Why "Dictator Envy for China" is a bad idea I Shyam Saran on how China sees India I Barkha Dutt

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 19 жов 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 36

  • @wanghui562
    @wanghui562 2 роки тому +10

    Chinese people think Buddhism came from Nepal, not India. In any case, India did not exist until British colonization. The birthplace of Buddhism is known as 天竺, while India in Chinese is 印度. Not many people make the connection between Buddhism and India. Nobody thinks of India as a wealth spring of wisdom or a centre of high culture. I don't think India is Buddhism today. India is rather Muslim and hindu.

    • @Sawvage
      @Sawvage 6 місяців тому

      Well that’s what you all think, and it is far from truth

  • @centtenzin8793
    @centtenzin8793 2 роки тому +2

    Manmohan Singh said to his holiness “thanks for choosing India as ur home “.

  • @JoyinEthiopia
    @JoyinEthiopia 2 роки тому +1

    "Dictator Envy" good one!! thank you for this conversation on China. Insightful and somewhat reassuring

  • @ianchen8582
    @ianchen8582 Рік тому +1

    Tibetans and Uyghurs haven't been integrated because the PRC tried to copy the Soviets ethnic policies until perhaps the last 10 or 15 years years which was idiotic IMO, they've since switched back to the more traditional Chinese/Confucianism way of ethnic and culture convergence that has been done for millenniums, and the minorities are being integrated much more now.

  • @edwardtang1977
    @edwardtang1977 2 роки тому +4

    Dictatorship is the most successful system in himan history. All democracies fell really quickly because democracy lesds to corruption. Indians have a long history but Indians forgot everything.

  • @mrpatchy9950
    @mrpatchy9950 2 роки тому +2

    A very interesting analysis over the ages of the two regional powers , over the years dynamics of its relations amongst themselves and the neighbouring countries over the years was very interesting not to forget the influence of the the other powers in the geopolitics of the region . It would be best for both countries to embark on a path of diplomacy to sort out the difference’s in a spirit in a spirit of cooperation, rather than taking an adversarial stance.

  • @jyatimali2033
    @jyatimali2033 2 роки тому +3

    There should be no discussion about chinese policy whatsoever but always watch china with suspicion and never trust backstabbers that should be India's policy

  • @munozgiovanni9384
    @munozgiovanni9384 2 роки тому +2

    I remember one month ago when China announced 4.8% GDP growth for Q1 2022, Indians laughed at China for economic slowing down. 🤣

    • @edwardtang1977
      @edwardtang1977 2 роки тому +4

      4.8 % of 18 trillion economy is way bigger than India's growth. The gap is getting bigger every year. 🤣

    • @Facts..Checker
      @Facts..Checker Рік тому

      ​@@edwardtang1977Precisely, if you follow Jayant Bhandari quotes, it's like comparing an ant with an elephant. Growth rate % aside, the actual two economies size r actually widening not narrowing bvoz India aint growing fast enough to see another China's miracle happening as anticipated.

  • @manjulkumarsharma1432
    @manjulkumarsharma1432 2 роки тому

    Nice discussion, can it change India policy or China’s attitude towards India . Is discussion a pass time or will it make in roads in Indo China relations.Excessive religiosity in India in Modi Era & Chinese Athiesm are contradictory to each other But China’s Hypocrisy in supporting Muslim Fanatic Pakistan to counter India is a big hurdle in Indo China relations .Mr Shym Saran is right when he says that China is unable to handle religions . Dialectics of Chinese Communist Party are unable to find out answers when so many Buddhist Monks have done so many aSelf Immolitons in Tibet

    • @arindamsaha735
      @arindamsaha735 2 роки тому +3

      Dont talk rubbish like a fool .u have no idea about china ...

  • @centtenzin8793
    @centtenzin8793 2 роки тому +1

    Barkha, with due respect to u…we had given Ladakh & arunachal to India, keep that in ur backdrop.

  • @lifeisdivine1584
    @lifeisdivine1584 2 роки тому +3

    JUST IN EIGHT YEARS CHAINA NE INDIA KI KAFHI JAMIN KABJJA KAR LIYA.. GOVT KO KUCH DEKHAI NEHI DE RAHA.

  • @tseringlhundup8759
    @tseringlhundup8759 2 роки тому +4

    Chou Enlai deceived Nehru and We see India kowtowing even now.

  • @sureshharinathbabu9717
    @sureshharinathbabu9717 2 роки тому +2

    56 a coward guy afraid to take name of china

  • @venkataramanrangaswami6721
    @venkataramanrangaswami6721 2 роки тому +1

    Can China without Western trade and investment? China’s prosperity comes from linkages with West including technology. The heydays of china’s prosperity is coming to an end.

  • @akuntes7584
    @akuntes7584 2 роки тому

    From2 family Dedy Dedy hand man end mummii ,bautty ,fretty mamimoy women you family energzic jeniuos prasiblel poduktip poluship zona area Darling end of harmony Asia fasipic unieropa antlantic Awhe zona meckanik Revpulusi Renovsasional to you area Economy ,politic ,astronologi ,astromologi, metrokimia, amoklogi ,Dialogi ,agiologi Diamitrec ,AirlineS ,INdrustri ,kontraktor ,mekanic energzi , energenering , Film ,live ,locomothip ,antrariksa ,astronont ,welding ,Biofisikalogi ,amosoplasasional , sasional you family world Darling Harmony

  • @rajeshmadan5265
    @rajeshmadan5265 2 роки тому +2

    There is a lurking sense of him being a China apologist -albeit well-disguised.