to lock both of the two sides together.
You just need a little imagination.
@@s3rjfan skin wouldn’t help the two halves stay together tho.
What if there was no way in or out until it created a way?
Imagine a circle. Inside the circle is the digestive system. There is no break in the circle wall until food appears. The food goes through the break in the wall, and the break seals behind it. The food is digested, and another break appears on the other side of the circle. Once the digested food goes out, the break seals itself back up again.
Nah
that's an amoeba
I mean, there are valves in the digestive system anyways so technically our body does exactly that.
There are also creatures with a stomach and no colon/anus, they just eat something, digest it, then vomit out the remains.
@@kiranerysegordon5485 yeah, and if you take a 2D slice, there's nothing to keep the valve closed
A solution for the digestive system would be to shape it like a loose puzzle piece where you can’t pull it apart but there’s enough wiggle room to make space for food to pass through
Here’s a crude diagram of what I mean:
Left side
___
| |
| | |
| |___ right side
| |
| | |
| __|
"We have a tube where the food comes in"
*Draws bottom end*
"...and we have a tube where the food goes out"
*Draws top end*
*H M M M.*
I'm getting south park vibes
It’s an interesting thought experiment. I think the whole issue is that a 2D body wouldn’t even be human, any more than a photo of a person is a human. There’s no logical reason a 2D representation of a human body would include the digestive tract.
That aside, for a human to live in a 2D world, the part that would need to transition is what makes a human a human: the mind. If that could exist in 2D, then perhaps that would be enough for a 2 dimensional “human.”
Maybe their mind can create 3D concepts in that 2D world
@@Sconechoc I guess that’s as possible as it is for us to conceptualize 4D.
The digestive system is as much a part of humanity as the mind is. While obviously some organ systems are more important that others, an entire species can't be reduced to a single organ.
The 2d creature could defecatefrom the same cavity it uses to eat. Gross? Yes. But thats the only way
Maybe he’d absorb nutrients through his skin…
Creatures in 362763728263627270 dimensions:
"And that's why you can't live in 362763728263627269 dimensions"
I’ve always hated this demo because you could easily just have two (or more) sets of curls, one on each side, that wrap up inside each other to keep the halves of the body attached. Sort of like how a yin yang fits together. The curls would sort of grab onto each other like how train cars interlock. These curls could then slowly undulate with pulsing waves with a small gap between them that can carry stuff through while still keeping a seal.
If we didn't count arteries/veins and were only worried about digestive tract, humans could exist in that scenario if they were facing forward/backward because our face above the mouth would connect both halves.
"He’s likely to go over it"
*2d person loses His foot*
In season 10 of futurama they did a bit similar to this.
Fry, Leela, Bender, and the professor become trapped in the second dimension. It's only when they try to eat that they discover they can't and they all immediately decide they need to get back to the third dimension
Futurama can be split into a different amount of seasons depending on whether you go with production seasons, or broadcast seasons.
This means that the episode you're referring to "2-D Blacktop", can be considered S10E1 or S7E15, depending on which source you choose.
@@larswijn yes I know. But with season 11 and upcoming season 12 it makes more sense to say season 10.
@@BigBillyMcBobJoeagreed
Yeah I came here to look for someone mentioning this episode
@@larswijnI believe most people go by broad cast season. This leaves us with 5 Fox seasons, the movie season, the 5 CC seasons, and now Hulu's season
Lil stickman violated that wall 💀
💀
Can you live in a 2D world?
Action lab: No, it’s impossible
Terraria: Allow me to introduce my self
So they never shit
That's not real 2D
Mario is always eating the mushrooms
One might enjoy the novella "Flatland" by Edwin Abbott, written in 1884.
@Plug Wafer -- I didn't realize that there was a movie. I just found that it's on YT. Thanks for the info.
Instead of a permanent tube, 2D beings can ingest food like an amoeba and then the food vacuole can be emptied externally after digestion
I like the "series of latching valves" argument better. Idw imagine translating my body into a world where I have to vomit back up my food waste.
Was thinking the same thing!
I was thinking this too. Can't have two openings.
Yea but what if there are bonds that hold the body together without blocking the space? Like how our bodies themselves are 90% empty space but dont fall apart because of the bonds between atoms/molecules
I remember there is one like this in Gravity Falls' short episode
When there is a guy but he's a robot controlled by the little creatures
I remember that!
Also bill cipher's original dimension was a 2D world.
yea
Futurama
I remember watching every episode of gravity falls and short too, I loved it, the guy you are talking about kinda scared me lol
Watching this guy's videos makes me regret not majoring Physics in college
Don't be. Physics in college is like a girl in a bar. Everyone like to see her but not seriously enough as to marry her.
@@amri1311 beautifully said
@@amri1311 give this man a like
@@amri1311 but what about me going for physics in college (╥﹏╥)
@@johannesziaether3916 aww dont cry! if u enjoy it be happy :D
People who wanted to reality shift to a 2D world:👁👄👁
Why does this remember me to a triangle with an eye?
Actually, the human body got separated into two halves because of the perspective. The conduct bifurcates the body in half up to the mouth, however, the skull is still holding both sides even in a 2d perspective...
You're actually right
He drew the side view. But considering the front view..damn it it is possible xx
@@_Sree_ there’s more than just the skull, you have all the other bones, the skin, veins, and other things
@@_Sree_ it wouldn’t just rip apart so easily
Well, if the mouth is in the front, then in 2D there would be no way to put food in it. The mouth needs to "touch" the borders to be able to put food in it, so the perspective of the video was the only possible one
@@_Sree_ the front view u only see a straight line ...
The way he demonstrated it is more accurate.. we cant be in 2D cz in 2D there is only lines straight lines and surfaces we cant have mouth or anything as a hole
Holes are 3D shapes
In 2D lines surfaces (in 3D shapes like cubes up down forward backwards and sides) and cuts separate 2 lines/surfaces (in 3D a hole an empty space inside a shape) anything as a hole in 3d it would be a cut in 2D we the 3D creatures we would see it from the side as two shapes (surfaces) separated left and but the 2D creatures can only see it front view and they would see it as 2 straight lines on top of eatc others... if we exist in a 2D world we would be like some creatures that doesn't need to eat or breath because in 2D width dont exist so u cant put a shape inside another. eating/breathing is basically filling a shape with another shape . In 2D u can only stack lines on top of each or on front of each (from front view as a 2D creature ) or surfaces side by side of each (from side view -our view- as a 3D creatures) ...
Sorry for my bad english but the idea is clear i guess.
"The pole is blocking the way"
*Stick-Man proceeds to lump the wall*
Bro used a whiteboard, magic, and the design principles of a Super Mario game from 1993 to give the body horror version of why you can never be with your anime waifu.
what mario game came out in 1993
@@cyanideA ... Mario's Time Machine.
But there’s also, by this logic, thick layers covering both holes. Remember, you can’t see the back of a 2D Characters head until they turn, meaning there are ways we could by his logic.